Complete Issue
Dec 1995
k
r
tl
1
I
1
t
I
v:
1^'-
^^•i
J.
<-
/
f
A 1905 Ri
«-
e
* i:
^1
»
t
• d
>
V J
W
>
I
z
<
w
.t « X
*-
<
-1
J'
I <
I
I
5v
*<.
s
1
*
¦¦^^<1
1u
• >
<3December 1995
Volume 18 Number 5
EDITOR Jehangir R. Patel
MANAGING EDITOR Arnavaz S. Mama
EXECUTIVE EDITOR Parinaz M. Gandhi
SENIOR EDITOR Dina K. Mehta
ASSOCIATE EDITOR Roxana A. Driver
DESIGN Kranti M. Shilotri,
Varghese W. Fernandez, Jayshree R. Ghosh
MARKETING DIRECTOR Veera Patel
ADVERTISING MANAGER Zarin Mistry
ADVERTISING EXECUTIVES
Niloufer Panthaky, Susan Hadvaid
FINANCE B. L. Arora
EDP Rohinton E. Daroga
ADMINISTRATION R. S. Pingle
MANAGEMENT Jasmine Driver
DTP Bakhtavar R. Batliwalla, K. P. Ravi
SUBSCRIPTION/CIRCULATION
Khurshid Panthaki, Bindu Pillai
ACCOUNTS Anagha Korde
OFFICE Swarupa Kamat, Varsha Ashar,
Indu Pillai
OFFICE ASSISTANTS Umesh Poojary,
Selvan Mark, Sunil Sakhare, Pramod Patil,
Govind Salgaonkar, Mahipat Jadhav
2 Readers’ Forum
10 Events and Personalities
16 Zoroastrians Abroad
20 Tehran Beckons World Zoroastrians
25 The Masanis: Flower Power by Parinaz Gandhi
30 The Federation and future fears by Arnavaz Mama
39 Status of Women: sacred and secular - 3 by Dr Ketayun Gould
43 Rustam Maneck - 5: A family In decline by Dr Homi Eduljee
50 Milestones
Cover: Flowers exported by the Masanis
Parsiana is published by Jehangir R. Patel
for Parsiana Publications Pvt Ltd at C/o H. L.
Rochat, Navsari Chambers, ground floor,
39 A. K. Nayak Marg, Fort, Bombay 400001
and printed by him at Kaiser-E-Hind Pvt Ltd,
300 Perin Nariman Street, Bombay 400001.
Color processing. Comart Lithographers;
black and white processing, Samir Scantech.
All rights reserved. ISSN: 0971-3786.
Phone: 2048730 Fax: 2042922. For editorial
enquiries 2048183. Tlx: 11-85710 RABO IN.
For subscription enquiries and payments:
C/o Kaiser-E-Hind Pvt Ltd, 300 Perin Nariman
St (Behind Reserve Bank of India), Bombay
400001; Phone: 2658619, 2665661.
Annual inland subscription for one year
(10 issues) Rs 200; for two years (20 issues)
Rs 375. Foreign subscription rates: Seamail for
one year Rs 375/US $ 14/UK £ 9; for two
years Rs 700/US $ 23/UK £ 15 (please allow
six months or more for delivery from the time
of publication). Airmail for one year
Rs 700/US $ 23/UK £ 15 (for Pakistan,
Indian Rs 500); for two years, Rs 1,300/US $
43/UK £ 27 (for Pakistan, Indian Rs 950).
For Indian upcountry cheques add Rs 10 for
bank charges; for US cheques add $ 5;
for UK cheques add £ 3. Cheques and drafts
are to be drawn in favor of Parsiana and posted
to GPO Box 892, Bombay 400001.
3
I
I
IREADERS' FORUM
Readers' views are welcome on any subject
of interest to the community and should
be sent to the Editor, Readers' Forum,
Parsiana, G.P.O. Box 892, Bombay 400001.
Letters are subject to editing for reasons of
space and clarity. Unsigned letters or those
without an address will not be published.
article, he never indicated his complaint or
any objection to it.
In his letter Dastur Noshirwan vaguely
objects to misunderstanding the implica- modernization make you forget your race,
your roots, and above all, your religion.
In one or two generations, do not wipe
yourselves out and please, please do not
wipe out the magnificent achievements
Please, please, do not let this poison gas
of pseudo-liberalism seduce and suffocate
you; please do not let this tidal wave of
tions of the article. But he does not point
out or quote any paragraph, sentence or
word in the article which he misunder
stood or found objectionable.
Further, DasturNoshirwan complains and the innumerable sacrifices of our fore-
against ‘observations and viewpoints ’ on fathers. What tortures they suffered to
‘conversion ’ without quoting any evidence, keep their race and religion alive — and to
He does not state his own observations and keep you alive. Will you throw away your
entire history and your entire heritage, just
because of your ignorance of, or indiffer
ence to, our religion?
We need reforms, but not such reforms
as will result in the extermination of our
views on conversion, and does not explain
why what he thinks (but does not state in
this matter) is correct.
In the article signed by all five Dasturs,
scriptural evidences from the Gathas,
Avesta, Pahlavi and Pazand texts have community, and worse, in the extinction of
been quoted. These are simply ignored by
Dastur Noshirwan. He does not state
whether he agrees or not with the scriptural
interpretations, and if he does not, offers
no correct translation or interpretation.
Dastur Noshirwan writes about his ‘re
alization ’ and ‘furtherrealization, ’ but these
occurred to him evidently much after the
article was published on December 24,
1995.1nhis ‘realization, ’ DasturNoshirwan qualities, our future in a w6rld of savage
adopts a negative attitude. He observes competition will be bleak, very bleak.
-.1 . , Let us prepare for this future, let us get
our priorities and institutions right. Let us
concentrate on priorities, not on triviali
ties.
But, above all, let us, in shaping our
future, not forget our past. Let us, in pro-
t to
commisioner, Bhopal, M. P., has issued us promote religious education, for, if the salt
a letter that donors to our anjuman from
April 1, 1995 to March 31, 1998 would be
entitled to relief under Section 80-G of the
our religion.
We need to get our priorities right. We
need modern education such as will enable
our young men and women to be in the
forefront of economic progress and job
opportunities. We need to launch financial
institutions (miltual funds, banks, trusts)
so as both to promote education and to
foster entrepreneurship, for without these
silence on important matters and does not
explain what his views are in the matter.
Dastur (Dr) HORMAZDYAR K. MIRZA
For self and on behalf of my colleagues
“New home for Mhow fire”
We are happy to state that the income-tax moting modern education, not forget
4'
*
“The Priests’ Rebuttal”
This refers to the letter of Dastur Noshirwan
Manchershah Dastur of Surat following
the article “The Priests ’ Rebuttal, ” (Par-
siaria, November 1995). The article was
originally published in the Jam-e-Jamshed Income-tax Act, 1961.
and The Bombay Samachar of December
24, 1995 with the signatures of five High
Priests (including his own).
We wish to state the bare facts in this
matter. The said article was prepared in
Bombay and sent by courier service to
Dastur Noshirwan at Surat who signed and
returned it to Bombay. The said article was
in his possession for seven clear days to
read, consider and approve it, or if he had Setting priorities right
any reservations, to reject it. After seven ' • • -
days of consideration and understanding,
our colleague decided to approve, and
signed the article.
During these seven clear days and any
time thereafter, our colleague never raised
any question nor demanded any explana
tion. Even after the publication of the and be likewise.
has lost its savor, wherewith shall it be
salted?
Liberalization does not mean licence.
Shaping the future does not mean burying
the past. Secularism-does not call for sui
cide.
Our greatest enemies are not non-Parsis
— our greatest enemies lie within. At a
time when almost every ethnic and reli
gious group in the world is prepared to die
to preserve its identity, we are the only
community in the world dying to die.
Let a mass movement for conversion be
__ _ started — the conversion of Parsis into
To be patriotic Indians does not mean that Zoroastrians.
we must cease to be Parsis. To be secular
Indians, does not mean that we must sur
render the immortal glories of our religion.
Remember what Sir Pherozeshah Mehta Parsis and the 1991 CCnSUS
said: “I am an Indian first and an Indian
last, but in between, I am a Parsi. ” Go ye.
We have posted certificates to this ef
fect to our donors. In case, however, any
donor has not received the same, we would
request such donors to write to us.
We are confident that intending donors
will now help us in our project of complet
ing our Adran Saheb. b. m. masani
Hon Secretary, Parsi 2;oroastrian Anjuman, Mhow
Reforms... yes, revolt... no, extermina
tion... never ! Ms KETI and Dr FREDIE A. MEHTA
The report that the Parsi population in
India has registered an increase according
to the 1991 census in spite of an excess of
2 Parsiana December T995
INew Year
LORD’S
CENTRAL
HOTEL
Enjoy the
mountains,
monkeys and
our hospitality
500 deaths over births per year (Parsiana, •From Christians (as represented by the
July-August 1995) is indeed intriguing. I Jesuits) celibacy which was extolled, and
believe there could be two reasons for this:
•Intermarried Parsi ladies may have shown
their offspring as Parsis through clandes
tine ‘navjotes. ’ These data would be re- •From Zoroastrianism (represented by
fleeted in the census but not in our commu
nal figures.
•Decrease in emigration (i.e. those going making light (Sun and Fire) the object of
abroad for studies and those coming back).
Most of these boys and girls are unmarried
and hence this effect is not reflected in our
birth rates.
Over the last five years I have main
tained in several letters in Parsiana as well of each religion prevented the actual imple-
as Jam-e-Jamshed Weekly that emigration mentation. Each of the religions believed
is the root cause of our dwindling popula
tion in India because it has a cumulative
effect on the decline, not only because of Din was never accepted. The Din was
emigration per se but also by decreasing regarded by Akbar ’s contemporaries as
the number of families and also by leading
to intermarriages due to the created short
age of educated boys earning good sala
ries. If this trend of decreasing emigration
continues, the Parsi population in India
will show further increase in the next cen
sus in 2001 AD. Dr p. d. sunavala
carnal sin condemned;
•Like Jainism, the slaughter of animals
was forbidden;
Dasturji Meherji Rana and another dastur
from Kerman) was borrowed the ritual of
divine worship; and,
•From Hinduism he borrowed the recital of
1,000 Sanskrit names of the Sun.
Though the motive was lofty and noble,
and the Din praiseworthy, the orthodoxy
that their own faith was truly superior and
worthy. This led to a lot of discord and the
Matheran 410102
Telephones
Matheran 021483-0228
Bombay 3867776
“Muslim apostasy ” or heresy, and Akbar
himself had soon to abandon the idea, to
prevent further deterioration.
One can therefore appreciate that at
best the Din was a set of loosely put
together ethical doctrines collected from
various religions, which functioned to build
up a personality «ult, contrived by the
“Priestly tales” superior intellect of Akbar, to attract full
I read Mr Kersee Kabraji ’s letter with great allegiance to himself rather than a religious
interest (“Priestly tales, ” Parsiana, Sep
tember 1995). Though I lay no claims
whatsoever to being a scholar, I have a
smattering of knowledge about this subject
which I humbly share not only with Mr principles of the Dih compare with our
Kabraji, but with readers who may find it
informative.
The Din-E Ilahi (Divine Faith) was compared at all, for the simple reason that
never an established religion fdr the masses, while accepting the ritual of the divine
even during Akbar ’s lifetime, but at best, worship of light, he appeared not to have
as. Mr Kabraji quotes, was an “ecletic grasped the basic beauty of our religion
cult. ” viz., righteousness, purity and the immor-
Akbar used to invite scholars to his tality of the soul, nor even its practise in
court from among the Muslim, Hindu, simplicity through humata, hukhta,
Parsi, Christian and Jain communities of hvarashta.
his empire, and encourage them to hold
free and scholarly debates and discourses there is a traditional belief in my husband ’s
before him in the court, because at first he family that a physician by the name of
was genuinely interested in and curious MeherVaid accompanied Dasturji Meherji
about all the faiths in his empire. Soon,
however, with his keen intellect he real
ized that most of the religious tenets were payment, he was given a grant of land at
common, but if he could get them to have
others imbibed into a common system, he
could bring about a practical and social
unification of all the religions. He, there
fore, went about including various tenets
from each religion, and loosely unified
them into his ethical system of Din-E Ilahi:
•Thus from Islamic Sufi mysticism he North American directory
enjoined constant yearning for God to The most comprehensive directory of North
purify the soul; American Zarthustis ever produced is near
system. Even during his lif^ime there
were just 19 followers actively professing
and practising the Din.
To answer the query “How do the basic
Lord Zarathushtra ’s teachings? ” I would
comment that I don ’t think they could be
Though it is irrelevant to this topic,
Rana to Akbar ’s court and was responsible
for curing the Emperor ’s lame horse. As
Navsari, which was passed on from eldest
son to eldest son. The last holder of this
“Tamrapatra ” was the late Mr Bomanji
Pestonji Master, who passed away a few
years back. Dr (Ms) roshen s. master
Pune
4 Parsiana December 1995
¦BOYS’ TOWN
Public School
Nasik 2
Recognised as a Public School
by the Department of Educa
tion for Indian Merit Scholars.
Excellent Climate -- All-
round Education.
A new two-storeyed dormitory
with attached bathrooms, study
and lounge rooms has just been
completed to house 180 boys.
All Academic Subjects —
Technical Subjects: Work
shop Technology, Mechanical
& Electrical Maintenance,
Carpentery & Farming. Train
ing in Self-Government
through Elected Boys ’ Office
bearers. Games — Physical
Training - Daily Assembly
with Congregational Prayers
— Weekly intensive Zoroas-
trian —Geeta —Koran classes -
Excellent Modern Kitchen
and Dining Room facilities.
Moderate Fees. Concessions to
Deserving Students.
Apply to
THE MANAGING
TRUSTEE
P. N. MEHTA EDUCATION
TRUST
Cooks Building
324, Dr D. N. Road
Bombay 400001
ing completion. It will contain over 3,000
entries of Zarthusti households in USA
and Canada (a household is defined as a
family with children under age 18, or a
single person over the age of 18). The
directory will be an important reference
book for all Zarthustis not only in North
America but also around the world.
The publication of the directory and
compilation of census data is a 10th anni
versary project of the Federation of Zoro-
astrian Associations of North America
(FEZANA). We request you to support
this grass-root volunteer community project
by advertising in it. The directory will be
available at a very nominal cost, so that no
Zarthusti home will remain without it.
We invite you to advertise your busi
ness or your profession in the directory.
Since virtually all Zarthustis are highly
educated with successful professional and
business careers, the users of this directory
will represent a tremendous buying power
for the goods and services that you are
offering.
In addition to advertising your business,
you could also support this project by
inserting a commemorative or an “in me-
moriam ” message. This would be an effec
tive vehicle to honor people, events and
your community with your financial
support.
The success of this directory and of the
Zarthusti community in North America
will depend on the number of individuals
and businesses that come forward with
financial support. Your advertisement will
not only maJte all Zarthustis aware of your
services and products, but will also support
present and future FEZANA efforts to
promote Zarthusti enterprise. Our rates
range from US $ 40 for a business card to
US $250 for a full page. Half page and
quarter page cost US $125 and 70 respec
tively. The cover rates are US $ 1,500 for
the back page, US $ 750 for the inside back
page and US $1,000 for the inside front
page.
Please contact any of the following
individuals on the phone:
Dr (Ms) Yasmin Ghadiali, New York (Res)
516-378-4516
Noshir Hansotia, Kansas (Bus) 913-469-
0077 (Res) 913-422-5915
Homi Davier, Houston (Bus) 713-270-5519
(Res) 713-242-3808
Homi Gandhi, New Jersey (Bus) 212-656-
5689 (Res) 201-445-3917
Pervaze Rabadi, Toronto (Res) 905-846-
6177 Ms DOLLY P. DASTOOR
President, FEZANA
With
best wishes
from
*
Farah
&
Tanya
6 Parsiana December 1995I
i
I
and fire-temples were stoned and attempts
were made to desecrate them. At this fearful
time when other sethias were silent or went
out of Bombay , it was Dhunjibhoy Bomanji
who came out in support of and stood by
the community, giving courage and de
fending them in several ways. He used his
influence with the Government to obtain
small arms to defend our fire-temples.
Because of this, anticipated attacks against
our atash behrams and places of worship
were prevented.
His baj is performed by grateful com
munity members every year on roj Zam-
yad, mah Meher. He passed away on April
1, 1937. His photo appears on the reverse
of the title page of the bookParjj Lustre on
Indian Soil (Vol, I) by H. D. Darukhana-
walla. This volume has been dedicated to
his memory.
Those interested in more details can
read the dedicatory page in this book as
also his obituary inParsi Prakash (vol, VII
part IV, pp. 359-360); also Pam Virlao by
N. H. Billimoria.
For the benefit of your readers you may
Iranshah’s anniversary
As you know on Adar rof Adar mah NL
Year 90 (i.e. November 24,720), our great
est Atash Behram, Pak Iranshah Saheb was of the fire-temples (below)
consecrated. The role and significance of
atash is the basis of not only the Zoroas- I ’ ‘ ‘ '
trian religion, but absolutely everything their goals only through you, because you like to give a feature article on this great
which exists in this mortal universe (nisti). are my son (Aathro Ahurahe Mazdao son of our commdhity. He was a legend
It therefore gives me great pleasure to Puthra), and next to me, you alone will be during his lifetime. It is said that he had
inform you that for the first time in our omnipotent. ’” cyrusr . r.cooper engaged a European driver /or his car
history, we celebrated the consecration of Essex, U.K. whom he paid a princely sum m Rs 900 in
Pak Iranshah Atash Behr^ at the Zoroas- .. those days, marzban j. giara
tnan House in London. On the evening of Late DhunjlSha Kalfati”
November 24, 1995, approximately 40 Mr Bhikhaji M. Adenwalla has queried Zoroastriau influences
adults and children attended a maachi cer- about the late Dhunjisha Kalfati (“Late It was heartening to read Kersee Kabraji ’s
emony performed by Ervad Keki Kanga. pt—» r. ¦ , ................ J
We recited the prayer of Atash Nyaish 1995).
and then Dr Tehmtan Sepai gave a short Based on my research
talk about atash. He quoted the following from the volumes of Parsi HH
extract from Kshnaothra Ahurahe Mazdao: Prakash and other books, is
Dadar Ahura Mazda emanated Khoreh some information for your
from within himself and said — ‘Oh holy readers.
