Complete Issue
Mar 1983
I
• t
*
¦1 i'
3*
'j?
•T?-
,.*«
«<•.
<
.X.S*
a*'
Ji
<3
.sC6*®^
»i^
X''”
-,^x*
fe*
WS^
\ z
,.w»«
*c
’cA
•*b.
\
\.^
J***
X
¦Jf^
X,
4"'
.0’
fcr-
XV’
’-IVi'.?
t4«* "
*
;<
X
1^
V
»SS^V<'
w
>
I
. i
,
•s’
.*y*
u*
y*
4“
0*
^'>
AMarab 1983
Votume 6 Number 9
¦5i
\ ¦ f.
4*^
/
^15
EDITOR JatMingirfi.Pi^
L ASSOCIATE EDITOR Abraham Mathai
r ASSISTANT EDiTORSIfototehiD. Doctor,
I Gouri Wagadarlkar
T l^vpinta and Parsonaiitiea
DESIGN eOfffiULTANT Mini RoStwaia ? Punchayet rejoins Federation
17 The Nayjote of Joseph Pierson
DESIGN ASSISTANTS Krand Shitotri.
Yasmin Irani
' MARKETING DIRECTOR Veers Patel
F ADVERTISING Zarin BiHimoriA
Hanita Irani and Mehsr Parakh.
I CHIEF EXECUTIVE R.P. Thanavala
I CIRCULATION D.B. Chifwy,
i Yezdi Gandevia
MANAGEMENT Cheryl D’Penha,
>- Minoo Patel and JasmiffS'Wriifor
>7*^
...
20roastria ns Abroad
¦ A 3
34 Bharucha's Quest for Zarathustra
43 Humbly, in Zarathustra's footsteps by Hutokshi D. Doctor
49 An Inquest on the'Quest'
53 Handarz Literature by Arnawi Patel
‘^:-
a
t-
if'
;
61 The Vigilantes by Hutokshi D. Doctor
64 Farewell to fire f^hting by Carol D'Souza
69 OpluTO boom from Bombay by M.D David
74 Double Woven by Hutokshi D. Doctor
r
7d Tha PaiHii Punchayot Case - XVII
84 In Memoriam
Cover: Pahlavi calligraphy
Parsiana is published by JShangir R Pafol at c/o !15^'LS?^5Si '‘~
ground floor, 39 A.K. Nayak M wg, Fort. Bombay 400 001, fxlnt^
Industrie, 324 A to Z Industrial Estate, G. Kadam Marg, Bombay
phototypeset at Decora Printers, Bombay 400 009. AH rl^tsrewnr^^Add^as^
editorial and business corresptmdence to Parsiana, G.P.O. Box 892, Bombay 400
001. Phone: 268730;
Annual Inland subscription: Rs 30for oneyMtJIZ
issuer )' Foreign subscription rates: Seamait Rs 60 for one ySar. Rs 110 for two years:
Airmail Rs 120 for one year. Rs 215 for two years.
For US. personal cheques addS2 to cover bank charges. For Indian upoount ^heym
add Rs 3 for bank chafges. Cheques and tfcafts are to be drawn in favour of Parsiana.
Single copy price Rs 5 and Re 1. AH rates subject to change in postal rates.
Airmail Rs 120 for phe year. Rs 215 for two years.
^4
f
i
R
'^vV
t
k
*' i’
y»
1.^
>«( .
-
’.5'“
‘i.:
w
I’
In Memoriam
Mr. Fall Meherji Variava,
biractor
BLAZE ADVERTISING PVT. LTD.
AND ASSCXJIATE CO»O»ANIES.p
.5
-’1
»^)i^'|li»I...Hi
A’-’^
si'
[-
I;
r
i
L
S
-V r???
^>‘
,.'r'-
¦iX', S,
¦F* '''’Ate-'
pfo^erhy.^assi^j^^ f-'" ' -.jm an envirois^ji^
culture and lOe-Of ;L
tiofft in thek ^wn faUh'a'^.^rimge th^ Js
•T
whelmed 1"^
S arficfe **0:^ j^atest^ the easily lose, their moorings?
as'lich issues eoncewj;-
L no two opfnioris/on the ds a's they are \Vntry<;^ reflected by their Anjumans. menstrual period has beep a, strict reli- ,?
Bombay Pafsl Pun». gious observance amongst the Parsis. *
I "chayevwiff .continue to enjoy a domi- fn the Vendidad Chapter XVj, it is -
I nant position'.. sBid, “The observaiwe,.fltf.^cluSioH7dur- '
I .K “Threat to Religion ” bogey has ing menres in a separate p^e has been
I rai^d^ten enough m the past to in vogue from time imrnemorial (the . -
I''' thirart all change, a^ should be treated or prehUtj»r£^t>ge}. Such -
I with the contempt it deserves. ' a 'pl^e shddld be an unfrequented part
And, nnally, doesn ’t mere name- "of the house. ”
calling, coupled with a refusal to even sit The Arabs of old observed a similar
, together and debate the difficult issues custom. Their wome n ,;d wing menses
facing the community, reflect a paucity have to stay in a «e^ate hut or tent
of truth? . v , ¦¦•¦¦'-;. ;f *
E. p. BHARucHA Mohammeduns have been observing
**« Jr "'5
f
Kan^r;
J
«-
"¦
Readers' views are Welcome on any
subject 0 interest to the community
and should be ^nt to the Editor,
Box 892. Bombay 400001. Letters are
. ......... - -.J
and clarity.
;v Readers' Forurn, Farsiana. .Q.P.O.
Box 892. Bombay 400001. Letters are
Subject tb ecttdny'^^H' teasons of space
Ewn at present certain classes . of '
. . _. ................. ,____ J ¦ ¦¦
Ba<«ia1 Uoa-olzUS this custom in one form or another. -
.z^****\^“5^***^’^ The menstrual discharge invites bac-
Ihe number of young Parsis both boys teriUl invasion of the body, as well as
Head fnr An&fraUa outside the com- susceptibihty to the mischievous influ-
Whii<=> I K/irwit »tia« .4 a .1 muutty is dlarmingty-latgc. Taking a ei^ofevil spirits ajid magicians leading
xoun. of several re«Bt tor- lb l«s of self-et^lSSted ?
1^07 /4 thm-perhaps '50 percent menul or psych?^aX
KuruXaimmS&aStl t”"*? married outside . h.is- such unclean stares of the body
ans ’ J?® community. The trend is siimfof for i^t tbe ZoroastrUtt and pther grea^
ans to. Austfalia (Readers Parsis residing ip. JBombi^'or other relijaoig® warn its foHowerii i '
Forum, Fursiiimn, Jawhkr|^,.W3) towns'm. India or ahri^? - th.
1?®? ?W;««y country At this rate we arc surely heading-fpr;
in the world which, ts not infested with what one Cstn call 'racial
one or the other srigma of vices. t' * '“¦ . *-
.^i;=S*SS?S£S
sphere. The Indian gpvcrnp^nt.^^^ WhCh our forefathers left their homes mental, physical or
‘.p taxatiottand o|her benefits and in Iran they sacrificed all they possessed ' Thefirst scientifre aimroach towards
S: SiS -S’.xHbetoS"X«.s
^to avoid by-
At this mtfr we arc tX
• i , '. "'¦ T’^'—dt l&ss effl^btive'J^^d..eyil-
p‘^ wal RpMtively haSlen.;^<^tintffidh (o^ldw Spirifs of the tfea^f -
w
*]»
inp them dpa to the economic decline of the' expfamed that she h^ always observed
3 Parsi^na March 1983 " "' ........ ;
1^;} '¦
I
¦tiI
fi
JEENA
&
COMPANY
ESTD. 1900
IATA AIR CARGO
Clearing, Forwarding
Warehousing and
Insurance Agents
/
10. Veer Nariman Road
Fort, Bombay- 1.
Cable : 'JUSTITIA'
Telex : 2313
Phone : 312032
BRANCHES:
E. Merc House
19/B, Shakespeare Sarani
(Formerly Theatre Road)
CALCUTTA-16.
Phone : 444711
that flowers handled by her during her
menses withered very soon. This led him
to investigate this influence of the men
strual state, and he found some sort of
toxin in the red blood cells of the maid,
but not in the plasma. He asked her to
wear gloves and touch the flowers, and it
was found that the gloves had protected
the flowers from her menstrual influ
ence, which consequently maintained
their freshness. He thus came to ’the con
clusion that some toxin is normally
excreted by the skin duripg the menses
by the sweat or sebaceous glands which
has a toxic influence on living things
when touched.
This led to a more critical investiga
tion at the John Hopkin ’s University
Laboratory by Messrs. Macht and
Lobin (the latter a well-known woman
investigator), who in order to avoid the
criticism levelled against Schick for in
vestigating the effect of a menstruating
woman on cut flowers i.e., dying or dead
tissue, investigated it on living, intact
seedlings and plants. They found a toxin
in the various body fluids of a men
struating woman which they named
‘menotoxin. ’ They came to the following
conclusion — (i) Menotoxin occurs in
large quantities premenstrually or just
before and during the first few days of
menstruation, (ii) Its presence is shown
by its inhibitory effect on the growth of
roots and stems of living seedlings and
yeast; by its blighting effect on cut flow
ers; by its distorting effect on the geo
tropic (direction of growth) properties
of the seedlings.
“The results were so constant that the
authors could, without much difficulty,
diagnose or differentiate between men
strual and normal saliva or any other
body fluid when unknown specimens
were submitted to them. ”
N.H. DADRAWAl.A
APPOINTED
VALUERS
OF JEWELLERY
TO THE
GOVERNMENT OF
INDIA
GAZDAR
PVT. LTD.
Taj Mahal Hotel,
Bombay.
f
' I
'Jeena House'
50, Hanuman Road
Connaught Circus
NEW DELHI
Phone: 310821
C.14, Devtha Plaza, 1st floor
Residency Road
Bangalore-25
Phone : 564474
No. 26-26-24, 2nd floor
VIZ AG AP ATN AM -35
Phone : 62018
Rashid.D. Bamanbefaram
Professioiial Photographer
for Photos of
Weddings, Navjotes
and Birthday parties.
Contact:
Flat No. 3, First Floor,
No. 6, Wadia Block,
Khareghat Colony,
30A Hughes Road,
Bombay 400007.
Phone: 8226074
Tel: 243666
Telegrams:
“MANUSCRIPT”
?
5 Parsiana March 1983Events and
I
I’
Personalities
' -si
¦¦ ¦ 'i''' •
1
^4
&
Borivli A giary Plan
As the Parsi population of Bombay
shifts from the congested, expensive
core of the city to the relative calm of the
suburbs, they feel the need for religious ing... 1 would request you to. pose-e„
on tne one ndnn jinH oAliAnc nf ziAnz\c>i4-f< i>r. nn_ ___ « _, ,
• ness ol the nature of interior designing.
. - - ? Billimoria “may well be termed as one
the Building Sinking Fund to provide of the pioneer Interior Designers in
uv- r . T “. 7--------- *V renovation or rebuilding Bombay, having started his practice in
donate lakhs of rupees in chanties every of the Adaran building, if necessary, at a 1941, when not many professionals even
year but the charity buildings of Mai- later date. - ly pioicssionaiseven
colm Bang (which consists of 20 build
ings and 65 bungalows) remain in
disrepair. Some of the roads have been ident,
are buildings which remain without any secretary, N.S. kotval? honorary treas-
been constructed. Large portions of the F. Ii^ni, B.J. Fatakia, B.J. Kalyanwa^
ment committee proposes to build up
¦
1
I
Billimoria “may well be termed as
rerio^ation or rebuilding Bombay, having started his practice in
_____ 1
knew what Interior Designing was, ”
states an LI.I.D. write-up. “He has
on an
The managing committee of the Asso- ____ __ _ ____ _____ _
®harucha, pres- designed numerous apartments, offices
A tc B.D. Thanawalla, honorary and banks, ” and “for many years he
resurfaced after over 15 years but there secretary, M.D. Siodia, joint honorary " ’ "
p ...Ixl A . -w V MV...
approach road years after they have urer, H.E. Biiiimon'a,"¥.M “‘'Gotii their^headqulrterT. ”
boundary walls continue to be broken
down and trespass continues
the west and south-west open plots of January 14. In the foreground
land are used as a public toilet by the Memorial Trust Fund, the
trespassers. Several large open plots of
land serve mainly as refuse bins instead
of providing much needed land in the I
service of the community. I
“Cultural programmes organised by I
the Association during the year, were I
limited to celebration of the Salgreh of I
the Adaran. Over the years, the Associa- I
tion held many cultural programmes in |
Malcolm Hall owned by N.M. Wadia
Charities. The Hall was made available
to us on payment of their regular rent.
Of late however, the use of the Hall has
been denied to the Association. The
of the Hall was first denied for
gramme of ‘Dumb Charades ’. Next
sought to organise a ‘Quiz Contest ’. I
Some correspondence followed in I
which various queries like the nature of I
the programme, age groups ot the S
members of our Library, were raised by "
the Charities and answered by us. We ¦
were orally told that we could use the I
Hall only a coupld of days before the |
scheduled date. Rather reluctantly, we S
had to cancel the programme as it was I
8 Parsiana March 1983
was
a Design Consultant of Air-India and
the Union Bank and designed many of
A student of the London School of
renowned Hollywood personality Persis Khambatta inaugurated
. „ _____ 1
is Mithoo Jesia of the Mancherji Edaiji Joshi
organisers of the fair. (Photograph courtesy The Daily.)
i
use
a pro-
we
’ hl
r I V
I -'x
Ml r*'
st
iy L
» •
I 4
I.
K
I
I .t
r
(
Interior Decoration, Billimoria was a .
member of the.Design and Industries
Association of London for several
years, notes the report and is a founder
member of the institute and one of its
earliest presidents.
Mody established his firm, Mody and
Colgan, in 1953, along "with his wife
Vina Colgan, also an architect, accord
ing to the report. He obtained his Mas
ter ’s degree in architecture from the
University of California, Berkeley, and,
according to his bio-data, was a former
vice-president of the Indian Institute of
Architects and a former member of the
Board of Governors, School of Plan
ning and Architecture, Delhi.
“He (was) a Member of Parliament,
author of several books, journalist and Boman-Behram: Pointing out problems
president of several organisations
social as well as educational, ” notes the problems faced by, the Parsi commu- the Act, but concerned about its
write-up which adds, “His architectural nity. administration which caused considera-
projects and interior works are too
numerous to relate. ”
Ghadiali: “Good running and hard work
99
¦ft]
Boman-Behram informed the Com- ble difficulties. The second problem was
mission chairman that the Parsi that there was constant interference in
community was not only a minority, but the affairs of schools run by the
ISdinOritV Panel amicroscopiccommunitywithapopula- community.
tion,of less than 92,000 in India and The delegation also pleaded for total
A delegation comprising B.K. Boman- 1,15,000 in the whole world. The exemption to be granted to the com-
Behram, Ms Perviz F. Dotivala, Adi problem common to all was housing, munity from the Adoption of Children
~ ~ Bill which is pending, or else
Pointing out the obstacles in the amendment to clause 14 of the Bill as
The delegation also pleaded for total
Mulla and Adi Chinoy recently met Boman-Behram said.
Gopal Singh, chairman of the high-
powered panel of the Minority Urban Land Ceiling Act, he clarified proposed by the Parsi Panchayat.
_ J . , It was also pointed out that the Parsi
Law of Intestate Succession, which
discriminated between a son and a
daughter, required to be reframed.
Singh has assured them that he would
look into all their grievances.
Courtesy Ttie Daily, January 6, 1983.
Commission and apprised him of the ii,at the community was not opposed to
Noted Gujarati theatre
personalities Ruby
and Burjor Patel and
other members of
the popular theatrical
trouipe Burjor Patel
Productions will
reportedly perfcntn in
Nairobi, Mombasa and
Kisumu. Among the plays
they will perform are
old favourites — Gher
Ghugro Ghotalo, Oogi
Dahapanni Daadh and
JaltU Kar Koi Joi Jashe
The team includes
’'ig-
‘J
s
3
. Daisy Irani, Dadi Sarkari,
' Mukesh, Raval, Bomi,
* and Dolly Dotiwala and
Cyrus Dastur with Sam
Kerawala as the technical
man.
r
Mukesh, Raval, Bomi,
••
9 Parsiana March 1983
I:
M j
&# J
Fj,--
r
n'
1
I Outstanding Jaycee
I The first-ever lady to win the Outstand-
I ing Jaycee of India award is Ms Gool
I Ghadiali, immediate past-president of
I the Mahalaxmi Jaycees, the first lady
I chapter of the Indian Jaycees, according
¦ to a press report.
i The Mahalaxmi Jaycees is “a
I dynamic organisation of young
women...from all walks of life, ” who
believe in the importance of active and
responsible citizenship, notes a souvenir
rdeased in March 1982.
