Complete Issue
Apr 1992
I
APRIL1992RS12
i
¦j.'iS'’
r>'
(
¦5;
BHARAT RATNA JRD TATA
,3.
.<
•5:[ t
April 1992
Volume 14 Number 10
EDITOR Jehangir R. Patel
MANAGING EDITOR Arnavaz S. Mama
EXECUTIVE EDITOR Parinaz M. Gandhi
ASSISTANT EDITOR Roxana A. Mirza
DESIGN Kranti Shilotri, Varghese Fernandez
MARKETING DIRECTOR Veera Patel
ADVERTISING MANAGER Zarin Mistry
ADVERTISING EXECUTIVE Cheryl Sequeira
CHIEF EXECUTIVE Rustom Thanavala
FINANCE B. L Arora
EDP Rohinton E. Daroga
CIRCULATION Behram Umrigar
MANAGEMENT Jasmine Driver
2 Readers' Forum
8 Events and Personalities
13 Zoroastrians Abroad
16 BPP Elections In August by Arnavaz Mama
18 Youth Federation: Plan of Action by Parinaz Gandhi
23 J.R.D. Tata: A jewel in his crown
-----------------—--------------------------- s___
27 Behroz Vacha's Helen Keller Institute... by Gustasp Irani
OFFICE Rajendra P. Nayak,
Khurshid Panthaki, Patricia D'Silva,
Bakhtavar Batliwalla, Nowzer Batliwala,
Bindu Pillai, Sugatha S. Kurup
33 Wedlock's end: 1 by K. C. Vajifdar
35 Books
J
4,
OFFICE ASSISTANTS Umesh Poojary,
Selvan Mark, Sunil Sakhare, Pramod Patil
41 Milestones
46 In Memoriam
Cover: Photograph by Superstar Video Labs
I
Parsiana is published by Jehangir R.
Patel for Parsiana Publications Pvt Ltd, at
C/o H.L.Rochat, Navsari Chambers,
ground floor, 39 A.K.Nayak Marg, Fort,
Bombay 400001 and printed by him at
Kaiser-E-Hind Pvt Ltd, 300
Perin Nariman Street, Bombay 400001.
Covers printed at Malti Art, 320, A-Z
Industrial Estate, Ganpatrao
Kadam Marg, Bombay 400013.
Color processing. Comart Lithographers;
and black and white processing, Samir
Process. All rights reserved.
Phone: 2048730 Fax: 2042922
For editorial enquiries: 2048183
Telex 11-85710 RABO IN
Annual inland subscription Rs 100 for one
year (12 issues); Rs 180 for two years
(24 issues). Foreign subscription rates;
Sea mail Rs 260/US $ 12/UK £ 7 for one
year, Rs 475ZUS $ 20/UK £ 12 for two
years (please allow six months or more
from the time of publication); Air mail
Rs 550/US $ 24/UK £ 14 (for Pakistan,
Indian Rs 290) for one year, Rs 1,050/
US $ 45/UK £ 26 (for Pakistan, Indian
Rs 560) for two years. For Indian upcountry
cheques add Rs 5 for bank charges; for US
cheques add $ 5; for UK cheques add £ 3.
Cheques and drafts are to be drawn
in favor of Parsiana and posted to GPO
Box 892, Bombay 400001
h5
J
)
4
0
READERS’ FORUM
I Ml
vti)
mJiJ
-i::
I U-p-
I u,
II
; “A Zoroastrian in Japan”
The letter “A Zoroastrian in Japan ”
(Readers ’ Forum, Parsiana, February was of this very firm opinion and if the
1992) does not give the full details. I am trustees of the Agiary were asked to inter-
happy to add the following: vene by my family, to permit me admis-
Mr Rustomji Vasunia and Mr Fram- sion to the Agiary for my mother ’s
roze Vasunia started the firm of Messrs prayers, he would refuse to conduct such
Vasunia and Company at Kobe (Japan), prayers and would be ready to resign on
H They were later joined by their two other this score.
I may add that I rarely visit this
family held at the Agiary.
He (the panthaky) reiterated that he
f.
M « « < I « i
» 4 * « « « « »
uBStUhf
««•»«< ?iitl
> I ( 4 o 4 « 1
H<•• •»
.Hlllllfll
Hlhh.ut
hWIF
r’
brothers Mr Pesi and Mr Homi Vasunia.
brothers worked togetho*. They Agiary as I have been residing in Worli
»»¦
Wj
** "St
*»
were all intelligent and hardworking, since my marriage 17 years ago.
Their main business was trading in silk msRoshnianand
piecegoods.
I The Company flourished largely be- ^^Mozart and.