Sir Dhunjibhoy Bomanji,
the merchant prince of
The Motlibai Wadia edifice that houses
the Iranshah
Sir Dhunjibhoy Bomanji: to the defence
kings and prophets, for they will attain
are my son (Aathro Ahurahe Mazdao
omnipotent. ’” CYRUS R. R. COOPER
Essex, U.K.
“Late Dhunjisha Kalfati”
Atash, I designate you as the supreme
authority over Behest. You will descend to
the earth and bring joy and prosperity to all Bombay, was the son of Seth
through your illuminating appearance. To Bomanji Dhunjibhoy Mistry
those who will respect and worship you,
you shall have the authority to bestow _______ ____
upon them the deserving degree of Behest jibhoy is affectionately
remembered by the Parsis
about the late Dhunjisha Kalfati (“Late I ' _____;_________
Dhunjisha Kalfati, ” Parsiana, September letter highlighting quotes from Dr Percival
Spear ’s History of India
Based on my research (Vol 2) which reveal how
Zoroastrian influences
made a lasting impression
on the mind of Akbar the
Great.
Although Shakuntala
Rao Shastri is not so well-
known (mainly due to the
fact that the Bhararati Vidya
Bhavan has thought it unfit
to republish her excellent
little book Women in Vedic
Times),she. has highlighted
how liberal Hinduism was before the ad
vent of Manu, and how this liberalism in
Atharva Vedic times, was partly due to
Zoroastrian influences!
Ms SHIRAZ N. NANPORIA
Looking forward
The article on the khandias “Remains of
the Prince. The non-cooperationists created Their Day ” appearing in India Today (No-
a riot against the Parsis. Several Parsis lost ' ‘ “
their lives. Many Parsis were beaten up.
Their shops were destroyed. Their houses
(Kalfati). A naval contractor
and philanthropist, Dhun-
1
7;
and to those who disrespect you, you may
give them any punishment that you may for the decisive role he played in providing
deem fit. You will be known to the world ¦
as Ardibehest and Adar and the key to the
‘Behest ’ will always be entrusted to you.
You will have supremacy over any form of
light, because the existence of any light is ____ ________ __ _________
due to you alone. A person who worships bay. Ignoring Mahatma Gandhi ’s call for
solid support and encouragement to the
Parsis during the Bombay riots in Nov
ember 1921.
In 1921, the Prince of Wales (later to
become King Edward VIII) visited Bom-
- ------------------------------ /a
you, will acquire wisdom besides attaining boycott of his visit, the Parsis welcomed
all happiness. A person doing charity on
this day, will derive its benefit a thousand
fold and will have all his wishes granted.
‘“You will be worshipped even by the
vember 30,1995) makes sad and sickening
reading. That a highly educated and west
ernized community like ours which
re-
7 Parsiana December 1995
Imains in the forefront for all human rights
and scientific advances, treats a small group
of its own members as social outcastes the vultures on any roadside. It is also minutes in the region of Malabar Hill at a
because their work involves transportation claimed that the bones get powder soft and comparatively lower altitude on the way to
or two hours. This can be ascertained by ’The modern high speed jet planes after
viewing any animal carcass devoured by takeoff from Santacruz Airport are within
the vultures on any roadside. It is also
and deposition of Parsi corpses into the ?
dokhmas, speaks of our double standards I
and hypocrisy. I
Should not we Parsis consider it our |
proud privilege to ourselves carry the dead i
bodies of our dear ones to their last desti- ]
nation, be it a dokhma, burial ground or jj
crematorium? a
The 13 odd families of khandias are a 8
rapidly dwindling group and in years to p
come will be irreplaceable as their children I
will take to better education and jobs with I
higher social acceptance. It is also likely ’
that a majority of their children will marry
outside the community as their social stand
ing within their own community is so low.
In addition to the problem of non
availability of khandias, the community bones are one of the hardest tissues of the
will have to face shortly or within the next body and the remains of the bones of dino-
generation, the problem of utilization of saurs which became extinct 65 million
the Malabar Hill property. The 50 acres of years ago are still found intact in the
prime real estate on top of the posh Mala
bar Hill in Bombay where five dokhmas
and one chotra are located, is no longer a
“nearly inaccessible and remote ridge, buried in a nearby pit in a ritual called
covered with jungle and inhabited by pan
thers, hyaenas, snakes and jackals, ” as
described in The Times of India of in Iran.
September 5, 1896.
Dokhmenashini was advocated in an
cient times when dokhmas were situated
on top of remote hills far away from be practicable, at least in Bombay, as a and conditions facing us.
human habitation and not in the center of method of disposal of the dead due to the
a bustling and expanding metropolis like following reasons:
Bombay city. Besides, vultures on whom
the disposal of our dead bodies is entirely
dependent, will no longer find nesting and from Malabar Hill.
breeding grounds favorable in a city envi- •Increased awareness from environmen-
ronment of noise and pollution. It is also talists against the method of disposal of the
not true that vultures could “pick clean ” a dead by exposure to carrion birds in the
human carcass within a short period of one very heart of the city.
¦
'll ” f
W’lii
,mr. ii,.
JIJi
either southern or eastern destinations and
are in great danger of bird-hit with vultures
leading to catastrophic consequences.
Preposterous as it may sound, we will
have to accept the following alternatives.
With Bombay harboring more than 70
¦ ¦¦¦viiaaiffljB ir percent of the entire Parsi community and
i. on an average three to five deaths a day, it
is not advisable to convert the Malabar Hill
property into a Parsi burial ground: in a
short time the entire area will also be filled
up with graves and it is very expensive to
maintain such a big burial ground in an
aesthetic condition.
The only solution left is to build a
modern electric crematorium in one corner
of the Malabar Hill property and utilize
the remaining vast area to house poor and
middle income Zoroastrians.
An electric crematorium does not defile
fire as only the heat generated by very high
Wyoming Desert in the USA. As far as wattage bums off the dead body. Besides,
information is available, the bones left in
the dokhma are periodically collected and
A khandia: facing an uncertain future
are washed away into the center well of the
dokhma. This contention is also unlikely as
the modern crematorium does not cause
any environmental pollution. ’
While remainmg true Zoroastrians by
“Astodan. ” This ritual was even done for following the teachings of our great Prophet
Cyrus the Great more than 2,000 years ago
Zoroaster and at the same tixpe practising
the moral virtues and spirit of adventure
handed down to us by our elders, it is also
now time to mend our fences to keep
It is thus very likely that within a few
decades, the community will have to face
a situation when dokhmenashini will not ourselves abreast of the changing times
A recent review of Arun Shourie ’s book
The World of Fatwas brings out the fact
that fundamentalism and fatwas are not
•Shortage or nonavailability of khandias.
•Migration of vultures to areas far away rulings but opinions handed down by the
clergy and should have no binding force
against the introduction of needed change.
Dr M. D. DISAWALLA
Bangalore
Edited by Arnavaz S. Mama
.^1
MAHENDRA
cP
Gold and silver Lord Zoroaster and
Asho Farohar medals available
Gold, silver and diamond exclusive showroom
594, Chira Bazar, Girgaum Road, Bombay 400002. Tel: 2065137
We accept Diners, BOB card, American Express,
Taj Premium, Visa & Master Cards.
REQUIRED
Accounts Assistant
tor printing/publishing
concern in Fort area.
Knowledge of computers
preferred. Write giving
full details to:
The Advertiser (Accounts)
GPO Box 892
Bombay 400001
8 Parsiana December 1995L.
Events and
Personalities
Rapport Poona ’ _ ~ “
“The trustees bring to you Rapport as they proposal to initiate a chair for Zoroastrian
found the need to involve the entire com- Archaeological Studies at the Deccan Col-
munity in the working of the Panchayat to lege which involves an annual expenditure
achieve long pending goals, ” states the of Rs 1.5 lakhs has been carried in Rapport registered an increase in their corpus over
". - course of the last 35 years. The nine
trustees of the well-placed anjuman are
entrusted with assets totally valued at Rs
82,634,569.27 of which Rs 13,373,003.45
constitute immovable property and Rs
69,809,364.38 are shown as investment.
When it comes to parting with facts in
the form of a newsletter, the SPP may be
Archeologist Dr (Ms) Roxana Irani ’s augmenting funds. As per the detailed
~ financial statement sent by the SPP presi
dent Dr Sam Bhacca, all the institutions,
trusts and funds under their control have
chairman of the Poona Parsee Panchayat as also news of the ghambar scheduled for
(PPP) Dara K. Irani in the first issue of their Zoroastrian men where “all the men are
quarterly newsletter. “The ideas, the ob- requested to wear their sudreh-kustis and
jectives and the performance of the Parsee topis without which entry will not be per-
Panchayat will be portrayed to you. In turn
you will have an opportunity to voice your
opinions or put forth your queries through
a column in the quarterly which will be gust 1995 have been published in the news- _________
duly responded to, ” assures the newsletter letterdated September 1995 which reached hesitant; but with figures they* are more
' ~ ’------ ------------------—than willing. One hundred and twenty
next issue that was to be out in December sheets of paper sought to convey through
the local community was asked to give figures the picture of the SPP and its
information on births for inclusion in Rap-
mitted. ”
Names of the 45 Zoroastrians who died
in Poona in the eight months ending Au-
edited by Ms Nilufer Sirvala on behalf of the Parsiana office in December. For their
the PPP trustees.
The first issue of the newsletter gives an
introduction to the present board of seven
trustees who will serve for a three-year port.
tenure and estimates the present strength
ofthePPPtobe 1,210. Inviting others from Surst’s SOUnd investment
the community to become members (the Those in the community who complain of
fees being Rs 1,001 for donor member, Rs depleting resources and eroding assets
501 for life member and Rs 12 for ordinary should turn to the board of trustees of the Hospital and the Nariman Home; in the
management of other bodies like the
Alpaiwala Institute, Dastur Meherji Rana
Trust, Dastur Darab Phalana Trust and the
Sorabji Burjorji Dastui. Darab Pahalana
Trust. The funds of the SPP which were Rs
4,185,822.91 on December 31, 1961 have
increased by Rs 29,327,164.51 to give a
total of Rs 33,512,987.42 on March 31,
1995. The other institution to record a
substantial improvement in financial
position over the same period was the
Nariman Home which registered an
increase of Rs 18,627,965.29 to bring its
total to Rs 19,757,978.58. Even the least
affluent of their trusts (Alpaiwala Institute)
showed an increase from Rs 160,615.12 to
Rs 224,653.96.
The immovable properties under the in
member), they clarify that women married Surat Parsi Panchayat (SPP) for lessons in
to non-Parsis as also children whose either
parent is a non-Parsi will not be granted
membership.
Maximum space in the four-page news
letter conveys news on the properties con
trolled by the PPP, especially the 68 acres
of land near the Tower of Silence which
have yet to be developed. As per the donor ’s
wish, eight and a half acres of land were to
be commercially exploited and the profits
arising to be ploughed back into the deve
lopment of the remaining land where the
trustees are proposing the construction of
flats for the poor and needy, a dharamshala
for Zoroastrians visiting' Pune, a hostel for
Zoroastrian girls and boys, and perhaps a
home for the aged. Involvement from the
community is sought on this project as also
for the beautification of the doongerwadi
estate.
10 Parsiana December 1995
“m
i
8
' I
•A
i
Li
r
ii'
I
f
Hl >>l 1 I
Si
hii
manifold activities in the field of educa
tion through the Surat Parsi Boys
Orphanage, Nariman Girls Orphanage, the
Patel School and the Polytechnic Institute;
in the area of health and welfare through
the Parsi General Hospital, Parsi Maternity
The headquarters of the Surat Parsi
Panchayat Photo: Ashvin Mehta.•5?;'
&•?
vA
[i
Hi
Hector Mehta,
Dr Dina Hakim,
Jasmine and Zarir
BhathenOj Homa
and Aban Petit
and Balsara out
side the cafetaria
Right: The self-
service counter
and (below) an
economical mini
meal
'¦'!
¦<
lT-Il
!»
I staff would be able to grab a quick bite (in
I addition to their normal hospital meals),
i the patients ’ own meals would continue to
I be provided by the Hospital, as also for
I those relatives who choose to order their
I trays in advance, informed PGH vice presi-
I dent Ms Aban Petit.
I Joining the Hospital in the attempt to
I provide nutritious, hygienic food to the
I economically weaker section of the com-
I munity is the Ratan Tata Institute (RTI).
'I Full meals and snacks as well as economy
I lunches and dinners will be available to
these caretakers to obviate the need to cart
I everything from home or settle for un-
I hygienic fare from streetside stalls.
I The cafetana has metamorphosed from
I an old godown adjacent to the RMO’s
I office, sprightly in white and green with
I granite table tops ahd assorted old fumi-
I ture like redundant bedside tables and laun-
I dry bins painted and refurbished to match
I the new decor. Plants and old china on the
I walls add color and ambience.
n Under the arrangement, the equipment
' j® ®VPP1’!^ ’’y the PGH, food and service
will accrue to the PGH. The food will
j come in fresh twice a day. Mini meals
consisting of one dry item, twk> chappatis,
rice, vegetable and dal — both vegetarian
and non-vegetarian — are available at Rs
15 to Rs 16, according to Bomi Balsara, a
PGH committee member who has been
deeply involved with the project. The
Hospital ’s expenses in the venture have
been defrayed from a specific donation
from Ms Manijeh Pleader, he added.
The cafetaria was inaugurated on No
vember 26, 1995 with a jashan led by
Ervad Aspi Dadachanji, largely attended
hy th^ommittee members of the PGH and
having done much of^e spadework of
getting the necessary permission from the
authorities for the project.
WWle the facility answers a long-felt
need, its limited hours of work (11 a.m. to
8 p.m.) does reduce its effectiveness. For
tru^s and Rs 37,691 from example, relatives who have attended
i
e
S!» «
'll fcft'
Ti ‘’uppiivu uj' uic rvjn, lotxj ana service
Ww all items sold
Rs 764,573.16; for the Boys Orphanage
from Rs 5,169.16 to Rs 170,300; and for
the Patel School from Rs 2,059.06 to Rs
127,536.
Not only the totals but the audited state
ment of accounts and balance sheet for
each of the institutions and trusts have
been sent by the SPP.
On analyzing the donations received by
different bodies, it is apparent ±at the SPP
is the largest beneficiary having earned Rs
52,444.02 from public trusts and Rs 158,676
from individuals during the last financial
year. The highest expenditure incurred in
the same period was on account of secular
a rise from Rs education towards which the SPP spent Rs
3A1 5,146,676.07. The next largest beneficiary
of donations was the Surat Parsi Boys
cornparing the Re- Orphanage which received Rs 210,987
Panchayat banner inclusive of the SPP are
the Surat Parsi Boys Orphanage, Nariman
Girls Orphanage, Patel School, Parsi Gen
eral Hospital, Parsi Maternity Hospital
and Nariman Home. Their consolidated
financial position indicates __________ _
2,115,528,83 in end 1961 to Rs
13,373,003.45 in end March 1995.
When it comes to < ’
serve. Development and Sinking'Funds of from Tubfic
these different trusts, the Surat Parsi Boys
Orphanage appears to be the most com
fortably placed showing Rs 1,255,391.04
as on March 31, 1995. At the other end is
the Patel School which shows Rs 70,332.23. The PGH’s Cafetaria
1
i
1
i
the RTI. The latter have been credited with J
hsvinty Haha «-Ua ____i_
a.m. to
'The Girk Orphanage received through the night on a patient undergoing
Ks /5Urrom niihlir fnictc anrl Pc 11 1Q1 _______ __ . ... Rs 35,750 from public trusts and Rs 13,191
from individuals.
emergency treatment are still unable to
f ¦ ¦
when they most need it.
find a much needed cup of tea or coffee
- ------------- Arnavaz S. Mama
, Cafetaria facilities are now available to PresS IVust chairman
have been able to record a substantial relatives and friends tending their patienu C— ' CnMITOan
1995-96. this is the third time thal
Lif ' persons can avail of the Cushrow Irani, editor-in-chief and manag-
case of SPP nrefeTtnS^"^^ comfort. Those who ing director of The Statesman, has beel
iVnoa P’^®^®'^‘^J^® ^'^ay are also in a position to chosen
.0 do so. While the honoraries and Hospital news
increase in the 35-year period under the
head of “rent and income from land re
ceived are the SPP, the Boys Orphanage
and the Patel School, In the ____
there was an increase from Rs 16,243.93 to
Elected chairman of the Press Trust of
to head India ’s leading English
agency. He had earlier held that post
11 Parsiana December 1995
1
J
1
I
>I
Irani: news
loyalty I
bM
his last on August 12,1995 at the age of 70.
With his fingers and toes deformed, and
wounds on the sole of his feet because of
which he always wore socks, walking was
difficult for Sidhwa. In addition, a depres
sion in the bridge of his nose had contorted
his facial features too.
When social workers Ms Freny Unwalla,
Ms Arnawaz Mistry and Aspi Parekh came
to know of his case, they regularly started
visiting him and on persistent queries came
to realize that he missed Parsi bhonu at the
Hospital. So, with the finance organized
by Ms Silloo Kavarana, they arranged for
tiffins to be delivered to him in plastic
GLOBE
THEATRES
Pvt Ltd
(j
1973-74 and 1974-75. Irani has also served _______ _____
president of the Indian Newspaper bags. In the last two months of his life
when he was not able to eat food. Mistry,
visiting him every alternate day, would
carry soup or other semi-solids that were
comfortable for him.
On one occasion the social workers
as ]
Society and the Audit Bureau of Circula
tion, according to a press release.
On the international scene Irani is vice-
chairman of the World Press Freedom
Committee headquartered in Washington _____ _____ _
and a member of the advisory board of the organized an outing for him, taking Sidhwa
Center for Foreign Journalists, USA. The to the Bandra Bandstand. They were also
first Indian to be elected chairman of the contemplating shifting him to a hospice in
International Press Institute (IPI), he is ' —
presently its vice-chairman. His “outstand
ing services ” as chairman in 1982 had
earned Irani honorary life membership of
IPI, mentions his biographical sketch.
