Complete Issue
Apr 1996
APRIL
7ft
- jj*
7
\'
- - j:
I
• T
tS22
F
t :
W.M^de-
5-
e
i« i
•in:
A
-¦^.
t
J
I
>»'
rr.
fApril 1996
Volume 18 Number 8
EDITOR Jehangir R. Patel
MANAGING EDITOR Arnavaz S. Mama
EXECUTIVE EDITOR Parinaz M. Gandhi
SENIOR EDITOR Dina K. Mehta
ASSOCIATE EDITOR Roxana A. Driver
DESIGN Kranti M. Shilotri, Jayshree R. Ghosh
MARKETING DIRECTOR Veera Patel
ADVERTISING MANAGER Zarin Mistry
ADVERTISING EXECUTIVES
Niloufer Panthaky, Susan Hadvaid
FINANCE B. L. Arora
EDP Rohinton E. Daroga
ADMINISTRATION R. S. Pingle
MANAGEMENT Jasmine Driver
2 Readers’ Forum
10 Events and Personalities
17 “Surrounded by storytellers” by Parinaz Gandhi
18 “Each one of us is a perfect individual” by Arnavaz Mama
20 Zoroastrians Abroad
22 The Mahatma on the Parsis by Burjor Karanjia
26 Status of Women: sacred and secular - 5 by Dr Ketayun Gdwld
33 Burjor Mistry: For sound results
4’
*
DTP Bakhtavar R. Batliwalla, K. P. Ravi
SUBSCRIPTION/CIRCULATION
Khurshid Panthaki, Swarupa Kamat
ACCOUNTS Anagha Korde, Bindu Pillai
OFFICE Indu Pillai, Chetan Halani
OFFICE ASSISTANTS Umesh Poojary,
Selvan Mark, Sunil Sakhare,
Govind Salgaonkar, Mahlpat Jadhav
37 Books
41 Milestones
44 In Memoriam
Cover: Tableau at Mani Bhavan depicting crowd receiving Gandhiji in
Bombay upon his return from South Africa in 1915.
Photograph: Varghese W. Fernandez
Parsiana is published by Jehangir R. Patel
for Parsiana Publications Pvt Ltd at C/o H. L.
Rochat, Navsari Chambers, ground floor,
39 A. K. Nayak Marg, Fort, Bombay 400001
and printed by him at Kaiser-E-Hind Pvt Ltd,
300 Perin Nariman Street, Bombay 400001.
Color processing. Comart Lithographers;
black and white processing, Samir Scantech.
All rights reserved. ISSN: 0971-3786.
Phone: 2078730 Fax: 2072922. For editorial
enquiries 2078183. Tlx: 11-85710 RABO IN.
For subscription enquiries and payments:
C/o Kaiser-E-Hind Pvt Ltd, 300 Perin Nariman
St (Behind Reserve Bank of India), Bombay
400001; Phone: 2658619, 2665661.
Annual inland subscription for one year
(10 issues) Rs 200; for two years (20 issues)
Rs 375. Foreign subscription rates: Seamail for
one year Rs 375/US $ 14/UK £ 9; for two
years Rs 700/US $ 23/UK £ 15 (please allow
six months or more for delivery from the time
of publication). Airmail for one year
Rs 700/US $ 23/UK £ 15 (for Pakistan,
Indian Rs 500); for two years, Rs 1,300/US $43/
UK £ 27 (for Pakistan, Indian Rs 950).
For Indian upcountry cheques add Rs 10 for
bank charges; for US cheques add $ 5;
for UK cheques add £ 3. Cheques and drafts
are to be drawn in favor of Parsiana and posted
to GPO Box 892, Bombay 400001.
IREADERS' FORUM
¦ariWBSiJIOU
Readers’ views are welcome on any subject
of interest to the community and should
be sent to the Editor, Readers’ Forum,
Parsiana, G.P.O. Box 892, Bombay 400001.
Letters are subject to editing for reasons of
space and clarity. Unsigned letters or those
without an address will not be published.
Zarthushti entrepreneurs
I am glad to read that the Federation of
Zoroastrian Associations of North America
(FEZANA), in its special supplement, has
highlighted the strides made by the first
generation of Zarthushtis in various busi
nesses in North America.
I thank Parsiana for bringing to the
notice of its readers and devoting its entire
issue of January 1996, released very recen
tly, to the achievements of these entrepre
neurs.
When we were young, we often used to
hear our elders state “Apra bap dadao
dario dohwta hatha (Our forefathers sailed
many an ocean). ” Implicit was the fact that
Zarthushtis stuck to honesty, integrity, cha
rity and hard work, ingrained in them even
as they traded in far-off lands. I am heart
ened to find the practice alive among North
American Zarthushti entrepreneurs.
May these ladies and gentlemen flour
ish and prosper. And may they never forget
to come to die succor of the less fortunate
and needy members of their community,
wherever they may be.
BHIKHAJI M. ADENWALLA
“‘Ubha’ Parsi”
This is in connection with Bhikhaji M.
Adenwalla ’s letter “‘Ubha ’ Parsi, ” Read
ers ’ Forum (Parsiana, November 1995). I
don ’t know whose picture you have printed
alongside. It certainly is, not of my great
greatgrandfather ‘Ubha ’ or ‘KhadaParsi! ’
What you have printed about Manockjee
Cursetjee under the title ‘The Editor re
plies ’ is correct; but Manockjee Cursetjee,
was the son of ‘Ubha ’ or ‘Khada ’ Parsi —
Seth Karsetji Manekji Shroff, bora 1762, a
sethia of the Parsi Punchayet, a contractor
to the Government of Bombay who did a
lot for his community.
So his son, Manockjee Cursetjee, and
some other friends and admirers presented
the bronze, imposing statue of Seth Karsetji
Manekji Shroff to the then municipality to
be installed at the junction of Bellasis,
Ripon and Clare Roads (near Nagpada).
About Manockjee Cursetjee, you have
omitted to mention that he was twice Sher
iff of Bombay in 1856 and again in 1863.
Maybe you were also unaware of the fact
that Manockjee Cursetjee was not only the
first Parsi, but the first Indian to become
Chief Judge of the Small Causes Court at
Bombay. It used to irk the then British
advocates to plead their cases in front of
him. But he was much respected: a just,
upright, farseeing man of impeccable char
acter and integrity.
As to the question of the protruding
‘kathli, ’ sticking out of the back of his
pugree, the explanation is as follows:
There was no kathli at the back of his
pugree but there was a protruding spout.
My grandfather Cursetjee Manockjee Cur
setjee (generally known as CMC) had ex
plained to me that as the statue was origi
nally copied from a fountain of The Three
Graces dancing on top of a tall column, the
sculptor had provided a spout. But it would
have looked pretty odd for water to gush
out of the back of the venerable gentleman ’ s
pugree, and Manockjee had it blocked. It
could not be removed, so there it stayed!
However, in the good old days, when
water was plentiful and Bombay was in
deed beautiful, water did gush from the
large conch shells, held in the hands of the
ornamental mermaids at the foot of the
statue, into a surrounding trough from
which thirsty Victoria-garee (horse car
riages) horses used to drink on a hot
summer ’s day.
This statue was shifted from its original
place where it had stood for 70 years, to its
present, commanding site at the comer of
Byculla Bridge (a stone ’s throw away from
where his son Manockjee used to reside at
Villa Byculla). It was kept in the municipal
workshop at the corner of Foras Road for
cleaning before it was reinstalled. I used to
visit the place with my grandfather, CMC.
It was rubbed over with oil and cleaned
before it was reinstalled where it stands
today, minus the water trough which would
have occupied too much space at this busy
junction. Anyway, there were fewer horse-
drawn carriages and bullock carts by then.
Ms PERIN M. R. B. JEEJEEBHOY
krnavaz Mama replies
Parsiana goofed! The photo published on
page 4 (Parsiana, November 1995) is that
of Maneckjee Rusj^mjee (1815-1891), the
first Indian sheriff of Calcutta.
“The Priests’ Rebuttal”
Must we continue to accept the disrespect
shown to our priesthood? When was the
last time any of us went up to our serving
mobeds, dasturs or wada dasturji sahebs
and said: Thank you?
‘‘Thank you for not becoming a doctor
or a banker and for dedicating your life to
serving our community and Ahura Mazda!
“For working long and tiresome hours
for very little reward, and keeping our
places of worship open and our sacred fires
burning day and night.
“For performing our ceremonies —
navjotes and jashans, weddings and funer
als — and allowing us to witness and ex
perience our customs and rituals.
“Thank you for keeping Zarathu-
shtrianism alive! ”
For those of you who have and continue
to do so — I say no more! For those of you
who don ’t... stop to think!
It is very easy for us to ‘crucify ’ those
who stand for something and have to make
important decisions (“The Priests ’ Rebut
tal, ” Parsiana, October, 1995). Time and
time again, history shows that those who
stand up to lead have to bear the burden of
all the indignation people throw at them —
never any reward. For the selfless and non
glory seeking leaders, this is unjust!
I personally wish to say that our wada
*
2 Parsiamt A\pnl 1996
I
«' , decision to implement the Fasli calendar
March 1993 and September 1995). Even will be taken either at the Sixth World
dasturji sahebs, like the very few who do June 1992, September 1992, January 1993,
the true work for our community, are vic- I' ‘ / ’ " ?
tims of a sad clan of ‘stone-throwers ’ in our two panels under topics III and VIII at the Zoroastrian Congress to be hosted by the
community. They are forced into very
unfair comers to make decisions that most
of us haven ’t even the capacity to compre
hend — although I am sure many may
think they do!
They are not corrupt officials amassing Parsi Punchayet (BPP) have become para
Fifth World Zoroastrian Congress held in Zarthoshtian Anjuman at Tehran, Iran from
Bombay, January 3 to 7,1990 had recom- June 19 to 22, 1996 or at the Seventh
mended the adoption of the Fasli calendar World Zoroastrian Congress to be hosted
with Jamshedi Navroze on March 21 every by the Federation of Zoroastrian Associa-
year.ButtilldatethetrusteesoftheBombay tions of North America (FEZANA) at
Houston, USA while the BPP trustees will
bundles of wealth by abusing the system; lyzed on this issue because the high priests be left mute spectators to the event, victims
they are not unscrupulous officials schem- of Bombay have not reconciled themselves to the whims and fancies of the priests,
ing to close down our places of worship; to the change-over on some flimsy grounds Dr p. d. sunavala
they are not hungry for ‘I did it ’ awards, for of the difficulty of reciting the mah and the
fickle praise and glory ; they have not roj on the varsi (prayers on the first death Allow me the privilege of your columns to
worked so hard and dedicated so much of anniversary) for a person who dies on a respond to Hoshung S. Kotval ’s hand-
their lives just to destroy all that they leap year day. The priests seem to forget wringing on leap-year day (“Leap year
uphold! that the heavens are not going to fall if the day? ” Readers ’ Forum, Parsiana, Septem-
They are our priests, with a very high varsi is held a day later or earlier. The ber 1995). But firstly, a firm rap on your
caliber of religious and spiritual acumen priests should also know that the Fasli editorial knuckles for letting slip for the
and they are human beings too, in case
anyone has forgotten!
So, isn ’t it time we did something a bit
more constructive? Rather than sensation- pitious for the change-over to the Fasli ing a Zoroastrian parallel to the Gregorian
alizing abstract cases that, to my mind, calendar for during these four years, universal calendar. If this was denied all
will never shake the core ethos of our ex- Hormuzd roj fell on March 21, for all the forward-looking Zoroastrians on the feeble
istence and our tradition, can we look to three calendars viz. Shehenshahi, Kadmi ground of “controversiality, ” it must be
the things that matter: direct ourselves to
wards the issues that need to be addressed? lost because of the apathy of the priests.
For example, our youth need education
to appreciate our documented history and calendars are basically faulty because they
culture, they need to meet and form re- account for only 365 days in a year, whereas
lationships, they need to be housed, they the true solar or tropical year (the period outlook and renown,
need help to start businesses and successful the planet Earth takes to make one com-
careers to prosper. They need to feel proud plete revolution round the Sun) comprises
to be Zoroastrian, they need to feel they of 365.2422454 days or 365 days, five door is now being opened — though ever
belong! hours, 48 minutes and 45.5 seconds. Thus so slightly — for his “more rational and
scientific reasoning? ” If so, then for the
benefit of genuinely interested readers we
are in a position to offer some re-workings
from earlier articles on the unified calen-
four years, and ignoring the leap year dar which had appeared variously in The
calendar is working effectively in Iran and past four years a sound opportunity for
the neighboring Central Asian republics. placing before your thinking readership
The years 1992 to 1995 were very pro- the facts about and the desirability of adopt-
pitious for the change-over to the Fasli
calendar for during these four years,
Hormuzd roj fell on March 21, for all the
and Fasli but the golden opportunity was straightaway pointed out that every issue
confronting our communities world-wide
The present Shehenshahi and Kadmi has been hurriedly and irresponsibly shel
ved as controversial! No kudos, therefore,
to a progressive journal of'^nternational
hours, 48 minutes and 45.5 seconds. Thus
the Shehenshahi and Kadmi calendars fall
<
•<
Would publication of Mr Kotval ’s letter
be Parsiana’s way of signalling that the
4'
*
Members of other communities help
each other and make sure their future is behind by 0.2422454 days every year. This
looked after. They are united in thought mismatch is overcome in the Fasli calen-
and united in faith. Their pride is their darby adding one extra leap year day every
motivation!
We need to create the atmosphere for additional day every 100 years, but adding Bombay Samachar, Hamazor and the
our young and old to know, love and again the extra leap year day every 400 FEZANA Journal. Progressive and
understand the beauty of living a good years, ignoring a leap year every 4,000 unificatory views there were counteracted
Zarathushti life; to address the issues that years and again ignoring a leap year every by proponents of the op-action-no-change
matter.
By insulting our priesthood we are dam
aging our religion and damaging ourselves. plain how the matching is carried out:
We are not being threatened by persecu
tion, dilution or extinction. Our ignorance
and our neglect to do something good and
creative for our community, especially our
youth, are our real ememies.
FARHAD D. SETHNA
Harrow, U.K.
200,000 years as is done in the Gregorian lobby whose long-term interest, as always,
calendar. The following mathematics ex- was to suppress verifiably accurate infor
mation based on both our prayers as well as
0.2422454 religio-encyclopaedic texts. Refusal to put
= (1/4-1/100+ 1/400-1/4000-1/200000) into action the very precepts of our emptily
= (0.2500000 - 0.0100000 + 0.0025000
- 0.0002500 - 0.0000050)
All the seasons of the year, viz, spring,
summer, autumn, winter and monsoon as
well as all biological rhythms or circadian dars miss the necessary quadrennial inter
clocks in nature follow the solar or tropical calation to maintain them in synchrony
“Leap year day?” year whether the variations are diurnal with the seasons and the rest of die world.
Over the last five years, various parties (daily) or annual (yearly), whereas our These so-called calendars drift back
including myself have expressed in your existing Shehenshahi and Kadmi calen- steadily; like rudderless ships they are
magazine the need and importance of dars have absolutely no relevance to the unable to cope with currents, winds, tides
changing over to the Fasli calendar seasons. and points of the compass! The analogy
{Parsiana, November 1991, February 1992, It now appears to me that the final with a slow-running watch which can never
mouthed prayers has resulted in our rituals
and commemorative prayers still being
out of step with the seasons.
Both Shehenshahi and Kadmi calen-
4 Parsiana April 1996
seasons.
It now appears to me that the final
Itell the correct time may make our point
clearer: one either gets it repaired or dis
penses with it. In calendrical terms, one
either intercalates it in accordance with the
universally accepted Gregorian system, or
one rejects it in favor of a religiously
inculcated system, i.e. the so-called Fasli.
For those ritually inclined, it can only
be fair to indicate that the gah Rapithwan
has become so displaced that it is being
largely observed when it should not, and
vice versa! If, as they would have us be
lieve, our prayers are so sacred that they
can only be truly effective at the reli
giously appropriate periods, then the ritu
alists have a great deal of explaining to do
to justify such untimely recitation.
The emotive issue of the fravardegan
was cynically brought up, doubtless to
promote the fears of the less educated
against those favorite bugbears — the lib
erals, the reformers and similar disturbers ___________________
ofthetraditional (time-honored, of course!) seeming push-pull adjustment, may
was whispered, suppress any number of
days in their calendar at any time, just as
they had 10 days in 1582! The fact is it was
a one-off move made to prevent a huge
drift in seasonal time-reckoning. For the
rest of foreseeable human history it was to try to convince its ecclesiastical and secu-
be regulated along very careful rules:
•Each year whose (full) number is divis
ible by four is a leap year and one day is to
be added to the shortest month of Febru
ary. _
•The exception to the above is that the last December should refer to theTewnth"
2200...) becomes a leap year only if the lively, but these they plainly do
century number (= 20, 21, 22...) is divis- ................. '
ibie by four.
•To account for the minutes excesses (11 perfected a working time-reckoner at least
minutes 48 seconds per year, or one day in 600 years before the westerners awoke to
128 years), the years 4(X)0, 8000, 12000 the imperfection of their annual observa-
and 16000 are to be common or non-Ieap tions and festivals; it may sadden him in
years. The year 2000 will be leap. advance were he to know that when their
To forestall Mr Kotval ’ s protests at this 10 days were suppressed, the ignorant ma-
, _„i. -J rioted throughout, being given to
believe by opportunists and bigots that
their lives were being shortened by hor
rible reformists who, yes, existed even in
•the unevenness of the months,
•the quite meaningless beginning of its
year on January 1 — speaking sun and
season-wise (that date should be on its
March 21, but foolhardy the one who would
lar authorities!),
•the caprice of its religious year with its
fixed Christmas and a floating Easter and
associated feasts!
•erroneous month names — September to
centu^ (i.e. 2000, 2100, eighth, ninth and tenth monthsTespec-
> not.
What might gladden Mr kotval ’s heart
is that our wise priesthood of yore had
and 16000 are to be common or non-Ieap
order. Little could they let on that their point out that these rules allow for an'
pious prayers were being offered up seven
months after their true time of commemo
ration, but the lie had to persist.
Another ploy was to “expose ” the falla
cious Gregorian system by dint of falsifi
cation: those crafty westerners could, it
pious prayers were being offered up seven
we
error
of one mere day in 3323 years. Having,
however, indicated the sagacity of the _______ ___,
Gregorian system solely with regard to its the 16th century of our Common Era.
quadrennial intercalation, we are con
strained to present its eccentricities which
our Zoroastrian calendars do not share:
But let us got become unduly compla
cent — who among us can explain the six-
day discrepancy in the 40-day reckoning
MATCH YOUR AMBITION TO A CAREER
To do so we offer you:
O Diploma Course in Business Management (Postal) (IMC)
O Executive Secretarial Course
O Private Secretarial Course
Personal Assistant ’s Programme (Working Stenographers)
O Shorthancd & Typewriting (English/Hindi/Marathi)
Telephone Operating & Receptionist Techniques
Electronic Telex Operating
O Electronic Typewriting & Word Processing
< English Conversation & Writing Skills
LATEST ADDITION: COMPUTERS
*
Enquire at:
Sir J. J. College of Commerce
14, Nanabhoy Lane, Hutatma Chowk
Bombay 400001 Tel: 2871058
6 Parsiana April 1996
I
«of our Prophet ’s day of birth and his death welcome, the government had made elabo- obtained from any individual during his
[Our Zarathushtra was said to have lived rate arrangements, but Gandhiji and Moha- professional career, as fees for the physical
for 77 years and 40 days. If his birth was, mmed Ali Jinnah of the Khilafat movement
as agreed by tradition, on Hormazd roj, hadjoined hands and appealed to the people
FravardinmaZi, only then does the 40th day to boycott the reception and not go to the
(his death) fall on Khwar roj of Ardi-
behesht mah. If we observe his birth on
Khordad Sal, i.e. on Khordad roj of Fra-
vardin mah, then the 40 days do not add fused to comply, and went to the docks to
up]; also, who can satisfactorily explain
the real significance of the order of our
Zoroastrian months? Muslim mob and our small community. Parsiana arrives regularly and is read with
Last but one, who can convincingly Many Parsis and their homes, and perhaps much interest. The low level of subscribers
explain why Mr Kotval ’s “well-educated, our fire-temples, suffered from their at- noted in your subscription appeal is not
enlightened, rational and scientifically in- tacks, and, thereafter, a huge mob passed necessarily due to dwindling numbers but
dined ” Parsis remain the most religiously through the narrow streets of the city and
backward of such communities, and why advanced towards Crawford Market where
our self-elected “policemen ” do nothing
about it? Lastly, who will excommunicate
our ever-ready excommunicators?
FARROKH VAJIFDAR
London, U.K.
harbor to welcome him.
All Hindus and Muslims followed these
commands. But the Parsi community re
treatment he gave to the Parsi magnate. It
was therefore but natural that he had a soft
corner for the Parsis, whom he called ‘one
of the most remarkable people I have come
across in all my travels. ’”
receive him. This was followed by a most
serious riot between the combined Hindu- Whither, PorSUina 1
Muslim mob and our small community.
F. K. DADACHANJl
Karachi
to the apathy of community members.