I cause of Framroze and his popular rela- There is a discrepancy in “Mozart and a
I tionship with members of the Silk Mer- Zoroastrian ” (Zoroastrians Abroad, Par-
, chants ’ Association. At that time, it was siana, January 1992). The article based
I an honor to be president of the Silk Mer- on “Mozart and a Zoroastrian ” in the In-
I chants ’ Association and candidates for the formal Religious Meetings ’ (IRM) news-
I office avidly solicited votes in their favor, letter (November-December 1991) has
I Framroze never cared for the presidency, been ascribed to Dorab Patel, retired jus-
I So a delegation of the Association mem- tice of the Supreme Court of Pakistan.
I bers comprising Sindhis, Marwaris and The author of 'the IRM article is Mr
I Gujaratis approached Framroze to be- Dorab J. Patel, a friend of mine who is
come president Framroze thanked them '
and courteously declined this offer. They is a trustee of its fund,
continued to press him, but to no avail.
Unfortunately he channelised his intelli- Arnavaz Mama replies:
gence only in his trading business; he We regret the assumption that there is
»»
closely associated in IRM activities and
VIRASPP. MEHTA
Karachi
Readers' views are welcome on any subject
of interest to the community and should
be sent to the Editor, Readers* Forum,
Parsiana, G.P.O. Box 892, Bombay 400001. ...
Lenars sre subject to editing for reasons of would also have been famous if he had only one Dcrab Patel in Karachi and
space and clarity. Unsigned letters or tIraM applied his mind to the manufacturing in- apologize to both gentlemen.
without ansddress will not be published. HnctriAc
dustries. ,
During World War II, luckUy all the “The Purifying...
brothers were in Bombay. Today, except Ervad Darius N. Sethna in “The Purifying
“Things fall into place” Homi, all the brothers, staff members Prescriptions ” (Readers ’ Forum,
I was delighted to read what Amavaz Phiroze Mehta, Minoo Wadia, Minoo Parsiana, January 1992) calls Dr Ali A.
Mama wrote about Homai Modi (“Things Master, Rusi Billimoria (Dandiwala) and Jafarey a “self jxoclaimed Muslim
fall into place, ” Parsiana, February other Hindu staff members have expired, scholar (whose) motive is to distort, ma-
1992). As a past member of the Young Mr Homi Vasunia and myself from nipulate and convert the Zoroastrian
Collegians ’ Zoroastrian Association the staff are leading an active life though teachings to suit hi& Muslim Iranians...
(YCZA) many years ago, I had very little retired. jEHANGiRM.ENtHNEER and make it acceptable for them to swal-
contact with Homai Modi. Since then I , .
have come to know more about her. What “Safeguarding the rights...
perhaps few know, is her private life and I * _ _ _
JEHANOR M. ENONEER
(Readers ’
low the pill. ”
_ I would say it is our own fault if any-
I In the ^ticle “Safeguarding the rights, thing of this sort is really happening to-
how courageously she turned her misfor- privileges, benefits... ” {Parsiana, January day. Dr A. A. Jafarey is right when he
tune into an opportunity for developing 1992) there is a reference to a recent inci- claims that in Iran nirang is not admini-
her great administrative talent for thb dent I experienced at the Bomanji stered at navjotes or weddings, and I
benefit of her community. - ................ . .......................
For her great faith in her religion and Victoria Gardens in Byculla, Bombay,
a strong belief that “things fall into
place ” I admire her greatly. She put clarify as under:
aside her own personal sorrow and After the 10th day ceremonies of my
plunged into working for others. She has mother ’s demise, the panthaky of the
truly practised her religion. We need Mewawala Agiary, mentioned to my fa- majority community on the minority. In
many more Homai Modis today to show ther to ensure that I do not ever visit this India among the Hindus the cow is sacred
our little community that “practice is bet- agiary in future, whether as a devotee or and drinking bull ’s urine would not be
ter than precept ” MsPareenlalkaka
Merwanji Mevawalla Agiary near don ’t think Mobed R. Shahzadi will be
ready to swallow the pill either and pro-
To put the record right I would like to vide gomez at the ceremonies or stop
signing wedding certificates and perform
ing navjotes in which gomez is not taken.
It is a question of the influence of the
agiary in future, whether as a devotee or
for any future death ceremonies that the looked down upon. In Iran among the
2 Parsiana April 1992
i
i
iand solutions could be studied from all cally. So don t be surprised or blame
oiieivo. . ............- - 1 1^’’™ '''taring the kusti to be-
a^Tcould be included in the council for gin with and replace the sutkeh with the
• - — -- the easily available ‘ganyi (vest). ’
¦ ; In Yazd, from where the majority
multifaceted. of Iranian Zarthushtis come, there is
We should not forget Iran where the only one fire-temple,^ which Js again
origin and history of Zoroastrianism lies.