Known for his relentless fight for the by Sidhwa ’s brother who is a priest at the
freedom of the Press when emergency was
declared in India in the mid 1970s, Irani
was conferred the Freedom Award by the
Freedom House, New York, and the Astor
Aw^d by the Commonwealth Press Union Ervad Rustomji Panthaky of Dadar ’s
to the Bandra Bandstand. They were also
in
Gujarat where he could be in the midst of
Parsis, but Sidhwa was not inclined, fear
ing rejection by the community.
The cost of his last rites and consign
ment at the Towers of Silence was borne
Sethna Agiary. According to the press
release, in between, Sidhwa had discontin
ued wearing the kusti since he could not tie
it on himself. However, on the advice of
------- _j_ _ ..... —J ____ _ 3
for “distinguished service in the cause of Athornan Boarding Madressa the social
Press freedom. ” For “highest loyalty to workers tied the kusti for him which he was
democracy, ” Irani was made Knight Com
mander of the Order of Isabella Catholica
by the King of Spain
distinctions conferred on the journalist. < '' '--------\
Born in Bombay, 65-year-old Irani was homage. When the sociarworkers
educated at the city ’s St Xavier ’s College
and the Government Law College. Pres
ently based in Calcutta, the journalist has
authored two books: Bengal — The Com
munist Challenge and In Pursuit of Free
dom.
^ess freedom. ” For “highest loyalty to workers tied the kusti for him which he
asked to leave on even at bath time.
Earlier he used to walk up to the
as per the list of Rustomfaramna Agiary at Dadar and stand
outside the premises to pay his silent
suited Panthaky, Sidhwa was granted per
mission to enter within, but he preferred
not to, lest he displease other coreligionists.
Born in Gujarat, Sidhwa had studied at
Bombay ’s Cama Athornan Boarding
Madressa and was ordained a navar. To
help his widowed mother, he first worked
for a travelling agency and later at the
Beach Luxury Hotel in Karachi. As he
confided to the social workers, since he
was 17 years of age he had noticed some
skin irritation and spots. But want of medi
cine made him neglect the symptoms until
Learning from adversity
His fellow inmates at the Ackworth Lep
rosy Hospital at Wadala loved and res
pected him. The doctors and staff at the
institute remembered his helpful and co
operative attitude, referring in particular
to the assistance he rendered to two patients the germs had taken deep root, necessita-
who happened to be mentally retarded, ting hospitalization, first at the Miraj Hos-
The social workers who visited him found pital and subsequently at Ackworth.
him to be contented, never lamenting or The services that he rendered at the
asking for favors. The “Parsi Bawaji, ” as Hospital were acknowledged with an hono-
Gustad Dinshaw Sidhwa was popularly rarium of Rs 35 that was given to him each
addressed at the Hospital, finally breathed month. From his savings totalling nearly
ting hospitalization, first at the Miraj Hos-
13 Parsiana December 1995
Established
April 3, 1915
Pioneers of Show
Business in India for
the last 80 years
We rededicate
ourselves to the ideals
we have cherished and
practised all along -
namely to show
NOTHING BUT
THE BEST
to our ever increasing
number of Patrons
Controlling:
REGAL
BOMBAY
CAPITOL
BOMBAY
GLOBE
CALCUTTA
The above three cinemas are
installed with
??1 DOLBY STE^
4’
J
I
5
II
f
I
8^
?!
1
I
..A
111. ¦;
Xi
a.
•» the Paul
has been donated for' ’us^by*th™XM ^iSe ¦' of Islamic
Covenants of faith
Ahd-Namaha
Ms Mithoo Coorlawala was released by
mijsjon Homi J. H. Taleyarkhan
Cama Oriental Institute
1995.
Giving a gist of the function
orary secretary of the Institute, —
day needed welfare, not warfare. Accorl
mg to Taleyarkhan, when India is empha
sizing the imperative need of national in
tegration and the unity of all religions,
Coorlawala ’s contribution should promote
1 _______________ V..V. ..11
pl=dgcsorcovenante;;;;ecTarte:rgS
by Prophet Muhammad and by his sun-in-
law Im^ Ali to the Ahel-e-Kitab, which
like thl cSan^ J^ws,° ‘zo^oitrians drnts"f ’th ’T^°P'"‘®’ stu-
whose religious teachings are contained in at D Athoman Boarding Madressa
their sacred book). All Le covenanSof " Pall-bearers with their
faith enjoin on the followers of Islam to .. fr®® "leal, according
gran, protec,ion of personX^y, P-fhaky o’f
dom of worship, exemption from paymen'
or the jazia tax and from compulsory mili
tary service. “The spirit of tolerance, un
derstanding, generous outlook and healthy
respect for the religions... runs through „„
sentence of these firmans, ” notes individuals
As stated at the function by Dr (Ms)
15 Parsiana December 1995
.u Xavier ’s College, “Though
the authenticity of these firmans has been
quesuoned, this research provides unusual
insights, disclosing a freshly perceived
mg is unusually extens ’ive. Hei^ rese^ch
sources have been meticulously investi
gated and the text reveals a positive and
questioned, this research provides unusual
Ms Mithoo Coorlawala v._ uy
former member of the Minorities Com
mission Homi J. H. Taleyarkhan at a
mnction in the Library Hall of the K. R.
on October 30,
, , -------—.^v.w.i and the
book, Capt Hormazdiar J. M. Desai, hon
orary secretary of the Institute, recounted Zanders Aw p j’"".
Taleyarl^an ’s message that the world to ^^0.
ing to Taleyarkhan, when India'is empha
sizing the imperative need of national in
tegration and the unity of all religions,
brotherhood and peace.
Ahd-Namaha, which
]¦ \ __ ______ _
by Prophet Muhammad and by his son-in-
law Im^ Ali to the Ahel-e-Kitab, which
means the people of the book (i.e. those
sources have been meticulously investi-
uniformly mature underlying structure An
interesting feature of this book i
information footnotes used, where
sary, to supplement the text. ”
This 1-----
--- *— r ””^**‘-’***'v* ij'i viiv
Gania Oriental Institute is printed on
/orkzlA«*» A Tfc_ . . * *
are the
! neces-
monograph published by the K. R.
in-
are
Patel Agiary marks 151
The 151st i
Nasserwanji Patel Agiary at Mazagaon on
October 2, 1995 was observed with two
Ae tmstees, and another in the evening on
Almost 450 members of the community
participated in a contributory dinner on the
anniversary of the Framji
j^hans (one in the morning on behalf of
same day when thanks to the largesse of
the Agiary Ervad Nariman Dalal. The een-
payment erosity of the owners of Wibs Brfad
Godiwalla Caterers, Khambatta Caterers ’
Saron Caterers and Ms Dhunmai Master, ’
as also the cooperation extended by the
”^^er committed
: was gratefully acknowledged.
Compiled by Parinaz Gandhi
Godiwalla Caterers, Khambatta Caterers ’
as also the cooperation extended bv the
triictoQr _
Investment in
Property:
Pune is the
I best city
I We accept bookings in
I exclusive schemes In
I Pune, like a Bungalow-
I scheme near the Pashan
I Lake, 6 km from Pune
I University. It is a small
I township consisting of:
17 Independent
Bungalows —
Rs 38 lakhs -
I 4 Twin Bungalows —
Rs 16 to 19 lakhs
22 Rowhouses — I
Rs 17 to 39 lakhs
Possession around I
March ’96. I
Payments by cheque. I
We also offer flats (small I
and large) at prices I
ranging from approx I
Rs 900 to Rs 5,000 I
per sq ft (built-up area), I
besides bungalow-plots, I
offices and shops in I
exclusive Commercial I
Complexes coming up in I
Pune. For details write to: I
Minoo Bhathena
BySel Estate I
302 Devika Apt I
2010 Janmohmed Str I
Pune 411001 I
Tel; 650757 I
4^
i
j
)
!
j
j
(ZOROASTRIANS ABROAD
The Gathas on computeF
“The days when simple devotion was the
driving force, are long over. It is essential
that we all, in our own mind, comprehend
the message of the Gathas and live our
lives by its precepts, ” notes Purviz Kolsa
walla, former president of the Australian
Zoroastrian Association (AZA) of New post-Sasanian times. Also “Pahlavi gram-
South Wales who mar and language are reasonably well un-
has completed his derstood, ” Kolsawalla notes in a printout
compilation
nearly 19 transla
tions of the Gathas
of Zarathushtra on
four 3.5” HD dis
kettes. This marks
the end of phase
one of his four-part
project to similarly actual thinking. Unfortunately, the Gathas
put together the Yas- are full of deeply esoteric and allegorical
na, Vendidad and the Yashts, each on four
diskettes. The idea is to put them all toge
ther on one CD-ROM which he expects
will cost approximately US $ 10,000 to tinged with Vedic Hindu ideas which are
produce. Kolsawalla hopes that every wes
tern university offering a syllabus on Zoro
astrianism will opt for a copy which he
says he is planning to produce with total
“hyper-texting ” (cross-referencing) facility.
Each verse of the transliterated Gathas
(the original text in Roman script) is fol
lowed by translations arranged in alpha
betic order of the translators. Thus B. T.
Anklesaria heads the list and is followed
by Mobed Firouz Azargoshasb, Dastur of the abed Maghavans, (Chiniwala) has
Framroze Bode and Ms Pilloo Nanavutty,
Ms Mary Boyce, J. M. Chatterjea, Dr F. S.
Chiniwalla, Stanley Insler, A. V. W. Jack-
son, Ali Jafarey, Ervad K. E. Kanga, Kavi
A. F. Khabardar, L. H. Mills (including his
retranslation from Neryosangh Dhaval ’s
Sanskrit text), Khodabax Punegar,
Framroze Rustomji, T. R. Sethna, Arthur
Bleek (retranslation from Spiegel ’s Ger
man translation) and I. J. S. Taraporewalla.
After faithfully entering all these transla
tions Kolsawalla has given an interpretation
of the verse in Khshnoomist terms.
While Gujarati works have been trans
lated by Kolsawalla into English, linguis
tic barriers and/or unavailability of the text
in Australia has precluded others.
The selected translators fall into four
separate schools.- Mills, Dhaval, Kanga
together with many other western and Zo
roastrian scholars have relied on extant
Pahlavi translations of the Gathas.
Taraporewalla, Khabardar, Chatterjea and The diskettes (priced at Australian $ 15
others have relied on Vedic Sanskrit, a locally and US $ 15 elsewhere - postage
16 Parsiana December 1995
sister tongue to Zarathushtra ’sGathic (also extra), are available from the author, 16
known as old Avestan).
The advantage of the Pahlavi based
texts, says Kolsawalla, is that these trans
lations are believed to have been effected
by very learned and spiritually evolved them being in Sydney. With their dar-e-
Zoroastrian priests in the Sasanian and
Tenison Avenue, Cambridge Park, NSW
2747, Australia.
Kolsawalla estimates about 1,600 Zo
roastrians in Australia, more than half of
of of the introduction given to Parsiana. On
meher being well established and three
young navars of the second generation
joining the pioneers like Ervad Peshotan
Katrak whose unceasing priestly help has
enabled the community to weather its
the other hand, he says, that by Sasanian inevitable crises, Zoroastrians in New
times Gathic grammar and language were
not only “imperfectly understood, ” their
interpretations may have been “tinged by the AZA’s established schedule.
other philosophies prevalent in Iran. ”
The Vedic Sanskrit based translations ZoFOHStrianS ill Bahrain
“are probably the closest to Zarathushtra ’s
South Wales seem better settled, with reli
gion, history and Gujarati classes as part of
references which could not be easily ex
plained by simple philology. Another po
tential problem is that the translations are
The 1995-96 directory of the Bahrain Zo-
roastrian Association lists 58 households,
17 of them comprising singles. The 41
married couples have as many children
among them. The grand total of about 140
Zoroastrians includes nine non-Zoroastri-
an spouses.
later reflected in Theosophy. ” The xeroxed compilation, sent to
The third school propounded by Parsiana by Neville Choksi, indicates that
Khabardar, took the aid of Sanskrit as well service in the airways and at the air termi-
as an astrological explanation. Considered nals, in trading compani^, petrochemical s
establishments, bank and investment or
ganizations, hotels, hospitals and the uni
versity is what attracts and keeps Indian ’*
Zoroastrians in the Gulf states.
unorthodox by many scholars, Kolsawalla
notes that it “provides a very deep chal
lenge to traditionally held beliefs. ”
The fourth school is that of the
Khshnoomists with their esoteric empha
sis. “Using the divine esoteric knowledge Flood tide fOF Bugli
... ................J , ; The Wyeth-Ayerst Research Laboratories
in Princeton, USA, recently promoted Dr
Jehan Bagli to the position of Distin-
%
given detailed explanations of these highly
complex and esoteric terms. ” However,
Kolsawallais foxed by Chiniwala ’s “highly guished Research Fellow. A press release i
Persianized Gujarati and extremely long from Wyeth-Ayerst ’s assistant vice presi- ¦
sentences, replete with extensive foot
notes... A full coverage of his text is im
possible for a layman like me, ” he admits.
The diskettes represent five years of business objectives of the corporation. ”
work for Kolsawalla who dedicated two , Having “pro-
and a half hours to it every night, entering j moted discovery
it all on his computer. “My background in i ¦- <¦
science, engineering and analytical re
search has reinforced the fact that truth has
many facets and knowledge has to be
searched in any quarter where it could be
found, ” he notes. “The Gathas provide us
with a very high moral code to live (by)
without any complicated ritual. A.s Jafarey
has so aptly said, ‘Forward with theGathas.’
After all, that is what Asho Zarathushtra
meant when he has asked (us) to think with
our own mind and make the right choice. ”
dent of chemical sciences Dr Majid Abou-
Gharbia details Bagli ’s numerous contri
butions and their ^^rofound impact on the F
research of new
drug candidates 1
in various areas
of medicinal che- >
mistry, ” Bagli ’s
creativity in the
field of synthe-
tics coupled with
his for
biological activ
ity have earned him an international re
putation, notes Abou-Gharbia. Author and
co-author of over 100 publications and
continued on page 22
,1
...***i *
''Sfc'i't*-'
ii
*ADVERTISEMENT
¦
H ¦I
RM
¦
1
THE PARSI FLAG
¦
i
¦
A Tribute to
the Parsi Vexillographer
Dr Jehangir R. Medora
|i
iB|Bb
¦
1
¦
¦
I
fl
by Meher Master-Moos, MA (Oxon),
LLM (Michigan)
T
he Flag decorates many Parsi homes around the
World as the symbol of “Earth Friendliness and
Universal Brotherhood.” Its three colours have
beautiful primary shades for three countries with
the Asho Farohar giving it a Zoroastrian touch.
We Parsis never had our own flag (since we arrived at Sanjan
in India on about November 22, 745 A.D.) but now we have
taken an instant liking to the flag designed by Dr Jehangir
Medora. It was flown at the convocation ceremony of the
Zoroastrian College (January 30, 1995) in Bombay and also
at the Zoroastrian College Building at Sanjan. It was unfurled
every morning and saluted at the Zoroastrian children’s
Leadership Camp organised by the Zoroastrian Stree Mandal
of Hyderabad on October 21 -24,1995 where 121 Zoroastrian
children from all over India participated. On November 22,
1995 the 1,250th year anniversary of our landing at Sanjan,
the flag was exhibited on the speakers platform, at the Sanjan
Stambh Anniversary Function. The Parsi children at
Zoroastrian Studies take an oath using the same words
inscribed on the walls of Persepolis by the greatest Zoroastrian
Persian King of all times, Darius — the Achemenian Emperor
(circa 521 BC-486 BC)
“A great God is Ahura Mazda
Who created this Earth
Who created Yonder Sky
Who created Man
Who created Welfare and Happiness for Man
Who made us all Zoroastrians.”
But what really impresses me is the inscription which
Darius has left about Zoroastrianism. In his book Religions of
the World Gerald L. Berry said “Zoroastrianism led to a
government in Persia more just than anywhere else in the
ancient world. The Emperors were given a sense of obligation
l.
as witness the quotation from Darius.
'Ahura Mazda brought me help because
I was not wicked (Good thoughts)
Nor was I a liar (Good words)
Nor was I a tyrant (Good deeds)
I have ruled according to Righteousness.’”
You will ask what went on in the year 1995, that had brought
Parsis together to salute this flag and make them all excited J
about it. It has to do with a Zoroastrian Parsi from Canada.
JEHANGIR R. MEDORA, LLB (Bombay University), PhD (Zo-
roastrian College), was born in Deolali, India. Now75 years old, ¦
the vexillographer has been living in Canada for the last 35 '
years. The six-footer felt a bit odd as a Zoroastrian, because he y
had no Parsi flag to fly at the INTER FAjTH PEACE Meetings ’
of the different ethnic groups in Canada. Wherever he goes in i
Canada he sees flags. Canada has a maple leaf red flag. Its ten
provinces have their individual flags. Canadian cities have their
own flags. The companies (Esso, Shell) and clubs (Rotary,
Lions) each have their own flags. The religious groups, each
have their own flags: Christians (Cross): Jews (Six-pointed Star I
of David); Hindus (Triangular Safron Pennant); Mohamadans ¦
(Green background) ; butwe Parsi Zoroastrians have NO FLAG.
It made him sad and made him think. He read books on flags;
“Too many pictures and pages: too confusing.” He went to flag
manufacturers: “Keep it simple,” they advised him, “and don’t
steal designs from others.” He met Parsi friends (Canadians),
but they were still thinking like backwoods country bumpkins:
“Who needs a Flag?” they said. “Better give money to the poor.”
After retirement he had one thing in plenty—time. Returned
himself into an instant vexillographer — a flag designer.
hADVERTISEMENT
He saw flags in his sleep; dreamt of flags; all day and all night
he saw nothing but flags. Being a bit of a pompous pioneering
man himself, he jumped into the art and science of flag design
ing for a proper Zoroastrian Flag. “The ladies like blue; the men
like red and the white in the middle." His vexillographer friends
stopped him, “Hey! that is Netherlands’ flag! Careful! Queen
Juliana or is it Queen Beatrix! She will shoot you on sight for
stealing the colors plus the design,” they warned him.
So gold (yellow) was inserted in place of white and the Asho
Farohar’s image was superimposed in blue on the golden
yellow. All primary colors. That’s good! They will not fade so
easily. A design, took shape, in his mind.
