Complete Issue
Apr 1995
I
y
'll
,«
t-
s
>
**>.
^rP”
*
rxi
•<* .
p-'i
*¦
r’::.
Ks
<
'K
V'
I- ¦ - - fL
"¦*1
IApril 1995
Volume 17 Number 8
EDITOR Jehangir R. Patel
MANAGING EDITOR Amavaz S. Mama
EXECUTIVE EDITOR Parinaz M. Gandhi
SENIOR EDITOR Dina K. Mehta
ASSOCIATE EDITOR Roxana A. Driver
DESIGN Kranti M. Shilotrk,
Varghese W. Fernandez, Jayshree R. Ghosh
MARKETING DIRECTOR Veera Patel
ADVERTISING MANAGER Zarin Mistry
ADVERTISING EXECUTIVES
Niloufer Panthaky Susan Joseph
FINANCE B. L. Arora
EDP Rohinton E. Daroga
ADMINISTRATION R. S. Pingle
MANAGEMENT Jasmine Driver
DTP Bakhtavar R. Batllwalla, K. P. Ravi
SUBSCRIPTION/CIRCULATION
Khurshid Panthaki, Bindu Pillai
ACCOUNTS Anagha Korde
OFFICE Smitha Nair, Swampa Kamat
OFFICE ASSISTANTS Umesh Poojary,
Selvan Mark, Sunil Sakhare, Pramod Patil,
Govind Salgaonkar, Mahipat Jadhav
2 Readers’ Forum
10 Events and Personalities
18 Zoroastrians Abroad: South Africa’s Dr Khorshed Ginwalla
23 Jamsheed Kanga steps down by Arnavaz Mama
— ____ _
24 Aesthetician Dinyar Workingboxwalla by Gustasp Irani
33 The Federation reviews the Wadia navjote
41 Books
?
43 Milestones
Cover: Dinyar Workingboxwaila’s creative artistry
Parsiana is published by Jehangir R. Patel
for Parsiana Publications Pvt Ltd at C/o H. L.
Rochat, Navsari Chambers, ground floor,
39 A. K. Nayak Marg, Fort, Bombay 400001
and printed by him at Kaiser-E-Hind Pvt Ltd,
300 Perin Nariman Street, Bombay 400001.
Color processing. Comart Lithographers;
black and white processing Samir Scantech.
All rights reserved. ISSN: 0971-3786.
Phone: 2048730 Fax: 2042922. For editorial
enquiries 2048183. Tlx; 11-85710 RABO IN.
For subscription enquiries and payments;
C/o Kaiser-E-Hind Pvt Ltd, 300 Perin Nariman St
(Behind Resenze Bank of India), Bombay 400001;
Phone: 2658619, 2665661.
Annual inland subscription for one year
(10 issues) Rs 150; for two years (20 issues)
Rs 275. Foreign subscription rates: Seamail for
one year Rs 375/US $ 14/UK E 9; for two
years Rs 600/US $ 22/UK £ 15 (please allow
six months or more for delivdiy from the time
of publication). Airmail for one year
Rs 625/ US $ 23/UK E 15 (for Pakistan,
Indian Rs 350); for two years, Rs 1,150/US $ 40/
UK £ 27 (for Pakistan, Indian Rs 6M).
For Indian upcountry cheques add Rs 10 for
bank charges; for US cheques add $ 5;
for UK cheques add E 3. Cheques and drafts
are to be drawn in favor of Parsiana and posted
to GPO Box 892, Bombay 400001.READERS' FORUM
it'1 rj
s:*'
¦ ¦
I
IF
Readers' views are welcome on any subject
of interest to the community and should
be sent to the Editor, Readers' Forum,
Parsiana, Q.P.O. Box 892, Bombay 400001.
Letters are subject to editing for reasons of
space and clarity. Unsigned letters or those
without an address will not be published.
The Boys’ Town offer
The trustees of the P. N. Mehta Education
Trust that runs the Boys ’ Town Public
School at Nasik have decided to admit five
Parsi boys at Rs 5,0(X) per annum, per boy.
While uniforms and the basic essential
items will also be supplied by the School,
it will not be responsible for any items
purchased by the parents arbitrarily.
The trustees have further decided to
admit five Parsi students completely free.
They may be recommended on merit by a
social worker of standing or by a charitable
trust or organization. We are desirous of
admitting students from rural Gujarat and
such other parts of our country from the
start i.e. at the age of four or five years, so
that the English medium will not be an
obstacle. Such students ’ applications must
be forwarded to us by the chairman of the
local anjuman, punchayet or similar body.
We will be very happy to admit the
above two categories of children in our
School from June 1995 onwards.
The trustees of the P. N. Mehta Educa
tion Trust will be pleased to receive com
munication in this respect at Cook ’s Build
ing, 3rd Floor, 324 Dr D. N. Road, Fort,
Bombay 400001. bejonn.desai
Secy, Boys’ Town Public School, Nztsik
“Portrait of an artist”
I have read with interest your cover story
— “Portrait of an artist (Parsiana, January
1995).” I must admit that I did not know
that our community had produced an out
standing artist, Pestonji Bomanjee, who
was called the Indian Rembrandt.
The cover painting Naughty Girl show
ing a teenaged girl traditionally clothed
and wearing a sapaat, is a picture of pure
innocence, whilst another painting Pray
ing for the sick would tend to suggest
efficacy of prayers. It is a tragedy that
Pestonji Bomanjee ’s 13 years ’ labor of
love — the Ajanta project — ended in
disaster.
'^'iWParsiana satisfy the curiosity of its
readers by printing Bomanjee ’s three other
memorable paintings, Parsi Priest at
Prayer, Feeding the Parrot and especially
that of his wife Jiloobai, portrayed in the
Leisure Hour?
Whilst on the subject, will any of your
readers enlighten me whether Mancherji
Pithavala, one of Bomanjee ’s contempo
rary artists, was the father of Sorab whose
paintings of our Holy Spitman Zarathusthra
adorn the walls of our atash behrams/
agiaries? Will Ms Aloo Polson and Ms
Gool Vachha throw light?
BHIKHAJI M. ADENWALLA
The Editor replies
If Parsiana is able to obtain transparencies
or color prints of the concerned paintings,
we shall consider publishing them.
“Tell us about Pithavala”
Mr Bhikhaji M. Adenwalla has enquired in
the Readers ’ Forum (Parsiana, October
1994) about the artist Sorab M. Pithavala.
I have the following information to offer
based upon books on Parsi history at the
Shields Library, Universtiy of California,
Davis.
Mr Sorab Manchershaw Pithavala was
the second son of the famous Parsi artist
and portrait painter Mr Manchershaw
Fakirjee Pithavala (1872-1937). Mancher
shaw visited England in June 1911 and had
the distinction of holding a one-man show,
the first in England by an Indian artist, at
the Dore Gallery, London, when Sir M. M.
Bhownaggree, one of the then three Parsi
and Indian members of the British House
of Commons, hosted a reception in his
honor and introduced him to society.
Among his various portraits were those of
Khurshedji Rustomji Camaand Sir Jamsetji
Jejeebhoy, first baronet. The photograph,
and four pages of information on the life of
this illustrious Zoroastrian is given inParsi
Lustre on Indian Soil by Hormusji
Dhunjishaw Darukhanawala, Vol 1. (G.
Claridge and Company, Bombay, 1939,
pages 190-193).
Mr Sorab M. Pithavala studied portrait
painting for 10 years under his distin
guished father. In addition to portraits of
Zarathushtra (modelled on the Sasanian
sculpture of our Prophet at Takh-i-Bostan
in Iran), Sorab M. Pithavala also painted
the portrait of Sir Sorabji Pochkhanavala,
the founder of the Central Bank of India.
When this portrait was unveiled at the head
office of the Bank at Flon^ Fountain,
Pithavala was accorded high praise from
the public and the Press. Together with a
photograph of the young Sorab, Daru
khanawala notes in his above-mentioned
book that “It is highly gratifying to find the
son keeping green the name and fame of
his revered father as a great artist. ”
ARDESHK B. DAMANIA
Davis, USA
*‘^Ahd~nameh authentic?”
I was astounded to read Dr Ali Akbar
Jafarey ’s acknowledgement of Omar
Khayyam ’s greatness (Readers ’ Forum,
Parsiana, January 1995).
Dr Jafarey has not directly refuted my
assertion that it is he himself who has
branded Omar Khayyam, a celebrated Sufi,
a “drunkard lecher. ” To refresh his
memory, this derogatory statement about
Omar Khayyam, in paiticular, and Sufis,
in general, was made to me personally at a
dinner in Toronto, at the time of the Youth
Congress of 1989.
During dinner, Dr Jafarey and I became
engrossed in a discussion pertaining to the
Sufis, Khshnoom and mysticism. Dr Jafarey
acknowledged to me that he does not be
lieve in mysticism and things “not seen ” or
physically existing, and that he believes in
only the verbatim translations and inter
pretations.
2 Parsiana April 1995
*The reference to Khshnoom was made
by me while discussing the esoteric inter
pretation of “sons, ” as referred to in the
Bahram Yasht. He advised me not to be
lieve in mysticism and to stay away from
consumed was the wine editor ever bothering to tender an apology
o him, these interpretations have no scrip- which intoxicated them physically, that Just two glaring and pertinent examoles
th Td insisting that Omar should be more than enough to amplify^the
msisted on the validity of esoteric mean- Khayyam was a “drunkard ” who led a point. Parsiana in its Readers ’ Forum of
mgs (“razeng, ” i.e. parables) which “lecherous life. ” Januarv 1992’ cI^ried^XoTeLr^^Wnh
Khshnoom ™Parts, by drawing on the Parsiana'3 editor may tender his bi- exnosed Dr Jafare.v nn twn rn,.ntc and t,,
parallel of the Sufis and the wine ” they zarre apology to Dr Jafarey, but I am
drink to become “intoxicated. ” As this was < 2.
my very first introduction to Dr Jafarey, I pushed to acknowledge Omar Khayyam ’s
thoughtmyanajogyofillustratingthemystic spiritual greatness. Now, let
in spiritual ecstasy might convince him to
accept the mysticism which Khshnoom
imparts.
I specifically pointed out that the “wine ”
the Sufis thirstily partake is the mystic
“ ¦ ’’ .............. . I _____ __________ _________
’’and divine love. I compared Jafarey ’s letter, "’Ahd-nameh authentic? ”
I was absolutely astounded at the editor ’s
unsolicited and totally unwarranted apo-
Forum , Parsiana, January 1995). A clear the Gathic “freedom of moral choice, ” into
with Dr Jafarey will not find it hard to
accept his contempt for mysticism in gen
eral, and Sufis as well as Khshnoom, in
particular. During our personal conversa- ________ ____ _ ... . c..oh*,m4 ?
tion, he distinctly emphasized that the Readers ’ Forum in'the pit^ without The
wine the Sufis consumed was the wine
which intoxicated them physically, that
cation, ” especially in letters sent in by
readers expressing their views. Any num
ber of patently ridiculous or fallacious
statements have appeared in Parsiana'3
Parsiana'3 editor may tender his bi
zarre apology to Dr Jafarey, but I ______o- - _____ &-•- / ..wxvjyij
amply demonstrated that
,, i Dr Jafarey, while quoting Prof James
us hear Dr Darmesteter ’s translation of the Vishtasp
exposed Dr Jafarey on two counts and to
which he gave (could give?) no reply:
Dr Jafarey, while quoting Prof James
acknowledge the Sufis ’ wine as the Nask (Sacred Books of the East, vol 23 pg
SDiritual ecstasv m.aht rnnv.n.,. h.rr, tz. “mystic wine of the spirit, ” then jaam as 336) to denigrate the use of sacred gome^z!
“divine wisdom ” and their “love ” as “spiri - had actually suppressed a crucial footnote
tual ecstasy! ” mspervinj.mistry given by Darmesteter (fn.no. 5, on the very
same page !) which completely contradicted
and nullified Dr Jafarey ’s mischievous
(mis)interpretation;
b) In the second, it was amply demon
strated that in his clumsy (mis)interpretation
of Dr Irach Taraporewala ’s translation of
Yasna 30.2, Dr Jafarey ’s attempt to twist
, __ >
a non-existent “freedom of religious
choice, ” in order to ventilate his conver
sion mania, was equally misdhievous. In
both these instances of blatant intellectual
and scholarly deception by Dr Jafarey, did
‘divine wisdom” and their “love” as “spiri-
, ’ MsPERVINJ. MISTRY
Ontario, Canada
“wine ” of the spirit which tead.s to spiritual
J 4 ZX « z*x aiX ’ zx MX zj zj 1 X . t zz. — _? 1
the Sufis ’ jaam (i.e. container) to the con
tainer of divine spiritual wisdom, their _______________________
“love of the beloved ” to the divine love (of logy appended below'the letter**(Read^ ’
God) and their “intoxication ” to spiritual ~
ecstasy. In short, I was extolling the splen-
the mysticism of the Sufism of Omar
Khayyam.
Anyone who is even faintly acquainted
While I was amused to read Dr Ali A.
case of bending over backwards to assuage
Parsiana is no exception to the fact of
journalistic experience that many “state
ments slip into print without proper verifi-
did mysticism of Khshnoom by illustrating the feelings of a favorite “blue-eyed boy. ”
4'
¦%
For Pure Diamonds
JEWELLERS
400007. Telephone 3099648 Fax
APPOINTED VALUERS BY THE GOVERNMENT oAnDIA
L
»h
the editor of Parsiana rush to tender his
apologies to the Parsi/Iranian Zoroastrian
community?
Parsiana's insidious editorial bias to
wards heterodoxy in general, and Dr Ali
This refers to "’Mid-nameh authentic? ”
and Dr Ali. A Jafarey ’s comments on the
Yes, it does behove Ms Mistry to make
known wnen and where Dr Jafarey has
called Omar Khayyam “a drunkard ” who poetry of Omar Khayyam (Parsiana, Janu
ary 1995).
Omar Khayyam died in A.D. 1123.
____ ____________ Fitzgerald ’s Rubaiyat was published in
direct allegation by decisively denying 1859. Only 250 copies were printed by
that this “cheap slander ” lies at his door. A Qharitch, the publishers. Not a single copy
was sold for 10 years.
In 1869 two friends of the poet and
painter Dante Gab'iel Rossetti found a
copy in an obscure bookshop near Leices-
“led a lecherous life. ” But, at the same
____________ time, it should be noted that in his letter. Dr
Jafarey in particular is, by now, well known. Jafarey has not directly refuted Ms Mistry ’ s
To illustrate: a full one-third of Parsiana’s " ” ’ ’ ’" ¦*
cover story (“The bitter-sweet lure of choco
late, ” December 1994) deals with conten
tious issues like intermarriage and the HVe.
Pray, what has intermarriage to do witi
wholesome, innocent and non-controversial
subject of chocolates? Which business is ----- , . .
Parsiana in — journalism or propaganda? Dr Ali A. Jafarey regarding the description Rubaiyat of Omar Khayyam
To come to Dr Jafarey ’s bone of conten- U - -- ’--'' ' . ¦ ' - * *-*- t.
tion — Ms Mistry, in the Parsiana of mathematician Omar Khayyam as a mously published andjjnced five shil-
October 1994, states, “In promoting the ‘ ...................... ’ ’
Fasli calendar, he (i.e. Dr Jafarey) relies on 1995).
Omar Khayyam. But in Dr Jafarey ’s own
words Omar Khayyam, a Sufi, was a drunk
ard and led a lecherous life! How can one
trust a drunkard to compute? And, was expansion ofthe binary polynomial, (x-i-a)'
Omar intoxicated with alcohol or love for
his beloved Creator? ”
Clearly, it is not Ms Mistry who is
throwing stones at the sagacious philoso
pher and poet, Omar Khayyam, but claims ------------
it is Dr Jafarey who ascribes these vices to his poetry The Rubaiyat of Omar Khayyam dards a Persian scholar and though he
Khayyam. Ms Mistry, in fact, questions Dr which was translated by Edward Fitzgerald, produced a profoundly beautiful work in
Jafarey whether “Omar (was) intoxicated *' ’ ' * - n t- .— ............
with alcohol or love for his beloved Cre
ator? ”
»e
direct allegation of this kind demands a
direct refutation (if there is any), instead of
an oblique answer, noshir h. dadrawala
I fully endorse the sentiments expressed by ter Square, a small volume entitled The
.......................... ~ ' ''
by Ms Pervin Mistiy, of the greatest Arab tronomer poet of Persia. It was anony-
“drunkard lecher ” (Parsiana, January lings, these friends ofRossetti bought two
copies for a penny, almost the price of
scrap paper, and when Rossetti was shown
this he was excited beyond measure. He in
turn gave it to the poet Algernon Charles
Swinburne who read it to his friends at an
evening gathering and so it was that Lon
don was set aflame by this new find. Copies
Omar Khayyam who lived in the 12th
century had contributed immensely in the
field of algebra. His masterpiece was the
.... . ...
which goes by the name of the Binomial
Theorem. His other notable contributions
were summation of series of squares and of within a week were being sold for a guinea,
cubes; and solution of cubic equations. There is no doubt in my mind that
Omar Khayyam is also remembered for Edward Fitzgerald was not by any stan-
his poetry The Rubaiyat of Omar Khayyam dards
More than the Editor ’s apology is an
expression of regret required from Ms
Pervin Mistry. Dr p. d. sunavala
the Rubaiyat it is far from what Khayyam
would have authenticatetkas a faithful
translation. So popular is the Rubaiyat,
%
With Best Compliments From
LEACH
WEBORNY
When in Bombay Contact
For attending to your laundry.
They are Launderers & Dyers of repute.
They will also attend to your carpets
for cleaning or dyeing.
66, Off E. Moses Road, Worli, Bombay 400018
Phone: Head Office 2654294 Factory: 4924384, 4925644
IInvestment
in property
Pune is the
best city
Flats:
We offer flats and
row-houses to your
requirement to suit your
budget at rates of Rs 600
to over Rs 4,000 per sq. ft.,
with or without amenities
like Club-house and
Swimming pool, etc.