_______________________ The Muslim population know of their an-
is bom into it by the master'plan of the cestors being ^rc^tti^s and^^®^^
has all the rejjgions included in its mast^
to conversion and even have used coer-
maiority community, the Muslims, urine scriptions, ” Parsiana, October 1991) but two parts; the upper part, the pure one, the
is a^efiler and a person coming in contact if such a council would include scholars, mind, and the lower
with it requires purification. Here you businessman, physicians, engineers, etc it the sexual part, thus he f«ls that the pant
cannot (Ufferentiate, justify and prove that would be more broad based. Problems and shut do the same job more pi^tt-
bull ’s urine, call it nirang, geushmaes- U..1 ;----
mana or gomei, can purify instead of angles. Even those with whom we do not
being a defiler. As it is, non-Muslims are i _
considered untouchable. If you add to it a they could raise their opinions in
urine drinking non-Muslim, it is an odd council and the final solution would be
position to get into. ' ¦*
About conversion Ervad Sethna says
“like one cannot choose one ’s parents,
one cannot choose one ’s religion — one
L vv... —~ .. -------------------r— -
cosmos... ” I think he means the cosmos know about their old religion. Many re-
has all the rejjgions included in its master l
plan, but then all other religions are open Now if you go
to conversion and even have used coer- j
cion for conversion. Thus if we accept books on the Zoroastrian religion wr^ten
interested, sincere converts we would 1,
not be Hisn ipiing the cosmos plan more Dawoud, Hashem Razi, Bohran, Hussain
than other religions but rather we could Vahidi, etc; but no one has translated into
say it is part of the cosmos plan to change Persian what has been written in India or
the t hinkin g of a person, from, for ex- around the world. The Iranian Zarthushti
ample, saying a ‘Doroug-e-maslahati’ (a hears Mobed R. Shahzadi at Porsa cere-
lie for good reason) to saying no lies moniesfindingparallelsandtryingtoex-
'Homato Huktho Havaresth.' .r .u-
I think Dr Jafarey has made a sincere
suggestion regarding the formation of a
Council of Mobeds (“The Purifying Pre- kusti are meant to divide the body into
5
d
-u
considered an 'Asar-e-bastani' (historical
monument) and is partly open to
visitors. The non-Zoroastrian visitors
outnumber us.
______ It is time we change our ways and lode
Sazeman Fravahar beyond the borders. It is time to be cot-
structive. Instead of booing our critics it
is time we find answers and teach them to
gret that their ancestors had given in.
¦* _ I to r "
bookshop in Tehran you will find more
by'" Dr Ali Akbar JafareyT Dr Pour our children. Don ’t just say cosmic plan,
Dawoud, Hashem Razi, Bohran, Hussain full stop. Prove it Today ’s child needs
more reasons than his father. Give them
to him.
In Iran the dokhmas have been closed
down, again because of the Muslim influ-
_ __________ __________ „ e* ’ce. Our people lacked the knowledge
plain things in Fight of what the Muslim to prove that the system had a solid base,
majority believes; he reads in a Persian The walls were often broken into or
book on his religion that the sudreh and climbed and photographs taken to find out
what it is like inside and the dead were
majority believes; he reads in a Persian
MATCH YOUR AMBITION TO A CAREER
To do so we offer you:
# Diploma Course in Business Management (Postal) (IMC)
5!e Banking CAIIB Course (Postal)
5*6 Executive Secretarial Course
3!« Private Secretarial Course
« Personal Assistant’s Programme (Working Stenographers)
? Shorthand & Typewriting (English/Hindi/Marathi)
# Telephone Operating & Receptionist Techniques
Electronic Telex Operating
? Electronic Typewriting & Word Processing
« English Conversation & Writing Skills
LATEST ADDITION: COMPUTERS
J
0
c
>
j
Enquire at:
Sir J. J. College of Commerce
J
0
c
J
Events and
Personalities
Elections in Poona cem Trans Environ Consultants (TEC) Honor for pFOSthodontlSt
Heading the new board of trustees of the manages projects outside the country, the At the World Congress of the Intema-
Poona Parsee Panchayat (PPP) is Dara K. company brochure informs. tional Research Committee of Oral Im-
Irani who will officiate as president for
the year 1992. Thereafter the president ’s
seat will be filled by rotation from
amongst the six other trustees who were
elected to the board on December 5,1991
at the Pudumjee Hall, notes a press re
lease from the PPP.
Working with Irani for the 1992-96 the director of the National Environ-
company brochure informs.
