Complete Issue
Aug 1978
August-November 1978
Price Rs. 3.50
WHAT
___
'9 d
1
ARE
II&.
. ....
• - f *
k"'
w
MADE OF?!
I
AUGUST-NOVEMBER 1978 VOL. 2 NO. 7
3
5
6
EDITOR'S COLUMN
READERS' FORUM
EVENTS AND PERSONALITIES
MARRIAGE AND DIVORCE BILL 13
WHAT ARE ENTREPRENEURS MADE OF? Dr. John L. Komives 19
THE UNMAKING OF ENTREPRENEURS S. M. Mistry 27
THE ICE CREAM STORY
WORLD CONGRESS PAPERS: THE
BOOK REVIEWS
VEHEMEMT VIRTUOSO
30
35
40
43
lESTHOOD
\
Parsiana cover by Manjuia Padmanabhan
EDITOR Jehangir R. Patel Parsiana is published and printed by
Jehangir R. Patel at Tata Press, 414 Veer
MANAGING EDITOR R. P. Thanavala Savarkar Marg, Bombay 400 025. All
. rights reserved. Address all editorial and
EXECUTIVE EDITOR Veera H. Parbhu business correspondence to Parsiana
T'iccTr-xTcn • n i G.P.O. Box 892, Bombay 400001.
DESIGNER Mmi Boatwala . ... , . . .
Annual mland subscription : Rs 20 for
ART ASSISTANT Ketayun Wankadia one year, (12 issues); Rs 36 for two
years, (24 issues). Foreign subscription
ADVERTISING Feroza Chavda and rates: Seamail Rs 36 one year, Rs 66
Mahakhurshid Byramjee two years; Airmail Rs 80 one year,
Rs 150 two years.
Dr Rustem Colah and p ^.s. personal cheques add $ 1.50 to
Zann Billimona bank charges.
CIRCULATION Shirin Bahadurji and For Indian upcountry cheques add Rs 2
M. R. Ambujakshan Nair for bank charges. Cheques and drafts are
to be drawn in favour of Parsiana. Single
copy price Rs 3.50 and 50p. All rates
subject to change in postal rates.
M. R. Ambujakshan Nair
OFFICE Mathew M. George and
S. Premkumarf
I
i
i
Editor s Column
tread; they are straightforward and acquire them but starts a business can
outspoken, though not always so in end up becoming an insolvent. (This
business matters, and their manner of is what happened to us in Parsiana.
dress, more often than not, traditional It could happen to you!).
Parsi. They build fire temples, hospitals As Dr, Fredie Mehta, a reputed
and schools and help people establish economist and director of Tatas
themselves in life. They live well and noted at the Third World Zoroastrian
when they die, the sethia legacy dies Congress that parents have to inculcate
with them. entrepreneurial traits and the work
After the sethias, comes the Warrior, ethic in their off-spring from a young
or Mara-nwri caste. Currently this class age. What makes for entrepreneurship
includes individuals like the trustees of is a subject we have tried to tackle
the panchayats, journalists, lawyers and in this issue,
scholars (there are a few women
Warriors). A detailed study of this With this issue, Parsiana begins
group is not available but one tell-tale printing at Tata Press. We offer our
characteristic is a quickness to take thanks to the management for the
<11 offence. Any remark can be taken as interest they have taken in Parsiana
, a slur, the ensuing'battle succeeding which due to its limited growth
several generations. Financially the potential, cannot offer the same returns
warriors are medium to well-off and as larger publications,
usually save their money for one great
court case or libellous leaflets. They to thank the directors, especially
believe that every generation must have Mr. Sushil Somani, the management
its small wars. and staff of G. Claridge & Co. for the
The people who serve and rally kind and generous assistance they
People often ask if the Parsees have around the warriors are referred to as have rendered us over the last five
a caste system and most often the the Haandas. The haandas (vessels) and a half years. Ever mindful of our
answer is no. But after having made comprise numerically the largest caste limitations, th^ extended their support
a deep sociological study of the com- in the community, though exact figures and co-operation at a time when it
munity, our researcher’s main quaii- are not available. The leaders of the was sorely needed and kept their rates
fication being a college freshman course haandas are called Huonda-Masters uneconomically low.
on the subject, we have come to the and they in turn owe their allegiance
conclusion there is a very definite to the Warrior class. While some
caste structure in the community. We HoanJa-Masters aspire to the warrior
present below some of our findings caste, they find it difficult to do so, the B
As Dr, Fredie Mehta, a reputed
We also take this opportunity
and staff of G. Claridge & Co. for the
haanda traits being so much a part of
the person’s character that some con
sider it to be genetic (whether inter-
the athornans, the priestly class and the marriages would weaken the haanda
which were originally published in the
Jehangimamah, volume IV, chapter 20.
Firstly there are two main divisions,
behdins, the lay people (Ratan Singara, characteristics is not known, but cer-
copywriter in Everest Advertis- tainly a formal education is no help;
(has put forward the hypothesis it has created instead a sub-category
__ Esther Williams is a Parsee be- ' ‘
cause she could be referred to as a
Behdin Beauty). The behdins are divid-
11
referred to as Educated Haandas.)
Behdin Beauty). The behdins are divid- Speaking of classes, there is one group
ed into several subcastes at the head whose reportedly diminishing numbers
of which are the Sethias.
The sethias are a dying species and
is a cause of concern: the entrepre
neurs. In every forum after speakers
aside from the Editor 'of "Parsiana and have rend their hearts on the frequency
a few others, are almost non-existent.
They are the men, (there are no women _ .
sethias). who through dint of hard work, youth, the subject turns to the abseiux
shrewd business acumen and some luck of businessmen and industrialists in
attain positions of privilege and power, the conununity. It is believed that if
Their wealth and interest in political Parsis took to business they would
prosper, money would flow in and new
agiaries and bangs would be built
(each in their wake creating new
problems for future generations).
What many of the speakers do not
realize is that entrepreneurs are not
made by simply wishing them to be
so. A person who does not possess
entrepreneurial traits nor manages to
of intermarriage, declining values,
increasing prices and today’s shiftless
Warden is good
For sandalwood
Head Office
378 Grant Road
Bombay 400 007
and Branches
Tel. 371464
Quality sandalwood
Aggarbatties. gum benzoin
(loban) and other
Perfumes
I
A-4
and social activities makes them res
pected in a community where the
commercially successful individual
rates second only to God.
The sethias have their faults: one
usually pictures thdm as strong willed
individuals with quick tempers, ambi
tious and often ruthless. But they pos
sess style, walk where others fear to
individual
31
READERS' FORUM
ij
I
I
i ¦
I
k
I,
i
j
i
1
I
the persecution of the Zoroastrians.