Convinced that “ladies chapters work
at par, in fact better than our regular
male chapters, ” Ms Ghadiali, according
to the club ’s bulletin, “filed for this
award instead of the usual habit of
ladies filing for the Outstanding Lady
Jaycee Award. ”
It ’s been good running and hard
work ” says Ms Ghadiali, a qualified
teacher and practising landscape gar-
ftt'
'i
t.I
dener referring to her eventful 3-year
membership of this international organ
isation, in the course of which she has
won several Jaycee awards for public
speaking and participation.
Dental A ward
Dr. Keki M. Mistry, a well-known
Bombay orthodontist was awarded a
certificate of merit and a scroll by the
Sri Lanka Dental Association at their
50th anniversary meeting held in Decem
ber last year, notes a report in the Jam-
e-Jamshed daily newspaper.
Mistry addressed the meet on the sub
ject of ‘Dental health services in deve
loping countries ’. Soonawalla: Maths shield
She was also presented a Silver Salver -
by the Delhi Parsee Anjuman.
Select Cadet
Arnaaz Behram Dumasia, a final year
student of the Lady Shri Ram College in
New Delhi, was awarded the Prime
Minister ’s Silver Baton as the best
National Cadet Corp (N.C.C.) cadet in
India recently, notes a report in the
Jam-e-Jamshed newspaper. “The high-
Scoring Success
The conception held by many that Par
sis are weak in mathematics is proved
wrong by Zahir Fardoon Soonawalla,
who won the first prize and was
adjudged the best student in mathemat
ics in Bombay at an inter-school mathe
matics quiz organised by the Nehru
Centre, Nehru Planetarium in
December 1982. •
Zahir, a student of the Cathedral and
John Connon School, whose father is
the noted Bombay surgeon Dr Fardoon
P. Soonawalla, also won the “presti
gious Shrinivasa Ramanujan Memorial
light ofthis function was an invitation to Shield, ” notes a press release. “This is
breakfast at the Prime Minister ’s resi- the first time that this newly instituted
dence and a tea reception hosted by the shield has been awarded and henceforth
President, ” notes the report. it will continue as an annually rotating
Ms Dumasia is also reported to have trophy. ”
won the Gold Medal from Delhi State as ~
the best Senior Wing Girl Cadet and Best (all-round) Student award by the
“was the first recipient of (the) Silver Rotary Club of Bombay in February
cup from the N.C.C. Director General. ” this year.
Planetarium
In addition, Zahir was awarded the
e
?
-
If you love
good food
you'll find it at
•The Gourmet ’
Restaurant
ALA CARTE
delicacies lovingly
prepared by
skilled
Chef de Cuisine
Hiron Gomes,
who has catered
to international
celebrities.
Open from
8 a m. to 11 p.m.
ANAVJOTE.ALAGAN,
ASILVER OR GOLDEN
WEDDING ANNIVERSARY,
A FIRST-BIRTHDAY RARTY-
OR ANY SUCH HIGHUGHTS
OFYOURUFE
celebrate
it at West End Hotel.
in beautiful setting
of its Terrace Garden.
Choose the day
and leave alt
the other problems to us.
AT THE
WEST END HOTEL
Holds
RECEPTION
at pur newly
renovated
and decorated
Banquet Room
OR
in the splendour
of our starlit
Terrace Garden
West End’s
Conference Plan
Rs. 55/
¦+• 15% Sales Tax
per head
Inclusive of:
Room Rent, Buffet Lunch,l
Morning and Evening Tea.
% Ask for special
concession offer
for larger conferences. J
*
11 Parsiana March 1983
«**, arr - -J*
ife
p S’;
I
Tithal
Sanatorium:
A Wasted
Asset
<9
,
r
'i.
?
1.
Is
b
PS **
,1
J-' -
1^019
t'. 1
¦W
M
-
^rj
..
'ZI
12 Parsiana March 1983
‘i:
present state of affairs.
Community members
have urged the trustees
The Tithef ^hbtorlum
in the Bulsar district of
Gujarat whose real
estate value is estimated to either maintain the
by some at around Rs.40 sanatorium or permit
Zoroastrians to develop
the property either
for housing or farming.
Photographs by noted
photographer Ashvin
Mehta.
*‘s
lakhs stands in ruins.
The four one-storeyed
structures built by
Seth Dhanjibhai
Hirjibhai Patel and his
wife reflect the
E
¥
¦ft.
* * .r It *’ *
5?
i
fes
'rf-
37
i.
.V,..^c
<
w
¦""TLft^At^ ¦ - ¦ V
Aitr '
-1.
r &» 1'“
t
.4?
f
Yr'-'^
' ‘-
-5'
V^-a
t ¦ -S'Ssl
Er*'
I
r*
'*
,, , . . V ' a
: abAi^^^BtUF to thtW margin, th«/<
¦“ 4j, ' • ox- ¦*k.
>J>
2 <-ily: a:tet*<>^ thrte margin, thp/
trusteCsOfithe Bohibay Parsi Puncteyei '-to^tesficdteat ttetFederfodu'W^aot^ ~ note of jd^tae
L v^;tb rej^n ttedFbderationrj^tarai? fna^ters Or it woufid^
k' Wate dr
< ’tea'll-cCH^iiBH)^,,--w*^ w-^wwww «
“Amceting waSbddwithrepreschta- ^ ttet ;dte Federation wiH have no sud^Mtwe..; dt^i^
tives,ofsditecdthettei® ’"Anjumansin' ftutbority to int^ere in the internal expressed on tte subje^ but ttet ift ’
r the month of fW2 and their a^irs pf the Pupchayet/ Anjuman itself should rtot picvent the Federatite^-^ ij
\/.viewsbbiamed," noteddtejMCi^t^eaw. ,, from dealteg with d, / <.- ¦
' -««TKr:r.j. ., ’’^ ' tlfe “We |ust.«^^;^l^i^1h^w^
The ih0^«mt<>vs^ »M as
Uiat
A
tV
.t'\
*>r*
^•'Ip^l^fF'etfeia^te5(b fto
.SS.S?i’-
from dealing wiiftIt, „
, ... ^________ ~ r / .
AniuoMW»^iS*^^itelf ie in consultation the Delhi Farsi Anjumin Present, Tipst could he,^iowed to fe^ace aft J
[: with some peopte who htitter in our ShiavtfxP.Nargolwala, ‘lta8commutrt-: the fWeratioa qf
I Community, the Trustees of the Bom- cated his concurrence to the abovecon- Ahjumans is a body consisting of An^-^ ..j
' - •• ............ “ mafisfromW^^^inlndm^^^^
In pui^it^. dlP^; vtew'o^ these^ *i
Z’y
tey Paim T^hayfet i£^.by a prepond- ditions, *
( ' erant majority, that itiain4he interest of Tbpse BPP members who vqtcd in o
the Parsi Community of libfia as, a favour of rejoining are: Chairman Dr
F- 1' ¦ “\ ................................................ /“'
J, Federadontl^ woo^bestroag,tepre- De^i and Jams heed Kahga. The three
work." ,. „
L The trustees, hbwevpr/nbtt^ o^ipe^") and Jal Vimadalal
i lowJig”pS’’!^*d^^*^S5 ^"^S^'Mfcd^’otftan^eofdis^iU in Fedemtiou^.ptbwdea4tey h»Wt
t tedcratioh. < Ute pr^^s^^rene^^wHfefc^ necessary amendm^^ ’inthefrMte^'
erant majority, thW ittain^te interest of Thpse BPP members who vqtcd in only in the ca« orDel|^;yt>dMPt^^sn^<
the Parsi 'C^momty of liakfia as a favour of rejoining are: Chairman Dr (wil!) be asked lo go out and (the)Trust ' /; A
, whole that a Federatioft Should exist, a AspiPtHwatta, Jamsted Guzder, Erach te aBow0^^th co^ in plaee of (the>
, Federationthat wouldbestrong,pepre- Demi and Jamsheed Kanga. The three
•' sentative andiabie to dd< consttucfive opposing members are: Dr Nelie K^le, that represents
. ManecX Hodiwalla (both “condition- that particulaMertHory -
'•^^i
s
¦ed*. ’).
Anlttman. After all it i^ the 'Atyuman
that re^re^ts the ^ews of Pata^ ’;|B(r;^^
therefore.^ that the
Anjuman should be aUow^.to remtUn
'-¦V
1
u
.*^>^.
'ibi
^3
..
a weibber
te^.|h)»ti
thaw Ttusi^ ’^'t^ «ia».
ties si
will be a. nrq
jU-
.kfca* '^j^IbcMMari^
? ties-1
**-
ft
,v
1^: j^4j^|>be«w>hoM|n to sotttedf^ trus-
¦’^1 i
¦F* ‘'' 4
* H*"
‘'^ ,/ »
11^^ / J
v«
W pretent- When Kanga asked for a s^rds.
Af^^ote. i^bJe replied she had
The
fo^^bte^
TShiph u«etB
s~'
tion in tetras of the above stated i^r
aa^^mter AM
"^lr"».*, *'V A -* X -1.^^ I
' *4 * , ' ‘ W. . - .
^^SHAbad tes^^'' from
ta 1SS8 tHHeTjtlteo
__ _ ^ aueecssful hostings^t^^
Zofoastrian
,
B ¦
¦“S^
1 ^^^ilKrA-,-.
of^ x, •; 1., *“ * ‘ ^1
-5^
‘¦^
*p
t5 •*
.-St
*
j4=>
' *“ ^k?
>r'
A-
’e
.> ’
•i ,
. -^1
n
'A.“ *
fv--.
The Navjote of
Joseph Peterson
ropolitan Chicago in reply stated: “Your
letter with the accompanying write-ups
was put before the ZAC Board at our
last Board Meeting on October 17,1982.
After a lot of discussion on this matter,
we arrived at the following stand:
(a) The number... of a dying race should
not be the only criterion upon which the
ony... No objections were made in the issue of Conversion should be decided.
¦ . (b) Our efforts should be directed
According to reports, Frvad Noshir- towards quality rather than quantity for
wan Hormazdiyar is to perform Peter- there is no point in having additional
son ’s navjote which reportedly has the so-called paper Zoroastrians when the
¦*
“As you may or may not be aware...
Mr. Joseph Peterson of Minnesota has meeting ’.”,
requested to be initiated in the Zoroas
trian fold, ” announced a Special News
Bulletin of the Zoroastrian Association
of Greater New York signed by ZAGNY backing of many of the ^oroastrians educational inputs of the religion are so
President Faroke G. Gandhi.
“Joseph is an exceptional individual
and has acquired a great deal of Zo
roastrian knowledge and is following when Dr (Ervad)Jehan Bagli, Editor of indicate that an expansion programme
the precepts of Zoroastrianism since Gavashni, the quarterly publication of should only be undertaken if one ’s
over the Iasi ten years, including wearing the Zoroastrian Association of Quebec house is in order. ”
the Sudreh and Kusti which he himself (ZAQ), wrote about him in the Sep- The Chicago association also asked
prepared. ”
With Peterson ’s navjote tentatively Parsiana December 1981£‘Zoroastrian-
scheduled for March this year, the issue
of conversion has come to the fore in the
New World as noted the ZAGNY new- North American Zoroastrian Congress
sletter.
“The Navjote ceremony would be a
precedent setting event and has pro
duced great doubts and agony in certain cepts — Do they have a place? ’ Adi
parts of the community. It has sparked Davar, president of the Zoroastrian
the related crisis situation on the unans
wered question of acceptance/non-
acceptance to Zoroastrianism which has
been a delicate and very pressing issue in
the Greater New York Zoroastrian com
munity. ”
As regards using the Arbab Rustom ____
Guiv Darbe Mehr in New Rochelle, ism. I passed a copy of the/tve ’jZa in a Ms Dastoor replied that ZAQ was “in
New York for the navjote ceremony. Dr library one day. 1 was half way out the the process of compiling comments and
Shari J. Merabi, chairman of the board
of trustees of the Darbe Mehr noted:
“The position of the Board of Trustees...
has now become very ckar as recorded again. 1 found it to be a difficult text, scholars contacted, stated Dastoor,
in the minutes of airecent joint meeting giving a somewhat unclbar picture of an were Dasturs Kaikhus roo JamaspAsa,
of the (Darbe Mehr trustees and the
ZAGNY Board of Directors) dated
from Iran recently settled in North weak and often unavailable to those
America. who are born in the faith.
Peterson first came into the public eye (c) Prudent business practice would
(ZAQ), wrote about him in the Sep
tember 1981 issue of the journal (see for views representing both traditional
ism: The Lost Vision ’). The subject of
conversion again arose at the Fourth
held in Montreal,Quebec on 10 and 11
^’'April last year in the session titled,
‘ Non-rZoroastrians in Zoroastrian Pre-
"Any desirous individual
who knows the basic
principles of the
Zoroastrian religion is
welcome to have any
Zoroastrian ceremony...
In the Darbe Mehr."
Association of Metropolitan Washing
ton read a paper on the subject which
was followed by a lengthy discussion.
Peterson also addressed the Congress
(see attached piece ‘Peterson ’s Perspec- and liberal points of view as they felt
tive ’) and noted, “It was over ten years only the liberal viewpoint was being
ago that 1 learned about Zoroastrian- presen^d.
ism. 1 passed a copy of the Avesta in a T' .
door before 1 realized that the title was criticisms received from various individ
stuck in my mind- Out of curiosity 1 uals and Associations which would later
went back and searched until 1 found it be presented as a report. ” Among the
again. 1 found it to be a difficult text
ancient and unique faith. The more 1 .
studied, the more I became impressed Hormazdiyar: Setting a precedent
with the inspired teachings of Zara-
thushtra. They seemed to answer my-
most difficult questions about life in a
perfectly sound and almost startling ¦.
fashion. I soon began to think of myself J
as essentially Zoroastrian. ” .
The Congress “charged (ZAQ) with
the responsibility of doing the spade
work into the question of ‘Acceptance ’
"Joseph is an exceptional
individual and has
acquired a great deal of
Zoroastrian knowledge."
» ¦'..... ......................!------------------ ----------- .-------------
i
October 1981 which reads, ‘In the opin- into the social fabric of the religion, the j
i
who knows the-basic principles of the
'Zoroastrian religion-is -¦
•J
¦-.
>¦
*^¦1
*
*
5
>
i
.Ja
,^,¦5
'-j
¦'5F
f
Firoze Kotwal, Meheiji Rana, Hor-
mazdyar Mirza and Navruz D.
Minochehr-Homji, Dr Pesho'tan Pire,
Ervad R.N. Panthaky, Ms Shirin Kutai ,
Farrokh Bamji, Dr Ali Jaffrey, Prof
Kaikhosrov Irani and Khojeste Mistree.
Dastoor mentioned that the question
pertained “essentially to acceptance of
children where only one parent is a
Zoroastrian and not to conversion
‘en masse ’.’*
Bagli, in a paper entitled ‘Zoroastrian
Challenge: A Position Clarified, ’ pub
lished in the August issue, of Gavashni
noted," although a religion per se is not
a monopoly of any group of human
beings, the right to preserve a religion is
fully within the bounds of any commu
nal group to exercise.
Prof. Kaikhosrov D. Irani, chairman
of the Philosophy Department at the
City University of New York in a paper
w
s
• Al
'4*
Witii Compliments
From
"Our efforts should be
directed towards quality
rather than quantity."
EMPIRE
}
Zoroastrians and the Zoroastrian Com
munity in North America (reproduced
in this issue of Parsiana) stated, “there
is... no rule in theology which prevents a
Navjote being performed by Zoroas
trian clergy or laity of anyone who
wishes it and manifests the competence
to undergo the same...
“What then is the issue the commun- ‘
ity faces? It is this: given a person with ?
Zoroastrian beliefs and performing
Zoroastrian ritual practice,-but of non-
Zoroastrian parents, may this person be
admitted to membership in Zoroastrian
religious associations in North Amer
ica?... This being a social (not a reli
gious) question, must be given a social
answer. I do not propose one, for after
all it must reflect the thoughtful and bal
anced judgement ol the comniunity. ’'
While the North American Zoroastri
ans will have to decide the issue of
accepting or rejecting Peterson, in
. India, where Peterson would be barred
from enjoying any of the privileges spec
ified for Parsi Zoroastrians including
worshipping in an agiary, his navjote is
bound to raise the same issue.
But while it is unlikely he will find
much support in the Parsi bastion of
Bombay and in parts of Gujarat, there
will be many who will view his navjote as
the first step towards a Zoroastrian
renaissance.
ESTATE
4
Liberty Building
41/42 Marine Lines
Bombay 400020
* *.