For 14 years Arceivala served as re- plantology (IRCOI) attended by 450 im-
gional advisor for environmental health plantologists from 16 countries. Dr Firoze
with the World Health Organisation ’s D. Mirza was honored with a gold medal.
(WHO) regional office in Europe and also The meet was in Berlin in end November,
officiated as chief of WHO’s South-East as reported in The Afternoon Despatch
Asia region covering 11 countries. Be
fore his stint with WHO, the engineer was
and Courier of December 10,1991.
President of the Indian section of the
IRCOI and founder chairman of the Bom-
term will be trustees Jamshed S. mental Engineering Research Institute bay Society of Oral Implantologists,
Bokdawala, Minoo P. Davierwalla, Marz- (NEERI) in Nagpur. Mirza was reportedly the first to introduce
ban C. Kaikobad, Dr (Ms) Perwin M.
Davierwalla, Boman E. Amaria and Din-
shaw S. Anklesaria.
The 66-year-old environmentalist who dental implantology in 1962 and porce- ’
has authored three books on his subject of lain technology in 1970, according to a
specialization is affiliated with educa- write-up in Mid-Town Musing of January j
tional associations in different comers of 22, 1992. In addition to his appointment j
Environmental award the world. Many a technical institute in
Conservation of water in industry in India Yugoslavia, Turkey, Sri Lanka, Vene- nor or ivianarasnira, jviirza aiso manageu j
and tertiary treatment of municipal sewer- zuela, Muscat, Bangkok and Netherlands the prosthodontic department at the Naif
age is Prof Soli J. Arceivala ’s major con- has Arceivala on its visiting faculty, the Hospital Dental College which Iw had*]
tribution. Master planning of storm water I
drainage and sewer rehabilitation for his bio data mentions. He has also been he accepted professorship at the Govern- |
Greater Bombay is the important World credited with introducing the first post- ' “ ~
Bank funded project of which Arceivala
has been appoint^ co-director. Such out
standing assignments in the field of engi
neering research and design earned Ar
ceivala, the managing director of Associ
ated Industrial Consultants (India) Private partment, further informs his bio data.
Limited (AIC), the Environmental Engi
neering Design Award, 1991, notes the
company ’s January ’92 newsletter. The
award came to him from the Institution of
Engineers (India) at the Indian Engineer
ing Congress in Poona on December 22.
Keeping things environment friendly
is the aim of AIC, a Bombay based con
sultancy company, founded 30 years ago
to specialize in environmental pollution
control work. A team of about 40 profes
sionals work under Arceivala to service
AIC’s major clients which include Hin
dustan Lever, Tata Oil Mills, Rallis India,
Premier Automobiles, Mafatlal, the Inter
national Airports Authority of India, the
Poona Municipal Corporation and the
Punjab Water Supply and Sewerage
Board, amongst others. While AIC ac
cepts assignments in India, its sister con-
as honorary dental surgeon to the Cover- i
nor of Maharashtra, Mirza also managed
has Arceivala on its visiting faculty, the Hospital Dental College which he had*
last one having him for the past 18 years, been heading for the past 25 years. Before j
mental Dental College, Mirza was in the
USA for seven years. When in the States, |
3
graduate program in environmental engi
neering at the Bombay University. At the Mirza qualified for his masters from the
Victoria Jubilee Technical Institute he Tufts University in Boston and later
served as vice president, rector and head served as associate professor in two top J
of the civil and sanitary engineering de- American universities, informs a press re- |
R
American universities, informs a press re
lease from the family.
3
Mirza: researching
dental implantology.
(Left) Arceivala
(in suit) receiving the
Environmental
Engineering
Design Award
8 Parsiana April 1992newable energy resources. He has been the WWF (India). Godrej was instrumen-
Iicwduic ‘vouu. ____ ffca Tn/lion hAaHnnartftrs
vice president of the Energy and Fuel Us
ers ’ Association and has chaired the en-
Presently he is chairman of the Con
tinuous Education Program of the Indi^
Dental Association. He has 62 scientific — --------- - KTofjzxnoi AiUanpp
papers to his credit and has been invited ergy committee of the Nauonal A^i^ce
torture in different cities in Europe, of Young Entrepreneurs, his bio data
USA and the Far East, further reads his notes,
curricuium vitae.
Rajiv Gandhi medalists
The Rajiv Gandhi Gold Medal for Excel
lence in Management was awarded to Ms
Zeenia Lawyer, partner of Associat^
Breweries and Distilleries (ABD) while
the Gold Medal of Merit for Industry was
bestowed on Rusi Engineer, managing di
rector of Induttrial Boilers Limited. The
awards were presented on January 30,
1992, under the aegis of the Special Ey
ecutive Magistrates' Directory Commit
tee, at the hands of Ramrao Adik, minister
for finance. Government of Maharashtra
at a special function at the Indian Mer
chants ’ Chamber.