After many trips to the manufacturers of flags he found out
that it cost too much. Then he ran into a lady banner-maker and
painter who suggested “make a banner first as a model.” He got
a paper Asho Farohar from a Parsi home and got it enlarged.
When the banner-maker/painter saw it, she recognized it
immediately, as that “Hollywood spaceman from California.'
She traced the Asho Farohar on a 4 feet wide and 14 feet long
strip of gold colored heavy plastic (cost $ 250) and then they
went to a store and bought blue and red coloured plastic strips
to fit equally and to make it into a banner of about 14 feet by 12
feet (which cost $ 650). The lady did a good job of stitching
(another $ 700) the whole thing together. At last a banner was
formed — one from which flags can be made in any size. The
banner cost a whopping $ 1,600. It has red on top for Canada,
saffron gold in the middle for India and beautiful Persian blue
indicating Iran. These three colours indicate the countries in
which we Zoroastrians are largely concentrated.
Itwas flown fromToronto to Bombay (at his expense) intime
to be displayed at Zoroastrian College World Congress held at
the Russian Cultural Centre (Bombay) in January 1995 and the
Parsi Fiesta in October 1994. It now adorns the Zoroastrian
College building at Sanjan.
And it was used to model a flag. Again the same flag
manufacturers were approached. These were the months of
November-December 1993 and all of them were busy with
X’mas orders in tens of thousands and it appeared that the flag
would stay unmade. At last one manufacturer took pity on
Jehangir (but kept calling it the Assyrian Flag—perhaps he had
also never heard of Zoroastrians) and charged $ 1,000.
In January 1994 the first run of the nylon flag (54" x 33") came
down the assembly li ne to the strains of Thus SpakeZarathushtra
by Richard Strauss. All six of them. That’s all. The next 25 would
cost another $ 1,000. No more money to spare! Even today
(January 1996) the number has stayed at six.
The Flag brought unity and identity and a little pride too to us
Parsis. But somehow Jehangir had a feeling that something
was missing in the Flag. Nice colours and Asho Farohar did not
indicate any Zoroastrian doctrines. Then suddenly, after reading
about theseven earthly gifts of Ahura Mazdaand His Archangels
and the seven spiritual aspects, he thought of putting two
seven-pointed stars on both sides of the Asho Farohar. Australia
and New Zealand are the only countries with seven-pointed
stars on their flags. All these appeared in his mind, just in time
before the laminated paper flags were about to be printed in
November 1995. The seven-pointed stars also symbolise Meher
Yazad and Behman Yazad (Mithraand Varuna). Now he feltthe
flag was complete.
In November 1995 the very attractive laminated and the
beautifully crafted printed flag (11 ” x 9”) was made out with two
seven-pointed blue stars astride the Asho Farohar. Ten
thousand flags were printed at the Union Press in Bombay, at
a cost of Rs 65,000 (all his own money) and were distributed
free. He is happy that they are admired and exhibited in Parsi
homes. Some are even framed and put up on the agiary walls.
He calls it “The Zoroastrian Flag of Friendliness anc
Brotherhood."
A full color page advertising the flag with his comments,
was inserted in Parsiana (July-August 1995) which was
mailed in early December 1995. His comments were that the
Friendliness — stands for a “Friend of Earth:" Use Ahura
Mazda’s earthly gifts but preserve them for milleniums to
come and do not abuse or pollute His environment.
Brotherhood stands for “Brother to Mankind.” That means
be of righteous behaviour towards our fellowmen based on
Good Thoughts, Good Words, and Good Deeds. These are
the main doctrines of our noble faith. Be proud! You are
Zoroastrian!
And finally (here’s abig plus) the flag has been well thought
of and recognized as a good one—as flags go — by the most
prestigious flag organization in the world—The Flag Institute
of England. Jehangir sent a Zoroastrian Flag (printed and
laminated) to England to seek their opinion. In reply Mr
Michael A. Faul, Honorary Secretary and Flag Consultant of
the Flag Institute, gave high praise for Jehangir’s vexillo-
graphical skills: “The Design is very good and is a model of a
Flag Designer’s art... It is distinctive and conveys the symbol
ism it has sought to embody... The colours are bold and dear
and not easily subject to fading... You have managed to
employ most of the principles of good flag design... /^copy of
the flag will be lodged in the archives of the Flag Institute in
England.”
And furthermore the Flag Institute has called him a“Vexi!lo-
grapher” — the professional title of a flag designer. All these
compliments have gone to Jehangirs head and he is so puffed
up that he finds himself elevated to the seventh heaven and
since then he has refused to come down to planet earth. That’s
Jehangir for you!
Besides printing the laminated flags which are quite attrac
tive, his plan is to bring out nylon flags just like the ones he
made in Canada. They are made of a single nylon cloth which
cannot be made in India. The costs, in Canadian dollars (C$
1 = Rs 26 approx) vary with the size of the flag: $ 4 for per flag
of 3” X10” ($8,000 for a minimum order of 2,000): $20 per flag
of 16” X 24” ($ 6,000 for minimum 300); and $ 5Crper flag of 36”
X 54" ($ 5,000 for minimum 100).
He has already spent more than Rs 1,00,000 and a few
thousand Canadian dollars of his own money and now has
become short of funds. He said he would very much like some
capable party to handle the production of such quality flags
and its distribution in an equitable manner to the members of
our community.
An application for a registered copyright (patent) has
already been made in Canada in 1994 under the Industrial
Design Act of Canada for world rights. A similar application
has also been made here in India.
There is a sequel to all this — an appropriate salutation for
Parsis: Be Good (to the Planet Earth) and Behave Yourself
(be a brother to men), shortened to BGBYE. Now don’t forget
to say “Beejee bye ” to our fellow Parsis instead of goodbye
or bye bye. And here's Beejee bye to you all!
i
1
t-1
I6WZCONGRESS
Tehran Beckons
World Zoroastrians
The Iranian government has assured all assistance to make
the Sixth World Zoroastrian Congress a success
The Iranian Government has given its
“blessings ” for the hosting of the Sixth
World Zoroastrian Congress (WZC) in
Tehran in June this year, said Federation of Pakistan. “They have been kind enough to
Parsi Zoroastrian Anjumans of India and bring the prices down to Rs 4,000 for India have known it to be in the recent past, ” said
Bombay Parsi Punchayet (BPP) chairman and Pakistan, ” said Modi as versus almost Modi. There is no discrimination against j
Jamshed N. Guzder. Addressing a press Rs 11,000 for all others. women speaking and participating in the
conference at the BPP office on February - -
12, 1996 Guzder said that the Iranian for
eign minister Ali Akbar Velayati had met
with representatives ofthe BPP in Bombay but it is assumed to be between 17 to 30
and assured them that the Tehran Congress years,
had the full backing of the Iranian govern
ment.
The dates for the Congress, which was the registration fees will double, said Modi,
originally to be held from June 20 to June
23, have been changed to June 19 to June Iranian Congress authorities will vet it and
22. According to Ms Homai Modi, the
Congress representative for India, the rea
son for the change was a “miscalculation egates has not been disclosed,
in date. ” When questioned by the press as
to how this miscdculation had taken place formed in Bombay to assist with the Con-
both Guzder and Modi said there were gress enrollment and formalities. The com-
some errors in calculation. mittee consists of himself. Modi, BPP
The venue for the Congress had not chief executive Behram Laskari, former delegate fees to the Congress of Rs 4,000,
been fixed and will depend on the number
of delegates attending. An air-conditioned and BPP joint secretary Ms Gool Tata,
venue will be booked. Guzder said that the
foreign delegates had voiced concern vited by the Iranian government and the
about getting visas. But the Iranian
authorities told him “Forget about it. We the organizing of the Sixth WZC under the Wednesday to Saturday delegates would
will help you to get visas. ” The deputy chairmanship ofDrMahyar Ardeshiri. The have to arrive in Tehran the Friday before
foreign minister Abbas Maleki and the quartet included Modi, who had helped the Congress and depart the Friday after,
new counsel general in Bombay Seyed organize the fourth and fifth congresses in Emirates airlines flies thrice a week to
Kamal Yasini promised the organizers Bombay as joint honorary secretary, noted Tehran but may not offer any discount,
“whatever you want. ” Even visas for industrialist Sohrab Godrej, Delhi Parsi Group booking on the Emirates to Tehran
Zoroastrians in North America would be Anjuman ’s president Lt Gen Adi Sethna costs approximately Rs 16,000, according
“no problem, ” said Modi as long as the (retd) and his wife Khorshed. to Modi.
application forms were routed through “In the past Zoroastrians in Iran were Friendly Tours have been authorised to \
the local punchayet, anjuman or associa
tion. Homi. Talyerkhan reiterated that the Guzder, “That has all changed. Zoroastri-
Iranian government was “very keen to
hold the Congress ” and that the meet would some restriction on what clothes women
“open up vast areas of cooperation. ” may wear, the delgates “can go anywhere
Delegate fees have been fixed at US $ they like. ” Permission has been given to
300 except for participants from India and organize tours.
“Iran is changing a little from what we
Rs 11,000 for all others.
The delegate fees for students from Congress. Explaining the dress code for
India and Pakistan is Rs 2,000. The age women. Modi said that “nobody knows
limit for students has not been specified exactly what the attire should be. ” Women
must wear a large scarf but it need not
cover all the hair. She ^ggested that a
loose coat or smock be worn over their
i
Delegates must send their registration
forms by March 31,1996 after which date clothes. The salwar khameez is preferable *
„ ¦ " ' . ¦ ”. to saris. Fitting or figure hugging clothes |
After the application has been received the should not be worn. Women will have to
wear socks and shoes. Men should prefer-
issue invitations to those who they wish to ably wear long sleeved shirts.
enroll. The basis for selection of the del-
Guzder said a committee had been
Iran Air would be offering “a special
concession ” to those attending the Con
gress said Guzder. Modi estimated the cost
of attending the congress and staying in i
Iran for two weeks to be around Rs 50,000
per person. This includes the air fare, i
BPP chief executive Rustom Anklesaria touring Iran and accommodation in Tehran
during the Congress . The two weeks stay is
necessitated by the fact that Iran Air flies
from Bombay to Tehran and back only on
Tehran Anjuman last year to help initiate Fridays. As the Congress will be held from
Four Indian Zoroastrians had been in-
{
“In the past Zoroastrians in Iran were
not at liberty to do what they liked, ” said make tour arrangements for groups of 25
’ ‘ “ each to Iran. Those participating in the
ans are given full freedom. ” Except for tours will be accommodated in two and
three star hotels during their stay. The tour )
20 Parsiana December 1995organisers will also provide loose coats for
the women to wear. There is no limit on the
number of delegates from India, said
Guzder. Guzder and Modi expect “hope-
Visas lor
Zoroastrians in
North America would
be “no problem”
fully a hundred ” delegates will attend from
India.
Four topics have been selected for the
congress. These are;
a) Increase cooperation among the world
associations in order to preserve our cul
tural and religious heritage, promote
progress and improve the living conditions
of Zoroastrians (especially our youth).
b) Reinforcement of the schools for edu
cating the priests (mobeds), and allocation
of special funds to send outstanding priests
to well-known universities.
c) Promote religious education to the Zo
roastrian youth.
d) Make decisions on the future of Zoroas
trians (especially our youth), including
investments and the use of assets for future
generations.
Those wishing to present a paper on any
of the above topics for not more than 20
minutes should send their papers or ab
stract by March 31, 1996 to Dr Khoshrow
Dabestani, general secretary, 6th World
Zoroastrian Congress, No. 8 Zarthoshtian
Street, Mirza Koochak Khan St, Jamhori
Ave, Tehran 11316, Iran.
Speakers should be researchers in their
respective topics, said Modi. If too many
papers are received on the same topic, the
executive council will evaluate the same
and decide upon the speaker and whether
other papers received should be printed in
the proceedings. Participants who speak at
the Congress will not be charged any reg
istration fee.
The principle language at the Congress
will be Farsi (Persian) but there will be a
simultaneous translation facility into En
glish and vice-versa.
The other trustees present at the press
conference were Ms Silloo Kavarana, Din-
shaw Mehta, Dadi Engineer and Rustom
Tirandaz.
Those wishing to attend the Congress
may contact Modi or Tata, c/o The B ombay
Parsi Punchayet, 209, Dr D. N. Road, Fort,
Bombay 400001, tel nos. 2617421/22/23,
2620028 or their respective anjumans,
punchayets or associations.
22 Parsiana December 1995
ZOROASTRIANS ABROAD
continued from page 16
patents, the scientist is currently pursuing
discovery research in cardiovascular areas,
of particular interest to his organization.
This is the first time in the history of the
company that anyone in the chemical sci
ences was promoted to this highest scien
tific level, notes the press release. S.
Hanessian, McConnell professor of chem
istry and NSERCC chair in medicinal
chemistry at the University of Montreal,
who is rated as Canada ’s number one
scientist in this field, described Bagli ’s re
search as “characterized by its practicality
and elegance. Jehan is an outstanding
synthetic medicinal chemist and a true
scholar. His contributions to the discipline
Sarosh Zaiwalla (extreme right), senior
partner of Zaiwalla and Company,
solicitors, with British Prime Minister
John Major and Ms Norma Major at the
Prime Minister’s Huntingdon Consti
tuency ’s Annual Christmas Ball and
with Dame Barbara Cartland (below,
right) who unveiled the sculpted head of
Rabindranath Tagore as created by
Shenda Amery
•p
w*u-.
,,4
have been significant and his dedication to
the profession exemplary. ”
After graduating in chemistry and phar
maceuticals from Bombay University,
Bagli obtained his PhD in medicinal chem
istry from the University of London en
route to postdoctoral studies at the Johns
Hopkins University in Maryland, USA.
Joining Wyeth-Ayerst in Montreal in 1960,
Bagli ’s sustained work benefitted his com
pany and his community who elected him
their founder president when the Zoroas
trian Association of Quebec was formed in
1967, was the founder-editor of its news
letter, Gavashni, for many years before
agreeing to take on the FEZANA newslet
ter in a similar capacity. Though he has
withdrawn from these positions in the past
few years, he continues to contribute to
Zoroastrian scholarship through lectures
and articles, partitular zeal being reserved
for the reformation and unification of the
Zoroastrian calendar and its restoration to
seasonal accuracy.
Bagli was invited to move to Princeton
in 1983 with his wife Freny, when Wyeth-
Ayerst closed their Montreal laboratory
for political reasons. In his new professio
nal position Bagli will continue as a major
contributor “in expan
ding 'lhe boundaries
of knowledge in his
specialty, ” providing
the drive and innova
tiveness to steer resea
rch projects to corpo
rate success while
functioning as an
“eminently regarded
advisor and consultant
of senior manage
ment, ” notes the press
release.
i
Compiled by Amavaz S. Mama
s
t
}
i
t
!
t
i
1
1J
HORTICULTURE
COVER STORY
Their pioneering effints in the field of cut-flower exports
have earned the Masanis interruttional and national recognition.
the lortest being the Krishi Bhushun
Parinaz Gandhi
(^^f^ook behind... and there are blooms.
C9t-
“leave « Xtou"" :™,vc':"' ’hraXis:i S I"
thTO^'a "" "’’',^'“’'2° '"f f™ •h' <>P«” focum to meMS^e SwSid bTpXreed ’’’“Itt
a towards an assessment of the need for to enlighten the citizens. ”^*The Federation
p ate body of those anjumans and change and the community ’s intellectual is not trying to hide anything from our
punchayets where they can safeguard their discretion. In point, Bhacca related an vnmh tLv j:.
said newsletter article, he said. However,
among themselves, say different things at
of time. ” He continued tongue-in-cheek.
By 2005 there will be two crore Parsis
V
of FOZYA made a blanket “youth sup
ports Mubarakai ” statement. _____________
While R. Anklesiina. in his personal according to the Pundolites. Someone will
come and look into your eyes and heart and
, I are
a Parsi) he ’ll convert you to Zoroastrian
ism... If that is not conversion what is? ’’
capacity appreciated the efforts of his
children as Zoroastrians, he questioned,
“Certain changes have to come. Is there a
socioeconomic issues?...
evolve... ” he advised.
This led the focus of the open forum to
shift towards an assessment of the need for
Let things ting the subject in its right prespective; ”
1_______ z * .« • «
a separate body of those anjumans and change and the community ’s intellectual
religion. ” It was Patel ’s contention that by
incident in
the publication of such material our youths had sought admission in their orphanage ~ •
took the cue that the road is now clear to The late Maneck Gheyara ’s experienced
marry outside the community. ” He was f *' • • -
also worried that Parsi trusts were unable a Parsi. The then president told her to bring
poverty in the her father and mother with her and i‘
converts? First the child of Parsi fathers.
Now children of Parsi mothers. Then Con
version. When other communities (
know that this community gives money to the girl performed and then admitted her to
produce children... think about it. ” Patel C___ _____
concluded by espousing “great faith in this few months'
‘"8 facts from oir
^^eki Gandhi. Please con- was not performed though he wore the youngsters ’’” Gandhi read out nhiAPtc
tmue wtft fte good work you arc doing sudrch-kusti. “Some fine%riest in Surat 0^*0 Seradon tarn S conXta to
leave aside (these) controversial matters. ” performed his navjote. We knew nnthina r.rz^a,ra Aut j.,*.. _r . ..
APP’s Porus Karanjawalla, president of about it. ” At the other end of the
From left: Pardiwalla, Guzder, Marfatia
and HPY club members
eye told him that the girl was probably not
a Parsi. The then president told her to bring
community. “What about the influx of transpired that the mother was Hindu the
parents were unmarried and no navjote had
been performed. Gheyara made them un-
come to dergo a civil marriage, had the navjote of
the orphanage. Bhacca further noted that a
Calicut ’s Darius Marshall.