*/*
19 Parsiana March 1983•« s\
7"
r:
Peterson’s Perspective
The following is a text of an address “It was over ten years ago that I
presented by Mr. Joseph H. Peterson-a learned about Zoroastrianism. I passed
The following is a text of an address
practicing Zoroastrian - to the acopyoftheAve^minalibraryoiwday.
realized that the title was stuck in my
mind. Out of curiosity I went back and
searched until 1 found it again. I found it
to be a difficult text, giving a somewhat
unclear picture of an ancient and unique
my interest in this subject has faith. The more 1 studied the more I
approached obsession. The only conclu- became impressed with the inspired
sions I can offer are the ways in which teachings of Zarathushtra. They seemed
my life has been affected. 1 am very to answer my most difficult questions
honored to have been invited here and 1 about life in a perfectly sound and
hope my perspective is of some interest almost startling fashion. I soon began to
to you. think of myself as essentially Zoroas-
“My approach to Zoroastrianism has trian.
been different from most others. No- “One of the first things I learned is the
body told me about it. I had to go to great debt, largely unacknowledged,
great lengths to learn what I could. This that Christianity and many other reli -
is somewhat sad, since I have found it to gions owe to Zoroastrianism. Indeed it
be a noble and beautiful religion. 1 have seems that a large part of the supposedly
had no exposure at all to the community divine revelations of their prophets
until very recently. 1 therefore have little came from the teachings of Zarathush-
background on which to judge its cultu- tra. The most obvious examples to me
ral problems. I have always viewed were the concepts of good and evil, the
Zoroastrianism as a personal religious renovation of the universe, the future
experience. My knowledge of it admit- saviour and the resurrection of the
tedly comes from books, mostly written body.
by non-Zoroastrians. 1 therefore lack „
the strong sense of tradition and identity tion by religious scholars of these influ-
that the Zoroastrian community shares.
“I’d like to start by giving some back-
North American Zoroastrian Congress 1 was half way out the door before I
held in Montreal, April 10 and 11,1982.
“I’d like to talk today about Zoroastri
anism from a view outside the commun
ity. Although I am not a Parsi or Irani,
1-^ ________
approached obsession. The only conclu- became impressed with the inspired
“One of the first things I learned is the
There is a wide and growing recogni-
ences. More and more mention is being
made in literature about the importance
ground on myself. lam a'middle-class of studying both the history and the
American. Perhaps the only thing theology of the Zoroastrians. It is very
remotely unique about my upbringing is _
the fact that my mother was Catholic ,
and my father Protestant. Although
they were both Christian they were quite
different philosophically . They even had
two versions of the Bible. They never
openly discussed their differences. I’m
sure they each were convinced their ver
sion represented the truth. I heard con
flicting versions of the so-called truth'
from each confidentially, and was there- _
fore forced to question both. While 1
was questioning, I found I couldn ’t unfortunate therefore that there is so
accept some basic Christian doctrines, little in print on this subject, and much
For instance 1 couldn ’t accept that all of what is, is a rehashing of already
pagans were denied salvation, especially obsolete material. Of my one hundred
if they had never had the opportunity to ^nd some odd books on Zoroastrian-
judge Christianity. I concluded that a ism, only about one fourth are in print,
person ’s salvation must depend primar- Most of these are from one publisher,
ily upon his acts of goodness, and not on AMS Press, and are very expensive,
the religion in which he is brought up. I Unfortunately almost all of it is by non
began to study the details of the major Zoroastrian scholars. The rest of my
religions in trying to answer these ques- books 1 have photocopied from some-
tions. what rare originals. The most important
21 Parsiana Mardi 1983
'Zarathustra's teachings
seemed to answer my
most difficult questions
about life in a perfectly
sound and almost
startling fashion."
little in print on this subject, and much
. ¦ 4'
AMS Press, and are very expensive.
."s
LALAS
SUMMER
VACATION
PROGRAMME
KASHMIR
Delhi, Agra, Srinagar,
Pahalgam, Gulmarg
14 April, 3, 14 & 22 May 1983
Cost: Rs.2,095/- (2nd class)
SIMLA - MANALI
Kulu, Chandigarh, Bhakra Nangal
6 May 1983
Cost: Rs.2,125/- (2nd class)
DARJEELING
Calcutta
8 May 1983
Cost: Rs. 1,750/- (2nd class)
NAINITAL
Delhi, Bhimtal
2 May 1983
Cost: Rs. 1,345/- (2nd class)
MLJSSOURIE
Delhi, Dehradun
10 May 1983
Cost: Rs. 1,155/- (2nd class)
NEPAL
Patna, Kathmandu
12 May 1983
Cost: Rs.2,175/- (2nd class)
SOUTH INDIA
Madras, Mahabalipuram,
Bangalore, Mysore, Ooty, Cochin,
Trivandrum, Kanyakumari,
Pondicherry, Periyar Game
Sanctuary and Kodaikanal
7 May 1983
Cost: Rs.2,100/- (2nd class)
H.K.LALA&CO.
Bansilal Villa, Sobhani Road,
Colaba, Bombay 400 005.
Tel: 211925, 215094
Gram: EDTOURS, Bombay
Office Hours
Mon-Fri: 10 a.m. to 5.30. p.m.
Sat: 10 a.m. to 1.30 p.m.
i
“I
v;
A-5
*
"Of my one hundred and
some odd books on
Zoroastrianism, only
about one-fourth
are in print."
“My style of Zoroastrianism has con-
references had to be taken out of storage I feel obliged to mention. There is a sunrise, and before and after sunset. I
for me. One example is a copy of fairly wide recognition of the impor- try to observe each Nyaish every week
Geldner ’s Avesta ini Avestan letters. It tance of the teachings of Zoroaster and each Yasht at least once a year,
seems to me to be critically important to within the -mystical community. This Besides self discipline these observances
make more of this material accessible. I includes Theosophy, Hazdazan and have taught me a deep respect for the
. Szekely ’s group. Although their doc- natural elements and the Cosmic influ- ’
trines are not always consistent with ences which govern these. To fill the
Zoroastrianism in my opinion, they need fora prayer book, I have handwrit-
have recognized and tried to associate ten a small manuscript with parallel
themselves with the immensely strong English and Avestan prayers. I found it
religious tradition of these teachings, too difficult to use Geldner ’s text, as it
My own impression however is that they continually abbreviated passages,
have mainly adopted Zoroastrian terms necessitating constant paging back and
rather than doctrine. I tfiight add that forth. Besides, I think it ’s useful to have
while 1 don ’t subscribe to any of these the English version side by side. I know
am particularly excited therefore that groups, I have nothing against them.
J.J. Modi ’s great work TTie Religious “My style of Zoroastrianism has con-
Ceremonies and Customs of the Par- stantly changed and grown. I originally
sees, is back in print. read the prayers in English. 1 still believe
“The general public has veiy little it ’s important to know the meaning of
knowledge of Zoroastrian teachings. If the praj^rs. 1 eventually found a cord
they have heard of Zarathushtra at all it suitable for a kusti which I renewed with
is only the name via Richard Strauss, or short impromptu prayers. I learned the
maybe they have read Nietzche. It Avestan versions of the Ahuna Vairyo,
therefore seems important to me that Ashem t'ohu, Yenghe hatam and Aie
more effort be made to inform people in ryema Ishyo. These 1 have since recited of no printed version to satisfy this need,
the interest of intercultural understand- many times daily as a source of inspira- but I feel that it would be very valuable,
ing. Most people would benefit from tion. 1 later adopted the English version I have tried to pattern my pronouncia- ,
• exposure to these teachings, for they of the Kusti prayers. It was a few years tion after Jackson ’s Avesta Grammar. I
inspire goodness, industriousness, self later that I learned the Pazend and find this a very difficult text however,
discipline and cooperation. Avestan version. I now try to renew it not knowing any Sanskrit, and would
“There is one other community which four times each day: Before and after like to find an easier text as well as a
"I made my first Sudra
around eight years ago.
I wore it day and
night and it quickly
fell apart."
-»
Match your AMBITION to a CAREER
•<
To do so we offer you :
• Diploma Course in Business Management (Oral/Postal) (IMC)
• Banking: C.A.I.I.B. Course (Postal) • G.C.D. Course
• Executive Secretarial Course • Private Secretarial Course
Steno Secretarial Course • Telephone Operating
• Personal Assistants' Programme (working stenographers)
• Telephone Operating-cum-Receptionist Techniques
• Shorthand & Typewriting • Punch Operating • Telex Operating
A
1
Enquire at :
Sir J. J. College of Commerce
14, Nanabhoy Lane, Hutatma Chowk,
BOMBAY 400 001. Tel: 251185
23 Parsiana March 1983r
good dictionary. The only dictionary 1
have found is very bulky and long out of
. print. -
“1 made my first Sudra around eight
years ago. 1 wore it day and night and it
quickly fell apart. The second one lasted
much longer because I started taking it
off while 1 sleep. 1 now have my fourth
Sudra and my third Kusti. I have tried as
best I could to consecrate them by recit
ing the appropriate prayers mentioned
in Modi ’s book.
“Although 1 am hardly qualified, 1
would like to mention my feelings on
some other issues. I view many of the
important issues confronting the com
munity as cultural rather than religious.
Distinguishing between these two com-
"Perhaps the only thing
rernotely unique about my
upbringing is the fact
that my mother was
Catholic and my
father Protestant."
JTow offers
A Grand Buffet Lunch
on every Sunday
at the Swimming Pool
for Rs. 40/-only
with a free swim,
sun-bathing 8* music.
From 11 a.m. to 3 p.m.
Fariyas Hotels Private Ltd.
25 Off Arthur Buiwler Road, Colaba, Bombay 400 005
For Tabla Reservations, Contact:
Hospitality Desk, Tel. 215911
*•?
ponents is important in order to permit
natural cultural change, while preserving
the purity of the prophet ’s vision. I stress
the word ‘natural ’ because 1 think that
forced change often ends up being more
destructive than constructive. This is
one reason why 1 strongly oppose mis-
sionary activities. People resist change
partly because of the need for identity
and stability and fpissionary activities
often destroy both religious and cultural
needs. On the other hand 1 don ’t under
stand any objection to performing
> ceremonies for people Who honestly
seek them of their own volition.
“The question of doctrinal unity has
never bothered me. 1 don ’t think that
any ancient religion can honestly claim
[ doctrinal unity, lhe various texts
1 involved were produced at different
times to suit different situations. Some
t of the issues that are discussed in the
. ancient texts have little application to
! * the modern world. Thus they need to
be examined in the context in which
they were written.
“Because 1 am not a member of the
community, 1 have had to make do with
improvised and very imperfect obser
vances. 1 have tried as best as 1 could to
be faithful to the teachings of Zara
thushtra in spite of the difficulties, and 1
welcome this opportunity to learn from
you. ”
25 Parsiana March 1983
•e
w
^1
C6.B82.151
-
Gifts&
[Wittflig
The Friendly Gift Shop for
handicrafts, festive gifts and
Zoroastrian artefacts
B&mbay Swadeshi Stores Ltd
Sir P.M. Roaxi , Bombay 400 001
Tel: 253443 & 2527304
’^'5
f
Zoroastrianisiii
andthe
Zoro^trian Community
of N orth America
f
Professor Kaikhosrov D. Irani
f
"There is no rule in theology which prevents
a Navjote being performed by Zoroastrian clergy
or laity of anyone who wishes it.”
1
'J
-(
?'
The general question on which much it by marriage to become a member of tain view of the world and a related way
' discussion has taken place and on which the faith, the rest are excluded, because of life. The Zoroastrian view of the
1 have been asked to comment is the god exercises protective power only world is the following: Ahura-Mazda
whether and under what conditionsper- on his tribe. envisaged an ideal creation according to
sons born of non-Zoroastrian parents The Gathas of Zarathushtra and the a principle of perfection, Asha. Within
may become Zoroastrians and be Bundahishn (the theology of creation creation there arose two Spirits, one
members of the Zoroastrian Associa- and the final restoration) indicate that good, Spenta-mainyu the other bad,
. tions of North America. Zoroastrianism is a universal religion. Angra-mainyu.In physical creation,the
Before examining the Zoroastrian We know from historical evidence that ideals of each type of creation are
position let us consider the possible reli- it is non-proselytizing; we also know represented by the six Amesha-Spenta,
giousattitudes>ofa religion toward those that many persons of non-Zoroastrian but creation itself is contaminated by
who are non-members. A religion may parentage in ancient and medieval Iran the evil spirit. The good-mind, Vohu-
be universal, i.e. the vision it offers is accepted the faith and were accepted mana, an essential element of creation,
us to discern the ideal from the
contaminated reality. We, human
beings, are divinely created but do suffer
religion may be proselytizing or not. If it Zoroastrianism viewed as the religion of evil contamination. Upon death our
is, the members of the faith or the clergy a tribe from which others were excluded ................
seek converts; usually by persuasion, but until the practice of the Parsis in the last
sometimes by force. If it is not proselyt- few centuries-in Indta; "
izing, it does not seek converts, but it
cannot refuse to accept a believer who 30, known as the Gatha of Choice, Zara-
wishes to enter of his own accord, for thushtra calls upon us to hear him, to
thatwouldcontradictitsuniversality.lt look upon the alternatives in life with a good-mind to realize Asha, the ideal
would be like saying: this is the truth but clear mind and asks each one to choose truth. Hence to practice good thoughts,
we will not let you believe it. for himself. Each one of us is inalienably good words and good deeds, thus work-
There are religions, however, which are endowed with the privilege of choice, as ing to bring the world to perfection, is
not universal, they are tribal or sectar- each one of us bears the responsibility the moral imperative.
ian. Such a religion is the belief oT a for that fateful choice. Freedom ofcho- -- - - ~
i
f
t
I
1
true everywhere and for all time. The into the community of the faithful,
divinity is proclaimed to be universal Almost the whole of Iran was Zoroas-
and the message addressed to all. Such a. trian in Sassanian times. At no time was
In verses 2^nd 3 o#4he Gatha, Yasna
immortal souls will be judged in terms of
the goodness of our lives. In the final
end all creation will be purged of evil
and perfection established.
Related to this view is a way of life
which calls upon each of us through the
-S
t "A universal religion
cannot refuse to accept a
i believer who wishes
[ to enter of his own accord.''
If we look at the Gathas (i.e., the mes-
ice bein^ a fundamental element of sage of Zarathushtra) this is what con-
Zoroastrian theology, it renders prose- stitutes being a Zoroastrian. Now if
lytizing, as distinct from preaching, there is a person who accepts this view of
unacceptable. Equally, on the other the world and is committed to this way
hand, it cannot permit exclusion of of life, is he or is he not a Zoroastrian?
someone from accepting the faith, for
that would violate his freedom to choose.
The issue we are considering is a com
pound of two distinctly separate ones.
And if he is not born of Zoroastrian
parents, is he less good, noble and
worthy of salvation than another whose
i " pound ot two distinctly separate ones, parents are Zoroastrians? In a very sig-
' group or tribe. The god is the god of that One is theological: What is it to be a nificant sense such a person is a Zoroas-
trlbe and not of another. It admits that Zoroastrian ? The other is social or com- trian, and religiously he is neither more
other people have other gods; this is why munal: Who may become a member of or less so depending on other Zoroastri-
it is not universal. In such religions one the Zoroastrian community ? ans accepting or rejecting him from their
must be bom into the tribe or come into A Zoroastrian is committed to a ccr- community. This is because Zoroastri- (
the Zoroastrian community ?
A Zoroastrian is committed to a ccr-
t
21 Parsiana March 1983
I-r.
7^
•ijr
SI ad*
Sv,
Ifnism is p^dominarttly ar* etftieal reli
gion.
But is there not a ritualistic aspect to
being a Zoroastrian, over and above the
betief aspect we ju^ saw ? The answer is
that there is a traditional ntuai, the
;, icusti prayer, in whichthe affirmation
the faith is Fecited in addition to approp
riate moral'injunctions. Frequently itas
the faith is Fecited in addition to af>prop-
'«*fe
With
Gomplimwts
held that for a person toa Zorot^-*
trian, the Nayjote ceremony, which ini
tiates one into this ritual, must have
been perfOrrned. This is clearly an
accept^ traditional rule. There is, how-
ei^r, no rulean theology which prevents
a ?rS
-
sX
-"‘I
-•^4about associations
of Zoroastriahs, a,
nbn-Zoroastrtans?; siflp&c ^m
«f there
r
r
f
I
I
!r
¦
purely religimtsi^' Resignation, tVhere husbands nor their chtlRrencouM enter
the association and the faith. Under
these ebnditions the community will
being a Parsi has neither religious nor
Thus 5ve have this option with respect dwi ndle and ultimately di sappea r.
legal significance.
to the social practice of out religious Second, it is quite possible that some
organizations: Shall wd accept as associations or communities will accept
members those who by conviction and Zoroastrians of nOn-Zproastrian paren-
practice are Zoroastrians, but whose par
entage is not ? This being a social (not a
associations or communities will accept
tage while others wiH noL We shall then
encounter the tragic prospect of a small
practice are Zoroastriahs, but whose par-
< J ' Z , . . .....
religious) question, miust be given a religious community dedicated to the
social answer, i do not propose'one, for same ethical teaching but divided on
after all it must reflect the thou^tful matters of ethnic and racial import
and balanced judgment of the comniuh- irrelevant to the teachings of the
ity. ^7 -
There is however one area where the
response ought to be in the affirmative,
r _____ ' , .... .. ,.. .
should, if they so wish and if ttey have reason of family connedtion or other-
the conviction, be made full-fledged wise wish to become members of
members of the Zoroastrihh association - Zoroastrian associations. Let the choice
regardless of parentage. The high regard be made in accordance with the admoni-
Prophet,^ Third, we adopt a policy of
acceptance into the assdeiations those
whose convictions and practices have
Members of the families ofZoroastrians made them Zoroastrians and who by
for the integrity and even sanctity of the tion of the Prophet: with our hearts
family in the Zoroastrian tradition filled with the spirit of benevolence
makes this conclusion perfectly plausi- {Spenta-Armaiti} with our thinking
ble as well as morally imperative. illumined by the good mind (PoAm-
As we look into the future three possi- mana)9iXxA our visions fixed upon truth
bilities seem to face us. First, we con- and righteousness (Aj/io).
tinue to apply the rules of the Parsi
Zoroastrians of India, in which case the
young women of the community will
leave the community upon marrying
Reprinted from the December 1982 issue of Cavaxhni
About the author: K.D. Irani is a professor of pbilosphy
and chairman of the department of philosophy. City Uni
versity of New York.