NOSMIRN.DASTUR
Bangalore
were located a number of shops of Parsi
wine-merchants, and other Parsi proper
ties. Had this situation been allowed to Much as I would like to renew my sub
continue, hundreds of Parsi lives and homes scription to Parsiana, I have decided
would have been in danger. against it, the reason being that with mad-
At this point. Sir Dhunjibhoy, being dening regularity the issues reach us three
“Late Dnunjisha Kalian” quite influential in the police department.
In Parsiana (Readers ’ Forum, September procured arms and ammunition for the
1995) I find a letter written by Mr Bhikhaji Parsi shopkeepers who bravely faced the such old news. It is just looked through and
‘ , goes straight into the raddi paper lot. This
firing blindly. is the only magazine which gives news
Fortunately, the mob was carrying no about Parsis, but when you read about
arms, so the Parsis, though small in num- things and happenings that took place
ber, succeeded in stalling their advance till months ago it doesn ’t stand\o reason.
If issues within the city are not received
on time, how can one even suggest gifting
it to anyone else within the country let
alone abroad? Would you please ensure
that future issues are received by the read
ers during the current month and not three
months later? Ms r. a. vaadoliwala
!»»
months too late!
The reading makes no sense when it is
M. Adenwalla soliciting details about the onslaught of the mob for over an hour,
late Dhunjisha Kalfati.
I am surprised that the people of Bombay
are so ignorant about their own great man
whose real name was (Sir) Dhunjibhoy
Bomanji —Kalfati (Kt), and not Dhunjisha; the arrival of the British troops dispersed
and I, sitting in Karachi, am supplying the hostile crowd,
information as requested by the letter writer.
Sir Dhunjibhoy Bomanji was a Steve- act of his, and the yearly jashan ceremony
dore —never a “Commissioner of Police ” ——p------ > — j—•
— and by sheer hard work he made a
fortune. He moved about in a Rolls Royce,
had a European chauffeur, and was very jubilee souvenir of Stri Zarthosti Mandal
influential with the high officials of the notes, “It was at the special invitation of The Editor replies
British government, including those in the the late Sir Dhunjibhoy Bomanji, Kt. that No one is more perturbed abontParsiana ’s
police department. Eugene Sandow (1867-1925), the Samson publishing delays than the publication ’s
In 1921, the Prince of Wales — later to of the last generation, paid a visit to this proprietors and staff. Financial stringency
become the Duke of Windsor — waspay- 1 ’’ ” ..................... -
ing an official visit. To give him a rousing patron a large sum, the largest he had ever
Sir Dhunjibhoy is remembered for this
continues to be performed to this day.
An article on Eugene Sandow by J. R.
B. Jeejeebhoy appearing in the golden
*
land in 1904/1905. He received from his adds to the constraints of a very small
editorial team, leading to bottlenecks.
Keeping our readers and subscribers in
mind, we try to ensure that we include
whatever is newsworthy at the time of
going to press, irrespective of the issue ’s
month-line viz the December ’95 issue
included coverage of the BPP press con
ference of February 12, 1996 on the pros
pective Iran Congress.
You many wonder why we do not em
ploy more editorial staff. The reason is that
our small specialized publication needs
Parsis to understand the nuances of the
community and the religion. Talented ones
prefer mainstream journalism which of
fers wider avenues for career growth.
22 Carat Guaranteed Gold
KUMAR JEWELLERS
House of Gold, Silver & Diamond Jewellery
Specialist for: Asho Farohar & Lord Zarathushtra
Medals in Gold and Silver
596, Chira Bazar, Near Wadia Fire Temple, Bombay 400002
Tel: 2017707/201J1894
We buy old Gold, Silver and Diamond Jewellery
We accept Master, Visa, Diners, BOB & Inter cards
Edited by Arnavaz S. Mama
8 Parsiana April 1996
IEvents and
Personalities
Sanjan stambh’s 75
For the 500-odd Zoroastrians assembled
for the platinum jubilee celebrations of the
Sanjan stambh (memorial column) on
November 22, 1995, there was little to
distinguish this Sanjan Day (traditionally
celebrated on roj Bahman, mah Tir) from
the last. Or the ones held earlier. A loosely
strung cloth banner that announced the
jubilee, in its own cynical way drove the
point home further of a momentous occa- ||
sion for celebration and consolidation be
ing lost. If anything was achieved, it was
the platform the occasion provided to
launch newly elected Bombay Parsi
Punchayet (BPP) trustee Rustom Tirandaz
to the community, and permit veteran
serving trustee Jamshed Guzder to
announce his willingness to stand for re-
election in the forthcoming hustings.
Guzder, as Sanjan Day Celebrations
Committee president Rohintan Daviervala IH
reminded the gathering, has always graced Sanjan stambh: momentous occasion
the function “since ’91, if in the country, ”
and had made it to this year ’s celebration
too “cancelling all his other appointments. ”
After the traditional jashan ceremony
Dastur Kaikobad Firozi of Udvada gave a
clarion call to the community to live peace- judgement of 1908. Guzder ’s pronounce-
fully in cohesion (“samp vadhaare aave“),
discussing matters of conflict amicably
¦
tri
'J «
¦IjRS.
' ' 1
IfsiS
I '
a?
service every day for the community... We
stayed in colonies, not just for marriage, ”
said Tirandaz, raising a hearty laugh, “but
to help one another. ” He suggested that
colony residents who are now consider
ably well-off put aside some money for
community welfare in fixed deposits, let
ting the weaker sections use at least the
'' interest from it (while retaining the amount
themselves) tq^further their means. “Noth
ing can be achieved without saath (togeth-
j emess) or sahakar (cooperatibn), ” he re
minded the gathering repeatedly, citing
j his own example of setting up an electro-
I plating business with a small venture capital
I provided by friends and well-wishers.
I Tirandaz further asked the community
I to participate in a computerized census
I initiated by him. “I’ll bear the full cost of
I this community database, ” he announced,
I requesting assistance from people to gather
I data from their mohallas (areas) and vil-
I lages, so as to arrive at an actual figure and
break-up of the community ’s population.
(Forms for the census as devised by
Tirandaz may be obtained from him by
writing to P.O. Box 5514, Dadar, Bombay
*
born of Parsi mothers married to non-
Zoroastrian fathers. Guzder ’s belief was
that this debarment was not in our "dharam"
(religion) but a result of the Daver-Beaman 400014.) **
The amrit mahotsav (platinum jubilee
celebrations) may have lacked the glitz
and glamor that was expected of it by some
and rising"above in-fighting. Guzder in his the orthodox view ” had the gathering sections of the community. Former mem
address to the community informed that in equally bewildered and a fair section smol- ber of the Government of India ’s Minori-
response to his scheme of the BPP subsi
dizing the third child in a family (an
nounced from this very platform two win- man, a member of the organizing commit
ters ago) “only 12 girls had come forward '
to claim the benefits. ” At this rate, rea
soned Guzder, the community ’s popula
tion would decrease to just 22,000 in an
other 25 years time, “and we would no
longer be called a community, but a tribe. ”
In response to queries raised, Guzder
announced his intentions in his re-elected
term to accept in the community children
ments on adoption law, and promise to
“change things there, but keeping in mind
equally bewildered and a fair section smol
dering too. Strongly chastizing the lady tiesCommissionHomiTaleyarkhan,retir-
who raised these points with the BPP chair- ing BPP chairman Eruch Desai, amongst
others regretted they could not attend,
despite promising to do so in communica- tee thundered, “This is not the platform, ”
and brought out the garlands hurriedly. It tions released earlier by ±e Committee to
was only by negating the call for lunch that
Daviervala managed to speak his few
words, or read out the messages received.
In his address to the gathering Tirandaz Tirandaz ’s exhortations find fruit, the 75th
had called for a commitment to service. “If commemoration day of the Sanjan stambh
you cannot give money, give of yourself, ” could signal a new coming in the commu-
he beseeched. “Provide at least an hour ’s nity. Homij.Rogers
the community. There was no entertain
ment, or even a sense of history breathed
into the function. Yet, if even a part of
10 Parsiana April 1996Boost for self-starters
Sixty-one more Zoroastrians seeking fi
nancial assistance to start their own .enter
prising ventures and thereby become self Roodi Savaar, Sad Hojo and ended it with under the songs are all about. This welcome
employed will receive Rs 1,11,35,000 Dafey, Dafey, Dafey. Both these are incor- effort is published by Giara, Dhunmai
through the offices of The WZO (World porated in the booklet. But then those were Building, 667, Lady Jehangir Road,
Zoroastrian Organisation) Trust Funds, the halcyon days when children, teenagers Bombay 400014. Adi Doctor
informs a press release issued by chairman
Dinshaw Tamboly. These funds have been
made available to The WZO Trust Funds
which screens the applications and for
wards the requests to the donors — a
Zoroastrian trust in the memory of Bai
Maneckbai and Seth Pirojshaw Bomanjee composed by Parsi lyricists like Firoze R.
Jeejeebhoy, acknowledges Tamboly. Batliwalla and Jehangir Desai, and set to
Applicants from Aanand and memorable tunes by VistaspBulsara, Kersy
Ahmedabad to Valsad and Vangaon, spread Mistry and others,
over 16 different urban, semi urban and
rural areas of India will benefit through
this project which extends interest-free
loans. The maximum number of be
neficiaries, 40, seek to establish themselves for posterity these already-forgotten songs.
” He also rightly exhorts the major Parsi
libraries, like the K. R. Cama and the J. N. Fascination for floWCrS
Petit in Bombay and the Meherjirana in “Flowers have a special place in my heart...
Navsari, to collect such songs so that they (reflecting) creation in its full splendor and
glory, ” mentioned Ms Hutoxi H. Madon in
a press releasdraccompanying the invite to
As Giara himself says in his introduc
tion, in his childhood days, Parsi schools
began ±eir day, among other things, with know what the various ragas mentioned
sette, it’s a moot point how many will be
able to sing these songs. They need to
the halcyon days when children, teenagers Bombay 400014.
and even the elderly, sang with gusto,
songs in honor of Ahura Mazda or those Marshall’s gold shot
praising Lord Zarathushtra. There were At the 39th National Shooting Champion-
the popular numbers too like Jaya ship Competition, winning a gold in the
Jarthosht, Nabee-o-na NabeeAmar, Amari
Deen Jarthoshti, etc., many of which were
veterans category was Darius Marshall of
Calicut. He scored 80 percent in the .22,50
meters free rifle prone position event, notes
a press release.
This competition was hosted by the
Coimbatore Rifle Club in the first week of
It is in this context that this anthology is September 1995. Marshall, who repre
sented the Kerala state from the Calicut
Rifle Club, informs that in his tally of
medals this is the fourth gold apart from
the two silver he has secured so far.
to be particularly welcomed. Giara has
indeed rendered a great service to the
community in collecting and preserving
in transport related activities. Engineering
workshops and computer centers are the
other fields to be pursued by 10 applicants.
Manufacturing and trading activities will
see four new Zoroastrians on the scene.
The other enterprising individuals want to
introduce provision stores, cold storage beginning with songs in honor of Ahura her exhibition of water colors and glow
facilities, cable TV network, watch repair Mazda and ending with “Parsee Gayano. ” glass at the ANZ Grindlays Bank from
establishment, pathology
laboratory, export of handicrafts,
improved farming inputs.
The 41 Zoroastrians helped
last year “have not only been
gainfully self employed, but have ]
begun to make repayment as per |
schedules drawn up, ” notes the
release. To accelerate their
screening process, the WZO has
requested prospective candidates
to furnish details of their back
ground, financial resources
available, field of self-employ
ment, funds required, realistic
pay-back schedules and other
relevant particulars. Individuals
seeking to diversify their existing business Marshall: veteran takes aim
or disinvest their own funds will not receive
any priority, clarify the WZO officials.
are not lost for good.
The book is divided into six sections.
•'i
b'
¦SB
|l|l
¦
¦
¦
¦
B /
ill
I
®l
In between you have monajats, both Per-
sian (including that indispensable one in
The torgotten songs honor of the Prophet of Prophets, Nabee-e-
Last Pateti, the indefatigable Marzban J. bahaq morsele ba kitab... by the late Mulla
Giara brought out yet another booklet in
Gujarati. This time, an anthology of Zoro
astrian devotional son^sjarthoshti Gayan
Sangrah (Bhakti Geeto), most of which
have long been forgotten. These used to be
sung in Parsi homes in the good old days
when the chief source of entertainment being in Gujarati, is out of bounds for most
was the gramophone (or better still, the
phonograph).
12 Parsiana April 1996
October 24 to November 4,1995.
Preferring to use flowers as the
- theme of her paintings, she adds,
“It offers the greatest challenge ’'
------ of color besides being a feast to
" the eyes. ’’Ofthe 40 odd paintings
— on display, 70 percent were sold.
*
informs the artist.
Chinese landscapes and
oriental flowers also captivate
the 44-year-old artist who paints
abstracts and landscapes too,
stating, “There ’s never an end to
how vivid one ’s imagination can
run especially when it comes to
planning the color schemes. ’’
Before she became a full-time
artist Madon had perforce to work for two
decades as a stenographer with Bayer,
devoting time to painting only in her free
hours. The untimely demise of her father
Jamshed K. Panthaki, when she was 18
years of age, shattered her dreams of join
ing an art college as she now had to assume
Firoz bin Kaus — strangely, only half of it
has been published!) and Gujarati prayer the role of breadwinner for her family,
songs, songs pertaining to Prophet Following her schooling at the J. B.Vachha
Zarathushtra, etc. High School for Parsi Girls in Dadar, she
There are only two drawbacks, which opted for a correspondence course in
Giara possibly couldn ’t help: the book, psychology to complete her graduation
----- 1 from the Bombay University. The self-
of our youth; secondly, unless the book is taught artist who began with a Walter
’- - FosterPublication,//owroDraH'ant/Pain/,
accompanied by the relevant musical cas-w
t:«ri ,
I
I
9
L
s
1
has since acquired a personal library of
books on painting that have helped to tutor
her. Another gift that she treasured
immensely and which boosted her
enthusiasm for art were the Windsor and
Neuter oil paints gifted by her father who
used to do etching on glass as a hobby.
Before this exhibition Madon had dis
played her works in some shops and bou
tiques that earned her the necessary confi
dence to display her works. For the future
she plans to continue with her chosen
themes believing painting helps man to
discover himself “both personally and ar
tistically and, in its highest form, (is) an
expression of freedom and an enrichment
of one ’s soul. ”
"nS-"
'(
F
¦
¦
meets too have their Group members par
ticipated, as detailed in the historical ac
count of their activities. A unique distinc
tion accorded to the Group was in the year
1938 when the chief scout of the world.
Lord Baden Powell visited India. The
youngest cub of The 15th East Bombay
Marzban Scout Group led the grand howl
and garlanded the dignitary.
It was at the instance of Kaikobad
Marzban, one of the founders and princi-
Madon with her paintings
pals of the New High School, that The 15th
Bombay Scout Troop was started in 1921
after he came in contact with B. T. Char,
provincial commissioner, scouts, Mysore
state. Among those involved in laying a
firm foundation for the Group were A. B.
Homavazir, Phiroze Lally, Rustom Talati
and M. C. Mafhiudar. On Marzban ’s de
mise in 1933 the Group was renamed the
15th Bombay Marzban ScQut Group.
Among their scouters
cou
10 went on to
75 years and ever new
“We take pride in the fact that over a
period of 75 years our group has partici
pated in all the national and state jambo
rees, ” notes a write-up in the souvenir
published on the platinum jubilee occa
sion of The 15th East Bombay Marzban
Scout Group. To mark their anniversary
year, the Group presented a play Satam
Atham on December 30, 1995 when the
chairman and managing director of REPL
Engineering Ltd, Homi Patel, was the chief
guest.
Guided by their motto “Ever new, ” the
Group invariably participates in the vari
ous activities organized by the district -
association — inter-pack and inter-troop
efficiency competitions, on-the-spot draw
ing competition for cubs and scouts, ad
venture awards, camporees, athletics,
games, aquatic sports, elocution competi
tions and Ambulance Cup, mentions the
article.
At international jamborees and rover
b
‘
I'- -
1
t
1 '
F
L
13 Parsiana ApriH 996
At the All Parsee Bonny Baby Contest organized by the Rustom Baug Association
and sponsored by Wipro on March 17, 1996 are the winners (from left): Meherzad
Dhunbhura who was conferred the rotating trophy and the first prize in the one to
three years category, the most charming baby Anainah Patel, Arzan Balsara who
stood first in the under six months age-group and Baktiyar Patel who won the first
prize in the six to 12 months category. Seated in the front row are the judges (from
left): Dr Sandeep Mehta, Dr Armaity Deboo and Dr Taher Kagalwala with the
convenor Dr Mehercher Chaina
Iwin acclaim for themselves were Dr Homiar
Dastur who was appointed ophthalmic sur
geon to the President of India, Yezdi
Gandevia who became Commonwealth
secretary, ministry of external affairs.
Government of India, plastic surgeon Dr
Bomi (left) and Hormuz Bhaka:
promoting Reza
Sam Mahalaxmivala, district commission
ers (scouts) Minoo Damania and Pesi
Damania... Presently the troop is led by
group leader Behram Dalal with J. R.
Mody serving as cub master.
The crush concern
The best form of publicity is a satisfied and
happy customer and they have no dearth of
them... The best test of any product is its
ability to withstand competition from cheap
and mass produced substitutes and Reza
fruit crushes have stood the test of time for
many decades, maintains Hormuz Bhaka,
the third generation entrepreneur referring
to the family business started by his grand
parents Shavak and Mehroo Bhaka in 1945.
Over the last 50 years it has been run under
different names: In Shavak ’s time the com
pany was Victory Fruit Products and the
products marketed under the brand name
Venus. When his widow Mehroo and son
Bomi ran the business the company name
was S. D. Fruit Products and the brand
name Reza. Since Hormuz ’s inclusioH in
the business, the manufacturing and mar
keting activities have been compartmen
talized with the incorporation of another
company S, D. Marketing Services where
Hormuz and his mother Kety are partners.
The marketing company deals directly
with the customers obtaining useful feed
back about existing and future trends and
consumption patterns. It also gives a clue
to varying consumer tastes by feeling the
pulse of the market and is expected to serve
as an outlet for future diversification into
other products in the retail food busi
ness. This will help the parent company in
offering what the consumer demands.
Their marketing is mainly concentrated
on bulk supply. Grade I restaurants and
deluxe hotels are their major clients, with
Indian Hotels Company Limited (Taj
Group) being one of their most reputed
customers, they inform. However, they
sell through retail outlets too and welcome
direct customer contact, their motto being
“Customer is king. ” Among individual
customers there are loyal ones like one
Parsi lady who gets a couple of jars of fruit
crush delivered every week since years
now, and people coming from as far as
Gorai and Vasai just to pick up a can of
fruit crush for their homes and parties.
Also, many going to Goa, take a can of
crush for their parents and relatives only to
return with a can full of fenny or wine!
Reza fruit crushes are basically fresh
fruit extracts without the use of any syn
thetic elements. Their product range con
sists of fruit crushes (orange, pineapple,
mango and lime), synthetic syrups (rasp
berry and rose) and fruit sauce. The prod
ucts are competitively priced compared to
other brands in the market and have a
standing of their own.
Hormuz, a computer buff, avers that
strict quality control standards are main
tained with every thing under their per
sonal supervision. “Nothing happens with
out our knowledge, ” he says. Purchasing is
done personally by them from a network of
regular suppliers with whom they share an
excellent personal rapport.
Although essentially a family business,
initially Shavak and Mehroo were joined
in the business by their Parsi neighbor ’s
wife who offered to be a sleeping partner.
However, Shavak ’s demise on June 30,
1960, led to the other partner not wishing
to continue in die business with his widow
and the matter went into litigation for four
years until arbitration resulted in a verdict
in Mehroo ’s favor, we are informed.
Ih the meanwhile, on October 1, 1960,
Mehroo had started business afresh.
Equipped with all the knowhow but no
premises, she started operations at a friend ’s
bungalow at Shivaji Park. At that crucial
juncture, she was supported financially
and in every other way by her brothers and
friends. After receiving their share of the
dissolution from the other partner, the
Bhakas — mother Mehroo and son Bomi
(who hadjoined her by then) — purchased
their present premises at Wadala.
Bomi recalls how his wife Kety got
involved in the business. Soon after the
demise of his mother in 1988, Bomi met
with an accident. As soon as he gained
consciousness after an operation, hc called
Kety to his bedside with a paper and pencil.
He proceeded to dictate all the aspects of
running the business from manufacturing
to marketing, and Kety creditably ran the
business single-handedly for four months.
After weathering many a storm their
business has grown from strength to
strength and Reza fruit crushes have
become a name to reckon with.
Villie Daruvala
Compiled by Parinaz Gandhi
MATRIMONIAL
A 35-year-old Parsi physician
from a good family, well settled
in USA, seeks matrimonial
correspondence from well-disposed
Parsi lady professionals (25 to 35
years). Please send bio data with
photograph (returnable) to:
The Advertiser
Parsiana, Matrimonial (Apr/13-96)*
GPO Box 892, Bombay 400001
‘Please make sure the reply envelope
bears the reference number cited here.