The elder sister elected to marry the
f German captain and went away with „„aiv wxm mitu, uouc auu
™Pirojai charity. In the past, we’have been
lyae u..., u.. u — —I. succcssful duc to hard work, an udvcn-
kusband. ui
* «7 11 taken to Bhikha-Behram s favours from our respective rulers and
*; well to sit quietly watching, though not the least, because of the absence
herself unseen, the eligible Zoroastrian of competition from sister commu-
swells. who congregated there, of an
; evening. Her choice fell on “Rustom
General . who w^ a sta^art. gtwd- ux^io lavuiu^.
lookmg m^ of 55 years. Her relations Except in the case of the old and in-
were horrified, because she was only firm, indiscriminate doles by the
15 summers old. They tried their best trusts, have contributed greatlv to the
to dissuade her. but she was q_:„
adamant. Only him she’d marry, and
none other. they sent a proposal,
which was accepted and Pirojai became
a bride, spending many happy years
with the man of her choice, because
Rustomji lived to a ripe old age of 89.
MS PERIN M. R. B. JEEJEEBHOY
Equality Before Death
Recently, at a funeral in. Calcutta ’s
Ravangah, after prayers were over, the The Parsee hat is such an ordinary
body of the deceased, while being object in a Bombay crowd that we are
taken to the hearse, was placed for a locally too apt to imagine that the
while on the verandah outside the Parsees themselves are plentifully
Ravangah hall for non-Parsis who sprinkled through all the towns and
wished to pay their last respects. But cities of India. This, however, is cer-
the body was covered under a shroud tainly not the case, and in any town
Readers ’ views are welcome on any since custom forbids those of other in India out of the Bombay Presidency,
subject of interest to the community faiths from viewing the face of the the followers of Zoroaster are quite as
and should be sent to the Editor, deceased. uncommon as in London itself, where
Readers ’ Porum, Parsiana, G.P.O. Box Parsis are making fools of our- the members of the little Parsee colony
892, Bombay 400 001. Letters are sub- selves and the earlier such a degrading at Highbury daily attract the a dmiring
ject to editing for reasons of space and practice is done away with, the better glances of all true Cockneys. Still the
clarity. for the community. Par^ character is notoriously enter
prising, and wherever money is to be
“ from Lombard Street to
Hongkong, the Parsees come to the
¦< « :
; ’ •' ’ • r
.......................................
1 H
• I' *
I
s
,!<>fit
* »
ivavjLug uu uiUA;, wiuie Kirojai
’‘J*was brought to Bombay by her rela-
it in the forefront of all activities.
Our religion teadies us to be always
active, to work with faith, hope and
successful due to hard work, an adven
turous and broad vision, receiving of
« ••»-.. >
. t.
. A
*•«
It **
iLt'
if >*
liBii nities.
Times have changed. Competition is
severe. We no more receive favours.
Rus
V
trusts, have contributed greatly to the
quite deteriorating economic condition of the
community. The easy availability of
doles has snapped the vitality of the
recipients. They have forgotten the
motto “Self-help is the best Help.”
DINSHAW B. IRAN
Mr. Irani expired recently in Bombay.
doles has snapped ±e vitality of the
recipients. They have forgotten the
A Hundred Years Ago
T. G. KATRAK 1
Calcutta made.
Empioyment Guidance
Too many youths graduate without
specialization or career planning. With
the growth of the public sector with
its concomittant written and oral
examinations, the opportunities of em- —ST" -------
ployment are keenly contested—only ^e Honble Mr. DosaWioy Framjee at
those who have a degree can hope to • ® G*rgaum Pohce Court, with assault
land jobs. 1 rn* , .----- .------
Also the centres of employment are
not restricted to cities like ^mbay. Cu^jee Sooklajee Street. It appears
Places such as Nasik, Udhna. Chinch- 5®*night of the day previous,
wad and Aurangabad are now growth . passing along the
centres. The sooner our youths realize
these fundamental changes in the
pattern of employment, the better it
would be for their future.
front.
Times of India 21-9-1978
A Parsee named Maneckjee Aspan-
diarjee was yest^ay diarged before
” .... ...—_____;----- 1
the Girgaum Police Court, with assault
ing a European woman named Dina
.Justom General
I read with great interest a letter by
Jamshed K. Pavri of Vancouver,
(Parsiana March 1978) Canada, about
Rustomji Dorabjee Patel titled “What’s
Cooking?”
My grandmother Soonabai had an
interesting story about her Great
Grandfather the above Rustomji, who
she used to fondly refer to as “Rustom
General”, because it was believed that _ _
Th^, a stronghold of the community ihese fundamental chanties in the otherwise annoyed her. Slfe came
m those days, to B^t against pirates, pattern of emplmm^ better it **’*“ verandah of her house
«*o attacked the Portugese Fort at JSd be teXftfmu ’re defendant, whereupon he
ij , , E CHINOY Upon the evidence
She told us of how Rustomji hap- ' adduced, the defendant was convicted
pened to marry his young wife, Pirojai, Economy Rrst and toed Rs. 25, or in default to under-
who along with her elder sister, had It is high time our small community go rigorous imprisonment for fourteen
been sent from Iran to Surat, in care of gave importance to the problem of the days.
a German ship’s captain because of economy of the community and place Times of India 14-8-1978
that on the night of the day previous.
E. CHINOY
f
5Events and
Personalities
earned Ervad Peshotan Peer, a docto- one-fourth of the approximately 400
—- eligible voters. Golwallas opponent.
Pirct Zoroastiian? earned Ervad Pestootan Feer, a aocio- orie-iourui vuc
Shudrair'an7 T kS Sve'^bLn sFty ^T^nthTky^'f D^Pesto'SrWarden?'^^
ss? ¦ ;.iS X's;-;:;
kSLo Matsushima from Kyoto, which according to the noted German received two votes. But aside from
&L^"Ss °'.h“nS ^^Sieson“ub “e^^co„Se?wi«S . GujeJ
U k-u ™ov;na thp nSSntation are of a very miscellaneous character, candidature was to ensure there was
“instructed me to five the Fife of good intended to furnish an outline of toe an election and to highlight toe imper-
insiruciea me uvc luc uiv ml g ,, ipoe-nds and moralitv of the fections m the system. As the 189 11
thoughts, good words and good dee . ailThe Register voters owe their allegiance to
iKuiR «ic plm^lllllvlml. are of a very miscellaneous character,
to five the life of good intended to furnish an outline of toe ------ - - ------ .. _
to uve me me g legends and moraUty of the fections m the system. As the 189 E
religion with which they deal.” The Register voters owe their allegiance to
Mino Kherd which means ‘Opinions BPP President B. K. Boman-Behram
of the Spirit of Wisdom’, was translated and BPP Trustee Nehe Noble no one
into Farsi from an earlier Pazand- can become a trustee without their
Sanskrit version 300 years ago by support. As both reportedly favoured
Dastur Hormazyar and his son, Darab. Golwalla. he was assured a second
A scholar of Farsi, Avesta and 10-year term.