Hailed as one of the leading woman
entrepreneurs of the country. Lawyer has
guided ABD, the manufacturers of the
popular beer London Pilsner, into achiev
ing the number one slot in Bombay, in
forms the company release. In the fore
seeable future, the businesswoman who is
reportedly the first to inculcate the pub
culture in Bombay, plans to open a chain
of exclusive ‘London pubs ’ in the city.
A well-known figure in the field of Prince Philip
boilers, being the founder member ^d
immediate past president of the Indian
Boiler Manufacturers ’ Association, Engi
neer has now adopted a new manufactur
ing technology. The acute shortage of
fossil fuel has made Engineer opt fw re-
Adik presenting the Rajiv Gandhi gold
medals to Lawyer (left) and Engineer
J
J
3
tai in establishing the Indian headquarters
of the WWF at the Pirojsha Godrej Na
tional Conservation Centre in Lodhi Es
tate, New Delhi. His concern about na
ture conservation is evident at
Pirojshanagar, the Godrej industrial gar
den township in Bombay, which boasts a
. - ---- —
haps the best on the Indian west coast, ” as
_____ ; _ ___ * . In a city like
Bombay where more than 12,5 million
•* _ , •_ J
believes that every tree is a symbol of
I To arouse environment
I consciousness at festival
I time, Godrej has initiated two
I movements: Sarvajanik Holi
I curbs the wanton destruction
i of trees while Sarvajanik
I Diwali marks the occasion as
I the festival of lights rather
I than as a festival of noise, fur-
I ther informs the release.
I Amrapali in London
I F^ty-one shows of the dance
I ballet Amrapali, directed by
I Hosi Mulla, were brok^
I even prior to the premier in
¦ London. The British Broad
casting Corporation (BBC), impressed by.J
the program, shot scenes from the ballet^
and interviewed Mulla along with his |
first of the avians to be taken off the list of partner Mahendra Boricha in Wl.^ |
endangered species in Canada, according same duo was also resj^ible de- j
toaraessreEe. The chairman of the signing and sutching of the costumes^-
Godrej companies who was conferred the cording to a wnte-up m the Jam-e-Jam-
awarf at Buckingham Palace last year has after
a successful running of 40 shows in Lon
don gained popularity in the States where
is
Wildlife benefactor (--------- , - ,,
The White PelicanpMng autographed ofjnMgov^foreste
by Prince Philip was presented to r .
Sohrab Pirojsha Godrej who qualified for notes the press release,
the 25th Anniversary Benefactors Award " ''........
(WWF). The painting of the white peli
can is particularly symbolic for it is the hope,
¦ill 4 B
3 i
from the World Wide Fund for. Nature people live in
Godrej (left) shaking hands with
joined the select band of 25 donors who
have earned this recognition.
Founder trustee and vice president of
10 Parsiana April 1992*
I
«
Students excel in law
The righteous Parsis are always
r known to fight for the right or
I rather their perception of the right.
I Pursuing legal battles with fresh
I fervor will now be a new crop of
F Parsi solicitOTs and lawyers who
L have excelled at different law ex
aminations in the recent past.
; Ms Sanober P. Nanavati was
, reportedly the only candidate from
India to appear and pass the ex
aminations of Solicitor — Eng
land and Wales in November last
year. After she completed her ar
ticles in India, the scholarships
she received from the R, D.
1 Sethna Trust and the Higher Edu-
I cation Committee of the Bombay
I Parsi Punchayet enabled her to
I appear for the examinations
I abroad, notes a press release.
I When a student at Queen Mary
-¦ School, the H. R. College of Com
merce and Economics and the Govem-
Siez Hahnemann, the great great grand- ment Law Collie, Nanavati had won
crtn rif r4r Cnmnoi u.,hnan,nn„ several prizes at'the Bharat Scouts and
Kala Kendra formed in 1975, Mulla has ered the father of homeopathy. Guides competitions, elocution competi-
performed Indian classical and folk I ’ ................... " ~ ’
dances in East Africa, Canada, USA,
Hong Kong, Japan, Korea and Australia ate degree, the press release further in-
besides several places in India.