Up on Adil Govadia,
the World, ’ (Parsiana,
) it was inadvertently
Govadia is planning a
a motorcycle. The tour
Laleigh lO-gear bicycle. .¦
‘ V.
¦ t
Best Compliments
From
The
White Cloud
Paper Mills
412, Gultekdi Road
Poona — 41 r 037
Pioneer
ManufaetuTers of
Quality
Filter Papers,
Filter Pads and
Filter Pulp
in India
Imitated by many -
Equalled by none
.’rt
1
fi'
B, JarhsbiBtijt Jivanji
Estdi 1901
Qoldarnith & Manu^turing
Appointed Valuers of Jewellery
to the GoverfthieM of India
T- '
Opp. Mumbadevi, Zaveri Bazar,
Bombay 400 002.
Telephone: 327464
Between 11a W. and 7 p.m.
StMement oF'OwnersMp uid other fMrticulars
about Paraiaihi.
Form IV (Rule 8)
Place of Pidrlication: Bofnbay
PcriodtcRy of Publicatton; Monthly
Printer, Publisher, Editor and Proprietor:
Jehiingir’R. Patel
Nationality: Indian
Address: 28S J. Dadaji Marg. Bombay 400 007
1, Jehangir R. Patel, hereby deciare that the
particulars given above are true to the best
of my knowledge and belief.
Sd. (Jehangir R. Patel)
I March 1983,
Phone: 441078
Gram: Whitecloud
31 Parsiana March 1983 .
-•i'- i-¦A’
ZOROASTRIANS ABROAD
1
Zoroastrian Traditions
A day-long conference on the ‘Aspects belief. ”
of Zoroastrian Tradition ’ in which the
theological, ethical and historical view reviewing the ‘Zoroastrian tradition in
trian tradition and viewed them in the your next visit to India you may want to
context of historical and contemporary visit Atashbehrams. Take your children
along. Such experiences will last them a
Ervad Noshirwan Hormazdiyar, lifetime. ”
“ ¦ I The ZANC office bearers for 1982-
of the message of Zarathushtra was dis- the contemporary world, ’surveyed the 1984 are: Dhun Engineer, president,
cussed, was held by the Zoroastrian “priestly tradition through the centuries
Association of Greater New York
(ZAGNY) on October 23 last year.
In the first half, Charles Evans,
Professor of Philosophy at the City Col-
, lege of New .York probing into the
‘Influence of the Zoroastrian tradition
on Western ideas, ’discussed the “theologj- Among the latest Zoroastrian Associa-
cal ideas such as the conflict between tions abroad to publish a directory of its
good and evil, the final judgement, life members is the Zarthoshti Anjuman of
after death, and the Zoroastrian influen- Northern California.
ces on the Judeo-Christian tradition “For quite some time there has been
from the time of Cyrus entering Babylon constant demand from the Zoroastrian
to the late Sassanian period, ” writes public that we should have a directory of
Kaikhosrov D. Irani, who was a speaker all Zoroastrians in (the) San Francisco
as well. Bay area, ” writes ZANC secretary
Irani, also a professor of philosophy Jimmy A. Makujina in the directory ’s
at the City College, speaking of the preface.
‘Comparative perspective on the
in Iran and India and traced the present
attitudes to historical incidents in the
life of the community. ”
California Listing
on the Judeo-Christian tradition
Darius Captain, vice-president, Rusi
."1
A’
: The attractively produced 44-page
Zoroastrian ethical tradition ’ concen- directory with over 20 pages of adver
trated on the ethical message of Zara- tisements, lists the approximately 170
thushtra. He contrasted it with other families residing in Northern California,
philosophic views in the history of The directory listing starts with the Vasania, treasurer, Shtzad Contractor,
human thought. names, qualifications, address and jt. treasurer, Jimmy Makujina, secre-
In the second half. Dr FarhangMehr, phone numbers of 11 physicians in the tary, Sarosh Patel, jt. secretary, Jeroo
a former vice-chancellor of Pahlavi Uni- area. The largest entry under one name Captain, Kobad Jamshed, Arvi Kasad,
versity in Iran, discussing ‘Zoroastrian- is Patel (&)followed by Engineer (7) and Jijibhoy Patel, Ronny Sadri, Vera
ism: new approach to an old wisdom ’ Irani (6). Shroff and Rohinton Surty.
examined the “message of Zarathushtra A list of the eight Atashbehrams in The office is located at 406 Blue Ridge
and several later elements in the Zoroas- India is also given with a note —“During Drive Martinez, California 94553.
A list of the eight Atashbehrams in
Evans: Theological viewpoint Irani: Comparing philosophies Mehr: Historical perspective
33 Parsiana March 1983
•is
J
*3
'v*
¦J¦ft
¦*
»
When Cyrus Bharucha first talked Conductor Zubin Mehta. Still strug- Service series 'Crisis to Crisis con-
about making a film on Zarathustra gling to raise money, enmeshed in sisting of ten major documentary
costing around Rs 40 lakhs, many several controversies about the script films on America. He was until
were skeptical of his succeeding. But and the. portrayal of Zarathustra in recently impressario/producer for
by January 25 when Parsiana inter- the movie, Bharucha appeared deter- Francis Ford Coppola s company,
viewed him attheTata head-quarters mined and confident he would sue- Zoetrope.
of Bombay House, the 40-year-old ceed. A winner of several awards, Bha-
New York based director and pro- EducatedatKentCollegeinCan- rucha has spent the last 19 ye^s in
ducer, had for his 90-minute docu- terbury, England and at the Polytech- television. From 1972 to 1976 he
drama 'A Quest for Zarathustra' nic in London, where he received his was a producer at the British Broad-
filmed scenes in Navsari, Panchgani B.Sc. in Photography, the Bombay casting Corporation, where he had
and Bombay with the internationally born Bharucha is currently the pro- over a hundred credits to his
renowned New York Philharmonic ducer for the Public Broadcasting name.
iNcvv luiix uaocu r--' EducatedatKentCollegein Can-
ducer, had for his 90-minute docu- terbury, England and at the Polytech- television. From 1972 to 1976 he
’ . ¦ • '.II.*— ___ _ _ _ D l>* «%/*l _
J
i
Bharucha’s
Quest
for
Zarathustra
s
•f
B
W
i
S‘
¦
¦
!
]*
*
fe
/¦&
So the decision was purely mine.
It is a huge risk; 1 mean the chances
were it could be a total fiasco having two
inexperienced actors playing these very
key roles. And 1 thought well, for better
-1
J'
Parsiana: How far have you come in the
movie upto now?
Bharucha: Well, so far we have got to
the point where we filmed the sequence
with Zubin Mehta and the person whois , _
playing the priest, which is Khojeste or worse that ’s my job as a director,^to
have done it. The other thing was that 1
found that if there were any points when
things had to be checked out and elabo
rated someone like Khojeste who is a
very fine scholar would have them at his
finger tips. It is better doing that than
having to carry an advisor on the film all
try and pull it off and 1 hope to God 1
ft'
k*
i
Mistree. We decided to take Khojeste on
because ‘A’ 1 thought we could get a
good performance out of him and ‘B’
because Zubin had this idea that we
should have a Parsi playing the priest,
because from time to time we wanted to
lapse into Gujarati and improvise,
which is what we did. And I would say
we stuck 95 percent to the script and the time. But I guess what finally con-
there was probably five percent of vinced me was the audition with him —
improvisation which kind of adds he came through on the audition,
authenticity to the whole situation. r •
I was going to bring in an actor and Parsiana: Khojeste ’s points of view to
interestingly enough the recommenda- " ‘
tions for Khojeste came to me from a
variety of sources including some trus-
tecs C* •a.-w ____-__
Zubin himself. 1 wasn ’t pressurised by give his own points of view at all. The
anyone, that 1 want to make very clear
and certainly the Parsi Punchayet had
not given us a penny at that moment.
34 Parsiana March 1983
authenticity to the whole situation.
r
a
I
tf
some extent are controversial ?
Bharucha: Khojeste was made to stick
__ _______ _______ very firmly to the script. He was not
of the Bombay Parsi Punchayet and allowed to divert from it, not allowed to
script was cheeked out not only by a
committee in America, but I cross
checked and made changes in the script
wwlSfjsa
¦& 41
'I
&
r1.1
?
*
1
-
a -y
with the help of people like Prof. Wil- long meeting with Dasturji Rana and ity and 1 guess 1 get hurt when some
lard Oxtoby from Toronto. 1 checked Dasturji Kotwal and we went through people start to accuse me of not being
the script very thoroughly with Dastur very, very intricate religious points. The
Dr Firoze Kotwal, Dasturji Meherji whole.aspect of God being perfect and
Rana and several others. I had the Parsi what does it mean when you say God is
Punchayet have their scholars look at not all-powerful. It ’s a very complex anyone in the world today who has
the script and Dr Aspi Golwalla (chair- answer. In the end yes, he is powerful,
man of the BPP) who only saw the but let me.put it this way —it is beauti-
second draft, said to (co-producer) fully put actually by I think Dasturji
Meherji Madon, the script is perfect.
honest. You show me anyone in the
world today who can spend five lakh
rupees on research alone; show me
worked as closely with scholars as I have
done; show me anyone in the world
today who has even attempted a film on
Zoroastrians the way we attempted it.
1 brought (script-writer) Bill Humble done is created a perfect blueprint for What upsets me a great deal is when 1
over with the express purpose of again the world. And we are in the process of hear people claiming that 1 haven ’t done
checking thingsand here as well he had a making the perfect world. There are at
the moment a lot of forces coming into
the world which are evil, but eventually
God will win out and God wall-perfect Qu6St...’ iS 3 Symbolic
and in the end, through man, he will
make this world perfect.
In the beginning when we discussed
this and when we put in lines like — God
is not all-powerful, well, everyone
jumped up in the air and got very upset
.about it. Well, people haven ’t read the
' script. We cannot in every single inter
view start telling people that this is page
17 on the script, Zarathustra says this
and the courtier says this. You know
you have to trust us a bit and what 1 get
offended and hurt about is when certain
people write to the press and certain
reporters, I find, take three words down
out of my 30 words and then decide
what the whole thing is all about. At the
Kotwal or someone, that what God has
my home-work on this. Meherji and I
i
'r, ¦
«
i
k < i
",
t
'¦ f
Left-Bharucha: “A once-fn-a-lifetime
situation ”
Above-From left: BPP trustee Erach
Desai, Golwalla, Bharucha and Mehta press conference here with Zubin we
at Punchayet Office
Below-Directing Mistree (left) and
Mehta (right)
i
1^'
35 Parsiana March 1983
title in the sense that it
deals with our whole
culture, our history,
our people."
have knocked ourselves out on this. We
brought Bill Humble in, one of the best
screen writers in Britain today. It is cost
ing a lot of money and 1 brought Regi
nald Pope as the cameraman. Reg has
worked with John Huston on ‘Moby
Dick. ’ 1 mean he has done some of the
biggest shows that BBC has produced.
I am going to go after some of the best
actors. I don ’t know who right now, but
we have approached a few actors. Zubin
himself is going to approach some of his
said that we have this question and
answer situation between Zubin and the
priest. But that is a very, very simplified friends and hopefully they will even
way of talking about the drama. One
person at the press conference said: Oh,
1 think it is a very old fashioned way of
making a film. How boring it is just to
have a question-answer session. It is
quite dramatic. Some of the scenes
between Zubin and this priest are very
powerful.
The film is a Quest for Zarathustra,
(but) it doesn ’t mean that Zubin Mehta
and Zarathustra can shake hands. But it
does mean that it ’s a symbolic title in the
sense that it deals with our whole cul
ture, our history, our people, who we
are, where we came from and so forth.
Zarathustra is projected as a prophet; he
mH is projected as a philosopher — and
there is absolutely nothing 1 see wrong
in that. We say it in the script , (Zara-
thustra is) the world ’s first prophet and
SUSSSM thinker — the world ’s first rational man.
' pl Ji’s a tremendous compliment to
anyone. The man (lived) around the
*«**»«*Sg Bronze Age and for him to come out
. v-a with what he did was quite extraordinary.
J 1 am so proud to be a Parsi that 1
' would do nothing to harm our commun-
come in and do it for an extremely nomi
nal fee or for a holiday in India for a
couple of weeks or something like that.
But we are in the process of getting the
very best kind of picture and 1 think the
budget is going to go up. My own feeling
is that the community, and specially 1
hope the richer people in the commun
ity, will realize this is a once in a lifetime
situation. Itll probably never happen
again and we might as well make the
best film we can. The Muslims were
ready to pay close to five million dollars
for a film on Mohammed and 1 am
struggling with a film and I haven ’t even
got the 500,000 dollars I need. People
think that the Oriental Heritage Trust is
under some sort of guidance of the
House of Tatasand the House of Godrej
and we have all the money. We haven ’t
got even half of it, quite honestly right
now, and we need an awful lot of money.
Parsiana: How much have you raised so
far?
Bharucha: I honestly don ’t know, but it
is over 10 lakhs.S-
i-'
1
Parsiana: How much more have you Parsiana: How much money would you everyone... it has to be very open in it ’s
got to raise? want to raise in North America? point of view. This is why when I had
Bharucha: Well, in the budget originally Bharucha: Ideally two hundred thou- Khojeste agree to do the film, the first
I was hoping to raise round about 25 sand dollars in North America, just to agreement was that he could not put his
lakhs but I have to discuss this matter do the post production. views into the film.
with (noted jurist) Nani Palkhivala who There have been people who hive
is my chairman and then tell him how Parsiana: How much have you raised approached me' with money, to say if
much I need. But all I can say at this from that amount? you make the film our way, you can have
stage is, it could be a lot more because -----
the prices I was given when 1 first made
my budget were prices that people told
me in terms of what documentaries
want to raise in North America ?
Bharucha: Ideally two hundred thou
sand dollars in North America, just to agreement was that he could not put his
tv
J
R
J
1-
J
I
i
-
v
L
r*
from that amount?
Bharucha: Well, we raised almost forty this money, and I’ve turned them down
thousand, which we ’ve spent now on
research, so all that ’s gone. And we need
to buy film stock; film stock alone costs gone away and just done a film, and I
1,200 rupees a roll. We need 90 rolls
right now.
flat. And believe me, it would have been
very easy to have taken that money and
said no, this is my film, this is the film
Meheiji Madon and I have worked on,
very hard, it ’s a film Zubin is committed
Parsiana: Are the Zoroastrian Associa- to. If you want me to do a film, hire me
tions abroad contributing ? as a director, you know, pay me my pro-
Bharucha: Z AGN Y (Zoroastrian Asso- per fee, and Ill do the film for you. I’m a
ciation of Greater New York) in New professional. 111 do that but this is my
York is the collecting agency, and they film, and I’ll do it my way.
are trying to help us a little bit. But it ’s a
would cost or if you like, the kind of very nominal amount that we ’ve got
films Indian Films Division makes, and from them so far. The Quebec Associa-
the salary structure there 1 understand is T
very low; and unfortunately, having no Quebec) gave us three thousand dollars,
experience of ever working in India, 1 Now I understand Tahamtan Aresh ’s
took these people at their word; which association in California raised some
wasn ’t that they were lying; it was just
-that they didn't give me what the best
cost. And I found that trying to work
with people of that kind of experience — money, and they are the largest organi- Ion Mistry (of Shapoorji Pallonji) sent
it ’s not their fault, theyjust are not expe- sation in North America, ‘and they claim us cheques, Mr (Jehangir) Vajifdar the
builder, and 1 think there are going to be
a lot more people who should help. And
"I am so proud to be a
Parsi that i would do
nothing to harm
the community."
