Complete Issue
Jan 1991
I;
*January 1991
Volume 13 Number 7
EDITOR Jehangir R. Patel
MANAGING EDITOR Arnavaz S. Mama
EXECUTIVE EDITOR Parinaz M. Gandhi
ASSISTANT EDITOR Roxana H. Kaka
DESIGN Kranti Shilotri, Varghese Fernandez,
Deborah D’sousa
3 Readers’ Forum
10 Events and Personalities
14 Travels in Iran - 6 by Manekji Limji Hataria
MARKETING DIRECTOR Veera Patel
ADVERTISING MANAGER Zarin Mistry
ADVERTISING EXECUTIVE Cheryl D'Penha
CHIEF EXECUTIVE Rustom Thanavala
20 Blessings at the Baug by Noshir Dadrawala
29 The Brazen Betrothal by Dosabhai Karaka
31 Milestones
FINANCE B. L. Arora
EDP Rohinton E. Daroga
CIRCULATION Behram Umrigar
MANAGEMENT Minoo Patel, Jasmine Driver
34 In Memoriam
Cover: Navjote at the Jeejeebhoy Dadabhoy Agiary
OFFICE Rajendra P. Nayak,
Khurshid Panthaki, Patricia Lewis,
Rajalakshmi Krishnan, Bakhtavar Batliwalla,
Nowzer Batliwala
Parsiana is published by Jehangir R. Patel
for Parsiana Publications Pvt Ltd, at C/o H.L.
Rochat, Navsari Chambers, ground floor,
39 A.K.Nayak Marg, Fort, Bombay 400001
and printed by him at Parsiana Publications
Pvt Ltd, C/0 Kaiser-E-Hind Pvt Ltd, 300
Perin Nariman Street, Bombay 400001.
Color processing. Comart Lithographers;
and black and white processing, Samir
Process. All rights reserved.
Phone: 2048730 Fax; 2042922
For editorial enquiries: 2048183
Telex 11-85710 RABO IN
Annual inland subscription Rs 80 for one
year (12 issues); Rs 140 for two years
(24 issues). Foreign subscription rates:
Seamail Rs 200/US $ 12/UK £ 7 for one
year, Rs 350/US $ 21/UK £ 12 for two
years (please allow six months or more
from the time of publication); Air mail
Rs 320/US $ 20/UK £ 11 for one year,
Rs 600/US $ 38/UK £ 20 for two years.
For Indian upcountry cheques add Rs 5 for
bank charges; for US cheques add $ 5; for
UK cheques add £ 3. Cheques and drafts
are to be drawn in favor of Parsiana and
posted to GPO Box 892, Bombay 400001
or C/0 H.L.Rochat, Navsari Chambers,
ground floor, 39 A.K.Nayak Marg, Fort,
Bombay 400001BLAZE ADVERTISING PVT LTD
AND ASSOCIATE COMPANIES
iREADERS' FORUM
innnr.n
¦t!'
^4^1
Jim.*
»11 Hb-jIhb 3
k****,*»*»j
i
if
Al*"
tee can ignore such law on the ground of
religious belief.
My personal view is that while no attempts have been for it to serve the
priest can be compelled to perform dead. Brig n.b. grant (Retd)
religious ceremonies against his con- pune
science, the trustees of community funds
and properties can exclude the claims of The Parsi Punchayet trustees not allowing
those Parsi Zoroastrians, who have the traditional funeral rites at doonger-
married outside the community without
renouncing their faith, only at their
legal peril. Dr b. m. masani
¦ Mhow
to serve religion, as long as he serves
man. Unfortunately, so far, all our
dead.
wadi for the late Roxan Shah has upset a
section of the community. The trustees
would have faced similar criticism from a
different section of the community if they
had allowed such ceremonies to be per
formed. To the best of my knowledge
none of the present trustees is a religious
scholar and therefore the board of trustees
“Whither good...?”
Congratulations for hitting the nail on the
head, through your excellent editorial,
“Whither goods thoughts, words, and has to depend on advice tendered to them.
- deeds? ” (Parsiana, September 1990). Their action should be castigated only if
Today, when Muslim fanaticism, and now
Hindu fundamentalism, is raging like
wildfire, devouring all sane thinking, I should not be resolved through legalistic
would have thought that Zoroastrianism, measures. The secular nature of our con-
the most simple and least complicated of stitution and the laws of this country give
all faiths, would have shone out like a
beacon for all religions of the world to
look up to and follow. I am afraid, not
only have we miserably failed in this, but of its rites and customs should have no
have today become the butt of ridicule, interference whatsoever from others,
of interest to the community and should and the joker bawaji (a term derisively Possibly there are those who think that
be sent to the Editor, Readers* Forum,
Parsiana, G.P.O. Box 892, Bombay 400001.
Letters are subject to editing for reasons of
space and clarity. Unsigned letters or those
without an address will not be published.
¦'7
‘S;
Im
Readers' views are welcome on any subject
malafide can be attributed.
All religious controversies cannot and
total freedom and liberty in the practise of
any religion, its customs and traditions.
Every religious group, in the practise
used by non-Parsis to refer to Parsis) of there should be a change with the chan-
the whole nation, if not of the world.
The Prophet ’s message is so simple
and easy to comprehend. This is the only
religion, which I know of, which has no
rituals, no dogmas, no jpenance and no
fasting. Any rituals and dogmas which leaders of our community have a referen-
the Parsis observe in India, are only those
of the country which gave us shelter.
Secondly, it is a religion of happiness nity should be given all the necessary and
and laughter, which expects its followers relevant information, knowledge and
to eat, drink, make love, create wealth, opinions of religious scholars so that the
and always be merry. However, it enjoins laity are educated on these matters and
that, all the above must be enjoyed on the
ging times; and there may be others for
whom tradition and existing customs are
sacrosanct. It is, therefore, absolutely
necessary and feasible, considering that
we are a microscopic minority, that the
dum on this and related issues. Before
holding such a referendum the commu-
“The divine laws of...”
Prefer to the article “The divine laws of
God must prevail ” by, and the interview
“If you want to come back, I want to stop
you ” with, Dastur Firoze Kotwal,
published in Parsiana, September 1990. that, all the above must be enjoyed on the therefore able to cast their choice as they
In view of the furore created on the three pillars of good thoughts, good deem fit. The results of this referendum
subject, I would like that there should be words and good deeds, bound together should then be adopted as a guideline for
clarity of thought in respect of the aspects with a band which stipulates that happi- all future decisions.
• involved.
There is, first, the purely religious as
pect. We must acknowledge that, in this. Lastly, the Zoroastrian religion is a “Whither ParsianaV^
there are few better qualifled than Dastur faith of the living, by the living, and for This is in response to Aspi Moddie ’s di
Ko tw al. He is also correct in stating that
no secular law or judgment can override
religious tenets.
There is, however, another aspect:
the management of religious and trust
properties. This is a secular matter, gov
erned by the law of the land, and no trus-
ness comes only to those who give happi
ness to others.
Lastly, the Zoroastrian religion is a
PHIROZE AMROLIWALLA
the living. It therefore stipulates that its rective (“Making good, clear choice*,"
tenets were made to serve the living man, Parsiana, March 1990) and Roni Khan ’s
but that man was not created to serve its appeal (“Whither Parsiana,” Readers ’
doctrines. Zoroastrian doctrine therefore Forum, Parsiana, April 1990), that some
is expected to bend to accommodate the form of religious education be imparted,
needs of man, as such; there is no need for
the latter to sacrifice his worldly interests
in small doses, by Parsiana.
May I make two modest suggestions?
3 Parsiana January 1991Could Parsiana see its way to printing
brief articles, not more than a single page,
on Zoroastrian concepts, in a series en
titled ‘Know your religion? ’ Basic con
cepts, such as the Amesha Spenta,
Sraosha, Daena, Ashi Vanghui, etc should
be described, and the article should un
failingly conclude by showing their appli-
cationjn daily life. used to have leaders like Kabraji, Pijam, four enchanting children ’s books
Secondly, to complement the above, Hirjibehdin, Vimadalal and others who (including The Navjote) has rather hastily,
I feel, downgraded their inherent value,
wish that Parsiana takes a leading role in They are an enduring and popular suc
cess. Certainly we have nothing quite like
these in our London Zoroastrian House
I am very sorry to hear that our commu- word and deed than in frequent empty
nity, once so very well-known for its proclamations to that effect, for mere in
charities, is now not able to support its in
stitutions. Its downfall is mainly attri
buted to being a leaderless community. It
can be compared to a ship in mid-sea,
drifting captainless at sea.
I remember in the good old days we Chance, ” Parsiana, May 1989) at Piloo ’s
used to have leaders like Kabraji, Pijam, four enchanting
tonation of this confessional clause does
not of itself make one so. Piloo ’s little
book — doing very well! — amply bears
out my assertion. Homi Rogers ’ retro
spective glance (“Navjote by Choice, not
there should be selections from our texts had great influence on the community. I
illustrating the articles. This page could
be entitled: ‘Our Beautiful Prayers. ’ I selecting a good leader. I am quite sure
stress the adjective, beautiful, for it is es
sential that beautiful renderings of our the community.
prayers be made to match Bahai, Chris- New Delhi A long-running sore with Piloo is the
tian, Hindu and Muslim prayers. How of- , , vexing question of geush urva. Why can-
ten have the young come to me and said: ‘‘Nsvjote by choiCG...” not early pastoral man ’s preoccupation
“How beautiful the Bahai prayers are. I fear my dear friend Piloo Jungalwalla with and wonder at this most precious
Why can ’t our prayers be translated in the has inadvertently knocked against well- material possession — domesticated
same way so that we can respond with a intentioned, responsible scholarship cattle — backed by millennia of rich
feeling of devotion because we under- (“Navjote by choice... ” Readers ’ Forum, Indo-Iranian, indeed Indo-European, my-
stand what we are praying? ” Unless this Parsiana, May 1990). I know her to be thology, be allowed expression of lofty
genuine need of our young is fulfilled, deeply involved in the religious instruc- cosmic concepts at the same time as deep
there is bound to be a longing to seek out tion of the young amongst whom she has respect for the tragically oppressed bo-
other religions or follow the saints of successfully achieved an enormous vine at a very earthly level? Zarathush-
other faiths rather than our own. amount for the propagation of our noble tra ’s time and milieu easily accounts for
A far more fundamental reform would universalist faith. his Mazda-inspired verses giving allegori-
be for each anjuman to start Avesta -
classes for old and young, teach them languages are at diverse levels. Learned through pastoral imagery. His Gathas
how to chant the prayers in the original, journals will carry only those which go
and side by side, have the beautiful trans
lations to inspire the learners. We still tend to be incomprehensible to all but phi- human as much as the brutally treated
have our madressas which are teaching lologians. Less highbrow publications bovine. Why should this gentle vehicle of
seven-year-old children the Avesta script aim at coherence and wide appeal at the his powerful universal message be re-
and grammar. They would be happy to expense of close adhesion to the letter — garded as inadequate or as somehow be
advise anjumans at home and Zoroastrian actually paraphrases-cum-commentaries littling his grand vision for the inner
associations abroad regarding such — arousing controversy when interpreta- transformation of all of mankind to
classes. Then the various trusts could tions are challenged on their particular achieve a perfected world? It appears in
help in the printing of Avestan grammar line or direction. Popular journals and congruous just because it is, literally, di
books and texts, starting with our daily magazines come off worst with free-for-
prayers. Gradually, our Khordeh Avesta all, irresponsible thoughts on heavy sub-
would be printed in Avestan script rather jects, ensuing in endless and futile debate
than in Gujarati or English transliteration.
Irani Zoroastrians still keep up with
their mother tongue, Persian/Farsi, no
matter where they settle, so they can fol
low the prayers in Pazend very easily.
Many also know Avesta and Pahlavi, so greater uncertainties than ever for the lay-
we should learn from them.
Finally, let us note the reason why the
Jewish community is so well integrated.
Conversions are very rare, if any, because not let fravarane happily rest at “I pro-
from the age of five years children are
taught Hebrew and learn their prayers in
the original. Most important of all, they for, ” “I assert, ” “I affirm? ” Var undoubt-
know the meaning of what they are pray
ing. Without such an understanding of our
scriptures, we are lost.
Ms 1'11,00 JUNGALWALLA
New Delhi
you will have full-hearted support from
N. s. MARKAR Library.
New Delhi
“Navjote by choice...”
I fear my dear friend Piloo Jungalwalla
has inadvertently knocked against well-
intentioned,
(“Navjote by choice... ” Readers ’ Forum,
enormous
amount for the propagation of our noble
Translations of texts in ancient, cryptic cal shape to his spiritual and social ideas
sing and, yes, proclaim his compassion
back to fundamentals of linguistics and and assurance towards the meek-spirited
tend to be incomprehensible to all but phi-
rect!
Some “translations ” read easily and
entice the unwary reader away from this
precisely because they lack depth and sublime visionary ’s teachings and to-
substance. wards the dangerous fantasies of occult-
Constani probing into the very origin ists and theosophists. They engender the
of certain technical words and religious most distressingly bizarre confusion in
terms which defy precision arouses the unprepared mind, and would have
bemus^ Zarathushtra himself. Dare I
man. “When I use a word, it means just paraphrase the poet who punned that a
what I choose it to mean — neither more translation is like a woman: it is seldom
nor less ” — and there ’s the rub! So why faithful if it is in the least attractive, and
— as corollary — unattractive were it to
fess, ” cumbersome as it appears? Or be faithful. It should be noted that beauti-
should we favor “I declare forth, ” “I opt ful, moving and occasionally inspiring
translations conferred upon the texts of
edly has its roots in choice. The fra prefix other religions are not wholly acceptable
is “forth, ” “pro ” (as in pro-claim, pro- to the followers of those systems. Thus
fess); note fravakhshya, “I proclaim. ” I the Muslim theologians fiercely contest
consider it more important to be Nicholson, ditto for the Buddhists
mazdayasno Zarathushtrish in thought, (though perhaps not fiercely!) and Mas-
»5
4 Parsiana January 1991caro (who I much admire) has irreverently Save the Parsis
been dubbed maskeril To my dear franco- Most people have heard the beautiful leg
phone friend I have to recommend yet end about the first arrival of the Parsis on
another string-chew: the latest, astonish- i' - -
ing, offering by Kellens and Pirart, Les ago. The ruler of the territories sent them
Texies Vieil-avestiques, completed now
with grammar and extensive philological
commentaries. Our sacred texts by their
very nature are destined for “dry ” treat
ment; it is left for theologians, philoso
phers and moralists to unravel the inher
ent profundities for future generations.
We should not be disheartened at our certainly symbolic —->• the newcomers re
inability to discover a scholar with total fused to take no for an answer,
mastery over the entire Indo-Iranian field. — - • - . . . _
Such a one will only come about in the dian life in all sectors. The religious tradi-
person of the Saoshyant who will, alack tion which they brought with them was a
and alas, expound the full majesty of signal contribution that enriched the spiri-
Ahura ’s wisdom long after the only sur- tual and philosophical heritage of India. , ____
viving Parsi has gasped his last, for, one Quite apart from their business acumen in imminent danger of losing the
should be reminded, statisticians have which has been a national asset, some Parsi entity, its ethos and all that it has
assured us only five more generations of the most illustrious names in our free- stood for.
of Parsis. However, I have one in the eye dom struggle were those of Parsis. Let it To an extent it is essential that with
for these ruthless calculators — Zoroastri
anism will win out right up to the
Frashokereti; in the meanwhile let us not get Parsis to accept separate representa-
forever quibble over the brush-strokes I’ • - - ......
and instead learn to fully appreciate the offers were firmly rejected by the geographical base, the smaller communi
grandeur of Zarathushtra ’s visionary community. The House of Tata alone has
painting! farrokh vajifdar done more for this country, than one
of free India piit together.
The Parsis are a happy mixture of
East and West, naturally and easily at
the w£st coast of India many centuries home everywhere. But — and here is the
- 1 sad part — in this land of exploding
a bowl filled to the brim with milk: there population, the Parsis are actually de-
was no place in the bowl for anything
more, and no place in his land for any
more people. The Parsis put some sugar which many others emigrate — because
into the milk, and sent it back to the ruler the stifling atmosphere in this country
who accepted the sweetened milk and the denies opportunities and is a constraint on
Parsis. Whether true or not, the legend is creativity and enterprise. That outflow
aggravates the basic problem: that there is
not much of a natural increase. The prob
lem is compounded by an old Indian tra
dition — the non-acceptance into the fold
of people who marry outside their
community, especially the women. With
this steady decrease this country is
creasing in numbers. Many of them
are emigrating for the same reason for
The Parsi community has enriched In-
some
of the most illustrious names in our free
dom struggle were those of Parsis. Let it
never be forgotten that when the British, greater national mobility and the breaking
with their divide and rule policies, tried to up, not only of castes but distinctive com
munities, increasing intermarriage, loss of
tions in the political confabulations, their tradition through loss of contact with a
ties of India are at risk.