Pahlavi, Peer studied for his doctorate
under the guidance of C—--
Dr. Hormazdyar Mirza. Bom in
Navsari, Peer lost his father at toe age . - . . .
of 14 and family circumstances required Md^rvanjee has made
him to give up I----------- - -------.
and start practising as a priest. As time years
permitted Peer continued to r^’"’y
receiving a diploma from The Sir J. J. i
Madressa after six years of studymg Fire Oiid. On SeP^mb^r
Avft'>as:>Mw*'>‘.'*'.v>kVA'.'.*.*>’>v>i^VjMi:>'' ““ members .
his schooling, you find an incredible to look at it three times and waiK entrepreneurs. V
bcideX of 65 per cent who w^e around two fost Set ^ant to say is that the team
Srown out of schSol sometime during turn you down. That «
their schooling days. The cause seems (again, you have to be careful). Ther
S relXno “o SaUsm nor to retar- are variations to this theme and obvi-
dation TsUms to be related to the ously .some very , succes£ul^ va«
fact that the kid got bored m school;
and he begins to mess around, and sure
enough gets thrown out. Sometimes
20
Xjuvrclv >
>$»
Ghandy at Colaba outlet
Daroga at Waikiki Super Snack Bar
Daroga opened the Waikiki Coffee returns derived from the business were confident enough to start selling it at
House next door to the snack bar, c,. t i------ i—i.;— x__ o--------- ‘=7 , , . . & .
sending continental food and snacks.
His plans for the future include a first-
class, air-conditioned Chinese restau
rant above Waikiki Super Snack Bar,
a supermarket on western lines, a
franchise for icecreams, a new Waikiki
in the suburb of Andheri is underway.
‘We will have four to five Waikikis ______ _______ ___ ______ __
this,’ declares Daroga whose icecream factories helped me to under- three ""5iiontirs'"\vilhour'Mlcs
¦ibition i‘ ----- ’ ' ’ J ' '' ’ ___ 2 __ anv. ¦ waa um
Perlene 12, and his 9-year old“ son I also came across an excellent maga- able to sustain "mT^loTses ^by **seUing
me a millionaire ’. ?
not adequate. So I began looking for Swapna, a snack bar I had opened at
new ideas for a business which would Gdwalia Tank.
not require too much capital. Why I now, invested in a large sancha for
not, I thought, go in for special ice- Rs 150 and started producing the ice
creams, better than the run-of-the-mill cream at Gowalia Tank, trying out
_ , . custard apple and fresh strawberry
rhe first thing was to approach flavours. The new fresh fruit icecream
major icecream producers to find out was a hit at Swapna though the snack
more about the business. Going round bar itself, proved a failure. It ran, for
. , J, 1 , ii,, , — — --------- iTiuiuui oaivS rising
IS shared by his daughter stand the background of the business, beyond Rs 100 a day and I was only
Porous who, he says, ‘plans to make zine. Icecream and Frozen Confec- ffie'icTOream To other private customer
I got my big break at my club, the
Willingdon. It agreed to stock my
icecream and it went down very well
icecream manufacture. with the other members, gaining me
I purchased a small sancha (icecream much publicity for my product. A few
churn) for Rs. 75 and began experi- months later, I began to supply Regal
Zine, J
tionery, the official journal of the Ice- as welt
cream Alliance and the leading
magazine of the British icecream
industry, which gave me insight into
I purchased a small sancha (icecream much publicity for my product. A few
- churn) for Rs. 75 and began experi- months later, I began to supply Regal
When I first began to experiment menting at home, working mostly by theatre whose owner, Dhanii Sidhwa
y. - , . , ----- —-r — “ --------- 1 knew. This was a further boost to
salt and kerosene; but my brother said Soon, I was able to keep out the salt the icecream ’s increasing ponularitv
jt WQC T ifflz* raoli'r»in/> 4.1. _ :________________ 1 X _ . « -r •
w --------- --- -------------- --------------------- T»**o OKZWXA lyvtpizijlxiK H w Ul'
poor sense of taste, 1 gave it to all my the consistency was still unsatisfactory Waikiki snack stall at Breach Candy,
friends, lhe consequences were of and the icecream, quite tasteless. Dis- Now that things were going well,
couree, disastrous. appointed and feeling helpless, I went I received many offers for partnership ’
This Ignoble start fortunately, was around all the bookstalls of Bombay which I needed, as I intended to close
things to come. In till I had collected many excellent books down Swapna and required a new place
1968, I had given up my job at a and journals on making icecream. I to manufacture the icecream from. I
bank to set up busmess, manufactur- — -
ing envelopes; however, it required i__________ ______________________ ............
immense effort and the pleasure and. icecream began improving and I was to spare’ at his business 'premises?
m^ufacturing icecreams, it tasted of myself with the help of a servant.
, -- ' _ ?, .« * a ‘*'^'**’ **xw xwvivuiii kJ XXA\zX VOikJXlAK
it was excenent. Little realizing his and kerosene from the icecream but and I was soon supplying it to the
pnnr camo a foefA T /vnwA ii- «!! »v.ti -xiii_________ x?_j?_ _x______ vmt m •« . « . ®
friends, pie consequences were of and the icecream, quite tasteless. Dis^-
^so got in touch with the famous Taj teamed up with one of the partners of
icecream shop at Bhindi Bazaar. The Waikiki, Nozer Daroga, who had space
31E. A. Chindhy
DECORATIVE
PAINTERS
4, East Street,
>
Poona-411 001.
The icecream gained further popu
larity and we were able to set up
stalls in many parts of Bombay. But
in business as in anything else, it is rare
that two will see eye to eye in every-
thmg—a major problem in any partner
ship. About a year later, I found it
more expedient to leave the partner
ship and be free to produce as 1 liked.
To set up business all over again
and to re-enter the market from scratch
was extremely difficult and required
an intense publicity campaign, from
advertisements in newspapers to spon
soring shows in the icecream’s now
new name, Kentucky.
Fortunately, the new icecream caught
on within a month, and 1 soon, was
able to get sales outlets all over.
I have now introduced a refrigerated
icecream van which travels to many
parts of the city selling the icecream,
and am now negotiating with sheikhs
in the Middle East who have shown
great interest in importing the icecream.
However, inspite of the increase in
business, to maintain the high quality
of our product, my brother (and I)
taste the icecreams daily!
With
Compliments
from
GLOBE
THEATRES
PVT. LTD.