Starting his dance training at five years
(Clockwise from top left)
homeopath Master,
dentist Mistry and
solicitors Nanavati,
Contractor
and Pardiwala
6
1
i
I
I
Mulla was invited to direct the flav to clcct its rcDresentatives. m April 1992 to enable residents to effect
their transfer, only 3,805 certificates have
notes the Bre^
announcement. The BPP’s response tA
by toe Bombay Parsi Punchayet (BPP) for can vote on any of these days at toe desig
toe general election of 802 members of r.atcd places, ccccrir.g ~ to? , • h tr, ov
the Aniuman Committee. But a further note of June 4, 1992. According m the so iBted are reqm^ to ra-
extension was sought and granted by the
Bombay High Court on June 16. The new
for holding of the Anjuman Committee ^ngle day to el^t its representatives,
elections. The elected Anjuman Commit- -i--
tee members together with 802 donors al
ready on toe Punchayet rolls will then 5.30 p.m.
enrolment on toe BPP’s general register figure now stemds at “4,000 andjxid.'
will be entitled to vote. The register is
required to close on November 30 prior to is
elect (by December 31, 1992, as per the
new court order) trustees to the BPP
board for the next seven years.
For the first time in its long history the
BPP’s elections will be held constituency-
The booths in all the vicinities were
scheduled to be open from 9.30 a.m. to been exchanged,
--Zi,..... 1-__________ _
Only those with valid certificates of an enquiry on June 8 revealed that this
_ « • . /*• _ __ _ I_ A* AM/1 zwizi **
The last day for transfer of certificates
¦! two clear days before the first
each Anjuman Committee election as per election day.
“ the city has been cited as a
The summer exodus from
1
wise. This change has been
necessitated by the large
number of persons who must
be elected. The number of
seats have been distributed
between 11 constituencies
demarcated by the BPP ad
ministration depending on the
demographic distribution of
the community. According to
this distribution, the Fort area
has the maximum represen
tation (see box).
The elections will be held
in five different parts of the
city for the convenience of
Zoroastrians resident in those
areas. The place's earlier des
ignated were the BPP office . , ,
building on D N Road, the Khareghat clause 10(i) of the electoral scheme. In stalled by August 31, 1992 and the elec-
---- - - this case the register is deemed to have tion of the trustees — there are two vacan-
closed on December 17, 1991 when the cies with the terms of Dr Aspi Golwalla
final High Court order cleared the way for and Jamsheed Kanga having expired —
the election which has been delayed by completed by end October 1992.
Electoral distribution into constituencies
Constituency
Denoted by Allocated seats
Colaba
Fort
Kalbadevi
Malabar Hill
Worli
Parel
Dadar
Borivli, Goregaon and Jogeshwari
Bandra and Mahim
Tardeo and Hughes Road
Grant Road
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
74
90
79
71
84
64
81
57
69
79
54
reason for the lack of a
significant number of nomi
nations. According to
Parsiana sources only 80
nominations had been re
ceived by end May.
The trustees also had sec
ond thoughts about holding
the elections in June as origi
nally planned on account of
the rains.
According to the High
Court order of December 17,
1991 which was framed with
due agreement of the Pun-
chayet, the Anjuman Com
mittee was required to be in-
According
Colony ’s Khareghat Hall, the Rustom
Bang Pavilion, the Recreation Center at S.
V. Bharucha Baug, Andheri and the
Madressa Annexe in the Dadar Parsi Col-
16 Parsiana April 1992I
POLITICS AND POLICY
i
YOUTH FEDERATION
Plan of Action
Parinaz Gandhi
* Identification of career opportunities and
support of community institutions are the initial projects
of the newly constituted Federation of Zoroastrian
Youth Associations
cided to enrol members on the basis of givings were expressed as to whether
announced there would be something worth reporting
FOZYA president Jehangir Bisney, on a monthly basis, Parakh was insistent.
The five young executive council mem
bers of the newly constituted Federation g^graphical
of Zoroastrian Youth Associations rZZY. ------ -
(FOZYA) solemnly sat round the table broaching the first item on the agenda, “It must be monthly; even if it means
Most of the Bombay youths
1^1 present reported that they were
living in the Parsi colonies in the
city ’s different localities. As
their statements, each 1
seem to have its own association.
But many of the youths ’ alle-
¦H giance appeared to rest more with
the Bombay Parsi Punchayet
W (BPP) Youth Club with which
they ’ve associated ever since they
completed the Holiday Rro-
gramme for Youth. (A project of
the BPP, the Holiday Programme
H for Youth is a month long series of
¦ activities conducted annually for
students who have appeared for
their school leaving examinations. There
after if they wish to retain their ties, the
students join the Youth Club.) And since
the BPP Youth Club is a vibrant body
meeting every month for social, welfare
location, ”
of Zoroastrian Youth
suiciiiiiiy mi luuuu mv ....... -------------j,-----------, — -------- u J ‘
on March 27, 1992. Facing them were a “enrolment of other Zoroastrian youth writing that ‘nothing has haj^ned. "
motley of 20 bewildered invitees,
most of whom had little idea why
they had been summoned barring
the knowledge that their interest
and involvement at earlier all-In-
dia Zoroastrian youth meets had
earned them this distinction.