But the Parsi community seems to be
London, UK could almost say all the governments shrinking before our very eyes at an
For Pure Diamonds
JEWELLERS
324, Grant Road, Bombay 400007. Telephone 371483 Fax 899648
APPOINTED VALUERS BY THE GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
6 Parsiana January 1991' ' I views with their names and addresses to
SHiAWAKR. MISTOY the Undersigned at Ratan Mansion, Forjett
Street, Bombay 400036 so that we may
I would exhort Parsis to: get together to formalize a concrete plan
• Be a Parsi: buy/use Parsi goods and of action. d. t. marfatia
services. AH Parsis should patronize,
alarming rate. Their high profile on the young couple who wish to settle down
national, scene probably blinds people to in life. :
this fact. Whether they manage to pre
serve their identity in countries like Can
ada or USA is not clear. But in this coun
try they are an endangered species. scivivcs. rytt ratsia aiiuuiu pauwiiiz-v, • T O
The trouble with trying to preserve the wherever available, goods and services, Touring Iran.'
cultural identity of a human community is manufactured, marketed and provided by While appreciating the love and enthusi-
that it is such a complex business, be- Parsi firms and Parsi managed compa- asm of Parsis for their madar vatan
cause human freedom includes freedom nies. Similarly, all Parsis should patron- (motherland) I feel it my duty to warn
to go in ways that lead to extinction.
A new formula has to be found to re
concile the intermingling of peoples with • Adopt a poor Parsi family. There is no
their preservation of culture and identi- dearth of organized Parsi charities and
ties. The Parsis who have pioneered so I, „ ' '
much and achieved so much, will perhaps benefitted. However, such help is largely, compulsory under the Iranian Govem-
find a solution to this problem too which inevitably, impersonal. I feel that many ment ’s latest regulation for all fweigners.
is increasingly becoming a global Parsi families who are comparatively well The bank at the airport gave me only
problem. MsCB.MurHAMMA,iFS(R«d) off — not necessarily very rich — would seven tomans for each US dollar whereas
New Delhi like to adopt a poor family and seek to in the open market in Tehran, Isfahan and
provide all their needs — monetary as other major cities of Iran one can easily
As our community dwindles, the solution well as emotional. The adoptive family get a rate of 140 tomans per US dollar,
lies in giving incentive to Parsi families will feel a sense of parental obligation In the interest of the community let me
who have three or more children, to being fulfilled and the adopted family also point out that our Indian Government
ties. The Parsis who have pioneered so
Parsi firms and Parsi managed compa
nies. Similarly, all Parsis should patron
ize Parsi managed schools and other insti- them to make proper enquiries before
tutions. booking their tour to Iran.
When I landed at the Tehran airport
in May 1990, I was ordered to convert
large numbers of needy Parsis are being US $ 150 into Iranian tomans. This is
find a solution to this problem too which inevitably, impersonal. I feel that many ment ’s latest regulation for all fweigners.
off — not necessarily very rich — would seven tomans for each US dollar whereas
like to adopt a poor family and seek to - . - -
provide all their needs — monetary as
lies in giving incentive to Parsi families will feel a sense of parental obligation
be accommodated in a bigger house of woufd feel a sense of being wanted and also levys tax at 15 percent on foreign
three rooms plus kitchen at a concessional cared for. Readers who feel that the currency purchased by us in India
rent and other necessities of life, like a above are good ideas and can be made parvezj. katrak
medical insurance scheme etc. Their one workable with suitable modifications/re- ---------------- ------------- --------------------
room plus kitchen could be given to a
finements, are requested to send in their Edited by Amavaz s. Mama
TriKaya.HRj.6.86
H&R Johnson (India) Ltd., Kakad Chambers, Dr. A. Besant Road, Worli, Bombay-400 018,
9 Parsiana January 1991Events and
Personalities
Long-lived Samachar years old), then The Times (of London, people ’s privacy had to be respected un-
Furdoonjee Murzbanjee may never have 205 years old) followed by The Samachar less overriding public purposes were at
imagined his small leaflet Mumbai na (168 years). The Times of India (154 stake; that the people written about had a
Samachar, announcing the arrival of years), Th^ Statesman, Calcutta (115 right of rebuttal; that the paper would not
ships from China 168 years ago, would be years). The Washington Post (113 years), pander to the baser instincts of the public
so honored. The Herald Tribune — now The Interna- by references to religion, color, race, etc;
Before a grand gathering of Bombay ’s tional Herald Tribune — (103 years) and and would not give coverage to the
elite at the Tejpal Auditorium on January the Wall Street Journal (101 years). sleazy, seamy side of life to gain readers.
7, 1991 rich tributes were paid to The “A newspaper has the heart, soul and Under the editorship of Daruwala,
Bombay Samachar, its present owners, mind of its owner, ” said Palkhivala prai- Palkhivala said The Samachar would go
the Cama family and the editor Jehan sing Noshir and Rustom Cama, the two from strength to strength. “The first 168
Daruwala. The function was organized brothers who along with their families years of a newspaper are the most diffi-
by the Abhivadan Trust.
The fourth oldest daily newspaper in
the world and the oldest outside of Great lowed a code of conduct which was simj-
Britain, “T/tc Samachar combines Ion- lar to what the British papers had con-
gevity with a degree of decorum and ceived and followed for many years: that isued by the government commemorating
The Bombay Samachar.
1 .* I 1 Bombay mayor Chhagan Bhujbal
stated he was proud to be the mayor of a
city in which The Mumbai Samachar was
bom. He noted that the Bombay Munici
pal Corporation (BMC) had honored the
paper by naming a road after it. Speaking
in Hindi he told the. gathering that the
BMC gave all sorts of names to all kinds
of roads but he was glad that they had
honored The Samachar along the way.
He said people trusted The Mumbai
Samachar but added that that did not
mean that the other papers were disho
nest. News should be presented as news,
he said; editorial comment should be re
served for the editorial/opinion pages or
columns. He lamented the tendency to
add "mirch masala (spice) ” to-news sto
ries.
The Shiv Sena mayor also noted that
when the controversy arose whether the
city should be referred to as Mumbai in
stead of Bombay, he had stated that the
oldest paper of the city was named Mum
bai Samachar and not Bombay Samachar.
Not to be outdone by the Bombay
mayor, Gujarat ’s Chimanbhai Patel com
mented that though The Bombay Sama-
char was bom in Bombay of which
Bhujbal was the mayor, the paper was
published in Gujarati, the official lan
guage of Gujarat of which he was the
chief minister! (Laughter.) He referred to
“A newspaper has the heart, soul and
mind of its owner, ” said Palkhivala prai-
own and manage the legendary institu
tion. He noted that The Samachar fol
cult, ” he said jocularly, “after that it ’s
easy. ” Palkhivala noted that a suggestion
had been received from a trustee of the
Abhivadan Trust that a postage stamp be
II
I
fi
I
PA’
At the function to felicitate The Mumbai
Samachar'5 existence {from left): Daru
wala, Noshir Cama, Gandhi, Rustom
Cama and Palkhivala
BelowrNoshir Cama with Patel
decency...rarely found amongst journa
lists, ” said chief guest Nani Pall±ivala,
the eminent jurist. Palkhivala had re
searched the age of the various newspa
pers and told the gathering that the Aber
deen Journal in Scotland was the oldest
daily newspaper in the world (245 years
old); next came the Glasgow Herald (208
10 Parsiana January 1991applied biology at the Bombay Hospital
and honorary consultant in neuropatho
logy at the Grant Medical College and the
J. J. Group of Hospitals, was conferred
the eleventh nation^ award of The Birla
Smarak Kosh. This award for 1990-91,
presented for outstanding research in
medical or related fields, comprises a
memento, citation and a cash purse of one
lakh rupees, reports the Indian Express of
November 20,1990.
In the field of neurological and neu
romuscular disorders, Dastur has made
the triputi (trinity) of the two Cama
brothers and Daruwala that had made the
paper indispensable to the public.
Speaking in Gujarati he noted that
“Many families don ’t drink their mor
ning cup of tea ‘without The Bombay
Samachar. He also referred to the pre
vailing disquieting media trend of own
ers ’ views being pushed on to the read
ers, citing specifically the case of the
Narmada controversy in which he had (Left) Dastur: handling nerves
been attacked by several publications.
The Samachar had supported the Nar
mada project, the audience was in
formed. In the name of investigative ------------ , , , „
journalism, newspapers print what route. “He thought if he printed a leaflet ing; nutritional disorders of the nervous
should not be printed. He said he had giving this information it would be help- system; intracranial and intraspinal tu-
preempted the Abhivadan Trust, having ful to the trade. It was originally called mors; allergic arid viral encephalitis; brain
Adajania: goodwill for boxing
know what cargo was to be discharged signal contributions relating to: cerebral
from the ships plying the Bombay-China blood flow and metabolism in human ag-
should not be printed. He said he had giving this information it would be help-
already requested the government to is
sue a stamp honoring The Samachar.
Mundjai na Samachar. He asked the audi- and spinal cord in tuberculous meningitis;
ence not to forget the second oldest paper
in the country also founded by
and many such areas.
_ __ _ _ __ ______ The ^-year-old doctor has published
vinchandra Gandhi, managing trustee of Murzbanjee, the Jam-e-Jamshed. Though about 180 scientific papers, presented
¦¦ “ • ¦¦ around 40 research papers at nearly 30
international conferences and delivered
about 70 guest lectures on his field of spe
cialization. He is co-editor of one book
____________________ each on leprosy, neurotuberculosis and
senior. While he refrained from narrating proprietors, Cina noted that “our editor neurological sciences,
all the pranks they played in school, he is our friend...he helps in making deci
said that in the newspaper business, as
far as finance and administration goes,
“Rusi is my guru. ” ____, ___
a technocrat and Gandhi sought his ad
vice when selecting machinery. Daru-
Presiding over the function, Pra-
’________ . . „ „
the Saurashtra Trust that manages the now a weekly, Cama hoped it would be-
Janmabhoomi group of publications, re
called that he was in Bharda High School
with the Cama brothers and that Rustom task, ” he added. Stating that the newspa-
was his benchmate. Noshir was one year per ’s editorial policy was laid down by its
come a daily once again.
“Running a newspaper is no easy
. Among the no
table institutions of which he" has been
sions. ” made fellow are: the Indian National Sci-
auiiiuiiauauuii gwa. He added that The Times of India was ence Academy, National Academy of
Noshir, he said, was not as old as its owners claimed as it had a Medical Sciences and Royal College of
different name when started.
Daruwala, while thanking the trustees
wala followed in the tradition of editors of the Abhivadan Trust for honoring the
Syed Brelvi and Benjamin Homiman. He
could modulate the tone of his writing to . .
suit the occasion. Gandhi recalled that day) taller than they entered. ” He praised J. J. Hospitals. As a Rockefeller Founda-
when he was the managing director of the work being done by the Abhivadan tion feUow and visiting scientist at the
the Dena Bank at which the Camas had Trust, a charitable organization that annu- National Institutes of Health, Bethesda,
their account, his only complaint was ally expends five to six lakh rupees pro- USA, Dastur pursued his studies on brain
¦ " ... metabolism. For nearly, two decades Das-
___ _______ tur has been associated with the Bombay
Gandhi had suggested Rustom* Cama ’s spective fields. Through felicitation func- University, teaching neurology, patho-
Pathologists, London, reads his curricu
lum vitae.
The neuropath ’s education was at the
paper, said every person connected with New Era School and later at the Wilson
the paper “would walk out (of the hall that College, Grant Medical College and the
Trust, a charitable organization that annu
ally expends five to six lakh rupees pro-
that the brothers never used the overdraft moting the cause of artists and other pub
facility, such was their financial prowess, lie figures who have excelled in their re
name as vice president of the prestigious tions, or grants of monetary aid to the logy and neurosurgery at the postgraduate
Indian Newspaper Society and thereafter once famous but now destitute personal!- level, further informs his bio data.
Rustom became the president of the all- ties, the Abhivadan Trust confers recogni- . '
India body. In turn Rustom proposed tion on the talented. Boxing OiilCldl honored
Gandhi ’s name for the same posts. . . The first Indian to be appointed technical
Speaking on behalf of the family. Distinguished neuropath delegate to the boxing championships at
Noshir Cama referred to the occasion as On the list of 39 “Neuropathologists of the Olympics is Capt Aspi Adajania,
• a “great day in the history of The Bom- the Twentieth Century ” features Dr Darab president of the Indian Amateur Boxing
bay Samachar...so many people who K. Dastur ’s name. This distinction came Federation (lABF), notes The Daily of
matter hhve gathered here, ” he said, to Dastur in September last at the Interna- October 14, 1990. Adajania has offici
ated at international meets since his elec
tion in 1984 to the executive committee
of the Association Internationale de
Boxe Amateur (AIBA). His earlier expe-
ties, the Abhivadan Trust confers recogni-
to Dastur in September last at the Intema-
“Furdoonjee Murzbanjee could have had tional Congress of Neuropathology in
no idea that his paper would one day be Kyoto, Japan, when Prof H. M. Zimmer-
the premier Gujarati newspaper of Bom
bay. All the members of the staff are re
sponsible for what the paper is today. ”
Recalling the humble origins of the
paper, Cama said Murzbanjee started the
paper to help traders who wanted to
man, believed to be the oldest living neu
ropathologist, shortlisted the few out
standing of whom only 22 are reportedly rience as recounted in The Afternoon
alive, notes a press release. Despatch and Courier of September 19,
Barely two months thereafter, Dastur, 1990 was as member of the jury at four
who is director of neuropathology and World Cups, two Olympics and four
11 Parsiana January 1991Aga (left) corporate performer
Mody: advisor on politics
/ X
o
III which she specializes: government and
m politics of India, South East Asia, China
and Japan.
Mody is conversant with several lan
guages including German and Bahasa
(Indonesian). Actually, an in-depth study
of Indonesia under Suharto was the sub
ject for her doctorate studies in ’82, fur
ther informs her bio data. On two occa
sions was she invited to Indonesia to par
ticipate in ventures there.
A first-class student throughout her
academic career, Mody had stood first
among politics students at the University
¦
a leader in boilers, pollution control examinations at the BA and MA levels,
equipment, water treatment plants, spe-
cial chemicals, energy conservation
Asian Games which should help him dis- equipment and surface- coating techno
charge his duties at the 1992 Olympics logy. Of late it has branched into elec-
scheduled to be held in Barcelona, Spain.
Additionally, Adajania, who has been
Bombay, ” played an important role at the Engineering Industry, Aga also chairs the the special committee outlining the
Sixth World Cup Boxing Tournament Maharashtra chapter of the Quality Circle course of future research and study in
held in November ’90 at the Bombay Forum of India. Since his training in Indonesia and Malaysia.
Gymkhana, notes The ^ternoon.
Besides officiating at bouts as a techni
cal man, referee and judge, Adajania him
self has been involved with the game as a
participant and a live wire organizer. The release. Before launching Thermax as a
Vivek Chakra Award for “The Best small company making packaged boilers.
Sports Organizer of the Year ” was Aga was with Burmah Shell, and later
awarded to Adajania last October by Duncans where he got his initial work Scribes Sw^inathan and Ms^Shahnaz
Vivek Varta, a Calcutta-based organiza- experience soon after completing his eco- / ” * . "' “S ' **¦
She was awarded a Fulbright Scholarship
for a year ’s doctoral study at the South
east Asia program, Cornell University,
Ithaca. Thereafter she was selected to
participate at the annual conference of
the Association of Asian Studies at Los
tronics and computer systems.
Besides being a member of the na
tional committee of the Confederation of Angeles where she presented a paper to
credited with bringing “the World Cup to
Skth" Worid Cup Boxing Tournament Maharashtra chapter of the Quality Circle course of future research and study in
1 Not only has Mody been academically
Business School, Aga is a much sought inclined. While studying at the Elphin-
after visiting faculty member on senior stone College, she captained the Col-
management programs, further reads the lege ’s basketball and hockey teams, fur-
“ ther reads her bio data.
management development at the Harvard
Bombay ’s loss, Delhi ’s gain
Scribes Swaminathan and Ms Snahnaz
Anklesaria Aiyar, along with their two-
nomics tripos from Cambridge, informs year-old adopted son Rustom moved to
Delhi on a new posting where Swami
nathan took up associate editorship -of
The Times of India (The TOT) and as-
The new dean of the arts faculty at the sumed responsibility of its editorial page.
University of Bombay is Dr (Ms) Nawaz Earlier they were in Bombay where Swa-
_______ B. Mody who won the elections by se-
The Outstanding Industrialist of the Year curing 74 of the total 104 votes cast,
andmanagin^dir^tor of the P^na-based 1990. Besides being a member of the will continue to work with the Indian Ex-
Thermax Limited, notes a write-up in The Academic Council and Senate, she is also press, reads the column by Dilip Thakore
Afternoon Despatch and Courier dated on the Board of University Teaching and in the BusinessWorld dated August 1-14,
October 9,1990. Research. 1990.
The award instituted by the Indian In- For the last eight years she has been a While Swaminathan was keen to work
~ ¦ ” ¦ ¦ 'i on his new assignment in Delhi, Shahnaz
was not as enthusiastic, believing “there
is too much harassment of women in the
stone and Sophia Colleges. Early last north. It makes my blood boil. ’’
year she was invited to the Advisory I ,
Vivek Varta, a Calcutta-based organiza
tion, reads the Jam^e-Jamshed of Novem
ber 18. His present ambition is to get the release,
more youngsters interested in boxing by , , ,
creating a goodwill for the game, reads Mody elected arts dean
The ^ternoonvnitxi-ixp. ~
Outstanding industrialist
:_ :: - . - -. -
award went to Rohinton Aga, chairman notes The Daily dated SqMMnber 29,
minathan resigned as editor of the Finan
cial Express to accept his new job in
Delhi. Shahnaz, a special correspondent.