Bungalows:
At prices ranging from
about Rs 50 lacs to over
one crore, depending
on size of the plot
and the location.
and its theme so persuasively compelling, same and not turn elsewhere for comfort at
that modern scholars believe that the author every misfortune. With due respect to other
was a hedonistic atheist and a lecher. Far
from the truth, Omar Khayyam was a
highly reputed philosopher and seeker It is up to us individuals to take greater
deeply immersed in Sufi thought and ide
ology. He had broken away from conven
tional Islamic dogma to a more liberal
understanding of the ‘Truth. ’ His reference
to ‘wine, ’ the ‘tavern, ’ and ‘love, ’ were
symbolic and there was nothing profane or
erotic in his poetry.
Fitzgeralds ’s translation was based on a
1 Sth century manuscript of dubious origin.
The recent work of Robert Graves is
founded on an authenticated 12th century religion as is possible and try and under
text which was translated by Omar-Ali-
Shah, a renowned Persian scholar. It was
then put to verse by Graves.
Graves ’ work, though not half as beau
tiful as Fitzgerald ’s, discloses that the po
ems express deep and constant religious Lady ” (Readers ’ Forum, Parsiana, De
faith. It is possible that Fitzgerald lacked cember 1994). I can ’t believe such things
sufficient knowledge of Persian or that the can happen in Bombay, the bastion of
symbolism of the Rubaiyat simply eluded Zoroastrianism in today ’s world.
him, or that perhaps he took poetic licence
to cater to the times.
faiths, I feel that one should adhere to the
faith in which one is born and brought up.
interest in our religion and what it stands
for. Only then would one feel its greatness.
I am not a religious zealot, but having
read about all the other faiths, have come
to the conclusion that all preach the same
doctrine. Then why go elsewhere? That is
a question each of us should ask himself/
herself.
I only hope the members of our commu
nity would read as many books on our
Stand the importance of being a Zoroas-
trian of which one should be truly proud.
HOMI H. JALNAWAI LA
I was surprised to read “Beseeching the
Dr H S. ADENWALLA
In our Pakistan there is the “«/tiGanga. ”
I know of two or th^ee Muslims working in
Trichur Parsi firms who keep a small phonograph
of Zoroaster in their wallet. Asked why,
they say that their Parsi bossed do that and
that is the reason why they are so prosperous
and happy. It is a pity that while Muslims
have faith in Zoroaster, the Parsis of
Commercial:
Offices and shops
as required.
“The bitter-sweet...”
I read your article on chocolates (“The
bitter-sweet lure of chocolate, ” Parsiana,
December 1994) with great interest, being
in the business myself. The brand name I Bombay have lost their faith. Maybe they
sell under is “Soft Centres. ”
The various types of chocolates I make
include flavored, soft centred and nut. I
may be contacted on telephone number
4127307. Ms DILNAVAAZ DARUVALLA
Bungalow Plots:
In different locations in
town and within a radius of
about 15 kms. A few plots
of 5,000 sq. ft. near the
Race course in an open,
green location, at the
most reasonable
rates available.
Write to:
Minoo Bhathena
BYSEL ESTATE
302 Devika Apt
2010 West Street
Pune 411001
Tel: 650757
8 Parsiana April 1995
are only a few exceptions.
A card captioned “Light of Zoroaster ”
which I had first published in 1980 was in
such great demand that I had to print it
again and again, to satisfy the public de
mand. It has now become a collector ’s
“Beseeching the Lady” item. A Parsi lady in UK keeps it on her
I read with interest letters written by Rustom bedside table so that when she goes to bed
C. ChothiaandMs Piloo Jungalwalla( “Be- and gets up in the morning she reads it, and
seeching the Lady, ” Parsiana, December acts upon it.
1994) regarding members of our commu
nity seeking solace and inspiration from
other religions.
This reflects to a great extent on our
clergy, many of whom are unaware of the
meaning of our prayers and unable to
impart the same to members of our com
munity. I would like my brethren to make “Women’s rights?”
it a point to read a book entitled Teachings
of the Magi by the German scholar, R. C.
Zaehner (publishers: Mcmillan and Com
pany). This little book gives in a small way
the meaning of our basic prayer, Yatha
Ahu Vairyo. It may be noted that the vibra
tions of the prayer when recited with real
intent would go a long way in overcoming
most of our problems.
I request my brethren to take heed of the
I know many ladies in Karachi who are
known to be keeping the card upright in
their cupboard so that it is seen instantly
when the cupboard is opened.
FAREDUN K DADACHANJI
Karachi, Pakistan
Dr P. D. Sunavala ’s selective acceptance
of Hindu and foreign surnames (Parsiana,
December 1994) into the Parsi commu
nity, e.g. Mehta, Gandhi, Rao, Forbes,
Marshall, etc, while rejecting others for
the reasons given, is patently absurd and
illogical.
Are we to assume from his arguments
that:
•If a Parsi girl marries a non-Parsi with ajI
name like Mehta or Gandhi, her children obtaining equal rights with their Parsi letter appears on the same page.
can be brought up as Zoroastrians, while if menfolk in this regard proves that they n.d. khurody
she marries someone with a surname that mean business — and more power to them!
As for Dr Sunavala ’s suggestion of “A Zoroastrian again”
Parsiana deserves to be commended for
our dwindling population, Ms Khorshed publishing the complete unabridged corre-
R. Ghandhi ’s remark that it is too absurd to spondence between Mr Neville Wadia and
be taken seriously says it all succinctly the seven learned dasturs from whom Mr
F. F. VAKIL Wadia had sought permission(!) for his
navjote (“A Zoroastrian again, ” Parsiana,
October 1995). It is not my intention to
dation for bigamy (Parsiana, May and comment on the opinions of the individual
dasturs. However, I feel that instead of
I, I
I
she marries someone with a surname that
does not conform to Dr Sunavala ’s idea of
an “adopted ” Hindu surname she may not bigamy (or polygamy!) as the answer to
do so? The same no doubt would hold for
Johnson and Thompson as opposed to
Forbes and Marshall!
•If a Parsi forefather had worked for a (Parsiana, December 1994).
Portuguese employer called Fernandez and
adopted the name as his own, would Dr Apropos Dr P. D. Sunavala ’s recommen-
Sunavala then have accepted Fernandez as
aParsi surname as he does British ones like December 1994) and Ms A. Mehta ’s re
Marshall and Forbes? Why then should not sponse (Parsiana, September 1994) I would indulging in separate correspondence with
Mr Wadia and conveying their individual
opinions on the issue, it would certainly
have had more significant impact and set a
precedent for future similar cases if the
seven learned dasturs (who all live in and
around Bombay) would have got together
in a conclave like a “Council of Elders ”
and then released a joint opinion with
reasons thereof on this important issue.
The two dasturs who had reservations could
have attached a minute of dissent giving
their own reasons.
Parsiana has seen many contentious
social and reli^ous issues relating to
Zoroastrians discussed in its columns
with very vehement opinions, scholarly
the same happen with recently introduced urge our high priests to make trigamy
surnames whichoverthe generations would mandatory on the conditions that
come to be accepted as “Parsi ” in the same
way as say, Rao and Shastri?
As for Dr Sunavala quoting from Dr •the younger wives agree to assist the older
Fredie Mehta ’s article (“We are getting in her chores,
wiped out, ” Parsiana, September 1994) if •the inheritance rights are equal for all.
it is true that Dr Mehta has indeed stated
that “Parsi women married to non-Parsis
are reluctant to bring up their children as
Zoroastrians ” one must enquire where Dr •male virility — currently suspect — will
Mehta has come up with such a categorical
conclusion? In fact, the reverse is true
except that every impediment is put in
their way by the prejudiced and the em and forward looking community. ”
This system would also reverse the
trend perceptively described by Aspi Patel and otherwise, expressed but finally without
continued on page 31
•the second and third wives are tribal,
•the man is above 40 years and fit,
Under such a system
•bickering over petty matters would cease,
•genetic rejuvenation will occur.
revive,
•the white skin complex will dissolve and
vanish. We can then call ourselves a “mod-
orthodox. Indeed, the fact that many such
ladies have got together and formed an
association, primarily for the purpose of ofUK (“The Parsi male outgrown? ”) whose
I
V/a jk into ^. stylish
ready-to-VJse
0ffice
Executive Centers
6 Business Centers in India & 140 Business Centers abroad in tie-up with GLOBAL-ALLIANCE NETWORK I
Bangalore: Tel: 2267272 * Fax: 080-2261133 Bombay : Raheja Chambers. Tel : 287 2641 * Fax: 022-2872640 Calcutta ; 8, A.J.C. Bose I
Road, Calcutta-700 017. Tel: 2477280 * Fax: 033-2474614 Madras : 31 A, Cathedral Garden Road, Near Palmgrove Hotel, Madras-600 034.
Tel: 8275191 * Fax: 044-8257258 New Delhi : World Trade Towers. Barakhamha I ana Naw nalhi-iin nni ToI- 'I'li/iftR 1
in
I
to
CD
Road, Calcutta-700 017. Tel: 2477280 * Fax: 033-2474614 Madras : 31 A, Cathedral Garden Road, Near Palmgrove Hotel, Madras-600 034.
Ts!: 9275191 * Fax: 044-8257258 New Delhi : World Trade Towers, Barakhamba Lane, New Delhi-110 001. Tel: 331466
* Fax: 011 -3312830 Secunderabad: 111-115 Chenoy Trade Centre, Park Lane, Secunderabad-500 003. Tel: 842588 * Fax: 0842-846855 1Events and
Personalities
The ^sanding’ of Udvada
With the monsoon barely a month away,
the anti-erosion exercises of the Save bring back from the UK a component that
cost of transporting it from Madras to
Udvada. He has also agreed to personally fisherfolk 25 years ago which has acted
an underwater bund constructed by
" ’. _ I as
an offshore breakwater, but the idea fell by
the wayside.
Shoring up the forestry aspect of the
Udvada Committee (SUC) have acquired is required for the unit,
a measure of urgency. The ingress of the
sea at the Zoroastrian pilgrim center has
been a source of anxiety for community by tetrapods to break the impact of the
members in residence there as well
others (see “Iranshah: Time and Tide,'
Parsiana, May 1994).
At a meeting convened by chainnan recurring exercise —as ecologically friend- 12,1 ” ". ____
Homi Taleyarkhan at his residence on May lier. He says that the burden of maintaining fast growing special species of trees which
7, 1995, the Committee has accepted the a sea wall would be as taxing as the main-
suggestion of experts that a two-pronged tenance of the beach with the added burden
drive is essential — engineering work
buttressed by tree plantation that would
help to bind the soil as well as to control,
if not eliminate, the salinity in the ground
water that is turning local wells brackish.
A high powered team from the Central
Water and Power Research Station,
Khadakwasla, led by its director Dr Zal
Tarapore and including additional director amounting to about a crore of rupees,
Ms V. M. Bendre and R.Kale has sugges- ~
ted the concept of teach nourishment —
Ae replenishment of sand on the teach, plications as different sets of people would
"" advocate different sites for the wall.
It was pointed out by Committee mem
ber Ms Aban Bana that local contractors
Originally it had been suggested that a Shoring up the forestry aspect of the
sea wall be constructed, further supported project were Ravi Kumar, conservator of
- ! forests from the Bulsar division, Binny
as incoming tide at the most vulnerable parts Mondal of the social forestry department
of the shoreline. Tarapore considers the of Bharuch district and Dr Yash Varma,
replenishment of the beach — an annually conservator of forests, Gujarat, besides
Meher-Homji. Their concern is to plant
a sea wall would be as taxing as the main-
would provide for a multiplicity of inter
ests: counter soil erosion, provide fuel
needs of the adivasis and fight salinity in
the ground wat^. To that was added an-
beach replenishment would be a faster other proviso: provide for the Ifanshah ’s
solution in the face of the oncoming mon- kathi requirements. It was agreed that the
. district collector be requested to permit the
The cost of a wall, about 2.5 to 3.5 forestry department to reafforest waste
meters in height, would approximate Rs land in the area.
800 to 1,000 per meter, the total cost
of its potential misuse by the local popula
tion as an open-air toilet. Besides, the
estimated Tarapore. Apart from the fi
nance Tarapore spoke of its political im-
kathi requirements. It was agn
district collector be requested t<
According to Tarapore, five to 10 cubic
meters of sand, dredged from Kolak creek,
would need to be transported and laid out
on the beach along the King and Majestic mine sand from the beach at Udvada and
Hotels. One way of doing this is by way of that natural erosion is only a part of the
pumping through a pipeline. However, problem. Countered Tarapore, “Bring it to
since the distance is about three to four the official attention (of the district collec-
kilometers, piping may be costlier than tor) that you cannot mine from an eroding East OH 3
transportation by truck. * ' . . .
A Madras-based firm has introduced
such a pump and Tarapore and his team are
seeking the assistance of its owner Vaidya
nathan to rent the device at minimal or no
cost in return for free publicity. The
operation would be the first of its kind in
India, Tarapore said.
Tarapore places the upper limit to the
cost of sand replenishment at Rs 10 lakhs fident of persuading them to see the ex-
Another subject of concern for the SUC
was the state of the road linking Udvada
station to the town. Taleyarkhan main
tained that the road has now been repaired
“all the way to the fire-temple, only one
kilometer from the station being a bad
patch. ” However, the committee members
felt that with heavy duty trucks continuing
to ply over it, together with the force of the
rains, the road would again be reduced to
rubble in a few months. Amavaz S. Mam
beach...It is a matter of implementation. The 700-strong Zoroastrian community ii
There is an order of the Government of Calcutta has been having a busy wintei
India that you cannot take sand from the judging by the events held as reported ii
the December ’94-January ’95 issue o(
The Government of Gujarat had agreed Calcutta Gavashni, the newsletter fron
to contribute to the cost of a sea wall.
Whether that contribution would be avail- _____ _______
able for the teach replenishment project is The publication which was originally a bi
_-.i nn-, .. . monthly has since April ’95 teen con
. . - ¦ verted into a quarterly to allow time for th
but anticipates that the costjnay decline: If pens ’ viewpoint. Savak Patel, president of secretaries of the Parsi institutions to sub
the Baroda Parsi Punchayet, opined that mittheir reports which can be incorporate!
about 50 lakh rupees could be raised if all
the anjumans of India contributed.
V. M. Meher-Homji, a geologist at the
not known. Taleyarkhan however was con-
the Calcutta Zoroastrian Community ’i
Religious and Charity Funds (CZCRCF)
the solution works, the Committee can
invest in a pipeline, he adds. about 50 lakh rupees could be raised if all in the newsletter.
If the pump for the project is provided the anjumans of India contributed. A barbecue dinner was held on Decen)
by Vaidyanathan, Rohinton Chinoy of V. M. Meher-Homji, a geologist at the ber 3, 1994 at the Calcutta Parsee Cluj
Union Press has undertaken to bear the French Institute in Pondicherry, spoke of (CPC); a vegetarian thali lunch ushered i
10 Parsiana April 1995
?t
the New Year; the annual atletic sports
were held on January 15; and the CPC
lawns were filled with the aroma of good
Parsi food as the third Annual Parsee
Bazaar got underway on January 22,1995.
Thirteen of the 17 stalls at the Bazaar were
devoted to food (ranging from home-
cooked bhakras to popatjis and mava-na-
samosas to chicken dhansak and sali-
marghi) and one to beverages. The White
Elephant Stall was a new attraction,
and “since most Parsis normally reject a
hand-down except from a family member,
the sales here were surprisingly good, ”
writes Ms Mary Bharucha in the news
letter.
Other events in the Calcutta calendar
included the annual Tin-and-Bottle Ten
nis Tournament held on January 26 and the Zoroastrian dentists: preventing caries
annual ghambar on January 28 and 29. At
the ghambar, “two specialist babarchis
(cooks) from Navsari enjoyed the thrill of
displaying their expertise in the culinary
art, ” as the community feasted on a “simple
but delectable dinner of papeta-ma-gosh
r *
1
B
IMHIM HftI Ife ’
1 HIT K I P < WIP
a^.NFjJk 4th OeCEMIU M. ontxonJs
in f f'll.ib Jr.itioi, uiih wgBSW
COLGATE- PA L,N IOU VE( IN DI A) LM mb
Iintk'r I'• \oi 11 i;i h'
Jamshed Guzder, Dr Sam Bhacca, Jamsetjee Jejeebhoy and Dastur (Dr) Hormazdyar achieved.
The books can be obtained from th
BPP office at 209, D. N. Road on paymei
of Rs 15 (Modi) and Rs 30 (Marzban), h. j.i
and a sister publication of humor, Gupsup. OpCFd AhuPO,
He distinguished himself as a radio and
Mirza. The occasion at Allbless Baug on September 24, 1994 marked the 97th
anniversary of Bombay’s Anjuman Atash Behram.
scheme launched by Damania Airways Marzban was Editor of Jam-e-Jamshed,
and Damania Shipping wherein passen- i
gers on board Damania aircrafts and cata- He distinguished himself as a radio and Billed as the first ever full-fledged musiq
maranjiuring January 1995 were asked to stage playright and director. His inquisi- rendition of passages from theZendAvest
1 . . in the choral an3 orchestral tradition)
Western classical music, Ahuna is th
handiwork of a 55-year-old i^usic teach
contribute funds in envelopes marked five mind brooked innumerable interests:
“Welcome Change ” that were distributed astrology, occult, plant and animal life...
to them. H.j.R. He was also, as his fans would recall, one
ei A 1. i«f I X 1 ^0 perform _
dketeny life sketches on Indian television, ¦¦¦¦¦¦
The Bombay Parsi Punchayet (BPP) has and give Doordarshan
published two more booklets in its on- some of its finest and
going series on biographies of eminent most popular programs
Parsis. Authored by Hormazdyar Shah- to date, like Aavo A/an
purshah Dalal, the biographies. Dr Sir Sathe and What’s the
Jivanji Jamshedji Modi and A di Marzban Good Word. Sadly, the sSjil'
H. J. R.
*
— a gentle genius seem at first glance to be booklet makes no men
tion of these facets and
seems more a personal
more detailed than the other works in the
series. However, this is not so, and neither
title really provides any comprehensive recollection by Dalal
of Marzban and his
theater world. There is a move spear-
t'
I .
ft a
¦&
look at the lives of its subjects.