Parsiana: How do you think you would
raise the remaining money abroad then,
tion (Zoroastrian Association of if the associations are not forthcoming?
Bharucha: Well I think we are going to
have to try and convince these associa
tions that this thing has taken off. But
money one afternoon that 1 was there, we have this phenomenal backing in
But I’m afraid Chicago hasn ’t sent us Bombay now; of the Punchayet, of the
any money. Toronto hasn ’t sent us any House of Tatas, Godrej. People like Pal-
rienced enough — and what we wind up they ’ve had a lot of their own expenses
having is too many headaches. And if to deal with and it ’s hard for them to ask
we ’re going to do this film right, I think people for money, but I hope now, once they should really send their cheques to
Nani Palkhivala, c/o the Oriental Herit
age Trust, Bombay House, Homi
There are some (and I don ’t say all) Mody Street, Bombay.
the community and everyone else has to they ’ve seen that we ’ve really got the ball
realise that we ’re going to make a really rolli^ that we will get some money,
terrific film. And I would just like to
have some more money from them; and factions who haven ’t even read the
they have to try and be helpful and give script, who are already persecuting this Parsiana: What has Zubin ’s contribu-
me some. whole film. This film is being made for tion to the movie been ?
Bharucha: Financially there ’s no contri
bution from Zubin, but then he hasn ’t
asked to be paid either. We ’ve obviously
had to pick up some of his expenses.
When he made his first trip to India in
December, he paid all his own expenses.
¦ On the second trip we are paying his
expenses.
whole film. This film is being made for
On location with Mehta (extreme left'k and Mistree
t -
36 Parsiana March 1983
I
"What God has done is
created a perfect blueprint
for the world. And we
are in the process of
F” making the perfect world."
t ; Parsiana: How do you find working
I ' with him?
I : Bharucha: Oh, he was fantastic. 1
thought, he is such a big name, and he
had sort of said to me before he arrived
"aIk
J
that you know, I would Fike to have for some reason; and by dienj guess the mentary shooting todo. And then I have
some rest and some time off, and I’ve got emotions were still within hirn, but the ’’“V?
people to see, and quite honestly I told fact is that he could repeat his perfor- pie, of the^ Sasanian dynasty - Photo-
Wm*^that Zubin, really- the schedule ’s - ---------- -- "f thmes. all those have
very tight. Plus he made a
calculation on <------ - . ............
thou^t that 22nd was Friday, but 22nd the film that read blandly, and the same
was Saturday, so we then found our- goes with Khojeste. They both came
selves a day late, a day short on the through, and Zubin came through as an
shooting, and I must say, he was pheno- actor just superbly. I mean from day one
menal. He was up at five-thirty in the he was terribly natural. Khojeste, natu-
moming with everyone, he was never rally, never having been in front of a
Ute, he worked one day from six o ’clock
in the morning to almost two o ’clock at
night, all through the day, with a very
short break for lunch and dinner.
I
4
M-
graphs, all kinds of things, all those have
IS he' uimic a mis- I was very concerned that he should to be photographed. And then, well
one of the dates... he punch a lot of emotion into the lines in finally, probably around June-Jug,
- • " •'*- ------ • start sitting down and editing the iilm,
and hopefully by then well have quite a
bit of money.
ParsUna: You couldn ’t get permission
to shoot in Iran, is that correct ?
Bharucha: At the moment, no, but we ’re
going to try again. We can get stock
footage of Persepolis, but I’d love to see
it anyway. I’d just love to go and film it
the way we want to film the thing.
Parsiami: When do you expect to com
plete the movie ?
Bharucha: If I get all the funds by the
end of this year, maybe next Jamshedi
Navroz well have the premiere.
Parsiana: How would you go about dis
tributing the movie ?
Bharucha: Well, well have to find a dis
tributor in America, for worldwide dis-
ParsUna: What is left to shoot ? tribution on television. We have already
2____ I been approached by a major American dis-
which will be done tributor who saw some of the ‘rushes ’
Bombay studio. And then in New York. In India, I want to show
¦••••'¦ ’ - it in the cinema theatres, so hopefully
(nance over and over again.
I was very concerned that he should
"The great massage of
Zarathustra was, man
must first begin to think
for himself, before
he can believe."
Parsiana: Whose idea was it to rope
Zubin into the movie ?
Bharueha: Mine- Completely. I’ve
always said if ever I make a film on
Zoroastrianism, it will be with Zubin
Mehta. He ’s our one big international
star. And what was terrific was not only camera before took a httle while, but
is he a good conductor, he ’s a superb Zubin you know, does so much televi-
actor. He really is. I mean he had to do a sion that the camera being there doesn ’t
scene on the steps of the agiary, and it bother him at all.
was an absolutely emotional, natural
scene. But for whatever reason it was, it
didn ’t work, I can ’t give you the reasons Bharucha: A lot really^., a big drama
now, I just can ’t remember them, so I snoot comes up v. —.......... -- ------
made him do it again, and he was spot at a P *•“"
on again. I made him do it a third time weVe still got a little bit of some docu-
sion that the camera being there doesn ’t
JOB-ORIENTED COURSES FOR YOU
AT
F'
v
/
DAVAR’S COLLEGE
'•*
i' •
< i-
i
< i-
certificate courses
Special Ladies Course
Home Management
Government Commercial Diploma (G.C.D.) Personal Taxation
Telephone Operating Cum Receptionist
Income Tax and Sales Tax
Computer Programming
Office Administration
Personal Assistant
Personal Secretary
Travel Transportation & Tourism
Conversational Arabic (with script)
CAIIB (Bank Officers)
DIPLOMA COURSES
Business Management
Commerce (Indian Merchants’ Chamber)
f’
Successful Investors’ Course
Personality Development
C.A. Entrance
Business Accounts
Business Correspondence
Shorthand/Typewriting
Rapid Reading & Memory Development
English
Conversational En^ish
Arabic Typing
Also Arabic & French Translation
Inquire at: DAVAR’S COLLEGEfOver so Yeats’ Experience ^ 51, M. Gandhi Roa^<^ct Bombay —400 023.
Phone: 251634 _ ¦ ; ' , .... ———
1
3^ -w—
-^ 38 1983i • ¦Sv’'*-
4-’-
V>, •‘4"-^’' T’
k
I
!
we ’ll try to gel the Eros, or Regal streets...not only Parsi's, theris are poor
or something like that. people out in the streets and those peo
ple should be helped by us. I think (this
Parsiana: Do you thitik you will recover simple message of the film) will come
the money from the distribution?
Bharucha: Yes, I think so.
across. We are going to show how Zara
thustra ’s thinking came about, and the
arguments that Zarathustra had about
Parsiana: And do you have to repay the good and evil. See, that ’s what never
people who have given the money? existed before, the clear moral choice
Bharucha: No. The money that the that man had to make. What Prof.
Oriental Heritage Trust raised will go Kaikhosrov D. Irani (chairman of the
department of philosophy. City Univer-
sity of New York) has said so often, is
that our religion is a religion of ethics,
and we are taught to live our lives com
pletely by this religion, and through that
we will improve the world. And I hope
that comes through... it is the good
thoughts, good words, good deeds and
we donY emphasize it enough in any
form of life. But we do try and bring it
out in the film as much as possible.
We had to touch upon the conversion
W
“People have approached
me with money, to say
if you make the film our
way, you can have
this money.”
SELVEL
back into the Oriental Heritage Trust as
a revolving fund, with the idea of doing question which we have, or will do... but
other films, not just on Parsis... the next we certainlv don ’t come to any conclusion
one could be on Buddhism or something about it. What well do is just present
like that. The trust was founded by Nani two points of view, and that ’s it. But
Palkhivala, with the idea of making there is so much information in the film
' films about oriental culture and Indian as it is about Zarathustra, and about the
culture in particular I guess, and things basic parts of our religion that really we
that have links with India, and to make don ’t have time to get into all these con-
films on a larger, highly researched troversial issues. That ’s a whole other
level, to make really substantial pieces
of work.
film, 1 think that has to be made and
should be made at some stage.
Parsiana: What is your feeling about the
Zoroastrians in North America? What
Bharucha: Honestly, it ’s a hard question
for me to answer because I donY know. I
FOR EFFECTIVE
OUTDOOR
ADVERTISING
THROUGHOUT
INDIA
With Best Complimentsfrom:
getting the very best kind
of picture and I think
the budget is going
to go up.”
u.
Parsiana: What do you think is the main
message that you want to get across in
the movie? One particular thing you is the future for them ?
want to highlight.
Bharucha: Well, I think if there is one
single message, itis that man is responsi- think, if they can keep the fires of the
ble for himself in the end. The great religion burning and not let them dilute
message of Zarathustra was, 1 think I’ll
use the line from his Gatha. .. Man must ~ ~
first begin to think for himself, before he "VV© ar© in th© prOG©SS of
can believe. That was what Zarathustra
said. And if 1 can capsulize it, that ’s what
it ’s all about; if people in the world
today, which includes us, our genera
tions to come and everyone else, can
believe and really are convinced that
what they are doing in life is the right
thing and not harming other people, but
* at the same time leading a good and away, and really try and educate their
comfortable life, we will all benefit from kids... Without sounding pompous, 1
it. Zoroastrianism doesnY condemn hope this film will help (do that). It ’s not
wealth. It does condemn excessive going to revolutionize anything in the
wealth. It condemns excessive drinking, world, but if it does help people to make
or anything in excess, but the Zoroas- their kids and their ownselves more con-
trian philosophy is that if we can live scious of what they ’re doing, and what
well and make umpteen lakhs of rupees, our religion is all about, maybe then
we Shouldn ’t just hoard it away some- we ’ll just keep the flame burning a bit
where. There are poor Parsis out in the more.
SELVEL PUBLICITY &
CONSULTANTS PVT. LTD.
Ravindra Mansion Annexe,
194, Dinshaw Vatcha Road,
4th Floor, Bombay-400 020.
Tel Nos: 240512, 240560
41 Parsiana March 1983
-..'kA''.; 1j: . r.f I
•» J
^^4,
I ¦t
j:
<1
Humbly, in Zarathustra’s footsteps
: Si
"It is a quest not only for Zarathustra but rather
for Zoroastrianism; not only for a Parsi audience but also
for the Western world."
- ^2
film, to legend and tradition. “We ’re not time for undermining the existing reli-
_;; 1 • • ¦ ” gion, is shown praying over Vishtasp ’s,
The image'of Zarathustra as pro- paralysed horse as well as administering
William Humble ’s ‘Quest for Zarathus- 1 _
I tra ’ started last year when director actually saying — this is true. ”
I Cyrus Bharucha approached him to T— .
write the script for the 90-minute docu- jected in Humble ’s script is that of a medicine to it. His success in curing the
drama on Zarathustra and his reli- rational thinker rather than a mystic, horse, thereby converting Vishtasp to
gion. “He is a human being, a mortal man. his religion is ascribed both to the power
He ’s a wise man, a rational thinker. He ’s of his prayers as well as his experience in
; tending his father ’s cattle, according to
Humble.
a Christ-
Zarathustra ’s main teachings as they
come across in the film, according to
Humble, include the “particularly inter
esting idea (of) involvement in this
world rather than denial. This world is
to be enjoyed and not a form of
penance. ” In short, “This is it. ” So also
Humble finds the Zoroastrian concept
of good and evil interesting. “God isn't
at the moment all-powerful. Man ’s job
is to help Him conquer evil which came
separately into the world...Evil is not
there to test man. ”
“Zoroastrianism is monotheistic with
a dualistic element, ” he comments. “If
we deny there ’s any dualism in it, we
take away some of the most fascinating
things.
Referring time and again to those
R The tall and bespectacled English-
man, winner of the American television
Emmy award for the best T.V. play of
y the year for his 90-minute film entitled
‘On Giant ’s Shoulders ’ remarked,
“Writing about a religion. I’d never done
that before, ”
Humble was in Bombay this January
to put the finishing touches to his script
for ‘The Quest for Zarathustra ’ starring
the noted New York Philharmonic con
ductor Zubin Mehta.
Mehta plays himself, a man in search
of his religious and cultural roots who
moves from scepticism and ignorance
through a confrontation between the
L traditional and modern viewpoints, to
i; understanding and eventually, respect.
I “1 had the idea of starting in the pres- ,
I ent and going back to the Gathas and J
I then to Zarathustra — unravelling the
I drama, ” says Humble. “The script starts f J
k
r-
-^4>^
li
r
’•J
w
H with Zubin Mehta along with a priest
» character. ” Mehta, among other things. r ’ • • u i u-
W speaks of his navjote, of learning words not the son of God. He ’s a thinking man aspects of the religion that struck him
J the meanings of which he has never in the bronze age. A startling thing. ” most. Humble said, “Rituals seem
understood. “The priest as a guide and The Gathas depict him as sometimes des- rather irrelevant to contemporary life,
instructor takes him through history pairing, sometimes depressed — “You but I was able to realize that they have ;
from the time of Zarathustra, but also have a human being there ” rather than significance. ” In the Zoroastrian J
talks about the ideas, the religion inter- an immortal character removed from method of disposal of the dead, for exa-
woven with history. ” man, recounts Humble. His characteri- mple, there is “a very effective logic ’’ in ;
The historical part of the film has zation of Zarathustra is intended to that this method prevents the pollution ;
been represented in dramatic sequences, come across strong. of the elements. Death is the temporary
And these dramatic sequences have been In keeping with this image of Zara- triumph of evil... (but) in the end Ahura j
included in the film to “help clarify the thustra, some of the dramatic sequences Mazda will triumph and disease and
ideas of the religion, ” according to as represented in the script have been death will be overcome,* and all men
Humble. The technique adopted in writ- modified from the original. For exam- resurrected, he said.
ing the script for these sequences is to pie, in the scenes at King Vishtasp ’s Referring to Zoroastrian rituals he
attribute the events as they occur in the court, Zarathustra, imprisoned at the said, “Not enough (Parsis) know what
43 Parsiana March 1983
‘*•1
ft -
il
And these dramatic sequences have been
ideas'*'of the religion, ” according to as represented in the script have been death will be overcome, ’* and all men
ing the script for these sequences is to pie, in the scenes at King Vishtasp ’s
:3n¦K
91
?
»•
It
they're doing... 1
explain about the religion. ” In fact, the
idea for the film, according to Bharucha
and Mehta, stemmed from their ignor
ance of the religion apart from the basic
tenet of ‘Good thoughts. Good words.
Good deeds ’, and from their belief that
the message of the prophet must be
/ revived and made known to a general
audience, at the same time hoping that
u. '-Z .t-
- *‘Zi^*t* ¦¦'
"A-
BOYS’ TOWN
Public School
Nasik 2
Recognised as a PabHc Sirhool
by the Department of Education
for Indian Merit Scholars. Excel
lent
Education :
"(Zarathustra) is a wise
man, a rational thinker.
He's not the son of god.
He's a thinking man in the
bronze age."
With Best
Compliments
From:
Climate ~ All<*roimd
All Academic Subjects —^Tech
nical Subjects: Workshop. Tech
nology, Mechanical & Electrical
Maintenance, Carpentry & Farm
ing. Training in Sdf-Govemmeot
through Elected Boys ’ Office
bearers. Games —^Physical Train
ing ‘— Daily Assembly with
Congregational Praym — Week
ly intensive Zoroastrian — Geeta-
Koran classes — Excellent
Modem Kitchen and Dinfan^
Room facilities —’ Airy Dormi-
tmies. Moderate Fees. Freeships
and Concessions to Deserving
Students.
Apply to —
THE MANAGING
TRUSTEE
P. N. MEHTA EDUCATION
TRUST
Cooks Building, 324 Dr. D. N. Road,
Bombay 400 001.
the film would breathe life and aware
ness into a largely apathetic community.
Besides the rationalism of Zoroastri
anism, H umble says he finds the concept
of God as a friendly God appealing. “It
could fascinate people, ” he says.
Equally appealing is the idea of “enjoy
ing the physical world in moderation. ”
‘The Quest for Zarathustra ’ as a title.
Humble feels is somewhat misleading in
as much as “It is a quest not only for
Zarathustra but rather for Zoroastrian
ism; not only for a Parsi audience but
also for the Western world...The ideas
will strike home not only to the Parsis
but are relevant to a lot of other people
as well. ”
In catering to this diverse audience.