Academic Council and Senate, she is also press, reads the column by Dilip Thakore
Research.
____________ For the last eight years she has been a
Stitution of Industrial Engineers (HIE) reader with the Bombay University ’s
came to him for being “an exemplary Department of Civics and Politics. Prior
corporate performer, a committed patron to that she was a lecturer at the Elphin-
of industrial engineering and for his con- i . - - • '
• tribution to human resources develop- — —- - . ..
menL ” Over 1(X) institutional members Council in Politics to frame the syllabi decade, Shahnaz started ou^ with Himmat
from different countries and about for a university in Nasik, reads her cur-
10,(XX) members are affiliated to the riculum vitae. The ministry of home af-
IIIE, notes a press release. fairs has, since 1982, appointed the edu-
The Thermax company which Aga canonist as a guest lecturer at the Internal press. The TOI, the World Bank and the
heads records an annual turnover of Rs Security Academy of the Central Re- London-based Economist during his 20
years in the writing profession, adds
HIE, notes a press release.
___ ,
heads records an annual turnover of Rs Security Academy of the Centra^ Re-
217 crores, 20 percent of which consti
tutes exports. Making a beginning 23
years ago, today the group with a work educational, political and security or-
force of 2,500 people, is recognized as g ’
13 Parsiana January 1991
In the field of journalism for over a
before she moved on to The Statesman
and later the Express group. Husband
Swaminathan has worked for the Ex-
serve Police Force in Mount Abu. Forty-
three-year-old Mody is invited by several BusinessWorld.
ganizations to lecture on subjects in
Compiled by Roxana H. KakaHISTORY
TRAVELS IN IRAN: 6
Education
amelioration
Manekji Limji Hataria
The best hope for the community’s revival lay
in the education of the youth
This is the sixth and last instalment of Hardly two to three percent of the Parsis
Manekji Limji Hataria’s publication,
Rishale Ej Har Shiyaate Iran. 7’
Gujarati original, rendered into English and poverty in mountain caves and for-
by Jamshed M. Bilimoria, has been ests for fear of Arab tyranny and having Zoroastrians took to vices and led an evil
abridged, edited and recollated by Par- known only broken Darri language they life in keeping with the customs of the
siana (courtesy K. R. Cama Oriental In- were unable to carry on trade and com- wild Arabs.
stitute to whom the translation manu- munication with people of other parts of The dokhma of Yazd was in a ruinous
script was gifted).
The author went to Iran in 1854, at was not difficult to realize their sorry the hill was constructed by the efforts of
the behest of the Society for the Amelio- plight as they worked in the winter with- the Zoroastrian Anjuman of Bombay; bqt
ration of the Conditions of the Zoroastri- out sufficient clothes. still the mobeds of the old school prefer
ans of Persia (otherwise known as the After the Arab occupation, education to use the old dokhma, saying the new
Amelioration Society), to report the con- had suffered. The Arabs were semi-bar- one was constructed in modem style and
ditions prevailing there at first hand. He baric tribes who had no culture of their thus was not in keeping with our religion.
returned only once to India, for an 18- own and did not know the value of edu- As the new one is constructed with stone
month spell, at the end of the first 10 cation. Old madressas, teaching Avesta, walls and the old one has muddy walls,
years. The book is largely a publication Pahlavi and Persian, were destroyed by the uneducated mobeds believe that the
of the speeches he then made to acquaint the invaders. Consequently the Zdroas- real dokhma must have muddy walls
the Parsis in India with the wretchedness trians who remained in Iran had no scope only. Stone walls are modem, adopted
of their Iranian coreligionists and to seek for education; their children could not from western countries, and thus they are
help to further the cause of Zoroastrian learn Avesta of Pahlavi and Persian lan-
amelioration in Iran. Having devoted guages and consequently their religious
the rest of his life to the task. Hataria knowledge was wanting. They were
died in Iran in 1890.
In the earlier instalments Hataria de
scribed the ruins that attested to Iran’s dren of Iran remained uncultured and mobeds remained uneducated, they could
ancient glory, the miserable conditions uneducated and, being uneducated, they not guide the behdins on the right lines in
in winch the Zoroastrians survived after became aggressive. It is, therefore, nec- religious matters. They often believed in
the Arab conquest, the spirit in which
they celebrated the milestones of their mean useful education — to the children.
personal lives, the political and economic Languages like Avesta, Pahlavi and Per-
impact of the intervention of Indian Par- sian need to be revived.
sis with the Iranian administration and
the contributions of outstanding individ
ual philanthropists.
lam, girls were forced to marry Arabs and
of Iran are in a somewhat better state Muslims and so on. Many Zarthushti
The than the rest. A majority lived in misery girls remained unmarried through life ei-
¦ ther due to poverty or some other reasons.
were unable to carry on trade and com
munication with people of other parts of
Iran. Most of them were farmers and it condition. A new dokhma on the top of
was not difficult to realize their sorry
out sufficient clothes.
After the Arab occupation, education
had suffered. The Arabs were semi-bar-
unfit for a dokhma. This wrong belief is
due to want of education.
There was a row and controversy bet-
forced to learn Arabic instead. ween the supporters of the old dokhma
Consequently, the Zoroastrian chil- and the upholders of the new one. As the
essary to provide some education — I superstitious elements and introduced
superstition into the religion. Thus the
real tenets of our good religion were set
aside and false beliefs crept in.
Even in India today, it is quite neces
sary for Zoroastrian children to learn
Persian and Avesta in order to acquire
For want of education, many evil cus
toms entered into the community.
Zoroastrians were forced to embrace Is-
14 Parsiana January 7997oriented education was given to the chil
dren even in very early times.
Considering ^1 this, it was decided to
start a boarding school so that the
Zoroastrian children of Kerman, Yazd,
Tehran and other provinces of Iran could
'live together and learn their own scrip
tures. Thirty-six Zoroastrian orphans
were collected from different villages in
Iran. Some of them were nourished and
education was given to them by charitably
The uneducated
mobeds believe that
the real dokhma
must have muddy
wails only
disposed persons and it was found that
they were really educated and useful
members of the community.
schools were established in Russia, it
was found that not a child in the whole
country remained illiterate. Education
was sound and useful. Everyone learnt a
means of livelihood and there was no
unemployment. Iran wanted to follow
the example of Russia. It was strongly
recommended to start a boarding school
in Iran for the benefit of the Zoroastrian
children. Scholars of the western coun
tries were also consulted in this matter
and they all approved the idea. A build
ing was donated by a Zoroastrian of
Tehran to house the proposed boarding
school. On October 30, 1860, a petition
was sent to the Parsi Anjuman of Bom
bay wherein the proposal for a boarding
school in Tehran was put. The petition
dated October 7,1860, written and signed
by the donor of the above-said building,
runs:
“I declare that I am a Zoroastrian in-
When
mended so that the Zoroastrian children
may not be attracted towards Islam but habitant of Tehran and the house that I
would follow with zeal the religion propose to donate for housing the pro-
taught to us by our prophet.
Let us take the example of Russia.
perfect knowledge of religion. It is fool
ish to abandon our own language (Per
sian) and culture and adopt those of oth
ers. taught to us by our prophet. posed orphanage has been purchased by
The great philanthropist Peshotan Let us take the example of Russia, me from a Muslim lady Imam Murteja
Marker has set up an orphanage in Yazd There were no schools in Russia in the for 1,000 tomans. I donate this building
at his own expense and hundreds of past yet education was imparted to the
Zoroastrian boys in Iran benefit from it. children in different ways and young men
There was a recommendation to start were prepared for army, navy, techno-
a boarding school in Tehran for Zoroas
trian children residing in Tehran, Yazd they could get efficient men for certain
and Kerman. This was supposed to be the jobs. Then schools were started and Rus-
only way to inculcate 2k)roastrian chil- sia took a great stride in education. In
dren in religious matters. A study of other countries of the West, all over the
Avesta and religious rituals was recom- < ... .
and the ground on which it stands to the
orphanage with my own free will and ac
cord, under the following conditions:
logy, theology, etc. Later they found that • Myself and my son and successor will
live in this house so long as it is not used
for the orphanage and we will pay three
tomans per month to the Parsi Anjuman.
• As there has been a need for starting a
continent of Europe, very useful and job- Zoroastrian boarding school in Tehran,
15 Parsiana January 7997>
J
I
I
the Zoroastrians there. He said that the
charity given by some of the well-to-do
to school ParsisEf India covers, to Jazia Tax
SuSTStoTtK tomans per function^ as under: imposed upon to ^roastnans .n tan;
moMh, which amount would he used by Of to 24 hours pf to day. nine houre but tore were still many difficulties
the Anjuman for the maintenance of the were kept for sleep. Of the remaining 15 which remained to be solved,
orphanage. ' - . .. . , j
• So long as the house is not used for the various achvities, including education,
orphanage, it could be used by TLoroastri- r ’ j """*
ans even as a godown for storing games, etc.
foodsrains and the utilizers must pay to imv. —j — —------ , a \ i
the fSjuman a rental of three tomans per boys were required to take a bath and then their ^tterment and the task Wrov-
month.
• I have been using this house at present
but in my will I shall direct that the whole
property together with the plot of land be
handed over to the Anjuman after my life
time. And if the house is rented, the
rental should be 150 tomans per annum. ”
The author went to Baghdad for some
urgent work and from there he sent a copy
of the above document to Bombay to Seth
Merwanji Framji Panday. Seth Mer
wanji Panday forwarded the same imme
diately to E----- ’E - „ , r J
Readymony, but unfortunately Seth work of the school starts afterwards.
Readymoney did not pay heed to it and Books printed in Persian only are used;
the orphanage did not materialize for and Persian is the medium of instruction,
some time. J . . - , - ., .
The author came back to Bombay and they learn in books. Much attention is
the same building can be used for that children between the ages of 10 and 15
Duroose and the organizers/owners of the were admitted from neighboring towns
hours, specified times was allotted to
The writer carried on a long corres
pondence with the various Zoroastrian
religious instruction, gymnastics, rest, bodies in India regarding improving the
After getting up early in the morning.
conditions of the Zoroastrians in Iran.
Large amounts of money were sent for
say their prayers. Then there was time ing their conditions was a Himalayan
one. Some people argued that instead of
spending large amounts like that, why
not bring those Zoroastrians to India and
make them settle down here. Here they
can follow any vocation and earn their
living. The question is, who would spon
sor the travel of all the Zoroastrians from
Iran to India. At present there are about
1 ,(XX) Zoroastrian houses in Iran, housing
about 7,(XX) to 8,(XX) souls. Are they all
willing to leave their ancestral houses
Seth Cowasiee Jehangir enough for breakfast and tea. The regular and lands forever and come to India? Is
- • .... ------ J- there any guarantee that they would get
livelihood in India? Lastly, will the
Government of Iran allow all of them to
“We must weep
over this Anjuman
which does not
listen to our
complaint”
Books printed in Persian only are used;
Boys are taught to put into practice what migrate from that couhtry? The Iranis,
• - ' -—¦— who currently come to India, leave their
country in some disguise under the pre-
w.vz __o___________________________ going for Haj or for trade. Then
so that boys can ” b^ome fresh after the only they get permission to leave the
some time.
on March 1, 1864 he contacted the paid to handwriting. There is fixed time
people concerned including Seth in the evening for games and recreation
« wh w work. --------------------- . counuy. ^roasuians of «
Tehran and appealed to the philanthro- There are special classes for science to come to Bombay, they must disuse of
nists here for necessary help and dona- and mathematics. Besides, boys are their house and property m Iran. But the
Sons. It was not possible for him to go to taught arts and crafts like carpentry, Muslims there are not willing to buy and
Iran immediately; so the matter was pro- smithy, cane work, masonry, mechanics, pay full value of the property to the
longed. etc. The aptitudes of the students are Zoroastrians. There are many other
On November 16, 1864, a meeting found out by special tests and boys problems that baffle any definite solu-
was held in Bombay by the Parsis to fi- given training to develop their abilities tion.
- - - • • •------------ -------------- The Iranis who have come to Bombay
are in the restaurant line and some are
doing well; but if all the Irani Zoroastri-
__ ans come down to Bombay there is no
Every month, Hormuzd roz, Khorshed guarantee that they will all get employ-
roz and Ram roz are days when the regu- ment, apart from getting accommoda-
_____________ ¦ . Afte? coming to Bombay, many
boys do work like washing, cleaning, become homesick andjo back to Iran as
ironing clothes, etc. ____________________f .
A register showing the record of work ancestral land and lose touch with it.
of each student is maintained. ””
For improving the conditions of the
vened at the bungalow at Mazagaon of ren can get proper education and become
Seth Merwanji Framji Panday on March good citizens wherever they stay and
¦ - ---- — . Sir Jamsetji earn their livelihood.
Jejeebhoy, Baronet, was in the chair. The writer (traveller) has collected
Seth Manekji Limji Hooshang ancient manuscripts and books in Per
Hataria, who had lived in Iran for 10 sian, Khila Roki script, in Hindi,
in the evening for games and recreation
There are special classes for science
and mathematics. Besides, boys are
taught arts and crafts like carpentry.
smithy, cane work, masonry, mechanics,
etc.
The aptitudes of the students are Zoroastrians.
was held in Bombay by the Parsis to fi- given training to develop their abilities tiom
nalize the venue and other details about so that they can become useful citizens
the boarding school to be established in and stand ot their own feet. The educa-
Iran. They had to decide where the tion imparted in the school is job-ori-
school should be set up, what subjects to ented.
be taught, how to impart religious educa- --------------------------------------- „ . -
tion etc. and Ram roz are days when the regu- ment, apart from getting accommoda-
The necessary fund was created by the lar timetable does not apply. Instead, the tion. After coming to Bombay, many
Parsis of Bombay for the purpose of im- boys do work like washing, cleaning, become homesick and go back to Iran as
proving the conditions of the Zoroastri- ironing clothes, etc. they cannot bear to be away from the
• ans in Iran wherein the greatest contribu
tion was made by Seth Maneck Noshir-
wanji Petit. Then Seth Bomanji Framji
Cama donated Rs 5,000 in
memory of his late daughter,
amount was specifically to be used for the
construction of the proposed orphanage. 20, 1864 at 2.30 p.m.
The work was started and was carried on * ' ‘ ‘
with zeal and enthusiasm. . , .
A boarding school was established in Hataria, who had lived in Iran for 10 sian, .
the capital city of Tehran and Zoroastrian years, had studied the miserable plight of Gujarati, Urdu, English, German and
sacred Zoroastrians of Iran, a meeting was con-
This
The best help for the Iranian Zoroas
trians is to send money to help and run
schools for them in Iran so that the child-
17 Parsiana January 1991inany other languages both from Iran and research workers,
from India, studied them well and pre
served them. Besides, he has collected health failing, he made his will in which
ancient coins of gold, silver and copper,
vessels of various metals, pictures, pho- mentioned above should be kept in such Museum. The author did not like this
tos of inscriptions on mountains, etc after a place and in such a way that it is avail- idea and kept the collection with him for
a labor of 40 years. able to scholars and research workers some time more. By this time he got a
The value of the whole collection at whenever they needed the same. To this reply from the Anjuman that they could
that time was estimated to be about Rs effect he had written to Seth Merwanji
30,000 and many European scholars and Framji Panday to take charge of the
research workers were willing to buy the whole collection on behalf of the fered to take the collection and keep the
whole collection. But the author handed Anjuman and keep It as stated above for
over the whole collection to the Zoroas
trian Anjuman along with Rs 20,000
cash, with instructions to preserve them
in a fitting place and augment it by the
research work of other scholars so that Anjuman, he raised a voice, saying,
the collection may be a permanent and
everlasting measure.
In Europe there are many such collec
tions of ancient articles, both public as know who is the listener of our com-
well as private, in the houses of lords and plaints). ”
nobles. The people appreciate these
things and study them. The same spirit in the subject. By this time the then gov-
must be here among the Parsis of today.
Such a collection of ancient articles is a
source of encouragement to scholars and the author (traveller).
examined some of the ancient coins and
When the author (traveller) felt his appreciated them and made a very hand
some offer to buy the whole collection to
also he had mentioned that the treasure be kept in a separate room in the Victoria
mentioned above should be kept in such
a place and in such a way that it is avail
able to scholars and research workers
not do anything in the matter.
Different parties and organizations of-
same in their museums or libraries or cre
ate a separate museum for the same. The
author found that those institutions al-
the use of scholars and learned men who
arc interested in ancient studies. He had
written to the Anjuman for the same but ready had some old books which were in
as he did not get any reply from the a neglected state; so he realized what
would be the fate of his precious articles.
He declined their offers.