Gandhi felt impelled to defend his ar
ticle; “People have said ‘Who are you to
talk about religi^. Ask priests and high
it priests. ’ To answer the point, go'back to
the High Court judgement. B speaks of a
committee of experts report which noted
that the Zoroastrian religion enjoins con
version. Even in 1908 the BPP trustees had
admitted that Ms (Sooni) Tata was a Zoro
astrian and her navjote was valid. How can
ago a 32-year-old man who they say the opposite now?... Are we say-
came to Surat from Iran, said his navjote
was not performed though he wore the
performed his navjote. We knew nothing
------------------ ; spectrum,
a Zoroastrian lawyer, an ordained priest
who was the executor of a will whereby a
bungalow had been bequeathed to the SPP,
prove that “it is the duty of the Federation
to promote true knowledge of Zoroastrian
ism. We are giving everyone a chance to
speak, to express every point of view... Do
not shut out intelligent debate. The objec-
z- IP
’•cr-
34 Parsiana December 1995
1
i
1tions are raised because this article under
mines what has been preached wrongly by
priests and the orthodox. ”
Uran Anjuman, had made contact with the
BPP. It is understood that if certain prop- _ ... ................
erhes are taken over by the Defence Pardiwalla said they Wuc wiih
inistry (as the Uran dokhma is, for the gaged couples inviting them for
_ — defence for the Bombay harbour), one can ~
Some homes and agiaries in the Udvada/ ask for equivalent land elsewhere, he noted.
Surat region have been burgled, informed Mistry voluntered help and urged the BPP
Bhacca and another Surat representative
Davar Cawasji Modi. Their tales under
lined the problems of aging and progres
sively impoverished communities. One
case pertained to the adanan in Surat ’s
feo
Defunct anjumans
1
kJ
IR
1
Parsi Marriage and Divorce Act. Premari-
U1 counselling was on the cards and
' were writing to en-
j a session.
The impact of a divorce on the children
is evidenced by the severe behavioral prob-
to respond quickly. Anklesaria agreed to lors filed for custody of the child as both
pass on the relevant papers to him and
Sethna.
In the matter of the Mistry Adarian ’s
trust property in Boisar where an
lems they encounter. Twice the counsel-
J
parents seemed to manipulate and misuse
the child, but “the court considers the
natural guardian as the best, ” reported
Pardiwalla. On other occasions the inter
vention of the counsellors has
helped children. However,
when they meet in-laws, the
first question they are asked
is “Will you give another
house? ” Pardiwalla felt that
the provision of housing does
not sQem to have increased
the number of children per
family. The one child norm
prevails. “It ’s a personal
option, ” she adds.
Ms Diana Marfatia who
has been involved with
school counselling says the
program currently deals with
about 120 to 180 children a
year with a success rate of about 60 percent,
courts, Its trustees Homi Mehta and Though there are currently six counsellors l
to deal with the six schools under the
program, dedicated community individuals
are hard to find. Non-Parsis need to speak
Parsi ways and empathise with them,
Marfatia noted. These problems prevented
on the land without informing his fellow (' ’
^ustees or the charity commissioner and counselling from the further suburbs
vestments had b^n given to a Hindu clerk.
Gandhi informed the gathering that the
i
F'
i
1
I
w -W-’j
. -fl
.. ...
From left: Dittia,R. Irani andPervez Irani internecine conflict has been
Vakil Atash Behram compound. Also a
Surat lady who keeps open house in Udvada _______ v,aa
“was disagreeably surprised when two falsely claiming it to be a private^ trust
priests came, used the house and pilfered i '
trom It, informed Bhacca. Behind the complaints are that Darabshaw had al-
occurances in Surat and the Iranshah is ‘
“the hand of Parsis. Someone is out to
harass the management... In Bombay two
Parsis were arrested but no one came to
give evidence, ” informed Modi.
The report on defunct anjumans lacked
SPP chief executive Sorab Katpitia ’s pres
ence and authority. While Dharwar and
Hubli, Badnera and Amravati had ex
pressed a desire to opt for the Federation ’s
custodianship, there had been no further
progress. The memorandum of under
standing (MOU) drafted for a similar ar- ___ ,_______ _____________
rangement with the Mhow Anjuman was plete. “ We are unable to understand the
yet to reach them.
At Raipur where 10 to 12 Zoroastrians
reside there is a community property of
about 20,000 sq feet according to Palkhi-
walla. Thnty and Rusi Wadia of Raipur are
lacks proper light and water connections Reporting on the family counselling pro
fought in the
Maneckshaw Mistry complained that
managing trustee Darabshaw Mistry was
trust Theif ’"ajor Gujarati. 'IheyfmditdifficdttoundVsS
lowed a Sai Baba temple to be constructed
the land without informing his fellow
that the brokerage on the trust ’s UTI in-
the inclusion of children in need of
requested by Borivli ’s Khurshed Pastakia.
An off-shoot of the Holiday Programme
if
<
for Youth (HPY) and the Youth Club
-'ex
students, is four or five likely marriages,
informed Anklesaria. -
This was R. Anklesaria ’s last executive
council meet attended as the chief execu
tive of the BPP. Also attending was Behram
Laskari, his successor designate. R. Ankle
saria has, however agreed to continue to
work on the BPP-Federation social service
programs, announced Gandhi.
Federation ’s mandate had already been formed under BPP auspices by the HPY
given. “If the solicitors agree the Federa- • • -
tion will implede itself. Mr Taleyarkhan
will take it up at the political level and
we ’ll take it up at the legal level. ” On his
part Anklesaria noted, on the basis of the
solicitor ’s letter, that the papers are incom-
I
scope and nature of the appeal, ” he added
and requested the complainants to prepare
a short resume from the many appeals and
counter appeals.
said to be looking after the property which Counselling programs
lacks proper light and water connections Reporting on the family counselling pro-
and the well has run dry. The place is said gram operated by the BPP under Federal
t* ' ¦ ¦ ’ ; ___ ___________
deposit of a donation from Dali Chinoy.
Anklesaria reported that Grindwell
Norton ’s Noshir Sidhwa, a trustee of the
to be maintained on interest from fixed
AGM
With the election of office-bearers on the
anvil, Gandhi clarified that the general
presumption was that the president of the
major anjuman in the zone would auto
aegis, counsellor Ms Roda Pardiwalla noted matically become the zonal vice president
that cases had been dwindling in the past ’ " - -
few years perhaps because of the provision
of divorce by mutual consent under the
but according to the Federation ’s constitu
tion, the anjumans in a zone were free to
elect any individual from any location as
36 Parsiana December 1995vice president of their zone. “The idea is to
have five enlightened individuals as vice
pres,den.s.-,„.heeve„,Se,h„,Mogre,ia,
tor. 1 he High Court has granted a stay Dittia, who said it
answer the call and Prof Farokh Vakil,
head of the department of science at AP
»
J
r.
I
Bodhanwalla and Bhacca were elected
vice presidents from the north, south, east
and west B zones. The vice president of
west zone A comprising Bombay and Pune offi ‘cia ’ls~suspect7he hand of
was E. Irani as proposed by his fellow i:„L vjaxiuiu ici
trustee Ms Shiraz Anklesaria and president feud between the Anjuman :
D. Irani - a development that led Gandhi ing back nearlv 13
to comment appreciatively on the latter ’s
lack of ego that permitted him to step aside
in favor of his junior colleague. The chair
man of the BPP is the ex officio president
of the Federation.
At the executive council meeting which trusteeship term expired in 1991 the Tov-
continued after the AGM, Ms Mani ’ gov
Clubwalla, R. Anklesaria, Peshotan
Nargol-walla, Eruch Surti and Rustomji
were co-opted on the executive council.
Eruch Desai and Gandhi continued as
jointhonorary secretaries and R. Anklesaria
as Federation treasurer.
With all paper prices having almost
doubled in the past year and likely to go up
substantially more, Bodhanwalla called
discretion Jn the distribution of As he could
increase in the sponsorship advertisement
rate from Rs 3,500 to Rs 4,000 and the next
14 issues have been sponsored by the BPP
(four), Guzder in his individual capacity
(two) and one each by the DPA, Madras,
SPP, WZO, ppp and Jamshedpur anjumans,
Taleyarkhan and BPP trustee Silloo Kava
rana in their individual capacities.
PZASH vs Dittia
In Secunderabad, the trustees of PZASH
have been suspended and an J ’ 1 _____
appointed by the Andhra Pradesh Endow
ment Board (APEB) which covers all chari
table trusts and Hindu religious trusts,
Gandhi reported to the Federation. The
Board is a said to have received complaints
of financial and other mismanagement at
PZASH and the anjuman was asked to
produce its books of accounts. An agree
ment to sell regarding one of its properties
is now being held up by the Board
authorities as violatory because its
permission was not taken and a show cause
notice has been issued why an administra
tor should not be appointed. Since PZASH
was advised that the Andhra Pradesh
Endowment Act ruling did not apply to
them, they did not answer the summons.
Now the PZASH trustees face an ex parte
order of suspension because they failed to
BPP s Gool Kias and Sheroo Master
with Modi (mike in hand)
until the PZASH case is heard.
The crux of the matter is that PZASH
Mr problems. Gandhi^eiaSaMte
1 and Dittia go
ing back nearly 13 years when Dittia ’s
supporters substituted the nomination of
f ' - - ¦
with his own. The ensuing legal battle was
going in Surti s favor but he passed away
and the matter died with him. When Dittia ’s
no right to interfere in its internal affairs.
“Conversely, an anjuman has no right to
interfere in matters of the Federation. ”
- ---- i was “not very important
for me to be invited, ” noted that he had
attended almost every Federation meet
delegates of the constitutional position
that any anjuman can invite any person
even from another zone to be a vice presi-
that any anjuman can invite any person
tb^' tMT?Took
with his own. The enciiiriCT UfTol kowl.. long
point of view.
Reverting to the genesis of his conflict
with Surti, Dittia maintained that the
managing committee “cannot constrict the
right of the general body, cannot arrogate
not the rights of the general body... the judge
has misunderstood... If the General Body
I’"" :::------j as president for six
years, he should continue there for six
years provided he was a trustee at the time
of his election. ”
Opinion on the issue was divided. E.
Irani noted that the Federation ’s constitu
tion says that the anjuman must propose
the individual wharwill attend the execu
tive council meet. “Since the anjuman is not
seconding him, Dittia should stay away. ”
Former BPP and Federation chairman
Dr Aspi Golwalla, Sethna, Dadi Mistry,
saw it as the Federation ’s right to invite
individuals. Mogrelia and Bodhanwalla
counselled a Compromise. “As the con-
anju- cerned anjuman has put it in writing that he
shouldn ’t be invited, sitting in judgment
can be interpreted as taking sides, ” noted
Mogrelia adding, “I understand Vakil is
also a relation of Dittia... ”
erning body blocked his renomination and
Dittia, then PZASH president, could i
continue to be president when he was no .x...u„ucisioou i
longer trustee. The matter again went to has voted in someone
court and strictures were passed against
Dittia. The PZASH had notified the
Federation that Dittia would not represent
them and at the executive council meet in
Calicut in September 1991 Dittia had stood
down as vice president in favor of Marshall.
1 not be a co-opted member
— — -- ’ c zones had their
own nominees it was decided that Dittia
attend Federation meetings as a special
invitee like Taleyarkhan
Federation: How can you invite a person
who has gone against the anjuman in court?
“Should we take cognizance of what the anju
man says or not? ” Gandhi asked the delegates.
Dittia argued that according to the Fed-
. , eration constitution every anjuman is com-
adrninistrator pletely autonomous and the Federation has
the Fed Newsletter. Gandhi now sought an because each of the five
SPP, WZO, ppp and Jamshedpur anjumans.
s current poser to the
4’
*
37 Parsiana December 1995
b“I am ashamed to think that a man of my
earth it. She has found a stone afarganyu xaiuaMmuicutoLiunKinaiamanormy earth it. She has found a stone afarganyu SherooMaster,MsHomaiModi MsDiana
a„dbUso5ouerybu.„on,e.a>ofa„y«„d. Marfada, Ms Reda Pardiwalla, “S:
jecting Mogrelia ’s compromise that he
should get the APEB to withdraw its action
and should himself withdraw his suits
against PZASH in return for the vice
presidentship of the Federation and in- _____________ ____
sisted that he be given a copy of the PZASH preserve it from erosion.
R. Irani urged the community to con
tribute to found a chair in Zoroastrian
re-
Carbon dating of these, together with bricks Khushnooma Deboo, Ms Urvakshi Mistry
and other items from the area has revealed T.
them to be between 300 and 1,200 years Readymoney from Bombay; Khurshed
old. Of Ajmalgad ’s three lookouts, only " • ¦ -
one remains. A cemented watertank which
was excavated now needs to be closed to
Burzin Mehta, Delzad Captain and Dick
Pastakia from Borivli; Darius Marshall
from Calicut; Zarthosht Mubarakai and
Pervez Irani from Dahanu; Lt Gen Adi
Sethna, Dadi Mistry, Noshir Captain,
Farokh Rustomji, Keki and Homi Gandhi
from Delhi; EduIji Dumasia from Dumas;
on the study at the Deccan College which will Aspi Irani from the Iranian Zoroastrian
provide a salary of Rs 30,000 p.a. to enable Anjuman; Homi Bodhanwalla and Eruch
her to continue her work. Asked what the
excavation itself would cost, Irani noted
had been researching at Ajmalgad recently not permit her to excavate unless she is
affiliated to a college. She told the gather
ing that she would like to pursue these
excavations together with explorations in
Sanjan and Diu as a lifelong task.
Barot they moved to the old fort at Ajmalgad Those attending the executive council meet
where they spent 15 more years before were: Ms Dolat Debara from Agra; Porus
related R. Irani adding, “Archeology is the Patel, Baman Cama and Homi Chothia
only way to find history in the absence of from Baroda; Zubin Jambusarwala from
written records... The Kisseh-e-Sanjan is
the only document we have. ”
A tunnel is said to have linked Bahrot to
Ajmalgad and R. Irani is anxious to un-
letter to enable him to give a written reply
as the matters were in court.
The council seemed to concur
need for compromise.
Surti from Jamshedpur; Ronnie Dick from
Jhansi; Nariman Mogrelia from Madras;
Pervez Mandviwalla from Mandvi; Dara
Deboo from Navsari; Dara Irani, Eruch
Irani, Firdous Kayani, Kersi Daruwala,
Boman Irani, Farokh Irani, Ms Shiraz
Anklesaria, Sarosh and Navaz Palkhiwalla
and Ms Farzana Taraporewalla from Poona;
Homi Palsetia and Ms Ruby Balsara from
„. ,, ” , z -------°------------------------ — Saronda; Dr Sam Bhacca, Davar Kavasji
where they spent 15 more years before were: Ms Dolat Debara from Agra; Porus Modi, Homi R. Mehta and Manekshaw
ngjo Navsm and thence to Udvada Karanjawalla from Ahmedabad; Shavak Mistry from Surat; Rustom Cursetii and
rftlatftn R Tram annino “ Aic DntAl _____ ______ i tt .1 • 7^ tm n
Pervez Bhesania from Thana and Homi
and Hoshedar Mehta from Zai Bordi. Homi
Ajmalgad revisited
Archeologist Dr (Ms) Roxana Irani who that the Archeological Survey of India will
had been researching at Ajmalgad recently not permit her to excavate unless she is
gave a brief talk illustrated with slides. The
Zoroastrians moved the Iranshah from
Sanjan to Bahrot in the 15th century to
preserve the sacred fire from the defile
ments of war. After about 15-20 years in
Bharuch; Jamshed Guzder, Minoo Shroff, Taleyarkhan, Dr Aspi Golwalla and Bezon
Ms Silloo Kavarana, Dinshaw Mehta, ' —
Rustom Anklesaria, Behram Laskari,
Peshotan Nargolwalla, Ms Gool Tata, Ms
Dittia were the special invitees. The press
was represented by The Bombay Samachar
and Parsiana.
MATRIMONIAL
Alliance invited for a 39-year-old,
good-looking, well-settled, Parsi
male, divorced and issueless.
Previous marriage lasted for three
years. The girl should be simple
and home loving. Outstation girls are
also welcome. Apply to:
The Advertiser
Parsiana, Matrimonial (Dec/42-9S)*
QPO Box 892, Bombay 400001
‘Please make sure the reply envelope
bears the reference number cited here.
A Zoroastrian Museum
Always remember
4 TATA
WS BATA
KHAMBATA
Ketayun & Bomi
22/A, Wellington Terrace
Wellington Street, Bombay 400002
Tel No: 2069636, 2057242
Pager No: 9602-104007
is being planned by Ms Zerbanoo
Gifford of London. Please donate
Books, Magazines, Pictures,
Artefacts etc, and send them to
Ms Zerbanoo Gifford
Herga House, London Road
Harrow-on-the-Hill
Middlesex - AWl 3JJ (U.K.)
38 Parsiana December 1995
I¦
SCHOLARSHIP
Status of Women: sacred and secular - 3
Created
to procreate
Dr Ketayun H. Gould
A Zoroastrian woman’s destiny
lay in bearing a troop of male children
The image of a liberated Zoroastrian that certain divinities perceived as
female on par with the male is only an female entities were venerated, that the
illusion, an ideal that has yet to be soul of a dead man was said to be met
realized. There is no denying that in by afemalefigure on its upward journey,
certain spheres she has been granted Yet within the stronghold of the
equal opportunities but she has had aristocracy and priesthood in the pre-
to suffer discrimination too. This article ~ '
which will run into six instalments
analyzes the relevant texts and tradi
tions to study the status of women in deemed allies of Ahura Mazda to fight
the ancient, medieval and modern
periods.
As it originally appears in Religion
and Women (a publication ofthe State period.
'University of New York Press, 1994) the
paper entitled “Outside the discipline,
inside the experience: women in Zoro
astrianism ” is a researched, academic lent belief that menstruation causes a
presentation. Since Parsiana will be woman to lose her ritual purity and
carrying an abridged version ofthe text spread impurity if she comes in contact
to make it simpler for the lay reader, we with others. Even though religious
will not be detailing the sources that the equality was denied to females in
author painstakingly cites at each
instance.
In the first two instalments we learnt
Zoroastrian era, paradise was denied
to women. With the advent of Zara
thushtra, both men and women were
the evil forces. The domestic routine
though was considered to be of prime
concern to the females in the ancient
While marriage and the begetting of
children is advocated in Zoroastrianism,
the third instalment dwells on the preva-
ancient times, within the confines of a
patriarchal society women were ceded
certain economic and legal rights.
These passages display not only an interest
in physical beauty, but a connection bet
ween youthfulness and virility, and the
child-bearing capacity of the maiden. In
her daily prayers, the maiden is said to ask
for a boon of “a husband, young and beau
tiful of body, who will treat us well, all life
long, and give us offspring; a wise, learned,
ready-tongued husband (Yasht .15.40).”