Established
April 3, 1915
Controlling:
41
A Hundred Years Ago
YESTERDAY evening a meeting of
Parsees was held at the Allbless Baug,
being convened by the trustees of the
f^nchayet in response to a requisition
signed by upwards of a thousand
Parsees to commemorate the memory
of the late Sir Cowasjee Jehangir,
Knight, C.S.I., by recording his
numerous charities and other acts of
benevolence in the books of the
Punchayet. About four hundred
Parsees were present, and the chair
was taken by Sir Jamsetjee Jeejeebhoy,
Bart. The chairman, in opening the
proceedings, briefly referred to the
charities and benevolent acts of the
late Sir Cowasjee, and afterwards read
a long memorandum relating to his
benefactions to be recorded in the
books of the Punchayet. Resolutions
were passed adopting the memo
randum, and requesting the trustees
of the Punchayet Funds to insert it
in the records. It was also resolved
to forward copies of the memorandum
to the mother, brother, and the adopted
son of the deceased knight. Thanks
were passed to the trustees of the
charitable funds of the Parsees for
convening the meeting to owners of
the Allbless Baug for the use of their
building, and to the chairman for
presiding.
Times of India of 6th October, 1978.
REGAL
BOMBAY
X
CAPITOL
BOMBAY
X
GLOBE
CALCUTTA
X
ROXY
MADRAS
33World Congress Papers .
The Zoroastrian
Priesthood
Dr. Ervad Peshotan F. Peer
bl the Aryan culture and scheme of . ................
life the priest was always to play a Th© plight of the priests has conventionally been a subject of
lengthy discussion but little action. At both the Second and T^ird
and erudition, priests were highly World Zoroastrian Congress, the topic featured prominently; at the
esteemed and ’ formed an influential Third Congress held in January, it was the first subject for discus-
«'on of the society. In ancient Iran sion. That the uplift of the priesthood has been attempted so often
l^gs themselves came from the without success, implies that the underlying causes are vast and
¦uy CloSSa
The Zarathushtrotemo or the chief
priest of the land was the most res- Parsiana carries abridged and edited versions of the three
pect^ person in the king’s court, so papers read on “The Priestly Class—Its Present Condition and
Ey persons aggrieved put^re Uplift” by Dr. Ervad Peshotan Peer, a Zoroastrian scholar
ri^t to appeal to ZafaStrSemo ^nd panthaki of the Tata Agiary in Bombay, Peshotan Nargolwala,
who had the power to reverse the a member of the ‘Working Group of Mobeds’ (a private group of
judgement if he thought fit in higher social workers) and one of the joint honorary secretaries of the
wisdom. Other hi^ offices of the state Third World Congress and Dr. Bouzardmehr Mehr, a member of
Sri2t^cl^s^S^^l^T^eir°Lte^ the Iranian Parliament, a professor of pathology of the Teheran
^ity and competence, the tone of the Medical College and a person active in the affaip of the Zoroastrian
administration remain^ lofty through- Community and anjumans of Iran. The session was chaired by
out the tenure of the Zoroastrian kings Burjor H. Antia, a noted Bombay lawyer and the Rapporteur was
in Iran. ’ ” , x-. , ., n• rr------- x
When the Parsees had to migrate to
India, the priest class kept up its high
traditions and maintained the leader
ship of the society. Time and again,
~reat priests arose in the community
‘‘ 1 names like Nairyosang Dhaval
Meherji Rana are revered to this
day. The priests rendered a selfless
service to the community by copying
the manuscripts of the Avesta, Pahlavi.
Pazend and Sanskrit texts.
Besides their priestly duties, for
vears they conducted religious classes
for the young. Thus they educated the
Zoroastirians, particularly the sons of
mobeds. With the spread of the British
system of education in India, the study
of our ancient religion and culture
came to be neglected even by the priest
class^ in general. It has also to be sadly
admitted that the, behdins gradually
grew less appreciative of the services
rendered by the priests. Many of the
talented members of the priest class
were, therefore, attracted to other more
lucrative professions. The priest class
gradually became indifferent to the pro
fession, so much so, that the practising
priests hesitated to take their sons into
lengthy discussion but little action. At both the Second and Third
complex.
Future Uplift” by Dr. Ervad Peshotan Peer, a Zoroastrian scholar
the Iranian Parliament, a professor of pathology of the Teheran
Ervad Godrej Sidhwa, an active member of the Karachi Zoroastrian
community.
€
35after year, with the result that the lar^e
Whatever may
have been our
lapses in the past, ?®ntury. the ceremonies were ^rformed
“ m the laitv s residence, as relimniis
let us do honour
where honour is
due.
after year, with the result that the large class must be raised. The elders of th
numbers of yozdathregar mobeds in community should evolve certaii
the whole of India has come down to schemes for the betterment of the clas
such as a sut«tantial central fund t(
which every Zoroastrian family woult
about 65. Till the beginning of this
. , ¦ • * 1 , _________
in the laity’s residence, as religious contribute every year; upward revisioi
tenets were strictly observed by the ' ' '
laity. In those days the priests were
paid very low charges for their services.
For instance, two annas (12 paise)
was paid for the afringan and fravashi,
and one arma for the baj ceremony. It
of rates for the various ceremonies^
benefits such as provident fund, medical
and educational aids should bi
extended. ’
Recently the Cama Athoman Insti-j
tute has adopted a very commendable
was an egregious fault on the part of practice to offer a handsome monthly]
the .behdins that they underestimated stipend to the sons of the priests who
the worth of the priestly class and paid may join the aforesaid institute an®
their own profession and the sons were i
reluctant to follow their fathers’ 1 ___
oc^pation. them so poorly. In fact, the beh^iins learn the priestly profession. Th^
Accordmg to Count Angelo de were in a position to pay suflheient scheme is that when a boy is admitted
Uurernete, Ervad Dadabhoy Khursedji charges if tney wanted to. As such, to the Madressa, Rs. 100 will be depo-
behdins are greatly responsible for sited with a bank every month in the^
amongst 48,000 Parsees in Boinbay.'
year 1874) there are 865 priests the present, acute shortage of priests, joint names of the boy and the trustee,
amongst 48,(W Parsees in Bombay.” For the various reasons, the laity When the student completes the course
It IS estimated that now there are only then entrusted the ceremonies to their after about a period of seven years
fl Aiit r.r.«cte 65,0CC pricito) ..ho per- and leaves the Madressa, then the
^arsee rwidents in Bombay and about formed the ceremonies in the fire amount accumulated would comet 'll
T priests in the whole of temples. Looking to the present econ- more than Rs. 10,000. Thereafter,
India. The fall in the number of omic condition, the amount received boy would be required to work as a
about 250 priests amongst 65,000 panthakies (family priests) who
350 to whole of temples. Looking to the present econ-
practising pnests is a cause of grave by the panthakies is quite inadequate priest for 15 years, at the end of whidi
anxiety for the community. Indeed the to pay the assistants sufficiently. Under a sum of Rs. 54,000 will be handed
very urgent basis.
problem deserves to be tackled on a the circumstances the economic con
dition of the priests is barely sufficient
to cover daily necessities. ITie priests
.............................