He made several requests to the
"Bareen Anjuman Bay ad jaar agist ke”
nadaanad fariad rash kiat (We must
weep over this Anjuman who does not Anjuman but in vain. He wanted his col
lection to be useful to Zoroastrian scho
lars and research workers. He also
The Anjuman did not take any interest showed his desire that if the Anjuman
could not acceed to his request he would
emor ’s brother, the Hon ’ble Freare came like to create a new museum to preserve
to know of this great treasure and sent for that untold treasure, as is done in many
Hon ’ble Freare European countries.
SERSON
Electrolytic Capacitors
For
All Electronic Applications
From
12 VDC To 350 VDC
Man ttja ctu ren:
Serson Industries Pvt. Ltd
Pfmpri PJFJP.O., Poona-lS.
Cable: EtchfoU Poona-l#. Phone: 82379
T
18 Parsiana January 1991
ITRADITION
COVER STORY
jILhe stage is decorated with, flora and
fauna: the lighting is soft, save the glaring
video lights; the band is all set to play,
“Here comes the bride ” and at the
tor an- decked gates, the omnipresent
fooggawalo (balloon vendor) proffers
his assortment of colorful balloons. In
the rahnni (kitchen) the chutney for the
patra ni machhi (steamed fish in banana
leaves) and the masala for the sali ma
murghi (chicken with potato straw) are
being given the finishing touches.
The backdrop is more or less the same
for the Parsi functions — whether lagan,
navjote, birthday or a wedding anniver
sary — from Sethna, Dadiseth, Saber and
Jeejeebhoy Dadabhoy Agiaries to Cama
and Allbless Bangs in South Bombay. If
it is a mohte gher nu mohtu gathering (a
large gathering from an affluent house
hold) it ’s got to be Allbless Baug or
Jeejeebhoy Dadabhoy Agiary. The dis-
tinguishing features of these different
venues — with their plus and minus
points — come across in our discussions
with trustees/managers administering
these baugs.
son of Eduljee Framjee Allbless in whose
memory the Baug stands, at the adminis
trative office in Ali Chambers, Fort. We
were told earlier by the secretary that he
has been visiting this office every Mon
day-Wednesday-Friday from 10.00 a.m.
to 11 a.m. for the past 40 years. Deaf
S'
I
wg,-
¦¦
Allbless Baug
Going alphabetically we begin with All
bless Baug. We met the frail and aging
Eduljee Bejanji Allbless, the great grand-
BLESSINGS
with age, our queries were understood
with difficulty. However once the sub
ject matter was known, Eduljee opened
for us his records and files.
Allbless Baug, an institution of im
mense social and religious utility to the
Parsi community, was publicly declared
1
KOTWAt <
A' >
4.-5’ n
'1
k
ATTHEBAUG
Noshir Dadrawala
Despite the multiple options in a megapolis,
Parsi bangs remain the most popular venues
for weddings and navjotes in Bombay
20 Parsiana January 1991Eduljee 28, 1785. His father Framjee came to
Bombay from Surat in 1780. Eduljee ’s
H
; L
i
1'
¦
IB . *
& P
»>. /
¦
open on October 13, 1868. Eduljee 28, 1785. His father Framjee came to June 11, 1865 at the ripe age of 80. On
Framjee Allbless, in whose memory his Bombay from Surat in 1780. Eduljee ’s his uthamna ceremony, his five son,s an-
five sons (Maneckji, Dhunjibhoy, was a rags to riches story. Beginning nounced that, to perpetuate his memory,
Bomanji, Dadabhoy and Hormusji) built with almost nothing except a spirit of ad- they had set aside a sum of Rs 1,00,000
the Baug to fulfill the wish of the de- venture, he went on to become the owner for the benefit of Parsis. They purchased
i ceased to do something for the benefit of of two ships Sir Jamsetji Jeejeebhoy a plot of land at Girgaum, measuring
the Parsi community, was bom on April and the Earl of Clare which dropped 4,772 sq yds at a cost of Rs 55,000 and
M erected two separate buildings and
¦ equipped them with furniture, utensils
H and other necessities at a cost of Rs
KI 80,000. At the opening ceremony on Oc-
k| tober 13, 1868, his five sons donated a
fl further sum of Rs 15,000 towards crea-
ting an endowment fund.
The opening ceremony was short but
impressive. A jashan was performed by
about 50 priests and after the ceremony a
paper was read by the sons of the mer-
chant prince declaring that the building
9 was being handed over in trust for the use
9 of the Parsi community.
9 In 1889, Eduljee ’s sons carried out
9 major alterations to the two buildings at
9 a total cost of Rs 75,000. In the early
9 1960s, a permanent stage was constructed
9 on the grounds between the two buildings
9 at a cost of nearly Rs 16,000 which elimi-
¦ nated the trouble and expense of erecting
9 a different stage on every occasion. ¦ Later
9 the whole garden floor was paved in con-
9 Crete for over Rs 15,000 and a band stage
erected for about Rs 5,000.
The atash dadgah at Allbless Baug was
consecrated on roj Govad mah Fravardin
YZ 1238 (October 13, 1868) by Dr Ja-
masji Minocher Jamaspasa. It is tended
today by Ervad Bahadur Panthaky who is
also the Bang ’s manager. The trustees for
the last 122 years have been members of
the Allbless family. The present board
includes, besides Eduljee Bejanji Allbless,
Ms Pilloo Jehangir Poncha, Ms Roshen
Jehangir Lentin and Dr Emch E. Modi.
According to records at Ali Chambers,
on an average the Baug remains occupied
for about 250 days a year. In the months
erous he became. And in the twilight of of December and January there is hardly a
his life, thought of building a baug — a day when the Baug does not echo with the
kind of Parsi community center which chanting of prayers for either the navjote
could be made available at nominal cost or wedding ceremony.
for navjotes and other religious functions.
But death does not wait for wishes to be
fulfilled, and Eduljee passed away on
Above: Grounds of the Jeejeebhoy
Dadabhoy Agiary
Below: Entrance to the Saher Agiary
Photo: Rashid Bamanbehram
(Facing page)
Top: The Cama Baug big otla hall
Photo: Homyar Mistry
Middle: At the Cama Baug small otla
Photo: Naozer Dubash
Bottom: The Allbless Baug stage
Photo: Rashid Bamanbehram
anchor at various ports.
The wealthier he grew, the more gen-
Technically the trustees divide the
Baug in two parts, the west side or the
sea side where navjotes/weddings areusually performed and the east side hall
where jashans are normally performed.
Usually wedding and navjote ceremonies
involve the use of the whole Baug for a
day for a fee of Rs 400. Nearly 3,000
people at a time can be accommodated in
the Baug. However one is free to opt for
only the west side for a fee of Rs 250 or in
case of a jashan, the east side for a nomi
nal charge of Rs 75. Weddings and
navjotes on the east side however attract a
fee of Rs 150. According to Eduljee,
lighting charges range from Rs 930 to Rs
3,500 depending on the glitter you re
quire.
At all times one has to book the Baug
six months in advance. Those requiring
the Baug on say December 25 must come
to Ali Chambers on June 25 and wait pa
tiently till 11.00 a.m. Those really keen
stand in queue from 5 or 6 in the morning
so that they may be among the first to
draw lots. If no one else turns up for
booking the hall you are blessed and con
sidered lucky. If there are more, thoje in
queue get to pick slips until the favored
one reads a “yes ” written on one of those.
If you happen to be among the unfortu
nate and disappointed ones, the whole
cycle has to be repeated on another suit
able day. There is no knowing how many
trips you will need to make until luck fa- plaint was consistent,
vors you. If you find over a dozen Parsis / " ' _
at Ali Chambers waiting for a Behram one, bucket of hot water from the kitchen is painted and this year we even carried
roj, do not be surprised. to the dressing room splashing much of it out tiling work, ” he noted. “The charges
If Jeejeebhoy Dadabhoy Agiary is con- over the 50 meters distance. For the are reasonable, ” he continued, and they
sidered the king of bangs by the local nahn (ritual purification preceding the are putting in every effort to see that the
Parsi community. Allbless is certainly religious ceremony) the bride or bride-
the prince. Its easy accessibility cuts a
neat edge over the former. However,
under the shimmering halo there are also
a few pock marks. The men ’s room
leaves much to be desired. Cracked mir
rors, damaged wash basins and not so
clean urinals leave behind unpleasant the family however dismissed the com-
memories. A short visit to the kitchen
could make you think twice before tuck
ing into a chicken farcha (fried chicken) we repeatedly heard was regarding the
or a patra ni machhi.
We interviewed a family who had en
joyed the facility of this Baug last Janu
ary. ' -
place ” to perform the navjote. The dot
ing mother in her early forties exclaimed.
At the Rustom Baug pavilion grounds
A little man in shorts brings one, just
one, bucket of hot water from the kitchen
to the dressing room splashing much of it
over the 50 meters distance.
original wishes of the founders are not
groom has to use this precious liquid as defeated.
sparingly as possible for if any more is
needed, there would be none available.
The women in particular complained quite rigid and prohibited any commercial
about the sofas being in a perpetual state exploitation beyond the objectives of the
of uncleanliness. The male members of trust. He admitted that a number of build
ers and developers had approached him
with lucrative offers only to be turned
ture of Parsi women. Another complaint away by him. His neighbor at Ali Cham-
; bers, solicitor Rustom Gagrat too had of-
lights on stage being switch^ on only fered to work on a plan of development,
after 6.30 p.m. "'Ketloo avardoo lage but Allbless flatly refused.
(how inauspicious it looks), ” quipped an
They believed “it was a great elderly member of the bride ’s family. Cama Baug
The fans too are switched off the mo- Ensconced amid the cacophony and tu-
ment the priests leave the stage, leaving mult of Central Bombay ’s Khetwadi area,
"Jeevta rahya to baba na lagan bhi aheej relatives and friends drenched in perspira-
karsoo (if we are alive we will also per
form the child ’s wedding here). Pun (but)
we wish they would improve some of the conveniences but he felt everything at
basic facilities, ” she continued. We
talked to two other families and the com-
plaint, attributing it to the fastidious na-
22 Parsiana January 1991
Pointing out a couple of clauses in the
trust deed, he noted that the indenture was
this staid hall of the community has been
tion during summer. the venue of innumerable feasts for the
We asked Eduljee regarding these in- past 121 years.
By an indenture executed on June 5,
1869 Pallonji Cursetji Cama — a success
ful businessman of Bombay — dedicated
Allblcss Baug was in order. “We carry
out major repairs every year. The kitchen
<
I
'1
(’ ¦ ¦¦ ¦ I “We have a complaint box but we
to up-country Parsis, even Parsis staying have hardly received any complaints, ”
in small one room-kitchen flats in Bom-
trust deed that the property originally bay find it convenient to host a function at
the Agiary and community center in his
name for the use of the members of the
Parsi community. It appears from the
nominal fee of Rs 50 per day. In addition
The big otla, according to the manager,
is in use almost 250 days a year, the small which lays it open to bird droppings espe-
otla following close behind with an aver
age of 200 days per annum. The months
Antia noted. We pointed out a few per
taining to the toilet and dressing room fa-
admeasured 5,116 sq yds and the settlor the Baug by staying there overnight and cilities that needed improvement, the
had intended that the Baug be utilized by avoiding inconvenience at home. illkempt kitchen and the stage in the com-
the members of the community absolutely The big otla, according to the manager, pound without a permanent covering
free of charge. We learn from a souvenir
brought out by the trustees on the occa
sion of the one hundred and eleventh an
niversary that nominal fees were charged between June-September are lean, but at-
f
i
cially since there is a huge tree looming
over it. While the roof is repaired every
______ ______________ year, plumbing and sanitation work is a
for the use of the hall only from the year tract birthday celebrations, jashans and regular expenditure. The toilet facilities
1922._______________________________ other festivities. The trustees of the Baug have also been improved, said Antia.
We wondered if all this expenditure
also meant higher rates for booking the
hall. The answer was in the affirmative.
Antia however hastened to'add that, the
hangWania. charges would not be exorbitant. “The
The managing trustee claims to visit whole charitable object would be defeated
otherwise, ” he emphasized. “Ours is not
a poor trust, ” he clarified. “No hall in
Bombay can claim to be poor. They all
generate money. In our case we divert the
other festivities. The trustees of the Baug have also been improved, said Antia,
include chairman Jamshed Guzder, man
aging trustee Burjor Antia and Ratan
While the small otla (wing) situated at
the north end has the capacity to accom
modate about a hundred people, the big Nanabhoy, Sam Rao, Eruch Desai,
otla at the south end of the property can Cowasji Dinshaw (Adenwala) and Hos-
accommodate twice the number.
The charges, according to Emchsha
Wellington who has served as manager of the Agiary and Baug every Sunday mor-
the Baug for the last 18 years, are very ning to look into the problems and diffi-
reasonable. Rs 100 for the big otla and culties faced by the staff. We interviewed
just Rs 30 for the small otla if booked him at his solicitors ’ firm in Fort. Ac- „
two months in advance. However, if cording to Antia, “The trustees are putting surplus income for maintaining the
booked over two months in advance, the in every effort to offer the best facilities at Agiary and the Baug. ” The trust, accor-
bigger hall attracts a fee of Rs 500 and the minimum cost. ” By way of example he ding to Antia, is also applying to the court
smaller hall Rs 50. The upper hall, which
according to Wellington is a blessing for
up-country and suburban Parsis, attracts a
23 Parsiana January 1991
Above: At the AUbless Baug hall
Photo: T. G. Panchal
Bottom: Entrance to the Jeejeebhoy
Dadabhoy Agiary
in every effort to offer the best facilities at
minimum cost. ” By way of example he
pointed out that a new permanent stage for permission to apply the income cy
has been erected at a cost of Rs 10,000, pres for the uplift of mobeds. “We are a
the garden around the Agiary has been forward-looking team of trustees and do
not believe in lying dormant, ” he con
firmed. “Our object is to serve the poor, ”
he emphasized for the third time.
I “We are open to any scheme for deve-
I lopment, ” Antia noted. “However, there
I are inbuilt difficulties. Any plan for de-
I velopment would lead to a sizable chunk
I of property being lost in setback. ” Antia
I also pointed out that presently the Baug
I enjoys the luxury of open air. Any new
I modem structure would be an assault on
I the aesthetic sensibilities of the commu-
j nity. He repeated however that the trust ’s
' architects were examining the various
possibilities. Wellington recalled that in
the year 1973, legal luminary S. R'. Vakil
had also worked on a scheme for develop
ment but for various reasons the plans fell
through.
1
Dadiseth Atash Bahram (Fanaswadi)
Built in the latter half of the eighteenth
improved, new neon lights have added century — September 20, 1783 to be pre
luster and painting work, estimated at
around one and a half lakh rupees, is on
hand.
cise — the Dadiseth Atash Bahram ’s
founder trustees included Dadi Nusser-
wanji Dadiseth, Framji Dorabji Panday,
Hormusji Mancherji Cama, Sorabji
Cursetji Dadiseth, Khursetji Nowroji Sa-
hiar and Ardeshir Hirji Dadyseth. Be
sides this scanty piece of information, the
present board of trustees — Eruch A.Dastur, Muncherji J. Cama and Kerfegar feels an amount of at least 10 lakh rupees land, according to Nanabhoy Jeejeebhoy,
K. Billimoria — were unable to throw will be involved in repairing the Atash were mainly fishermen and made their
any light on the history of the Atash Bah- Bahram building and compound which living by the net The elders of about 125
ram, the adjoining property or the foun- includes the two otlas. Merchant la- Parsi families residing on Old Woman ’s
ders. The trustees sent their assistant sec- mented the loss of the late Jehangir Island, appealed to Seth Jeejeebhoy Da-
retary Behram A. Merchant with some of Dadiseth, the last managing trustee and dabhoy to build an agiary on the island,
the details we had earlier requested. Mer- direct descendant of the Dadiseth family thereby obviating the necessity of moving
chant, a retired employee of Tata Textiles, who was totally dedicated to the affairs of to the mainland by boat to meet their re-
has been connected with the Dadiseth the trust and spent two hours every day at ligious requirements. Seth Jeejeebhoy, a
Trust for only about a year. the trust office. resident of Parel, paid a visit to Old
The baug, according to Merchant, was P
gifted to the Dadiseth Trust by the Kadmi all appearance could be made more ap-
Gambhar Fund. The year
in which the gift was exc- I
cuted was unknown. I
With a capacity to ac- I
commodate as many as L
500-800 people, the baug ’.
adjoining the Atash Bah-
ram is barely used for 50- »
75 days a year. The fee for 3
booking the Baug is a mere |
Rs 60 and like Cama Baug, __________________ __________________________________
facilities for staying over- Yarosh, mah Shehrevar 1205
night are provided within YZ (March 15, 1836).
the complex for an addi- Jeejeebhoy not only used to
tional fee of Rs 30 per day. visit the Agiary from time to
Snooty Bombayites -- , time but also stayed there
would not think much of during the days of muktad.
this place but there are The trust ’s secretary Nariman
families in Surat who ccHne Neralwala, who has been in
all the way to Bombay to Dadyseth Atash Bahram and the adjoining baug Photo; Homyar Mistry service of the trust for the
perform their children ’s past 48 years, eagerly showed
weddings and navjotes at the Dadiseth pealing. However there are others who us Jeejeebhoy ’s antique furniture at the
Atash Bahram. Merchant claims there are feel the baug exudes an old-world charm. Agiary and in particular the rosewood
families whose weddings and navjotes We met a devotee at the Atash Bahram table where he played cards with friends,
have been performed at this Dadiseth who coaxed us to close our eyes and feel In the early years the facility of the
Atash Bahram for three generations, the atmosphere. “Can ’t you sense it? The Agiary and baug was predominantly
There is a belief among the Parsis of Surat atmosphere is charged with spiritual en- availed of by the residents of Colaba.
that a wedding performed at the Atash ergy, ” he pressed us. We closed our eyes However, in today ’s small world the
Bahram assures a happy married life with and, strangely, we did experience a sense Agiary ’s remoteness is no deterrent. The
many children. of tranquility. baug, according to Nanabhoy, is in use
The baug however is in a total state of almost 200 days a year. Even during the
disrepair. The Trust has received a no- Jeejeebhoy Dadabhoy Agiary monsoons there are several jashans and
tice from the Bombay Municipal Corpo- Unlike Allbless Baug and Cama Baug, religious ceremonies performed in the
ration to carry out necessary repairs. The Jeejeebhoy Dadabhoy Agiary is tucked baug.
walls have not seen a coat of paint in away in a remote yet elite comer of South
many years. The kitchen, according to Bombay, within the naval complex just on a purely first come first served basis.