MATRIMONIAL'
A 38-year-old bachelor having
own business and accommodation
invites correspondence from slim,
good-looking, cultured, and
domestically trained women.
Apply with recent photograph
(returnable) to:
The Advertiser
Parsiana, Matrimonial (Apr/11-96)*
GPO Box 892, Bombay 400001
‘Please make sure the rfeply envelope
bears the reference number cited here.
4/
Always remember
TATA
I BATA
KHAMBATA
I
¦ \ i
Ketayun & Bomi
22/A, Wellington Terrace
Wellington Street, Bombay 400002
Tel No: 2069636, 2057242
Pager No: 9602-104007
15 Parsiana Aprit 1996ZOROASTRIANS ABROAD
“Surrounded by storytellers” I
The struggle to retain her
minority identity has considerably
influenced the works of Dr Roshni
Rustomji-Kems
Parinaz Gandhi
sity, California. “Being
a teacher and writer
takes the same creative
energy, ” she maintains.
g soning her literary
work. She has also
penned a series of “Par
si stories, ” set against a
J I make-believe town cal-
I led Devinagar. They are
“I think I recognize the voice and the vi
sion... The way women look at the world...
Their language reverberates. ” Dr (Ms)
Roshni Rustomji-Kerns explains her affin
ity for writings authored by members of When she was full-time
her own sex. “To hear what women say and into teaching, she ser-
how they say it; how they use the English ved as coordinator of ' ‘ 4- recollection of her
language, ” is particularly fascinating for the India Studies Program from the BA young days spent partly in Bombay and
Rustomji-Kems, a penperson herself, who course, and had for a while coordinated subsequently in Karachi, of her holidays
took time off from her teaching and writing women ’s studies too. with the family. “Remember, Vwas very
schedule to co-edit Blood into Ink, a book Following Blook into Ink, Rustomji- thoroughly colonized, ” she states. “How
wherein “South Asian and Middle Eastern Kerns edited another anthology Living in do you fight back against colonization?
women write war. ” The pathetic price that America: Fiction and Poetry by South
females have to pay for the bloody battles Asian American Writers, brought out in
waged by males is portrayed through the 1995 by Westview (See “Sheltering against names from Jamshed to Jimmy...”
fiction and poetry presented in this work, the hurt ” on page 38). For the last few mon- To explore how thought processes work
Since Rustomji-Kerns herself would not ths though, she has only been focussing on differently, what can be construed and
write such stories, she was even more her own writing. As contributor to a histori- interpreted at different times, she worked
captivated. And as the co-editors mention cal account of Asian Americans, she will for a while at a Sleep-Dream Laboratory,
in the book, “The hope behind our antho- - - —
logy is that by transfiguring blood into ink south America, giving a first person acco-
and death into discourse, we may survive
beyond war into peace. ” What would
Rustomji-Kerns like to present to her read
ers? “My writing crosses continents, (fea
turing) places, houses, people. They are support received from her husband Charles tions, the enjoyment of being with people
stories heard from my parents, grandpar
ents, friends. I have always been surrounded and helped her make the transition to the
by storytellers. These stories indicate how
people relate or don ’t relate to one another.
Some parts are imagined or come in dre- of Multi Media Library at Stanford Uni- tic circles for Behram was the principal of
ams, ” reveals the author who in the past versity, who has been constantly reminding the Bai Virbaiji Soparivala Parsi High
has seen her short stories published in jour- her to concentrate on her own writing. School in Karachi and the late Gool was a
nals and anthologies in the USA and Cana
da, and is currently finalizing her novel
The Braided Tongue which she hopes will Rustomji-Kern ’s first attempt at writing a
be published soon.
“I wish I had started writing earlier, ”
admits 57-year-old Rustomji-Kerns, pres
ently professor emerita, Hutchins School she explains how her unwillingness to
ofLiberal Studies at Sonoma State Univer- hoard articles could have led to her jetti-
Following Blook into Ink, Rustomji-
How do you retain your identity and yet be
true to yourself? I was very against changing
J
1
17 Parsiana April 1996
the hurt ” on page 38). For the last few mon-
her own writing. As contributor to a histori
cal account of Asian Americans, she will
be focussing on those settled in central and That periods of sleep or quietude can last
for 24 hours was a revelation to Rustomji-
unt of why they migrated, what their journey Kerns who finds stimulation in adventure
was, their encounters with the dominant
community. “Now all my writing is done
on the computer, ” she acknowledges the the respect for people of all denomina-
and new experiences.
The love for books, music and travel.
who in her words is a “big computerwalla ” — all these pleasures she imbibed from her
close family. Her parents, Behram and
Gool Rustomji, well-known in the com computer even though she did not know
typing. It was also Charles, head librarian munity, were respected figures in scholas-
of Multi Media Library at Stanford Uni-
ber to concentrate on her own writing.
The Braided Tongue will be her first Montessori directress of different schools,
novel to be published. But this is not Among their commendable efforts was
the English translation of Dastur M. N.
Dhalla ’s autobiography which has been
serialized in Parsiana.
“Ours was a very simple household full
of books and music. To this day I get
continued on page 40
novel. She had in the past written two
novels but can ’t seem to trace that particu
lar notebook. “I don ’t like to keep things, ”
I
I
IZOROASTRIANS ABROAD
st
Each one of us is a
! ¦
¦
I
PERFECT
INDIVIDUAL”
You must know the constituents of
your body before you can treat it, says
ayurvedic practitioner Mehlli Bhagalia
Arnavaz S. Mama
*
During a brief interview with Parsiana
gifted with his/her ownprakruti (variously on December 29, 1995 Bhagalia had ex
plained how lifestyle and )bod habits work
for health or its detriment. His thesis em-
sea-
sons, the time of day. “Like attracts like, ”
he says, comparing the body to a driveway
where no seeds could take root unless there .
were cracks. Bhagalia theorized that dis
ease could never strike where mind and
body were in harmony with nature and
“A rose does not want to be a daffodil, but (fire), kafa (water and earth). Each one is
we want to be different from what we are, ”
says Mehlli Bhagalia. The co-founder and interpreted as balance, harmony, nature,
co-director of the Ayurveda Institute of because everything in nature is in balance).
Upstate New York (with his wife Perin)
shakes his head ruefully as he reflects on
stout people wanting to be slim, or short
people wanting to be tall, on men who necting link between the body and the
want to be like Robert Redford, or women
who seek to resemble some famous ac
tress. “Each one of us is a perfect individual,
an original masterpiece at the time of
conception when the blueprint is
established, ” he states on the authority of secondary element.
Chanaka, the ayurvedic sage of ancient
India. life ... It teaches us to read the book of life Cold fluids in the cool hours of morning
“Chanaka tells us how one can have a — our own book. If one only reads this one or night increase the build-up of mucus in
happy, healthy baby, ” Bhagalia told host- book, it would enable us to have a happy, the body. To keep colds, coughs, flu in
ess Theresa Cosco on the TV show Insight
(Bhagalia had provided Parsiana with a that is what his Institute is all about. “I try
video cassette of the interview), adding
that classes at his Ayurveda Institute teach for themselves as to who they are ” and
American couples the route to harmony what they should do for themselves (US
before they conceive as also the post- law prevents Bhagalia from prescribing,
conceptual care of the expectant mother — anyway) in an intensive 10-hour program
family happiness would depend on the of four equal sessions. He says he seeks to much heat in the system, skin, blood and
well-being of the infant in and out of the empower them by teaching them to look at
womb, he comments. The dominant ele
ment in the dominant parent would domi- wrong with you, look at your tongue... tis, he told us. The correct dietary principle
nate the child physically and emotionally. Everything below the waist is taboo in involves an evaluation of which is one ’s
he adds.
Dominant element? Quoting the an
cient shastras, Bhagalia says each human
being is a compound of vata (air); peeta
“Without all three elements we couldn ’t phasizes harmony with nature, the
survive, ” he says, neither in our bodies nor
in our mental state. “They form the con-
emotions, ” he explains, because “thought
produces the molecule which translates
into emotion. ” Every human being is domi
nated by a combination of two of the challenges anyone to give him a cold. “I’ll
elements, known as the dominant and the sit in a room full of people with colds and
coughs. I’ll sit and read until the cows
“Ayurveda is the science (or book) of come home, ” he promised Cosco.
life... It teaches us to read the book of life
— our own book. If one only reads this one
contented life, ” Bhagalia told Cosco. And check, we must control the water element
in the system, especially during the cooler
to make them (student-patients) find out hours of the diurnal cycle, he amplifies.
“There are two types of asthma — dry and
wet, ” he told Cosco. “In the first case you
balance with water; in the second you
remove the excess fluid. ” If there is too
eye disorders would result; excess air can
themselves in the mirror, “know what ’s lead to joint and bone disorders like arthri-
wrong with you, look at your tongue...
Westem society, ” he notes, but advises dominant element. Bhagalia identifies
observation of the eliminatory functions
which are a good barometer of the state of
one ’s health.
“alienation from nature ” as the primary
cause of trouble.
Bhagalia distinguishes the ayurvedic
18 Parsiana April 1996
*
I(
i
I
I
I
ohilosophy. of health from the allopatic education in his leisure hours. Since retire-
„ tv t^viutv ment he has been teaching the ayurvedic
The latter is doomed to failure, he path to good health, yoga and meditation
techniques. (“Meditation is not something
you can ‘do; ’ you fall into the state of me
ditation by using certain techniques. Con
centration is not meditation; but it could
be used as a technique be-
yond which you might fall
into meditation. ”) He also
couples
the
ayurvedic
route to
harmony
concern to “isolate germs, conquer dis
ease. ” —--------------
says “because we can ’t conquer the envi
ronment. ” Ayurveda, on the other hand,
seeks not to cure a disease but to remove
it. “Medicine is something that removes
the disorder and removes
itself, leaving only good
health. Allopathy leaves
the original poison and the
medicine ” in the system. In
contrast Bhagalia says that
ayurvedic medicine “toni
fies, metabolizes and remo
ves. ” A basic resource in
the deshi arsenal is trifala
or three fruits: amalaki (a
tonic), bibitaki (an elimi-
natory agent) and haritaki before they
(a metabolizer). But each
plant/stem/bark has an affi
nity to certain areas of the
body, he adds. Anabolic metabolism, he and development (R&D) center (one of the
reminds us, is the normal rebuilding state largest R&D centers in the world, accor-
of the body; catabolic metabolism implies ding to Bhagalia) and teaches a gentle
an excess of adrenalin (the fight or flight form of yoga for older people. Of their
syndrome) produced by stress that leads to three children, the eldest Nilufer (also
premature aging because it robs the body called Shraddha because she trusts in the
of the chance to rebuild. Divine) is married to an Englishman in
It is difficult to accept that Bhagalia New Mexico, speaks Japanese and has
started professional life as a banker. An been a teacher in Alaska and England. The
economics graduate from Bombay ’s St
Xavier ’s College whom the Bank of India
sent on assignment to Ahmedabad, Bha-
conceive
provides massage therapy
to four or five persons a
day as he says he is profi
cient in oriental, ayurve
dic, Japanese and Chinese
systems of massage.
Perin, who had been
executive secretary to the
managing director/chair-
man of Brady/Glaxo in
Bombay, continues as an
administrative assistant in
General Electric ’s research
Investment in
Property:
Pune is the
best city
I
Bhagalias ’ son Zarosh is in electronics sa
les in Syracuse and Zerxes is a third year
computer science student at the State
galia got talldng with a yogi fellow traveller University of New York,
in a bus. Having grown up in Jogeshwari ™
with an academic interest in his uncle Pal-
lonji Bhagalia ’s ayurvedic practice, Bha- state capital Albany, Schenectedy and Troy
galia readily accepted the yogi ’s invitation
to the Sabarmati Ashram where, he says,
people come from distances to learn what
physician Chanaka and surgeon Sushruta
had taught millennia ago.
Pursuing it as a hobby outside of work
ing hours, Bhagalia learnt yoga —
pranayam or the science of breath. “Ev
erything in our Indian sciences is to be
done, not read, ” he avers, explaining that
when you breathe through the right nostril
you are inhaling the male, or sun, energy;
through the left, the moon, or female,
energy; and laughs at our dearly held belief promoting harmony between the home/
that the nose functions as a single entity! business and the natural environment. No
“Change the chemistry in the body by Oriental businessman, large or small, ever
changing the nostril through which you are
breathing, ” he advises.
The Bhagalias had no intention to mi
The Bhagalias are the only Zoroastrian
family in the three city ambit of New York
though there are four to five intermarried
Zoroastrians in the area. At Syracuse there
are about 10 Zoroastrian families, he info
rms. Though the entire area lies within the
purview of the Zoroastrian Association of
Greater New York (ZAGNY), it is only a
rare function at New York ’s La Rochelle
darbe mehr that the Bhagalias say they are
able to attend.
With his penchant for awareness —
“knowing your surroundings ’’ — Bhagalia
has also imbibed the Tibetan Chinese sci
ence and art of Feng Shuai which aims at
starts a business or building construction
without consulting a Feng Shuai practitio
ner, he informs. “I do (these things) on a
grate but a visit to the US in 1978 changed very small scale... It makes me feel good
their perceptions. Mehlli continued there because I’m teaching, (doing) something
as a bank executive, practising ayurvedic worthwhile... ”
19 Parsiana April 1996
We accept bookings in
exclusive schemes in
Pune, like a Bungalow
scheme near the Pashan
Lake, 6 km from Pune
University. It is a small
township consisting of:
17 Independent
Bungalows —
Rs 38 lakhs
4 Twin Bungalows —
Rs 1610 19 lakhs
22 Rowhouses —'
Rs 17 to 39 lakhs
Possession around
March ’96.
Payments by cheque.
We also offer flats (small
and large) at prices
ranging from approx
Rs 900 to Rs 5,000
per sq ft (built-up area),
besides bungalow-plots,
offices and^shops in
exclusive Commercial
Complexes coming up In
Pune. For details write to:
Minoo Bhathena
BySel Estate
302 Devika Apt
2010 Janmohmed Str
Pune 411001
Tel; 650757
*ZOROASTRIANS ABROAD
In and around Manchester
Some of their functions are attended by Cyrus Jokhi. Their committee of three ex-
almost 90 percent of the members. At other
times barely 40 percent are present. In addi
tion to the five or six functions annually every three years as per their constitution,
organized by the North West Zoroastrian The NWZC came into being in 1987 under it be the management of their small
Community (NWZC), the nearly 80 strong the leadership of Prof John Kinnells. Among circulating library or providing transport for
Zoroastrians of Manchester, Blackburn, those who worked very hard to bring about functions, those with facilities invariably
Bradford and Birmingham, located within a this association is Burjor Avari, mentions help out. They dream of having their own
radius of 30 miles, get to meet on other Khambatta. community center but unfortunately the large
occasions too. At anniversaries and social Barring two or three life members — one majority being salaried people, “koi khas
functions of importance invariably all the
Zoroastrian contacts are invited, including Farrokh Engineer — who have contributed
those settled in Newcastle and Leeds, informs
Ms Annu Khambatta who served on the first of them pay £ 5 as their annual membership Sustaining the NWZC for the present is
committee of NWZC. The members of the fee. When they organize functions, the their membership subscriptions and their
nine-year-old association also keep in touch catering for the meals is done by the members fund bottle brought out each time a function
through their three-page newsletter brought themselves to minimize costs . Yet the hiring
out every month. of the hall plus overhead charges necessitate
Despite all their attempts at community collection of £ 6 or more from each person
interaction they find that four or five indi
viduals opt to stay away from the commu
nity. What is of far more concern to the
NWZC is to “try and keep the youth within
the flock, ” points out Khambatta who has
two children in the marriageable age-group.
They organize debates for their young,
encourage them to attend seminars in Lon
don but find that though there is camaraderie from Woolverhampton or Ervad Jal Karkaria,
among them it is difficult to match-make as
these youths, who constitute nearly one-
fourth of the NWZC population, are not in
the appropriate age/sex bracket. “There
should be more communication between rest choose to be cremated. In case of burial,
London (at a distance of 100 miles from the body is interred at London ’s Brookwood
Manchester) and our group, ” observes Cemetery. Irrespective ofthe cause of death,
Khambatta.
Members of their community try to adopt from where it is released after three or four
a neutral stand on community controversies, days. Often by the time the geh sarna is done,
Khambatta gives the details, with many of the chahrum prayers in Bombay or Karachi,
them enrolling as members of both the depending on the country of one ’s origin.
World Zoroastrian Organisation and the would have been completed by the family
Zoroastrian Trust Funds of Europe. To ex
press their solidarity and support towards
setting up a new community center in London have adopted from their new environment is
their members purchase raffle tickets and the‘wake. ’Following a burial or cremation, ciples in an easy-to-understand form — has
participate in their dinner-dance. But the friends and relatives go to the house of the led them to break down each verse into
NWZC constituents are essentially liberal deceased to pay a condolence visit when syllables which even the beginner can recite
in outlook. As per their constitution, non-
Zoroastrian spouses, as also children of chaval. “Everything is very solemn, very
intercommunity marriages, are enrolled but dignified, ” impresses Khambatta. Just as the
without voting rights. They are happy that turnout is good for celebrations, similarly, edged the help of the published translations
there is no Parsi-Irani divide as a cause for '
possible conflict.
In fact the first president of their associa
tion was Taraneh Zomorrody (daughter of first generation migrants, believes
ShahrokhShahrokh) who to this day arranges Khambatta. Khambatta ’s family has been
for the publication of their newsletter from residing in Manchester since 1986 when her
husband Shahariar ’s employers, Ingersoll-
Rand International, posted him there,
ecutive members and four members-at-large, Referring to the community settled in the
one of whom is a youth officer, is rotated area, Khambatta states, “We are a very
unassuming, simple, friendly lot. ” Whether
her printing press. The present chairman is
those who worked very hard to bring about
this association is Burjor Avari, mentions
Barring two or three life members — one
of whom is erstwhile international cricketer paisawalu nathi ke motu donation aape (no
one is so wealthy that the association would
£ 75 as their dues to the association, the rest benefit from large donations), ”
of them pay £ 5 as their annual membership
is held. One member may contribute £ 10,
another a penny. This is their way of ex
pressing their solidarity for a community
cause. Parinaz Gandhi to cover expenses. Currently they are seeking
registration with the government and hope
that some finance will be forthcoming from CIMNA’s Gothtt C3SSCtte
that end. The CounciP of Iranian Mobeds of North
Among their regular functions is a jashan America (CIMNA) has been actively pursu-
organized at least once a year. On such ing the task of educating the Zoroastrian
occasions they have to rely on the services of community in its scriptures and history. Its
Ervad Behram Udvadewalla who is invited regular camps for children have been popu-
lar locally for a number of years. But theii^
felicitous prayer recitation on tape benefit
aft
from London. Just as the priests help out on
auspicious occasions, in the event of a death Zoroastrians all over the world.
too are their services summoned. While
some NWZC members opt for burial, the
The three-cassette compendium of
Khordeh-Avesta prayers initially launched
in 1991 had been well received. The same
team of mobeds — Mehraban Firouzgary of
the melodious voice, Firouz Azargoshasb
a body is invariably taken to the mortuary who provides the translations in English and
Farsi and Fariborz Shahzadi, the compiler
editor — have now produced the Ahuna-
vaiti Gatha on tape. Unlike the Khordeh
Avesta venture,>-the English and Farsi
translations are not spoken but separately
published in an accompanying volume.
The producers ’ objective — to make the
work of Zarathushtra accessible to his dis-
members who have stayed on in the subcon
tinent. A custom the Zoroastrian migrants
they are treated to a simple meal of dar- correctly. A pronunciation guide in English
accompanies the cassette.
In his preface Shahzadi has acknowl-
“when someone dies, the whole community of the Gathas by Dr Iraj Taraporewala and
is there and all help out. ”
Almost all the residents in their area are
Dr T. R. Sethna in providing the background
and explanation to each verse. Moreover he
has tried to capture the essence of each
verse in its title. While the Gathic content
is intact, Shahzadi notes, “It is possible
20 Parsiana April 1996
I¦ Daruwalla has also earned praise and
suitable incumbents from among students thanks for his involvement with The Royal
living in New Rochelle. They are then
trained by the District Attorney ’s office, a
adopts a highly selective process to pick
that the interpretations in this version may
vary from oUier ones. This is because the
Gathas are poetry (hence) the interpreta
tion differs with each audience. ”
The Ahunavaiti Gatha book has been defence lawyer, a judge and the City
British Legion ’s Poppy Appeal — a mode
of fund collection for Britain ’s war veter
ans — from G. W. C. Peacock, chairman of
financed by the family of Meherbanoo Marshall. Upon successful completion of the Wood Green Branch of The Royal
(Zartoshty) Soroushian and Mehrborzin ’ ’
Soroushian. Expenses for the Ahunavaiti
Gatha tape were borne by Mitra and Dr prosecutors and defence attorneys. Pun- Margaret Thatcher. The Legion itself had
Rostom Kavooshi. The package has been ishment for the guilty is meted out in terms
distributed free of charge “because the
words of our Prophet should be available
to all Zarthoshtis regardless of their
financial situation, ” as notes Shahzadi.
More Zoroastrian textbooks and a cor
respondence course on the religion are on
the anvil and financial support is welcome.