Jivanji Modi is a sketchy account of the ___ ____ _ ______ _
son of the Colaba Agiary panthaky who as headed by the editors of both Jam
Jamshed and The Bombay Samachar to
have the work recalled.
Both the books lack material that would
provide new insights into two of our
community ’ s greats and, at best, are only a three years, used certain sacred words fnj
the Zoroastrian prayers to create an oven
known, or culled from books with easy stirring and stunning musical compositio
access. Even these seemed to be riddled ‘ "
with mistakes. Modi is said to have ad
dressed the 8th Oriental Congress in
Stockholm in 1887, whereas the chrono
logically laid-out sketch which appears as
an appendix to the recently released edi
tion of Modi ’s magnum opus. The Reli
gious Ceremonies and Customs of the
Parsees informs us that the year was 1889.
Further, while Dalal devotes a chapter to
a result of a fortuitous meeting with his
mentor K. R. Cama, and his own love for
nature and books grew into a savant. The
book recounts Jivanji ’s lectures, his ordi
nation into Zoroastrian priesthood, and his _______ ______ _ ______
appointment as secretary of the BPP, a record offactsTmany of them already well-
position Cama was not keen to see his '
protege accept. Nevertheless, Modi, sol
dered on balancing his work with Iranian
studies, and writing, during his eventful
life of 70 years.
And Marzban comes across as a man
who seemed to owe his position to his
parentage: more than 70 percent of the
book i.s devoted to telling the history of the
Marzban clan and Jam-e-Jamshed. A re
naissance man who defies categorization.
Sir J. J. Modi (left) and Marzban:
sketchy sketches
and composer, Ms Meher Madon-Jansa
The 45-minute piece, on which Jansen hi
been working erratically for over the p(
And her coordination with Parvez Dock
with whose Bombay Chamber Orchesi
she has been associated since 1968, i
suited in the fruition of her experimt
with professional finesse on October 2
1994: its performance by a 30-piecet
chestra and an equally-strong, talent
choir drawn from the Bombay Schoolf
Music and the Dadar Music EnscmK
conducted by the dedicated Doctor, f
14 Parsiana April 1995
*
1
Jpride), “I noticed very definite rhythmic BharUChH bagS tWO golds
Sahavir Sarosh Bharucha won two gold
medals on securing first rank at the BE
Ahura consists of six movements [
through which Jansen has tried to convey patterns in our prayers. ” Jansen incorpo-
a philosophical idea with the right use of rated these intonations into the chorus __
Avestan words and a suitable melody. The and, slowly but surely, built up Ahura (Meeh) examination conducted by the
opera starts with the clashing of sounds as a harmonious blend between the Gujarat University. His consistently good
and harmonies that are discordant on the mystical East and the melodious Western performance earned him a first rank not
ear, signifying chaos before the advent of school. only in the final semester but in nearly all
Zoroastrianism. The second movement is Jansen is all praise for Doctor and his the semesters while he was a student at
the rendition of Ashem Vohu in the form of group who worked with her in right earnest Ahmedabad ’s L. D. College of Engineer-
a Western classical hymn. “The melody, for over six months of rehearsals forAhura. ing, notes a press release.
the discipline of a set form used here, is to “I would write out my notations, play them Bharucha is a resident of Ahmedabad
indicate the coming of Order, the Truth or ‘
the Good Mind on this Earth, ” explains they would truly sound only when the
Jansen. This is followed by the Ahunavar (choir) and conductor worked on (hem, ”
prayer where only certain words of the
Yatha Ahu Vairyo are sung as invocation.
Jansen is all praise for Doctor and his
for over six months of rehearsals forAhura.
“I would write out my notations, play them
on the piano, but would get to hear how and presently employed with Ingersoll
Rand (I) Ltd at their Naroda unit. The 22-
year-old engineer further plans to do his
states Jansen. She then incorporded the MBA studies at one of the top 10 institutes
changes in the master sheet.
The Fravarane prayer is next rendered working into the wee hours
as a soprano aria. A little girl seated next to
us stifles a giggle as lead choral singer,
Ms.Freny Dalal-Paghdiwala breaks into a
wafting ‘ha-ha-ha-ha ’ after saying Jasa-
me-avenghe-mazda in a manner redolent director of B. P. Musical
of traditional Western classical singing in Enterprises,
the bell canto style of the 17th and 18th
centuries. “The aria is a musical
elaboration, ” explains Jansen, “where hasn ’t been another public >
words take second place, ” justifying her
interpretation.
The Zoroastrian influence, however,
was soon re-ushered with the Tandarosti
blessing rendered in a manner akin to its
intonation by priests at a fire-temple. The
sixth and final movement with which the
concert climaxed was a paean to Ahura
Mazda executed with full-throated voices
and soaring instruments.
For Jansen, who grew up in a Zoroas-
trian atmosphere (she had dedicated her rendering since the premiere; and the con
cert though recorded live isn ’t being sold
as a shy and reticent Jansen doesn ’t wish to
of the morning.
Put up at a cost of over Rs
60,000 as per Ms Bepsy
Marzban, the organizational
A/zwra was a
unique experiment. Despite
the “good response ” there \
i
attempt to the memory of her parents)
complete with Parsi influences that in- __________________
eluded appreciation and learning of West- explore the possibilities of commercially
ern classical music, Ahura was the culmi- releasing the music. h. j. r.
nation of a life-long dream. The theory of
I
¦ Top: engineer S. Bharucha
I (lef^ and cricketer
¦ Z Bharucha
K Alongside: prosthodontist
Mirza (left) and
educationist Ghadiali
oFh
if
I itt
*
of India and, if funds permit,
to pursue a master of science
degree in the USA.
A brilliant student all
through his academic career, Bharuchaj
who had won sports certificates at thei
school level lists billiards, snooker,
swimming, cricket, volley ball and table
tennis among his extracurricular activities.
Bharucha’s unbeaten 164
An unbeaten 164 in the Irani Trophy tour-
. . nament brought opening batsman Zubin
Communications Art Bharucha the distinction of being able to
carry his bat through an entire innings. He
... - w c, ------------ is the first player on the Bombay team to
torship for a short while), I was impressed A<&A/honor was presented to Birdy in New achieve this feat and the second in the
by the Latin masses put to music by Haydn p -
and Mozart, ” informs a publicity-shy received the C AG title at the organization ’s
' ' " . - . awards function in Bombay.
Thirty-two-year-old Birdy works for
releasing the music.
classical music that she learnt under Ms Birdy’s best copy
Gool Tata stood her in good stead when The Best Copywriter of the Year distinc-
composing the opera, a fact she remembers tion was conferred on Freddy Birdy by
with gracious gratitude. I ’
As a singer in the Cantata Choir (of Guild (CAG), and Advertising and Mar-
which she had later taken up musical direc- keting (A&M), a fortnightly magazine. The
is the first player on the Bombay team to
Delhi on M^ch 11 and on March 2 he history of the tournament (Sunil Gavaskar
’ had performed this feat in 1974-75), notes
a report in the Mid-Day of October 14,1994,
Bharucha, 25, who had hit a century on
debut, batted “for 531 minutes, faced 591
balls, and had 21 hits to the ropes ” when
Jansen. Then she thought of casting Parsi
prayers in a similar mold, and was en
thused when her hymn Ashem Vohu met Mudra Communications and has in the last
with a good response when first performed
in this style by the B. P. Orchestra at their
Pateti concert a few years ago.
“Besides, ” smiles Jansen who is mar- — the highest award — in the category of “It ’s a great feeling to get a hundred, ” say(
ried to a Hollander but was brought up in Cinema/TV/Video film in English at the Bharucha, adding, “(but) you must not liv
if
t-**.
l»
i?
'^'d^
®.iV!
.i? ”
4
«’
'ay^ .A
?>
I
.r ’>
-^1 tli^
b -\i
;c
a
¦- top): fied Indian and lioness;ment of our face: “If s oily, except for the would sit by my phone all day long waiting realm of “what might have been. ” Twi
area under the eyes where it is dry . And you for clients tb ’ ring up, ” Workingboxwalla trophies, won at international competition
of creative make-up — where the beauti
cians paint the most amazing designs oni
face — adorn a shelf in his room, a test)
with people begging mony to his artistic skills,
to get their names
squeezed in. The job he needed to set out on this uncertain ad
is demanding and venture in his Zoroastrian roots, for in i
Workingboxwalla Workingboxwalla sees the same spirit (
starts early and ends work that helped the community to surviii ‘
late, well after sun- and establish itself as a leading one in th
set. Since the nature past. Yes, he wears the sudreh and kustiani
ofhisjob requires that believes in the message of the proph^
he segregate the
sexes, he gives appointments to male
realm of “what might have been. ’’ Twi
have not been sleeping too well either recalls fhose'. ’early days.
(true!). ” '
“Your face is your calling card. It is the
first thing a person
sees, and his first
impressions about
you — which are
very important, es
pecially if you are
looking for a job or COtTl^ ^1/
to clinch a business ,
deal — will depend UPPOintlflClit
on what he sees, ” *
says Working boxwalla. Women seem to
realize this instinctively. Men are slowly clients only after sundown. He laughs at the
realizingthatthemachomaninthecorporate suggestion that the dark is a good time for
world is the well-groomed expense account
executive who is edging out the savage
Tarzan they idolized as kids.
Many men, like women, are slowly ac
cepting the fact that they don ’t need to have
an acne problem as an excuse to have a
facial. It not only relaxes and rejuvenates ingboxwalla has even conducted private
but also delays the aging process. This is so
because, according to Workingboxwalla,
the facial muscles are directly under the
skin and keeping them in shape is the best
way of stopping premature facial wrinkles.
Yet social conditioning is hard to brush ledge that it was not by design but by
aside; there are many who see good groom
ing as effeminate and a threat to their ma
cho image. “These people are stupid and
with a false sense of pride, ” says Working
boxwalla.
If you detect a trace of bitterness in his
voice it is understandable, for he bore the
brunt of similar prejudices when he started
out on his career as a beautician some 20
years ago. That was the time when it was
viewed as a profession suitable only for
women and definitely not the one for the
son of a doctor — his father was a GP. “My
relatives, friends, everyone thought I was after he obtained his SSC from Sir Cawasji education in Bombay JMts Gool Ghat
crazy wanting to become a beautician! I Jehangir High School was filed away in the principal of the New Era School, was
' Today there are no gaps in his appoint
ment diary and the phone rings incessantly,
//
'Movie stars are
like any other
clients and must
It is probable that he found the courag
“I will be a Zoroastrian from womb t
tomb, ” he says. It is a spirit that he believe
is less and less evident in the current get
eration, and he fears that it is this — thei
them to sneak in undetected. inability to tune into the realities of tlr
“If they are embarrassed to come here I changing world and act decisively —ratht
will insist they don ’t come at all, ” says the
unrelenting aesthetician. His confidence is
a reflection of his acceptance even by those
who scoffed at him earlier. Indeed, Work-
classes and many of his students, some
males, even Parsi males, are recognized
beauticians in their own right.
Yet, if he is seen as a pioneer of sorts in
his profession, he is the first to acknow
than the issue of declining numbers that i,
the main problem facing the communitj
But what about the problem of declinin
numbers?
Workingboxwalla does not visualij
himself contributing towards solving it i
real terms: he is a confirmed bachela
Where he can contribute is cleaning up th
faces of its individual members and thet
are few around who can do it better.
------------------------------------
EVENTS AND PERSONALITIES
continued from page 16
of clearing up the acne problem he was SPOTLIGHT
plagued with as a kid. Then after one pain
ful treatment when his face was inflamed
and bloated (“I could not even open my
eyes, ” he recalls), Workingboxwalla plaque for promoting oral health in Ind4
reached the breaking point, or rather the Mirza was the first implantologist in Indf
turning point. “I decided at that point to to successfully perform full mouth iii|
start treating myself, ” he states. Using him- ' ¦ - ¦ —
self as a guinea pig he launched out on a
new career.
His ambition to become a graphic artist For her outstanding contribution in the fieldt
after he obtained his SSC from Sir Cawasji
default: default on the part of the innumer
able beauticians he had visited in the hope
At the five-day world congress on prosthi
dontics held in New Delhi in mid-Februa^
1995, Dr Firoze D. Mirza was awarded
plants way back in 1962, notes The Aft^
noon Despatch and CourierMarch 6,199|
it’
sented a certificate by Dr P. C. Alexand
Governor of Maharashtra, at Raj Bhavan
February 20, ’95. The selection for this hot
was made by the “I Love Bombay ” Coi
mittee.
Dr Jimmy N. Vazifdar, honorary seen
Gold and silver Lord Zoroaster and
Asho Farohar medals available
Gold, silver and diamond exclusive showroom
594, Chira Bazar, Girgaum Road, Bombay 400002. Tel: 2065137
We accept CitiBank, Taj Premium, Visa & Master Cards.
tary of the Indian Red Cross, Maharashti ¦
chapter was presented the Bombay Med I
cal Aid Foundation ’s Karmayogi Puraskt (
on April 8, 1995 by State health ministt )
DaulatraoAher,accordingtoanewsrepa f
i n the Indian Express of Apri 19,1995. Th I
award was conferred for his work in bloo I
ii.
banking and transfusion services.
Compiled by Parinaz Gandhi
E
26 Parsiana April 1995VI
I,
j
t
i,
•V
•J
t
“TOO MUCH WELFARE HAS SAPPED US”
continued from page 23
that youngsters are not coming forward for community work. ”
On the flip side, the Punchayet “has been able to continue to
service so many poor people. Creaky as the machinery is, it has
been able to stand up to the pressure of a massive housing
program. No matter how much criticism there ’s been about
allotments, in the absence of any other method, the merit rating
system has worked fairly well. (Retired Justice Bakhtawar)
Lentin when he was Ombudsman, was unable to find any flaws.
However, if the applicant conceals facts, the Punchayet machinery
is not strong enough to detect it. We give every opportunity to
people to let us know (their objections) by publishing the names
of the allottees. Yet the allegation is of favoritism. ”
Changing the focus from the Punchayet to the community
Kanga notes, “Parsis have become so helpless. To no other
community in the world has subsidized housing been given to this
extent. Almost 15,000 to 20,(X)0 of the 50,(XX) Parsis in Bombay
(are accommodated in Punchayet and other trusts ’ flats). The date
of registration of their application is considered by many people
as the sole criteria for their right of entitlement. If I had registered
in 1956 when I started service, I too would have been on the
waiting list even though not otherwise entitled! ” Many people
don ’t plan for themselves when they are earning well, as other
communities do, and merely rely on the Punchayet, says Kanga.
He cites the example of top bankers and police officers who have
never thought about their own accommodation after retirement.
At the other end of the spectrum parents don ’t accommodate
their married sons, preferring to keep the extra space for their own
comfort, says Kanga. “I know of a woman who has three flats but
won ’t allow her brother to use one! ” he adds, quoting the frequent
line “Hun kai aapun? Tu Punchayet pase maag (Why should I
give you? Demand it from the Punchayet). ” How do the young
people of other communities manage and prosper, he asks.
Defending the Punchayet staff who are often accused of being
hard-hearted and rude, Kanga notes, “Social work is a very
difficult task. All the time you are dealing with people in misery.
Nature anesthetizes you in time. When they respond to hard luck
stories with 'Tare thi vadhare kharab cases che (there are cases
worse than yours), ’ people say they are hard-hearted. But they
couldn ’t survive if they fell for every sob story! They are doing
a creditable job inspite of the pressures and other handicaps. ”
Remarking on the declining role of philanthropy in the
community, once considered an article of faith in the Zoroastrian
religion, Kanga draws an exception in the house of Godrej. The
BPP’s program on the housing front was possible because of
them, he adds, though he “would like to qualify that the Godrejs
have also benefitted by it. For example, their charity was not done
purely altruistically as Jamsetji Jejeebhoy had done. The Godrejs
used (their philanthropy) to provide accommodation for the
community but it also helped their retired employees through
their right of recommendation. But, without the Godrejs, Godrej
Baug wouldn ’t have happened and many more Parsis would have
been suffering from the accommodation shortage. ”
Tracing the history of Godrej Baug development Kanga
recalled how cosmopolitan builders were upset when the court
ruled in the 1970s that the FSI (floor space index) purchased by
them at the Dadar Parsi Colony could only be utilized for Parsi
residences. At that time the Maharashtra government was
embarking on a program of slum development and Kanga, then
a public servant, got wind of the builders ’ plan to ed^e the
CROLt-REYNOLDS
TWO-STAGE VACCUM PUMPS
iiu.
TWO STAGE
VACUUM PUMP
CR-25 MODEL-|—F
MOTOR-5 “ ------
21 Parsiana April 1995
100
oe
X
n'
S
20
HP 1450RPM
I '!'r rrM ..
— -CURVES ARE BASED ON-
: 30-C SEALANT WATER .
V
SINGLE STAGE
VACUUM PUMP
__ WITH rfePLON / RubBER BALLS
580
MOTOR-7 5 HP 2850 RPM
. t - i
600
«
710 720 740
VACUUM-MM HG
HIGHER VACUUM & CAPACITY
AT REDUCED POWER CONSUMPTION & RPM
Over 75 years of depth and Experience
Technically the most advanced of its
type on the market
¦ EFFICIENCIES THAT PAY OFF IN SAVINGS OF
THOUSANDS OF RUPEES PER PUMP PER YEAR-
CR Pumps offer the first real improvements in
Vacuum Pump technology in nearly 75 years.
They have dramatically improved operating
efficiencies and offer long-term savings of tens of
thousands of Rupees in power costs. You not only
save elecricity to run the Pump, you can often
downsize the motor to gain additional savings.
niazda
CONTROLS LTD.