This was the scene at the com-
mencement of the first executive ¦¦
council meeting of FOZYA. A
registered body, barely four
months old, FOZYA is constituted
with the intention of “promoting
unity and solidarity amongst the
Zoroastrian youth. ” A delayed
start by 25 minutes; a last-minute
change in the venue from the
Muncherji Khareghat Hall to the Parukh
Dharamshalla at Bombay ’s Khareghat Bisney, Parakh and Karanjawalla
Colony; and the presence of two senior
guest speakers before the business slated associations. They had envisaged differ-
on the agenda could be initiated contri- ent baug associations in Bombay nomi- _
nating their representatives who would and leadership training projects, the
serve as focal members between their re- i. . ''
>. ns per J
baug did|
¦
Council members (from left): Debara,
on the agenda could be initiated contri
buted to the prevailing uncertainty,
c- "
comers of India enrolled with FOZYA, spective geographical locations andjhe
was eviden't'from *the self introductions main aim is interaction, ” reinforced membership? ” “Why can ’t you channel-
that the maximum attendance was from FOZYA secretary Ms Mehernavaz Par- ize the group available? ” “Which other
Bombay even though the Bombayites akh; “not to become members and forget organization has worked for the Parsi
* . - J _____u.,*_______ _ rto LTDV /'UrhIHoij PrAffTQmmA thr
had only been invited as observers and
no one was officially representing the
largest Parsi settlement in India. This is
because Bombay had yet to join FOZ Y A.
“Bombay being a vast city, we have de-
spokespersons from this group failed to
vuiiioio ui iiiuia _____ ___ _____ appreciate why the Club could not be
only four were represented that day. It FOZYA secretariat in Hyderabad. “The made a member: “What is the criteria for
. _ * . (Xiain aim i" ” roinfAr/'a/l momh/>rphin7” **\XZhv Pan*t vnil phxinnftl-
FOZYA secretary Ms Mehernavaz Par-
Of the 15 youth wings from different
all about it for six months but someone
who ’ll give an immediate reply ” and be Youth)? ”
prompt in correspondence. To maintain "
continuity each association was asked to
send in a report every month. When mis-
youth as HPY (Holiday Programme for
Over the cross-talking Bisney pa- j
tiently tried to explain the complications '
that could ensue: Youth wings from dif- |
i
18 Parsiana April 1992you accommodate larger numbers within
a restricted budget, advised Bisney, notic
ing the interest and awareness generated
Representations of his talk narrated experiences, colored by earlier youth meets. The role of youth
in community organizations and entrepre-
in their traditions and imparting certain
keynote messages of Zoroastrianism was
ferent camps within the community
would then demand membership too re
sulting in rivalry and attempts to super- Lt Gen Adi Sethna who during the course
cede one another.
would then also come forth from other by years of association with the armed
cities and towns demanding that youth forces, the Delhi Parsi Anjuman where he neurship is what the organizers plan to
bodies other than the one recognized by serves as president and the FPZAI where include in the sessions, stated Karanja-
the anjuman be granted membership, he is vice president. “Can anyone present walla enquiring what else the prospective
“This would lead to conflict. Why don ’t recite the Din no kalmo, with meaning? ” participants would like to see introduced,
you activate the bangs in- Variety, greater group par-
stead? ” persisted Bisney. ticipation, overcoming sex-
The youths who had come ual biases and the need to
in their individual capacity break through different
rather than as rflpresenta- ' i pockets of isolation without
tives of their bangs were compelling anyone to share
thus convinced to get a let- SSn^ lodging quarters with
ter from their respective ^llr strangers were the views
colonies indicating their 1 • IB ^1S|||b||I||H that came forth.