J was financial wherewithal. Another reason
training for remaining a bachelor is the housing
The Madressas
In the beginning of this century it
felt that there should be a t__2__
centre for the sons of priests in problem.
Bombay and thus with the initiative
of Dastur Dr. Darab P. Sanjana and Future Lpliftnient
Mr. Jehangir J. Vimadalal, the Dadar The economic condition of the priestly
Athoman Boarding Madressa was
founded under the auspices of the
Athornan Mandal in 1917. Though the
Institution faced severe financial difii-
culties and the trainees were in a
limited number, they produced a good
number of trained priests.
In 1923, Seth Mehrvanji M. Cama,
established the M. F. Cama Athoman
Institute at Andheri by donating a
princely amount of Rs. 25,00,000 to
educate the boys of the priestly class.
For the first two decades, a large
number of trained priests set them
selves up as (practising) priests. They
were educated specially in Avesta
Pahlavi, Iranian History etc.
After World War II more doors of
employment were thrown open in
Bombay. The educated and intelligent
sons of the priests were unwilling to
continue their forefathers’ lofty pro
fession and entered into other fields.
It has been noticed from the records
of the Cama Athornan Institute that
the Institute brought out seven to eight
qualified priests every year between
1955 and 1975. Hardly a few have
adopted the priestly vocation. On the
other hand old qualified and devout
priests left (and leave) this world year
over to the priest.
Even after having completed the pre
scribed course a new qualified entrant
hesitate, to, get rnarried for lack of will definitely entail difficulty in obtain
ing a fair livelihood while practising.
It is necessary to extend a stipend to
the new-comers. Besides, those priests
who are highly educated in the religious
subjects may be given a sum in appre
ciation of their work.
Praying before meals at Cama Athornan Madressa
Photo Noshir Marker
36but he has to take birth in an athornan
family. When our community as a The proliferation
whole is dwindling, the prohlem is agtartCS did nOt
¦3
more acute when applied to the mobeds C -
who constitute a restricted category a,riS6 OUt Ol tlie
within the community.
I classify priests into four functional
categories—Ervads,
Dasturs and Religious Scholars.
The ervad is an athornan who has
passed the basic navar/martab tests
which qualify him to practice as a
1 spiritual needs of
Yozdathragars, ParsiS.
U't
^11181
J ,
I wiiiuu uuttuty xiiiii UM pxM-v/vxww e:-
priest. He generally performs the pupils is 38. A third institution The Sir
the S.S.C. curriculum. They also teach
religious subjects. The number of
afringan, fravashi, baj and satum Jamshedji Jijibhoy Madressa prepares
ceremonies nmHiintp. anH nnst-ffraduate scholars in
The yozdathragar belongs to a
higher, more experienced and com
petent category. He is capable of per
forming the more difficult vandidad,
nirangdin and yajashne ceremonies,
apart from the ceremonies listed for
ervads. There are only 15 ~
yozdathragars today in Bombay ___
approximately 30 in the whole of India.
Dasturs are those to whom the
anjumans or the priestly class have
presented a ‘shawl’ on the basis of
sterling services rendered. While it is
a symbol of high, status in the priest
class to be called a Dastur, the title
J a mastery of the
__ _____, ancient languages and
specialised rituals. (Some people con
sider only those who are the head
priests of atash-behrams to be dasturs — -- ,— ., *
—Editor). liferation of agianes and atash-
Religious scholars are well qualified behrams in Bombay during the last
6 .... . centuries. At its peak the Parsi
population in Bombay has been 70,000
not justifying the constiruction of
46 houses of prayer roughly one for
^vv.y 1.600 Parsis. Two atash-
behrams are within 200 feet of each
uvixvx. Li a square mile, there sue more
than a dozen agiaries. The proliferation
of agiaries did not arise out of the
spiritual needs of the Parsi but was
more often based on sentiment and
Godly beliefs.
Chalenge
In olden days the priest had a deep-
rooted faith in his holy vocation.
vvxix.li nv. 1- ---5 invoke
divine help and blessings. The behdins
after the turn of the century, the faith
of the behdins in the efficacy of prayers
11 ix.Hiiiv^o __ was greatly shaken owing to the spread
The total of westernized, secular education.
Over the last three decades, attempts
were made to revive the faith in reli^on
graduate and post-graduate scholars
Avesta and Pahalavi.
petent category. He is capable of per
forming the more difficult vandidad.
Places of Worship
We have nearly 85 fire temples spread
all over India, of which 42 agianes
and four atash-behrams are in Bombay.
pairs of Apart from the great reverence in
ibay and which fire was held, our forefathers
^8
'j
HI '
Priest Selling Sandalwood in Udwada
The life of a priest is always the also presuppose
life of penance and sacrifice. Before scriptures,
a boy is qualified to practice as a "
built fire temples to commemorate the
memories of their departed ones; it
was considered thrice blessed to donate
an agiary; also one could build a fire
temple at a cost of Rs. 50,000 only
and the maintenance was negligible.
Supporting the priest and his family
was not considered a major financ^l
responsibility for the donor or the
trxistGCS
But the reasons mentioned above,
could not explain or justify the pro
liferation of agiaries and atash-
priest, he is called upon to spend years
Arning the scriptures and the pres-
cril»d ceremonies. If at the end of it
all, he is left high and dry. it is quite
understandable ll..'.
attracted to tread this difficult path. It
is heartening to find that the com
munity has started to be aware of its
responsibility towards the priest class. _ _
The Zoroastrian community in India ou£ scriptures.^
has faced many challenges in the past '
and has faced them bravely. The pro-
b^m of the dwindling priest class may
ifljtbe accepted as a challenge to the
centuries. At its peak the Parsi
that few will be persons capable of undertaking
I this difficult path. It ing, preaching and indei»nde
lUUVll AM ---------- • f
justifying the constiruction ot
1,600 Parsis.
a square mile, there sue
out of the
b^in of the dwin
j^pbe accepted
often based on sentiment and
Education of Priests
labie of undertaking teach-
lent re
search pertaining to the Zoroastrian
religion. Ibey are specialists in ancient
languages and scholarly students of every
The yozdathragar and the dastur other. In
is expected to lead a life of piety. His
personal life has to be exemplary and
in line with the hipest principles of
community. personal purity laid down in our
In every cultured community, a religion,
section dedicates itself to acquire
spiritual knowledge and wisdom so -- ---------- ------ , .
that it may serve the higher needs of There are two basic teaching institu-
the commmiity. Ihis section remains tions, both offermg residential accom- rooted ^^th in n s noi.