Patel Chambers, Near H.K. House,
Ashram Road, Ahmedabad-380 009, India.
Tele. No.; 408967, 408014, 408654
Fax; 0272-427394 Telex: 0121 -6620
*4’
Y
1
I
I
t
to be claiming a hefty tax on what they Parsis will get flats at a lower price and the
community ’s coffers will get less funds,
says Kanga. “There are Parsi trusts with
“There is a difference between the IT lands which are getting encroached. If they
come forward, we are ready to help, ” he
adds.
On the heels of the induction of CER
the appeal, he notes. “Of course, the money candidate Dinshaw Mehta on theBPP board
of trustees at the end of Homi Ranina ’s
tenure in June 1994, the community grape-
government into using the BPP’s idle land
adjoining doongerwadi — then already consider to be the BPP’s commercial pro-
under government embargo thanks to the fits from Spenta apartments.
Urban Land Ceiling Act — to rehabilitate ”
the Simla House slum. Kanga says he department ’s and our assessment ofthe tax
urged the BPP trustees to do something, liability, ” concedes Kanga, but the Pun-
Fortunately prime minister Indira Gandhi chayet has the resources to pay up if it loses
came to Bombay for an Indian Merchants ’
Chamber function of which (trustee, now (for the tax) could be used more pro
chairman of BPP) Jamshed Guzder was ductively, but we took a conscious risk,
then president and through her intercession after taking expert advice, for the sake of vine had been humming with stories of
the land was made available for the the community. At least now we have so Kanga ’s disenchantment with the party he
construction of housing for lower income much more housing, ” he adds, referring to had helped to found in 1980and his eventual
Parsi families. Development plans were
passed in a hurry but the Punchayet didn ’t
have the machinery for such a large scale
construction program. It was the Godrejs
who came forward and helped to undertake
the construction which prevented the land
from falling into the wrong hands, notes
Kanga.
“Some new trustees are trying to modify
the terms of the agreement with Godrej, ”
says Kanga. (The Godrejs had 50 percent
right of allocation of flats on buildings
they donated. In the case of those buildings
which they constructed for the Punchayet
at cost, eschewing their professional fees,
the Godrejs had sought that the savings to Bharucha Baug at Andheri and elsewhere,
the Punchayet be treated as a donation,
earning the industrial house the right to Kanga provides the genesis of the
-....... ¦¦¦¦Illi.............. resignation from its membership. “In its
initial phase it did what it promised to do, ”
In building Spenta says Kanga listing among the CER’s
we took a conscious
risk, after taking
expert advice, for
the sake of the
community”
contributions the amazing awareness that
it created in the community regarding the
election of trustees, the ensuing community
participation at the AC elections, the shake
up in the Punchayet ’s priorities and the
benefit to the Punchayet board of getting
trustees with commercial and managerial
experience like Minoo Shroff who were
prepared to work for the community. But,
he notes, “I felt that it was cramping my
style as trustee. As trustee I felt I.should
the BPP constructions at Godrej Baug, the take decisions liased on my own judge
ment, independently, not because some-
Turning to the contemporary scene body else felt it was right, I^also disagreed
r ; con-
allocate the proportionate quantity of nection between the Tata Housing Com-
J pany and the Petit Trust: The new building
(with the party) on certain issues. I wanted
to convert the CER into a welfare organi-
housing.) “The initial formula was loaded pany and the Petit Trust: The new building zation. It was not able to continue to en- I
in favor of Godrej. The Punchayet is now being constructed in the compound of the thuse young people as it did in the begin-
trying to renegotiate with them, ” says Petit Sanatorium at Cumballa Hill has '
Kanga, adding; “however, the Punchayet been challenged at the Charity Commis-
would loose its credibility if it does not sioner ’s court by some individuals. “The
keep its commitment. Besides, at that point Petit Trust approached Tata Housing as
in time that was the best deal the trustees they had no money for (the upkeep of) the
could have got. ” Sanatorium, no money even for salaries. ” Punchayet, make it more effective. It would
There are also plans to build 40 to 50 Tata Housing took a management contract
ownership flats at Godrej Baug. As Kanga about four to five years ago, to construct
explains, the concerned plot was originally for the Trust which would sell the flats and
on the doongerwadi side of a meandering make a profit. “Unfortunately the trust
line dividing it from Godrej Baug. Thanks deed limits the use of the land to Parsis
to a straight new road the area now falls only. The Trust wanted to make the
within the housing colony and the new
development plan empowers the BPP to
utilize it for residential accommodation.
Russy Khambatta has been appointed the profits are to be used only for poor teeship term drew to a close, the CER and
. , - - B--------------- theorthodoxcamphadcometoanunder-
that this project would yield a good income vation plus 30 more rooms and moder- standing that CER president and mutually
when completed as land values on Napean **-- - ' ¦ • • •- ¦
Sea Road are very high.
Kanga rose to the defence of the CER’s
Robin Hood concept (sell flats to the still be a surplus left in the Trust ’s coffers group or stood independently. At the last
rich and use the proceeds to build tenan- which is to be used for more housing and minute Mehta filed his nomination and the
cies for the poor) which led to the con- other charitable needs of the Parsis. It is CER pressured Engineer to withdraw, en-
structionofSpenta, a building of ownership only if the maximum profit is generated ablingMehtatoentertheBPPboardunoo-
flats at Malabar Hill: “Without this project •*-- ¦ - • - -
no new housing would have been possible. ”
The Income Tax authorities are now said
ning when electoral registration was the
main aim. I thought if we continued on
welfare (lines) we ’d get people, supple
ment the Punchayet ’s creaking organiza
tion... Young volunteers could help the
also help young people to come forward.
The CER could have been that institution.
“I am not a politician. I abhor the rancor
and bitterness at election time...When
Ranina ’s term got over we had a good
opportunity for consensus. Unfortunately,
the way things worked out at the last
new
residential building cosmopolitan (to gen
erate more funds). Some people have election has given a setback to the consensus
objected to this cy pres petition although approach. ” [When Homi Ranina ’s trus-
ychitect in charge, informs Kanga, adding Parsis. ” According to Kanga much reno
vation plus 30 more rooms and moder
nization of the toilets and kitchen are respected solicitor Dadi Engineer would
----- -- ------ —A takeRanina ’splace. Accordingly, no other
planned at the Sanatorium to meet the t ' ~ ‘ *
community ’s needs. Thereafter there will candidate was fielded by the orthodox
still be a surplus left in the Trust ’s coffers
which is to be used for more housing and
other charitable needs of the Parsis. It is
from the rich that the Trust can raise posed, thereby flouting the earlier under
resources for the weaker members of the standing (see “More Effective Outside, ”
community. Otherwise a few well-off Parsiana, July-August 1994).]
29 Parsiana April T 995
¦<»
IAlways remember
Assessing another community body not been practised by Zoroastrians since
. « • 1* _ __ t T*_ I*• z»zvV n«/l OAr'i
” * ¦ ¦ ¦ ! reasons, Kanga notes that at the beginning
Federation of Parsi Zoroastrian Anjumans of the 20th century the Parsis were per-
of India has done good work, answered a t .? . ‘
which he has served ex-officio during his coming to India for historical ^d social
Punchayet years, Kanga feels that the i „ -
TATA
BATA
KHAMBATA
Ketayun & Bomi
CJ22/A WellingtonTerrace
Wellington Street
Bombay 400002
Tel No. 2069636, 2057242
MATRIMONIAL
Divorcee gentleman, 42 years,
working in the Middle East for the
past 16 years, earning a five figure
salary, seeks matrimony with a
homeloving, sociable girl. She can
be a divorcee or widow and must be
willing to reside abroad. Reply
with details and photograph to;
The Advertiser
Parsiana, Matrimonial (Apr/18-95)*
GPO Box 892, Bombay 400001
’Please make sure the reply envelope
bears the reference number cited here.
MATRIMONIAL
Matrimonial alliance invited by parents of tall,
slim, fair, good-looking youth, 27 years old,
with a postgraduate degree from a prestigious
US University, holding a senior executive
position in a leading company. The girl should
be well-educated, good-looking, cultured and
belonging to a respectable family. Apply with
full details and photograph (returnable) to;
The Advertiser
Parsiana, Matrimonial (Apr/15-95)*
GPO Box 892, Bombay 400001
‘Please make sure the reply envelope
bears the reference number cited here.
MATRIMONIAL
Parents invite proposal for their
daughter, aged 24 years, 5’61/2”
BCom, domestically trained with
good family background. Apply
with full details and photograph
(returnable) to:
The Advertiser
Parsiana, Matrimonial (Apr/17-95)*
GPO Box 892, Bombay 400001
‘Please make sure the reply envelope
bears the reference number cited here.
realized that if he
gave an opinion in
favor of conversion,
it might lead to a
mass influx as Parsis
were a very rich
community with
huge welfare funds.
We might have lost
our identity. ” Con
trasting that scena
rio with the present
one Kanga asks.
“Now where are the
attract others to
become Parsis for
monetary benefit?”
Kanga says that at the time of Ms Sooni
(Suzanne) Tata ’s navjote, when the ques
tion of allowing her access to the Anjuman
Atash Behram f3r prayers came up, its
trustees had written to a large number of
scholars and priests including Prof A. V.
w. _ ______ _____ __ -__ ______ ‘ ceived as a very rich and progressive
need. “It ’s got a limited agenda and it ’s community. “Justice Daver may have
going on that basis,
perhaps a bit slow
ly ...Its main achieve
ment has been the .
creation of a feeling funds which would
of brotherhood
among associations
all over India. It ’s a
body to which (the
smaller anjumans)
can turn in case of
need (like to) an el
der brother. ” A major
plus point for the Federation, according to “Now where are the funds which would
Kanga, is the creation of the Federation of attract others to become Parsis for monetary
Zoroastrian Youth Asso-ciations(FOZYA) benefit? ” Also, the national reservation
and the involvement ofyouth in community policy in favor of the scheduled castes
affairs . ensures that they are better off the way they
He is comparatively more sceptical are.
about the need for an international apex
body. “It ’s nice to say there should be an
international organization. But what would
be its role? ” Kanga wonders aloud. It could
provide networking for students, a mat
rimonial bureau, maintain the community ’ s
demographic profile. “When Zoroastrians W. Jackson, Prof Miller, Dr Sir Jivanji
were fleeing Iran, a representation at the Modi and all other high priests asking
UN may have been necessary, but it didn ’t categorically whether there is anything in
materialize. The WZO (World Zoroastrian our religion which prohibits conversion.
Organisation, which came up at that time) “The answer they received was in the
is doing good work as a welfare organi- negative, ” infoims Kanga, wondering what
zation...It has good workers but it has no had happened to the Expert Committee
representative character — it does not Report referred to in the Daver-Beaman
represent Zoroastrians all over the judgement which had also come to the
world...There is no urgent need (for an
international organization). If there had
been one, it would have been formed. ”
Recalling the “bold, enterprising, risk
bearing Parsis of yore... gregarious, unin
hibited by social customs, even then too
small a minority to be a threat to anyone, ”
Kanga notes that the community “capita
lized on these advantages in the first half of present-day scholars differs from that of
the 20th century. It was our heyday...We
went everywhere — to Quetta, to Bur
ma...Too much welfare has sapped us. If
(Parsis) leave Bombay now, they only [By June 8, 1995 — the last day for filing
want to go to the west.
“What to do when the community is
declining? The pros and cons of conversion
need to be examined according to a correct Bombay municipal corporator Rustom Ti-
interpretation of our scriptures. Why is randaz, homeopath Dr Viraf Kapadia and
everyone pussyfooting? Why is it not tack
led head on? ”
Placing reliance on Justice Daver ’s
judgement of 1910 — that Zoroastrianism
enjoins conversion but that conversion has
30 Parsiana April 1995
I
w-f*
t*' ’>* • •>,
I ;
S’
same conclusion.
Quick to clarify that he was not ad
vocating conversion per se, Kanga says he
is seeking a proper examination of the
scriptural interpretation and of all the
available evidence irt*the interests of a
rational policy decision regarding the fu
ture of the community. “If the opinion of
'¦5
?fl
-'-L 1
the Expert Committee, is it not fair to
1 .t . __________ 1_ - _ _1__ I
know the reasons? ” he asks.
nominations —the Punchay et had received
applications from noted solicitor and CER •
president Dadi Engineer, businessman and
president of the Zoroastrian Culture Wel
fare Association of Mahim Dr Syrus Irani.
On the last date for nomination with
drawals, June 22, Irani pulled out. The
election is scheduled for July 8, 1995.]
r:
1/;
i
i«; ¦
B’i.'i
choose to bring their dead to be interred in
the tower of silence here.
An adarian saheb, like an atash behram,
has a perpetual fire burning, and special boi
repairs. It had received major repairs and
renovation in 1916. The most recent sub
stantial repairs were done about 13 years
All this work had prolonged the life of prayers are said five times a day, at every
change of the gah. It is vital therefore, that a
READERS’ FORUM
continued from page 9
any conclusion. This is because there is no
organized structure within the community back,
for the guidance of all Zoroastrians. Even A’ - .
in resoect of our holiest scriptures, the the fire-temple far beyond expectations. ~¦ j * ? • •
Gath^diere is no consensus on their However, a portion of the building sud- place of such religious and strategic signifi-
interpretation and translation. Most Gathic denly collapsed in January 1995, and ex — -
scholars have their own interpretation and/ perts have opined that the present structure
or translation. This is confusing to lav 1—- -- — A"'/¦
persons interested in learning about
the Gathas. Which one is he/she to
accept as authentic? The Gathas
were the subject of two recent
colloquiums in London and Los
Angeles attended by many learned
Zoroastrian and non-Zoroastrian
scholars of the Gathas. Perhaps
the time and effort expended by
both the organizers and the schol
ars would have been more fruitful
and efficacious if the organizers
had arranged first for a few selected
Zoroastrian and non-Zoroastrian
Gathic scholars to meet in a con
clave and enjoined them to come
up with a single interpretation/
translation of some if not all the
Gathas (or even parts thereof)
agreed by a majority of the schol
ars if not all, and then arranged for
the presentation of the agreed ver
sion to the community.
It is high time that the commu
nity organizes such “Council of
Elders ” comprising members of
all shades of opinion and then
refers contentious social and reli
gious issues to such councils for
thorough in-depth study and deci
sion. There could be different
councils or conclaves for different
issues and, for specific issues, the
Council ’s members could include non-
Zoroastrian scholars of our religion. Of another time, another place
course, the first barbican that would need
to be crossed would be to resolve the
contentious issue of who will select and
appoint members to such councils and
conclaves.
cance is not allowed to perish.
X..WV _ ___ _ ____________ Please send your donations by demand
h^ lived its^full life, and ^s beyond resto- draft or crossed cheque, favoring the “Parsi
Zoroastrian Anjuman, Mhow. ” All
donors sending Rs 5,000 or more
will be acknowledged, if they wish,
with a mention on a plaque which
will be installed at a prominent
place in the new structure. We have
applied for a certificate under sec
tion 80G of the Income Tax Act
1961 so that donors too could derive
benefit. behram masani
Hon Sec, Parsi Zoroastrian Anjuman, Mhow
DINSHAW F. D. JOSHI
Maryland, USA.
k«; '
bat
Dead in Penang: Zoroastrians from
ration. Therefore complete demolition and
construction of a new adarian saheb will
have to be undertaken, the most conserva
tive estimate for which is about Rs 13 to 14
lakhs (equivalent to about US $ 45,000).
We are a tiny population of about 125,
with limited resources, so a project of this
magnitude is beyond our capabilities. We
have no option therefore, but to appeal to
our Zoroastrian brethren to help us out.
This appeal is being made not just for the
Parsi population of Mhow, but also to help
Parsis in Penang
I have been residing in Penang,
Malaysia for the past 25 years. Re
cently I discovered two graves of
Parsi Zoroastrians in the Western
Road CemcStery of Penang.
The inscription on the. tomb
stones read as follows:
“In loving memory\)f Byramji
Cowasji, a devoted husband and
father, who fell asleep Feb 24th,
1951. Born in Bombay Feb. 2nd
1879. By caste a Parsee Zoroas
trian. ”
“The earthly remains of 4 Parsee
(2Soroastrians — names unknown).
Originally interred in the Parsee
cemetery situated at lot No. 251
Mukim XVI11 NED, Penang. Have
now been exhumed and re-interred
here on account of the closure of the
previous burial ground. Penang 15th March
1939.”
I would be interested to make contact
with any of the family members or rela
tives of the deceased who may be able to
enlighten me on the background.
You may be interested to know that the
only Parsi family here — the Maneckshas
— has been in Taiping, Malaysia since the
1890s. My husband Pervez is the son of
Rustom and Rhoda Manecksha. There are
some expatriate Parsis in Kuala Lumpur
now. MsNERGlSH PERVEZ MANECKSHA
Penang, Malaysia
4^
Help rebuild Mhow Agiary
Although Mhow is a small place with a
small Parsi population, it is located strate
gically in central India, and has the north
ern most adarian saheb in the country. The ----- --------------------------,----------------- f. . , ,
fire-temple was first built as a dadgah preserve a part of our common heritage as InCOUSisteilt StutistiCS?
during or before 1840. It was upgraded to many people passing through the area make It is a great relief to know that the Mile-
an adarian in about 1857, and over the it a point to stop and visit and many Zoro- stones published in Parsiana are almost
years it has been maintained with minor astrians from the surrounding regions nowhere near authentic. You mention that
it a point to stop and visit and many Zoro
astrians from the surrounding regions
31 Parsiana April 1995i F
With Compliments
From
your statistics are not always consistent. I
think that the statistics are never consis
tent.
The young cannot afford to buy flats in
central Bombay today because of the soar
ing property prices. Hence most of the
younger people live in the suburbs. You
monly used word today — Can you spot it?