Humble says, “We ’re trying to juggle the
thing — a lot of the details that might
interest Parsis might not interest the
Western audience. This is one of the
problems. ” Humble also commented
that in writing the script he has used a
“heightened language ” because “writing
about a character (Zarathustra) who
lived that long ago, you can ’t write in a
casual way. ”
Not being especially knowledgeable
on the subject of Zoroastrianism when
first commissioned (by director Cyrus
Bharucha) to write the script, he spent
four “mind blowing ” days being briefed
on the religion by a committee compris
ing scholars of Zoroastrianism in
Washington. This was only the begin
ning of months spent researching Per
sian history, Zoroastrianism and
comparative religions which involved,
he says, “Maximum work ina very short
time. ” Now however, he says with a
lau^, “The danger of this project is I
could spend the rest of my life Writing
different projects for different reli gions ”
All India
Theatres
Syndicate
Private
Limited
Regal Talkies
Ahmedabad
New Super Talkies
Surat
Reuben House,
357/59, V. P. Road
Bombay 400 004.
?4 Parsiana March 1983W
. ' s
I
a"*
z
¦
H-fe-
&¦¦¦
)
S*"'
’\
I'
A
I;'-'
MZifh compliments of
LORD’S
CENTRAL
HOTEL
MATHERAN 410102.
46 Parsiana March 1983
Humble started writing in his teens,
publishing his first literary work at 18.
His film ‘On Giant ’s Shoulders ’tells the
moving story of an emotionally crippled
couple who adopt a physically crippled
child and how “they all make something
of each other ’s lives. ” A script writer
mainly for television. Humble is also the
author of a commercial play ‘Fly Away
Home ’ which is about “people growing
up or failing to grow up — trying to
achieve some sort of maturity in their
lives. ” A student of drama and the thea
tre arts from Birmingham University,
Humble lives in London with his wife
Sue and two young children.
Slightly taken aback when asked
whether he would, given a chance, con
vert to Zoroastrianism, the London
based author countered with his easy
smile, “I’ve never been an active member
of any religion. ” Adjusting to the Parsi
way of life would be difficult for a per
son like himself.
Nevertheless, he says, “1 find it very
hard to swallow that your religion which
is dying out, won ’t accept converts. ”
Humble also found it surprising that the
Parsis can say, “We ’re dying out ” with
out sounding unduly concerned. “It
seems very difficult to say a thing like
. that, ” he says.
Having been so involved with the reli
gion, Humble said, “It ’s very frustrating
that I can ’t go to a fire temple or a Tower
of Silence. ” He points out that people
keep asking, if the film is a big success
and people want to convert, what will
you do?
People keep asking, if the
film is a big success and
people want to convert,
what will you do?
Though the film does not deal at
length with the history of the Parsis in
India or their current problems, only
touching upon these, the conversion
issue has been dealt with briefly in the
film, according to Humble. At one point
Mehta asks the priest, “Has this religion
got a death wish ?” and the priest replies
that this question can only be consi
dered when we have educated both our
priests and ourselves. “We talk about
the Parsis in India, about their great
achievements, ” says Humble, but there
is a question mark over the future, and
whether anything can be done about it.
Photo courtesy Sooni Taraporevala
Burjor Framji
& Co.
Licensed Plumbers
Sanitary & Drainage
Contractors
MARINE MANSION
1ST MARINE STREET
BOMBAY 400 002.
TELEPHONE 313207‘‘I . ' j??
'’01
An Inquest on the ‘Quest
'll
*1
Hormazdyar K. Mirza
Kaikhusroo M. JamaspAsa
Firoze M. Kotwal
not found in the extant Avesta and Pah-
; zoroas — is ,he worlds oldes, ,avi literalure. Then why has i. been ¦,!
. ¦ • !--» __9 I« I nn ivit h t r! IS StOTV. 1
witch-doctor ’, and another, as ‘a politi
cian! ’ Both these scholars were ably and
revealed religion and at no time in its
selected? In connection with this story,
Mr. Bharucha states in his interview;
“This miracle is supposed to have con
long history has it ever been considered in his book depicted Zarathushtra as a
SiSss" ..... k™ ........z™.......-.
duce into the film the idea of conversion.
Leaving aside such stories of miracles,
acknowledged as a prophet with sprititual
knowledge, as it is evident from the
Further, it is universally acknowledged
that the Gathas are the compositions of
the prophet himself, and that they con
tain spiritual wisdom. But all this is not
acceptable to the producers and the
director of the film.
The question of conversion is subtly
‘moral choices. ’ This is a gross misinter-
or even imagined to be a mere philo-
turies, the ancient Iranians
through Divine Wisdom gave Iran the huge amount to depict Zarathushtra as
great Zarathushtrian and Mazdayas- a horse-doctor !
nian faith interview with the Indian -
. Therefore, as practitioners of the E-rpres,i (January 9. 1983). Mr. Cyrus Zaiath^JbSiS
good Zoroastrian religion steeped in the Bharucha states. .
;^L?d^s^dylXseaX^e man. ’^iS^r^t^n ^legei^s Gathas 'a.d othe^ ancient
are shocked into disbelief on reading is somewhat different from the tradi-
Vr press reports, that a film called ‘A Quest tional. ” .
’ - - • . ¦ • ----- 1-----1 With what knowledge and with what
authority does Mr. Bharucha make this
years of devoted study and research, we
are s
r'
t
i"'
t
“I definitely do not
a mira-
for Zarathushtra ’ was being produced
which will portray Zarathushtra, not as .
a prophet, but as ‘the world ’s first great sweeping statement? In the same inter-
thinking man. The first great philo- view, Mr. Bharucha goes on to give a
sopher! ’
Thus, a mischievous attempt is
scene from the film —their own interpre- The question ot conversion is suotiy
is beine tation of the story of the miraculous introduced also under the guise ot
madTro^reiesate 'zarathushtra to the cure of King Vishtasp ’s horse. To quote ‘moral choices. ’ This is a gross misinter-
Of his own words: “As we were researching pretation of the
course, every prophet in mankind ’s his
tory has through his Divine Wisdom,
propounded a philosophy of life, involv
ing 1
level of ordinary philosophers.
‘i
¦d
JI
4^
'1
J
lit
dance of the public. The Gathic stanza
Yasna 30.2 is often quoted to show that
Zarathushtra grants freedom of ‘moral
choices, ’ in other words, enjoins conver
sion. To say the least, this is not correct.
The said stanza, Yasna 30.2, may be
material for the film, we found that
there is a form of horse paralysis that
..................... responds positively to herbal remedies,
ing the morals and ethics of human So we ’ve shown Zarathushtra as rub
behaviour. But that does not make any bing the horse ’s body with a herbal mix-
nronhet a mere philosopher or a mere ic,. i—j-- -------- ,---- i , j r
thinking man. TcIsay that of Zaralhush- dear-that a prophet is a man o special
tra is a blasphemy, a travesty of the knowledge, tn this case veterinary Do you hear by ears with best mind,
Zoroastrian religion and a cruel joke on knowledge, not a spiritual being.^
the Zoroastrian community in India and ‘
abroad. We wish to make it amply clear
that what we state above is based on
press reports of various interviews given
by Mr. Cyrus Bharucha, whose ‘brain-
Mr. Zubin Mehta, the renowned music
conductor, who is going to play an
important role in the film. In as much as
we would like to disbelieve such press
reports, in
tions or L
£“^e'"As “uckX ‘hav: cTton^f deeding ih; pVo'phe ’t oT his good and the result of bad will bad
state categorically that the film, if pro- supernatural status and showing him as
.1 ___J_____ ___1 1 l5^
days of the who at that time catpc from the higher Zoroastrian works after the downfall of
strata ofsociety. They are adiisedlo get Zoroastrian Iran appears to have been
, ”...... — wine and up btforesunriseandgoassoonaspos- begun under Aturfarnbag Farroxzat,
\ ajake merry; oft fflfe day of Vo'human, sible to school, not to offend parents, to the high priest of Iran during the reign
ye should put on new clothes; on the __________ _ ___________ \ ‘ of aTMarnttn (813-33 A.C.f and eom.
on the dav of OhrmArd by Atu^t-i Emet, who assuhii^
vn jne uay ot unrmazu the position of high priest of Pars ?dter
one shdu Id drink wine a nd,;At«rfambag*s son. The benkart is tfe
j mekp mArrV- on th«a most important as well as the most
tox^ts name has been attached to a HiaKe merry, On the extensive work m Middle-Persian. apd
fwndarz tCKt called the Pandnamak-i Vohuman, 006 the seven extant volumes (the first twd?
Chttak handarzd shdUldout dn hfiWClothec and the beginning of the third
/jyi-ortM/wn. containing the maxims onoUiapuiOO neW ClOmeS. book have been lost) are a treasure
of the primeval It deals with ethi- house dfinformation from older sources
cal, social and religious matters that cultivate cleanliness and politeness. and that are now lost to us.
every Zoroastrian should know on to be dutiful and obedient. Another text While most of the other honddrz cbm-
reaching the age of 15. It has in fact been for children is the Xveshkarih-i retakan, positions are primarily addressed to a
referred to as the Zoroastrian eate- ‘Theduties of Pa^s, ’ which is attributed lay audience, the sixth book of the
chism,.^ all religions seek to establish to some forgotten school-teacher, for we kart is eYidently addressed to an
man ’s relationship to this world and the read; this knowledge was given by the audience with a higher intellectual
. - ------------- - cajpacity. Much of its contentsare based
questions that need answeringart^ ‘Who Perlraps the largest surviving single on oral traditions from the Sasanian
am I, aid to whom do I belong, from collection of gnomic sayings and the ful- period, while some portions of it are
where did 1 come and where shall 1 lest exposition of the ethical wisdom of distinctly more ancient; and indeed, cer-
return? ’ In reply to these questions, the, Zoroastrian Iran in late Sasanian timeSi tain portions of it seem to have bem
author of the Ch/mA; categorically is the sixth book of the ‘The formulated in the cryptic Middie-
5- declares that man was created in the Act ofReligion. ’TbeDcnArar/is itself an Persian style typical of translations
spiritual W^rld, "belongs to God and encyclopaedic work, originally in nine from the Avesta. One may therefore p^*
shall retdrb to Rim. books, on the ^igioii, philosoplQ^ and sume that the Avesta also contained
The Handarz-i kotakan is a collection history of the Zoroastrians. The gargan- handarz sayings that are now only aVail-
-, Ohrms?^ '<
the day of strata of society. They are adidsedto get Zoroastrian Iran appears to have been
d®y-of Vo'human, sible to school, not to offend parents.
®C
&¦
»-V
»r
-
’ 5
fe
f'V ’ ••
On the day of Ohrmazd
'y- V* sasb** WI.4WOL V»* B
one should drink wine and Aturfwnbag*s son. The Den^tor/ is tfe
ihake merry; on the
day of Vohumahr ooe
shduldputdn hewclothes. and be^nning of the thM
every Zproastrian should know on to be dutiful and obedient. Another text
next, to God and to the devil, the first school-teacher.
sume that the Avesta also contained
- XE
The Zoroastrian CxO-operative
Credit Bank Limited
Zoroastrian Association Building,
16^ Horniman Circle>-
A Grtidays
«
I
I-w
1
1^
2
THE VIGILANTES
Hutokshi D.Doctor
«
&
'"I
¦
S'.''
t After the last Bombay Parsi Punchayet Some of the Council ’s members have
¦ Anjuman Committee elections, the studied Zoroastrianism and Nariman
' orthodox camp fell in disarray. The has read papers on Zoroastrianism at share certain ideas in common decided
• • * *¦ it ’s no use trying to counter these attacks
individually but rather to pool our
efforts collectively. We do not necessar
ily want to expand membership unless
we find someone who is genuinely
orthodox.
“We are not intending to fight elec
tions but if a reformist trustee is put up
Jam-e-Jamshed but to a limited extent
because of the limited space. We who
Committee of United Zoroastrians, an several international conferences,
electoral alliance of several factions
' claiming to represent the orthodox group was
point of view, was dissolved. chayet ’s decision to reconsider member-
sBut filling the void after a lull of ship of the beleaguered Federation of
h around two years is a new orthodox Parsi Zoroastrian Anjumans of India,
i group calling themselves The Council of Many of the orthodox view the Federa-
Vigilant Parsis. The announcement of tion as a reformist body and therefore a
' the new Council was made in the threat to the religious customs and tra-
November 16, Cyclostyled Letter No.2I ditions.
published by Russi D. Wadia, a market-
1 ing research consultant. According to
the newsletter, the nine-member group
aims at “maintaining and preserving the
ideals, principles, doctrines and tradi-
The impetus for the newly formed
the Bombay Parsi Pun- 1
ii
!)C ’ '
• -H
“1 was informed by two trustees of the
Bombay Parsi Punchayet that the BPP
was to rejoin the Federation, ”said B.K.
Mistry relating the genesis of the Coun
cil. “I told Adi Doctor about it. We
tions of the Pristine Zoroastrian Reli- called a meeting. At the first meeting we
gion. ”
“The operative word is vigilant. ”
' notes council member Adi Doctor, a
publicity officer in a bank. “The Parsis
r are ignorant of and indifferent to their
religious, social and cultural heritage...
'At the first meeting
we were nine people,
an auspicious number in
our community.”
A
were nine people, an auspicious number
in our community. We submitted a
memorandum to the Punchayet. The
response was very good and the Pun
chayet called us. The Trustees listened
to us patiently. They could not give any
'' the average Parsi is so involved in.the reason lor leaving the Federation and
daily rat-race ” that he has little time for
religious and spiritual matters.
The other members of the group
include Kaikhushroo N. Dastoor. gen-
<
Ki^:
as a candidate — we will oppose him. He
may be efficient but he is not fit for this
office. ”
“We have to stop non-orthodox per
sons from taking steps detrimental to
the community, ” noted Dastoor. “The
spiritual and mystical aspects of the reli
gion have to be preserved, ”as well as the
religious institutions, he said.
“The Zoroastrian religion says that
each individual born into his own reli
gion has inherent genetic differences...
The religious, spiritual and psychic fac
tors stem then from religion. This is the
reason why mixed marriages are not
permitted. ” noted Dastoor.
“The Delhi Parsi Anjuman believes in
accepting ” children of both Parsi men
many issues, ” in the religious, social and and women married to non-Parsis, said
economic fields. Dastoor. This is one of the main reasons
........... The Council is opposed to the com- why the Council is opposed to the Feder-
chief vigilance officer of the Bank of munity being included in the Adoption ation. “No matter what you wish to do
_ _ __ . __ • w-~> ¦ • 1' « ¦ r* *11 1 1 t* _ ' n _ .. I T m 1. . iLaM/ximU nil
lor of the Ilm-Kshnoom bi-monthly is against intercommunity marriages.
"We do not necessarily
want to expand
membership unless we
find someone who is
genuinely orthodox.”
eral manager, chief legal adviser and
?'
•-^J
- ¦•¦¦¦
i ¦¦¦¦¦
• ¦ —1|
PRESTOSICN
PRtSTOGRflPH j
n
Old post cards etc./wanted
Advertiser wishes to buy OLD
picture postcards, photographs, cigarettes,
’ cards, playing cards, posters, prints,
illustrated books, albums and
other related material.
Willing to pay top prices for single
items or entire collections.
Please send detailed list with
expected prices to:
The Advertiser,
(OLD) C/o. Parsiana, G.P.O.
Box 892, Bombay 400 001.
¦
63 Parsiana March 1983
' 'jf
• ‘
productivity.
Use Prestosign/
Prestograph for sales
projections, inventory
control, budgetary
allocations, production
planning, PERT/CPM and
other complex
applications as well as
for simpler uses like
displaying information
and events, exchange
rates, airline schedules,
etc.
1
I
1 'K
®
PRESTOSIGN
PRESTOGRAPH
The 3-D Interchangeable Display and
Charting System.
Provides the know-now tor competent
administration.
Manufactured by:
C.J. IndustriSS, Bombay 400005.
Sole Marketi ng Concessionaires:
•=M
mnws MARKirwe ,
Hampton Court, N. Parekh Marg, Nr. CoIabeTp O
Bombay-400 005.
Phone: 213103/212752 Grams: PRESTOSIGN
Branch:
Continental Plaza. 2nd Floor,
705 Anna Salai (Mount Road), Madras 600 006
Phone; 83832 Grams: LETRO
in^A.
TPa^'*
^^.¦
"t^
'it.
'»<
I.
¦
I'
l=T
Farewell
to
fire fighting
?:
Carol D’Souza
<»
h
k
F
V.
F'
t
w
j8
Mehervanjee: "I'm a fireman
first and last,
the chief only in-between."
Bombay is going to miss Mr. L.S.D.
Mehervanjee, the chief fire officer of the
city ’s fire brigade who retired on Janu
ary 31,1983, after a little over 40 years in
service.
Not that the man who has taken ov^
from him, Mr. V. B. Nikam, is not effi
cient, it is just that we have all got so
used to seeing LSD’s trim form, immac
ulately uniformed, at the site of major
fires and house collapses, that it is going
to be strange not to see him.
It is one of the first things that impress
itself on the memory. In the midst of
sweating firemen heaving huge coils of
hosepipe around, he would be a calm,
cool, very collected figure with his
helmet firmly on his head and scarcely a
hair out of place, directing operations
with vigour and energy.