Merchant, threatens to cave in any mo- off Pilot Bunder Road. Offering the Parsis residing abroad book the baug al
ment. There is no parking facility and panorama and freshness of the Arabian
the premises stand surrounded by matka Sea, the Agiary ’s prime locale is un-
(gambling) and opium dens. matched. We met the chairman, Nana-
Unlike all the other Parsi baugs we bhoy Jeejeebhoy, bent almost at right stretched to 2,500 when the first floor
visited, this was the only one incurring a angles with age, yet one who could recall room and terrace are also utilized, says
loss. “There is an excess of expenditure historical data from memory and seemed the trust's secretary.
over income, ” notes Merchant, “and the to be a living encyclopaedia on historical According to Nanabhoy, the baug of-
trustees are contemplating extensive re- data and geographical records. fers one of the finest facilities in town. “It
pairs and renovation. ” The use of the The place where the Agiary stands to- is even better than a five-star hotel, ”
baug for religious functions, including day was then the “Old Woman ’s Island. ” adds Ms JerDhondy, a long time associate
weddings and navjotes, was to be sus
pended for a period of at least two years
starting November 1, 1990. Merchant Post Office. Parsis of Old Woman ’s Is-
includes the two otlas. Merchant la
mented the loss of the late Jehangir Island, appealed to Seth Jeejeebhoy Da-
Bombayites
24 Parsiana January 1991
vm 't
Ef*?.
I
the trust office.
Patrons generally feel the bang ’s over- Woman ’s Island and personally pur-
" .. '' ‘ . ¦ chased a large piece of land for the pur
pose of an agiary and a com
munity center. Additionally
he also purchased an adjoin
ing property to house the
agiary ’s panthaky.
house was occupied for many
—years thereafter by the illus-
'«nr hious (Dr) Sir Jivanji Modi.
The
f
> ' **
Dadyseth Atash Bahram and the adjoining baug Photo; Homyar Mistry
who coaxed us to close our eyes and feel
to be a living encyclopaedia on historical
The place where the Agiary stands to-
The Agiary and commu
nity center was thrown open
to the community on roj
The baug, informs Neralwala, is given
most 18 months in advance. It can ac
commodate about 800 people with ease
and the capacity can be comfortably
There was the Arabian Sea between what of Nanabhoy and director of Jam-e-Jam-
is today ’s Regal Cinema and the Colaba shed. Repairs are carried out from time to
time and the baug can boast of one of theI
most well-maintained kitchens and toilet elite Bhulabhai Desai Road, Saher Agiary
facilities. The office of the trust was
originally housed in Alice Building, Fort,
and had to be shifted to Colaba in 1973
after the fire which gutted that entire ill-
fated complex.
enjoys a unique distinction. Not many
Parsis are even aware of its existence.
However, those who do, experience a
strange force of attraction. The greenery
and geographic elevation provide one al-
The present trustees of the Agiary and most with an out-of-town feeling.
baug besides chairman Nanabhoy in- Built about 145 years ago by Homusji
elude: Jamshedji Rustomji Jeejeebhoy, Dadabhoy Saher, the Agiary ’s affairs to-
Dossabhoy Jamshedji Jeejeebhoy and day are managed by Naoroji Gamadia
Russi Ardeshir Jeejeebhoy. The trustees (managing trustee), Muncherji Cama, Sir
from the time of inception have been Jamsetji Jejeebhoy, Rustom Jejeebhoy
members of the Jeejeebhoy family. The and Phiroze Bookbinder.
trustees, says Nanabhoy, hold more than
six meetings a year. _ .
Development and commercial exploi- from the number of devotees patronizing
tation of the property is a near impossi- the Agiary and availing the facility of the
bility. Situated in a defence services compound for weddings and navjotes.
area on a “quit and ground rent ” basis, * ’ ' ~
Nanabhoy claims builders and develo
pers have never bothered him.
Financially the trust is rich. The baug accommodate about 350 people com-
generates enough income to maintain the fortably and records indicate that on an
Agiary, support educational institutions, ’
and extend medical and financial assis
tance to poor and deserving Zoroastrians.
According to Gamadia, awareness of
the Agiary is on the increase as is evident
There is no regular kitchen and guests
enjoy their dinner amid the lush greenery
and canopy of stars. The compound can
average it is in use about 125 days a year.
According to Gamadia, the compound
_____ facility is offered to the members of the
According to Neralwala, last year the community for a donation of Rs 700 and
trust spent over a lakh of rupees on educa- '
tional and medical assistance.
Yet the trust foresees difficult times
ahead. It may have to undertake major pose to provide patrons with still further
repairs and carry out reinforcement facilities.
work. “The saline air does our health a C . .
lot of good but also corrodes the iron further FSI (floor space index) for deve-
beams and general infrastructure, ” be- wac anv fhp
moans Neralwala. To provide for this
foreseeable expenditure the trustees, with
a lot of hesitation and constraint, have re
cently raised the donation for booking the
above. Repairs to the Agiary and com
pound are carried out regularly. The trust
has a good income and the trustees pro-
Gamadia believes the property has no
lopment and even if there was any, the
trustees would hate to put up any other
structure that would come in the way of
the Agiary ’s aesthetic grandeur.
The trustees are presently contempla-
baug'to Rs 5,(XX). This has ruffled a few ting an increase in the minimum donation
feathers. “We might as well throw a re- ' ' " ' -- .l -*--
cepdon at The Taj, ” sighed a family we
requested for the use of the Agiary com
pound. “After all we are providing and
know. “We have to pay additionally for will provide one of the best and most
the bus arrangement between the Agiary unique wedding-navjote facilities in
and Churchgate (the nearest railway sta- town, ” explains Gamadia. and Churchgate (the nearest railway sta
tion, for the convenience of guests), pay
for the lighting which ranges between Rs Sethna Agiary
2,300 and Rs 3,500 and even the caterers Somebody asked the other day what Tar
quote a fatter estimate, ” the family con- deo Road ’s highest common factor was,
tinned. We were intrigued by the last and without a moment ’s hesitation the re
statement and decided to probe deeper, sponse was — Parsi fire-temples. Four of
• But were happily informed that the cater- them, and that too, all fairly well-patron-
ers ’ rates firom Cama and Allbless Bangs ized. The focus of our study however was
to Jeejeebhoy Agiary were uniform. We not fire-temples but wedding-navjote ven-
stood by the sea near the east end of the ues. Our eyes therefore turned to Sethna
baug savoring the saline air. It was about Agiary situated at the junction of Tardeo
The Agiary ’s managing trustee Jal
Vakil talked to us for over an hour and
thrice during the period he corrected us
Saher Agiary for referring to the Agiary as Sethna
Situated on a hillock just off Bombay ’s Agiary. “It should ^orrecdy be called
12 noon, the baug was empty and silent Road and Forjett Hill,
save the chirping of birds and swaying of — ¦ -
palm trees.
25 Parsiana January 1991
OUR WORLD OF
VACATIONS-1991
Lala's ofter'special holiday
package tours, both Deluxe and
Economy for individuals and
groups.
J
• Shimla-Manali • Nainital-
Muasourie • Darjeeling-
Sikkim e Nepal e Bhutan
e Kashmir e Delhi-Agra-
Jaipur e Mysore-Bangalore-
Ooty e Madras-Trivandrum-
Kanyakumari-Kodaikanal
e Bhubaneshwar-Puri-
Konark e Goa e Andamans
• Lakshadweep
Note: Rail Tour booking closes
70 days prior to departure.
Chalk out your
own package. Stay where, when
and as long as you like,
according to your personal
interest, time and budget
Lola
tours
V
e U.S.A. - Canada • Europe-
U.K. e Kenya • Japan
e Bangkok-Pattaya-Hong
Kong-Singapore e Maldives-
Sri Lanka e Mauritius
e Australia e New Zealand
Note: Subject to GOI/RBI
approval. FTS/NTS
passengers only.
For detailed itinerary,
contact us or your Travel
Agent:
H.K.LALA&CO.
• Capitol Cinema Bldg.,
Murzban Road,
Bombay 400 001.
Tel: 204 5094/5744/3006
Oattarom-LT 70/91the Muncherji Sett Agiary, ” he admon
ished.
In the eighteenth century the majority razed to the ground. A new structure was
of Parsis were residents of “Cote” (Fort built and thrown open to the community
locality). It was Sohrabji Muncherji Sett on October 31, 1896.
(who after adoption by his uncle became
Sohrabji Maneckji Sett) who induced this century. Parsis began to sell their Hill.
Parsis to settle in “Bahar Cote” (outside
Fort). Sohrabji, states Vakil, owned vast
fields around what is today ’s Sheik
Menon Street and as an act of charity and
benevolence gifted plots of land for resi
dential purposes to Parsis at a nominal
rent of eight annas per annum,
dadgah, better known as Khara Kuvani
Agiary, was consecratead on November .............. and hall today are managed by Vakil and
24, 1796 (roj Sarosh, mah Ardibehsht) to property around the Agiary to non-Parsis his colleagues Dinshawji Maneckji Mis
meet the religious requirements of Parsis and the Agiary was left with little or no try and Minoo Rustomji Sethna, all three
of Bahar Cote. In the meantime, the Par- patronage. It was then that the trustees being descendants of the Sett family
sis of Cote enjoyed the benefit of the decided to purchase a plot of land belong-
Maneckji Sett Dar-e-Meher. ing to Adamji Peerbhoy at Jaifal Wadi
With the passage of time the Parsi and relocate the adarian saheb. After per-
population of Bahar Cote flourished and mission to sell the old property was ob-
the dadgah was raised to the status of an tained in 1923 from the Advocate Gen-
adarian on November 24, 1822. A deed eral, it was sold in 1927 for a sum of Rs the community from Mughal oppression,
of settlement was executed on April 1, 4,75,000. The property at Jaifal Wadi Vakil claims his was the very first
1874. By 1896 the building was in such a along with Jaifal Terrace was purchased
dilapidated condition that it had to be for a sum of Rs 3,11,000. Rs l,50,0(X)
were spent on the construction of a new
structure at Jaifal Wadi that would house
the fire. The holy fire during that period
However, around the second decade of was kept at Thuthi Agiary on Malabar
A
If no one else turns
up for booking the
hall you are
considered lucky
The Agiary at Jaifal Wadi, with the
additional facility of a wedding-navjote
hall, was thrown open to the members of
the community on March 27, 1927 (roj
Behram, mah Meher). “Thus we ob
serve two salgrehs (anniversaries), ”
noted Vakil, one of the building, and one
of the holy fire. The affairs of the Agiary
whose founder was the illustrious Rustom
Maneck (1635-1721), a broker in Surat
who founded and developed the Rustom-
pura locality there, and who is particu
larly remembered for his efforts to free
1
4,75,000. The property at Jaifal Wadi
MATRIMONIAL
Matrimonial correspondence
invited from well-settled
Parsi boys with good family
background for 23-year-old,
slim, 5' 3" beautiful, fair,
well-educated (M.A. Eng. Lit.
1st class), domestically
well-trained daughter.
Willing to settle anywhere
in India or abroad.
Advertisement for
better choice only.
Write giving full details
with photograph (returnable) to:
Matrimonial alliance invited
from good-looking,
cultured Zoroastrian girls,
27 to 33 years, willing
to settle abroad for a 39-year,
tall, good-looking,
highly educated, very
well-settled Zoroastrian boy
having bungalow
accommodation. Boy
arriving shortly in Bombay.
Apply immediately with
full photograph
(returnable) to:
The Advertiser
Matrimonial (Jan/1-91)
Parsiana
GPO Box No 892
Bombay 400001
The Advertiser
Matrimonial (Jan/2-91)
Parsiana
GPO Box 892
Bombay 400001
Young (31 years),
attractive, intelligent,
petite, warm-hearted,
Parsi Zoroastrian girl,
management graduate,
working in an engineering
firm, belonging to a respected
family, invites
correspondence with a view
to matrimony from
intelligent, attractive;
well-educated, well-settled,
friendly, mature,
broad-minded young
Zoroastrian men.
Please write, enclosing a
photograph if possible, to:
The Advertiser
Matrimonial (Jan/3-91)
Parsiana
GPO Box 892
Bombay 400001
26 Parsiana January 1991navjote to be performed at the with the music arrangement. Most pa- first birthday was recently celebrated at
Sethna (oops! Muncherji Sett) Agiary trons complain about the quality of re- the hall. Vakil, on the other hand, felt
hall. The hire of the hall, which has a corded music provided by Sam that besides bringing in Rs 20,(XX) annu-
capacity to accommodate around 300 Poonawala — the hall ’s one and only of- ally for the trust, Poonawala was doing
“It his best. “And there is nothing to stop
any one from having a live band from
people, also entitles the user to the benefit ficial and approved contractor.
of a fairly spacious terrace and a little gar- leaves much to be desired, ” noted a fam-
den which, according to Vakil, is hardly ily whose child ’s navjote was recently Nellie ’s to Hijackers, ” he continued.
used. “I would strongly encourage the performed at the hall. “We have no The other complaints concern light
use of the garden but Parsis seem to have choice. The trustees insist Poonawala is ing. “But nothing serious.
course can be quite demanding, ” Vakil
continued on page 30
an aversion, ” bemoans Vakil. the only official music contractor for the
For a nominal fee of Rs 150 plus an hall, ” added the parents of a child whose
Parsis of
additional sum of Rs 150 to cover the
cost of electricity, the hall is in use for
almost 150-200 days a year. The facility
is offered on a purely first come, first
served basis.
We asked Vakil about the mainte
nance and he seemed to take some pride
in mentioning that the Agiary and hall re
cently received a new coat of paint. “We
have also arranged for some new tube
lights and additional fans, ” he added.
“We have a very fine ladies dressing
room and until recently I personally used
to supervise the cleanliness, ” Vakil said.
If there is a sore point it is mainly
|6
designer
&
SirP-W-
PHONE'- 2^
Steamship agents — master stevedores
dubashes — lighterage contractors
Darabshaw B.Cursetjee's
Sons (Bombay) Pvt. Ltd.
Darabshaw House, Ballard Road, Bombay - 400 038.
Grams: 'DEADWEIGHT
Phone: 260021 (4 Lines) (Dock Office: 262230)
Telex: 5824 DBCB IN
Also associates at
Calcutta, Vishakhapatnam, Kakinada, Mangalore,
Bhavnagar, Bedi-port, Navlakhi, Veraval, Porbunder & Kandla.
Also sole Government Landing contractors at
Jamnagar, (Bedi) Bhavnagar.
28 Parsiana January 1991!
TRADITION
The Brazen Betrothal
Disregarding the Punchayet resolution, the son of a mobed
decided to get married to a behdin girl
Dosabhai Framji Karaka 1
While everyone knows the orthodox the Parsis seldom failed to accept without dered government interference necessary.
priests' aversion to intercommunity mar- demur the decision of their governing The altercation sprang out of a regulation
riages, many may not be aware that the body. or ordinance made by the Piuichayet of
athornans many years ago similarly This state of affairs seems to have con- Bombay, with the consent of its commu-
frowned on their daughters marrying
behdins. In fact, the priests passed an ----- ........ . _
ordinance in the 1700s that they would Bombay found that it could no longer rule marriage to the mobeds. The Punchayet
not permit their female relations to the Parsi community with its old author- took this step in order to counteract the
marzy lay Parsis. ity. Under the earlier system offenders effect of an ordinance, which the priests
In his 1884 publication History of The were punished by being beaten with a had passed among themselves, to the ef-
Parsis including their Manners, Customs, shoe; but it was found almost impossible feet that they would continue to revive in
Religion and Present Position, Dosabhai to enforce this mode of punishment when marriage the daughters of behdins, but
Framji Karaka narrates the altercation the Parsis passed under British rule. The that they would not allow their own fe
male relatives to marry with
the laity. The Punchayet,
therefore, prohibited the giv
ing of daughters in marriage
to the priests, and thus sought
to deprive them of the unfair
privilege they had claimed.