“His disastrous failure was a great shock to
Xerxes. Now he was afraid, afraid lest the
Greeks, either on their own initiative or at
the suggestion of the lonians, should sail to
GLOBE
THEATRES
Pvt Ltd
Established
April 3, 1915
Pioneers oF Show
Business in India for
the last 7 9 years
We rededicate
ourselves to the ideals
we have cherished and
practised all along --
namely to show
NOTHING BUT
THE BEST
to our ever increasing
number of Patrons
Controlling:
REGAL
BOMBAY
CAPITOL
BOMBAY
Jjc
GLOBE
CALCUTTA
32 Parsiana April 7 995
the Hellespont and cut his bridge; afraid of ;
mention that suburban hospitals are not being trapped in Europe; afraid ot dying |
included.
Today commuting time in Bombay is
so great that even from a relatively close
suburb like Bandra to reach Malabar Hill
or Central Bombay takes an hour. What
about people from Andheri? It is not con
venient for people from the suburbs to
come all the way to south Bombay for a
there. His immediate reaction was to think { .
ofretreat. But he wanted to conceal his fear | •
from the Greeks as well as from his own
men, and so he gave orders for a causeway
to be built across to Salamis. Phoenician
r.
J.'-
cargo boats were lashed together to form a |
bridge and a breakwater — great activity |
went on as if another battle was to be fc ’
hospital. I hope this is brought to the light fought. Seeing this, everyone assumed that J-
of our great community. he contemplated nothing less than a con- h
tinuation of the war on all fronts in Greece,
L
ZUBIN C. M. SHROFF
New Delhi Only Mardonios was not taken in. He knew
very well what was going on in Xerxes ’s
mind.
“Meanwhile, Xerxes sent a messenger
to Persia with news of the battle. These
messengers are the fastest known method
>¦
A stamp in his pehramni?
It is understood that the government of
India has decided to phase out currency
notes of smaller denominations, viz Re 1,
Rs 2 and Rs 5. The discontinuance of the
Re 1 note is likely to create a problem for
our
fine art of “pe/iramni-giving! ”
I feel that this problem could be solved
by ‘tagging ’ a Re 1 postage stamp to the Rs
50, Rs 100 and Rs 500 currency notes to
arrive at the accepted norm of Rs 51, 101,
Rs 501, etc. This would do away with the
carriage of heavy metal in the form of Re
1 coins to the various baugs where one
usually attends navjotes and weddings.
Besides the Re 1 postal stamps could
also be used as postage towards the sending vice is called angareian in Persia. ”
of “Thank You ” cards — one of the fast- rashidirani i
disappearing social graces. Bombay
SOLI canteenwala
of communication and the system was ,
invented by the Persians themselves. For
community which has developed the every day the complete journey should ;
take, they havcxa horse and a man spaced
out a day ’s ride apart. Snow, rain, scorch- >
ing sun, night — it is all the same to these
men; they get their messageihrough as fast
as is humanly possible. The first hands
over his message to the second, the second
to the third, and so on until, by relays, it
reaches its destination — like the handing
on of the torch in the Greek festival of |
Hephaistos. This form of messenger ser-
I
Kapadias of Astley Hall
Spot the word in Dehra Dun an aged couple live
This extract from Herodotus ’ The Struggle Who, this autumn, 1994, sixty years
for Greece (circa 450 BC) contains a com-
S.J
MATRIMONIAL
Matrimonial correspondence
invited from an attractive, well-
qualified, Parsi girl up to 30 years,
for a well-settled, 33-year-old, tall,
fair, handsome, cultured. Parsi
computer professional and Green
Card holder. Write to:
The Advertiser
Parsiana, Matrimonial (Apr/16-95)*
GPO Box 892, Bombay 400001
‘Please make sure the reply envelope
bears the reference number cited here.
of blissful marriago.celebrated.
In today ’s matrimonial graveyard
that is so inebriated,
A happy record indeed this has created!
He, a gentleman, a famous
Dental - Surgeon of “90,”
of the town.
She, a gentle heiress, “83,”
gracious, and never in a frown.
No children have they -
God, their mainstay -
They live in their fine home
in an exemplary way.
Above bookshop “Jugal Kishore, ”
With courteous elan and very much more.
APPAN NAIR
Dehra Dun
b
Edited by Amavaz S. Mama
?i
'r
POLITICS AND POLICY
THE FEDERATION
reviews the Wadia navjote
Neville Wadia's navjote was
the key to an open t
dialogue on community issues
Arnavaz S. Mama
1
u- tthruVatrakDar- Federation awards and guests witnessed
IntheaftermathofNevilleW^ia'snavjote ^SSe^ltTX^ edin* «>e pomp P^*-tr^nja_^h^^
theexecutivecounciloftheFederaU^ ^.S^d been tempered by Ahura Mazda inherited the Retreat at
Parsi Zoroastrian its forthebenefitoftheassembledcommunity, he ceremonial bands of
bated the issue at con^der^k^^^ noted DPA president Lt G^n Adi Sethna in regiments unfurled the
Xp) chairman Jamshed Guzder stated. Block. The mounted camels of the Border
“ s have asked for the Federa-
It was a rare invitation to the Federation swune into the finale of ^are jehan se
to discuss the ‘internal affairs ’ of a mem
ber anjuman, though it must be acknow
ledged that the matter was of interest and
import to cnmmunitv at large.
TheL
astrians later this year and Ms Toxy Cowasji
has extended a warm welcome to the Zo
roastrian youth of India.
ZTFE (Zoroastrian Trust Funds or Eu
rope) president Rusi C— —
Jamshed Guzder stated,
, be considered a behdin).
have asked for the Federa-
invitation to the Federation
------ - Qf interest and
the community at large.
In his inaugural speech M.
member
Guzder (left) and Sethna: permitting
AnjumanTrustFund open
Comn-ission of WW —• -
Block. The mounted camels of the Border
Security Force were etched against the
setting sun on the ramparts of the North
and South Blocks which flank the road to
Rashtrapati Bhavan as the military band
swung into the finale of Sare jehan se
achha, Hindustan hamara.
terrain to reach the seats reserved for the
delegates proved worthwhile for all except
Capt Homi Dandiwalla, president of the
Allahabad Parsi Zoroastrian Anjuman and
nmuin>u„------------ ,
The long and laborious walk over uneven
vO reach the seats reserved for the
delegates proved worthwhile for all except
Cant Homi Dandiwalla, president of the
W^d^T^x^ WsZf?Shim;n7Despi.. a fall, drauks fo
SL extended a warm welcome .0 the Zo- -^^^Xcy^^drelh. lack of
was due to receive the Federation award
for professional competence, they gamely
exceptionally successful exp^imem in ^“"^rS'XdT"
X^ocS ’vXe ’’had lemned to live ^hedul^ te'Sl's “ons “tte following
together for 24 days, eating food spectalt- they m^s
ties from all over the country, experien- day! The quiet, matter o --------
cing a variety of life styles, customs and
at the time of separation. “If you can
gress will be held in Tehran; the dates cawu -- “^iJ'become set, drill presentation of the Eeoerauon ,
however are not yet known. . 8-^ed m , ^992 and 1993
And several Zoroastrian ladies mairied mm^thern ^Val^raian asserted. “Address
to men
invitation
integrity as a nation;
not poverty, 1"—- ..
shelter or unemployment but the absence
¦ He recounted how
Sethna and he had worked together on an
ZTFE -who attended of the spirit of unity
luuvy —* • 1 • ’x « -J
the Federation meeting as a special invUee
extended a similar invitation to India s
Zoroaslrian youth to attend the Second
World Zoroastrian Youth Congress in Lon
don in 1997.
Though at the time of the Federation
meeting the venue of the next World Zo
roastrian Congress (WZC) was under de
bate it is now likely that the sixth Con-
r
ties from all over the country, experien
cing a variety of life styles, customs and
beliefs, building friendships, which led to
tears <----------
catch hold of the kids
acceptance of their pain and discomfort
I in the courage ot
elderly Parsis from the mofussil.) lhe
tewee„ ‘;,gh; and delegate.ta
of other faX re"spotded"to the be saved, ” '^’AUhX'tmeTrn Bombay in June 1994
, of the Delhi Parsi Anjuman the common issues t g Federation had collected funds for the
(DPA), the host anjuman, to air their wishes India See if you P P ^tash behrams of India and to help
nroblems in a special open session scriptions not only tor yourselves ^6^. ^is video
dedicated to interfaith dialogue and to all o1e ctog docutnentatyontfieOathasofZ^atetoa
keeping the community together. invited to receive This time Parsiana was the unexpected
The DPA had organized atight schedule
of the next World Zo- was an object lesson
in the courage of
will be held in Tehran; the dates
keeping the community together.
India. See if you can come up with pre
scriptions not only for yourselves but for
all of India, ” he charged.
The same evening, the delegates, out
standing Zoroastrians invited to receive
scriptions not only for yourselves but for
33 Parsiana April J 995
IST*
vene. However, even when the population
is substantial, if an individual is trying to
subvert the community property towards
and grateful beneficiary of the Federation ’s
largesse as individuals and anjumans pro
mised annual amounts ranging from Rs -
1,000 to Rs 15,000 to defray the costs of his own coffers, the Federation will inter
producing what British scholar of Zo
roastrianism John Hinnells^ had dubbed
“the only international Zoroastrian link
medium. ”
As usual the DPA had spared no effort
to ensure the comfort of the delegates at
the dharamshalla^with grazing and water
ing to match!
Objecting to the use of the term “take
over ” Gandhi noted, “The Federation is
not ‘taking over. ’ The Federation can be a
custodian of the assets and the Federation ’s
name can be added as joint owner in the
7/12 (saat-baara) records. The Federation
has only a watching brief. It will take over
the responsibility of an anjuman only when
vene. ”
Katpitia however was determined that
Federation members be aware of the
problems before them when salvaging the . .
property of an anjuman which is totally the anjuman no longer exists. Unless the
defunct; “Landed property is affected by anjuman (or individual) comes forward
19 different acts. ” In certain cases the trust
land lies in areas where the zoning has
changed from residential to hazardous
industry and the price has soared. Then a
certain part of the land is lost under the
agricultural land ceiling act and the urban
the Federation will not go and say ‘We ’ll
be custodian. ’”
Volunteers from Nagpur have identi-
f’
t
t ¦
vuiuincvia num
fied community properties in Gadak, |
Defunct anjumans
Back in the saddle after hospitalization for
an angiography, the hard worked Sorab aguvu.Lu..*. .....---- -e —; — - _
Katpitia ofthe Surat Parsi Panchayat (SPP) land ceiling act which claims almost 50
has been busy making up for lost time. His percent of the total. Releasing the land
project report was laced, as usual, with from these restrictions is time consuming,
pertinent details as he urged the council to “Onlv after completing all this (can we
adopt a proper definition of the term “de
funct anjuman. ” “If five or six Parsis say
they are not defunct and want to get dona
tions to maintain an agiary or dokhma
should the Federation consider (such an
anjuman) as defunct? ”
think ^ofXindUng ’^Lfumans when the full'^of legal complications. ” He said he “Delhi has half-heartedly done things.^It s
population is down to four or five tamilies.
In such cases they should appoint the
Federation as custodian (of their proper
ties), ” clarified Federation joint honorary may be prolonged,
secretary Keki Gandhi.
Declining in numbers, the generally
aging communities are finding their pro
perties encroached or gratuitously annexed the Collector rejected his clairn that his
by outsiders. Despite these obvious hurdles
most anjumans are averse to include a Fed
eration representative among its trustees.
The rising land values everywhere, es
pecially in and around urban areas, seem to ,
make the local anjumans fearful of not recounted Katpitia. Judicial ^proceedings
being able to sell off their assets to their
own benefit. In the case of Bhopal the
Federation ’s defunct anjumans subcom-
mitee rescued its property from the mo
rass, after which the Bhopal anjuman chose
to ignore the Federation. The community ’s
penchant for in-fighting often further ad
vantages its adversaries. An example is
percent of the total. Releasing the land
Harda, Chandrapur and Disa, informed
Katpitia. The residents of Disa had even
tually migrated to Navsari. One survi
vor there had offered to help, he added.
FOZYA (Federation of Zoroastrian Youth
Associations) president Porus Karanjawalla
{
‘Only after completing all this (can
approach) the charity commissioner of the of Ahmedabad has volunteered to help
zone applicable to the area (for permission with the Disa property which includes a
to sell the property). ”
Recounting the acquisition of two lakh
rupees by selling scrap in Cambay and four aramgahs and other properties in Sahranpur,
lakhs from the land sale in Junagadh, Hathras, Aligarh, Mathura, Jabalpur, etc
Katpitia cautioned, “The entire project is DPA vice president Dadi Mistry noted,
had just been informed that an application essential that ^e have one dedicated
'___ * Sorabji. ” Easier said than done, as even a
reliable assistant for Katpjtia has been
hard to find. Katpitia cited a case where the
_ opposing party “instigated our person to
around the tower of silence, a Muslim has depose (before the court) in such a manner
appealed to the Nadiad High Court after
uaw _________________ __ _____ __ >
forefathers tilled the land . In Nadiad where that he had had to go personally to Ambala >
the negotiations were on the verge of fina
lization “a non-Parsi trust has put a claim
on our property. We won the case but
they ’ve gone to the Nadiad District Court, ”
against the land sale had been filed with
the charity commissioner and the matter
In Cambay where there is more land
tower of silence.
Referring to the “phenomenal ” value of
as to lose our case. Not only is revenue
involved but public trust, ” he said, adding
Cantonment, where there is said to be a
graveyard, to file an application for infor
mation as a friend who had been requested
to probe hadn ’t made a worthwhile effort.
Ms Mini Boga, said to be the only
• •<»
!
t
r
are in progress in Khandwa and at Neemuch surviving trustee in Amritsar, had appro^-
a compromise seems likely. The Dharwar
and Hubli anjumans have expressed a de
sire to appoint the Federation as custodian
and Badnera (with two families) Anjuman Katpitia noted on the basis of a volunteer js
is considering the appointment of the Fed
eration as custodian of its properties — an
ched the Federation to take over the
management of the aramgah and the
anjuman ’s corpus of Rs 8 lakhs according
trustee. The Amravati (with four families) to Kerman Nowsherwanji of the DPA. But
t
i
&
information that the land is encroached. '
Guzder apprised delegates of the land in
vaniaged iu> ™i VA.aiiij7iv *a w*«v*v.. , J JU ?u^
that of Suwali near Hazira in Gujarat where agiary on the main road with a good amount Colaba that was comand^red by the .
of land and also a dokhma, as noted SPP’s Indian Navy four years ago. The concerned
'¦ ¦¦¦ ¦; trustee returned the Navy ’s compensation
silence is in decay... there are three or four Jal Dotiwala. cheque for one crore rupees and had got a
Parsi families. They want to manage their As it was announced that Mulla and commitment for 7.5 crore rupees from
own affairs because of the valuable land, ” Mulla and Cragie, Blunt and Caroe were them. BPP chief executive Rustom Ankle
said Katpitia. But Gandhi cautioned, “We preparing a draft MOU (memorandum of sana felt that as Zoroasftian land had been
walla asked if thc solicitors had any in- —to protect Bombay harbor —the commu-
ing to an anjuman but to an individual? the land but agreed with Mistry, who had
« __ A.-*— _______________ lUnf oxMAA “AfkarnAmiYiiini.
land values have risen because of indus
trialization. “The property of the tower of Jamshed Dotiwala on behalf of his uncle
As it was announced that Mulla and
Mulla and Cragie, Blunt and Caroe were
own affairs because of the valuable land, ’
do not intervene unless we ’re satisfied understanding) for these cases Dandi-
about the mismanagement (of the trust ’s
affairs). There are two prongs to the de
funct anjuman policy: If the population is _
dwindling, but still managing its affairs Can the Federation take it over on certain
properly, the Federation will not inter- terms and conditions? ”
r
strument “to tak e, over property not belong- nity should not object to the acquisition of
...... . ... .----------1.. i--.j
raised the topic, that since “other communi
ties benefit from a quid pro quo, so why
terms and conditions? ”
34 Parsiana April 1995From left to right: {top row) Davierwalla, Anklesaria, Gandhi, Guzder and Sethna;
(second row) Davierwalla, Mistry and Rustomji; (third row) Pervez Irani,
Karanjawalla and Mogrelia; (fourth row) Kavarana, Syrus Irani, Karanjawalla,
Farokh Irani and Eruch Irani
Hi
>'
Irani, Karanjawalla,
35 Parsiana April 1995
aot us? ” . .
Land in Boisar belonging to a private
trust is worth crores of rupees according to
Karanjawalla. It was alleged that there
were encroachments and that a Sai Baba
taiid in Boisar belonging to a private
alleged that there
were encroacnrnenvb Se,,na. Ka^arana.
row) Navaz Palkhivala and Phiroza Singh
' . __ I • f /altifH »*Z3A47 I
Del^ra and Con.raaar
37 ParsianaApril!995
Ireminded the gathering that more housing leading Dalal to remind the youths of the
does not necessarily imply an increase in
the number of children.
Noting that the largest percentage of
people who come for BPP flats do so on the
vl.-v _ -- - ' '— • an venue was s — —---------- ---------
ultimatum, Guzder°informed the" council the objection that Indian youth may have
When Mistry urged FOZYA to book
the 2001 meet for Ahmedabad Parvez
Irani commented on the level of commu
nication: “The youth are invited at Federa-
discharged two projects: increasing Par
siana's subscription base and enrolling
plea that the engaged girl has given an
UlllIliaLUllX, kJULUVl llllVilllVW v**w -----~J---------------------
that the BPP has acquired four acres of problems with Pakistani visas^
land in Vasai to build another 250 to 400
flats. He also revealed that the BPP had
received offers to the tune of three crore
rupees to buy land.
Social scientist and demographer Ms
Ava Khullar of the DPA admitted that the
adults were “putting the onus on the
London venue of the Second World Zoro
astrian Youth Congress (SWZYC) in July community professionals as Zotarians,
1997. Earlier the SWZYC had been sche- “ ............ - -r
duled for Karachi. According to Dalal the
venue was s... .—----------------------
FOZYA is now entrusted with the task of
______________ helping with the field work in collection of
shifted to London because of demographic data as well as the unearthing
of background information on defunct
anjumans.