And what is the ideal of female beauty?
The ideal is personified in the description
of the maiden of the bridge discussed in the
first two instalments: “beautiful maiden,
brilliant, white-armed, strong, well-grown,
erect, tall, high-bosomed, graceful, noble,
with a dazzling fall, of 15 years (Martin
Haug). ”
The p2irents or guardians generally ar
ranged the marriage, although the girl was
consulted in the choice of the husband.
The ideal union was considered to be based
on mutual affection. There is some
evidence, however, that under certain cir
cumstances, there was some room for love
marriages. Moreover, in this context,
women were described as being capable of
stepping outside the societal constraints of
role definition and display the “force of
character ” to “go straight to (their) objective
without hesitation (P. B. Va^a). ”Thus,
we read in the Shah Namah, that women
like Manijeh, Rudabeh and Tahmina were
“transported by love into making active
advances, ” while at the same time
protecting themselves and soothing their
beloved ’s male ego by disclaimers about
their “immodesty ”: “No one has ever seen
me outside the purdah nor has any man
ever heard my voice (Vacha). ”
The fact that there were at least .a few
Zoroastrian women who gave themselves
permission to act in an unconventional
manner though using conventional excuses
(transported by love) cannot be seriously
doubted. Nor can it be denied that the
stories display a certain amount of grudg-
*
Other evidence about the ideal role of a delight of her husband in the future (Darab
woman can be gleaned from the develop
mental highlights that are singled out for
attention in the sacred liturgy. The Avesta ily life and begetting children led to the
contains direct allusions to the status of a early marriage of girls at about the age of ing respect for women who are the respon-
maiden in the “father ’s ” house (the patri- 15 — “at the age of puberty, with earrings sible parties in consummating the union,
lineal and patrilocal family). She was given ' ~ '
training in the religious schools after the (Vendidad 14.15).” Obviously, chastity is
age of seven so she could be initiated into
her faith. Other than that, education con
sisted of preparation for the housewifely about the value of the same quality in a ized as proof of the “high ” status ofwomen
in the Zoroastrian tradition.
The general Zoroastrian view of sexual
love is that within marriage, sex and pro
well, having her husband as her lord (Ga creation are virtuous acts, since the beget-
A Q\ ” .l;ij__ i__ :_______ ____ ¦____
The texts also provide an instructive
Dastur Peshotan Sanjana). ”
This concern for building a stable fam-
15 — “at the age of puberty, with earrings
in her ears... whom no man has known There is no reason, however, to believe as
some authors have done (Sanjana), that
these scattered instances of alliances bet
ween aristocratic lovers can be general-
considered to be the most essential quality
in a bride, although no mention is made
role:
“General training in moral and reli
gious precepts, the elementary rules of (Yasht 11.4)” is “receiving her instruction
sanitation, the art of tending domestic ani- i ..............................................................~
mals, of spinning and weaving the sacred 4.9).” ting of children brings more people into
girdle as well as garments, of superinten- The texts also provide an instructive the world to do battle against the evil spirit,
ding the laborers in the field and the milking view of the ideal images of the maiden and Every new birth is seen as sending a thrill
of the cows ... in short she aspired to be the her fantasies of the prospective bridegroom, through the whole creation of Ahura Mazda
groom. Another characteristic that is
praised besides a “mind absorbed in piety
39 Parsiana December 1995centered on the Zoroastrian belief that
menstruation results in a woman losing her
sexuality is viewed in the context of a child conceived of a stranger and presents ritual purity and becoming capable of
it to her husband (Yasht 17.54).” Such a spreading the impurity to all those who
woman is unfit to offer any prayers (Yasht have contact with her. Thus, husband and
wife were strictly forbidden to have inter
course during this period, and for three
days after she had performed her post-
menstrual ablutions. Ignoring this taboo is
listed as the fourth of the five sins that
render one aPeshotanu (a high level of sin
requiring a punishment of up to 90 lashes
— Vendidad 15.7, 13-16). 'Hie Vendidad
goes even further by declaring that such a
man does not act better than “if he should
burn the corpse of his own son, born of his
own body... and drop its fat into the fire
17.54). The yazata Haoma is entreated to (16.17).”
¦ ! Obviously, the Zoroastrian conception
harlot, with her magic minds o ’erArowing of menstruation and its relationship with
and casting a shadow of gloom over the female: “the courtesan who destroys her
wicked world of Angra Mainyu. In this ............... ...
sense, i
a religious duty, and as such, it is a pious
act only within the confines of marriage.
However, within this narrow definition,
there is no downgrading of the physical
needs of the human body compared to the
higher status of the spiritual sphere. Hence,
the celibate state is discouraged. In fact,
Avesta recognizes the joy that the
sexual encounter can bring to both husband
and wife, although the language and
imagery reflect a male world-view: “The
men whom thou dost attend...have their
ladies that sit on their beds, waiting for
them: they lie on the cushions, adorning
themselves... ‘When will our lord come?
When shall we enjoy in our bodies the joys hurl her mace “against the body of the
of love? ’(Yasht 17.10)” 1 . ' „..................................._
The patriarchal nature of the family and with (intoxicating) pleasures ” (Yasna the status of women is a far broader subject
................ ........ . ¦ ¦ ...... taboos associated with marital
faithful or unfaithful, there is no difference relations. The notion that menstrual blood
(Vendidad 18.62). Furthermore, the male is dangerous is widespread among many
control of the family especially the “own- cultures and religions (Denise L. Carmody
fruit ” and the “courtesan who brings forth
All Zoroastrians
are thought
to be polluted by
impurities
associated with
the birth process
society during the ancient period is evident 9.32).” Whether she gives her body to the
from the fact that conjug^ infidelity as a - - - - - -........................-
sin and an offense is spelt out very care
fully in the case of a woman, but the texts
are silent on how adultery is perceived ership ” of the female, is demonstrated by and H. R. Hays). In Zoroastrianism, all
among men. The infnngement of chastity the fact that once the woman has borne
on the part of a woman grieves Asi (femi
nine personification of piety), who is pic
tured as fleeing to the heavens or sinking Choksy).
into the earth at the sight of an unchaste
substances leaving the body are consi-
children, she cannot be divorced for any dered ritually im|jure and polluting. Such
other reason except adultery (Jamsheed K. substances include hair, nails, skin, feces,
saliva, breath, blood, semen and menstrual
Other taboos on sexual intercourse are blood.
I*'
If
For Pure Diamonds
JEWELLERS
324, Grant Road, Bombay 400007. Telephone 3099648 Fax 3073483
APPOINTED VALUERS BY THE GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
40 Parsiana December 1995
Iih
M
4
/
C
These substances are open to grave
pollution by the corpse demoness, since
creation of with unconsecreted bull ’s urine and water
while saying the required prayers. Other
prayers that specifically ask for expiation
from sins were also recited. At menopause
a woman was required to have priests
which marked her rejoicing in “being
able thus to prepare herself for eternity
Although pregnancy gave a woman re
spite from the restrictions attendant on
. Liidi uic z.oiuas- apan tor tMis purpose. Any Zoroastrian menstruation, the texts soecifv that child
t^ine linked the origm of men- who had physical contact with her was birth also lesd^SS^^t^^
to a blight caused by the evil required to purify himself or herself with the mother and the child AJl taboos that
h unconsecrated bull ’s urine and water. The apply to the menstruant are to be enforced
IS w.tr era t .......1 m^struant was supposed to abstain from during this period. It would seem logical to
everything she touched became polluted.
r --------- uwiiiwiivaa, aiiivc Ahura Mazda. The texts specify that a
any flow of blood out of the body is a menstruant should withdraw 15 paces from
fro™ other Zoroastrians (Ven —---- < ’ • • — . . : . _
visit to England; and A. Das Gupta’s In
dian Merchants and the Decline of Surat ____ _____ _
(1979). A careful study of all these and accede to their demands. Barring a tempo-
many other sources has resulted in the rary period when Rustam Maneck was
compilation of an article by Dr Homi dismissedfromtheemploymentoftheEng-
Eduljeeon“RustamManeckandHisSons: -
Brokers of Surat’’ carried in the Journal of
the K. R. Cama Oriental Institute (KRCOI),
No 60.
To acquaint our readers with the vicis
situdes in the lives of Rustam Maneck and selves and waging a feud with their rival
------
KRCOI trustees to reprint an edited and sons fell out of favor with the English. The
Rustam Maneck was called upon to
range a meeting between their English and
on Rustam job that requried great tact, diplomacy
Rustam Maneck later when he had to se
cure the release of the ambassador who
had offended the Mughals by refusing to
The attitude of tht>-Bombay Council
towards the Rustamjees began to change in
1722. It had been customary to give pre
sents to the Rustamjees on the marriage of
their children; in January of that year the
. . . „ Council decided to stop these gifts. By
lish Company, he continued to be favored now Laldas Parekh ’s fortunes had revived
as a broker. The fourth instalment found and in April 1722 he told the Company that
him negotiating new deals even at the age ' ~
of 86 years.
Preoccupied withfighting among them-
his sonsParsianahas been permitted by the brokers, the Parekhs, Rustam Maneck’.
abridged version of the text from their supremacy that the family once enjoyed in
Surat was no more and one after another
the sons opted to settle in Bombay as is
recounted in this fifth, and last, instalment.
Journal. Along with this piece there is
another dissertation in the same publica
tion, “The Zoroastrian Calendar: an Over-
the Ruslamjccs had committed fraud in the
accounts of their investments and in the
‘laskari ’ account of Rustam. He also of
fered, to provide the annual investment for
the next season on cheaper terms than that
offered by the Rustamjees in the previous
year. Laldas ’ offer was accepted and Phipps
set up a committee to look into the allega
tions of fraud. The committee consisted of
Robert Newlin who was neutral between
43 Parsiana December 1995Bombay account books clearly showing him to England his nephew Bhikaji
the credit balance standing in the Rustam-
the two parties; Robert Cowan, a staunch
friend of the Parekhs, and John Hope, a _
friend of the Rustamjees. The committee jees ’ name. Armed with such information,
was to meet in Surat and use Laldas to
uncover the facts.
The Rustamjees raised the obvious ob
jection that their accounts had been thor
oughly examined by Aislabie and Boone provide him with passage on one
and nothing wrong had been found; more- ships,
over, the old accounts books had been
burnt and were no longer available. Laldas
was not to be deterred. He found two
Banias who had supplied cloths to the
English (through the Rustamjees) who said
they had supplied the cloths at a much
lower price than what the Rustamjees had
charged the Company. The committee also
found that the brokers had gained almost
complete control of the private trade of the
English at Surat and had charged one per
cent commission on all such trade which
did not pass through their hands. At about
this time the Company became suspicious
that Framjee and Bomanjee were in corres
pondence with the Mughal Governor of
Surat to get the Company ’s trading privi
leges revoked.
The Council overruled the Rustamjees ’
obiections and as punishment suspended against the pirates, but he did notice that . .
them from the service ofthe Company and trade was very Jucrative. He Qu^elled belwve you toLe
rescinded the award that had been made in
favor of Rustam ’s ‘laskari ’ account. In
their report the committee wrote: “The
family of Rustam, in their prosperity, had
carrv ’d verv hauehtilv and made use ofthe ---------rr ---------------- „
crX devolved upon them, from being help, for he demanded of the Bombay Company it may give room for reproacfr
employ ’d in the Company ’s service, to Council that they release Bomanjee, tell- A week later Cowan again warnd Hope
enrfch^themselves and depress all others. ” them that thev were only traders and not to be too solicitous about the Rustam-
Troubles now heaped upon the Rustam
jees. In January 1723 Bomanjee went to
Bombay to plead his family ’s case before
the Council. The Council, instead of hear
ing him, first placed him under house
arrest and then confined him to the fort. In
August Framjee was arrested by the Gov
ernor (_____ ,
the instigation of Cowan and Phipps, and
forced to pay Rs 50,000 to the Gover-
besides Rs 200 per day for the supply to say we
Khurshedji Wacha, 12 servants and, ever
the merchant, a large quantity of merchan
dise to sell in England. He reached Eng
land at the end of April 1724.
In the meantime Framjee appealed to
Nowrosjee may have felt that he had a
good case to plead. There was, however,
one problem: how was he to get to London?
He could hardly expect the Company to Delhi against his arrest by the Nawab and
of their he eventually obtained an imperial order
which secured his release in early 1724.
J We have seen that the Bombay Council
Matthews. The European Companies were knew by January 1723 that the Rustamjees
still plagued by pirates and in 1719 the were in discussion with Matthews about
United Company prevailed upon their gov- getting a passage for one of them to go to
informed London about this, for in a letter
dated September 7, 1723 Robert Cowan
wrote to John Hope, president at Surat,
about London ’s reactions to Phipps ’s pun
ishment of the Rustamjees and their at
tempt to go to London: “The letter from
London is pretty tart according to Custom
but more relating to former management
than the present Governor Phipps. His
measures are generally approved and par
ticularly the prosecution of the late brokers
hews, to Indiato suppress piracy. Matthews strenuously recommended. They are pre
reached Bombay in September 1721; he pared to give Nowros a proper reception
does not seem to have been very active when he arrives^. I laid before the Board
Fram ’s petition which you sent me. It will
ity in designing to come to'll fair account
before you demand to have him released |
for should he persist in his obstinacy and
The problem was solved by Thomas
still plagued by pirates and in 1719 the
ernment to send a squadron of the Royal England. They must have immediately
Navy, under Commodore Thomas Matt-
''If any dispute
happens among
you then you will ruin
your business''
with both Charles Boone and William
Phipps and let it be known that he would
aid all those with whom the Company had
a quarrel. Bomanjee (or his brothers in the Surat Government prove cold hereafter
Surat) must have appealed to Matthews for when applied to for obtaining justice to the
t
Council that they release Bomanjee, tell
ing them that they were only traders and
had no powers to punish anyone. The jees: “Your solicitations on behalf of that
Council obviously ignored him. In appeal- f *, ’* -
ing to Matthews, Framjee and Nowrosjee while they continue obstinate wKhout .
wrote: “...when gentlemen here were in showing the least inclination or design of
very great distress, (Rustam Maneck) was coming to an account. The hardships they
first taken into the Company ’s service undergo from the Surat Government under
merely for his abilities, his continual ap- the pretense of obliging them to do the
family are not acceptable to the president.
showing the least inclination or design of
coming to an account. The hardships they
the pretense of obliging them to do the
of Surat, Momim Khan Dehlami, at plication to their affairs and his good Company justice tho probably the real
success therein, continued him in their intent is something else, they can only
service to his last day... We have the glory blame themselves for, but I smcerely think ¦
that after the insolent behavior they have
shown to the President in the sundry steps
they have taken, they have no reason to ;
expect his patronage or protection, until J
they expiate for their sauciness by a sincere |
repentance. ” J
Nowrosjee reached London in April
1724 and lost no time in arranging a meet
nor besides Rs 21x) per day for the supply to say we are sons of a father, who at least
of food and water to himself and his family, deserved well of the English nation. ’
Nowrosjee seems to have escaped arrest.
He now decided to go to London and
personally place the family ’s case before passage to one
the Court of Directors and seek redress ' ‘
from them.
Nowrosjee may Lave been fortified in
his resolve to go to London by the fact that
the Rustamjees had friends in Bombay
They then explained their case to
Matthews and asked him if he would give
of the brothers to enable
him to go to England. Matthews agreed.
The Rustamjees ’ letter was sent by
Matthews to Bombay in early January
1723,anditwas probably this thatprompted ing with the Court of Directors, lhe Court
the Bombay Council to have Framjee plac- Book records that at the Court of Directors
who'^W "him^with valuable inside ed under house arrest in Surat. heldonMay ‘34724“Nowrosj«Rust^-
- - ............ Nowrosiee sailed for England after the jee presenting himself to the Court dehv
monsoon in __
Captain Braithwaite. Nowrosjee took with
information about the Company. When he
appeared before the Directors he surprised
them by producing a duplicate set of the
heldonMay 13,1724“NowrosjieeRustam-
in the Salisbury, commanded by ered in a petition in behalf of himself and
his brothers late brokers at Surat praying
44 Parsiana December 1995
*Uli
that justice may be done them in relation to
the demands which he alleges they have on
the Company. Ordered that it be referred to
the Committee of Correspondence to ex
amine into the allegations of the said peti
tion and to report from time to time to this
Court how they find the same. He was
called in and acquainted therewith. ”
Having placed his case before the Di
rectors, Nowrosjee now turned his mind to
business. On June 19 he petitioned the Bomanjee and Framjee which being read resolved that this Court do agree thereto.
Directors that the goods he had brought and debated. Resolved that this Court don ’ t and that the letters be prepared accor-
from Surat be allowed to be sold with the think fit to make any alterations therein but dingly. And Nowrosjee was called in and
Company ’s goods. This was agreed to. He that he may have them as they are or else acquainted therewith. ”
then presented a petition “relating to his they shall be cancelled. And he being The letter was given to Nowrosjee on
brothers Framjee ’s confinement at Surat called in was acquainted therewith. To August 19 and is dated that day. The letter
and Bomanjee ’s at Bombay. ” The Com- which he replied he could not take them for mentions: “But however the case be, we
mittee of Correspondence prepared a draft they would do him no good. Whereupon have at Nowrosjee ’s request consented
of a letter to the President and Council of another motion being made resolved that and agreed and do hereby direct and order
that you do give leave to Bomanjee, if he
do yet remain at Bombay, to go to Surat
Nowrosjee also presented a second pe- whenever he pleases without delay and
_ I that you do your endeavor by proper
“five thousand pounds for the reasons application to the Governor of Surat to get
therein mentioned. ” In reply to his second Framjee released from confinement, and
I the guards taken off from his late father ’s
“two thousand pounds to be advanced him house. Our desire to bring to end all differ-
for his present subsistence and on ac
count. ”
The refusal of the Court ’s letter to
He would aid
all those with whom
the Company had
a quarrel
Bombay seems strange as the letter gave
instructions for Nowrosjee ’s brothers to be
freed. Eventually on August 12 “Nowrosjee
Rustamjee desiring to speak with the Court,
was called in, and requested that he might
have six letters to the President and Coun
cil of Bombay relating to his brothers ’
confinement at Surat and Bombay of the
same tenor as those sometime since pre
pared, and the same being considered.