The quarrel owed its im
mediate origin to a mobed
having married or betrothed
his son to the daughter of a
behdin, in defiance of the
regulation passed Uy the
Punchayet. So great was the
excitement that the govern
ment was compelled to take
notice of the event, and a
committee, composed of
Puhehayet therefore, about the year i /78, three European gentlemen, was appointed
and to report upon the best mode of bring
ing about a satisfactory settlement.
After considerable inquiry the com
missioners gave it as their opinion that the
ail intercourse between the person excom- with the sanction of the government. bandobast or ordinance, made by the
municated and his countrymen was com- About eight years after this circum- mobeds, was unfair, and fully justified the
pletely broken off. So great, therefore, stance a violent dispute arose between the behdins in refusing to give their daughters
was the penalty of excommunication that mobeds and the behdins which again ren- in marriage. They also declared that the
This state of affairs seems to have con
tinued until about the middle of the eight- nity, in the year 1777, which prohibited
eenth century when the Punchayet of the behdins from giving their daughters in
I
that took place between the
priests and laity in the last quar
ter of the 1700s. Parsiana carries
the pertinent extract.
OWK VERDICT 1$
<^XC0HMVI HICATIGK
A
WITH
^Hoes
The Punchayet was the court of M
justice, and its decisions, being H
invariably given after great de- B
liberation, and without fear or H
favor, were never disputed by
the contending parties. Anyone
refusing to obey the decision of yw
that tribunal was excommuni- f
cated from the caste, and his f
coreligionists held no further in-
tercourse with him. He was not
invited to their feasts, religious
’ ceremonies or marriage festivals.
He could not attend either funeral proces- ---------_
sions or the fire-temples; nor, if he died petitioned the governor of the time, Mr to investigate the causes of the dispute,
while in this state of disgrace, could he William Hornby, for legal authority to in- ‘
receive the rites of Parsi burial. Priests flict this punishment. The prayer was
were prohibited from performing any re- granted, and the Punchayet, for the first
ligious ceremonies in his family. In fact time we believe, exercised this power
with the sanction of the government.
About eight years after this circum-
<0
the penalty of excommunication that mobeds and the behdins which again ren-
29 Parsiana January 1991we. fRoww ,
oW OUR PAUG-HTERS
MAKRYIH&
BEHPIHS
Timh we
BLESSINGS AT THE BAUG
C.0 W W T£R- continued from page 28
added. We asked him if, from his long
association with the Agiary, he could re
count any memorable experiences. He
remembered one occasion when on a sur
prise visit to the hall he found a large
number of Hindu guests. Investigations
revealed it was the wedding anniversary
of a Parsi girl married to a Hindu. The
girl however had surreptitiously booked
the hall in her maiden name. The girl
apologised and Vakil, not desiring to cre
ate unpleasantness, let her off with a
warning.
Before departing we asked if there was
fault lay rather with the priesthood whose scope for development and further im-
. _ V _ I J J AM ? fA 1* Z* « AzI ^^XIZa
resolution passed by the former was cal- fault lay rather with the priesthood whose scope for development and fuiwer im-
culated to enrich and aggrandise their selfish designs had necessitated the adop- provement of facilities. He replied, “We
own sect, for as the behdins were ex
cluded from marrying in turn the daugh
ters of priests, their own women and
property were carried into the clerical
class without any reciprocal advantages sioners recommended that the Punchayef
being gained by the laity. On these should be formed upon a more equitable bless Baug and ended with Muncherji Sett
grounds the commissioners observed that basis, and that its authority, which Agi^, we reflected for a whiles A com-
the behdins had every right to put a stop seemed to them to have been rather as- munity of barely 50,(XX) in Bombay and
to this unequal intercourse by any means sumed than conferred, should be defined six venues for weddings, navjotes, and
in their power, and that consequently their by government, which would thus invest other celebrations in just central and south
resolution of 1777 was fully justified. ......................... ’ ’ * '
tion of such a resolution. mainly have to safeguard what our forefa-
In order to prevent the recurrence of thers have left for us. Property after prop-
these disputes, and to preserve peace and erty is being lost to the community. We
good order for the future, the commis- must remain alert and stay on guard. ”
Having started our journey with All-
1
IN APRIL ngt, A toMMirret
op three en&ushmen was
APrdIHTEp"
I
it with a formal sanction. In order to ef- Bombay. And we have not taken into ac-
fect this, they recommended that some count the Dadar Parsi Colony Gymkhana
instrument should be expressly drawn up grounds with a capacity of nearly 2,000,
which would have the effect of giving rented at Rs 5,000 to non-memters and
more weight and efficacy to the deci- free of cost to members, as per Gymkhana
sions of the Punchayet. They further ad- secretary Mahiyar Dastoor ’s statement,
vised that the Punchayet, thus constituted All however have to pay an additional
5 on a new basis, should have powers given amount to Chitrajan and Company, the
If to it for settling petty disputes and matters contractors for the mandap erection and
of religious form and ceremony. But they lighting, plus for the floral decoration of
J likewise gave it as their opinion that the their choice. The Sorab Palamkote Hall,
-* power of punishing with the shoe, which also at Dadar, rents its ground floor hall
Before these commissioners the Parsi the Punchayet had exercised by special with a seating capaticy of about 4(X) for
behdins asserted that the priests made this “ .................................................
regulation during their term of power at ommended that it should be withdrawn.
Surat, while the latter contended that it .
was the original law of their own religion, the Governor in Council concurred. It Unvala the manager there. The pavilion
and not a modem innovation. On this was decided that the Punchayet, or gen- grounds at Rustom Baug have begun to be
• point the commissioners reported that eral assembly of the Parsis, had a right to used for similar functions. Booking is
there formerly existed a mutual inter- make regulations for the common benefit routed through the R. N. Wadia trust sec
course of marriage between the two and good of the community, as is custom- retary Adi Khan or assistant secretary
classes, and the priests themselves were * ” ........................
forced to admit that there had been many
cases of intermarriage. The commission
ers further reported that the resolution of
1777, which was the immediate cause of
the dispute, was equitable in principle.
permission, was objectionable, and rec- Rs 2,000 inclusive of chairs and electri-
............................ . city, and its first floor hall with a capacity
With the general tenor of this report of 200 for Rs 1,200, according to Jimmy
ary with the races of every denomination Keki Udwadia. In the more distant sub
living under the protection of the British urbs, serving community needs are the
Government. Patel Agiary in Andheri and the agiary in
Malcolm Baug, Jogeshwari.
What will become of these properties
in 2000 AD and beyond, time alone will
and no blame whatever could with justice dency magistrate and chairman of Her Uten, knusnitni jamva cnalo ji
be attached to the Punchayet, but that the Majesty’s Bench of Justices, Bombay. (welcome to the dinner)!
Dosabhai Framji Karaka, a scholar and author,
was also chairman of the Municipal Corpora
tion and sheriff of Bombay. He was a presi-
30 Parsiana January 1991MILESTONES
I
The age of Zoroastrian brides
(as listed in this issue) in Bom
bay ranged from 19 to 37 years,
the arithmetic mean — the total
number of individual ages di
vided by the total number of
brides — being 25 years. The
conesponding figures for the
grooms were 24 and 41 years,
averaging at 29 years.
Among the 86 Zoroastrians
who- died in Bombay in Decem
ber, 20 succumbed to heart dis
ease. The next major killers
were cancer claiming 12 vic
tims, pneumonia and lung dis
ease claiming eight and old age
and general debility, seven.
While six patients fell prey to
diabetes, three succumbed to
hypertension. Septicemia, liver
and brain diseases and bronchi
tis claimed two lives each. Two
victims perished in accidents.
Isolated cases registered this
month: Parkinson ’s disease,
dementia, ulcer, uremia, arthri
tis, sereoma abdomer, kidney
failure, motor neuron disease,
malnutrition, respiratory failure,
stroke, nervous disorder, arterial
fibrillation (contraction of the
muscle fibres of the heart), di
arrhoea, tuberculosis, myos-
themia gravis and bronchiecta
sis (dilatation of the bronchial
tubes following infection).
Three baby boys (one premature
and two stillborn) were lost to
the community. The eldest and
youngest to die in December
were both males, aged 93 and 32
years respectively.
The data on births, marriages
and deaths has been compiled
from information supplied by
various newsletters and anju-
mans in India and abroad, courts
and hospitals. This information
is not always complete or con
sistent. In this breakup of
deaths, according to illnesses,
• especially of the elderly, death
is often due to a combination of
several diseases.
If readers have any births/
marriages/deaths they would
like published, some proof to
ensure the veracity of the report
would be required. We are sure
our readers would appreciate
this requirement and cooperate
with us.
following
BOMBAY
Born
A boy to Kashmira and
Jahangir Doodha on
December 1, 1990
A girl to Rukshana and Jimmy
Colabewala; December 2
A girl to Jasmine and Aspandiar
Kharas; December 2
A boy to Benaifer and Rattan
Toddywalla; December 2
A boy to Jasmine and Hafez
Katgara; December 4
A girl to Ferzin and Mehernosh
Colsawala; December 6
A boy to Dilshad and Dinshaw
Patel; December 6
A boy to Zarin and Farrokh
Bharucha; December 12
A boy to Nergis and Mehernosh
Bhagwagar; December 15
A girl to Rashna and Dicky
Contractor; December 16
A girl to Mahrook and Firoz
Jamshedji; December 19
A boy to Kermin and Dinyar
Balaporia; December 21
A girl, Khushnam, to Yasmine
and Nozer Mirza; December 21
A boy to Farida and Hoshang
Jal; December 22
A girl to Kashmira and Homi
Kotwal; December 22
A girl to Jasmine and Neville
Bharucha; December 23
A boy to Annahita and Pesi
Sidhwa; December 24
A girl to Manjula and Farhad
Patel; December 26
A boy to Hutokshi and Hoshi
Rao; December 28
Married
Shernaz Merwanji Shroff and
Kerman Homi Gagrat;
October 27
Diana Soli Daruwalla and
Homyar Burjor Goiporia;
November 22
Zubina Faredoon Aga and
Zubin Pervez Mehta;
November 23
Roshan Hoshang Zaiwala and
Rohinton Framroze Patel;
November 23
Maharukk Minoo Irani and Adil
Percy Antia; November 25
Nazneen Dara Daruwalla of
Kanpur and Mozam Khushru
Daruwalla; November 25
Thrity Maneck. Elavia and
Nozer Tehmurasp Mistry;
November 26
Gulshan Nariman Guard and
Porus Phiroze Daruwalla;
November 21
Parizad Jehanbux Pesuna and
Adil Dara Elchidana;
December 3
Parveen Homi Messman and
Rohinton Phiroze Kerawala;
December 3
Rukshana Keki Viccaji and
Mehernosh Noshir Patel;
December 4
Huffrish Pervez Dordi of Thana
and Ruzbeh Dhun Patel of
Nasik; December 4
Armin Jehangir Zaiwala of
Ahmedabad and Dinyar Pesi
Deboo; December 6
Anahita Naval Brass and Homi
Farrokh Kaka; December 6
Zarin Tehmuras Jangbarwalla
' and Farrokh Pheroze Munsiff;
December 7
Khusmede Jal Balsara and
Manecksha Adi Patel;
December 7
Kashmira Minocher Billimoria
and Khurshed Jehanbux
Gandhi; December 8
Hufriz Maneck Patel and Cyrus
Minoo Poonawalla;
December 8
Khorshed Rustomji Halhadaru
and Jimmy Hoshang Patel;
December 11
Mehernavaz Baji Maloo and
Rustom Cyrus Vesavevala;
December 11
Ayesha Dhunji Dhunjibhoy and
Mahiar Bomi Mehta;
December 12
Pervin Nariman Umrigar and
Vistasp Burjor Sopariwalla;
December 14
Kashmira Minoo Daruwalla and
Rayomand Phiroze Daroowalla;
December 16
Parizad Behram Billimoria and
Kaikhushru Maneck Kutar;
December 18
Yenisha Rashid Irani and
Furokh Tehmurasp Santoke;
December 18
Yasmine Cawas Behramji and
Hooshman Behram Irani;
December 20
Armin Rusi Randelia and
Hector Gustad Kharadi;
December 23
Bakhtawar Burjorji
Moudawalla and Adeel
Kekobad Medhora;
December 23
Rukhshana Behram Gandhi
and Zaheer Hosi Mistry;
December 23
Dilshad Minocher Irani and
Mehraban Rustam Yazdani
Buicki; December 25
Maharukh Dinshaw Master and
Viraf Shariyar Vajifdar;
December 25
Perveen Keki Pithawalla and
Mehernosh Mahervanji Elavia;
December 27
Hamshad Cawas Bharucha and
Sheri Framroz Bamboat;
December 30
Erine Behram Vatchha and
Jimmy Sovak Shroff;
December 30
Died
Tehnuna Faredoon Master
residing at Dadachanji Bldg,
Marzban Clny, A. R. Nair Rd,
400011; December 1
Rustomji Bejonji Allbless (92),
Homi Mans, Oomer Park, B. D.
Rd, 400036; December 2
Meherbai Nadirshah Daruwalla
(90), 15, Walchand Ter, Tardeo,
400034; December 2
Pestonji Menabhai Desai (94),
Bacha Manor, 600, fame
Jamshed Rd, Parsi Clny, Dadar
400014; December 2
Freny Cawasji Bengali (84),
Dubash Bldg, 627 Parsi Clny,
Dadar, 400014; December 3
Nariman Hormasji Bulsara
(89), 16, Khareghat Clny, 34,
Hughes Rd, 400007;
December 3
Kaikobad Shiavaksha
Debadavala (67), Gulistan,
802, Dr Ambedkar Rd, Parsi
Clny, Dadar, 400014;
December 3
Khorshed Dinshawji Kadodwala
(66), Kudiyana Bldg, 679,
Katrak Rd, Wadala, 400031;
December 3
Homi Jamshed Pavri (67), B/8,
Cusrow Baug, S. B. Rd,
400039; December 3
Minoo Pestonji Dastur (60), 2,
Mehta Bldg, Panthaki Baug,
Andheri, 400069; December 5
Dinyar Jal Dubash (40), 38, Sai
AsWsh, Peter Dias Rd, Bandra,
400050; December 5
Minocher Ardisher Mama (81),
693, Dinshaw Master Rd, Parsi
Clny, Dadar, 400014;
December 5
Daisy Naoroze Baria (73), 3,
Perry Cross Rd, Bandra,
400050; December 6
31 Parsiana January 1991Kaikhasru Framrme Bharucha
(72), Afl, Shapur Baug, V. P.
Rd, 400004; December 6
Peroza Pervez Engineer (60),
Fairy Maix>r, R. Sidhwa Marg,
Fort, 400001; Decembo* 6
Minocher Bomanshaw Mino-
cher-Honyi (JK), AD,
Bakhtavar, Opp Colaba Post
Office, 400005; December 6
Baby boy of Diinavaz V. Shroff
(stillborn), Jer Mans, Gazder St,
J. S. Rd, 400002; December 6
Khorshed Dinsha Dastur (65),
Kaiser-E-Hind, Ballard Est,
400038; December 7
Najamai Bapuji Gohvalla (85),
BDl, Nowroz Baug, Lalbaug,
40(X)12; December 7
Aloo Jimmy Mody (81), 16/17,
Jyoti Mhl, 13, Noshir Bharucha
Marg, 400007; December 7
Maid Sorabji Doctor (90), 216,
Shalimar, Marine Drive,
400020; December 8
Siloo Firoze Fraser (69), 35,
Gopal Mans, Guru Nanak Rd,
Bandra, 400050; December 8
Behram Gustad Irani (49), CI2,
Jer Baug, Dr Ambedkar Rd,
Byculla, 400027; December 8
Najamai Minocher Bhagat (J33),
228, Shirin Mans, J. Dadaji
Marg, Tardeo, 4(XX)07;
December 9
Pestonji Maneckji Cooper (85),
A/18, Usha Sadan, S, B. Rd,
Colaba, 400005; December 9
Framroze Dhunjisha Wadia
(76), G/19, Nowroz Baug,
Lalbaug, 400012; December 9
Khorshed Noshir Green (63),
14, Gautam Darshan, 7 Bglws,
Versova, Andhori (W), 400058;
December 10
Tehmi Ruttonshaw Madan (82),
Sun-Shine, R. Patel Rd, Off B.