These are in addition to their normal
activities in their home base. For example,
the Young Zoroastrians of Dahanu have
been running a school over the past four
who have not attended a FOZYA meeting
or seminar. Often, FOZYA members don ’t
children but our elders don ’t give support know about Federation meetings. ’’He sug-
the way other communities do. ’’ Noted "
social worker Ms Dinaz Damania of Ban
galore, “As social workers and researchers,
our good intentions and solutions fall far
short of expectations. Solutions should
work from the bottom up. Qualitative Pervez Irani also felt that since the Fed-
research of concerned people should
produce the solutions. ”
!
¦
lllvauull. 1 lie JVUUl €UV III vnvu X vuviu --------------- --- r
tion meetings. But there are youths here years. It has now reached the seventh '
• L.
five acre playground. Basket ball, cricket ?
and other tournaments held locally and
Standard level with its own building and a
with neighboring anjumans help to main-
tions should secure an invitation to depute tain their morale. They function as pall-
their representative to attend Federation
meetings instead of requesting the anju
mans to depute a youth representative.
gested that alt FOZYA member associa- i.
eration recommended that each anjuman
should coopt a youth representative on its
governing body it was only proper that the
Youth activities Federation should coopt a youth represen-
With an Asian youth meet being sponsored tative on its executive council,
by Karachi during the Diwali or Christmas
holidays this year, Karanjawalla urged lo
cal punchayets to sponsor at least one
candidate each.
To overcome the problem of costly council. He added that a proposal to amend
international travel Gandhi suggested that the Federation constitution suitably could entries,
the Karachi youths be invited to India be mooted at the next meeting,
instead. Mistry urged FOZYA to host an
international conference once in four years,
bearers and help maintain the dokhma,
informed Pervez Irani.
In Delhi the Farohar Club has performed
remarkably in the field of religious educa
tion, DPA’s representations at interfaith
meetings being well applauded, as noted
DPA trustee Farrokh Rustomji. A presen
tation backed up by posters, which had
amazed the gathering at the Jhansi aramgah
Gandhi, always partial to youth involve- centenary celebrations, had been reenacted
ment in community matters, suggested for the benefit o^the Federation delegates
that the FOZYA president be an ex officio ’ ’ ' ' * "
member of the Federation ’s executive
who were also presented a short religious
•
1.
i-
p
knowledge quiz to solve. Remarkably, not I
a single elder featured amon^ the winning
¦ A report regarding the activities of the
Having undertaken and satisfactorily Madras youth was presented by Mogrelia.I
«
(
3S Parsiana April 1995
I
Left to rightftop row) Entrance to aramgah; graves in aramgah; priests
quarters at the dharamshalla; (bottom row) Ervad Bagli in front of
the Katrak Dar-E-Meher; embroidered Zoroaster at the entrance of the
Dar-E-Meher; delegates at prayer
¦fc JL - "
r
J
?
I"
r
hM
¦
Left to right (top): Dalal, Kety
Marshall, Khullar and Darius Marshall
Far left: Vardharajan ceremonially
received by Dhun Bagli
Left: AU and Malikar: interfaith session
¦
¦
»
-4i
He noted how the youth had collected Anklesaria.
about Rs 1.7 lakh at short notice for repairs
to the anjuman building and how they hold given time to make children say prayers at
regular monthly get-togethers and help
clean the agiary.
It was a matter of regret for Gandhi and
the other delegates that Calcutta and
Jamshedpur did not participate in FOZYA
activities. Even as Federation delegates,
these centers are often unrepresented. “The
late Ardeshir Batlivala used to travel sec
ond class and came to every meeting as
long as he could... We had to give Adi
Rabadi an award to make him come, ”
noted Gandhi, only partly in jest.
Quipped Anklesaria: “Keki Gandhi is
the evergreen youth of Calcutta, but I hope cational endowment. We have a very good
you don ’t think Keki Gandhi is the only library with thousands of pounds worth of
youth of Calcutta! ” books... ”
Khurshed Pastakia of the Borivli and
Suburban Zoroastrian Association sugges
ted that the money from the Zartoshty
brothers could be used to reprint the pub-
the suggestion, anjumans and individuals
pledged varying amounts: the Allahabad
Parsee Zoroastrian Anjuman Rs 1,000; the
BPP Rs 15,000; the Broach Parsi Puncha
yet Rs 5,000; the Calicut Parsi Anjuman
Rs 2,000; the Madras Parsi Zarthosti
Anjuman Rs ^000; the Surat Parsi
Punchayet Rs 5,000; Sarosh Ginwalla
an impressionable age. Every single parent Rs 1,000; Jamshed Guzder^ Rs 15,000;
must create conditions for routine prayers. ” “*• ’
While agreeing with Davierwalla that
“education begins from birth, ” Dalal advo
cated, “get teachers and pay them well.
Create a ‘feel good ’ effect among the
youngsters...The demand for information
on Zoroastrianism is so great in the UK, we
can ’t cope. There are special functions at
Zoroastrian House; we take part in Com
monwealth Day observances; our children
see Zoroastrians on screen and in the
media... We are hoping to create an edu-
Davierwalla noted that “We have not
Aspi Irani Rs 1,000; Silloo and Farrokh
Kavarana Rs 5,000; Areez Khambatta
Rs 19,000; Boman Mehta Rs 10,000; Homi
Mehta Rs 1,000 and Ms Pansy Dinshaw
Mehte Rs 5,000. {Parsiana is thankful to
the generous donors for their support.)
Neville Wadia’s navjote
Guzder referred to the Wadia navjote and
Wadia ’s letter to the BPP seeking to be
considered a Zoroastrian to which the BPP
has since conveyed its assent. The Federa
tion members ’ response was wide and
varied. “If Wadia gives you a donation,
won ’t you put him oiiThe F (donor) regis
ter? ” queried Gandhi. “If not, he ’ll go to
court...(It ’11 be) Wadia versus Guzder if
you want to be immortalized like Petit
versus Jejeebhoy, ” he jested.
“What was Neville before he became a
Zoroastrian? ” asked Mogrelia. Guzder ex-
Zoroastrian literature
Ms Arnavaz Chubb ’s plea for the pre
servation of Zoroastrian literature (“The
enemy within, ”Par5iana, November 1994) lications now out of print and translate
was taken up by Gandhi. Guzder informed others. Gandhi voiced FOZYA founder
the members of a donation of Rs 23 lakhs president JehangirBisney ’ssuggestionthat plained how Sir Ness Wadia fell in love
from the Zartoshty brothers of Canada and FOZYA be asked to chart out a master with the daughter of an Irish priest who
Iran for inculcating a knowledge of Zoro- ? '
astrianism among school childen as well religious knowledge,
as for creating a body of scholars. A com
mittee comprising Dastur.s (Drs) Hormuz-
diar Mirza and Kaikhusroo JamaspAsa
and Homi Dhalla has been set up under the
chairmanship of Nadir Modi who has
drawn up a program which is to be sent for
Mehraban Zartoshty ’s approval, informed curred by the publication. Responding to
FOZYA be asked to chart out a master
plan as the youth have repeatedly sought insisted that Ness convert to Christianity
• before he could be allowed to marry his
A delegate present suggested that in the daughter. Neville, the son of the union,
same manner as money had been raised for
Homi Sethna ’s video documentary The
Voice of Zarathushtra, various delegates applies universally. ” Agreed Guzder:
should, turn by turn, offer their contribu
tions to Parsiana to offset the losses in-
was baptised at birth. RespondedMogrelia,
“The BPP should ensure that the ruling
“Where the person is of Zoroastrian ances
try. ” Countered Navsari ’s Dara Deboo:
“Neville Wadia was baptised so he was not
39 Parsiana April 1995r
38
MATRIMONIAL
Parsi parents of only daughter, 30 years, 5’5,54 kgs, (very
fair), PhD, internationally travelled, domestically accomplished,
invite proposals from equally eligible gentlemen up to
35 years. Kindly respond with (returnable) photo to;
The Advertiser
Parsiana, Matrimonial (Apr/19-95)* GPO Box 892, Bombay 400001
•please make sure the reply envelope
bears the reference number cited here.
a Zoroastrian. ” ... .
atash behramFasked Ginwalla and was informed that entry to an
“What happens if Neville wants to enter the Navsy i
agiary or atash behram is regulated by its trustees. Why not
register navjotes? ” asked Dr Syrus Irani of the Iranian Zoroastrian
Anjuman. “There is a law under which marriages must be
registered. There is no such law regarding navjotes, ” informed
Katpitia. .
“We look to India for religious guidance from the priests, lhe
P
i
MATRIMONIAL
Matrimonial alliance invited for handsome, highly educated, Parsi
youth, 34 years, well-settled in USA, shortly to be in Bombay, from
educated, pleasant girls, 23-28 years, willing to settle abroad. Please
apply promptly with photographs and telephone numbers to;
The Advertiser
Parsiana, Matrimonial (Apr/20-95)* GPO Box 892, Bombay 400001
The Advertiser
•Please make sure the reply envelope
bears the reference number cited here.
MATRIMONIAL
Correspondence invited for a lady, 47 years, commerce graduate,
5'2”, working in a nationalised bank. Domestically trained
good natured with affluent family background. Write giving complete
5'2”, working in a nationalised bank. Domestically trained
particulars and recent photograph (returnable) to:
The Advertiser
Parsiana, Matrimonial (Apr/21-95)* GPO Box 892, Bombay 400001
•Please make sure the reply envelope
bears the reference number cited here.
LONDON
TSed^reaktast
• oe'J i_»z^erTl
• Homely
• Congenial
• Three i - *
Atmosphere \
^*1 t 1^ t 1 1
walk to \
central
minutes
Tube station
to
London bylube
• Very
• Visitors
reasonable
terms
SpreteraW
Zoroastn^^
CONTRACTORS
Bombay Phone Nos: 3634161,3641581
10.00 a.m. to 12 noon, 8.00 p.m. to 10 p.m.
3760707, 3728549 11.00 a.m. to 7.00 p.m.
London contact:
Beroz Mody. No 10
Court Farm Road, Middlesex, UB 5—5 HQ
Tel No: 0044-181-8413491
Katpitia. .
“We look to India for religious guidance from the priests, lhe
priests by a majority have accepted that (NevUle) is a Zoro-
astrian. Here we i-------------
priests, ” noted Dalal. .
“Can ’t we examine (the prospects for creating) a uniform civil
code of conduct for all anjumans to follow? Eliminate this
frequent discussion...? ” asked Rustomji.
To Gandhi ’s query “Apart from Navsari and Udvada are the
other anjumans willing to accept the decision of the five high
priests? ” came a barrage of views. “Embrace gracefully what one
can ’t avoid, (face) the facts of life... ” advised Mogrelia. Syrus
Irani requested the Federation to form a council of religious
leaders and behdins to decide the issue. Davierwalla exhorted the
council to “listen to me peacefully for five minutes. I believe in
protecting my religion from dilution... It is the opinion of my ;
anjuman also...20 percent of families have individuals married
(it was) Nehru ’s condition that Phiroze Gandhi (a Zoroastrian) ¦
become a Hindu... By tradition there is no conversion in Zoro-
astrianism. An apostate is always*an apostate...The impressiot ,
z.. . < /- i:r_\ ___________ nr- **
“Does religion get diluted by increasii^
fnllnwprs7 ” challeneed Gandhi. “Christianity mi
______________r - - ¦
must be advised by the decision of the high |
I
I
out. The silent majority is orthodox. When Indira Gandhi married,
become a Hindu... By tradition there is no con vision in Zoro-
that we gather in"the first 15 years (of life) remains with us... ”
“Does religion get diluted by increasine the number c
followers? ” challenged Gandhi. “Christianity ^d Islam are note
for conversion. It is their experience that the converted Muslin
Christian is a greater devout than the born Christian or Muslin
‘Silent majority ’ is a term dishonestly used by those who canni
Si
muster majority opinion in their favor. If Nehru forced Phiroze t
become Hindu, why don ’t Parsis say (to all non-Zoroastria
suitors), ‘become Zoroastrian ’?”
“May I suggest that everybody read the GathasT' interpose
Shahpur Captain of the World 2^roastrian Organisation, Londoi -
suitors), ‘become Zoroastrian ’?”
Congress and census
The holding ofthe Sixth World Zoroastrian Congress (WZC) wi
tentatively scheduled for the first weekend of January 1996 i F
Bombay. “India does not wish to monopolize the WZC,” sa L
Guzder. Its claim of having the largest Zoroastrian population hi
been disputed by Iranian Zoroastrians, who are keen to hold it
Tehran, he continued. (It has since been noted that the next W2 i.
will be hosted by the Tehran Anjuman, though the dates have n ;
been finalized.) The Federation of Zoroastrian Associations
North America (FEZANA) has already reserved the Congress 1 ,
the year 2000, he informed the council. It was generally conced
Bombay. “India does not wish to monopolize the WZC,” sa L
been disputed by Iranian Zoroastrians, who are keen to hold it
that the number of Indian delegates who will be able to atte
these Congresses may be very small. The question of visas for 1 i
delegates to Iran was raised by Dalal. ,
Demography was the overriding concern of the 5WZC i ;•
delegates to Iran was raised by Dalal. _____
Guzder noted that the 1991 census figures had not yet bi
declared. The BPP has employed Ms Katy Shroff to work o
detailed socio-economic survey of the community nationwi
the cost of which over the next few years would exceed Rs
lakhs. Guzder noted that he was personally committed to do
would contribute in equal measure. He now urged the Federal
continued on pagt S
ting one lakh rupees each for 1995 and 1996 and that the IBOOKS
f
Enduring cures g
Parinaz Gandhi
Nature's Materia Medica — A Handy Guide on we endeavor through
Prevention and Treatment of Diseases by Rational natural ways of living
Methods by Dr J. M. Jussawalla. Published in
1994 by Popular Prakashan Private Limited, 35-C,
Pandit Madan Mohan Malaviya Marg, Tardeo,
Bombay 400034. Pp: xvi+379. Price: Rs 450.
“Some books are to be tasted, others to be bid encumbrances and
swallowed, and some few to be chewed disease taints which
and digested. ” This quote by Bacon, car- furnish the soil for the
ried in Nature’s Materia Medica prepares development and mul-
the reader for the morsels of information tiplication of disease
. . „ . . „ •--------J
the book. The thera
peutic measures he would recommend are
and rational methods
of treatment to purify
the organism of the
systemic waste, mor-
co
philosophy and a practice fol
lowing definite physical, mental
and spiritual laws for restoration
and maintenance of health and the
correctioirr of bodily disorders
without the use of poisonous drugs, ”
Ofttimes palliatives worsen the prob-
that will come his way in the course of this germs, ” it i^ stated in
379-page book. And since nature cure
believes in treating the cause of the disease .
rather than its symptoms, not surprisingly fasting, natural diet, massage, hjdro-
the maximum number of pages (95) are f
devoted to the section on the alimentary osteopathy and chiropractic treatment,
tract which is believed to be the seat of mental and emotional equilibrium.
many diseases. The 88-year-old author. Dr
Jehangir M. Jussawalla, who is the recipi
ent of the Dhanwantari Award and has
written 11 other books on health and diet
states in this tome, “Many are the tonsils he sums up. The lymphatic constitution is
and many the teeth that have been sacri
ficed in looking for the root of infection
should have received the attention. ” and circulatory disorders; and the neuro- is also beneficial not only for constipation
Covered under “Diseases of the Ali- pathic constitution is inclined towards ner- but for cleansing the system, diluting the
mentary Tract ” are diverse problems from vous troubles. blood and wishing out poisons. To
common indigestion and constipation, to The fundamental cure therefore lies in indigestion the person should be taught to
diabetes and ulcers and obesity. Failing raising the vitality, purifying the blood and empty
eyesight too finds a mention here as the
right type of food is responsible for good -. . .
eyes. According to Jussawalla the sense of material through elimination. A cold is
sight is the most abused of all man ’s facul- ’
ties and it wouid be “no exaggeration to
say 1 . . -
nowadays suffer from defective eyesight. ”
therapy, exercise; sun and air baths, lem. “Drug laxatives taken s^ trustingly
and innocently by thousands for the cor
rection of acute bowel sluggishness is one
____ ___ _______ ______ of the most productive sources of our
tion the predominance and combination of chronic cases of constipation. It can in-
which determine the ailments to which stead be prevented, we are told, by a diet of
different individuals will be susceptible, figs, prunes, raisins, apricots, spinach and
other greens, whole grain cereal products,
wholemeal bread, tomatoes, honey, mo
lasses and other fruits, all of which have a
There are three basic types of constitu-
*
inclined towards gland troubles, skin dis
eases, tuberculosis; the acidic constitution
is prone to rheumatism, diabetes, cardiac laxative effect. Regular,drinking of water
and circulatory disorders; and the neuro- ’ ’ ' ———-
pathic constitution is inclined towards ner
vous troubles.
The fundamental cure therefore lies in
__ _ _____ _ _ ______ _ _________ ‘ usually being 316 hours) by lying on the
matter and removing the waste and morbid right side, thus lowering the discharging
\ end of the stomach and bringing gravity to
considered a cleansing process whereby the^aid of the weakened organ,
the body eliminates systemic refuse. “Do
that above 90 percenfof people not attempt to suppress a cold, ” warns
___ „„„„„ " Jussawalla. The chief causes of a cold as
Among the organs in the human anatomy listed by Jussawalla are: overeating, die-
the most abused is the colon, believes the
author. He traces the problem of constipa
tion to “the civilized colon (which) has
become a cesspool instead of being a sew
erage system. ”
As naturopaths “we do not endeavor to
‘kill the germs ’ with poisonous drugs, . .....
vaccines, serums and antitoxins, but instead veteran practitioner, is an art, science, a
lymph streams, or breaking up the waste
That most humans don ’t control their
food intake is known. That food is ram
pantly adulterated is also known. To
indicate the extent of adulteration and its
consequent ailments we are given
Mwv. _____ ____ ____________ instances of common favorites that can
ing, deficient skin activity, insufficient cause cancer: the yellow jalcbi contains
tetic errors like excess of starch, sugar or
both, constipation, inadequate water drink
exercise, fresh air and deep breathing, metanil yellow, a coal tar dye, the glowing
wearing of excess clothing and being con- yellow turmeric powder has lead chromate
fined too much in dry and superheated causing anemia, paralysis and sometimes
quarters. Naturopathy, as defined by the abortion; the tempting pink papad has
--=----- 1 Rhodamine-B; mustard oil is adulterated
41 Parsiana April 1995
bwith motor oil and diesel oil.