Requests/donations may be mailed to The
Council of Iranian Mobeds, P.O. Box position, the first being his sister Kervin. ”
22911, San Diego, CA 92192, USA.
the training they are appointed to serve the British Legion, the chairman of London
Youth Court, taking turns to act as judges, Transport and ex prime minister Ms
conferred upon him a special award in
1991 — a certificate of appreciation — for
21 years of involvement in the Legion ’s
work, as notes the press release. The Appeal
provides for the rehabilitation, training,
employment and welfare services for ex-
servicemen, their widows and families.
“This is a very worthwhile cause and I
should like to join the Legion in thanking
you for all your work, ” MP John Marshall
They are the children of Ervad Shapur had noted in a personal letter to Daruwalla
Doctor of New Rochelle. whose other social service activities in
clude scouting.
of community service and sentences can
range up to 50 hours, notes the write-up.
The Youth Court is said to have led to a
very significant reduction in juvenile crime
in New Rochelle.
Z. M. Zend, who forwarded the news
item to Parsiana, notes, “Jimmy is the
second Parsi Zoroastrian appointed to this
Lion Eric Daruwalla of Hounslow was
privileged to take part in the 50th anniver-
Compiled by Amavaz S. Mama
Serving the Youth Court
Jimmy Doctor was sworn in as a member OrUSSrOOtS inVOlvement
of the Youth Court of New Rochelle by
Mayor Tim Idoni and presented with offi
cial credentials at a special ceremony in sary VE and VJ (the victory of the Allies in
the city’s Court House on February 5, Europe and Japan respectively, which
1996. Following the appointment ceremony ended World War II) day parades in London
Doctor was administered the oath of con
fidentiality by Judge DeLuca in the pres
ence of commissioners of the Youth Bu
reau, members of the legal profession, derground — he is station supervisor at the
police detectives, prominent citizens and Finchley Central Station — Daruwalla has
dignitaries, notes a press release.
The Youth Court of New Rochelle is an
official court under the United Court Sys
tem in the State of New York where first
time juvenile criminal offenders between don Underground is an integral part) is said
the ages of eight and 17 are tried. This to be the only civilian organization permit-
“justice of the youth, for the youth by the ted to march with the armed forces on
youth ” has proved to be very time efficient Remembrance Day — a right conferred by
and decreases the load on the Family Court the royal command of King George V in
in the County of Westchester, informs the recognition of the dedicated busmen who
write-up. drove their buses to the front line in France
The executive board of the Youth Court during World War 1.
last year, notes the Lions Club of
Hounslow ’s newsletter of March 1996. A
long serving member of the London Un-
been a regular part of the annual
Remembrance Day parades at the Ceno
taph, informs the newsletter.
London Transport (of which the Lon-
Gold and silver Lord Zoroaster and
Asho Farohar medals available
Gold, silver and diamond exclusive showroom
We also undertake polishing of ses
594, Chira Bazar, Girgaum Road, Mumbai 400002. Tel: 2065137
We accept Diners, BOB card, American Express,
Taj Premium, Visa & Master Cards.
21 Parsiana April 1996
THE
PARSIANA
BOOK OF
IRANIAN
NAMES
The Iranian names of boys and girls
along with their meanings which
originally appeared in Parsiana have
now been reprinted in an attractive
24-page booklet. T^g book, which is
priced at Rs 25, is available on sale at :
Kaiser-E-Hind, 300 Pehn Nariman
Street, Behind Reserve Bank of India,
Fort, Bombay 400001.
Faredoon and
Burjor Sandalwood Shop,
Princess Street.
Union Press, 13, Homji Street,
\ \ Bombay 400001
*
IHISTORY
The Mahatma on the Parsis
For a miniscule community, the Parsi contribution to the freedom
struggle was remarkable, believed Mahatma Gandhi
Burjor K. Karanjia
to prohibition, which he considered a very
necessary reform: “The liquor shop pick
eting has an intimate relation to Parsis. We
had got had made them seek Government
employment, and it was a great pity. Com
merce had taught them to be honest and
collect money dnd do good to other com
munities in this country. ” Gandhi asked
the Parsis to take stock of the present
conditions and their future, and noted,
Few people may be aware that while many
in the Parsi community were sharply criti
cal of Mahatma Gandhi ’s imposition of
prohibition, particularly because it deprived will have to exercise great forbearance
a large section of the community of their towards our Parsi countrymen. While we
income, Gandhi himself was appreciative cannot stop picketing altogether, we must
of the suffering imposed on the Parsis and meet the liquor dealers in conference, un
willing to discuss the issue with leaders of derstand their difficulties and explain our “They had fully paid their debts to the
the community. This apart, Gandhi was own. Mr Godrej has earmarked his dona- country by producing such great men as
full of praise for the community — for its
philanthropy as well as for its contribution
to various spheres of national life.
Researching recently on material for
the Godrej Story, our attention was drawn
by the eminent Gandhian, Ms Usha Mehta,
to what the Mahatma had to say about the ____ „______________ ______ . ______ ___ ______________________ _________
community in The Collected Works of writes: “When in South Africa the whites in tkic ntr,, tko
Mahatma Gandhi (Vol. 20). In the extract had besieged (my) house in the dead of were they keeping themselves aloof from
below the Mahatma refers specifically to night and wanted to kill (me), it was Parsi the movement now? They were a rich
the donation of three lakh rupees by the Rustomji who had protected (me) at the community, possessing crores of rupees,
pioneer founder of the Godrej enterprise, risk of his life and that of his people and and why had not they given any more
Ardeshir Burjorji Godrej, to the Tilak stood by (me).” As long as Gandhi lived he money to the Fund? Dadabhai had served
Swaraj Fund: “Mr Godrej of safe fame has could never forget what Mr Rustomji had India by leading the life of a political
eclipsed all donations to the Tilak Swaraj done for him. The Parsis were full of recluse for the purpose of making India
Fund with his announcement of three lakhs virtue, truth and honesty, and he was proud
of rupees. His donations to public purposes of them as a race. Even if the Parsis had not
have been hitherto quite unknown. But he collected Rs 30,000 and had only given speak to the Parsis “as their friend because
was induced to appreciate the necessity him Rs 5 he would still have been satisfied he was a great aij^irer of theirs and was
this time of a public announcement. I
tender my congratulations to Mr Godrej him a sum of Rs 3,00,000 and he had
and the whole Parsi community. I wish
also to testify that, during the collection
week in Bombay, not a day has passed publication,
without Parsi donations. Parsi ladies and
gentlemen are also making door-to-door sought government employment, he re
collections. Parsis are also working as
pickets. Among the newspapers, too, not
all the Parsi papers are hostile to the
movement. But Mr Godrej ’s generosity that by coming to India they had not done
puts the Parsis easily first in all India. Parsi
Rustomji ’s Rs 52,000 would in any case were a commercial people, and it was a were true to themselves, they would see
have put the Parsis in a respectable position, pity that they had taken up government that not a Parsi was starving before they
Mr Godrej has secured the first place. ” appointments lately. It was a loss to the took any morsel of food. If Hindus or
The Mahatma goes on to call for an whole ofindia and not to the Parsi commu- Muslims wished to do anything else, then
understanding of the community ’s attitude
own. Mr Godrej has earmarked his dona
tion for liquor prohibition and the uplift of Dadabhai Naoroji, Pherozeshah Mehta and
the suppressed classes. ”
Recalling his experience in South Af
rica when some whites had besieged his
house and threatened to kill him and how
Parsi Rustomji had come to his rescue
risking his own life in the process, Gandhi every department of life. If they had done-* ’
so much in this country in the past, why*
Jamshedji T^a. ”
He appealed to the Parsis to take part in
the swaraj movement which was now go
ing on in full swing: “Th^ Parsis were able
to compete with other communities in
free, not for Parsis alone, but for all com
munities and races. ” Gandhi promised to
with them. Mr Godrej had already handed very intimate with them for a long time.”
Continuing, the Mahatma said, “If the
Parsis wished it, they could easily accom- shown to the whole of India what the Parsis
were capable of doing, further notes the plish anything, because they were a small,
compact community of 80,000, but that
was not so with the Hindus and Muslims. ”
If they could remain independent even
commended the example set by some great before the English came, he did not know
Parsis: “The Parsi community had given why they could not be so when they got
liberally in many ways and it was not a fact
While deploring that Parsis as a rule
swaraj. “It was the first duty of Hindus and
Muslims to protect the smaller communi-
any service to this country. Naturally they ties in this land. If the Hindus and Muslims
were a commercial people, and it was a
appointments lately. It was a loss to the
whole of India and not to the Parsi commu
nity alone. But the education which they they were not working for a dharmarajya?
22 Parsiana April 19961!
h
1
41
#¦
//
__SL
4'
I MM
«*» ,1
In the struggle against oppression: (From left)
Pandit Malvia, Kaikobad Cowasjee Dinshaw
(Adenwalla), Gandhiji and Sarojini Naidu. Picture
taken at Ballard Pier prior to Gandhiji's departure
for the Round Table
talks; and Parsi
tomji (inset and second
from right, below) "the
Grand Old Passive
Resister" of South
Africa. To his right are
Gokhale and Gandhi
He wanted “to make the Parsis fearless and
drive away their doubts ” and he wanted
them “to devote their energies for the
welfare of this country. If they could do so,
they could get swaraj this year, and they
could also right the Khilafat wrong. ”
^In passing, the Mahatma criticizes those provided the same numberof
movement launched by him. He quotes the
example of Ardeshir Godrej against whom
the British rulers passed a secret circular
not to purchase any Godrej products, for
his temerity in donating three lakh rupees
to an anti-British cause. Gandhi writes: “A
close friend points out that those who
inveigh against non-cooperation seem to
forget that all these years the Government
has non-cooperated with our culture, our
language and our race. We would be the
biggest fools if we do not resort to non-
--• W VIII VllIIIU IlIVlllUCl
cooperation against this system. A fresh Congress and doing excellent
example of the Government ’s non-r : ~ ¦
eration even at the present day, and
have merely smiled. The
Parsi population in the
country totals one lakh. On
the basis only of numbers,
their contribution would be
full if they gave Rs 4,120,
could also right the Khilafat wrong. ”
who inveigh against the non-cooperation members and accounted for
824 spinning-wheels. As a
matter of fact, Rs 4,120 have
come from them just by way
of petty contributions. The
sums which Parsi friends sent
anonymously must have
come to this total. I also
include in this Fund Parsi
Rustomji ’s contribution of Rs 52,000.
The Parsis must have, I believe, provided
4,120 members too. Some Parsi volunteers
have been enrolling members of the
t work in
coop- Bombay. There has been a Parsi lawyer,
, , . . ¦ . .. "dan too, who gave up practice. One gentleman
example which reveals its meanness, is has resolved to utilize his scientific knowl-
Lra “h r Mr Godrej. This edge for the service ofthe people. It is true
large-hearted gentleman has donated that the number of .sninnina-wLpk
money to the Tilak Swaraj Fund earmark
ing the contribution for the uplift of the
untouchables and for propaganda against
drink. This (has) provoked a secret circu-
no Godrej safe should be ordered for any of that they have in any way done less than
papers run by them are
¦I .¦
( -
5 ¦
' ** s
..4«
8
IT ¦ I 1
.«¦
I
J
too, who gave up practice. One gentleman
has resolved to utilize his scientific knowl-
that the number of spinning-wheels among
them is small, but even so Parsi women,
and some men too, have taken up the work.
Some Parsis also go out to picket liquor
booths.
“How can one say, in the face of this,
to them, would have no reason for pointing
a finger at them.
But the fact is that Shri Godrej has
done something which far exceeds any
other performances. He has contributed
three lakhs. No other single individual has
given so much. True, the entire amount is
not available in cash today, but it is as
secure as if offered in gold. He has ear
marked the sum for two of the purest items
in our program, banishing liquor and Antyaj
uplift. Money was eamiSrked for the latter
cause on his insistence. For myself, I would
have preferred to employ only Hindus ’
money for this work. It is for them to carry
out this particular reform. But how could I
stand in the way of this friend who offered
*
its departments, which used to go in for others? Not all
numbers of them in the past. Because Mr ooDosed to the mnvpmpnt Th.,',,..., • f ”'7““ i......“““ onerea
Godrej(has)eo„.ribu>edto>heTilakSwa ” S^nTvanmar.?k„X„ J ail X h X of heart?
Fund, the‘jusfGovernmenthasboycotted not heard of Shri Bharucha ’s hard waf ‘I"®I believe
his safes. How should the people deal with As fonhe Xk bein v do„, h, o by P"sis, so far as
Reverting again to Parsis and their con- CraXl^Lrhl beS w^ i' X ’¦ “'"r?"
nection With the freedom Struggle, Gandhi lessly. She has actuallv ndnnipH A the Parsi community sufficiently. ”
refers to the many contributions made by pletely khadi dress Even if the Parsi com f ‘^ohected
23 Parsiana April 1996
ladies, I shall give my experiences some
other time, but there is one name I must
mention. The granddaughter of India ’s
Grand Old Man ’ has been working tire-
1 a com-
.. . - —..i com
munity had done no more than what they
have, we would have reason to be grateful
IGLOBE
THEATRES
Pvt Ltd
Established
April 3, 1915
Pioneers of Show
Business in India for
the last 81
cial Congress Committee appointing a sub
committee to manage the funds, on which
the only Parsi member was Ardeshir
Burjorji Godrej.
“The Bombay Provincial Congress
Committee has come to a decision on the
question of the management of the big
collection made by it in a most business
like and becoming manner. I quote from
memory the effective part of its resolution;
“‘Whereas the All-India Tilak Memo
rial Fund collections made during the month
of June were made not to meet provincial
needs merely but in order to fulfil the
obligation incurred at Bezwada and in
order to meet the requirements of pro
vinces in need of help, in the opinion of the
LORD’S
CENTRAL
years
We rededicate
ourselves to the ideals
we have cherished and
practised all along --
namely to show
NOTHING BUT
THE BEST
to our ever increasing
number of Patrons
era
Mani Bhavan at Gamdevi, Bombay,
houses the memorabilia of the Gandhi
HOTEL
Matheran 410102
Erijoy the
mountains,-
antics of the
monkeys and
our hospitality
*
Controlling:
REGAL
BOMBAY
CAPITOL
BOMBAY
*
GLOBE
CALCUTTA
The above three cinemas
installed with
nni DOLBY STEREO I
are
Committee it is desirable to entrust a spe
cial committee with the control and man
agement of the collections. Messrs
Raghavji Purushottam, Velji Lakhamsi
Napu, Revashankar Jagjivan Jhaveri,Umar
Sobani, Jamnalal Bajaj, Ardeshir Burjorji
Godrej, Shankarlal Banker and Lakshmidas
Tairsi be appointed a committee to control
and manage the said funds, subject to the
following conditions:
‘“•The non-cooperation expenses of the
Provincial Congress Committee to be a
first charge on the funds.
‘“•The other provinces to be helped on the
advice of the All-India Congress Commit
tee in respect of the spread of the charkha
and khadi, elevation of suppressed classes,
national schools, famine relief and prohi
bition of liquor. ’
“It is an act of self-denial, for which the
Bombay Committee deserves the warm
congratulations of the country. The one
intention running through the resolution is
to put the administration of the large funds
beyond suspicion and on a sound footing. ’’
25 Parsiana April 1996
Matheran telephone
number 021483-0228
Fax 021483-0595
Bombay telephone
number 3867776
ISCHOLARSHIP
unable to bear children. At the same time,
however, the patriarchal structure of soci
ety was gradually being eroded by the fact
that by the middle of the 17th century the
Parsis had made the transition from vil
lages to towns, and had branched out from
agriculture to become artisans, merchants,
traders and bankers. By the end of the 18th
century, there was an exodus from the
hinterlands to the port of Bombay, where
the Parsis assumed the mercantile role,
which became a source of their wealth and
power. They established a mutually ben
eficial relationship with the British as
“mediators and pace-setters of social
change ” (Kulke) — a role that would ex
pose them to what must have seemed like
a very liberal Western system of sex-role
relations. Gradually, the Parsis abandoned
the system of purd^, and the female mem
bers of the families of prominent reformers
and some sethias (business magnates)
mixed socially with outsiders at private
and public functions. By 1884 this “inno
vation ” had grown into a popular custom
among the Parsis (Sahiar).
The changeover though was not as
smooth as Kulke maintains — that Parsi
reformers interested in “purifying the reli
gion ” were successful in eliminating such
customs as infant marriages, polygyny, or
the prohibition of widow remarriages, since
these practices were only assimilated su
perficially from the Indian environment.
In fact, the tenacity with which these cus
toms hung on for a few generations attests
to the fact that the priests, who were the
spokespersons of the community diring
the early years of the Parsi settlement in
India, gave it their tacit stamp of approval.
However, when Bombay became the new
stronghold of Parsi immigrants, it was
evident that the strength of the clergy in the
new city was weak. The Bombay
Punchayet, which sought to carry on the
leadership function of the community,
became an organ for hereditary member
ship for leading merchant families.
This change from priest to laity in lead
ership positions was a mixed blessing for
rulings affecting the status of women. For
example, the Punchayet passed regula-
tions against bigamy, but tolerated it among
T’he socioeconomic independence of to the adoption of certain Hindu customs its own members. It tried to control the free
X women has often been pointed out as like infant marriages that did not show a movement of females by interjecting an
an outstanding characteristic of the Parsi decline until the last part of the 19th century interesting religious twist in one of its
Zoroastrian community (Eckehard Kulke, (Gooloo H. Sahiar). Polygyny also pre- ordinances. In 1819 the Punchayet ruled
T aaU VtcoriQ x^ai,«. vailed during this period, with the Parsi that no woman could stir out of the house
the checkered history of this phenomenon Punchayet (a quasi-judicial-cum-social before sunrise and after sunset, and no
has usually been glossed over in an effort body) forbidding bigamy, but dispensing
_i r.. rr-. ... .J permission to remarry if the first wife was
Status of Women: sacred and secular - 5
Educated, not
emancipated
Dr Ketayun H. Gould
Higher education for their women
could threaten the domestic peace,
feared the Zoroastrian men
The image of a liberated Zoroastrian deemed allies of Ahura Mazda to fight
female on par with the male is only an the evil forces. The domestic routine
illusion, an ideal that has yet to be though was considered to be of prime
realized. There is no denying that in concern to the female in the ancient
certain spheres she has been granted period. While marriage and the
equal opportunities but she has had to begetting of children is advocated in
suffer discrimination too. This article Zoroastrianism, the prevalent belief
was that menstruation causes a woman
to lose her ritual purity and spread
impurity if she comes in contact with
others. Even though religious equality
was denied to females in ancient times.
which will run into six instalments ana
lyzes the relevant texts and traditions to
study the status of women in the an
cient, medieval and modem periods.
As it originally appears in Religion
and Women (a publication of the State within the confines of a patriarchal
University of New York Press, 1994) the society women were ceded certain eco-
paper entitled “Outside the discipline,
inside the experience: women in Zoro
astrianism" is a researched, academic suffering in the medieval period when
presentation. Since Parsiana will be Zoroastrianism was relegated to the
status of a minority religion. Also no
ticeable were the double standards that
condoned remarriage and adultery
among men but censured females who
dared to take the same liberties.
With the introduction of formal edu
cation for girls in modem times they
were able to assert their socioeconomic
nomic and legal rights. Women had to
bear considerable hardships and
carrying an abridged version ofthe text
to make it simpler for the lay reader, we
will not be detailing the sources that the
author painstakingly cites at each
instance.
In the fir st four instalments we learnt
that certain divinities perceived as
female entities were venerated, that the
soul of a dead man was said to be met by independence. However within the
a female figure on its upward journey, religious sphere they continued to be
Yet within the stronghold of the discriminated against, as this fifth
aristocracy and priesthood in the pre- instalment indicates, and the privileges
Zoroastrian era, paradise was denied enjoyed by men who had married out of
to women. With the advent of the community were denied to their
Zarathushtra,bothmenandwomenwere female counterparts.
to the adoption of certain Hindu customs
like infant marriages that did not show a
outstanding characteristic of the Parsi decline until the last part ofthe 19th century
Leela Visaria, Malini Karkal). However,
to glorify the past. The move to India led
before sunrise and after sunset, and
woman could visit Hindu temples or Mus
lim tombs or perform any related ceremo-
26 Parsiana April 1996
Inies in their own home.
The accompanying charge that “super
stition and pernicious practices had taken school stirred up the community to a state The first Indian girl who was sent to
root among Parsi women (Jehangir R. P. of frenzy, especially since Wilson attacked such a missionary school through the ef-
Mody) turned out to be a very clever ploy the validity of Zoroastrian teachings. The forts of a very unusual, strong mother
on the part of Punchayet leaders, because community realized that the double-edged happened to be a Parsi Zoroastrian. She
it ended up appealing to both the orthodox effect of education, both in helping the has written a feminist document that
and reformist wings of the community.