Desai Rd, 400026; December 11
Nanu Ardesidr Bharoocha (67),
West View, 952, Nana Peth,
Pune, 411002; December 12
Darab Cooverji Lelinwalla
(87), A/33, Bharat Ngr, Grant
Rd, 400007; December 12
Farokh Sorabji Todiwalla (42),
B-15/104, Vaishali Ngr,
Jogeshwari (W), 400102;
December 12
Khorshed Darabsha Arjani
(84), 22, Arshiyana, Nepean
Sea Rd, 400026; December 13
Behram Ardesher Irani (71), 9,
Patel Bldg, Gamadia Clny,
Tardeo, 4(X)007; December 13
Fall Rustomjee Karaka (71),
Chotani Bldg, Proctor St, Grant
Rd, 400007; December 13
Minocher Hormusji Mistry (89),
19, New Municipd Bldg, Nana
Chowk, 400(X)7; December 13
Jer Jehangir Ruaom (70),
Arsiwalla Bldg, 61, Wodehouse
Rd, Colaba, 400005;
Decembo' 13
Perin Dorabji Bagwadia (77),
B, Empire Ter, N. Petit St,
Lamington Cross Rd, 400007;
December 14
Maneck P. Sorabjee Tavadia
(88), B/2, Mandar Hsg Soc,
Raut Lane, Juhu, 400049;
December 14
Rati Rustonyi Wadia (83), 29,
Sethna Bldg, Naoroji SeOi St,
Thakurdwar, 40(X}02;
December 14
Soli Cawasji Jeejeebhoy (88),
Flat no 11, 4-A, New Dubash
Bldg, Gamadia Cbiy, Tardeo,
400007; December 15
Freney Ratanshaw Dubash
(53), 3/4, Sir Ratan Tata Bldg,
S. V. Rd, Bandra, 400050;
December 16
Freni Temurash Manekshana
(60), Mota Parsivad, Valsad,
396001; December 16
Zarine Burjor Dhondy (65), 13,
Halima Manzel, Forjett St
Cross Lane, 400036;
December 17
Goolbtu Minoo Iraru (72),
Darshan Apts, V. K. High
School Rd, Panvel, Dist
Raigad, 410206; December 17
Belu'amji Cawasji Umrigar
(91), 71, Ferena, 25, Arther
Bunder Cross Rd, Colaba,
400005; December 17
Nilouffer Dinyar Jamshedji
(39), 4, Vakil Bglw, Jitendra
Larie, Juhu Tara Rd, 400049;
December 18
Noshir Manekhji Makwa (72),
B, Adam Mhl, Wadia St,
Tardeo, 400034; December 18
Gool Jamshed Balaporia (69),
32/C, Meherzin, Colaba,
400005; December 19
Minocher Maneckji Cooper
(76), E/15, Jer Baug, Dr
Ambedkar Rd, Byculla,
400027; December 19
Homi M. Mehenti (74), l -B/38,
Tata Mills Hsg Soc, Elphinston
Rd, 40(X)12; December 19
Homi DartdjJi Palsetia (73), 54,
Ocean Crest, 85, Warden Rd,
400026; December 19
Dhunjisha Rustomji Bhagwagar
(78), Adenwalla Bldg, Pauwalla
St, Grant Rd, 400004;
December 20
Ferdotm Behram Irani (66),
Zarin Manzil, Mather Pakady
Rd, Mazagaon, 400010;
December 20
Framroze Ardeshir Jassawalla
(80), 7/A, Sea Face Park,
Warden Rd, 400026;
December 20
Baby boy of Sunnu Sam Modi
(stillborn) Ratan Mans, Forjett
St, 400007; December 20
Shal^four KaUchshroo
Yezdagardi (32), Sailor Bldg,
373, Dr D. N. Rd, 400001;
December 20
Lulu Behram Dastoor (56), 4,
Groveiwr Hse, Peddar Rd,
40(X)26; December 21
Sorabji Bejotyi Engineer
(Amrolia) (85), Pushpavati Bldg,
Chira Bazar, 400002; December
21
Nergish Ratansha Siganporia
(60), E/13, Nowroz Baug,
Lalbaug, 400012; Decembo* 21
Perin Nadir Bulsara (78), 8/11,
Rustom Baug, Victoria Rd,
Byculla, 400027; December 22
Khusroo Jehangir Irani (35),
Nanabhai Chmbs, Gunbow St,
Fort, 400001; Decemb« 22
Minoo Jehangir Karaka (85),
Worli Sea Face Co-op Soc,
Abdul Gopor Rd, 400018;
December 22
Sorab Navalsha Cooper (71),
Ruluns AjXs, Setalv^ Lane, 30,
Nepean Sea Rd, 400006;
December 23
Eddi Nawroji Darukhanawalla
(62), C/618, Bhiwandiwalla
Ter, Girgaum Rd, 400002;
December 23
Hiraji Bapuji Medhora (73),
Setlrna Bldg, Wadia St, Tardeo,
400034; December 23
Banoobtu Jehangir Mistry (85),
28, Daruwalla Hse, Dhobitdao
Lane, 400002; December 23
Meherbai Nusserwanji
Toddywalla (90), Nusserwanji
Hse, 13/15, Dhuswadi,
Dhobitalao, 40(X)02;
December 23
Dirdfai Erachshaw Gandhi (92),
E/12, Nowroz Baug, Lalbaug,
40(X)12; December 24
Pesi Nariman Karkaria (77),
N/9, Dalal Est, Lamington Rd,
400008; December 24
Aloo Bahadur Khan (90), 2,
Kharegat Bldg, Gamadia Clny,
Tardeo, 400007; December 24
Jal Pestonjee Cooper (88), 139,
Khushnum, Dr B. Ambedkar
Rd, Dadar T. T., 400014;
December 25
Savakshaw Meherwanji
Jassawalla (92), 47, Jassawalla
Court, B. Desai Rd, 400026;
December 25
Baby boy of Mona Nevil Mistry
(2 hrs), Chikalwadi, Tardeo Rd,
40(X)07; December 26
Jehangir Darasa Desai (61), 15,
Malabari Bldg, New Khareghat
Clny, 34, Hughes Rd, 400007;
December 27
Dara Bomansha Mehta (70),
29, Kerelwadi, Thakurdwar,
400(X)2; December 27
Dolly Pestonji Panthaky (52),
25, Cranome Rd, London,
S. W. 10; December 27
Amy Meherjibhoy Dubash (65),
Room no 28, Jame Jamshed
Bldg, Parsi Clny, Dadar,
40(X)14; December 28
Parvez Kaikhushru Engineer
(51), EZ16, Ginwalla Bldg,
Captain Clny, Tardeo, 400034;
De^mber 28
Dinshisw Hormasji Tachakra
(78), 106, Valentina, N.
Gamadia Rd, 400026;
December 28
Mehroo Jehangir Madon (88),
Room no. 22, Irani
Dharamsalla, Gamdevi,
400(X)7; December 29
Dinshaw Khurshedji Panthaky
(62), 595, J. S. S. Rd, 400002;
De^mber 29
Rustom Honu Cooper (77), 51,
Sonarica, 33/A, Peddar Rd,
400026; December 30
Rusi Behramji Gilder (63),
Gilder Villa, Perry Cross Rd,
Bandra, 400050; December 30
Daizy Jamshed Treasuryvala
(72), 6, Marine Mans, Byramji
Jijibhoy Rd, Bandra, 400050;
December 30
Jamshed Rustom LJlaowalla
(63), R/32, S. B. Bharucha
Baug, Andheri (W), 400058;
December 31
Phiroshaw Edulji Mistry (93),
Lady Bomanji Bldg, 24, A. B.
Nawtd) Tank Rd, Mazagoan,
400010; Decemb« 31
POONA
Died
Homai Sarosh Mody (70), 23/2,
Bundgarden, 411001;
November 4
Banoobai Kaikhushroo Doctor
(90), 480, Rasta Peth, 411011;
November 10
Horru Kaikhushroo Todiwala
(56), Ktpadia Bldg, 873, D. M.
Rd, 411001; November 13
Shernaaz Purcy Mistry (30),
232, Khadki Bazaar, 411003;
November 21
Alloo Jamshed Karbhari (70),
832, Guruwar Peth, 411002;
November 26
SURAT
Died
Shera Bapuji Pithawala (75),
32 Parsiana January T991Gam Suwali, Taluka Choriyasi,
395003; December 9
Shirinbai Cawasji
Amalsadiwala (90), GEB
Qrs, Nawagam, 395003;
December 10
Cawasji Meherwanji Bharucha
(82), Gam Suwali, Taluka
Choriyasi, 395003;
December 10
Edulji Cawasji Fatakia (78),
Farampura, Rustompura,
395002; December 11
? ? ?
BRITISH COLUMBIA
Born
A boy, Shaquil, to Mr and Mrs
Dehnani; July 1
A boy, Reza, to Hutosky and
Darius Driver, July 16
BROSSARD, QUEBEC
Married
Golanaz Gulshah and Shahjehan
Sotoodian;
September 18
CALIFORNIA
Born
A boy, Neal Cawas, to Gulnar
and Percy Irani-, December 4
Married
Anita Malbari, daughter of
Perviz and Bejan snd Jamshid
Karanjia, son of Aimee and
Jehangir: August 26
MATRIMONIAL
TORONTO
Born
A girl, Alison, to Anna and
Jamshed Boyce, October 2
Married
Lilly Patell, daughter of Sooni
and Bahadur and Terry Lee
Creamer, son of Marion and
Lionel; September 29
Died
Darius Golwala, husband of
Marge, son of Amavaz and
Burjor and brother of Armaity
Jussavala and Zarine Patel;
October 18
TOTALS (for this issue)
Births: Boys 12, Girls 11
Marriages: Parsi 36
Intercommunal 1
Deaths: 96
Compiled by Roxana H. Kaka
Correspondence invited from
tall, well-qualified,
well-settled young men
of amiable disposition, aged
between 28 and 35 years for
our daughter, tall (5’6"),
well-educated, well-versed in
household pursuits, teaching
in school, and of a sociable
disposition
settle abroad. Please reply
with a photograph (will be
returned immediately).
Write to:
The Advertiser
Matrimonial (Jan/4-91)
Parsiana
GPO Box 892
Bombay 400001
willing to
SAVE LIFE.STAY
0*
33 Arsana JknuarxIN MEMORIAM
Naoroji Godrej
HELMSMAN EXTRAORDINARY
Arnavaz S. Mama
was the managing director of
die largest closely held company in
India. Under his stewardship Godrej and
Boyce burgeoned from a respected manu
facturer of locks, safes and steel furniture
into India ’s first and leading producer of
refrigerators; typewriters and forklifts,
computers, machines for atomic reactors
and other sci-fi products followed, with
out sacrificing its reputation for integrity,
reliability. Accounts, marketing, produc
tion, delivery, all departments were said
to be handled by Naoroji.
His ideals, imbibed from his uncle
Ardeshir, the founder of the House of
Godrej, and father Pirojsha and conveyed
to his heirs, ensure that the families of
over 10,000 Godrej workers enjoy the
fruits of their labor in terms of housing,
health, education, security — Gandhian
ideals of trusteeship of wealth for the
benefit of all.
A former trustee of the Bombay Parsi
Punchayet (BPP), Naoroji Godrej had
helped to found and stabilize the Indian
machine tools industry. The Pirojsha
Godrej Foundation, the Soonabai Godrej
Trust, the Pirojsha Godrej Garden Town
ship at Vikhroli, Godrej Baug — the new
residential colony for Zoroastrians off
Nepean Sea Road that the Godrej Foun
dation developed jointly with the BPP,
the Foundation for Research in Commu
nity Health... attested to his passionate
interest in the welfare of people — all
provided for from company profits. “I
do not know how to ask, ” he had once
confided to Housing Development and
Finance Corporation (HDFC) chairman
H. T. Parekh. “I have only given. ”
Small-built, soft-spoken, low-key,
everything about Naoroji seemed in re
verse proportion to his achievements.
Few who interacted with the self-effac
ing 73-year-old on the go, escaped the
imprint of his charismatic smile, the hon
esty of his responses, the simplicity of
dress and demeanor. A professed literal
in religious terms, Naoroji Godrej ab
jured the trappings of Zoroastrianism to
practice the ideals propounded by the
Prophet — courage, charity, kindness...
When death claimed him on August 8,
1990 {after a long illness that doctors felt
was related to the many blood transfu
sions in the aftermath of the assassina
tion attempt on him in 1979 by a dis
gruntled ex-employee owing allegiance to
34 Parsiana January 1991ing of the way Naproji succeeded, Burjor
says, “you have got to be a little aggres
sive, even a little autocratic, to get on in
life. Otherwise you fall by the wayside! ”
No matter how important the matter at
hand, Naoroji ’s decisions were very
quick, says Raje. “He thoroughly knew
each and every product that the company
made. Every machine that was bought
he ’d inspect, see it unpacked and in
stalled in his presence. Earlier he knew
each and every worker in the factory,
many by name... He knew the strength
and deficiency of his workers and... for
gave genuine mistakes. ”
During World War II, machine tools
like sheet metal working machinery were
not available. So Naoroji started to make
them at the Godrej factory in Lalbaug,
“The workers so loved him, they would
not believe any unhappy decision could
be taken by Naoroji, ” added his personal
at the condolence meetings summoned by secretary of 30 years, Chandrasen Raje.
the BPP and the then sheriff of Bombay
Nana Chudasama. Attesting to Naoroji ’s
wealth of virtues were a former vice
president of India, fellow industrialists.
the militant trade union of Dr Datta Sa
mant) the tributes poured in in a seem
ingly ceaseless fount in the press, on TV,
“Old workers believed they were
Naoroji ’s buddies because they had
helped him to set up his empire, ” noted
Bezun Dittia, president of the Parsi
educationists, scientists, financiers, BPP Zoroastrian Anjuman of Secunderabad
trustees and eminent citizens. and Hyderabad and a former chairman of
“When the British quit India, and it Allwyn — the competitor Godrej left be
fell to Indians to build a nation compa
rable to the rest of the world, Naoroji
was one of the men who helped to build them alternate accommodation, said BPP
it. Doubt if in the history of India, with
out the share capital of outsiders, any
hind.
As his men retired, he tried to find
trustee Jams heed Kanga, and even those
who resigned were helped to set up for
family has done even half of what the themselves, as noted Naoroji ’s wife,
Godrej family has done, ” commented Soonu. Social worker Ms Perviz Doti-
legal luminary Nani Palkhivala. “Plain vala recalled how Naoroji had employed
living and high thinking never had a a qualified but inexperienced engineer,
more dedicated exponent, ” continued depressed because two years of search
Palkhivala recalling the small car 1 - - - ¦ • -
Naoroji always drove: “Not for him the figure salary after one brief interview;
posh cars in which lesser mortals move. ”
Indeed, during his days as BPP trustee,
Naoroji “would walk (from his down
town office in Godrej Bhavan) to the signed. Moved by her plight, Naoroji not
Punchayet office, scan the papers and only authorized that all the provident “Because he designed and made them, he
* state his decisions on the spot ” instead ‘ ' ' ’ ’ ’ ’
of having everything sent home to him as
is the normal practice, attested BPP trus
tee Eruch Desai.
To his workers, “Naoroji bordered on
the level of the mythical and the legen-
had failed to find him a job, on a four- Naoroji at the Goti Agiary celebrations,
' . . - . . Surat (Photo: Homyar Mistry) Top. ’Ar/lOZne
Lam presented the case of the destitute with grandchildren (from left) Navroze
widow of a Godrej worker who died on Godrej, Frey an Crishna, Raika Godrej
the shop floor, his nomination papers un- and Nyrika Crishna
fund, etc be made over to her, accepting had a love and understanding for ma-
total legal responsibility, but permitted chines. He felt there was a lot of capabil-
her to continue living in the company ’s ity in the country and not enough was
quarters and schooling her children in the being done to show it off. It was his deci
Godrej school at Vikhroli. sion to start the Indian machine tools ex
Brother Burjor, managing director of hibitions (IMTEX),” says Naoroji ’s son
dary, ” noted Godrej and Boyce vice presi- Godrej Soaps, recalls that Ardeshir, Jamshyd, tracing the history of IMTEX
dent Phiroze Lam. “He was never our Pirojsha and Naval (as Naoroji was which Godrej hosted at Vikhroli seven
employer but our friend, philosopher, known to family and friends), faced great times. The first exhibition, circa 1965,
guide, father, mother... He believed in us difficulty in the early days. There was dis- had about 10 exhibitors. The last one had
and taught us to believe in ourselves. ”
difficulty in the early days. There was dis
crimination against Indian goods. Speak- 400 participants and occupied ap area of
35 Parsiana January 199155,000 square meters. “A permanent in
dustrial exhibition center (with a mini
mum of 30 to 40 acres for parking, recrea
tion and an auditorium) was one of his Godrej Foundation, in memory of his fa- search which Godrej jointly sponsored
dreams, ” says Jamshyd. When IMTEX ther, is a general purpose charity for edu- with Vasant Sheth of Great Eastern Ship-
began, there was no exhibition ground in cation, health, travel associated with edu- ping, a leprosy project aimed at finding
India. The Pragati Maidan in Delhi came cation, etc. The Soonabai Godrej Foun- ways of diagnosing it fast enough.
up in the 1970s. Every two or three years dation, named after his mother, is en- Invited to the Godrej shack in
when a new Godrej shed was ready, an dowed with the Godrej land in Vikhroli Mandwa, Antia said he walked over the
IMTEX would be held before putting it to
Godrej ’s own use. The layout, the choice
of exhibitors, “everything was completely
done by him. Our people provided the includes preprimary, primary and secon-
entire infrastructure. ” Raje recalls how dary sections, three media of instruction
Naoroji would even help to move the fur- — Marathi, Gujarati and English — and is themselves? ” Naval ’s financial support
niture! housed in three buildings. Its current was assured and Antia started out on
Naoroji had a great love for planning strength of about 4,0(X) students, with 100 what became the Mandwa project - with
things out in grand style. “The entire lay- percent results at the Secondary School one young doctor from the J. J. Hospital,
out, landscaping (of the Vikhroli town
ship) was planned by Dad. Even for de- company two crore rupees a year, says stitute of Social Sciences — which even
signing the flats he would personally sit Jamshyd. There is no screening, but only tually had repercussions on the govem-
with the architects. The many years ’ex- the first three children of each family are ment ’s health policy, he says. Groping to
perience at Vikhroli was helpful in
planning Godrej Baug, ” says Jamshyd. remembers the time when they started that would serve as a channel for trans
An abiding source of satisfaction for with seven or eight children in an old mitting knowledge at the grass roots and
Naoroji was welfare work when people grain warehouse in the early 1950s. “We enable them to maintain better health in
really did benefit, says Soonu. Also, had to go from house to house to get them their own surroundings, the project ulti-
when he wanted to start something new to send the children, ” she recalls. mately trained a woman from each of 20
and it got going. And he liked doing “Naoroji ’s concept of charity was not to 30 villages grounded in poverty. The
things to help children of schooling age. just handouts but help that would put education was imparted by trained nurses
It is said that if he had a little time to spare people on their feet. ” With that aim in the local dialect arid eventually these
while in Vikhroli, he would drop in on the Godrej was involved in two projects with
company ’s school. noted plastic surgeon Dr Noshir Antia.