well cared for and honoured by the modation, the Athornan Boardmg When he pray^ it was^
rest of the community. Whatever may Madressa at Da.dar and theM. F. C^a However,
have been our lapses in the past. let Athornan Institute at Andheri. Tbe pray ___
us do honour where honour is due and Cama. uZin
translate our sentiments in worthy acts year onwards, has stml^
of sacrifice by contributing our mite ’ ' ’ ’ ‘
to the cause of the amelioration of ------ — -- - .... ,
the priest class who has served us well number of pupils is 14, including four
given Vzarathush.™, Sv
Peahotan Nargolwala oriented curriculum, the Cama the conung generation m y
The mobeds form a small part of Athoman Institute will find it difficult of prayer and be lef n Zoro^man
the Zoroastrian community. A mobed to produce scholars, Athornan tenets is r^ ore problem
has not only to be born a Zoroastrian, Boarding Madressa at Dadar follows a long way to mitigate tne prooiem
31
rest of the community. Whatever may Madressa at Dadar and the M. F. Cama
have been our lapses in the past, let Athornan Institute at i
• ‘ ' Cama Athoman Institute from tins
oriented curriculum which replaces the
standard S.S.C. course. ’
the 9th and 10th standards.
applies. However, it may be noted
here, that owing to the mobedi-
oriented curriculum, theL'
of mobeds. A behdin, who understands
• the principles of his religion, is the
best guarantee for the success of the
mobed profession.
When we left Iran 1,400 years ago
an athravan, Dasturan Dastur Nairio-
sang Dhaval was our leader. In the
centuries to follow, the athravan guided
the destinies of the community through
a multitude of vicissitudes. When
occasion demanded, the athravan sacri
ficed his flesh and blood for the survival
of our religion and our community.
Today when we are asked to repay this
age old debt to the athravan, let us
make it our bounden duty to do so.
Dr. Bouzardmehr Mehr
First of all, we must pay attention to
what our definition of a “Priest” is.
In my opinion it is insufficient to say
that a priest has only the function of
performing rituals. Priests should have
sj^glucational function. They should
i^i^pected not only to perform cere
monies but they should guide members
of the community in ethics and morals.
Every intellectual Zoroastrian is inte
rested in knowing the theological con-
cepts and would like to seek explana- economically
tions regarding certain ideas and j Ic in
ideologies that the religion propounds. OepreSSeClj IS, 111
The priests must find a vocation in 1 a
religion, and not treat it merely as ® ’
one of the ways of making a livelihood. respected.
towns where priests are lacking, we are understanding
Performing jashan ceremony
in the new literature that needs to be
produced and compiled for disseminat
ing the knowledge of Zoroastrianism.
Zoroastrians outside India and Iran
find themselves isolated in the midst of
a large number of diversified cultural
influences. It may be suggested that
for some children, it would not be a
bad idea if any individual or indi
viduals, who have a deep grasp and
ance concerns the salary of priests, towns where pnests are lacking, we are understanding of Zoroastrianism,
The priests and their families should obliged to provide and train assistants volunteer as teachers in their spare
be safe-guarded. If we neglect to con- to substitute priests, in order to per- time so that our children do not feel
sider the priests and their families now, form vital rites. If the priests in India lost in an alien country, because they
we will deprived of any priests in consent, we can use them in Iran for have not had the opportunity of know-
the future. In Iran, there are many various religious ceremonies and train- ing and understanding their religion,
cases where the children of priests ing purposes. Fortunately, the condi-
have become successful professionals tions of society in Iran offer an oppor-
in various fields, but naturally, they tunity for Zoroastrian priests to live
c^BPOt carry out their duties as priests, comfortably and prosper. .
can state that a priest who is The cultural heritage of a people
—Comically depressed, is, in general, can only survive if it be transmitted
little respected. We have an obligation from generation to generation. Over
to teach the new generation to respect the centuries, however, the oral trans
priests, and those people who assist mission of religion has dwindled to the
in religious ceremonies. If poverty reading of a few prayers, which are
and disrespect are a part of b«x>ming difficult to comprehend. Most families
a priest, certainly no one will desire are only able to recite a few prayers,
to fulfill this vocation. and explain Zoroastrianism in terms
There are in Iran a few young of Good Thoughts, Good Words, and
Zoroastrians of priestly families from Good Deeds. This transmission is so
India, in different fields of work. As weak in content, that it leaves behind
they are qualified priests, they are of an intellectual vacuum and a cultural
great help to Zoroastrian families in lag or gap, which must be filled if the
Iran, performing various duties of Zoroastrian cultural heritage is to
priests, and also conducting religious survive in the modem world,
classes for the young and old. All this Zoroastrian scholars, theologians and
they do after their daily work, and on priests must come together to produce
holidays. I have found they are greatly adequate literature in the languages
respected by all. Of course, this is known to the younger generation,
“helpful ” for a town where there aren't Research on Zoroastrianism must be
any priests available, but it is not the carried out, and the findings of this
solution to the problem. In cities and research must be carefully incorporated
A priest who is
The second topic of utmost import
ice concerns me salary of priests.
c»|n<
ccon(
to substitute priests, in order to per
form vital rites. If the priests in India _____________________ ______ _ __
consent, we can use them in Iran for have not had the opportunity of know-
Teacher and Pupil at madressa
Photo N. Marker
39
1
t
’IBOOK REVIEW
Minns into Plus Jogeshwari by train, returning home “Joining the prestigious Presidency
after a full day’s work, pushed and College, Calcutta, he graduated and
Out of th© Night, by Banoo S. jostled by the uncaring throng. But went on to do his M.A. and his LL.B.
Tarapore. Th© National Association back home, he never sits idle. He is side by side, attending the M.A. classes
For the Blind, India, 86 pages.
Out of The Night is the story of
40 blind people who, despite their
handicaps have demonstrated their
ability to “turn a minus into a plus ”. _________
We publish below the story of two HrisVoU oflife, fulFoffunViid loves ------- ...--------------------------------- c,
such people from the book written by hold long conversations with the stint at his former school in Narendra-
Banoo S. Tarapore. i
“Feroze Kaikana, Packing Depart- time to think of others in trouble and course of the Perkins Teacher Train-
merit, Tata Mills, Bombay. Valiant has donated his blood to the blood
indeed is his spirit, as great in inverse
proportion to his diminutive height
which is perhaps a little above 3 ft.
for though Feroze Karkaria is blind,
deaf and crippled he has stood up
squarely to the blows of fate.
“Feroze entered the world with his
two legs joined together. When he was
five, a major operation set him on his
feet, but the weight of the encasing
plaster was so excessive that it affected
his hearing and caused him to be
stunted for life. Walking remains for
him a major exertion.
“As if this was not enough, in his
teens he lost his vision, first in one
eye due to a cataract and later in the
other due to a flying cricket ball.
“He had elementary education at
St. Helena’s School, Pune, upto the
second standard after which he attend
ed a class for the blind, run by two
English ladies. Here he picked up
r s ............................... ¦
he joined the Pune School for the
1" ' ¦ „ * ¦ ¦ • ______
ing plastic bags and undertook orders down, he is definitely not out!
from friends and neighbours.