The conservatives were looking for an
acceptable way to turn the tide of alien themselves became knowledgeable about
influences, which they blamed for ruining ' ’
the traditional sex-role structure of the Kinnells). (1911) is the only piece of literature that
community. They were afraid that the There were, however, other changes drives home the point that although the
newfound freedom of Parsi women would that were taking place in the educational male Parsi reformers, who are lauded for
lead to “numerous cases of divorce and
domestic trouble reported in England which outcry was no less bitter. The first schools education deserve all the credit, die girl s
were attributed to mutual intercourse bet- for female education were being themselves — the real heroines — are a
ween the sexes (M. M. Murzban). ’’ The established, originally by missionaries, and forgotten page in history.
reformists worried about how the commu- later by organizations like the Students ’ ’
nity would “abjure priestcraft... organize a Literary and Scientific Society. At first,
new national church founded on simple the schools provided education in the ver- ___________________ _
tradition of good thought, good word, good nacular language (Gujarati), although edu- public support to risk their participationin
deed... ----- ----u; ---- —r T- ,• . .. . . „ ......... r
(Behramji M. Malabari). ’’ schools after 1860. Of course, the females
could have attended the girls ’ schools es-
Christian teachings. The 1839 conversion that might lead women “to make slaves of
of two Parsi boys in Rev John Wilson ’s their husbands (R. P. Masani). ’
school stirred up the community to a state ~
9)
community and undermining the religion, presents what it was like in 1842 to
could only be dealt with if the Parsis encounter the ire of the community in
xv . . ., . acquiring English education. Dosebai
their own religious traditions (John R. Cowasjee Jessawalla ’s autobiography
TT ,i_x (1911) is the only piece of literature that
There were, however, other changes drives home the point that although the
arena in the mid-19th century where the their pioneering efforts on behalf of female
for female education were being themselves — the real heroines —
Ultimately, the sethias themselves, and
then the government, decided that the idea
of female education had gained enough
. _ _ - - - . . -----------------------rr-------------------------------------------f------- in
weed scriptures of its verbiage cation in English was provided by Parsi establishing such schools. By 1881 the
ntl .n I. .n. .n. 1 ,, 1 O^l\ ________ _ 11 n 1 a a ¦ _
The turmoil over the religious/ethnic could have attended the girls ’ schools es-
community identity was also fanned by the tablished by missionaries between 1824
n 1-,. . . . 1830. But the Parsis, like other re
spectable families, were opposed to
census recorded that “over 15 years of age,
the smallest proportion of illiterate, either
. - . ----------------- male or female, is found in the Parsi popu-
mtroduction of Christian mission school and 1830. But the Parsis, like other re- lation ’’ (Census of India 1883). This fact
education that the Parsi middle-class rec- spectable families, were opposed to did not exactly overjoy the majority of the
ognized as an avenue of upward mobility, breaking purdah and sending girls out of community. Newspaper articles expounded
but also feared for its ability to convey the homes to acquire English schooling the theory that “education would spoil the
For Pure Diamonds
or
JEWELLERS
324, Grant Road, Bombay 400007. Telephone 3099648 Fax 3073483
APPOINTED VALUERS BY THE GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
28 Parsiana April 1996
Ii
health and delicate bodies of the females.
They need education in English, but they (Gould),
need sufficient education, nothing beyond
that {Kaiser-E-Hind 1902).”
The 1880s saw the beginning of yet troversy regarding conversion and inter-
another radical trend that was not so obvi
ous in terms of its consequences for the
future of the community. Visaria has de
monstrated that as early as 1881 the marital
fertility of the Parsis was only 46 percent
of the maximum potential. Obviously, this
finding indicates that even before the in
troduction of modem contraception, resort
was sought to some form of control of
fertility within marriage. The continuing
demographic decline of the Parsi commu
nity during the 20th century with its pattern
of late marriage, nonmarriage, and low
fertility has led to a few studies to under
stand and possibly deal with this critical
phenome^n (Visaria, Ketayun H. Gould, marriage, and the ambivalent attitude to
ward the status of women in Zoroastrian
ism. Among the Parsis, a marriage is rec-
tion if these trends continue unabated
years of their settlement in India (Sahiar).
It is also evident that these non-Parsi wives,
as well as some other adults like personal
servants, were initiated into the Zoroas
trian religion (Sahiar). The children of
these intermarriages between Parsi men
and non-Parsi women, as well as the ille
gitimate children of Parsi men had also
been accepted into the religion by having
an initiation ceremony that is reserved for
children of both Parsi Zoroastrian parents.
The occurrence of these phenomena are
attested to by the fact that from time to
time there were public outcries about ad
mitting such persons to the fire-temples,
and consigning their bodies to the towers
of silence. In fact, in 1770, this matter was
referred for clarification to the Zoroastrian
authorities in Iran who saw nothing objec
tionable in admitting converts. In 1818 the
Punchayet decreed that the initiation cer
emonies of children of Parsi fathers and
“alien ” mothers could not be performed
without its sanction. Notice that in the
parties are Parsi Zoroastrians, and the priest patriarchal religion there is no record of
consecrates the marriage by the ashirvad Parsi women marrying non-Parsi men, and
This topic itself has great significance
for understanding the bitter religious con-
Newspaper
articles
expounded the
theory that
education would
spoil the health
and delicate
bodies of the
females
Karkal). The 1981 census reveals that the
Parsi population of India was 71,630, with _______ _______________
62,478 or 87.2 percent of them living in ognized as a “Parsi marriage ” when both
greater Bombay (Census of India 1981, - -
Karkal). The 21.5 percent decline in popu
lation in the 1971-1981 decade (some of it (blessings) in the presence^ of two Parsi
due to emigration) is disastrous for the i ~ ................. .............
survival of an endogamous ethnic minority been shown that many Pars?men took non
community that sees itself facing extinc- -
the consideration that children of such
unions can be initiated into the religion.
In 1903 a melhber of a prominent indus-
Parsi wives, especially during the early trialist family in Bombay married a French
witnesses. Despite this regulation, it has
CONTUCTJt.4».M.
30 Parsiana April 1996
*
If
woman while he was abroad. When he
returned to India, he had her converted to
Zoroastrianism and married her in a Zoro
astrian ceremony. An anjuman (commu
nity) meeting passed a resolution that she
could not enter a fire-temple, use Parsi
trust funds, or have her remains consigned
to the towers of silence. The resulting
court case, popularly known as “the Parsi
Punchayet case of 1908,” set the standard
on conversion that has not been challenged
to this day. The Bombay High Court ruled
that even if a non-Parsi is duly admitted
into the Zoroastrian religion, such an indi
vidual is not entitled to the uses and ben
efits of the funds and institutions that are
under the Punchayet ’s control, since these
privileges are traditionally reserved for
only those individuals who are Parsi Zoro
astrians (a caste). Thus, the ruling spelled
out that a Zoroastrian could not be auto
matically considered a Parsi. The judg
ment upheld the customary definition of
the Parsi community as follows: Parsis
who are descended from the original Per
sian emigrants, and who are born of both
Zoroastrian parents, and who profess the
Zoroastrian religion, the Iranis from Persia
professing the Zoroastrian religion, who
come to India, either temporarily or per
manently, and the children of Parsi fathers
by alien mothers, who have been duly and
properly admitted into the religion (Sapur
Faredun Desai).
A related case, Saklat vs Bella 1925,
did involve a child of a Parsi mother and a
non-Parsi father. This child (a girl) was the
“orphan ” daughter of a Goanese Christian
father and a Parsi mother who was brought
up in a Zoroastrian household of Rangoon
from early infancy. After her initiation
ceremony was performed, Bella was taken
by her adoptive father (a Parsi) to the
Rangoon fire-temple on March 21, 1915.
Ten days later, three members of the Parsi
community of Rangoon filed a suit against
Bella and the adoptive father, claiming
that they had “not only wounded the reli
gious feelings entertained by religiously
inclined Parsis, but also caused the des
ecration of the said sacred temple (Privy
Council Judgement). ” The case was thrown
out in the preliminary judgement, and the
chief court of lower Burma agreed with the
initial judgement. But on appeal to the
Privy Council,they ruled that Bella was
“not entitled as of right to use the temple,
or to attend or to participate in any of the
religious ceremonies performed therein
(Privy Council Judgement). ” But the j udges
also noted that while the trustees “can treat
her as a trespasser...it does not follow that
they are bound so to treat her (Privy Coun
cil Judgement). ” Thus, the right of admis
sion to converts could be decided by the
trustees of the fire-temple. This particular
point in the ruling, however, is only a salve
at this point, since nearly all the community
trusts governing fire-temples and towers
of silence require the beneficiaries to be
both Parsis and Zoroastrians (Feroza Pay
master and Jeroo Gorimar, Parsiana).
The succeeding years saw the conflict
over these religious/societal issues trans
late itself into questions regarding the lit
eral meaning of Zoroastrian scriptures,
tenets, doctrines and tradition. The ortho
dox and reformist camps battled it out at
several Zoroastrian conferences, with some
elite reformists, trained at Western univer
sities, pushing for a more rational, less
ritualistic view of the religious tradition.
The early 1940s saw at least two major
events that shook the orthodox foundation
of the community: the mass initiation cer
emonies of children of Parsi men and non-
Parsi women in the village of Vansda, and
the “wrongful ” consecration of the Fasli
fire-temple in Bombay (Adi F. Doctor,
Parsiana). The furor resulted in the re
formist group suggesting a round table
conference to settle various religious is
sues, but the orthodox wing refused on the
Progressives
4*
*
--
®Q'/-
¦^'Stance
Distance _ -
The lens for uninterupted vision at different ranges
distance, mid-distance & reading.
Progressives are muitifocai ienses without the teii-taie lines of bifocals.
Progressives need professional care .
For the best results come to Baliwalla & Homi.
One of the finest optometrists & contact-lens practitioners in the country.
@) Baliwalla & Homi
Private Limited
Flora Fountain: 365, Dr. D.N.Road, Bombay 400 001 Tel: 287 4916, 287 1762 • Dhobi Talao: 614, J.S. Seth Marg, Bombay 400 002. Tel: 201 4906
Parel: J.Merwanji Street, Parel, Bombay 400 012 Tel: 412 6051
IWith
best wishes
from
Farah
&
Tanya
32 Parsiana April 1996
grounds that further discussions would snuff
out “whatever faith that Zoroastrians had should respond to inter-marriages of Parsi
in their scriptures (Doctor). ’’ The attacks females was complicated further by the
and counterattacks between the two camps passage of the Special Marriage Act of
were played out in the Parsi newspapers
over the next decades, with clear lines
being drawn at times between those who marriage (required by the Civil Marriage
supported the reformist and those who Act of 1872). The 1954 law strengthened
supported the orthodox cause, and a turn- the argument that a Parsi woman does not
around in editorial support at other times leave the community automatically when
that infuriated supporters. Doctor mourns
the effect of all these factors on community
identity today, since he views with alarm
the fact that “fissiparous tendencies and advice, and were told that the Bombay
internecine squabbles and wrangles have Prevention of Excommunication Act,
done far more damage to the orthodox 1949, had already established the rights of
cause than the attacks of all the heterodox Parsi women who married non-Parsis but
thinkers put together. ’’
An examination of some other laws
might provide further proof of the ambiva- ing and maintaining the religious rights of
lent attitudes toward women in Zoroastri
anism. In 1868 the Legislative Council,
Calcutta, had introduced a bill to legalize priests who exert their authority in their
marriages between members of communi- own “territories ” (Parinaz Toddywalla,
ties who were not Christians. The Parsis, Parsiana), and influence their anjumans to
afraid of the implications of such a bill for support their decisions to prevent such
interreligious marriages, prevailed on the women from entering fire-temples, attend-
govemment to pass the Special Marriage ing religious ceremonies, and having their
Act, commonly known as the Civil Mar- remains disposed of in the customary Zo-
riage Act of 1872, making the contracting roastrian traditions of the community. In
’ fact, they also refuse to ^cept the 1908
Parsi Punchayet case decision by not per
The issue of how the Parsi community
1954, which nullified the necessity of re
nouncing one ’s faith in the case of a civil
she marries a non-Parsi, as long as she
continues to profess the Zoroastrian reli
gion. Again, the trustees asked for legal
continued to practice the Zoroastrian faith.
The roadblocks, however, to establish-
these Parsi women are numerous. The
main problem are some orthodox high
parties renounce their Zoroastrian reli
gion. However, in 1918 a Parsi woman
married a Christian not under this act, but forming the initiation ceremonies of chil-
under the Indian Christian Marriage Act of dren of any mixed marriages, or offering *
1872. She continued to practice her reli- the sacred elements that are required at
gion, and on her death, her relatives wanted such ceremonies so that other nonlocal
her body consigned to the towers of si- priests could perform the navjote
lence. After consultation, her body was (Toddywalla). Thus, there is a checkered
consigned to the chotra where “doubtful ” pattern of compliance with the Special
bodies are assigned. The decision was still Marriage Act of 1954, with different
based on the belief (supported by the advo- anjumans/punchayets following their own
cate general) that even if she remained a individually defined rules or practices.
Zoroastrian she went out of the community To be concluded.
by having married a non-Parsi.
During the intervening years, the ques
tion again surfaced in 1948 when the trust
ees of the Punchayet were concerned about
the “large number ” of Parsis marrying
outside the community (Desai). The trust
ees drew up a case for opinion, and they
were advised that if the woman continued
to be a Zoroastrian, the only way they
could deprive a Parsi woman marrying a
non-Parsi from enjoying the benefits of
Parsi institutions was to prove one thing:
that there was a prevalent custom that such
a marriage meant that she left the commu
nity automatically. However, the opinion
stated that legally, it was not possible to
prove such a custom. As a result of this
opinion, the Bombay Prevention of Ex
communication Act, 1949, was passed.
- Dr Ketayun H. Gould is
professor emerita in the
School of Social Work,
University of Illinois at
Urbana-Champaign in the
United States. She is a
partner, along with her
husband, in Independent
Scholars Associated in
I Stafford, Virginia. She
I opted for early retirement
I- to pursue her research
and scholarship. Her writings have dealt with two
main areas: feminist theory, models and practice
frameworks in the area of women and ethnic
minority concerns, and historical and demographic
studies of the Parsi Zoroastrian community in
India. Currently she is authoring a book on the
historical and demographic decline of the Parsi
Zoroastrian community in the rural and urban
areas of Gujarat.
-r
;*iinPROFESSIONS
FOR SOUND RESULTS
1
f
i f
i »
I
First there was sea. After that came the I
land. Next followed the erections and with I
that the sound effects. This is not a new I
theory of creation but a measure of time to I
indicate Burjorji Mistry ’s association with I
the National Centre for the Performing I
Arts (NCPA) in Bombay and the different I
auditoria constructed on its premises at I
Nariman Point. Mistry remembers the func- I
tion when Sir Homi Mody had thanked the I
then chief minister of Maharashtra for I
gifting 10 acres of the sea at a nominal rent I
of about two rupees a year for perpetuity. I
Subsequently the land was reclaimed by |
the NCPA to house thereon the Experi- I
mental Theatre and the Little Theatre, the I
Tata Theatre and the upcoming Drama I
Opera Arts complex. I
In all these ventures the man entrusted I
with helping in the designing and/or ex- I
ecution of acoustics was Mistry who along I
with the architects, Patel, Batliwalla, I
Manohar and Associates, has worked as a I
team on different landmarks. “Everyone I
talks of acoustic treatment which presumes I
that the patient is sick. It should be acous- |
tic design, ” clarifies Mistry, a physicist by j
training. “A theater is built inside-out, ” he j
adds, “after determining the parameters I
and needs of the performing and viewing I
space. ” At the auditorium under construe- I
tion, the interiors will be designed such I
that half the floor space will be reserved for
the stage, the seating capacity being re
stricted to 1,300. “This project will be one
of its kind in India and will enable foreign
dance troupes or orchestras to come in full
strength to perform in India. Until now
they did not have such performing space, ”
says Mistry, seated on his couch at the
NCPA Guest House where he has presently
taken up temporary residence to be able to
monitor from close range the progress of
the building. This living arrangement saves
the energies of the 77-year-old sound and
theater specialist who would otherwise
have needed to commute regularly from
his residence at Marine Lines, to the office
of the architects at Napean Sea Road, to the
NCPA complex at Nariman Point.
Within this complex has also arisen a
high-rise residential building which the I
1
Burjorji Mistry's
acoustic expertise
is sought in the
construction
of landmark
auditoria in India
Parinaz Gandhi
HBjlll critics have dubbed a “monstrosity, ” but
according to Mistry it was the revenue
raised from the sale of these flats that
helped finance the new auditorium esti-
mated to cost between 20-30 crore rupees.
The Tata group of companies are the other
major financiers along with other business
groups and individuals. In response to
those who may well ask, ‘Does India need
such a thing? Why not use that money to
feed the poor? ’ Mistty has an answer: “For
the sake of art every country needs such a
thing. ” Work on this auditorium commen-
B ced four to five years ago and should be
I
I
ready for use by December 1996, hopes
I Mistry. “India is a strange place, ” reports
I Mistry . “On one side the government helps
I and on the otk^er side functions so
I bureaucratically, asking irrelevant
I questions (tantamounting to) ‘Why is your
I nose crooked? ’ That ’s takdn up consi-
I derable time.”
I The man who has been credited with
I designing over 500 auditoria and cinema
I houses all over the world has slowed down
I his pace of work, preferring not to accept
I any outside project on the rationale, “I’ve
I become aged, insecure in mind and body, ”
I he says with a straight face. Mistry has
I benefitted from varied work exposure. His
I pre-war and war years with the Royal Air
I Force were rewarding. But when he opted
to work in India, he was disappointed. For
a while he worked with a group of people
involved in the production and distribu
tion of films, and ownership and building
of cinemas. He then branched out on his
own.
His first cinema, in Nairobi, built in
1949 for an international operator is still
functional. But ask him which is his best
work, and prompt comes the response:
“The next one. People forget that you
never stop learning. ” He then recalls the
words of Einstein who when asked by an
upstart journalist how much he had learnt
in the course of his long hours of work had
replied, “How little I know. ” Mistry too
has adopted the same maxim and believes,
“People should learn from their mistakes
instead of trying to cover them up. We
i should constantly analyze and find out
33 Parsiana April 1996
I^^People believe that if you study
more science, you become godless.
But it's exactly the opposite"
\.
¦
I
I
li
H
year, when Zubin Mehta had toured India
with the Israel Philharmonic, Mistry, as
before, had designed that shell.
When it comes to a cinema. Mistry
takes maximum pride in the Satyam
SundaramSachinam complex (a multiplex up of the Air Raid Precaution wing in
unit of three auditoria) that he designed at India, he happened to be on the same ship
Worli where for the first time he pioneered that exploded in the Bombay harbor,
a technology whereby the screen would wounding him substantially. In the process
have no black border which he perceived his colon was destroyed and to this day he
was a “constraint and narrowing of the
visual field... It’s like watching a madari
(roadside artiste) perform from the second techniques developed to train man. Apti-
floor. ” From their seats the viewers should tude testing, the theory of management,
faster methods of reading and assimila
tion... are the outcome of war. Men were
The constant urge to innovate, to ex- taught reading skills such that 400 pages of
plore new avenues. Mistry says he imbibed technical matter could be covered in one
from Father Rephal who taught him maths hour. And since the English language was
and physics when he was an undergraduate found to contafh 50 percent of superfluous
student at St Xavier ’s College. The ana- words, it became easy for th© reader to
lytical and rational thinking that Rephal scan the written words. Iq^the process of
have
no bearing on the University curriculum awful spellings but I don ’t care to correct j
~_j .l-. u- them. Where are the rules and regulations? ” -
interested in a degree was requested not to he adds defiantly.
When aptitude testing was developed
first class first and thence proceeded to the during the war, subjects were required to
answer stupid questions without any
forethinking. Questions were in the nature
cannot eat any foods that leave a residue.
The positive side of combat are the new
what we could have done, what we missed
out on, what we did wrong... There are
only two people who never make mistakes
— a bloody fool and God. ”
A good theater, maintains Mistry, is
one where the audience can see and hear in
a comfortable and pleasant environment...
where they don ’t have to keep shifting in
their seats... after the show is over they
don ’t feel the need to say a word about the
auditorium. ” He talks at length about the
creation and functioning of the Tata The
atre that has a seating capacity of almost
1,100. On this assignment the world ’s lead
ing architect Philip Johson and physicist/ feel that they are a part of the movie scene,
acoustician Dr Cyril Harris chose to work he insists,
as a team for the first time. To resemble the
intimacy and rapport shared between the
artistes and the audience in the traditional
Indian ‘baithak ’ setting it was decided that
the Tata Theatre would have no pros
cenium, no barrier, no curtains to differen- lytical and rational thinking that Rephal scan the written words. In the process
tiate between the performers and the inspired among his students may have had perfecting this skill he aamits, “I ha
viewers. It was also expected that no i
electronics will be in use at the Tata Theatre and any student indicating that he was
for the simple reason that there is no sound
system which will not color the sound that attend his classes. Mistry graduated with a
it reproduces. Further, while in the west
musicians are trained to become sound Indian Institute of Science at Bangalore to
operators, such facilities do not exist in do his PhD. But midway through the course
India with the result that “the attendant Mistry ’s services were requisitioned by of “How long is a piece of string? ” “How
who finds it difficult to catch the whispered the Government of India defence wing and far can you go into the woods? ” There
endearment ‘meri pyari (my dear) ’ will
unknowingly increase the volume and when
a man ’s shouts are supposed to be distur
bing to the ear, the attendant will tone it World War II.
down, ” points out Mistry.