A high fiber vegetarian diet will de
crease the likelihood of cancer of the stom-
ach and rectum, advocates the naturopath prosperity
who also cautions realistically that “some
dietary pundits go a little too far in assuring
that dietary change alone can offer cure for
cancer (and) similarly some consider that
bowel wash is specific for cancer. Not a
rational approach in any case, ” says the
veteran practitioner who in 1938 founded
the Natural Therapy Clinic in Bombay and
has served as member on the health panel
of the Planning Commission and as ad
viser on nature cure to the Government of
India.
If seeking an answer to obesity —which
affect the eyesight. Overweight persons
are said to be more 1
diabetes, a disease associated with
Many of humanity ’s aches and pains
Certain proofing and editing errors sur-
* • . --- -»
heeling ” power is described as a divine
WViKHV p/iOVUU —---I----- /» • *V
likely candidates for face in the book where for instance the
____“hooiinrt” ru-«wAr is Hftscrihed HS a divine
“The civilized
colon has become
a cesspool instead
of being a sewerage
system ”
gift. Even then the plethora of facts should f
<< ____fnA *
serve as “a standard text book on the
practice of nature cure for students and
training centers, ” as reads the introduction
is «i^tS wl*:^ “coid wi ” - patience, are traced to the three overs and two unders:
perwverance and moderation are the three “In this age of mechanization, j^p e are mg
key words. Not appetite suppression but over-rested, over-fed, over-stimulated,
omission of white sugar and starches for under-developed ^d under-disciplined,
some time can help reduce the problem. When dealing with aches and pains the
we are told. Overweight persons are also author explains that the site ot the pain
advised to sleep less (growth takes place may be different from the cause of origin,
during sleep); increase physical activity e.g. pain over the liver may indicate a
by being more on “the heels than the diseased organ, but pain at the top and back
wheels; ” reduce fluid and salt intake to of the right shoulder may also be due to
avoid a waterlogged condition; and divide liver disease or congestion. Similarly m
the day ’s ration into 45 percent for the hip-joint disease there may be no pam
breakfast, 30 percent for lunch and 25
percent for dinner. Complete absence of
butter or oil in the diet for a long time could are served by the same nerves.
some time can
advised to sleep less (growth takes place may be different from the cause of origin,
r . . _i ________________________ livAr mav innmatft a
of the right shoulder may also be due to
in the joint while there may be severe pain
in the knee. This is because both the joints causes are
on the jacket. “There is a wealth of infor- |
mation for the layman also on how to
maintain health and prevent disease, ” im- |
parting knowledge on certain vexing prob- |
lems, by elaborating at length on the symp- I
toms, causes and treatment for each dis- |
ease. The guidelines summarizing every |
ailment would be of use to those who want
to be spared from the details. However, a
mere passing reference to certain ailments
like the foot-and-mouth disease and sleep-
¦ J sickness leaves the reader groping for
more light.
In his introduction to the book Jussa-
walla cites the 1921 report of the president
of the Rockefeller Foundation which states
that the fundamental delusion of the medi
cal profession is that “it makes a living
from diseases while the real scientific ap
proach to the problem of human welfare is
through their prevention. ” Not all the lines
of treatment advocated in the book can be
practised by the patient himself but if the
------ —> studied serifeusly many of
humanity ’s woes may be eliminated.
S'
1’
lit
THE DINA
Bai Dhunmai & Cawasji
Dadabhoy Sanatorium Trust
C/o; D. Cawasji & Co., N M Wadia
Building, 123 Mahatma Gandhi Road,
Bombay 400023
Where only
the best will do
*
‘(IS,
Contact:
Bombay: Mehta 2024005,
Nayyar 6040298
Mahabieshwar: Jal/
Mehemooz (02168) 60246
SflMAM,
Dina Hotel,
Mahableshwar 412806
tcmTs
- t Sohrab Jeejeebhoy Divecha
(^5), 64, Belle View, 85,
Warden Rd, 400036; March 11
1 Jolly Cowasji Doctor (75), 799,
Minoo Mans, Jame Jamshed
Rd, Parsi Clny, Dadar, 400014;
March 11
’ Behroz Phiroz Motiwalla (69),
R/1, Nowroz Baug, Lalbaug,
400012; March 11
Khudabux Rustom Atashband
(73), 2/1, Ramodiya Mans, Opp
Century Bazar, Worli, 400025;
March 12
; Rus turn Merwanji Baxter (81),
28/29, Sneh Sadan, Opp Colaba
Post Office, Colaba, 400005;
March 12
Najamai Phiroze Homavazi
(85), Widows ’ Chawl, Modi St,
Fort, 400001; March 12
T Arnavaz Aderji Gandhi (15),
Old Petit Mans, Sleater Rd,
400007; March 13
Noshir Phirozshaw Chiniwalla
(73), 16/1, Bomanji Kassinath
Bldg, Kashinath St, Tardeo,
400034; March 14
Hilla Homi Elavia (86), China
Bldg No 5, Carpenter St,
Mazgaon, 400010; March 14
Daulatbai Khodadad Irani (98),
18, Sunita, Opp Colaba Post
Office, 400005; March 14
Zer Adi Irani (72), 693, Dr
Dinshaw Master Rd, Parsi Clny,
Dadar, 400014; March 14
Soli Dinshaw Tata (74), F/5,
Shapur Baug, V. P. Rd, 400004;
March 14
Khodadad Rustom Irani (63),
T/15, Cusrow Baug, S. B. Rd,
400039; March 15
Jamshed Savakshaw Mistry
(70). F. S. Parukh
Dharamshalla, 34, Hughes Rd,
400007; March 15
Darab Pallonshah Nanavati
(S6), H/38, Cusrow Baug, S. B.
Rd, 400039; March 15
! Tehmina Darabshaw Oomrigar
(S9), 668, Katrak Rd, Wadala,
400031; March 15
Sheriar Behram Tirandaz (75),
D/804, Jai Bhagwati, Dr
Ambedkar Rd, Dadar, 400014;
March 15
Homi Phirozsha Choksey (85),
2, Sethna Bldg, Khan Est,
Chhotani Rd, Mahim, 400016;
March 16
Dali Jamshedji Doriawalla
(61), Rtisi Mehta Bldg, Dinbai
Petit St, Grant Rd, 400007;
March 16
Goola Ratanshaw Mehta (80),
E/41, Jer Baug, Dr Ambedkar
Rd, 400027; March 16
Dina Sorabji Pesina{S2),
31/28-A, Takshila, Mahakali
Caves Rd, Andheri (E), 400093;
March 16
,: Soona Merwanji Mowjee (85),
Sethna Mans, Near 10th Lane,
Khetwadi Back Rd, 400004;
March 17
.Jehangir Jamshed Tarapore
(81), 878, Bootee St, Poona,
411001; March 17
Bapoo Burjorji Mama {JQ),
Bel-Air Sanatorium, Dalkith,
Panchgani, 412805; March 18
Jal Manekshaw Merchant (90),
Mon Repos, H. K. Bhabha Rd,
Bandstand, Bandra, 400050;
March 18
Phiroje (Phiroze) Nariman
Behramfram (75), 20,
Dhanjibhoy Bldg, Lady
Pochkhanawala Rd, Off N. B.
Marg, 400007; March 19
Homi Burjorji Frac is (15), 55,
Maharshi Karve Rd, 400002;
March 19
Phiroze Bomanji Bhesania (74),
C/o Daulat B. Bhesania, 679,
Kildiana Bldg, Katrak Rd,
Wadala, 400031; March 20
Dali Dossabhai Gai (65), 621,
Dubash Bldg, % Homavazir Rd,
Parsi Clny, Dadar, 400014;
March 20
Fall Dhunjisha Jesia (69), 191,
Jesia Bldg, lame Jamshed Rd,
Parsi Clny, Dadar, 400014;
March 21
Ardeshir Dadabhoy Revilna
(94), 66C, Motiwala Bldg,
Gow alia Tank Rd, 400026;
March 21
Banoo Minocher Choquri
(Javizian) (72), 682/B,
Khareghat Rd, Parsi Clny,
Dadar, 400014; March 22
Aspi Khodabaksh Irani (42),
5, Devidas Mansion, Balaram
St, 400007; March 22
Framroze Ardeshir Rabady
(83), Khushnuma Apts,
Carmichael Rd, 400026;
March 22
Maneck Cowasji Kutar (88),
Shirin Manzil, Balaram St,
Grant Rd, 400007; March 23
‘ Behram Jamshedji Karanjia
h
I
i-
fc
f
44 Parsiana April 1995
J
I
i'
I
r
(82), 1 -B, Tata Mills Co-op Hsg F
Soc, Elphinstone Rd, Parel,
400012; March 24
’ 1 Rustomji Mistry (86),
B -11, Tardeo Chmbs, Kashinalh
St, Tardeo, 400034; March 24
Parin Rustom Nagarwalla (90),
2, Scheherazade, Off Arthur
Bunder Rd, Colaba, 400005;
•i-
r
«Dhobitalao. 400002; April 20
Nergish Minoo Sethna (87),C
162, Jivanji Mistry Bldg,
Khetwadi Back Rd, 400004;
April 20 ,
Mani LimDumasia (71), 738, '
Shirin Villa, Dr Ghanti Rd,
Parsi Clny, Dadar, 400014;
April 23 .
Faredoon Sheriar Irani (65).,-
B. Avabai Petit St, Balaram
St. 400007; April 23
Jal Ardeshir Bahadurji {15).
Botawalla Bldg, Raghavji Rd,
400036; April 24
Hormusji Nusserwanji
Madraswalla (95), C/o Maku P.
Motiwalla, Joshi Hse, Cumballa
Hill Rd, A. K. Marg, 400036;
April 24
Hilla Noshir Bisni (68), A/4,
Cusrow Baug, S. B. Rd,
400039; April 25
Jamshedji Phirozshaw Desai
(86), 238, Mulla Hse, Dr
Cawasji Hormasji St,
Dhobitalao, 400002; April 25
Furrokh Ratansha Hataria (68),
R/11, Nowroz Baug, Lalbaug,
400012; /^ril 25
Dhunmai Ardeshir.Adrianwfilla A v
{10), F. S. Parukh
Dharamshalla, 34, Hu^es Rd,
400007; April 26
Minoo Nadirshaw Sidh\/a (87),
Pemino North, Altamount Rd,
400026; April 26
Freny Sorabji Bharucha (69), -
M/41, Cusrow Baug, S. B. Rd,
400039; April 27
Khodadad Merwan Irani (70), ’
1/4 A, New Dubash Bldg,
Gamadia Clny, Tardeo, 400007;
April 27
Dhun Dinshaw Patel (72), C/o
Jamshed K. Fatakia, 406, Vijay.
Apts, Ceasar Rd, Amboli,
Andheri (W), 400058; April 27 <
Rutty Eruchshaw Sanga (84),
B, Siddick Ebrahim Mans,
Lamington Rd, 400007;
April 27
Jerbai Dhunjishaw Anklesaria .
(82), 15, Irani Dharamshala,
Pandita Kamalabai Rd,
Gamdevi, 400007; April 28
Keki Ardeshir Ghadiyali (76),
794, Family Hse, Parsi Clny,
Dadar, 400014; April 28
Faramroz Sorabji Patel (85),
B, Wassiamul Bldg, Grant
Rd, 400007; April 28
Khorshed Peshotan Mama
(89), 667, Lady Jehangir Rd,
Parsi Clny, Dadar, 400014;
April 29
Shirin Kaikhushru Motafram
Near Tata Power Hse, Borivali
(E). 400066; April 10
Shera Sohrab Dubash (78), ’
kl29, Jer Baug, Dr Ambedkar
Rd, Byculla, 400027; April 12
Zizuiz Rohinton M unde gar (40),
A/6. Shakti Sadan, Falkland Rd.
400007; April 12
Rusi Jehangir Palia (75), S/7,
Cusrow Baug, S. B. Rd,
400039; April 12
Mehemosh Jehanbux Kapadia
(44), Sector 8, Plot No 45.
G-Lane, Vashi, New Bombay.
400703; April 13
Arnavaz Pesi Siganporia (54),
E/11, Jer Baug, Dr Ambedkar
Rd, Byculla. 400027; April 13
Homai Minocher Billimoria
(86), 6, Narielwala Bldg. M. M.
C. Rd, Mahim, 400016;
April 15
Tehmina Cooverji Daroowalla
(71). Dharamraj, Mith Chowki.
Marve Rd, Malad (W), 400064;
April 15
Dhunmai Manecksha
Tarapcrevala (89), 1/4, Sir
Ratan Tata Bldg, S. V. Rd,
Bandra, 400050; April 16
MinooJamshedji Dover (69),
D-19, Jer Baug. Dr Ambedkar
Rd. Byculla, 400027; April 17
Manek Rustamji Got la (88),
J-22, Cusrow Baug, S. B. Rd,
400039; April 17
Homai Kersasp Avasia (13),
625, Nariman Hse, Dhobi
Talao, 400002; April 19
Kaikhushroo Jamasji Baria
{95), 10/G2, Shapur Baug, V. P.
Rd, 400004; April 20
Tehmina Munchershaw
Bhumgara {9S), 623, Marker
Mans, Parsi Clny, Dadar,
Bhagwagar (stillborn), Nibbana
Hsg Soc, Pali Hill, Bandra,
400050; April 2
Bana Eruch Mistry (72), The
Reward, Tardeo Rd, Tardeo,
400007; April 3
Edulji Nusserwanji
Tumboowalla {31), 51, Mehr-
Dad, Cuffe Parade, Colaba.
400005; April 3
Kavasji Meherjibhai Suntoke
{35), \I2K, Tata Mills Co-op
Hsg Soc, Elphinstone Rd. Parel,
400012; April 4
Gool Merwan Hakim {13),
Firuz-Ara, Churchgate
Reclamation, 400020; April 5
Dhunjishaw Framroze Mistry
(81). B. Sanjana Bldg, Forjett
Hill Rd. 400036; April 5
Dinyar Sorabji Mistry (86),
10/5, Wadia Block. Malcolm
Baug, Jogeshwari (W), 400102;
April 5
Freny Minoo Mistry {60), 18,
Sai Darshan, Kemps Comer,
400036; April 5
Khushnoor Emmanuel
Shailendra (33). 1, Wadia Bldg.
Malcolm Baug, Jogeshwari
(W), 400102; April 5
Rohinton Adarbad Bharucha
{59), 3!A, Tardeo Chmbs,
Kashinath St, Tardeo, 400034;
April 6
Dolly Fardoonji Kuka (65), B/3,
Jer Baug, Dr Ambedkar Rd,
Byculla, 400027; April 6
Feroz Merwanji Gazdar (80),
303/D-33, MIG Clny, Bandra
(E), 400051; April 7
Maneck Phiroze Mistry (64),
808. Asha Hse. Dr Ambedkar
Rd, Dadar T.T., 400014; April 7
Adi Sorabji Bharucha (80),
Taher Bldg. Jalbhai St, Rajaram 400014; AprU 20
Mohan Rd, 400(X)4; April 8
Jehangir Mahiar Irani (59),
Malegaonwalla Bldg No 2,
M. M. Chotani Rd, Mahim,
400016; April 9
Soonamai Dhunjishaw
Jasoomaney (90), 14, Manekji
Petit Bldg, Marzban Clny,
Gilder Lane. Lamington Rd,
400008; April 9
Boman Hormusji Mistry (84),
E-12, Captain Clny, Tardeo,
400034; April 9
Baheramji Dorabji Charna
March 24
Arnavaz Ardeshir Vakil (80),
Bellevue, Bandstand, Bandra.
400050; March 24
Soona Fall Jilla (60), 46/B,
Gowalia Tank Bldg, Gowalia
Tank Rd, 400036; March 26
Ketty Pervez Wadia (71).
M/3/6, Tata Hsg Centre.
Lalubhai Park Rd. Andheri (W),
400058; March 26
Roshan Rumi Dastur (51),
513, Bombay Market,
Tardeo, 400034; March 27
Homai Sorabji Giara (15), 10,
Gool Mhl, Naushir Bharucha
Rd, 400007; March 27
Raru Nariman Khajotia (80),
Toddywalla Chawl, Sun Mill
Rd, Lower Parel (W), 400030;
March 27
Homai Jehan Tamboowalla
(67). 637, Le Repos, Parsi Clny.
Dadar, 400014; March 27
Jamshed Nadir Batliwalla (58),
13/1, Malegamwalla Bldg,
Station Rd, Mahim, 400016;
March 28
Hosang Sorabji Billimoria (65),
1-A, Green Fields, S. V. Rd,
Santacruz (W), 400054;
March 28
Merwan Dinshaw Hakim (87).
Firuz-Ara, Madam Cama Rd,
Churchgate Reclamation,
400020; March 28
Shiavux Khusru Sethrui (74),
11-A, Cuffe Parade, Colaba,
400005; March 29
Jaloo Jehangir Kapadia (15),
693, Dr Dinshaw Master Rd,
Parsi Clny, Dadar, 400014;
March 30
Banoo Maneckshaw Poonawala
(90), B-41. Bina Apts, Sir M. V.
Rd, Andheri (E), 400069;
March 30
Eruchshaw Manchershaw
Wellington (80), 0/16, Dalal
Est, Lamington Rd, Bombay
Central, 400008; M^ch 31
Dinshaw Jehangir CEo^y ’
(66), Nicholson Bldg, Wadia St,
Tardeo, 400034; April 1
Naju Jamshed Daruwalla (66), ’
14/3, Sir Ratan Tata Clny.