“Then in 1957 he joined the M. N.
Jogeshwari by train, returning home
jostled by the uncaring throng. But went on to do his M.A. and his LL.B.
>
busy making plastic bags, very often in the morning, and the law lectures
just to present to friends and acquaint- in the afternoon. He studied through-
ances. out on scholarships and he states with
“He refuses to be overwhelmed by legitimate pride that his father did not
his misfortunes as any one would be have to spend a single paisa on his
. . 1. -J-... .1----- education.
“Next, after a three year teaching
to hold long conversations with the stmt at his former school in Narendra-
help of his hearing aid. He even has pur, Cawas appli^ fo£ the diploma
ing Programme, U.S.A. His interviewer,
bank. All of which goes to show that Dr. Waterhouse, was highly impressed,
and he was selected for the year 1970-
1971 and given a Fullbright travel
grant to cover his passage both ways.
“At Perkins also, Cawas achieved
excellent grades and he decided tQ.;3Q
in for the M.Ed degree course as
To meet the heavy expenses, he applied
for a scholarship to the Institute of
International Education. This he could
only get on the recommendation of the
head of his department and the con
sent of the Indian government. Whilst
the former was given in glowing terms
the O.K. from the government took
three long months to come. By that
time Cawas was , in dire financial
straits and found it very sticky going.
In desperation, he applied for smaller
loans from two or three other places,
and waited and waited. When the
money came, it came from all sides,
and did he splurge!
English Braille and music. Later oh »^ansana. never si» mie. return home he married
Bina whom he had courted for ten long
blind, learnt caning of chairs and weav- though Feroze Karkaria is certainly years. She is a doctor with the Govern
ing plastic bags and undertook orders down, he is definitely not out^ ment Family Planning Programme, and
from friends and neighbours.
“Then in 1957 he joined the M. N.
Banajee Industrial Home for the Blind
at Jogeshwari, Bombay, where he re
ceived more elaborate training and to the top in whatever he has under-
, , , _ s . t ’ ’ ; ’ - ’
“In 1959 Feroze got a job in the barrier to him in any way. Today he is
even with one handicap, let alone three.
Karfearia: ‘never sits idle ’.
they now have a charming little tqcl'
dler, Yasmin.
“Looking for a job, Cawas joOa
“Cawas Tambofi, Principal, Govern
ment School for Blind Boys, Delhi.
“You can’t keep a good man down,
and Cawas Tamili has always risen the Delhi Branch erf the National As^-
taken. Blindness, he says, has been no Officer, where he remained till 1974.
ciation for the Blind as Executive
where he has been living ever since.
“In 1959 Feroze got a job in the barrier to him in any way. Today he is “His present post he secured
Tata Mills at Dadar in the packing a Central Government Grade I Officer, through selection on merit by the
and folding section on daily wages. Principal of the Government School Union Public Service Commission,
He makes around Rs. 400/- a month, for Blind Boys, under the Directorate from all candidates interviewed. He is
He is a conscientious worker and ac- of Social Wdfare, Delhi Administra- the principal administrator-in-charge of
cording to Mr. S. N. Roy, the Per- tion. the entire school, including the boarf-
sonnel Manager, his work is entirely
satisfactory. Mr. Roy says that it is
his experience that blind workers are
in no way inferior to their sighted col
leagues, in fact they are often much
better. As if to prove his point, Feroze kept back home for some years. He desire to devote* his time to pure,
won the award for the best physically made up for lost time by gaining voluntary welfare work, God willing.”
handicapped employee of 1967-68. double promotions at the Calcutta Those wishing to acquire a copy of
“How much this reflects to his credit Blind School, Behala, and passed out the book can do so from The National
is clear when you stop to consider the from the Blind Boys Academy, Association For The Blind, Revenue
amount of effort daily required of him. Ramakrishna Mission, Narendrapur, Unit Finance Raising Committee,
He reports to work all the way from in the first grade. Bldg. No. 3, Office No. 1, 13th floor.
a Central Government Grade I Officer,
tion. the entire school, including the board- i
“A bright, intelligent boy, he had ing and hostel supervision and the i
to use all his persuasive powers to ac^emic training of the students. j
convince his parents to let him con- “Cawas is determined to clim*_ _ ‘
tinue his education after his failing high as he can go. And one day, when '
vision was first detected, and he was he has made his pile, it is his sincere
‘Cawas is determined to climb as 1
40ie
Navjeevan Society, Lamington Road, keeping non-Zoroastrians away from
Bombay-4(X) 008. Phone 893388. There the body after the sachkar is attributed
is no price but donations are accepted, to “the simple reason. . . .that the
Zoroastrians have. . . .been through
purificatory ceremonials”, which of
course are denied to the others; “and
any thinking reasoning non-Zoro-
astrian” is expected to be convinced of
‘The Original Emissary of God’
Discourses on Zoroastrianism by
Ervad Godrej Dinshawji Sidhva :
published by the author from th^ necessity of hjs exclusion.
Dinshaw Villa, 71-72 Cyrus Minwala - -
Colony, Mahmoodabad, Karachi 29,
Pakistan, pages 107.
out an understanding of the prayers or
In the preface the author emphasizes the significance of the ceremonies, the
¦ book is instructive. The author observes
that his labour “. . .will be regarded
as well rewarded if (the book) enables
the reader to obtain some elementary
For the Parsi Zoroastrian who has
faith, but who goes through the rituals
of the faith in a mechanic^ way, with
out an understanding of the prayers or
JEENA & COMPANY
ESTD. 1900
T
that for man to live as man, the trans
cending need is religion, and ‘the first
need of religion is faith.’ The book is
a product of the author ’s abiding faith
in the teachings of Zoroaster, ’the knovyledge of our religion and cere-
original emissary of God .
f
O
monials.” Judging by this criteria the
book serves its purpose.
Need Contacts?
All About Contact Lenses by
Dr. Keiki R. Mehta, Jaico Publishing
House, Bombay, pages 112, Rs. 7.50.
Everything you always wanted to know
about contact lenses but didn’t ask or
found your optician didn’t have time
to answer, you can now read about in
Dr. Keiki R. Mehta’s book. Titled
“All About Contact Lenses” the 112
page paperback by the noted Ophthal
mic Surgeon presents in a readable,
easy to comprehend, question answer
format information for those who wear
lenses and those who wish to wear
them.
Aside from the routine hard lenses
and the more recent “soft” lenses,
Mehta also refers to the permanent
wear lenses which can be worn upto
three months at a stretch, 24-hours a
e
day. And the science of orthokerato-
, logy whereby the spectacle number can
»li : double promotions reduced by shaping the front cur-
book covers a wide field with vature of the cornea is explained.