Any talk of a multipurpose hall is anath
ema to Mistry who explains that a cinema
is meant to reproduce what is recorded in
the film while for an orchestra, an audito
rium is also part of the orchestra; another horrible things, ” in Mistry ’s opinion,
instrument without which the music would
be lifeless. An auditorium where you mix
the two mediums is like a “woman in a
man ’s body — a horror, ” was Mistry ’s
invariable lesson to his students at the Film
Institute and the Drama Institute. Since
most auditoria in India are not able to do
justice to visiting orchestras, for best ef
fects, Mistry has often been called upon to diverting useful manpower, ” he elaborates,
create an acoustic shell such that the sound
does not get dissipated on the stage. Last
then passed on to the Royal Air Force could be several correct responses to the
(RAF) and he was deputed to their research first one: The distance from one end to the
wing in England just before and during other; or twice the distance from one end to
its mid point; or. .. For the second query the
While abroad he availed of the opportu- right response would be: When you are
nity to do his BSc in structural engineering halfway through it. After that you are
and MSc in telecommunications from the
University of London. “War does some
good things and some terribly cruel and Mistry, is to “apply it truthfully and (pur
posefully) for result-oriented action. ” He
gleefully cites the case of a Parsi who ran
a workshop at Tardeo insisting on adding
the suffix CIE to his name. When the
British administration chose to question
getting out of it.
The purpose of education, according to
“When it’s a choice of man or materials,
the correct decision is ‘lose man. ’ Man is
human fodder while the sinews of war are
materials. The objective of bombing is
more to maim than to kill; the reason being him diplomatically, his unabashed response
if you kill one Johnny, a few will cry but if was, “I am a Cast Iron Engineer. ”
you maim one person you take away the “Many people have degrees but no ap- ¦ ; “Many people have degrees but no ap-
energies of others in caring for him, thereby plication, ” observes Mistry who worked as
an examiner for the Bombay University.
He is disturbed by the prevalent attitude of
puted by the RAF to oversee the winding judging a person ’s prowess by his bio data
Mistry should know for when he was de-
34 Parsiana April 1996
4
Iand refuses on principle, to supply it to
anyone who wants to engage his services
on the merit of academic qualifications. “I
am prepared to be evaluated and cross-
examined but I say no to a bio data... When
you go to a doctor or a lawyer do you ask duplicately applied to a changed environ-
for his marksheet first? ”
Mistry ’s foundation in education was
laid at the Master Tutorial High School.
Staying in Andheri he would commute
daily to the Nana Chowk area where his formerly, he informs. Mistry who has
school was located. If
he got a chance, he
would surreptitiously
cycle his way back and
forth without his
father ’s knowledge,
remembers Mistry. His
father Ardeshir Jivanji
Mistry was an engjneer-
architect who ran his
own organization. “He
had a very funny atti
tude to life, ” acknowledges Mistry. If personal capacity wherein Zoroastrian and everything in the world but we have no
people would go to him with complaints
about his son he would tell them, “I have
fulfilled my obligation in educating him.”
The nature of their complaints? The
usual — roams around, does not put on integration, more than 50 percent mistook
proper clothes... The latter is now con
stantly expressed by his wife, laughs the opposed to making translations of
bald-headed physicist with a take-me-or-
leave-me countenance, attired in a shirt
that he seemed to have outgrown but with
a pocket accommodating his constant sta
tionery companions including a six-inch Mistry who describes himself as “a stu-
ruler. Mistry ’s wife Pola (nee Sabavala) pidly religious man. ”
whom he fondly addresses as Popo or
Popee much to her chagrin was an an
nouncer with the AU India Radio “reputed actly the opposite, ” claims Mistry. “If you
to have one of the finest broadcasting genuinely study, you come to an end and
voices in English ” because of which she is
still invited there even though she has
retired. Their son Kaivan does lighting for
plays and exhibitions.
“According to my wife, I am not mar
ried to her because (contrary to the prevail
ing Parsi custom that is supposed to have
originated with our oath to King Jadav plainable presumptions. Eventually you
Rana) I insisted on getting married before forced to acknowledge something which
sunset, ” discloses Mistry, firmly of the you cannot perceive. Without that your
view that under the Zoroastrian religion
darkness is not good and besides it is not
healthy scientifically. Parsis of the grand ways of God, Mistry narrates his personal
old days had two marriages, he enlightens
us. One was the aara-antar adopted from
the Hindu rites following which the couple
waited in the baug for the early rays of the
sun to receive the Bamdaad na ashirwad.
With the passage of time the two ceremo
nies came to be performed together and little difference to Mistry as he did not use
Jater the second was discarded. it. Subsequently his left eye had to be
In the course of his study of compara
tive religions Mistry has realized that ev
ery religion is divided into the modality of
rituals and the spiritual aspect. The first functioning. “I keep asking myseff ‘why? ’”
reflects the environment “and cannot be says Mistry.
Does he wear the sudreh-kusti? Yes,
says Mistry to the sudreh because he con-
operated for a triple operation which was a
failure. Three months before he lost the
vision of his left eye, his right eye started
ment, ” he points out. Our attire is now
based on the Hindu dress. Even the style of siders it a very hygienic underwear. Again
the topi — the headgear — has changed,
no longer covering the ears as it used to
"There are only
two people who
never make
mistakes — a
bloody fool
and God"
we probe about the kusti. The answer to
that is yes too “because I know the purpose
of the prayers said. Ninety percent tie it as
a piece of rope. The mind can hear unspo
ken thoughts. It is now proved that the
brain and mind are not the same. The mind
is the functionary of the brain which inter
studied Avesta-Pahlavi
up to the MA level re
minds us that Pahlavi is
a dead language and
Avesta is cent percent prets logic. The brain is like the computer
parallel to Sanskrit. He and yet all computers are brainless, ” main-
relates the incident of tains Mistry.
simulated research
conducted by the religion but he is not as sanguine about the
officers of the Tata community ’s future days ahead. “The fu-
Institute of Funda
mental Research in their
The scientist may have great faith in the
ture of the community is as stupid as that
of the country in general. We have
Hindu priests were made to recite Avestan sincerity to apply it for community use, ”
and Sanskrit prayers backstage before a he laments. “If we could pool our assets we
mixed audience who did not know either could be called one of the richest in the
of these languages. Due to the phonetic
world, physically and mentally. But we
don ’t...”
36 Parsiana April 1996
the prayers as that of their own faith. “I am
our
prayers available to lay people because
verbal translations give stupid and funny
results. Without the philosophical
background the mind gets biased, ” opines
“People believe that if you study more
science, you become godless. But it’s ex-
you can ’t go any further. As an escape
mechanism scientists take the help of a
‘constant, ’ a ‘factor x’ or even an ‘un
known factor. ’ This is an answer to God ’s
work, by use of mathematical equations
and thus God may be a phenomenal index
used to explain unaccountable and unex-
are
progress stops. ”
To cite an instance of the inexplicable
experience. From his childhood he suf
fered from the lazy eye syndrome whereby
he never used his right eye despite his stint
with the airforce when binocular vision
was important. When this eye developed a
cataract it was operated upon but made
matrimonial
Parents of an attractive, fair,
24-year-old, post graduate daughter,
5’6”, invite correspondence from
qualified, well-placed, tall, Zoroastrian
boys. Girl is creative minded and
domestically trained. She desires a
modern and straight-fon/vard life
partner. Apply with recent
photograph (returnable) to:
The Advertiser
Parsiana, Matrimonial (Apr/10-96)*
GPO Box 892, Bombay 400001
‘Please make sure the reply envelope
bears the reference number cited here.
MATRIMONIAL
Parents of a fair, attractive daughter,
25 years, studying for her doctorate
in USA, desire matrimonial
correspondence from suitable, young
Parsi boys, 25-32 years old,
well-qualified and settled in business
or profession in USA. Write in
confidence with photograph
(returnable) to:
The Advertiser
Parsiana, Matrimonial (Apr/12-96)*
GPO Box 892, Bombay 400001
"Please make sure the reply envelope
bears the reference number cited here.
¦4^
*
IBOOKS
The verse below could apply to our age of
all-pervasive corruption:
“Unto Thee, O Lord, the Soul of Creation
cried:
‘For whom didst Thou create me, and who
so fashioned me?
Feuds and fury, violence and the insolence
of might have oppressed me.
None have I to protect me save Thee,
Command for me, then, blessing of a settled,
peaceful life. ’”
In the early stages of his divine mission,
according to The Gathas, Zarathushtra was
The Iranians initially felt let down by troubled by questions for which he had no
this appointment. They had expected, ac- answers but which he dared to put to Ahura
cording to the beliefs then prevailing, that Mazda. He calls upon Ahura to reveal to
a mighty and powerful warlord would be him who balanced the ^arth and heavens to
appointed to fight these destructive forces, keep them apart, who created the waters
Instead, here was a weak man with no ar
mor except “the charm of speech. ” But Za
rathushtra is not deterred and asks for „__________ ______________ __
Can one presume to review The Hymns of the gift of righteousness in action, and for and produced the phenomenon of sleep
Tarathushtra any more than one can re- the wisdom of the Good Mind. He knew and waking? Who made the dawn, noon
view, say, the Bible? One can only bow in that the gift of revelation was not for the and night, that remind man of his duty?
homage to the great truths enshrined in the chosen one alone, but that it was his duty In gradual stagSs Zarathushtra came
noble hymns and be grateful for the schol- to spread the message throughout the to a full realization of God, but continued
arship and dedication of Dinshaw J. Irani, world. He asks for help that would allow to be troubled whether his followers would
Kaikhosrov D. Irani and the K. R. Cama King Vishtaspa, perhaps his earliest disci- achieve the same realization. He wanted
Oriental Institute, who have combined to pie, to propagate the new faith among his them to appreciate that Ahura Mazda is not
, J. , - o --------------- remote from their lives, that indeed He is
little volume. Understanding The Gathas. enable people to decide bet- their brother and father The
One finds portraits of Zarathushtra in ween Spenta Mainyu, the choice was always theirs:
fire-temples and prayer books, and in the spirit of goodness and Ang- f following His teachings
homes of rich and poor. This is the rather re Mainyu, the forces of evil. tUITJl tQ thcS^ to achieve the Abode of
hymns to
discover
is assured of a place in a mission, in the evening of
as he really
was
The
Goodness
of the Gathas
Burjor K. Karanjia
Understanding The Gathas, The Hymns of Zara-
//jushfra.IntroductoryLectureson Gathic Themes
by Dinshaw J. Irani. Edited with an Introduction by
Kaikhosrov D. Irani. Published in 1994 by Ahura
Publishers, Inc. Reprinted in 1995 by K. R. Cama
Oriental Institute, 136, Bombay Samachar Marg,
Bombay 400023. Pp; 87. Price: Rs 50 (for India
and Pakistan only).
and the plants, who yoked swiftness to the
winds and motion to the clouds? What
great artificer created light and darkness
the wisdom of the Good Mind. He knew
that the gift of revelation was not for the
chosen one alone, but that it was his duty
to spread the message throughout the to a full realization of God, but continued
world. He asks for help that would allow
King Vishtaspa, perhaps his earliest disci-
introduce, interpret and reprint thks great subjects. He asks for enlightenment to
enable people to decide bet
ween Spenta Mainyu, the CinP tn
spirit of goodness and Ang- ftCIO llJ
-4*
*
unfortunate fate to which all great prophets
are subject, with the exception of the Is
lamic Prophet Mohammed. The portraits loeai torm ot existence as
of the Iranian prophet are so unlike each envisioned by Ahura Mazda,
other that one puzzles how they could
possibly bear any likeness to Zarathushtra.
One has to turn to these hymns to discover Songs.
Zarathushtra was no
ascetic, preaching with
drawal from the world and
its pleasures. He wanted his followers to
lead a productive life, full of joy, and bring
joy to others. He was the first Prophet to adoration of thy glory. ”
emphasize freedom of choice: “Let each The most haunting and delightful of the
. .... , --------- —-------- t-~~f--------- * Gathas relate to the wedding of the Pro-
and priests, who had imposed a religion accept what they were told, but to think for phet’s daughter Pouruchista to Jamaspa a
of fear upon the people with meaningless themselves, “for a thinking man is where minister in King Vishtaspa ’s court and a
rituals and cruel sacrifices. To confront r ¦¦ •• * • . ...
them and expose their hypocrisy. Lord i
Ahura Mazda, as a discerning judge, chose cording to good thoughts, words and deeds,
a religious act, the finest form of worship.
He anticipated thinkers like the Buddha incorporated in the marriage service:
‘These words do I address to you, maidens
marrying.
These counsels do I give you bridegrooms.
He who chooses rightly and
lives according to Asha, the
ideal form of existence
Songs; if not, be relegated
to the foul darkness of the
House of the Lie.
Towards the end of his
heaven called the House of
Zarathushtra as he really was, with his
doubts and tribulations, his adoration of
Ahura Mazda and fortitude in His service,
his humility in contrast to his exalted
spirituality, the earliest and perhaps the
greatest of prophets, a born leader of men.
Ancient Iran around 1300 BCE was in _
the^thrall of/c(7v;.s ’ and karpans, tribal chiefs choose his creed. ” He wanted people not to
of fear upon the people with meaningless
emphasize freedom of choice: “Let each
young Zarathushtra: “As there is not a
righteous, spiritual Lord, or secular chief/
So have I, indeed, as the Creator, made
thee, Zarathushtra, the leader/For the wel
fare of the world and its diligent people. ”
37 Parsiana April 1996
his life, Zarathushtra did ac
quire a sense of fulfilment.
He realized that Ahura Maz
da ’ s believers and followers
would ultimately be vindi
cated in times of social uncertainty: “Then,
at the time of salvation, there shall be full
themselves, “for a thinking man is where
wisdom is at home. ” A pioneering religious devout follower of the new faith. In fact, as
Dinshaw J. Irani so aptly puts it: “These
thoughts are timeless in their application,
noble in their sentiment, worthy of being
moralist, he made the good life lived ac-
and Gandhi in his belief that social stress
and political violence are to be corrected
not by force, but by moral regeneration.
IHeed them in your mind and lay them to That such encounters — the starting
heart point of the quest for a place in the sun in
Learn from the righteous the precepts of
the Good Religion; disconcerting if not traumatic, is vividly
illustrated in Living in America, a compi
lation of poems and fiction by South Asian boy at New York ’s Hotel Ambassador
American writers. The voices here are of took charge of his suitcases. He simply
exiles who straddle at least two distinct was not ready to let a white man carry his
cultures and are struggling with questions luggage and it was some time before he
realized that the hotel employee “was not
directly related to the Queen of England. ”
That perspectives change and the initial
awe with which the exile regarded his
hosts gives way to criticism, frustration,
alienation and (after much conflict and
One of the excerpts included here is agonizing) to a synthesis of cultures and
from Ms Bapsi Sidhwa ’s novel. An Ameri
can Brat. It describes the ways in which
Sheikh ’s story also sketches in the dif
ference in attitudes of successive genera-
the country of one ’s adoption — can be tions of an immigrant family towards the
host country. His father before him, for
instance, was appalled when a white bell-
Let both then strive to lead the Life of the
Good Mind;
With upright hearts let each cherish the
other;
Then surely a happy life shall be yours. ’”
Immortality, as surmised from these of assimilation and identity. What they are
Gathas, is of two kinds: After death we live doing is participating in the on-going pro
in the recollection of all those who were cess of shaping 20th century American
near and dear to us. But the good we do and literature — even if the rich complexity
the transformation we are able to achieve, they bring to traditional literary norms has
is a more lasting testament to our immor- yet to be fully acknowledged,
tality. Death comes to all, but the degree to
which we reach the spiritual state in after
life depends on the extent of our realization
in consciousness of Truth and the Good Ms Feroza Ginwalla, on a visit to her uncle
MindintheHouseof Ahura Mazda. So we Manek, a student at the MIT, is intimidated
leave Zarathushtra standing, at last, at the by two “demon persecutors ” at the Kennedy example Saleem Peeradina ’s Reflections
on the Otherwhich is hewn out of a “double
consciousness. ” In Ms Qiron Adhikary ’s
the fashioning of a new literary mythology,
is illustrated again and again by the poems
and stories in this volume. Sometimes the
agonizing itself is the poem — as for
i
Gate of the Abode of Songs with this Airport. With their false allegations they
prayer on his lips: ~
“With Truth moving my heart.
With Best Thought inspiring my mind.
With all the might of spiritual force
within me,
I venerate Thee, O Mazda, with songs
of Thy praise!
And at the last when I shall stand at Thy this piece does not disguise the vulnerability
gate of people who enter the brave new world.
I shall hear the echo of my prayers from ’.......................
Thy Abode of Songs. ” States on a visitor ’s visa, though what he
SHELTERING
against the hurt
Dina Mehta
confuse Feroza into unwittingly incrimi
nating her uncle with her naive answers. Nosey Nakshitka ’s Adventures in America
Manek manages to sort things out for the conflict is more down-to-earth: she is
them, but not before Feroza has been overwhelmed by the vast, complex systems
reduced to tears and is ready to catch the of the country and critical of the “many
next flight back to Pakistan. Aapri Bapsi colored peoplej^ese systems oppressed. ”
writes a bouncy prose, but the humor of Ms Meena Alexander in the selection from
Fault Lines included here, talks of the
nurturing of children who liave inherited
Ved Mehta also entered the United multiple cultures. Her daughter puts it in a
5 nutshell: “You are brown mama, papa is
required was a student visa for studying at blond papa, Adam is brown Adam, and I
the Arkansas School for the Blind — which am peach Svati. ” Such acceptance, sug-
was not on the list of approved schools for gests the author, is like creating music out
foreign students, which was why he had
not applied for a student visa in the first
place. All rather complicated. How he indeed makes music as in Darius Cooper ’s
untangles all this in his joust with his I Have Been Offered My Country’s Beg-
immigration officer is told here in an ex- ging Bowl Again in which echoes of Bud
dhism are skillfully woven with the Adam
of discord.
Sometimes the synthesis of cultures
immigration officer is told here in an ex
cerpt from Mehta ’s autobiography, Sound-
Shadows of the New World. The disgruntled and Eve story as the poet keeps vigil over
official becomes helpful towards the end his sleeping wife and son. The humble
of the interview — impressed, no doubt, begging bowl strikes a note of compassion,
by the sheer guts of the blind boy! -
A truly harrowing experience of an
expatriate ’s first day on the land “famous fornia to pursue a doctorate in literature
for the Statue of Liberty ” is related with
wry humor by Moazzam Sheikh in his
In geopolitical terms, South Asia is a vast short story Kissing the Holy Land. (Could
region of mixed ethnic affiliations. A South
Asian can be a native of Afghanistan,
Bangladesh, India, the Maidive Islands,
Myanmar, Nepal, Pakistan or Sri Lanka, always admired American presidents, has (” ’ ‘ ___
And the South Asian experience of America his wallet stolen at the airport by one of the of objectivity and common sense, is aapro
[Canada and the United States for the ~ “
purpose of this anthology edited by Dr the late Lincoln? Of Kennedy? Nixon? from his forthcoming novel. Asylum USA,
(Ms) Roshni Rustomji-Kerns (see inter- " ............ — - - _
view on page 17)] usually begins with an
encounter with the immigration official at
the airport.
Living in America Poetry and Fiction by South
Asian American Writers edited by Roshni Rustomji-
Kems. Published in 1995 by Westview Press,
5500 Central Avenue, Boulder, Colorado 80301 -
2877, USA. Also Westview Press, 12 Hid’s Copse
Road, CumnorHill, Oxford 0X2 9JJ, UK. Pp: xiv+
277. Price: $17.95.
which binds together all of humanity Aapro
Darius is a Bombay boy who went to Cali-
and film. He has presented papers on Indian
cinema at various conferences abroad and
we look forward to his essays on the late
it be that humor builds a shelter against the Satyajit Ray in a forthcoming anthology to
hurt, the frustration, the culture shock suf
fered by immigrants?) Sheikh, who had
be published in India.
Another writer who welds what is In
dian with what is American with a degree
“President-looking men ” — a relative of Boman Desai. In This Thicket, an excerpt
Totally unnerved by his loss, Sheikh weeps Desai takes us from one technique of
with his head on the carpet. “He is kissing storytelling to another, from straightfor
ward narration to philosophical discourses
— a technique used brilliantly in the
the holy land, ” says a voice above him.
“Welcome to America. ”
38 Parsiana April 1996
4^
*
I
«Mahabharata and other classical Indian exploring the concept of this collection, the same name brought out by a fiery
literary works. Desai ’s novel is structured And she has contributed copious headnotes publisher, the late Amrutlal Sheth, in pre-
as if it were a drive in a car, and the ' * ’ - .
‘thickets ’ are the perplexities the driver
ploughs into. Here is one particular
‘thicket: ’
The driver of the car is married to an compile a volume by Parsi writers in _________________ _________
American in order to get his green card, diaspora. Help them emerge into light became free, Sheth shifted to Bombay and
and is awaiting his divorce. But in the ................... ............
meanwhile his parents have sent him their
blessings and gifts — and they want wed
ding pictures. What is he to tell them? That
he is married to a gay and lives with her and
her girlfriend?