Tardeo, 400034; April 1
Mehru Homi Dharwar (75), -
Sagar Tarang, 46, Bhulabhai
Desai Rd, 400026; April 1 ,
Perin Sorab Gazdar (63), 11/B, f i (91L 32, Aderbad, Hughes Rd,
lllava Bldg, Mori Rd, Mahim,
400016; April 1
Rusi Jehangir Mistry (72), 9/16, Burjor Bldg, Wa^dia St, Tardeo,
Tala Clny, Tardeo, 400034;
April 1
Baby of Nargis Mehemosh .
.1
400007; April 10
Jehanbux Bomanji Gandhi (83),
400034; April 10
Gool Phirozshaw Jesung {15),
Sai Sapiarishi Co-op Hsg Soc,
Jer Burjore Burjorjee {^2),
12-A/B, Meherina, Off Nepean
Sea Rd, 400036; April 20
Framroze Siavax Chandana
(85), Al, Malcolm Baug,
Jogeshwari, 400102; April 20
Homai Dins haw Daruwalla
{i3), B/5, Botawalla Bldg,
Tardeo Rd, 400007; April 20
Roshan Bomi Irani (72), Nav
Hse, 14 B Rd. Khar (W),
400052; April 20
Pirojbai Editlji Karanjia (84),
, 174, Mody St, Opp Fort Market,
Fort, 400001; April 20
. Khurshed Jamshedji Pakka
(63), D-28/2, Godrej Hill Qrts,
L. B. S. Marg, Vikhroli (W),
400079; April 20
Faredoon Havroz Pavri {12);^
Mahavir Mans, 70, Trinity St,
45 Parsiana April 1995
hi
*
I(82), 2, Godrej Bldg, Contractor
Baug, Mori Rd, Mahim,
400016; April 29
Homai Pheroze Shroff (i2), ,
GH, Cusrow Baug, S. B. Rd,
400039; April 29
Meherji Mancherji Vakil (81),
Hira Manzil, Gilder Lane,
400008; April 29
Freni Sorabji Chapkhanawalla
(69), P/18, Nowroz Baug,
Lalbaug, 400012; April 30
CALCUTTA
Born
A girl, Tashya, to Trista and
Cyrus Madan; March 13
Married
Lisa M. Mehta and Varun
Shukla: December 12, 1994
Died
Burjor Phirozeshaw Balsara
(9Q), March 3, 1995
Nergish Behram Batliwala,
sister of late Behram, Kershasp
and Jal; April 18
Adi Pirojshah Balsara (11),
husband of Dipti and father of
Shenas; April 19
DEOLALI
Died
Fredoon Bavaadum;
December 6,1994
JABALPUR
Born
A boy, Hoshedar, to Jasmine
and Jal Engineer, April 10, 1995
JAMSHEDPUR
Born
A boy, Nekshad, to Jasmine and
Percy Irani; October 9, 1994
A girl, Pallavi, to Behroz and
Kayomarz Shroff; December 25
A boy, Zurwan, to Maharukh
and Mediomah Patel;
January 28, 1995
A boy, Danesh, to Rukshana
and Homyar Cardin; March 3
POONA
Died
Aspandiar Bomanji Kaikohadi
(Irani) (83), 5, Mody Clny,
Synagogue St, 411001;
March 2
Gulnar Faredun Irani (72), 3/3,
Ardeshir Irani Baug, Ardeshir
Irani Rd, 411002; March 9
Jal Jehangir Patel (79), Divine
Ter, 913/914, Synagogue St,
411001; March 14
Lal Sohrab Irani (72), 4,
East St, 411001; March 16
Jehangir Ardeshir Irani (75),
1/2, Ardeshir Baug, Nana Peth,
411002; March 19
Berzis Behram Shahbadi (32),
900, Boottee St. Pune 411001;
March 21
Najamai Bejanji Bharucha (82),
872, Dastur Meher Rd, 411001;
March 23
Rustom Kekobad Batliwala
(87), 1, Salisbury Apts,
Salisbury Park, 411001;
March 24
Phirozeshah Cawasji Avasia
(88), Devika Apts, Camp,
411001; April 10
Alamai Ardeshir Chindhey (85),
854, Dastur Meher Rd, 411001;
April 13
Rusi Fall Rabadi (48), Pleasant
Park, Hadapsar, 411028;
April 18
Zarine Rusi Rabadi (41),
Pleasant Park, Hadapsar,
411028; April 18
Dinshawji Pestonji Jalnawala
(73), Hermes Apts,
Bhavanipeth, 411002; April 20
Jerbanoo Mehranji Major (80),
Tulsidas Apts, D. M. Rd,
411001; April 29
Phiroz C. Boomla (72), Viman
Ngr, 411001; April 30
Sorab Rustomji Dubash (86),
Pushpanjali Apts, Gidney Park,
411001; April 30
SHIRDI
Died
Homi P. Dady-Barjor (Homi
Baba) (84); April 6
SURAT
Died
Motaji Adarji Mandviwala (78),
Wadi St, Rustampura, 395002;
March 2
Hormasji Barjorji Amrolia (81),
12/706, Wankibordi, 395001;
March 5
Lilibai Beharamsha Karma
(80), Malesar St, Rustompura,
395002; March 9
Tehmina Kaikhushroo Dumasia
(82), Palia St, Nanpura, 395001;
March 15
Banubai Darbshaw Bhada
(74), Hira-Parekh Chawl,
Nanpura, 395001; March 20
Nargish Shiavaxshah
Bhagwager (82), Parsiwad,
Sayedpura, 395003; April 7
Dinshaji Darabshaw Bhagvager
(72), Meher Ngr, Adajan Rd,
396445; April 9
Nargish Jalejer Mobedjina (74),
Dasturwad, Navsari, 396445;
April 9
Ami Rustamji Tavadia (67),
Lalgate, 395002; April 11
Ratamai Kawasji Dumasia (74),
Faram St, Rustompura, 395002;
April 21
Shirinbai Jahangirji
Porbandarwala (68), Nariman
Home and Infirmary, Shahpore,
395003; April 23
Hillamai Rustamji Tadiwala
(72), Bharbandwad, Ranitalao,
395001; April 30
***
AUSTRALIA
Adelaide
Born
A boy, Darien, to Taina and
Timmy Pavri, brother to Priya;
March 5
The Telling Figures
The count of births, marriages
and deaths among the Zoroas- taiiy or lus/, me numoer. or j
trian community in Bombay bodi^ cremated showed an in- |
showed a decline in 1994 com- ------- ----- ----- -
pared to the previous year.
Seventy-eight of the 372
marriages were intercommunity
crease by 14 over last year ’s }
tally of eight. Yet, the*data may
have the exhaustive listing from
unions. The prior year there doongerwadi, our knowledge of
V
were 79 intercomtnunity mar
riages out of a total of 403 mar
riages. While the numerical bay, the Chandanwadi cremato-
count of intercommunity mar
riages reduced by one, that of
community marriages dropped
by 30 to give a count of 294 as
versus the 1993 figure of 324.
Hence the percentage of inter
community marriages rose to 21
if calculated as a ratio of inter
community marriages to the to
tal number of marriages
(78:372) and 27 if calculated as
a ratio of intercommunity mar
riages to community marriages
(78:294), The 1993 percentages
were 20 and 24 respectively.
Among the intercommunity mar
riages, it is interesting to note that
there were 44 males who had
married out as versus 34 females, compared to the number erf girls.
This means that males account for 115, where the count was lower
56 percent of intercommunity by 20 from the 1993 figure.
marriages and females, 44.
Thd death count reduced by
77 to give us a figure of 1,018 Born: Boys 133, Girls 115
for 1994 when compared to the
1993 figure of 1,095, the differ
ence between men (513) and
women (505) being a meager
eight. While the number of bod
ies consigned to the dokhma
of
CANADA
Toronto
Born
A girl, Alina, to Farahnaz and
Darius Patel; March 23
Vancouver
Married
Niloufer Balaporia and Rustom
Dubash of Shreveport, Los
Angeles; April 22
KUWAIT
Died
Marazban Contractor;
January 28
PAKISTAN
Karachi
Born
A boy, Meherzad, to Diana
were less by 91 over the 1993
tally of 1087, the number, of
not be accurate Jor though we
those cremated is limited to
only one crematorium in Bom- I
rium, where alone we have ac
cess. I
The birth count which is ob- I
tained from only four hospitals |
in Bombay was 248 which is t
lower by 24 when compared to |
the 1993 count of 272. Ever I '
since the Municipality ceased to I
list religion on the birth certifi-1
cate, there is no way of knowing |
the numbgr of Zoroastrian births
in Bombay. We may assume
that Parsiana’s figures may be
around 50 percent of the total
number of births. From the data
available with us we find that
the number of boys born to the
community, 133, fell by four as
¦f
L
We list below the 1994 fig-|
ures as collected by Parsiana: I
Married: Parsi 294
Intercommunal 78
Died: Consigned Males 501
Females 495
Cremated 22
Males 12, Females 10
I
46 Parsiana April 1995
%and Jehangir Bilimoria-,
December 6,1994
A boy, Fars had, to Neilie and
Hormazd Engineer, December 14
B
TOTALS FOR 1994 AND 1995
C
A B C
A B C
Married
Natasha Baria and Naushad
Mehta-, January 14,1995
BORN
Boys
Girls
A
15
13
133
115
33
30
4
3
13
8
4
2
5
2
35
31
5
3
QATAR
Doha
Born
A boy, Behzaan, to Navaz and
Pesi Bhomisa-, February 9
married
Parsi
Intercommunal
45
294
78''
123
25*
1
16
5
1 2
12
5
2
2
SOUTH AFRICA
Durban
Died
Jer Randeria (64), wife of Dara
and mother of Parvez; March 25
DIED
CONSIGNED
Males
Females
CREMATED
Males
Females
77
67
501
495
159
145
19
16
l^
2)^
34
28
1
1
37*
30*
2
6
12
10
2
USA
Augusta, Georgia
Born
A boy, to Deborah and Kersi
Bharucha-, March 31
A; Total numbers in this issue
B; Running totals tor 1994 (February-March 1994-April 1995 issues)
C Running totals for 1995 (February-March 1995-April 1995 issues)
* Males married out in 1994 ” 44
Females married out in 1994 - 34
• Overseas deaths are listed in the consigned column as
cremated.
Houston
Born
A girl, Shayan, to Ava and
Noshir Bharhena-, March 16
Compiled by Roxana A. Driver
•Males married out in 1995 -- 12
Females married out in 1995 -- 1J
Pa rs ia na does not have any breakup ol those
*
With Best Wishes
from
Mr Rusy M. Shrofif,
M.B.E.
and
Mrs Purviz R. Shrofif
1
?7 ParsianaAprill995
IJ
the Zoroastrian female as guaranteed in tressed by the “great deal of misinformation j
other matters by the Indian constitution. “
The DPA, that bastion of liberal Zoro
astrian practice in India, had invited a
number of Parsi ladies married outside the that will bring out our heritage. “We need ’
community to participate in the pro- a global view...In all yashts we say ‘May ;
ceedings. Noted Katy Hussain (nee Nazir), our religion spread to all corners of the :
“When the community is dwindling, you
should win us back, not push us away.
When you call me an apostate, it doesn ’t
make me feel very good. ” Phiroza Singh bers, anything dogmatic and not relevant j
to the changing times should be avoided, ” i
advised industrialist Sorab Godrej. “Even
in China, Muslims are allowed more chil
dren because they are in the minority; a
Catholic community like France only rec
ognizes civil marriages — the religious t
in published word and lectures on Zoroas
trianism. ” She suggested that a team get to i
work on a Zoroastrian manual, something
earth, ’ and we say 'Manayoavayadshodan
(May it be so).
“If the main concern is dwindling num-
»»»
THE FEDERATION REVIEWS...
continued from page 40
ting one lakh rupees each for 1995 and
1996 and that the BPP would contribute in
equal measure. He now urged the
Federation members to contribute in
proportion to their population and income.
Khullar, a member of the committee set
up to monitor the project, affirmed the
need to collect as much data as possible so
as to get a total community picture. Once
the complete data is in, it could be updated (nee Satarawala), who is the only Parsi in
from year to year, she noted. “At the mo
ment there are wild assumptions that edu
cational levels are falling, that the rich are
bearing (fewer) children and the poor bear- affect their rights to inherit property from
ing more, etc. (We need) the fertility his
tory of women in the reproductive age-
group, ” she added. in Delhi on March 19: “I want to know discrimination should be encouraged bet- |
To objections from members regarding whether I’d be doing the right thing if I ween men and women... Our people don ’t f
poor response from the community, Khullar takemy daughter to an agiary in Bombay. ”
advised persistence and also the coverage
of mixed marriages: “Get them in. In 1985
40 percent of Delhi ’s Parsis were married
out. If we leave (them) out, our data won ’t anjuman functions). We only hope that a
be complete. ” The four-page questionnaire percolating effect will take place. A lady noted, “You can ’t force someone to prtxiuce ;
is totally objective, she added. i
Sethna urged word of mouth motivation, mother ’s muktads . The (husband) sits out-
“Tell them it is not for income tax returns , • - ¦
or litigation but for community survival. ”
Ginwalla suggested that a Gujarati ques- both the boy and girl to be Parsi. It ’s a tribal And in a gesture besp^Udng classic
tionnaire be circulated where the people feeling; it makes for easier adjustment democracy (or rabid one-upmanship) an
~ within the community, ” said noted mana- eight-year-old lad admonished the gather
gement consultant Aspi Moddie (who) has ing for failing to stand to attention when
two children married out. “I was present at
the navjote of my granddaughter in Aus
tralia. TTie priest is married to a Dutch lady
Simla, tends the aramgah there. She said,
“Our children should be accepted. ” But
she also wondered how such a step would
I
the HUF (Hindu undivided family). Perin
Das was planning on her daughter ’s navjote ceremony is not compulsory ...No religious I
in Delhi on March 19: “I want to know discrimination should be encouraged bet- I
know enough about our own religion and I
Sethna was ever hospitable: “As far as heritage. ” ;
Delhi is concerned, not only your child,
but your husband is welcome (to the
Adil Nargolwala whose father, the late }
Shiavax Nargolwala had steered a liberal f
course as the DPA’s president for 26 years, t
married to a Swiss comes here for her kids. If the community is dying let my t
~ (Tibetan) wife jedn the community — and j
anyone else who wants to... Excommuni
cate the priests who try to get people out! ” j
side. We hope one day he too can come in. ”
“All of us Parsi parents would prefer
both the boy and girl to be Parsi. It ’s a tribal
are not sufficiently conversant with Eng
lish.
the agiary bell sounded the changing of
the gah\
r-"'
V
Open session
An open session devoted to keeping the
community together and inculcating inter- (who) was (quietly) reciting the prayers of Among those attending the Federation
the navjote to herself...We are living in the meeting were Hoshang and Porus Debara
modern age of science... Is this exclusivity from Agra; Areez Khambatta and Porus t.
humane and just? Does it make people Karanjawalla from Ahmedabad; Dr A. E. |
happier or does it create more suffering? ” Contractor and R. J. Bodhanwalla from I
According to Dr Ali “Decline of a re- Ajmer; Capt Homi Dandiwalla from Alla- »
J
J
faith solidarity was flagged off by Khullar:
“Keeping the community together is very
closely related to keeping the community
alive. (It is) our predominant preoccupa
tion... ” She spoke of the “listlessness that
makes meaningful solutions impossible, ligious or cultural group indicates that habad; Sarosh Ginwalla from Bharuch; B
our inability to produce babies, our failure something has gone wrong with its moral Jamshed Guzder, Ms-^illoo Kavarana and ¦
Rustom Anklesaria from Bombay; Khur-
shed Pastakia from Borivli; Adi Rabadi
from Calcutta; Darius Marshall from Cali- fe
to garner the best specialized brains for and ethical values. ” He noted that groups
(the good of) the community...Once a cer- of interested people were going from door
tain group of people accept certain family to door telling Muslims in India that the
and childbearing practices, it ’s almost children be given proper training...Every
impossible to reverse. ” system of law is meant to serve the com-
Retired secretary to the Government of munity, (must be) adjusted to the exigen- Brig Adi Sahukar, Yazad Kapadia, Farrokh
India ’s law ministry Rustom Gae wel
comed the Wadia navjote as “an important
change...a worthy precedent for the fu
ture. ” Noting that BPP trustees are akabars, viewpoint noted how the Jews attach more Zoroastrian Anjuman; Ronnie Dick from
“leaders of the community whose views importance to the mother. If a male Jew Jhansi; Nariman Mogrelia from Madras;
should be applicable to all Indian anju- marries outside the community their child- Farokh Irani, Eruch Irani, Sarosh andNavaz
mans, ” Gae urged that a logical sequence
should be the acceptance of the children of converts to Judaism after passing the Sohrab Katpitia and Jamshed Dotiwala
Parsi mothers if both parents agree to the requisite tests. from Surat; Homi Mehta from Zai Bordi
navjote. Decrying the “higher rights of
males ” Gae advocated gender equality for Zoroastrian scholarship in Delhi, was dis- was represented by Parsiana.
t
cut; Pervez Irani and Kaizad Irani from
Dahanu; Lt Gen Adi Sethna, Dadi Mistry,
r.
cies of the time. It is essential that it gives Rustomji, Sam Mehta, Homa Mistry and ,
Keki and Homi Gandhi from Delhi; Aspi r
L
up its rigidity... ”
Mr Malikar who presented the Jewish Irani and Dr Syrus Irani from the Iranian
marries outside the community their child
ren cannot be accepted until the mother Palkhivala from Poona; Dr Sam Bhacca, B
Piloo Jungalwalla, high priestess of and special invitee Bejon Dittia. The press
48 Parsiana April 1995
%
◆ ◆ ◆
From the archive