At the end of the book Mehta lists
some do’s and don’ts for those consi-
chapters on the life and teachings of
Zoroaster, the navjote, marriage, fune
ral and other ceremonies and customs, dering contact lenses such as: purchase
such as the more esoteric Yazishna and the best lenses you can afford; select
Vendidad. Some of the chapters are your practitioner carefully; do not ex
reproductions of the author ’s speeches pect instant results as the “success of a
—on occasions such as the birthday well-fitted lense is a happy marriage
celebration of Zoroaster—and therefore between curvature and power va.riable
necessarily of a limited scope in cover- of your eye and a contact lense;” and
ing the subject. look after lenses well.
Over a third of the book is devoted __________________________
to the three contemporary religions of .
the early but.now forgotten Zoroastrian Rasnitl D. BainanDGni'aiH
era, — Mithraism Manichaeism —
Ma^akism, with a final erudite
chapter on Ancient Iranian Literature.
The book is replete with references
to texts in explanation of the cere
monies, but there are portions which Khareghat Colony, 30A Hughes Road,
seem to justify customs merely because Bombay 400 007.
of the ancient lineage. The custom of _ ------------------------------------
Professional Photographer for Photos
of Weddings, Navjotes and Birthday
parties. Contact:
Flat No. 3, First Floor. No. 6 Wadia Block,
IATA AIR CARGO
Clearing, Forwarding
Warehousing and
Insurance Agents
10, Veer Nariman Road
Fort, Bombay-1.
Cable: 'Justitia'
Telex: 2313
PHONE: 312032
Branches:
E. Merc House
19/B, Shakespeare Sarani
(Formerly Theatre Road)
CALCUTTA 16
Phone: 444711
'Jeena House,'
50, Hanuman Road
Connaught Circus
NEW DELHI
PHONE: 310821
41
I
i
!
IVehement Virtuoso
BOYS’ TOWN
Kaikhosru Son^| who holds the
record for "the longest non-
repetitious piece for piano ever
composed," as noted in the
Guiness Book of World Records
was featured in the London
Sunday Times of June 2, this year.
We carry below a text of the
article.
Kaikhosru Sorabji, the 85 year-old fair attendance." viOiat we h^dTaUied
On Tuesday at the Wigmore HaU
he chose a daunting programme con
sisting of a brisk, brilliant, extro
verted account of Bach’s Goldberg
Variations, followed by Sorabji’s
manuscript Concerto per piano senza
orchestra per suonare da me solo
(1946) to give the work its full title
as set out in Grove.
There was much curiosity and a
___i__ ___ _ __Z
Parsee composer who has lived for roughly in texture and style, with what
many years in strict seclusion in we had expected to hear, but strangely
Dorset is music ’s self-creat^ mystery contradicted in detail the pianist ’s ac-
man. Fifty years ago he enjoyed some count of the unknown work printed
celebrity as a composer of vast, com- in the programme. So far from “be-
a intellectually and technically ginning with a silence” and embracing
g works, mainly for piano of in its course the equivalent of “a very
in the programme. So far from “be-
I!
•1
Public School
Nasik 2
CHOICE SCHOOLING
FOR YOUR SON
Recognised as a Public
School by Department of
Education —^for
Merit Scholars. Excellent
Climate—All-round Edu-
cation:
Indian
which once in a while he would give descriptive orchestral” silence (what-
public performances that showed his
’ own virtuosity to be fully equal to
thar demands.
He made a second reputation as Mr. Solomon’s scintillating perfor-
what is called a “trenchant” critic, mance—began before the applause
writing mostly in the New Age and had quite subsided and continued for
the New^ English Weekly, sometimes some 35 or 40 minutes in a virtually
with insight and eloquence, especially unbroken torrent, a ceaseless pounding,
about the special objects of his enthu- cataract of pianist bravura.
siasm (Busoni, Reger, Medtner, Szy- it was not nonsense; the music was
manowski and others who lie slightly evidently the work of a great virtuoso
to one side of the beaten track of (for such frenzied yet sustained bril-
classical tradition) and invariably in a Hance could hardly have been other-
vein of dogmatic superlatives, whether wise conceived), and even of a musi-
l^datory or hostile. Two volumes of cianly thinker—in that the harmonies
his reprinted criticism have appeared, and figurations that scudded past in
“Around Music ” (1932) and “Mi the whirlwind seemed logical and
Contra Fa” (1947) the latter has a pointful, in so far as they could be
subtitle “The Immortalisings of a grasped. But how far was that? For
'' "hiaveUian Musician ” which con- short spells die result was exhilarating;
! the quirky and somewhat musty after a while the vehemence of the
-Jvour of his provocative prose. music became self-defeating, like the
Before long Sorabji not only with- letters of a friend who underlines every
drew from active musical life, but im- second word.
posed an absolute veto on “any The listener, never granted more
proposed public performance under than a moment’s respite and rarely
any circumstance ” of his music, and that, becomes bemused by the sheer
even on its further publication. The rush and multitude of notes and is re
music world thought of him as a com- duced to a kind of a rustic gaping,
bination of Timon of Athens and a Those who have written admiringly of
less jovial Miller of Dee—that worthy Sorabji’s earlier works opine that they
who cared “for nobody, no not I, and exhibit an Oriental mind expressing
nobody cares for me.” itself in terms of modem European
Somebody, however cared enough musical technique (the composer is
about tins remarkable man to penet- m fact of mixed ancestry) but in this
rate his hermitage and overcome his (Concerto without Orchestra I could
ingrown suspicions of the outside detect little that was specifically
world. This was the young and bril- Oriental except the profusion of
liant South African pianist Yonty ornament and indifference to time
Solomon who in due course received scale.
Sorabji’s permission to play his music
and has already done so more than
once.
iptive orchestral silence (what
ever that phrase may mean) and (by
way of a second movement^ “a frag
ment of nocturne ” the music —in
Farming—T rain-
Self-Government
Zoroastrian—
I
^cl
]^o
All Academic Subjects —
Technical Subjects : Radio
and Wood-Work Tech
nology,
ing in
through Elected Boys'
Office-bearers, Games—
Physical Training—Daily
Assembly with Congre
gational Prayers—^Weekly
intensive
Geeta—Koran classes—
Excellent Modern Kitchen
and Dining Room facilities
—-Airy Dormitories . Mode
rate Fees. SUBSTANTIAL
CONCESSION AND FREE-
SHIPS OFFERED TO DE
SERVING
Any help from Social
Workers welcome regard
ing recommendations and
admission of boys.
STUDENTS.
APPLY TO THE
MANAGING TRUSTEE
P. N. Mehta Education Trust
Cooks Building, 324 D. N. Road
Bombay 400 001 or to the Principal.
Submitted by Geeta Doctor
43
◆ ◆ ◆
From the archive