Periodically, he has been receiving
medals and awards, including an
“honour the brave ’’ award (from the
Jaycees), a President ’s police medal, and
the President ’s medal for distinguished
services.Periodically too, details of his
life have appeared in the newspapers, of
how he joined the auxiliary fire services
at the age of 17, how he was born in New
Chawang, Manchuria, in the northern
part of China in 1925, how he was only
19 years old when the “Fort Stikine ”
blew up in the docks and he took active
part in the fire-fighting operations that
followed, when 66 men and officers of
the fire brigade lost their lives and Bom
bay was practically devastated.
On Monday, the very last day of his
life-long career with the Bombay Fire
Brigade, LSD (his initials are unforget
table) looked a bit lonely (as any man
must look when retirement stares him in
the face at a time when he feels most
useful). Sitting in his rather plush office
in the headquarters of the fire brigade at
Sankley Street, he confessed to feeling
“very touched, 1 am most sentimental. ’’
And anyway, he said, what ,can you
expect from a man for whom the fire
brigade has been his whole life !
It gave me an opportunity to ask him
what those unforgettable initials stood
for and he told me —Lovejoy Sisil Dadi
no less ! And his father used to be known
as “Chinwalla ” because of the China
connection.
He remembers much of his early days
in China, where he was educated. He
remembers the Sino-Japanese war and
the bombardment of Shanghai with the
carnage that followed. It was his grand
father ’s idea to have LSD become a Chi
nese scholar but friends prevailed upon
him to let the boy learn English as well.
64 Parsiana M arch 1983‘ 5 »¦' * s
J’
e
r.
E
X'"
w
''
rO
r
V
’\
>
-lysr
L***
4
W;-
.ri»4?W? "'V-..
w
s
,4--
'
¦i
IE:
Which was just as well becau^ when
“Chinwalla ” came to India from China
on a year ’s vacation, the move became
permanent since the Second World War
broke out. ,
It was the war that enabled LSD to
join the auxiliary fire service at 17.
“Actually, I was attracted to the pay,
Rs. 70 per month in those days was
hardly to be sniffed at. And 1 used to
watch the men parading from Byculla
bridge. 1 was most impressed. ”
And so the youthful Mehervanjee
landed in uniform, enjoying himself t ho
roughly. Thoughts of China receded as
he threw himself into his new existence.
In just two years he was to face the
biggest test of what would become his
career.
He became a section leader and was
given independent charge of a large fire
station in the docks area. At that time,
with the war effort in full swing, ships
used to draw in with dangerous cargo.
The protection offered by fire-fighting
services was of the utmost necessity.
And then on April 14, when “Stikine ” W
blew, it was a nightmare.
Remember he was just 19 years old
when a fire was followed by two massive
explosions within half an hour of each *
other. It was carnage all around in the
Victoria Docks, people lay lifeless or
desperately injured, the heat was sear
ing. No one could have blamed him for
. running away, but Mehervanjee stood
his ground. He survived, though badly
injured. And, perhaps, the seed for his
permanent career was sown at that time.
When the auxiliary service was dis
banded, Mehervanjee was at a loose
end. He worked as a fire instructor at the He has been on the scene of every major fire, house collapse, or other emergency
home guards for some time, but finally duty, ready to lend a helping hand, seldom ruffled.
in 1950, he was with the Bombay Fire
Brigade as a station officer. In a way,
LSD had come home.
In the years since, he has been on the
scene of every major fire, house collapse his office, flanked by the flags of the are brave, daring, courageous and full of
or other emergency duty, ready to lend a country and the red and blue of the bri- initiative. And they are completely
helping hand, seldom ruffled except gade. The formal flag is gorgeous, the dependable. ”
when public enthusiasm came in the way emblem resplendent in “jari ” folded Apparently, the men feel the same
of the fireman doing his duty. Then he away in a cloth cover and kept with the way about him for as I sat in his office,
could be as cutting as the rest.
He is lucky in the sense that he has _ _
watched the brigade grow to its present with housewifely pride tinged with a bit landed him as he sat, presented him with
proportions, watched as its Indianisa- of anxiety. “I have looked after it for a bouquet and made speeches. And he
tion was completed, its jurisdiction
extended to the suburbs, the VHF
radio-telephone link system commissi
oned, control room reorganised (it is to been like, he shrugs and says: Retirement will take a bit of getting
be completely computerised shortly, “Remember 1 am a fireman first and used to, specially for a man who is used
making it one of the first in Asia), the last, the chief only in-between. This is a to being on the parade ground at 6.30
creation of five sub-divisions. And the wonderful brigade. Perhaps, we cannot a.m. and continuing at the job till well
proudest momentof all, he was chief fire compete with western countries in terms past dusk. This is excluding the fact that
9i
W- i
65 Parsiana March 1983
?S-
<
1
¦•ai
- -I
¦ 1
5
-¦
1
.-o-.S
.''t*
ilS^W
• J
¦d
'¦1
' ]
uv
4-
¦
J
officer when the Brigade received its of equipment, but we are rapidly moder
own emblem and colours in 1979. nising the brigade. And our men are
It stands behind thedeskofthechiefin second to none other in the world. They
greatest care in the chiefs inner office, one of the two Union representatives
Mehervanjee showed it to me almost came in, flanked by office-bearers, gar-
three years. Now, Mr. Nikam must take accepted it all as a fireman, even putting
over. ” on the navy blue cap insfead of his
And when you ask him what it has peaked officer ’s hat.
been like, he shrugs and says:
¦J
-R
.i
,
f
dff ’’T?,
J ¦’>T
being in the fire brigade is a 24-hour job-
with no real let-up. “We have to stay in
the vicinity of our particular areas while
on duty so that we can hear the bell. And
in half a minute we respond to calls,
though actually we are supposed- to in
ten seconds !”
That, I suppose, would be too much
to expect, particularly in view of the
record of Bombay Telephones which
(most private citizens will aver) hardly
give the police and fire brigade special
treatment where numbers are con
cerned. Still, 30 seconds is not at all bad
considering the exigencies under which
the brigade must labour.
For four years he has headed a band
of 800 men, living close enough to them
to feel the whole organisation is one big
family. Now it is over, because, as
Mehervanjee himself puts it: “There is
time for change, someone else must take
over. ” What he will not forget, however,
is his association with the country ’s pre
mier fire-fighting force and his stint as
its head.
~ Courtesy MID-DA K February 4, 1983.
'^9
:5
awithpif
cleaning
1923*1983
SIXTY YEARS OF CLEAN SERVICE
r ’
ST
Continued from page 15.
body of the D.P.A., further angered the
BPP who then tried to get the other
Anjumans in the Federation to oust
Delhi from the body.
But at the crucial meeting Nargol-
wala ensured there were enough repre
sentatives from anjumans sympathetic
to Delhi to defeat any ouster vote.
In order to break the deadlock, Nar-
golwala had suggested the Delhi Parsi
Trust replace the Ahjuman as there were
no non-Parsi Zoroastrians in the Trust
This formula was unacceptable to a
majority of the BPP trustees.
It was only with the C.E.R. victory in
the Anjuman Committee elections in
1981 and the expiry of BPP Chairman
B.K. Boman-Behram ’s term a few
months later, that the balance shifted in
favour of rejoining.
No doubt Golwalla was aware there
would be opposition from the more
orthodox section to the BP’P rejoining
. the Federation. But as he has demon
strated Itime and again in the last few
months, he is not hesitant to take deci
sions in the best i^iterests of the com
munity no matter hpw painful they be.
And doing so he and his colleagueshave
once again displayed the qualities of
great leadership,
Other announcements made at the press
conference will be published in the April
issue of Parsia/Ki.
DIANA-ECLIPSE
For all your carpat and upholstery cleaning.
o HoHand House, Colaba Causeway, Bombay
Tel: 230619
O ’‘Parag ” 27. Redder Road.
DHARMA
PRAKASH
RADIANT LIGHT OF RELIGION
A Religious Digest For Happy Living.
We desire to vigorously spread
Religious Awareness.
Please support the endeavor.
ASK FOR “FREE GIFT” Copy Now.
Edited and Published by
Mr. P.A. SIGANPORIA
Gowind Bhovan.Bazon Baug, Nagpur - 440004.
«
c
4>
" £
-"n
11
'3
'Js
¦«
VJ Parsiana March 1983/
isf
*r '
^’S'*-"’
'X
I
?i'
' .
?•
.'A*
/
-«’l
'•¦ y
-.^ ,?=J
- J f>
“ * r
LacqaHM-edtray Showing
foreign hKtontes I* Canton <<825)
't'- ’" ¦ ' ¦' ' '1 ' , A-
V ' -H
OpiHin
5
wOm
from
Bombay
^m©i6bay into a
prosperQj^ri^ thriving „
¦ -^aM ’ fnerj^jMs>^f.,-"' •
'a Gigim’sa and Bombay, wi^I
hab a mohbpoiy over „ < '
tHe'toda tor over aix
decades, rtlto a^
^^ffoent community^ ;
r
^1
¦^* *z
’ k
’Ki
“"?4F.*'5'-F^’
r ’
i.
••«i ^'p. - v^ ¦“•>'¦................ ¦*’¦ ...
k China fey Arab merc^oTs aS a d/t^
introduced into China by the Cask Ind^ ' o^ni trade be;^n to pass fbf'gastric diwrder«, a painiciHeranda
Company, The deadly poppy was etslti- Bombay ywld>ng a revenue of 200.000 J
vated in India and transported by sea to pounds m one year aloud; . T^ hhmt of opium smoitfqg afi^J
C^ina. . -^¦' ? P . ,. . « r ,u
' M w the uaethipal optUm tra^ with ;frw Java, one of the o^
Wen^tSkW6 tniM<^, W: .Oina pridr to now gav? way to - smoking countries. By^^
>de«tufyandtha'nhWfe^iekratonopoii^^Ap^^ traders, bdth iCaropean ahd ^ wdj^nce in opium fewfc^
the trade for wer._^&mdK,|^bay\ (n^wa; as/tts monopoly XMW^
irwas turticd into k ’^ving afe^j^jj^r ‘7 trade W ended by the Charter- Act of hold in
• A - ‘oua poir; U»o Pg^ inta.,,^f833; licences to becauw
An afntt^t comi^ii^., '' ;>«tisb Par^ l^TSpis Jop^^hip-
- Most of the popB^r brands, rnalva- pipfr-Oi^^a^h^^wf^fek rettttWV^-
ppfum*an»9ngt|iebftxusedtafe^jt^0id€d: .'ab^M-W^
from E^matibi^ IS31 wheh;feiM?i^^ “
'‘U)iop.^« ^rtnernmertt,i^y^|-l»^^yeft,
it hygratiRdgi^s^fOf '
direct finite to of
duty,oTBS ’?f7$fow^^^^^'W'eigfe^'
ae.
Wti
' ^j^«'
xj-
&¦'
'#a
t
>rq^
/-
transit
69 Parsiarta Mtirctf
¦‘*^^
S' Old ifls^
for free jrfehsirfey i:
Wdf?^
,, r-. - > . >5
•i**
4
’^'3#
9^
>
* A
‘‘^per
^n 1^
fop*
(T th
j;
the feiaitffJ
t ofih? Asidp^iipn^, chi^
yT -->f
oj
^1
1
,P"-Sl
JS:
r.vf
5
id a Ml
S&, ¦^3;-,!S:i^
*<’ •¦**^V’
* PudbRjee a Q>.X1 E h
¦ Aa IKUIc^. when opium eonstituted as
Wack, granj^.eontmning m^^e» or Into heavily armed rigs Or much as 42 pertent of dottoii export?
nareotica.^<^mie, Hert^alsoisan . schoc^ Which then oae^ tlm^
from the »R€rn!^ was a hereditary But when the Chinese government month and exported 9,500 chests to
occupation and is so even now. How- deeded to put an end to this uwdiical dfne Matheson A jCo., of Hongkong.
ever, toeby,. . po opium is used or trade^fhelBntish in India, sensing a loss They also shipped 8,2^ chests on van- '
exported ete^fi^mndicinalpn^pt^s. -of tte huge income decided to invade ious steamers, keeping another 2 J 000
The addicts irt'thc early niw^eCnth China in 1840, leading to tte famous chests ready in the warehouses in Bom*
c«turyco.iaprisedmostlyyoungttena//y newspaper. Reprinted with the«i«terK^.^
permission. , •
X
5'^
'Aa
««^6>
r
r
«.*>
71 P»sian»
-ST
Cen^fUHients from
»-y
<
5 5’
(Bipbi
<\ *
^s,"^
(Phoife 253324)
, /?• *
¦¦¦ - ’z?
f'
*
?>(
‘ >7^1
P
0
J
;?
I
•*»«»*I0***
?rr^St€- A
"1.^
~4
*^ir-^.*
f
I
I
I'
-
I
I
I
£
I
I
1 *
^4
I
•4
Ik-
ART
4
While Nelly Sethna, seated at her loom,
visualizes and executes her versatile
works of art, her husband Homi,
with his flowing white beard and khadi
kurtas, has spent a life-time recording
Indian art on film. Each complements
the other ’s work, advising, criticising and
actively participating in it. Surrounded
kurtas, has spent a life-time recording
Indian art on film. Each complements
the other ’s work, advising, criticising and
actively participating in it. Surrounded
by their cherished artifacts in their
spacious Bombay apartment, Nelly and
Homi see beauty and art in the smallest
and seemingly most insignificant
articles.
Double
Woven
Hutokshi D. Doctor
>
M '
s®
* i
i
IB
is
51
Weaving wonders
A piece of brown paper folded twice,
with the words “nelly h sethna designer+
weaver ” in raised print constituted the hanging with
invitation to her exhibition of hand-
woven and handcrafted rugs, wall
hangings, torans and screens at the
Jehangir Art Gallery, Bombay, in
December 1982. The innovative invita
tion held promise of a rare experience,
and Nelly ’s materials, designs and tech
niques are certainly unique and uncon
ventional. They are also bold and
, striking.
ths.* for mistakes and mess panel or wrapped strip' perfectly alisnVd
thousands of punched leather^ bits
method and patterns, says Nelly. “1 march in neat order down a fringed
m"S Teels°~" equally matched and
XT II • I lOliUU ¦
" - - ----- i." any f ..............
or technique. Her myriad new designs but, confined to
“She Ls a contemporary artist who takes
from nature a nd old motifs, ” says Homi.
One striking example is a wall-
_ „ 1 maroon arrowheads on a
black background pointing east and
west on either side of an orange panel,
with orange tassles hanging below.
The leather wall-hangings are partic
ularly eye-catching. “One leather hang
ing includes punched leather strips,
panels in a combination as striking as it
isunlikely, ”writesan art critic. “Each
piece is meticulously finished, each
thousands of punched leather bits
, --------- >«'*^*.B*wa oni|^o,
seashells, wooden beads and fringed
a
V
Fl
¦3
1
Nelly does not confine herself to any
particular material < '
components are as varied as rope, woof,
leather, jute, seeds, beads and even sea
shells. These are sometime.s convention
ally woven, double woven, hand-knot
ted, braided, tufted < ’, L.J.
designs are simple, uncluttered, and
often derived from traditional motifs.
The colour combinations are novel,
( sometimes startling but never clashing.
' 74 Parsiana March 1983
Nelly s vibrant mind conceives of a
, ------------.J a
wheelchair, she now leaves their execu
tion to her four associates, ‘mochi ’
Bhanu, domestic help Chandrabhaga,
file odd-jobs man Mansingh, and
has worked with Nelly for over 13 years.
She lists their names in her invitation,
describing them as “people who are
influenced, involved and have evolved.
or latticed. Her Roshan Mulla, her chief assistant, who
J
1
1
t
F
i.” ¦« A
?u*^
75 Parsiana March 1.983
at Bombay Dyeing Nelly got a scholar-
i* ship to the Cranbrook Academy of Art
L in Michigan, one of America ’s select
I academies. “She left, went to America
I and did weaving for the first time, ” said a
I Homi. On her retprn in 1960 she worked
I with Bombay Dyeing for eight years. A
I National Diploma in Design holder
I from the U.K., Nelly has held several
I exhibitions of her work.
I In 1972 she was awarded the Homi
I Bhabha fellowship to work on Kalam-
j karis, an old South Indian art utilizing
vegetable dyes which she wanted to
revive. Subsequently she held five exhi
bitions of Kalamkari all over India.
From these traditional motifs she would
design contemporary lay-outs. Now,
however, Nelly works independently
but depends on Homi ’s help in organisa-
[ people of talent who go unnoticed and tion and public relations.
unseen, when the creative germ lies quiet
and forgotten within. ” She describes ’Happiness Unto Others ’
Homi as “the real force behind this Since his first film on the hygienic main-
show. ” Homi ’s lighting and artifacts tenance of drains, Homi Sethna has
from their personal collection including worked on a variety of films, he says,
terracotta figures, bronze diyas, baske- including films on the construction of
try and ancient pots provided the back- dams, the development of fish, village
drop for Nelly ’s work at the gallery.