Of the two Godrej trusts, the Pirojsha One is the Foundation for Medical Re-
cation, health, travel associated with edu
cation, etc. The Soonabai Godrej Foun
dation, named after his mother, is en
dowed with the Godrej land in Vikhroli
and is concerned with low cost housing, surrounding region and a new concept
informs Soonu.
Godrej ’s Udyachal School at Vikhroli
developed: “How people coped and sur
vived was shocking. ” Recognising the
rural folk ’s practical competence, Antia
wondered, “Could we teach them to help
percent results at the Secondary School
Certificate (SSC) examinations, costs the and one young graduate from the Tata In
company two crore rupees a year, says
the first three children of each family are
accommodated, he informs. Yet Soonu establish links with the rural community
remembers the time when they started
had to go from house to house to get them
to send the children, ” she recalls.
“Naoroji ’s concept of charity was not
Rotary Screw Air Compressors
Crawlairs and
Blasthole Drills
I" 'I
Process Gas Compressors
I
z-
't
Portable Compressors
?
Water Well Drills
I
j’J
WfiCTSOU'W*©
8
Air and Gas Compressors • Construction & Mining Equipment
INGERSOLL-RAND
Ingersoll-Rand (India) Ltd., Maybaker House, S.K. Ahire Marg, Bombay 400 025
IR.191.88
36 Parsiana January 1991ladies were able to give injections, vacci
nations, diagnose the diseases that needed
modem drugs and ensured that the medi
cines were administered to the patients in
their villages. The training was given
once a week under the trees and Naval
would come and sit quietly on the ground
like the rest of them, recalls Antia.
The Mandwa project, carried out under
the banner of the Foundation for Research
in Community Health, even acquired a
center designed by Jal Gobhai. Eventu
ally, however, the project had to be dis
banded because the village bigwigs re
sented the importance that the women
got. They “started squeezing Godrej,
making demands, ” informs Antia.
When these were rejected, there was vio
lence and finally a shutdown. “Naval charges or requests the community chose membership of the Federation by a major-
and I were adamant; but he was very dis
appointed. He was interested in people, overhauling the Punchayet ’s residential
in looking after them. We worked for 10 properties to obviate ad hoc repair; to ap-
years, spent nearly 20 lakh rupees, but no point a truly good administrator and give
one knew about it — that ’s the differ
ence! ” Soonu remembers how when a
doctor had mentioned that a woman
needed a cesarian operation but there
was not enough light above the table,
Naoroji had immediately interjected,
“Why didn ’t you call me? I’d have held buildings constructed by Godrej in Godrej
the light up for you! ”
Brought up in a Gandhian and nation
alistic atmosphere (uncle Ardeshir was a BPP scholarships worth Rs 5,000 could the apprehension of others that Bombay,
friend of Mahatma Gandhi), Naoroji be asked to contribute to the BPP’s build- which had more Zoroastrians than the rest
couldn ’t stand ostentation or a false sense
of importance, say Naoroji ’s
Sorab and Soonu. The children ’s and requested? “Where can you get such a
grandchildren ’s navjotes were performed place for Rs 40,(XX)?” he had queried,
at home. When the BPP sought to honor adding, “I have done this openly... what-
outstanding members of the community, ever money comes in is given back to the come this problem Godrej suggested that
Naoroji refused to accept the accolade, " “
noting that Sorab was more eligible, in
formed Kanga who also commented on project was incredible, ” says his son
Naoroji ’s “impeccable record of atten
dance ” as BPP trustee. Revealing how
much the Punchayet ’s Godrej Baug review the process. Right through his the approval of the BPP. The Federation
project owed to Naoroji ’s dedication,
Desai noted, “A few days before his death and on discharge, he desired to drive
he rang up enquiring atxjut a problem and through Godrej Baug, remembers Jam-
was happy to be informed that it had been shyd, adding “He was hurt that (his
solved. ” “A true democrat, Naoroji never cotrustees) didn ’t back him up. ” Noted
threw his weight around with the staff,
never raised quarrels, ” noted BPP chief
executive Rustom Anklesaria. Though a
man of few words, he “never minced how he had been misunderstood, deliber-
words when necessary ” and could be ately misunderstood. He was ensuring
“fearlessly frank. ”
Although Godrej ’s contribution to proach) was so obvious, so sensible.
Zoroastrian welfare was immense — over Human beings have a tendency to stand
1,000 Parsis have found employment by and see a good man reviled. Let us aspects. Every Saturday there would be
there, the vast Godrej Baug, developed say to the memory of the great man what a race. He enjoyed cruising down the
on Punchayet land, will eventually house
about 5,0C)0 families — Naoroji ’s one-
informs
38 Parsiana January 1991
and-a-half-year foray into the Punchayet self unable to function. “He joined to
was less than happy. He had wanted to help the community. When he realized
computerize accounts; to introduce an
open house policy where all seven trus
tees as well as the main administrative of
ficers would be available on certain days
of the month to face and answer whatever
“ He told me
how he had been
misunderstood,
deliberately
misunderstood ”
that he couldn ’t do much, he withdrew.
He never was interested in holding on to
a chair. ”
Naoroji ’s backing of the controversial
Athravan Educational Trust (AET) is an
example of his sturdy independence.
Unmindful of all that was said against it,
Naoroji not only accepted trusteeship of
the body but provided space for its func
tioning in Godrej Bhavan. His ability to
assess a situation for himself, undeterred
by extraneous pressures, was also evident
in his decision regarding the BPP’s mem
bership of the Federation of Parsi Zoroas
trian Anjumans of India. Prior to his join
ing the Punchayet, the BPP had resumed
to make; to institute a regular system of ity decision of four to three of its seven
member board of trustees. With the re
tirement of businessman Jamshed
Guzder, opinion on the matter was evenly
him enough rein to do the job... None of divided with Naoroji holding the fate of
it came to pass, largely perhaps because the Federation in the balance. Despite
he resigned over the issue of collecting persuasion to the contrary, Godrej de-
about Rs 40,000 in donations from those cided to attend a two-day meeting of the
whom he recommended for allotment of Federation and see for himself. As rec
flats from the 50 percent donor quota in ords the November 1990 issue of the Fed
eration Newsletter in its tribute to “The
Savior, ’ Baug. As he had told Parsiana in an Savior, ” “Just before the end of the meet
interview after the event, if rccepients of ing he spoke in his usual gentle tone about
be asked to contribute to the BPP’s build
ing fund, why shouldn ’t beneficiaries of of India put together, might be forced to
brother flats worth Rs 3.5 lakhs each, be similarly accept the viewpoint of other anjumans
whose total voting power in the
Federation ’s executive committee was
greater than that of the BPP.” To over-
BPP” for further construction.
“The amount of time he spent on that
the Federation ’s unwritten code, ensuring
the autonomy of member anjumans, be
embodied in its constitution together with
a proviso that the body would make no Jamshyd. From the time of ground break
ing he was known to go every Saturday to representation to the government without
long illness, on his way to hospitalization willingly accepted Godrej ’s terms and the
issue was settled agreeably.
Naoroji never took long holidays but
he ’d be loth to miss a weekend from
Mandwa. “Sailing was the only sport he
Palkhivala at the condolence meeting, enjoyed and it gave him a lot of satisfac-
“He considered housing as a major prob- tion, ” says Jamshyd. “Whatever he did,
lem facing the community. He told me he want^ to get the best out of it and en
joy it. Because of his enthusiasm I grew
up sailing, ” says Jamshyd who was com-
that the work would carry on. (The ap- modore of the Royal Bombay Yacht
Club. In the early days Naoroji was in
terested in yacht racing, in the technical
we lacked the courage to say earlier... ”
Soonu remarked how Naoroji found him-
a race.
coast to Goa, the Laccadives, Karachi,
says Jamshyd. Naoroji ’s yacht Tir wasMATRIMONIAL
A Chartered Accountant (CA)
25 years of age, height 5'4",
working in an international firm
in Bombay with very bright future
prospects, desires matrimonial
correspondence from a suitable,
good-looking girl of a well-to-do
Zoroastrian family.
Write giving girl's
details with recent postcard
size photograph.
The Advertiser
(Matrimonial (Jan/5-91)
Parsiana
GPO Box No 892
Bombay 400001
MATRIMONIAL
A Parsi youth of 27 years,
5'6" height, working in a reputed
company of Bombay,
drawing Rs 4,500 per month,
desires matrimonial
correspondence from
Parsi working girls who can
provide accommodation.
Write giving girl ’s
details with recent postcard
size photograph.
The Advertiser
Matrimonial (Jan/6-91)
Parsiana
GPO Box 892
Bombay 400001
built according to his own plan at the Al-
cock Ashdown yard. Tir had two prede
cessors — the Wyvern and the Sagitta. Tir
was designed and built when the Sagitta
struck a sandbank near Cochin in the
course of a cruise to Colombo. He had
planned to make the trip but had had to
change his plans at the last minute.
Sorab Godrej, the eldest of the three
brothers and chairman of the House of
Godrej, remembers Naval as an average
student. They went to St Mary ’s and then
to St Xavier ’s School because father
Pirojsha wanted his sons to intermingle
with all classes of people, not only the
elite, says Sorab. Though Versova-bom
Naoroji was the youngest and most ro
bust of the three, he had an acute skin
problem and hence was put on a vegetar
ian diet. Like his father and uncle Arde
shir, Naoroji remained a vegetarian all
his life. When he was three, his mother
Soonabai had died of pneiinomia while on
a holiday in Mussoorie where she is bur
ied, says Soonu. The Soonabai Godrej
Dance Academy Theatre at the National
Centre for the Performing Arts has been
gifted by Godrej in her memory.
Quick-tempered — a trait he later con
trolled so effectively his secretary de
Best Wishes From
RUSY & PURVIZ SHROFF
39 Parsiana January 1991scribed him as “calm like the sea ” — but everything, ” continues Smita. “I looked Naoroji couldn ’t bear to watch further:-
''have to jowalu nahiS
“In discussions, the most important
thing that came through was his concern
for others, ” says Jamshyd. “He had this
great love for doing things for others,
even to the extent of being put to personal
. Even on long drives he
would insist on driving half the time.
There were innumerable instances when
he ’d leave the nicer thing for somebody
else. Always gave the credit to some
body else even if he had done it. Those
who had worked with him for years and
years had a very close feeling. They
would literally do anything for him. But
he was very hurt if somebody whom he
trusted didn ’t come up to his expecta
tions in terms of honesty or if his trust
friendly and cooperative, Naoroji was not
allowed to go to college because their
father wanted him to start working,
says Sorab. At the age of 17, in blue
overalls on the shop floor, he learned to
handle machines, and files in the office,
learning by experience, a self-taught engi
neer who could solve any problem. Thus, help run a family-owned company ” remi
nisces son-in-law Vijay Chrishna. “To my
upon him as a true friend. He was inter
ested in all our activities, even those of
our friends. He was so full of fun, so opti
mistic... ”
“It was with some trepidation I ac
cepted his inyitation to leave my previous
job some months after our marriage to discomfort.
in later years, even when he interviewed
people, he did not pay much heed to their
degrees but to the way a man reacted,
says Soonu.
According to Burjor, Naoroji and
Pirojsha were temperamentally on the
same wavelength: “Naval was father ’s
favorite from the beginning. He was me- ¦±il
chanically minded (and) the partnership With the architects ”
with father was ideal. Father needed
such a person, otherwise he would have • was broken... ”
been very lonely. ” “The only time his fa- amazement, in the years that followed, he That such a man was the victim of an
ther is smd to have hit him was when he offered advice and support but left me assassination attempt was one of life ’s
cheated in a game of cards and father completely free to run the unit totally, ironies. “There was no security because
saw, ” Soonu recalls stories of Naoroji ’s Such a practical demonstration of trust Naval felt we had no enemies, ” says
youth. “My father was very close to his ' .......................... ~ ‘
father Pirojsha, imbibed his taste for
simple living from him, ” corroborates
Naoroji ’s daughter Smita Crishna.
“Pirojsha was very disciplined in his
personal life, very nationalistic in his out
look. ” Smita also recalls that father and followed a recent play of mine. Royal
son often had very intense and excitable Hunt of the Sun, from his sick-bed. He
discussions on the business of the day. '
Literature and poetry were Naoroji ’s civilization of Peru and the Spanish con
quest with which the play dealt. We of
ten talked about Shakespeare, Bombay
productions and his fondness for the
Parsi nataks and the annual show per
formed by Bombay ’s Parsi doctors!! ” re
“ Even for designing
the flats he would
personally sit
amazement, in the years that followed, he
me
Smita
Such a practical demonstration of trust I’ ' ‘ ¦'
and confidence naturally inspired the best Sorab. “Our father felt that if there was
from me.
“He always displayed an active inter
est in my hobbies. Amateur theatre has
been important in my life, and he used to
come sometimes to watch my plays. He
favorite reading and the J. N. Petit his fa
vorite library, temembers Soonu.
Zoroastrian to the core, Naoroji never be
lieved in the accoutrements of the reli
gion, says Soonu: “He didn ’t believe in
rituals, said, ‘It ’s all in your own heart calls Vijay,
and in your own mind... ’” Some rituals,
like the segregation of menstruating
women, was to him a way of keeping
women down, she added. Naoroji ’s daughter-in-law Pheroza.
“In our whole life father never forced Highlighting his simple ways, Pheroza
anything. He ’d state his views but never
insisted, ” informs Smita. “He encour
aged us to think and work things out for basket of strawberries? Some juice? Some
ourselves, take our own decisions. Reli
gion to him was a way of life. He was
very fair in all his actions. If we were
wrong he wouldn ’t take our side. His
actions spoke a lot... He never com
plained, right through the miserable final to do things, but if they were wrong, he ’d
months. He would say, 'Soo thayoo?
Jara haso ni (What ’s wrong? Why don ’t
you smile a little)!
Until Smita was 13 or 14 the family
holidayed together. “Our holidays were after a film Naoroji had seen, recalls
always trekking, ” she states. I
years the family gathered together at the watcher.
Godrej shack in Mandwa on weekends.
“We were brought up with openness in
A
tension in employer-employee relations,
we must leave all else and concentrate
on that. We always took a firm and
fair stand, did not believe in giving in.
Naval was courageous, clearheaded. Be
cause he was handling the negotiations,
he was attacked. There was a lot of
was keenly interested in the ancienfinca propaganda. Even the union minister
for labor said it was a political matter, not
employer-employee relations. What is
most remarkable is that it happened and it
was over. He took it in his stride and
never referred to it, ” says Sorab. “Never
said workers did this to him, ” adds Raje.
After the stabbing he was rushed directly
to the Breach Candy Hospital where
Doctors Farokh Udwadia, Fardoon
on
him for nearly two months. The excellent
treatment saved his life, acknowledges
his son.
“So when . the government required
that the Breach Candy Hospital have a
good pickle? ” charity wing, they approached Dad... He
An affectionate man, he loved to have gave 20 lakh rupees to found the Pirojsha
his four grandchildren around him. He Godrej Memorial Wing ” and an annual
was perhaps “more liberal with them than contribution towards its upkeep, says
with us... a great one for enthusing them Jamshyd.
Referring to his support to the AET,
the tribute in the Zoroastrian Studies
newsletter, Ushta, noted, “When no one
believed in us, he believed in us and
above all he gave us the strength to be
lieve in ourselves. ” “He instilled confi
dence in everybody. It was his biggest as
set, ” remarked Soonu.
Naoroji is survived by his wife Soonu,
son Jamshyd and daughter Smita Crishna.
“He was not just a father-in-law, he
was a great friend of mine. What can you
say about the loss of a friend? ” asks Soonawalla, Kersi Dastur worked
Naoroji ’s
adds, “It was always difficult to find a
present for Dad, his needs were so few! A
tell them. ” Extremely fond of gardens,
animals, especially dogs, a Labrador
named Tuka was a member of the house
hold for many years. He had been named
In later Smita, though he was not a great film
She remembers going to a
Satyajit Ray film on the Bengal famine
with him. They left midway because
40 Parsiana January 1991
J
◆ ◆ ◆
From the archive