From this situation we are led to the
protagonist ’s encounters with racism within
his family (his father thinks he won ’t send
the pics because he’s married to a black
woman), and within the different cultures
he has lived in. We are then drawn into his
struggle to find a solution to end racism —
“skin cancer ” — within all races and hier
archies. 380009). Price: Rs 25. jects like mixed marriages, etc.
A ttiad of Parsi writers in an anthology The collection is, on the whole, feeble
breaking new ground is exciting news! But Phool Chhab means a tray full of flowers, except for the first section of 10 articles,
wait. The distinguished editor, aapri The wicker tray, shallow and circular in which discusses questions of death, nirang ’
Roshni brings the tally to four. She has not shape, artistically woven, is commonly satan, khoreh or aura, patet or seeking the
only given us a taste of new writing, but used by female flower vendors. Almighty ’s forgiveness for one ’s sins, etc.
provided two introductions (one authored The title of Noshir Dabu ’s book re- In these articles the author, well-known to
by herself, the other by Ms Rashmi Sharma) minds this reviewer of a popular paper of Parsi readers as a columnist of Jam-e-
the same name brought out by a fiery
to place each poem and story in context. Independence days from Ranpur,
and discussed their literary nuances. Saurashtra. Like a sentinel it sought to
The writers are in very good hands. One guard the rights of the subjects of the
' former native states. Sheth was also a
bitter critic of the British rule. Once India
can only wish that Roshni will one day
from every corner of the globe!
Admonition
and advice
established an evening paper in Gujarati.
Janmabhoomi was a very popular and well-
edited paper. Today Janmabhoomi, Pravasi
and Phool-Chhab are published under the
aegis of the People ’s Trust, Saurashtra.
Dabu ’s P/ioo/ Chhab, a collection of 27
articles in Gujarati, has been divided into
four broad sections: 'Dini Prakash' throws
a searchlight on some religious problems
concerning the Parsi community; ‘Komni
Karvaf deals with vexing community ques
tions; ‘Kavya Kalrav' is reflection in free
verse on assorted topics; and ‘Chintan ni
Hormazdyar S. Dalal
Phool Chhab — Guru Prasad, Part II by Noshir
Dabu. Published in 1995 by Mehr-e-Band-e-Khuda,
Secunderabad (author ’s address: Gandhi Block,
Parsi Sanatorium, Ashram Road, Ahmedabad Chingari' offers sparkling thoughts on sub-
380009). Price: Rs 25.
Phool Chhab means a tray full of flowers.
The wicker tray, shallow and circular in which discusses questions of death, nirang,
only given us a taste of new writing, but used by female flower vendors.
The title of Noshir Dabu ’s book re-
With Best Wishes
from
Mr Rusy M. Shroflf,
M.B.E.
and
Mrs Purviz R. Shroflf
I
*Jamshed, provides some direction to the
presentgeneration ofthe community which continued from page 17
has lost its moorings. To a large extent it uncomfortable in a luxurious household,
has drifted away from the basic principles We weren ’t brought up in an orthodox and Brian, Charles ’ son by his first mar-
of the ancient faith. household and yet you woke up every riage. The “khichri ” that she speaks at
The next section deals with the desecra- ] ' • " * ’
tion oftheholy navjoteceremony; cultural the loban. It purifies you, it makes you
links between Iran and India; Irani names ready for the day, ” believes Rustomji-
selected for newborn children in Zoroas-
train families; and the knotty problem of
non-Parsi husbands selected by Parsi girls . powerful a hold some of these rituals have, ”
she points out. “To this day I lose my tem
per if the house is dark when I step in.
Chuk (her petname for her husband) knows her own in this city !
that he has to keep one light on. ” The
values of manashni, gavashni, kunashni taken Rustomji-Kems to different parts of
America, Europe, South East Asia and the
grained in her as a child, abide with her but Middle East. Among the places that she
she regrets missing out on navjotes and
“the overwhelming sense of a jashan ”
after residing in America for almost 30 the landscape — “the texture of the earth,
years.
It was the pursuit of higher education
“SURROUNDED BY STORYTELLERS” and distress). Their family stories become
my family stories and vice versa. ” Her
immediate family though includes Charles
household and yet you woke up every
morning to the fragrance of grandma doing home has rubbed off on her husband too
with the result that his vocabulary includes
words like 'ekdam (absolutely) ’ and
Kerns who now continues with this ritual "phataphat (quickly). ’ When in Bombay
in her own home. “It is surprising how she indulges in the care and concern of
family members like for instance her pa
ternal aunt who insists that Roshni have a
companion and not commute by taxi on
The open letter, Parkomi Jamai, is parti
cularly addressed by the author to Parsi
girls who so freely walk out of the commu
nity fold. But Dabu also wishes it to be
taken note of by Parsi boys. The letter is
rather long, running into six printed pages (good thoughts, words and deeds), in-
(69 to 74) and serves a heavy dose of advice.
Section three consisting of five topics
in versified form, is weak and trite. The
first topic, 'Pasti' deals with the human
weakness of preserving unwanted, useless
things in life. But at the same time it is
suggested that human beings carelessly that took Roshni to the States. Her school-
allow their minds and souls to be cluttered
with evil thoughts and sinful actions. The School for Parsi Girls and Karachi ’s Mama may not be able to recollect all the people
simile is far-fetched. Other topics in the Parsi Girls High School. After two years of from her past, their voices have left a firm
section are: Who am I?, Fountain of studv at the Colleee of Home Economics imnrint '
Knowledge, ’ 'Etlun to Karjo Nabi' — a
prayer to the Creator for the dear departed
souls. Prani Pukar is about the agony of University in Beirut. She spent six years in
hunted birds. 'Antar-ni-Aag' tells of the Lebanon and thence proceeded to the Duke was uaiciy lu. u iouk me years lo realize j
soulful repentance of a Parsi girl who University in North Carolina to do her the impact I had. Overnight, old friends
married outside the community; and ] ¦ ~ " • > •• • - — ’
Sodagar deals with Satan ’s call to human her field of study being comparative litera-
Her sojourns, most of them solo, have
would like to visit are China and Peru.
What she misses of Bombay and Karachi is
the sounds, the smells. I think it is the same
for a lot of us expatriates. The birds — the
crows, sparrows, parrots — the bougain-
ing was at Bombay ’s J. B. Vachha High villae, ” she cites in particular. Though she
School for Parsi Girls and Karachi ’s Mama
study at the College of Home Economics imprint,
in Karachi she opted to go to Lebanon
where she graduated from the American
She also carries with her ehildhood
memories of the Indian struggle for free
dom; of Pakistan ’s partitio^from India: “I
was barely 10. It took me years to realize
masters. For her PhD she went to Berkeley, disappeared and new ones came. We never
- r _____ understood why. One day we were speak
beings to follow him in life by rejecting the ture, Sanskrit and Greek. ________________ ing Marathi. The next day we had to learn
path of truthfulness and purity. Spanish is another language Rustomji- Urdu. Karachi was a small quiet town and
The fourth and the last section begins Kerns is conversant with. In fact bits of one fine day we found it jammed with
again with an open letter to young Parsi Spanish are woven into her novel. “There people... ”
boys and girls. “Yuvan tun kon ChheT' is a is a lot of me, lot of my friends in this no- Indian music and dance have always
fervent plea to the youth to sincerely fol- .................. ~ •
low the ways of Ahura Mazda. 'Dukhi
Thavaun Chhe to Bhale' is the topic of the Hispanic culture, Rustomji-Kems found
the need to learn Spanish. “The texture of
life in Mexico, ” she says, “reminds me of enthusiast who had tsained in modern dance
my childhood. ” Since her first visit to the in America for several years until a back
city (Mexico is the world ’s largest city, she problem compelled her to discontinue. Af-
I ter learning the piano at length, she regrets
ture, Sanskrit and Greek.
Spanish is another language Rustomji-
Kerns is conversant with. In fact bits of
is a lot of me, lot of my friends in this no
vel, ” she declares. Being a frequent visitor captivated her, acknowledges Rustomji-
to Mexico and always being interested in Kerns, particularly Bharat Natyam dan-
' J I cing. Given a chance of .another life she
would love to learn this art, confesses the
24th article; it advises the reader to live
without too much grumbling against ad
verse circumstances. Accept life as it is —
with its clouds and sunshine.
The last three articles have nothing informs us) 22 years ago when lack of hotel 1 ’ ’ / \ J.__ ___
much to say. They are insipid, written with accommodation had led her to the house of that she did not pursue it and is now totally
~ ~ ~ out of touch with the keyboard.
Just as she misses the landscape, she
offer of bed and breakfast, Rustomji-Kerns also misses company, Rustomji-Kems has
must have returned to that city umpteen
times. Now she is almost a part of their
a too obvious desire to counsel readers. Signora Glafira Cruz Porras with whom
They employ wornout images, they lack she had boarded for a while, accepting her
artistic skill. "" .......................* - ¦
Phool Chhab sadly suffers from a pau
city of thoughts, too generous slices of
advice and incorrect usage of words. For family and in fact they would not consider
example, ‘KeriRasnePooliniMehfilJame' holding a social function of importance in
on page 3, and 'Jeevanthi Parvadi Hath
Masalta Raheshe' on page 101. The cor
rect Gujarati words are ‘Keri Rasne Poori
and ‘Jeevan thi Parvari.' The book is also
burdened with a sprinkling of wrong spell
ings (jodni) all over the 101 pages.
realized. “A model of someone older. ”
Someone like her father. Observing him
grow old with grace she feels “it’s like a
gift. No complaints; no envy of youth and
her absence, smiles Rustomji-Kerns. on the contrary immense joy to be with the
Removed from their close families, “a youth. ” Contemplating at length on the
lot of us immigrants make families, ” she choice of an appropriate model to pattern
notes. “Not just for social outings pun oneself on she finds that now “I have
dukh-sukh ma oobha thai leva (those who
can be counted upon in times of happiness
become a model for the younger people.
It’s a scary thing... ”
40 Parsiana April 1996MILESTONES
This issue of Parsiana presents
data for the months of March and
April 1996. As the marriage regis
ter was not currently available at
the Bombay High Court, the data
on marriages for these two months
will be published in the May ’96
issue of Parsiana.
There were 147 Zoroastrians
consigned to the Towers of Silence
while 33 babies were born during
these two months. The major
killer, heart disease, claimed 53
lives of whom 22 were 80 years
and above. Twenty-five deaths
were attributed to respiratory
diseases and 12 to cancer. General
debility and old age took a toll of
10 lives, whereas eight patients
succumbed to brain disease. Kid
ney failure and diabetes claimed
four victims each and head
injuries, three. Septicemia, circu
latory disease, gastro-enteritis,
gastro-intestinal bleeding, liver
disease, bronchitis and Parkin
son ’s disease were responsible
for two deaths each. There were
14 isolated cases registered for
the two month period. They were:
hepatitis, malaria, tuberculosis,
uremia, thrombocytopenia (a re
duction in the number of platelets
in the blood), neuro-muscular
dystrophy, intestinal obstruction,
nervous disorder, hernia, asthma,
miscarriage, accident and peri
tonitis (inflammation of the deli
cate serous membrane which lines
the abdominal and pelvic cavi
AHMEDABAD
D ied
Freny Marshall, wife of Ratan
and mother of Rustom on
March 23, 1996
BOMBAY
B orn
A boy to Meherangir and
Jamshed Rangoonwala’ ,
March 5
A girl to Shemaz and Homiyar
Bhumgar; March 8
A boy to Navaz and Darayus
Marolia’ , March 9
A boy to Farida and Adil
Sahukar, March 9
A boy to Firangiz and Eric
Sethna’, March 9
A girl, Ayesha, to Tanaz and
Mark Selwyn’ , March 11
A girl to Farida and Vizak
Ankleshwaria’ , March 12
ties). Two girls, aged 11 and 19, a
40-day-old baby boy and a pre
mature female child were lost to
the community. The oldest to die
was a 101-year-old lady. The
Zoroastrian life expectancy at
birth in Bombay, was 75 years for
the two month period.
The data on births, marriages
and deaths has been compiled
from information supplied by
various newsletters and anjumans
in India and abroad, courts and
hospitals. This information is not
always complete or consistent:
we are unable to carry data from
areas where the anjumans do not
furnish the particulars; the birth
figures for Bombay are supplied
by four hospitals — births in
suburban hospitals and private
nursing homes are not included
unless individuals send us infor
mation together with a copy of
the birth certificate. There may
be an inadvertent repetition of
names in the marriage list when a
civil marriage precedes a religious
ceremony. In the breakup of
deaths according to illnesses, es
pecially of the elderly, death is
often due to a combination of 1 Aspandiyar Khodadad Irani
several diseases.
If readers have any births/
marriages/deaths they would like
published, some proof to ensure Dinamai Edulji Engineer (92),
the veracity of the report would be
required. We are sure our readers
would appreciate this requirement
and cooperate with us.
A boy, Firdous, to Bakhtawar
and Percis Sat ha’ , March 13
A boy, Farzan, to Phiroza and
Mehernosh Surti’ , March 13
A boy to Rashna and Rayomand
Choksi’, March 16
A girl to Jesita and Rajiv
Mehra’ , March 18
A boy to Pervin and Percy
Wadia ’, March 22
A girl to Pervin and Darayush
Contractor, March 25
A girl to Gulshan and Mhernoos
Bhesania’ , March 27
A boy to Shehnaz and Kaizad
Dumasia’, March 31
A boy, Meheryar, to Gulshan
and Rohinton Kasad’ , April 1
A boy to Ketayun and Kurosh
Fallahzadeh’ , April 8
A boy to Renu and Rointan
Katrak’ , April 9
Twins (boys) to Delna and
Tarvinder Singh’, April 9
A boy to Khushman and
Khushroo Cooper, April 10
A girl to Tanaz and Firoz
Batliwalla’ , April 13
A girl to Shernaz and Yazdi
Barooliwalla’ , April 16
A girl to Roshan and Neville
Deboo’ , April 18
A boy to Yasmin and Nariman
Khan’ , April 18
A boy to Rukshana and Hirji
Choksy’ , April 19
A girl to Firozi and Adarbad
Motafram’ , April 22
A girl to Mahtab and Burzin
Daruwalla’ , April 24
A boy to Avan and Fredy Bam’ ,
April 25
A boy to Aban and Kiran
Deohans’ , April 25
A boy to Phiroza and Yezdi
Patel’ , April 25
A boy to Gitanjali and Bahadur
Dastoor, April 27
A girl to Zarine and Dinsha
Singpoorwala’ , April 27
A boy to Anahita and Kersasp
Mistry’ , April 30
D ied
(65), residing at Sukh Shanti
Clny, Chai D/4/6, Tisgaon,
Kalyan (E), 421301; March 2
E/2, Bhiwandiwalla Ter,
Dhobitalao, 400002; March 3
Khodi Behram Irani (73), G/14,
Godrej Bang, Nepean Sea Road,
4(X)036; March 3
Khorshed Jamshed Petigara
(74), Jaiphal Ter, 31, Forjett St,
400036; March 3
< Coomi Pestonji Sethna (80),
Panthaki Hse, 19, Turner Rd,
Bandra 400050; March 3
Ratanbai Minocher Mirzan
(82), 704, Brighton Tower,
Lokhandwalla Complex,
Andheri (W), 400053; March 4
Freny Maneckshaw Mistry (84),
D/2, Jer Baug, Dr Ambedkar
Rd, Byculla, 400027; March 4
So hr ah Navalshaw Patwa (JAr),
4/4, E. M. Est, 291, S. V. Rd,
Bandra (W), 400050; March 4
Maneckshaw Darabshaw
Anklesaria (87), 3/B, High Peak
Apts, S. V. Rd, Bandra, 400050;
March 5
'Soli Ardeshir Palkhiwalla (11'),
Naoroji Hse, Naigaum Cross
Rd, Dadar, ’400014; March 5
Jer Minoo Wadia (76), 619,
Banoo Mans, Jame Jamshed Rd,
Parsi Clny, Dadar, 400014;
March 5
’ Sheroo Savak Gamat (79), 16,
Shiv Sagar, Worli Hill Rd,
400018; March 7
Nerisa Bobby Khambatta (11),
7/18, Blossom Hsg Soc,
Maroshi Rd, Marol, Andheri
(E), 400059; March 7
Purviz Burjor Vakharia (68),
Seervai Bldg A, 20/G, Sleater
Rd, 400007; March 7
, Rusi Kaikashroo Bhagwagar
(75), 247, Veera Hse, Dr
Cawasji Hormusji St,
Dhobitalao, 400002; March 8
Freni Homi Mistry (67), 275/L,
Old Master Bldg, Chikalwadi,
Tardeo Rd, 400007; March 8
Kolan Darabsha Hataria (74),
5, Petit Block, Balaram St,
Grant Rd, 400007; March 9
Kety Kaikhusru Daruwalla (82),
Shirinbai Dinshaw Mody
Hostel, 83-A, Annie Besant Rd,
Worli Naka, 400018; March 10
Vicaji Man&fkji Engineer (97),
599, Sharma Nivas, Jame
Jamshed Rd, Matunga, 40001^;
March 10
Tehmurasp Dinshawji Pavri
(79), D/16, Godrej Baug,
Nepean Sea Road, 400036;
March 10
Khorshed Russi Boyce (64),
C/610, Usha Ngr, Khandelwal
Marg, Bhandup, 400078;
March 11
Manijeh Jamshedji Doriawala
(93), Rusi Mehta Bldg, Dinbai
Petit St, Grant Rd, 400007;
March 11
Bapsy Kersi Edibam (65), R/17,
Shapurji Bharucha Baug, S. V.
Rd, Andheri (W), 400058;
March 11
Khorshed Minoo Chinoy (78),
327, Bhesania Bldg, S.B.S. Rd,
Fort, 400001; March 12
Jer Soli Cooper (64), 648, Kaka
Bldg, Firdoshi Rd, Dadar,
400014; March 12
Gustadji Pestonji Dehnugara
(80), 65, Firoz Villa, Malcolm
Baug, Jogeshwari (W), 400102;
March 12
Shahrukh Nariman Kapadia
(49), 10, Cama Bldg, Marzban
Clny, Gilder Lane, 400008;
March 12
' Savaksha Munchersha Shahuna
(82), 1/25, A. H. Wadia Baug,
Parel Tank Rd, 400033;
March 12
41 Parsiana April 1996
I• 'Alloo Sorabji Bharucha 5,
Dina Bldg, Shrikant Palekar
Marg, Chirabazar, 400002;
March 13
Homi Kawas Bharucha (60),
604/D, Lady Jehangir Bd, Parsi
Clny, Dadar, 400014; March 13
Khorshed Cawasji Fitter (72),
18/6, Mahalaxmiwalla Bldg,
Sleater Rd, 400007; March 13
Nerges Nusserwanji Talaty
(85), M/32, Cusrow Baug, S. B.
Rd, 400039; March 13
Put Ian Rustomji Adajania {^1),
5, Turner Bldg, Gamadia Clny,
Tardeo, 400007; March 14
Mehramai Phirozshah Bilimoria
4, Quest-End, Cuffe
Parade, 400005; March 14
Sorabji Cawasji Elavia (76),
R/20, S. B. Bharucha Baug, S.
V. Rd, Andheri (W), 400058;
March 14
Dhun Pherozeshaw Shrojf {^1),
K/13, Cusrow Baug, S. B. Rd,
400039; March 15
' Tehmina Jalejar Batki (jJl),
di, Rustom Baug, Victoria Rd,
Byculla, 400027; March 16
Goolestan Cavasji Engineer
(80), F. S. Parukh
Dharamshalla, Hughes Rd,
4(X)007; March 16
Perin Jamshed Amroliwala
(86), 5/BC, High Peak Apts,
20/A, S. V. Rd, Bandra,
4(XX)50; March 17
Mani Manekshah Bhadha (80),
Burjor Bldg, Wadia St, Tardeo,
400034; March 17
Farrokh Munchershaw
Bhesania {JS), 8, Asha Mhl, N.
Gamadia Rd, 400026; March 17
Khorshed Burjorji BUlimoria
(89), A/28, Nowroz Baug,
Lalbaug, 400012; March 17
Kersy Darab Kutar (84),
Nanabhai Chmbs, Rustom
Sidhwa Marg, Fort, 400001;
March 17
Goolbai Gustad Irani (80), 25,
Khareghat Clny, Hughes Rd,
400007; March 17
Minoo Ardeshir Katrak (89),
72/B, August Kranti Marg,
400036; March 18
'1. Mahiar Maneksha Dastur (75),
B/2, Jer Baug, Dr Ambedkar
Rd, Byculla, 400027; March 19
1 Minoo Dossahoy Engineer (86),
N/8, Rustom Baug, Victoria Rd,
Byculla, 40(X)27; March 19
Ketie Behramji Katrak (80),
Central Studio Bldg, Tardeo Rd,
400034; March 19
Amy Burjor Mehta (68),
Dalamal Apts, 15, Cuffe
Parade, 400(X)5; March 19
Amy Sorab Pavri (92), 7,
Swastik Court, 132, M. Karve
Rd, 400020; March 20
Banoobai Fakirsha Anklesaria
(83), C/3, Parijat, Patel Est,
Jogeshwari (W), 400102;
March 21
Tehmina Ardeshir Desai (91),
Union Bldg, 54, Sleater Rd,
400007; March 21
Cavas Sorabji Mehta (65), 5/4,
Petit Block, M. P. Agiary Lane,
Balaram St, 400007; March 21
Darabsha Kawasji Patel (92),
Darab Manor, Opp Rly Stn,
Gholvad, 401702; March 22
Dinshaw Dorabji Patel (75),
347/A, United Chmbs, Next to
Shalimar Talkies, Grant Rd,
400007; March 22
Bomanshaw Nadirsha'
Akolawala (86), 14/1,
Dhunbaiwadi, Dadabhai Rd,
Vile Parle (W), 400056;
March 24
Goolbai Framroze Elavia (86),
G-2/11, Shapur Baug, V. P. Rd,
400004; March 24
Tehmina Kaikhushru Mistry
(90), E/21, Cusrow Baug, S. B.