The letter was given to Nowrosjee on
I
I
Bombay, and this was read and approved the said letters be cancelled and they were
and it was decided to give Nowrosjee six cancelled accordingly. ”
copies of the letter as he desired to send T’
them to Bombay overland by different tition asking the Company to advance him
routes.
The letters must have been delivered to
NowrosjeeimmediatelyfortheCourtBook petition, the Court on July 8 granted him
records that on June 24 Nowrosjee deli
vered a petition “desiring to have alter
ations made in the six letters the Company
gave him... about the releasing his brothers
ences amicably f^jr we would not have him
opprest. ”
The letter was signed by seventeen di-
Progressives
Distance--
rhe /ens for uninterupted vision at different ranges
distance, mid-distance & reading.
Progressives are muitifocai lenses without the tell-tale lines of bifocals.
Progressives need professional care .
For the best results come to Baliwalla & Homi.
One of the finest optometrists &. contact-lens practitioners in the country.
Baliwalla & Homi
Private Limited
Flora Fountain: 365, Dr. D.N.Road, Bombay 400 001 Tel: 287 4916, 2871762 • Dhobi Talao: 614, J.S. Seth Marg, Bombay 400 002. Tel: 201 4906
Parel: J.Merwanji Street, Parel, Bombay 400 012 Tel: 412 6051
45 Parsiana December 1995
*
Ir
rectors amongst them William Aislabie. It
showed that the Bombay Council had given
London a version that differed from the
truth. The letter suggests that the Bombay
Council had tried to get the Rustamjees to
agree to the reasonable request to get the
matter of their accounts settled by arbitra
tion, and they had the support of the mer
chant community of Surat, but that the
Rustamjees were obdurate. Also, the letter
suggests that the harsh treatment meted
out to Framjee by the Surat Governor
could have been avoided if Framjee had
behaved civilly and “according to the
Costume of the country. ” Nowrosjee, with
his papers and copies of the Bombay ac
count books, must have presented the Court
with a different picture and influenced
them to order the release of his brothers.
But why did Nowrosjee first refuse to
accept the letter and then, a few weeks
later, change his mind? Probably the tone
of the letter suggested that the brothers
were not entirely blameless and that they
had brought the trouble on themselves by
their behavior while he wanted the Court
to completely exonerate them. Perhaps his
friends in the Company — Aislabie was
one such — may have advised him that he
could not expect anything better, and that
The Rustamjees
had friends in
Bombay who supplied
valuable inside
information
he should accept the letter, specially as it
served his main purpose, which was to
secure the release of his brothers.
On September 18,1724 Nowrosjee was
informed that the claims and counter-claims
made by the Rustamjees and the Company
regarding the debts had been sent to the
Committee of Correspondence. The Court
minutes for November 18 record that the
Committee had recommended that the
matter be left to arbitration and Nowros
jee, on being so informed, agreed. Four
arbitrators, two from each side, were ap
pointed and instructed to determine the
issue in two months.
The arbitrators did their work well, for
the Court Book records under January 12,
1725: “Award given by the arbitrators
between Nowrosjee Rustamjee (in behalf
of himself and Framjee and Bomanjee his !
brothers) as also Rustamjee Maneckjee i
their father deceased and the Company •
dated this day was now read and published,
whereby it appears that there was due from
the Company to the said brothers either in
their own right or as representatives of
their said father Rs 5,46,390 which the
Company are to pay. ” The payment was to
be made in installments; £ 19,125 on Feb- j
ruary 1, 1725 in repayment of two bonds
taken out in 1716; payment to be made in i
England;Rs l,88,195tobepaid ‘atBombay ‘
in the East Indies ’ on or before February 1,
1726 and Rs 1,88,195 to be paid in Bombay
on or before February 1, 1727. It is inter
esting to note that as far as the records go,
the Company made no claims on their
brokers.
Nowrosjee asked for, and was paid, £ ,
15,000 out of the £ 19,125 that was to be
paid to him in London; the balance he
wanted in Surat. His business over, his
thoughts turned to home. On February 5,
1725 he asked the Court to let him and his
retinue travel by the Windham under Cap
tain Lyell. He^lso requested that the Com
pany should not charge him any fares and
should allow free passage for 10 brass i
C0HT«ACTIIUJ,4.
46 Parsiana December 1995
b4
1
i
I
guns, some copper pots, sheet lead and —— ....... . -....
provisions for himself and his servants. All
this was agreed tn hv tho _____ ______t
, . ---- — W (till
this was agreed to by the Company.
1 xV' hitch arose. On March
u ’ L Nowrosjee wrote to the Company
that he was afraid that Mr Proby was going
to have him arrested “on an old but unrea
sonable pretense of an accompt between
him and his late father. ” Also Commodore . - --------
™hews was threatening to stop him inSOlenCC ima^inahlf^*^
from leaving England. Nowrosjee sought UUdginaOie
the Company ’s intervention on his behalf
and requested it to stand security for him. 1
me problem seems to have been sneedilv ;ii,i • icii seriously
solved for, on March 17 the Coutt Bwk of thrnrel^S?
records that the Company have settled his business of the
honorably and much to his
April
1725 and the Windham probably carried
ietter that Charles Boone wrote to Framjee and his famili^ '
and Bomanjee at Surat; the letter is dated it
March 25 1725. In this letter Boone tehs “ “
Nowrosjee: he also
aavised the three brothers should live and \Vo ‘7 ’ “ “ "¦ =>uiiie styie.
work amicably because “in a very short wrote ?'¦ mp.sc in a letter Cowan
tiine It ’s to be hoped the Hon Company 1725-“You^Ho" '
will employ you all jointly as their broker hac not Perceives thatNowros
but if any dispute happens among you then Hp l ™pudence by his travelling,
you will ruin your business. ” From fh2 L'oach and a fine house in..
dance. I am told that he has bilked Matthi
lews
the Company ’s intervention on h
the problem seems to have been
letter that Charles Boone ----- ' "
March 25, 1725. In"t ‘his leUeTBoone ’^
c* *¦-- ' ' ¦
brothers should live
time it ’s to be hoped the Hon
a
tells
your business. ” From the
’^They did constantly "Eighty sum he promised him.
behave to their United
superiors with aiithe of slpTemb? ^25°^^^^^
tion order, instructions to thTBombX
of Directors, and a
- -- ’s obvious that the Governor and his
letter we see that Nowrosjee fell seriously dedsTol of ^the
ill during his Slav in ---------J.uccision or the Comoanv tn npppnt
behave to their
arrogance and
Co
/ in the last
. ¦ . - bringing home
h ’lumphant with the arbitra-
bombshell for the Parekhs. '
his
-— Company to accept the
case in toto; however, they
option but to obey orders and to take
Rustamjees ’
1—lno( ¦
th Rustamjees as brokers and to pay
them the sums according to the arbitradon
show their
thefactoiy. ' from
OnJanuary25, 1726 the Bombay Coun-
“f? - LondoTwhh Ss n ±" 1°"'
of the great pains he took ’
to settle the had
, “every-
great value and esteem for
Company ’s debts,
him because he has managed this affair to
It is apity we have no record of Now- oil
servants he must have live'd in some ’style'
no record of Now-
(illegible) Square wi,h whores in abun-' SnS'a
were taken back into favor;
On receipt of your orders
the admitting (of) Framjee tv u,
Surat, and to present him with
(= an article of dr^s),
for to give him
paid and a general release i,
we directed
to the factory at
-...-1 pamorines
rosewater and beetle
countenance as one taken
‘: is
-------- is given us, the
*
SERSON
Electrolytic Capacitors
For
All Electronic Applications
From
12 VDC To 350 VDC
Manufacturers:
Serson Industries Pvt. Ltd.
Pimpri P.F.P.O., Poona-18.
Cable: Etchfoil Poona-18.
Phone: 772379 & 774296
47 Parsiana December 1995
Ibrothers shall be presented with a sarpaw
(= robe of honor) besides a horse to the
elder brother, which as we take it is the
time you intended it should be made... ”
Bomanjee returned to Surat at the end
of 1726 and the three brothers were again
reunited. They were now riding the crest of
the wave; not only were they reinstated in
the factory but became wealthy as the
Company paid them the amounts under the
award. However, the last years of the 1720s
were not tranquil ones for the Rustamjees;
they quarrelled among themselves and by
the end of 1727 they divided their father ’s
estate and lived separately. Also, at about
this time Sorab Ali, the Governor of Surat,
had the three brothers arrested and put in
jail on a false charge and released them
only when they paid him Rs 70,000.
The Governor was not the only one to
cast covetous eyes on the Rustamjees ’
newly-found wealth. Others turned up
claiming that they had lent large sums of
money to Rustam Maneck, and they now
wanted their money back. Surat was be
coming uncomfortable for the Rustamjees
and in 1727 Nowrosjee shifted his base to
Bombay, and by early 1728 Framjee and
Bomanjee also settled there. The Rustam
jees concentrated their activities in Bombay
where they played a prominent part in
Parsi community affairs. Thus ended the
family ’ s residential ties with Surat although
as brokers of the Company, their business
ties remained.
The Court of Directors in London had
ordered the Bombay Council to recover Rs
1,50,000 from the Parekhs (in connection
with the claim made by Sir John Child ’s
family), and the Council had settled the
matter by recovering only Rs 28,571 from
Laldas. This did not satisfy the Directors
and in early 1728 they ordered the Council
to recover the full amount, and if Laldas
refused to pay, then the position of the
broker was to be offered to Nowrosjee on
condition that he bought over the Child
claim. Laldas was unwilling to pay and the
offer was made to Nowrosjee who wanted
time to think over the matter.
At the end of 20 days Nowrosjee put
forward certain conditions for taking over
the Child claim. They were:
•Nowrosjee would try to recover the money
from Laldas; if Laldas refused then the
Company ’s navy must blockade the port of
Surat to force him to pay;
•the Governor and merchants of Surat must
be informed of the Parekhs ’ debts and that
if Laldas refused to pay then Surat and all
its shipping would suffer by the blockade;
•Laldas and all other Parekhs were to be
turned out of the factory and debarred from j
all English factories;
•the factory must seal all the godowns
belonging to the Parekhs;
•while Nowrosjee was discussing with the
Governor of Surat as to how the money
was to be exorted from Laldas, if the J
Parekhs offered any terms they were not to
be accepted; j
•his brothers were to be associated with
Nowrosjee in the brokerage, and removed
from it, at his pleasure;
•Nowrosjee must nominate the brokers at
Cambay and all other English factories in
Gujarat;
•he would not pay any interest on money
claimed by the Company and would de- |
duct the amount already paid by Laldas.
The conditions are extraordinary by
any standard. It seems that his success in
London had gone to Nowrosjee ’s head. As
one would expect, the Bombay Council
flatly turned them down, describing them
as “exorbitant, insulting and certain to
embroil them with the Governor and mer
chants of Surat. ” Governor Phipps ’ com
ments on the PSrekhs and Rustamjees are
revealing in showing the relative standing ]
___ >______ J
I*
With compliments from
B. B. GARDA & SONS
10 B. J. Road
Poona 411001
48 Parsiana December 1995 I
I4
I
I.
-r
i
of the two parties in the Council:
“Loldass... in general has shown a dis
position to acquit himself in his office with and kind treatment to the sons of Rustam in and their quarrels were conducted through
credit and reputation so as not to risque case they should desire to pass through their sons. This enmity led Framjee and his
that forthe sake oflucre and gain, behaving with their ships and transact business in son to bury their rivalry with the Parekhs
always modestly and with the best man- any part of the State whatsoever; whence I and to become their allies against Now-
ners to his superiors, Whereas the sons of will permit them to sail freely to any other rosjee. The date of Framjee ’s death is also
Rustam have never been to our knowledge part convenient to their business. ” not known. Nowrosjee, as we have seen,
been known to forego any advantage they
could make of either the Company ’s ne
cessities or any others they have had deal
ings with; and the very reverse to the other,
they did constantly behave to their superi
ors with all the arrogance and insolence
imaginable... Besides the reputation of the
different persons in the eyes of these coun
try people with respect to their caste exclu
sive of being the Hon ’ble Company ’s bro
kers, the Banian being Sheet or Principal Framjee ’s son Cowasjee looked after his
(i.e. nagar seth of Surat) of about 400,000
people and the others only in common with
their caste distinguished by a name of other, Nowrosjee ’s son Maneckjee went to
infamy as that of Cawkry, which signifies Surat to put spokes in Cowasjee ’s wheels, facing in Surat; also, Cowan in February
carrion crow. Further, Loldass in his pri- Nowrosjee himself seems to have main- 1734 (NS) was writing disapprovingly of
vate character is looked and adhered to by tained good relationship with the Bombay Nowrosjee ’s behavior. He must have died
all the substantial merchants in Surat as an Council. Robert Cowan, the Governor and in 1734; he was then 69 years old.
honest man, which none of them esteem President at Bombay, had been accused of With the death of Nowrosjee, the con-
either of the sons of Rustam to be. ” receiving a bribe from Nowrosjee. nection of Rust^ Maneck and his sons
Laldas was continued as broker but
pressure was brought on him to accept the
Company ’s claim, which he very reluc
tantly did signing an obligation for Rs Bombay and the Company had forced him commercial center and the importance of
1,60,206 (inclusive of interest) and pleaded ~ — - -
that the matter be kept secret.
We get an interesting glimpse of the last and Maneckjee was able to pay them only
with the help of some influential mer-
wrote to the General on May 10, 1728:
“On my behalf you will extend all help Nowrosjee had now become bitter enemies
Company affairs were concerned. He and
Obviously the Portuguese had not for- was actively involved in Company affairs,
gotten the good service that Rustam and, through his friends on the Bombay
Maneck and his father had rendered them Council intriguing against the Parekhs.
over so many decades. The Rustamjees
obviously did not accept the Portuguese jee died on April 13, 1732. The day and
offer, and although they no longer held a month may well be correct for the corres-
dominant position in Surat, they made ponding day and month according to the
Bombay their main base and operated from Parsi Calendar would have been recorded
there. Framjee and Bomanjee now drop by the family for carrying out the anni-
out of the Bombay Council ’s records.
According to Parsi Prakash, Nowros-
versary ceremonies. The year is obviously
wrong for, Nowrosjee was taking a loan
father ’s interest in Surat and, the three from the Bombay Council in September
brothers now being at odds with each 1733 and the Bombay Diary for Decem
ber 1733 mentions the problems he was
Council. Robert Cowan, the Governor and
President at Bombay, had been accused of
receiving a bribe from Nowrosjee.
Towards the end of 1733 a false rumour with Surat effectively came to an end. The
had been floated in Surat that Nowrosjee 1730s were turbulent years for Surat and
had lost Rs 1,00,000 in various ventures in marked the decline of SurM as a great
to pay Rs 40,000. This led to a rush from Bombay grew. Rustam Maneck had been
his creditors on his son Maneckjee in Surat,
<1
addressed by the honorific title of Seth,
and the title became the surname of his
days of the Rustamjees in Surat in the with the help of some influential mer- three sons and their families. The services
history of the Desai family. When Desai chants of Surat or — as the Bombay Diary that the Seths and their descendants
Khurshedji Temulji ’s father died heavily for December 1733 notes — “Nowrojee ’s rendered to the Parsi community is another
in debt, Khurshedji lived as a tenant in two credit would have been utterly ruined. ” story.
houses owned by his mama (mother ’s —
brother) Ratanji Maneckji. But later his referring to Nowrosjee.
fortune turned and he broke down the two
houses and built a new one there. In this
work he was helped by two brothers who Bombay. The date of his death is not
were prominent citizens of Surat: Framjee known. Framjee kept a low profile as far as religion.
Rustamjee and Bomanjee Rustamjee. Be
cause of the intrigues ofLaldas Parekh and
the fear of the Nawab, the brothers had to
flee secretly to Bombay. They came to
Khurshedji for help and he arranged to see
them safely oft their way accompanying
them up to Baida Pardi. On parting, the
brothers gave him some gold coins and a
gold necklace worth Rs 250 for his mother.
The Rustamjee brothers must have left
Surat in the middle of 1728. They appear to
have contacted the Portuguese to find out
whether they would be allowed to trade in
their territory, and the General of the North
informed Goa of the Rustamjees ’ request in
a letter dated April 30, 1728. In reply, the
Viceroy of Goa Joao de Saldanha da Gama,
credit would have been utterly ruined. ”
This is the last entry in the Bombay records
Dr Homi Eduljee was associated with the K. R.
Bomanjee and his family drop out of Cama Oriental Institute both as a joint honorary
our story after they finally settled in
secretary and as a trustee for a number of years.
A chemical engineer by profession he is also well
read on Indo-Iranian topics and the Zoroastrian
MATRIMONIAL
Parents of a beautiful, fair, cultured, MBA, self-employed
daughter, 30 years with a pleasant and friendly nature,
who loves to travel and meet people, invite correspondence
from like-minded, educated, smart, well-placed Zoroastrian
bachelors settled in India or abroad. Please write with
recent photograph (returnable) to:
The Advertiser
Parsiana, Matrimonial (Dec/43-95)*, GPO Box 892, Bombay 400001
’Please make sure the reply envelope bears the reference number cited here.
49 Parsiana December 1995
4^
*
IMILESTONES
I
The age of Zoroastrian brides (as
listed in this issue) ranged between
16 and 34 years, the arithmetic
mean (the total number of indi
vidual ages divided by the total
number of brides) being 25 years.
The corresponding figures for the
grooms were 24 and 42 years, ave
raging at 29 years.
Twenty-eight Zoroastrian
births were registered at four
hospitals in Bombay in December
compared to 66 deaths. Twenty-
three of the deaths were attributed
to diseases related to the heart, 11
of them being above the age of 80.