These hangings and screens are now processing of cotton. Recently he com
displayed at their home, and sitting pleted a film on the Parsis entitled
amidst her creations and her treasures Happiness Unto Others for Films Div-
Nelly reflected upon her youthful days ision, which, according to him, repres
in the countryside of a Bombay suburb, ents the “historical backdrop of the
She commented that she had learnt Parsis. ” The 20-minute film for public
more from nature and life than from her screening, shows “who the Parsis are,
formal education. Her work is con- what they have done and achieved in
stantly on her mind, she said, and she most walks of life, ” said Homi.
needs no other relaxation. The title. Happiness Unto Others is
i When she was already chief designer taken from a hymn from one of the five
<
A black and white double weave rug
Left: One of Nelly ’s hand-crafted
room dividers
punchayets, rural development and the
jl
I
I
n
Homi: “Versatile jogger ”
r
‘i“As a designer and artist she sees described by Homi as “the best Bombay
work together. She ’s my artistic advi
sor for ail art and craft things. ”
Homi has made some films on Nelly ’s building is to be demolished. Homi has
With a degree in arts and law from carpet, Nelly ’s wall-hangings arc promi-
Gathas, the entire quotation being film, Vishvakarma the Great, on the khadi vest, carrying two freshly replen-
“Happiness unto him who brings happi- wood carvings of India was written by ished bottles of milk and the morning
ness unto others. ” Briefly outlining the Nelly, he says. “She conceived the art newspaper. Till recently Homi would be
history of the Parsis since their advent to and craft shots for the film. ” accompanied by their dog Nicholas,
India, the film, accompanied by a first
person commentary depicts traditional things in a different light, ”says Homi. “Nelly breed ” who decided to adopt Nelly and
Parsi village life, the man in the fields, is a part of all this. She has the eye for the Homi five years ago. Nicholas however,
the women at the village well, the setting of a typical Parsi home and we died recently.
beaded torans on the doorways, the por- work together. She ’s my artistic advi- It is a pity too that the Sethnas ’large
traits of the forefathers above. sor for ail art and craft things. ” apartment on the second floor of an old
Outlining the basic tenets of the reli
gion. 'Good thoughts, good words, work; one of these, entitled IVeaves is lived here for fifty years, and their living
good deeds, ’ the significance of the fire, still being distributed in America even room is crowded with their cherished
showing the navjote ceremony and a pri- after 18 years, he Said. artifacts. A charkha lies on a worn
est in an agiary, the film is a comprehen
sive introduction to the Parsis and their Bombay University, Homi first joined nently displayed, there are even a pair of
religion. From there the film proceeds to his father ’s firm of solicitors and then shoes from Saurashtra, displayed back
the contribution of the Parsis in various, the army films centre as an apprentice and front, which Nelly says are more
fields, from their contribution to the and later a lieutenant, he says. In 1946 beautiful thain a modern painting. An
freedom struggle, to the arts, from he went abroad, working in the film oldswingissuspendedfromchainsori-
industry to medicine. studios of England, Denmark and ginally from Gujarat, each chain com-
“But 1 am now concentrating on art Germany before returning to India prising the figures of peacocks, women
and craft films, ” says Homi. His film and continuing his career as a film and elephants linked together.
Creations in Meta! on Indian metal- maker. Nelly and Homi even treasure a tube
ware, won the President ’s Award for the The Times of India recently carried a of tooth-paste pressed into the shape of
best promotional film, he says, while report on Homi Sethna, the “versatile a woman, the figure of Christ on a
The Himalayan Tapestry, directed by jogger ” who can be seen jogging along wooden cross, created from a twisted
him. won the President ’s gold medal for most mornings at Bombay ’s Breach rag. and the twigs which represent a man
the best documentary. The script of his Candy in blue khadi shorts and a white and a woman walking together.
i
i
i
1
I
00
§
FRIENDV^
PRE PACKED
CUPS
FOR
f
i
n Parsiana March 1983
FRIENDLY
ICECREAM
Rs 2-50 (small)
& Rs 3-50 (Big).
Try our
delicious Kulfi
Pista, Kesar, & Malai
k toe our
I l^ot
--snxouw®
occassioj^
SALES DEPOT 9 C, READY MONEY BLDG,, SANKLI STREET,
BYCULLA. BOMBAY 400 008. TeL 898634
FACTORY : DEONAR VILLAGE HOAD,OPP, METAL- BOX CO.
DEONAR, BOMBAY-400 078 Tel : 52941 4-523054 ay
7^
Petit vs Jeejeebhoy XVI
Triumph of Caste
THE JUDGEMENT SO FAR When, 150 years ago, leading members society, its attitude towards Dubras, its
In 1903 R.D. Tata married according to of the Indian Zoroastrians talked about attitude towards the surrounding infe-
Par si rites, a French lady, after . ..
having her navjote performed. Tata
claimed his wife “had become a Parsi
professing the Zoroastrian faith
and consequently she was entitled to
participate in all the charitable and
religious Funds and Institutions of the Community in India had meant one
Parsis including the right to enter fire thing —and one thing only to them —
temple.'i and have her body consigned to their own select people. And the Holy
the Towers of Silence. Mazdiasni faith, as far as they knew.
Thus the scene was set for the historic was professed by that select body and by probably impossible for any English
court case of Petit vs Jeejeebhoy, also them alone. The religion —originally the Churchman who has not been in years in
known as “The Parsi Punchayet Case. ” principal, if not the only social and tri- ’close intimate contact with Orientals of
The question before the two judges of bal bond —had long since been con-
the Bombay High Court, Justice
Frank C.O. Beaman and Justice
Dinshaw Dhanjibhoy Daver,
was whether a person horn in another
faith but converted to Zoroastrianism
was entitled to the benefits of
certain community trusts.
The Plaintiffs (Sir Dinshaw Maneckji recurrently in the air, but was growing
Petit; Tata and others) contended
Zoroastrianism enjoins and practises
conversion and that converts are
entitled to all the benefits provided. The likely that had these Founders of the
defendants (Sir Jamsetji Jeejeehhoy
and others) while admitting that
Zoroastrianism permits conversion
state that “ever since their fParsis)
advent into India (they) have not
admitted a Juddin (person belonging to mind was a regular Convocation of
another religion) into their fold.
They admit, however, that children
born oj a Zoroastrian father by an alien ble and desirable, much as members are regarded as a contamination. No Eng-
admitted into an exclusive club. Had lish Christian would think of regarding
they been further told that this would be a place of worship desecrated, because a
impossible, that they must choose genuine believer happened to have come
between accepting any Convert or
one —that accepting any meant accept- deny to such a one rites of Christian
ing all Converts indiscriminately; and burial in a Christian cemetery.
1 But in the Zoroastrian Community,
that the probabilities were immensely in the conditions are widely different.
dedicating Temples and Towers to the rior Hindu castes, 1 cannot doubt for a
Zoroastrian Community, or for the moment that they would have unhesitat-
benefit of all the Holy Mazdiasni faith, ingly said that, whatever might be the
we must reflect how those ideas pres- abstract religious dogma, they meant
ented themselves to the speakers. For their benefactions for their own people,
many hundreds of years the Zoroastrian the members of the Indian Zoroastrian
Community, that is to say, those who, as
in the case of every other close caste,
were born into it.
It is difficult for any Englishman
verted also into a distincti\e caste badge.
Being a member of the good religion, it
was doubtless at that time synonymous
with being a member of what we may
now, 1 think, fairly call the Parsi caste.
The subject of conversion was
unquestionably, as a theoretical dogma.
constantly to be more and more impera
tively conditioned by purely caste con
siderations. As 1 have said, 1 think it
all religions and castes —to put himself
into the place of men situated as the
Founders of these Trusts were situated.
We must find it hard to realize or even
laintly appreciate the sense of repulsion
which orthodox Zoroastrians would
feel at the bare idea of their places of
communal worship, much worse their
sacred Towers of Silence, being invaded
by persons whose very proximity in the
streets, or on the thresholds of private
Being a member of the
good religion was
Trusts been asked whether they were pre
pared to accept Converts, they would
have replied that they would not object . .
to duly-accredited, and approved Con- SynonymOUS With being a
verts. And what they would have had in member of the Parsi CaStO.
Elders on each case as it arose, to decide
whether the person proposed was eligi- dwellings, had for generations been
, mother have been admitted into their
fold by the performance of the
Navjote ceremony.
Dover, in his part of the judgement
discredited the evidence, past and
present, of conversion in India.
In the last issue, Beaman came to the had it been further pointed out to them
conclusion that faced with the 1'
possibilitv ofpermitting all or no converts, favour of hundreds of the most undesir- There, while the religion and its ritual
the founders of the Trusts would undoubtedly able people, for every single desirable purity are still the mainspring of the com-
have denied conversion on any terms.
This is the last instalment of the case.
from a base trade; still less would he
person, offering themselves for conver- munal life, they are so intimately bound
sion; looking to the constitution of the up with the exclusiveness and the purity
/’a
70 Parsf'ana March 1983-tl
C0^'
5 become' ’stoically tdeiilidal; and reli^ou^ worsMp, “ ro ZoR^istriantsm. But if they do,
I is only this dtfifereS^e, that ,u nK^erh - Now, ff we were to hold upon the they mustproyideseparate Temples and
K nrrthndoit un'A jnfi- ift^ef^h-of Scattered phrascs, itres'pcc- Towers for their use. These are our Tern--
F nftely greater loatliiMiand horror from tive of lhe Conditions of the Commun- pies and our Towers. Never sintie their
.• .V" . « 'WiW r * - S''*. ' __ ._. ---------41 ZXM' A'V TA
1^ *.:v#r»vBw *• ^'*^?*’**oi ........... , —
I person whos^ presenceiwas^a socialron- them that fhe original Zoroastrian reli- by the admission, to our knowledge, ot a
f lamination, thaiff be woi^d from aid.mit- gion enjoii^d the making of Converts, 7——
F ting him to his table ami die freedom of and therefore since these endowments that is, of our caste, born into it, and
I his family cimle. No mspectable Parsi were d^icated to the use of all of the brought up iait. AmJ it grown to
would dream of esatmg with, say, a
; is only this thatmodern
Towers for their use. These are' our Tem--
adbi*-Temples a»d Towfers a Uy, leading members of which used foundation have they been o^crat^
single person who was not one of us — -
temination,,thiff be Wot4d ftojnadntit-- enjoiMd the making of Converts,
I No Engffsh Christian
would. thinK of regarding a munity. There might be a c
' s ' > *. . • ctr^owk /\T fViA JrswAcf art/l TlTACf zi
I place of worship
I desecrated, because a
I ge.nui ne beiidver
fe happened to have come
I from a base trade.
pure add good faith, therefore they were an integral part of our religious and social
open to ail Converts indiscriminatdy,
. we should undoubtedly profoundly
shock' the sentiments of the Whole com-
cOnstant
stream of the lowest and most despised
persons pouring into it, and in the esti-
mation of all good Zdroastrians poHut-
A modern orthodox Parsi
would shrink with loathing
and horror from
admitting to hisTerpples
and Towers a person
whose presence was a ' ,
social contamination.
ing the 'fempies and Towers. We should
be inviting the immediate disruption of
the whole, ecclesiastical establishment. .
Genuine Zoroastrians would feel that
the venerated seats of their ancient refi-
gibh were desecrated past redemption
Bhungi It would seem to him utterly and no longer fit to be used by those of organization that these Temples and •
* ¦ " ¦ — -¦ - . . - Towers shaU for ever remain conse*-
____ _________ ________ I crated exclusively to the religious and
.iiiTvi^uiu v.». finite simple, and, in view of the ritual uses of such persons, and such
irreparable and considerations I have been discussing, persons only. Destroy that belief, and ,
- • - • •- • 1 -T-v -------- .... j_ you sever all the bonds of our caste
cohesion: we must cease to be what we
' SV*
B impossible to do so; it would.defile him the old faith,
in what is really an esst^ial caste semi-
ment But that defilement would he infi
ll nitely ’ worse —more i
jfe far-reaching-^if it touched the sacred quite intelligible. They say, we do not
B sources of the whole communal and object to proselytizing fanatics —if there
Their position irt this matter seems to
me (
of the whosJe communal and object to proselytizing fanatics —if there
I
J
A Veiy hanw Jainglie^ to oiir i^rsi Patrons
7. AFRICAN
safari
13T)AYS
Mata, Mt,
M; Lodge, Tree,
Samburu Game .
National Park,Tsavo
WesLTaite Mills.
1.U.S.A.
ISOAYS
New York, Niawa
Falls, Los Angles,
San Francisco, _
Yesomite National Zurich, Innsbruck,
Park, Las Vegas, Salzburg, Vienna,
Miami, Orlando, Venice,f«^,
Wadungton, Chicago. ' RotOTce, Rsa,
J
¦fe
r
1.
«5.
X
For Details Please Contact
The House of Travel
4U.S.A. 5. FAR EAST 6 FAR EAST/
GRAND HORIZONS JAPAN
CARIBBEAN 14 DAYS 16 DAYS
CRUISE BaigiK*, Hongkong. Honc^tong, Tokyo, NairoN, Masai
... .. . 22IMYS Kamakura, Hakone,
Forest, Ltfeem^ ’. . San Frahci^, - Piirit, JfetSla, AtamLKy^o,
-......• -....... *".......... - - • ¦ l aji Sinaeodte. Incluctng Nara, Os^a,
Si^osa Island. &n^ok, Singepore. Reserve, Amb^h
Canyon, b&uiH,
StThomas .Nassau,
Out IslaiKl.
2.EUROPE/UjC 3.EUROre/
—' U.K./U.S.A.
30 DAYS
Londoni Amster^vn,
Frankfurt, Sack
Zurich, Paris,tiw Los Arra^.LaS
YriWi WS^Bgttm, Vegas, &and
Orlando, Mbtni, "
Los Angles,
San FranfciiBtxj,
Las Vegas , C34cagri.
22i>AYS
Ijonddn, Amsterdam,
Frankfurt, Black
Forest, LuG^e/_
^zbiirg, Vienna,
AtoiceiiKone,
Nice, Lyon, Paris.
5.FAREAST
HORIZONS
14 DAYS
Ban^ok, Hongkong.
kkkK^O) Ocran
1^’
Saitosa Island.
MTT.Hin?rrAY
n la
ASIATIC 7a»/aSBMX 7
12, Mureb»n*flosd. B<»nMMv 400()01 Tel.: 288151 (B Liimi -
Telex: 011*3151 AIRA
81 Parsiana March 1983
3^ 4- ¦
¦b
H'rCSII.¥EiiT5
5"
if
Pick Any One
toSSSffiSSw ’ it W»« Be
A Glorious
Experience
SuHectlaRar Approval
........... . " '¦ —
APM-ATS^13
4
¦ V 41.
>
I
a' ’eho,^' ’a"^' ’±‘teS^r" '*** 7 '’7““’ “ "''¦‘‘y > ’“PPl™™- '» Ms. «
That is what^ have been ^2*' PfeiMliiffs end by repeating it. In the constant,
M —---- -------------• should, under the Circumstances of the often long and arduous, discussions we
of one or have held orally and in writing oven
more of the Trust Funds. points upon which, we do ’^ted whether
I cannot close without expressing my we agreed.my brother Daver has shown
deep sense of gratitude and obligation to the most consistent and conspicuous
----- --------------- ¦ I —------------- - courtesy, patience, and open-
It was not the intention of And it is a source of the
the Founders of these
Trusts to t hrow them open
indiscriminately to any
one and every Convert.
ment as merely a supplement to his, I
¦
a chosen and ptxuKar .piBiople. ,
told over and overag^n in the progress
of this case; and it does, I believe, fairly
represent what the Founders of these
benefactions really felt, and would have
unqualifiedly expressed, had they been
called upon categorically to do so. They
did not guard against the present peril,
because it never occurred to them.This, tne POUnOfirs nt aii i hoi r .t 7
shortly,isthegrounduponw»ichlhave ^unoerS m tnese all I have found myself able to agree
come to the conclusion that, while the ' ^UStS tO t hroW them open him on every mam point. Nd one
Zoroastrian religion certainly didorigi- indisCriminatelV tO anv associated with him can
nally recommend maijihg Converts, it -
was not the intention of the Founders of and Overy Convert. and serenity, sustained throughout
these Trusts to throw open indiscrimi- "" '' .. ——i------
nately to any one and every Convert, my brother Daver fdr the ‘J’°”him —himself a leadihgihember of
Andfor,hep„rpo«se Sk/Kfet-
Mukeijee lamented, “Life will go on, from there.
W Ptrsiana Mardi 1383^ ,
1
◆ ◆ ◆
From the archive