Rd, 400039; March 24
Banoo Camaji Bharucha (81),
Vatcha Gandhi Fire-temple
Comp, Hughes Rd, 400007;
March 25
Jehangir Maneksha Katrak
(73), C. D. Sethna Bldg, Golanji
Hill, Parel Village, 400012;
March 25
Pesi Jamshedji Motiwala (54),
8/B, Mota Mans, Tardeo Rd,
400007; March 25
Bachabai Jehangir Batliboi
(93), Terrace Cama, Altamount
Rd, 400026; March 27
Homi Rustomji Siganporia (73),
C/o Eddie Bhot, 1103, Dun Apt,
Tardeo Rd, 4(X)007; March 27 _____ ____ _
Nergish Pestonji Captain (70), ' Behram Rustomji Mistry (52),
Nawab Manzil, Wadia St, ----- “
Tardeo, 400034; March 28
Najamai Ruttonshaw Nariman
(78), R/32, S. B. Bharucha
Baug, S. V. Rd, Andheri (W),
400058; March 29
Burjor Jehangir Davar (78),
5/B, Heera-Villa, Pali Rd,
400050; March 30
Roshan Jal Khambata (65),
32/33, Bhavashwar Niketan,
August Kranti Marg, 400036;
March 30
Meru Tehemurasp Havewalla
(57), C/o Sheru, 5, Yogita
Bldg, Daulat Ngr, Dahisar (E),
400068; March 31
Jamshed Dorabji Homji (76),
Batliwalla Bldg, Zoroastrian
Clny, Tardeo, 40(X)34;
March 31
'.W
Dhun Faramroze Panthaki (77),
Beach View, 93, Bhulabhai
De^i Rd, 400026; March 31
'^"Iwstom Behram Kermanian
(75), 64/9/B, Wadia Bldg,
Cawasji Patel St, Fort, 400001;
April 1
Perrin Marazban Mehta (78), 5,
Sayaji Bldg, Balaram St, Grant
Rd, 400007; April 1
Ratan Bhikhaji Patel (64),
M/26, Nowroz Baug, Lalbaug,
400012; April 2
Ardeshir Khurshedji Wadia
(88), 61, Las Palmas, 20, Little
Gibbs Rd, 400006; April 2
Adi Savaksha Engineer (87),
Indian Surveyor Hse, Above
Kerala Hotel, 315, S. B. Singh
Rd, Fort Market, Fort, 400001;
April 3
Minoo Kaikhushru Mistry (15),
52/A, Sea Pearl, 7 Bglws,
Versova, 400061; April 3
Framroze Rustomji Titina (72),
Dr Dadina Bldg, Jehangir Daji
St, Sleater Rd, 400007; April 3
Ketty Kaikhushroo Surty (11),
40, Powwalla Bldg, Raja Ram
Mohan Roy Rd, Grant Rd,
400004; April 4
Rati Nariman Kapadia (74),
6/4, Tata Mills Co-op Hsg Soc,
Elphinstone Rd, Parel, 400012;
April 5
Meherbai Barjorji Lal (99), 17,
Sheri Hse, Cawasji Patel St,
Fort, 400001; April 6
¦ Mani Erachshaw Khambatta
(69), Motiwala Bldg, Proctor
Rd, Grant Rd, 400007; April 7
- Dhun Jal Shrojf (66), 41,
Aderbad, Hughes Rd, 400007;
April 7
‘Homi Framroze Chothia (68),
194, Talati Bldg, Khetwadi
Back Rd, 400004; April 8
Cusrow Baug, S. B. Rd,
400039; April 10
Soli Dinshawji Siganporia (78),
Q/1, Cusrow Baug, S. B. Rd,
400039; April 10
Rohinton Ardeshir Tatary (46),
12/3, Baria Bldg, Gamadia
Clny, Tardeo, 400036; April 10
Dinoo From Dhondy (66),
Kumar Villa, 1st Pasta Lane,
Colaba, 400005; April 11
Goal Faredoon Nusserwanji
(63), 22, Usha Kiran, Bank of
India Bldg, Opp Lallubhai Park,
Andheri (W), 400058; April 11
Banoobai Phirojsha Katrak
(92), Vimla Sadan, 8, Navroji
Vakil St, 400007; April 12
Bejanjee Bomanshaw Surtee
(84), 51, Hill Rd, Bandra,
400050; April 12
^Meharwan Naswarnji
Taraporewalla (80), Post Barda,
Via Vangoan, Dist Thane,
400601, April 12
Sharukh Jehangir Nanji (45),
Om Yogeshwar, Kanderpada,
Dahisar (W), 400068; April 13
Shavak Sorabji Tata (90), 29,
Jaiphal Ter, Forjett St, 400036;
April 13
Bhickoo Bejoh Chinoy (84),
G/38, Cusrow Baug,^S. B. Rd,
400039; April 14
Rustamji Faran^i Karanjia
(83), Yusuf Bldg, Mehella Patel
Agiary Lane, Balaram St,
4(X)007; April 14
Minoo Kaikobad Tarapore (75),
794/C, Family Hse, Jame
Jamshed Rd, Parsi Clny, Dadar,
400014; April 14
J Dolly Jahanbux Bhathena (69),
5, Karani Widow Chwl, Gilder
Lane, Tardeo, 400007; April 15
Burjor Nusserwanji Dantra
(72), 13, Shri Vallabh Co-op
Hsg Soc Ltd, Murbad Rd,
Kalyan, 421301; April 15
Ketty Phiroaz (Parushesp)
Daruwalia (75), Railway Clny,
4*
42 Parsiana April 1996
36/A, Engineers Bglw, Sunmill
Rd, Lower Parel, 400013;
Aprils . _ _____
Goal Marzban Master (88), Hill Taloja, 410208; April 15
View, 25, N. S. Patkar Marg, “
400007; April 9
Rodabe Rus turn Vankadia (60),
35, Vidya Vihar Clny, Chakan
Rd, (Dist) Pune, 411001;
April 9
Dinshaw Behramji Chinoy (74),
11/2, Rustom Baug, Victoria
Rd, Byculla, 400027; April 10
Mani Savak Choksey (85),
Divine Grace, 114, Turner Rd,
Bandra, 400050; April 10
Dhunmai (Dhun) Eruchsha
Dotivala (83), 4/6, Rustom
Baug, Victoria Rd, Byculla,
400027; April 10
Dolly Minoo Driver (55), F/20,
From Sorabji Merchant (81),
602, Shiv Shakti, Caesar Rd,
Amboli, Andheri (W), 400058;
April 15
Ardeshir Cawasji Todywala
(85), E/44, Jer Baug, Dr
Ambedkar Rd, Byculla, 400027;
April 15
Khorshed Godrej Unwalla (82),
609, Mercury Apts, 4th Cross
Rd, Lokhandwala Complex,
Andheri (W), 400058; April 15
Goolbai Meherji Bharucha
(82), Chhatriwala Bldg, Wadia
St, Tardeo, 400034; April 16
Mani Kaikhushroo Chinoy (86),
751, Rustom Villa, Dr GhantiRd, Parsi Clny, Dadar, 400014;
April 16
Dhunmai Jehangirji Vajifdar
(101), 91, Cuffe-Castle, Cuffe
Parade, 400005; April 17
¦ 'Ratanshah Manekji Bhura (79),
F. S. Parukh Dharamshalla,
Hughes Rd, 400007; April 18
Villie Ker si Chavda (19), C/o
Noshir D. Chavda, A/201,
Bafna Apts, Mugal Lane,
Matunga (W), 400019; April 18
Rusi Maneckshaw Daruwalla
(78), 319, Samudra Mhl, Dr
Annie Besant Rd, 400018;
April 18
'Jamshed Rustum Ahrestani (84),
18, Wadia St, Tardeo, 400034;
April 19
ip Baby girl of Jasmine Hormaz
Daruwalla (miscarriage), C/20,
Rustom Baug, Victoria Rd,
Byculla, 400027; April 19
¦^‘ Najamai Ratansha Katrak (95),
Gamadia Bldg, Wadia St,
Tardeo, 400034; April 19
'¦ Nariman Ardeshir Palkhiwala
(66), 785/A, M. Joshi Rd, Parsi
Clny, Dadar, 400014; April 19
Bhikan Shapurji Govadia (92),
600, Bachan Manor, Jame
Jamshed Rd, Matunga, 400019;
April 20
Eduljee Jamshedji Nilgiriwala
(80), E/22, Jer Baug, Dr
Ambedkar Rd, Byculla, 400027;
April 20
-' Goolhai Erachshaw
Taraporewalla (87), E/10, Jer
Baug, Dr Ambedkar Rd,
Byculla, 400027; April 20 _____ , .
¦ Gool Framroz Mirza (74), AJh, Sarosh 'jamshe7Irani (39) 6
Tardeo Chmbs, Cassinath Rd, - •
Tardeo, 400034; April 21
Jeroo Rusi Patel (65), Lam
Bldg, Delisle Rd, Lower Parel,
400013; April 21
Jal Minocher Pavri (65), 650,
Karani Charity Bldg, Firdoshi
Rd, Parsi Clny, Dadar, 400014;
April 21
Homi Jehangir Presswalla (86),
Presswalla Bldg, 190,
Lamington Rd, 400007;
April 21
Rusi Pirojsha Sidhwa (67), 4,
Sheetal, Chirabazar, 400()02;
April 21
' Ramyar Darabshaw
Sukheswalla (76), 788, Avabai
Mans, Jame Jamshed Rd, Parsi
Clny, Dadar, 400014; April 21
Banoo Eruchshaw Gandhi (78),
3/8, Panthaky Raug, Sanatorium
Rd, Hargovindas Marg, Andheri
(E), 400069; April 23
Dhunbai Manchersha Tata (2,5), -F Kety Cooverji Mistry (45)
F. S. Parukh Dharamshalla, .............
Hughes Rd, 400007; April 23
BORN
Boys
Girls
A
21
12
43 Parsiana April 1996
TOTALS FOR 1996
Bombay
B A
India
B
A
World
B
34
26
3
1
1
3
MARRIED
Parsi
Intercommunal
DIED
CONSIGNED
Male
Female
CREMATED
Male
Female
63
84
64
17A
142
167
1
6
7
2
3
26
19
13*
6*
A: Total numbers in this issue
B: Running totals for 1996 (February-March 1996-April 1996 issues)
'' Males married out - 9
Females married out - 8
* Overseas deaths are listed in the consigned column as Parsiana does not have a breakup of those cremated.
UISSSiJSf '"•O'^ation provided to or collected by Parsiana. They do not reoresent the total
number of births, marriages and deaths in the Zoroastrian community in India and Xld
(’'Mani Jamasp Tata (80),
Husanali Bldg, 5, Jijibhai
Dadabhai Lane, Fort, 400001;
April 23
'' Mani Sorabji Wachagandhi _________
(93), 6, Nadirsha Dinshaw Bldg, Jamshedji Tata Bldg, Vv Rd
2, Babulnath Rd, 400007; _ .
April 24
A^ Keki Rustom Avari (81), Shroff
Mans, N. Petit St, Grant Rd,
400007; April 26
Perin Sorabji Colabawalla
(86), 38, Dubash Bldg,
Walchand Hirachand Marg,
Fort, 400(X)l; April 28
Mani Jal Laskari (86), 5,
Bandra (W), 400050; April 28
Khorshed Dali Mistry Ifil),
Mistry Hse, 49, 3rd Marine St,
Dhobitalao, 400002; April 28
'Bahadur Byramji Udwadia
(IW), Kavarana Bldg, Dadar
Cross Rd, 400014; April 29
Aris Zarir Patel (40 days), BJl,
Godrej Baug, Off Nepean Sea
Rd, 400036; April 30
Rati Ardeshir Petigara (79),
Hornby View, Rustom Sidhwa
Marg, Fort, 400001; April 30
20/3, Mod^Clny, Camp,
411001; March 15
Nanabhai Jejeebhoy (?,7), Viloo
Villa, Church Rd, 41io6,;
March 19
Ardaiviraf Nosherwan Irani
((>3), Alh, Hermes Tower, 618,
Sachapir St, 411001; March 19
4^
*
Engineer Hse, Dhobitalao,
400002; April 26
ir ‘Mani Kaikhusroo Khambatta
(83), New Khan Bldg,
Chikalwadi, Tardeo, 400007;
April 26
k'^Nusserwan Dhunjisha Mistry
(74), 4, Mody Trust Bldg, Parel
Tank Rd, 400012; April 26
U Dina Maneckji Mody (80),
Navaz Mans, 25, S. B. Rd,
400039; April 26
; Gool Jal Adaggra (87), 11,
Vikas, 31, Peddar Rd, 400026;
April 27
Eruch Jehangirji Billimoria _______
(75), Kashinath Bldg, Kashinath Firdose Vandrevala; March 14
St, Tardeo, 400034; April 27
Jehangir Fardoonji Dhalla
(76), Sorab Manor, Henry Rd,
Colaba, 400005; April 27
Aloo Eruch Engineer (75), 594,
Wadia Bldg, J. S. S. Rd,
400002; April 27
CALCUTTA
M arried
Shehnaz Dalal and Sudeep Roy;
April 19
D ied
Najoo Kapadia, wife of Homi
and mother of Aspi and Jeroo
Jamshed Kotwal, son of Soona
and Ardeshir and brother of
Piloo Gan; April 30
Khalakdina Ter, Gowalia Tank,
400036; April 27
POONA
D ied
Gool Rustom Sethna (102),
Bund Garden Rd, 411001;
March 11
Gulbai Kekashru Writer (92),
SURAT
D ied
Hormasji Fakirji Variava (92),
Vegalpur, Parsiwad. Broach,
392001; March 1
Homai Jalejer Bhagat (86),
Umra Jakat Naka; March 10
Dinamai Ardeshir Tavadia (82),
Diwanjiwadi, Rustompura,
395002; March 12
Rustamji DosabHoi Patel
(Bhesania) (65), Divali Baug,
Athwa Lines, 395001;
March 16
Bepsi Manchersha Katpitia
(80), 11/2429, Muglisara,
395003; March 27
Eruchshaw Ardeshir Billimoria
(80), Near Nagarelas ’ Wadi,
Shahpore, 395003;
April 3
CORRECTION
A boy, Zal, was born to
Farinaz. and Marzin Shroff.
The mother ’s name wa,s
mistakenly printed as Parizad
h Parsiana, February-March
1996. The error is regretted.
Compiled by Roxana A. Driver
IIN MEMORIAM
Jungalwalla:
indoctrinating health
Parinaz Gandhi
a latrine be built near her hut also. Refusing
the payment, Jungalwalla assured her that
a latrine would be built for her too. When
the sanitary engineer objected saying it
was outside the purview of the Institute,
the doctor answered that the payment would
be borne by him personally, the incident
was reported in The National Medical
A firm believer in the efficacy of prayers. Journal of India (November-December Died: Dr Nowshir Kaikobad Jungalwalla,
82, founder director of the Government of he had related to his wife Piloo, reputed for 1995). On another occasion an old peasant
India ’s National Institute of Health Edu- her discourses and books on the Zoroas- who wanted to show his appreciation to the
cation and former director of the World trian religion, the incident when he was on doctor, came to him at the Institute with his
Health Organization ’s (WHO) Health Unit, duty with an ambulance brigade engaged life ’s savings, all in small coins, totalling
on May 8, 1995 following Alzheimer ’s in mine sweeping and the explosion of a several thousand rupees. With the donor ’s
disease at London ’s Ealing Hospital. mine hit two men — killing one and injur- consent it was decided to use the money to
Referring to Jungalwalla as “one of his
country ’s most distinguished medical sci
entists ” Morocco ’based Dr K. W. C. Sin-
clair-Loutit who had in the 1950s worked post, he fervently prayed the Yatha. An-
with Jungalwalla at the newly started South other occasion when Jungalwalla had to
East Asia regional office of the World
Health Organization in Delhi, acknow
ledged in his condolence letter,
“I did indeed appreciate his
professional leadership and
even more his human qualiti
es of kindness and of humor. ”
Jungalwalla had then been
appointed consultant, venereal
diseases, by the WHO. There
after he served a three-year
term as WHO’s first represen
tative to Indonesia. A certifi
cate of appreciation from the
Indonesian health ministry as also two
large wooden panels carved by Balinese Yatha in thanksgiving,
artists was that country ’s way of showing
their gratitude. Two decades later he was
appointed the WHO representative to India, public health commissioner, ministry of
The story of how Jungalwalla had earn- education. Government of India. In the in-
ed his Order of the British Empire (among terim period between his WHO appoint-
the last Indians to be conferred that distinc
tion) as a doctor in charge of a military hos- institutes in India. As acknowledged Dr P.
pital during World War II, is interestingly K. Khosla, secretary of the National Aca- College of Physicians which appointed
narrated by Sinclair-Loutit. Able to satisfy demy of Medical Sciences (India), Jungal-
almost all the whims and fetish of the gen
eral relating to cleanliness and neatness,
Jungalwalla so impressed his inspector a national loss “particularly (for) the medi-
that he was even invited to dine at the divi
sional headquarters — a rare privilege!
When the doctor was called up for war
service, he was posted somewhere in a
desert in Egypt, notes his bio data. He was
given the charge of the venereal diseases kind in South East Asia. Identifying remo-
section of a 1,000-bedded hospital. As te villages in need of fresh water and sani-
remarked Col K. N. Khosla commander of tation was part of his job. On one such trip
the hospital, “If Nowshirbh.ai says 'koshish he was approached by a poor woman who
karunga (I will try), ’ the take it from me
that the work is done. ”
her discourses and books on the Zoroas
trian religion, the incident when he was on
r •
44 Parsiana April 1996
¦
in mine sweeping and the explosion of a
mine hit two men — killing one and injur
ing another. Carrying the dead man in his help treat tuberculosis,
arms while giving cover to the other with
his body until they reached the first aid achievement was ’the founding of the Na
tional Institute of Health Education, ” Gov
ernment of India, later renamed the Na
tional Institute of Health and Family Plan
ning, states his wife. Among Jungalwalla ’s
doctor, insisted on serving him other appointments with the Government
during the Delhi riots of 1946.
Once when Jungalwalla was
driving to a hospital in old
Delhi, he was held up by a
gang of armed hooligans who cal Sciences, mentions hi^bio data,
insisted on inspecting his car.
They saw an old, torn, army
blanket lying crumpled near the Rangoon University winning a gold
the back-seat of the car, never
suspecting that the Pathan lad
lay trembling beneath it. They was conferred the Fellowship of the Royal
waved the car on, the doctor reciting the College of Physicians. It was a decade la
ter that he was awarded a fellowship to do
his masters in public health from the Johns
fall back on the Yatha was when an order
ly, a young Pathan lad dedicated to the
4®
“Nowshir himself felt that his greatest
of India were as additional director gen
eral, health, an^ as convenor and honorary
treasurer, National Board of Examinations
affiliated to the All India Institute of Medi-
Jungalwalla, whose roots were in
Burma, had earned his MBBS degree from 4*
medal for standing first class first. After
his MD he proceeded to London where he
In 1946 Jungalwalla had reverted to
civilian life, working for a while as deputy Hopkins University, Baltimore, USA.
The expertise that he had gained over
the years was put to use by UNESCO
(United Nations Educational, Scientific
ments the doctor was building up health and Cultural Organization), the Union Pub-
¦ ..... ...................* ~ lie Services Commission as also the Royal
walla “evinced keen interest in the promo
tion of medical sciences. ” His demise was
cal profession and different organizations
including ours, ” he added.
He served as director of the All India
Institute of Hygiene and Public Health,
Calcutta, reportedly the only institute of its
him consultant. The last named organi
zation appointed him their first represen
tative in India. To Jungalwalla goes the
distinction of being listed in the Indian
Who’s Who, as also the British, American
and Canadian Who’s Who. Despite his fail
ing health and the onset of Alzheimer ’s
disease in 1993, the American Biographi
cal Institute nominated him Man of the
Year in 1992 and 1994 and conferred on
him an honorary professorship in 1993.
Jungalwalla is survived by his wife
Piloo, and son Hoshang who is a consultant
was willing to part with her worldly wealth psychiatrist in geriatrics affiliated to the
of two rupees to reinforce her request that National Health Service, UK.
«
◆ ◆ ◆
From the archive