While pneumonia and lung related
diseases claimed the lives of 13
victims, eight succumbed to old
age and general debility. Cancer
was the cause of four deaths and
tuberculosis, hypertension, brain
diseases, kidney failure and bron
chitis of two deaths each. Intestinal
obstruction, hypertension, athero
sclerosis (deposition of fatty sub
stances in the arteries), liver
disease, septicemia, diabetes and
malaria were the isolated cases
registered last month. A stillborn
baby girl was lost to the commu
nity. The oldest to die was a 99- .
vear-old man as compared to the would appreciate this requirement
youngest: a 43-year-old lady, lhe
BARODA
MARRIED
Hutoxi Amrolia of Bombay,
daughter of Mani and Dinshaw
and Jarsis Bonesetter, son of
Villoo and Pharokhsha on
December 3, 1995
Monaz Bonesetter, daughter of
Villoo and Pharokhsha and Adil
Randeria of Surat, son of Nergis
and Parvez; December 3
BOMBAY
BORN
A boy, Jehan, to Zenobia and
Kersi Engineer, September 7
A girl, Afreed, to Shirin and
Behziod Mehta; September 13
A girl, Zenia, to Nilofer and
Jamasp Irani; December 1
A boy, Demavand, to Armin
and Nosherwan Sethna, brother
to Farhan; December 1
A girl to Silloo and Aspi
Dubash; December 2
A girl to Benaifer and Noshir
Surveyor; December 2
and Bomi Fitter, brother to
Jenaisha; December 19
A boy to Auzita and Naresh
Asrani; December 20
A girl to Farida and Nirmal
Kejriwal; December 20
A girl to Kamal and Yezdi
Mistry; December 20
A girl to Sanober and Yazdi
Dastur, December 21
A girl to Havovi and Behram
Kermani; December 21
A boy to Roxana and Massion
figures for Bombay are supplied Pascal; December 23
by four hospitals; births in subur
ban hospitals and private nursing
homes are not included unless
individuals send us information
together with a copy of the birth
certificate. There may be an in
advertent repetition of names in
the marriage list when a civil mar
riage precedes a religious cere
mony. In the breakup of deaths
according to illnesses, especially
of the elderly, death is often due to
a combination of several diseases.
If readers have any births/
marriages/deaths they would like
published, some proof to ensure
the veracity of the report would be
required. We are sure our readers
Zoroastrian life expectancy at
birth, in Bombay in December,
was 76 years.
The data on births, marriages
and deaths has been compiled from
information supplied by various
newsletters and anjumans in India
and abroad, courts and hospitals.
We are unable to carry data from
areas where the anjumans do not
furnish the particulars. This infor
mation is not always complete or
consistent. For example, the birth
and cooperate with us.
A boy, Darran, to Roshni
and Hoshang Contractor,
December 5
A boy to Avan and Homyar
Kasad; December 5
A boy to Keshmira and
Sharookh Colabawalla;
December 6
Twins (girls) to Persis and
Dick Jasoomoney, December 9
A boy to Benaifer and Aspi
Bilia; December 12
A boy to Kashmira and Sarosh
Engineer, December 13
A girl to Niloofer and Rayomand Roxana Homi Ghandhy and
Karkaria; December 14
A boy to Kamal and Bomy
Damania; December 15
A girl to Delna and Jimmy
Mistry; December 15
A girl to Gulshan and Abad
Wadia; December 15
A girl to Pearl and Farokh
Keravala; December 17
A girl to Khursheed and Jimmy
Patel; December 17
A boy, Yavisht, to Daisy
A boy to Shemavaz and
Cherezad Bharucha;
December 24
A girl to Rushna and Khushroo
Forbes; December 25
A boy to Betty and Murzban
Narsang; December 27
A boy to Khurshid and Khurshed
Bharucha; December 29
MARRIED
Rukhsana Phiroze Chowna of
Ahmedabad and Zubin Dosabhai
Sahukar, December 1
Daisy Navroz ^adia and Adil
Rusi Jesia; December 2
Rukshana Namdar Irani and
Kaikhosro Rustom Behjit of
Ontario, Canada; December 3
Beniefer Daraius Patel and Nevil
Dady Kavarana; December 3
Zenia Dhunjeeshaw Pajniger of
Poona and Sarosh Homi Mody;
December 3
Gulshan Aspi Bhathena and
Khurshid Keki Pithawala;
December 4
Binaifer Baji Bharucha
and Karl Kersi Sahukar;
December 4
Mahtab Ratan Bharucha
and Darayus Hoshang
Chhapkhanawala; December 7
Persis Rusi Bharucha and
Sharukh Khudamurad Kohinoor,
December 7
Viraf Homi Mody; December 7
Dilnavaz Phiroz Patel and Vispi
Jimmy Pardiwalla; December 8
Havovi Jal Chothia and
Khushroo Aspi Pastakia;
December 8
Persis Navroz Dalal and
Sam Dhanjishaw Cooper;
December 9
Hufrish Tehmasp Munshi
and Jal Dinshaw Mehta;
December 9
Veera Khushru Delkha and
Meherwan Dinshaw Pollard;
December 9
Tanaz Farrokh Tata of Vasai
and Rohinton Kariman Patel;
December 10
Khushnum Phiroze Damania
and Riyaz Homi Buhariwala;
December 11
Shiraz Burjorji Elavia and
Minoo Nariman Tarapore;
December 12
Khursheed Sohrab Gimi and
Rayomand Bahadur Ichhaporia;
December 14
Dilshad Rustom Irani and
Kuresh Rustom Manoocheri;
December 14
Anahita Manchi Bomanbehram
and Cherag Minocher
Daruwalla; December 15
Natasha Dinshaw Nanavati
and Rishad Sammy Lalla;
December 15
Pearl Jehangir Irani and
Khusj^ru Rustom Chothia;
December 16
Jasmine Pesi Goiporia'and
Hormaz Cawsi D<^walla;
December 16
Kashmira Nariman Kasad
and Dinshaw Adi Dastoor,
December 17
Firoza Beji Bajan of Katni,
Madhya Pradesh and Zarir Vispi
Dalal; December 18
Rukhsheda Darayus Pagdiwalla
and Vispi Jamshed Irani;
December 18
Tozirjz Pesi Bhathena and
Khushroo Hoshi Mody;
December 19
Farida Eruch Bhote and Adil
Gustadji Nasirabadwala;
Decembejr 24
Tenaz Pesi Turner and Farhad
Soli Sahiar; December 24
Binaifer Kersi Dubash and Aspi
Rumi Daruwala; December 25
I
t
f
1
(
I*
f
DIED
Jehangir Jijibhai Khambata
(i2), residing at 36, Hampton
Court, 154, Lower Colaba Rd,
400005; December 1
Jal Aderji Patrawala (85), Q/6,
Cusrow Bang, S. B. Rd, 4(XX)39;
December 1
Meher Jimmy Presswalla 1^2},
Presswalla Property, 190,
Lamington Rd, 400(X)7;
December 1
Perin Kaikhushroo Bhaya (43),
50 Parsiana December 1995I
j
!
i
I
Shriji Hse, 75, Mint Rd, Fort,
400001; December 2
Parinbanu Sham Irani (72),
Post Gholwad, Tai Dahanu,
Dist Thana, 401702;
December 2
Minoo Sorabji Bilimoria (84),
583/2, Girgaum Rd, 400002;
December 3
Jimmy Khurshed Irani (68),
B/62, Rajkamal, Parel, 400012;
December 3
Bhickaiji Sorabji Khambatta
(90), F. S. Parukh Dharamshalla,
Hughes Rd, 400007; December 3
Dhunmai Pestonji Parakh (88),
5/4, India Hse, Kemps Comer,
400036; December 3
Minoo Jehangir Bilimoria (78),
Readymoney Bldg No 1, Ratan
Tata Rd, Tardeo, 400034;
December 4
Jehangir Bomanji Bilimoria
(84), 202, Udharam Hse,
Santosh Ngr, Hill Rd, Bandra
(W), 400050; December 5
Ratty Phirozeshaw Chinoy (78),
5/36, A. H. Wadia Baug, Parel
Tank Rd, 400033; December 5
Kersasp Hirjibhai Soonawalla
(74), 13/15, Soonawalla Apts,
Arab St, Comer of Grant Rd,
40(X)08; December 6
Meherbai Rustomji Tata (86),
Shraddha, Om Ngr, G. F. Dhuri
Complex, Ambadi Rd, Vasai
(W), 401201; December 6
Shavaksha Nariman Ilavia (72),
C/o Ms Khorshed B. Bhamcha,
18, Contractor Chawl, Sussex
Rd, Byculla, 400027;
December 7
Cover Jamshed Irani (69), 16/3,
Tata Mills Co-op Hsg Soc,
Elphinstone Rd, Parel, 4(X)012;
December 7
Jasmine Kersi Mistry (72),
11/10, Tata Clny, Tardeo,
400034; December 7
Sorabji Behramji Pastakia (91),
658, Firdoshi Rd, Parsi Clny,
Dadar, 400014; December 7
Minoo Nariman Ruwala (61),
12, Star Bldg, Uranwala St,
Off Alibhai Premji Rd, Grant
Rd, 400007; December 7
Faredoonji Kavasji Avari (69),
302, Madhuvan, Shrikrishna
Complex, Vartak Rd, Virar (W),
401303; December 9
Dinabai Phirozsha
Bhiwandiwala (94), 80 Quarters
gate, Bhiwandi, Dist Thane;
December 9
Aloo (Avaz) Phiroze Dastur (76),
Empress Court, 142, Maharshi
Karve Rd, 400020; December 9
Nargish Dorab Doctor (68), J/7,
S. Bhamcha Baug, S. V. Rd,
Andheri (W), 400058;
December 9
Roda Bomanshaw Mughaseth
(83), Cama Bldg, Kashinath Rd,
Tardeo, 400034; December 9
Russi Faramroze Taraporewalla
(71), 2, Sir Dorab Tata Bldg No
1, S. V. Rd, Bandra, 400050;
December 10
Perin Nowrojee Hormusjee (84),
6, Band-View, 665, Parsi Clny,
Dadar, 400014; December 12
Freny Homi Kabir (88), Kabir
Hse, Khambatta Lane, Byculla
(E), 400027; December 13
Jehangir Darabsha Masala-
walla (85), Bhiwandi Hse, 92,
Cumballa Hill, 400036;
December 13
Baby girl of Shirin Cyms
Parestani (stillborn), B/7,
Contractor Baug, Mori Rd,
Mahim, 400016; December 13
Goolbano Jamshed Sahyar (95),
31, Foijett St, 400036;
December 13
Rustomjee Limjibhai Sopariwala
(91), 502, Happy Hse, Hastikar
St, Prabhadevi, 4(X)025;
December 13
Homai Rusi Dadachanji (60),
B/1, Motta Mans, Bai Motibai
St, Opp Bhatia Hosp, Tardeo,
400007; December 14
Zarine (Aloo) Navroze Vatcha
(89), F/2, Cusrow Baug, S. B.
Rd, 400039; December 14
Keki Pestonji Cassad (77), 196,
Lotus Court, Jamshedjee Tata
Rd, Churchgate, 400020;
December 16
Sherry (Scheherazade) Dinyar
Patel (47), A/3, Satyabhama
Nivas, Kashinath St, Tardeo Rd,
400034; December 16
Nozer Fardoonji Dastoor (99),
Mohamed Bldg, 56, Wodehouse
Rd, Colaba, 400005;
December 17
Tehmina Eruchshaw Karanjia
(85), Muncheiji Seth Bldg, 2
62, Tardep Rd, 400007;
December 17
Jalejar Edulji Mohta (83), 6/A,
26/B, Beristan Bldg, Opp Rly
Stn, Vikhroli (W), 400083;
December 17
Hillamai Munchershaw
Bhathena (81), Dhenu Bldg,
Dr Ambedkar Rd, Parel, 400012;
Decem&er 20
Piroja Eruchshaw Mistry (91),
9, Widow ’s Chawl,Modi St,
*
With Best Compliments From
LEACH
WEBORNY
When in Bombay Contact
ir
For attending to your laundry.
They are Launderers & Dyers of repute.
They will also attend to your carpets
for cleaning or dyeing.
)
66, Off E. Moses Road, Worli, Bombay 400018
Phone: Head Office 2654294 Factory: 4924384,4925644
51 Parsiana December 1995
ITOTALS FOR 1995
BORN
Boys
Girls
A
13
16
Bombay
B A
India
B A
World
B
JALGAON
BORN
A girl, Dinaj, to Femaj and
Rustom Adajania', May 28
A boy, Viraf, to Roshon and
Firoj Darbari; September 16
111
107
3
2
9
5
3
2
30
22
MARRIED
Parsi
Intercommunal
31 256
61A
5 10
1
13
10
NAGPUR
BORN
A boy to Zubina and Percy
Sidhwa', December 14
DIED
CONSIGNED
Male
Female
CREMATED
Male
Female
32
34
472
464
5
9
87
90
3
3
28*
34*
A: Total numbers in this issue
3
1
B: Running totals for 1995 (February-March 1995-December 1995 issues)
Males married out - 27
Females married out - 34
* Overseas deaths are listed in the consigned column as Parsiana does not have a breakup of those cremated.
These figures pertain to information provided to or collected by Parsiana. They do not represent the total
number of births, marriages and deaths in the Zoroastrian community in India and abroad.
POONA
DIED
Minoo Nadershah Daruwalla
(57), 1152, Saifee St, 411001;
December 7
Jamshed Kayas (75), 9, Mody
Clny, Synagogue St, 411001;
December 23
Feradun Bakhtiyar Irani (62),
Bakhtiyar Garden, Shahabad,
Dist Gulbarga, 585101;
December 26
Ardeshir Framroze Pardiwalla
(82), 17, Abdul Coure
Suryavanshi Marg, Bombay,
40()028, December 31
Fort, 400001; December 20
Nargis Minocher Daruwala (68),
275/J, New Cama Bldg, Tardeo
Rd, 400007; December 21
Burjor Cawasji Kalyaniwala
(84), B, Rustam Palace, Tardeo,
4(X)007; December 11.
Gayomard Cavasji Mehta (82),
F. S. Parukh Dharamshalla,
Hughes Rd, 400007;
December 22
Tehmi Behramji Mistry (72),
275/D, Soona Bldg, Chikalwadi,
Tardeo, 400007; December 22
Shirin Framroze Rabadi (82),
401, Royal Gate Co-op Hsg Soc,
Yari Rd, Versova, Andheri (W),
400061; December 22
Murzban Jamshedji Mistry (65),
784/B, Readymoney Bldg,
Parsi Clny, Dadar, 400014;
December 23
Macca Naoroji Bhagat (78),
Kaka Block, Marazban Clny,
Gilder Lane, 400008;
December 25
Behram Sohrabji Dubhash (93),
5, Nariyalwala Bldg, M. M. C.
Rd, M^im, 400016;
December 25
Eruch Rustomji Bhathena (84),
693, Parsi Clny, Dadar, 400014;
December 26
Dhunmai Hormusji Hansotia
(77), 7, Lam Bldg, Delisle Rd,
Lower Parel, 400013;
December 28
Khodabux Behram Hormazdi
(83), Behram-Abad, Rd No 4,
T.P.S. IV, Opp Bhabha Hosp,
Bandra (W), 400050;
December 28
Mani Minoo Katrak (58), Forjett
Hse, Foijett St, Gowalia Tank,
400036; December 28
Najoo Hormuzshah Chibber
(75), Boman Hse, Homji St,
400001; December 29
Mehemosh Nariman Kajanwalla
(74), Pundole Bldg, Opp
Mithaiwalla Fire-temple, Sleater
Rd, 400007; December 29
Eddie Hirji Nagarwalla (83),
645, Khareghat Rd, Parsi Clny,
Dadar, 400014; December 29
Dali Nusserwanji Sethna (64),
15, Ardeshir Dady Cross
Lane, Khetwadi, 400004;
December 29
Katy Dinshaw Talaty (72),
307, Keravala Bldg, Nana
Chowk, Tardeo Rd, 400007;
December 29
Kersi Kaiki Tata (53), Ashoka
Apts, Off Arthur Bunder
Rd, Colaba, 400005;
December 29
Naval Sorabjee Achadwala (80),
B/16, Godrej Baug, Nepean Sea
Rd, 400036; December 30
Edi Savaksha Contractor (80),
71, Dinath Court, Sir
Pochkhanawala Rd, Worli,
400018; December 30
Perin Pirojshaw Karbhari (76),
C/o Nargish F. Dumasia, Taher
Manzil, Mahella Patel Agiary
Lane, Grant Rd, 400007;
December 30
Cyrus Shapur Mody (55), 8, St
Anthony Rd, Bandra (W),
4(X)050; December 30
Ra tans ha EduIji Daruwalla (88),
F, Adam Mhl, Wadia St, Tardeo,
400034; December 31
Piloo Keki Satta (83), Kala
Niketan Bldg, Queens Rd,
400020; December 31
Behramshaw Bomanji Sethna
(IS), Hirji Sethna Bldg,
Zoroastrian Clny, Tardeo Rd,
400007; December 31
CALCUTTA
BORN
A girl, Tara, to Nilufer and
Sanjay Prakash', December 14
MARRIED
Kay Jehangir Master of
Bombay and Khushrav
Hiramanek', December 23
Rashna Godrej Dandiwala of
Bombay and Phiroz Savak Sadrr,
December 28
DIED
Khorshed Nariman, wife of
Dorab and mother of Burjor,
Perin, Lily and Homai;
December 30
SECUNDERABAD
MARRIED
Diana Feroz Mistri and ^ezdi
Phiroze Bhagwagar of Bombay;
December 14
SURAT
BORN
A boy, Zarath, to Prochie and
Sairas Bhesania', October 29
*
DIED
Dolatbanu Tehmursap Dastur
(78), Dasturbag, Nanpura,
395001; December 6
Jamshedji Rustomji Dustur (84),
Adajan, Dist Surat; December 6
Mani Gustadji Vesuna (85),
Por St, Nanpura, 395(X)1;
December J 2
Coomibai Pirojshaw Engineer
(85), Darani Chmbs, Sayedwada;
December 13
Gulbanu Jahangirji Vaghchhi-
pwala (87), Nariman Home and
Infirmary, Shahpore, 395003;
December 15
Ziniben Bamansha Dapotawala
(65), Ranitalao, 395003;
December 16
Banubai Pirojshah Vajifdar (79),
Lalgate, 395003; December 22
Khorshed Dhanjisha Katpitia
(67), Bhavnagri St, 395003;
December 25
Pirojbai Eruchshaw Gandhi
(91), Dehala St, Rustampura,
395002; December 26
Compiled by Roxana A. Driver
52 Parsiana December 1995
I
◆ ◆ ◆
From the archive