willingness to enrol on j|||||||FB|H i' The subject of career and
FOZYA. *
Bisney ’s contention that
FOZYA is aiming to bring
together the Parsi youth of
the entire community, led to
another series of interroga
tions: “What will be the
benefits from joining FOZYA? What do he challenged. Goad-
we expect from getting together? ” De- ed by his guidance the
spairing the community attitude of always group
seeking returtis, one of the FOZYA sup
porters queried, “What is the association quence and the mean
going to do for FOZYA?” How are you ing right,
going to help? ”
As youth you should not wait to be
told to do something; take the initiative,
do it. This was the message impressed by
guest speaker Homi Bodhanwalla of Jam- tober 24 to 26, 1992
shedpur, vice president of the Federation there will be a session
of Parsi Zoroastrian Anjumans of India on religion, but not
(FPZAI) and advisor to several Tata com- the social aspect of re-
panies. This, he believed, would be an ligion, it was stressed,
adaptation of a Tata philosophy for the Taking up subjects
employee: “give him what he deserves like the Roxan Shah case (which created employment opportunities has been taken
before he asks for it ” With health, educa- a major controversy when a Zoroastrian
tion, spirit of adventure, tolerance, dignity woman married to a Hindu was not per-
of labor and discipline, every Parsi could mitted to be interred at the Bombay doon-
achieve wonders, he was sanguine for he gerwadi), the youths felt, tantamounted to periences. FOZYA instead plans to do
believed that “there is no royal route to going round in circles for ultimately the sometliing more definite on this issue by
becoming great. ” An advocate of yoga discussion came to nothing. Zoroastrian taking it up as its “main project. ” From
who at 70 plus regularly docs the head- history is what the session will focus on, the deliberations it emerged that there was
a need to bring together employers and
youths, and to disseminate information
M
quarters
1
I
I
r
i I
¦
¦¦
collectively
fumbled to get the se-
At the Sixth All
India
Youth Seminar
Ahmedabad from Oc-
Zoroastrian
in
Execulive council members
of FOZYA (above) and
youth invitees (below) hear
Sethna (gesticulating)
relate his experiences
up at earlier youth meets too. But this
only went to the extent of inviting out
standing entrepreneurs to share their ex-
An advocate of yoga discussion came to nothing. Zoroastrian taking it up as its “main project. ” From
history is what the session will focus on,
stand, Bodhanwalla maintains, “The briefed Porus Karanjawalla from Ahme-
world today is so much upside down that dabad, vice president of FOZYA. La-
it is when you are on your head that you menting on the level of ignorance among along the lines of a glossary on careers
are actually seeing the right side of the community youth, he said, “We do not describing the training and funds — avail
things. ”
“To educate Zoroastrians in general
and Zoroastrian youth in particular on all
matters affecting the Zoroastrian religion would like to restrict the number of par-
and culture ” is one of the objects of ticipants to 200, working within a budget tional purposes. The formalities, the bu-
FOZYA. Trying to instill in them a pride of two to three lakh rupees. Better that reaucratic procedures and the time lapse.
know who is the father of Zarathushtra able and required — for different courses,
but we know who is the brother of Ram. ” Another area where the youths seek im-
The organizers of the Youth Seminar provements is in the operation of trusts
that extend grants and loans for educa-
19 f^siana April 1992
I
'Fthe Parsis. But little could they do to rem
edy the situation on this front as youths,
so they were advised to consult the sen
iors at the executive council meeting of
the FPZAI on the following two days
(March 28 and 29).
There were other issues too left unre
solved. With enrolments from Bombay
still unconfirmed, FOZYA decided to de
fer the co-optation of five members on the
executive council. But as Bisney summa
rized, “Today was the first meeting so
don ’t expect to come to a decision on all
matters... The most important thing is that
we keep in touch. ”
The next meeting of
“Can anyone
present recite the
Din no kalmo,
with meaning? ”
they complained, defeat the purpose and voring this monthly over the other com- particularly irksome was the media mak-
the energies spent in procuring the loans, munity publications. In response Bisney ing a laughingstock of the community and
What they recommended instead was the detailed Parsiana's financial position suggested legal measures like injunctions
formation of a central body of trusts that running as it has in the red over the years, against producers for tarring the image of
could screen the applicants and then sane- and counter questioned, “Has any one
tion scholarships of higher denomination found out how Jame is doing? ” This de-
to a select few rather than nominal bate came to a natural end when a Bom-
amounts to several such that the aid ex
tended could, in terms of the devalued
rupee, measure up to requirements. The
ambitious youth were urged to be more
practical by senior invitee and joint hon
orary secretary of the FPZAI Keki Gandhi
who advised, “set goals where you can
succeed. ”
“Support Parsiana'' is a project that
FOZYA hjft voluntarily undertaken, even
including the item on the agenda of its
first meet. To augment Parsiana's lim
ited subscription base, every member bay resident who had never heard of The next meeting of FOZYA is
present was urged to enrol at least six sub- Parsiana enquired, “But what does scheduled in Ahmedabad to coincide
scribers before the next meeting. Bisney Parsiana do? ” with the Youth Seminar in October.
advocated gifting Parsiana on festive oc
casions and told the youths to adopt a dheela (ineffective). ” “We are getting The executive council members present at
door-to-door approach to overcome the bogged down because we have no politi- the meeting were: Porus Debara from
inertia of potential subscribers who could cal voice. ” “It is one thing that we Agra, Porus Karanjawalla from Ahme-
not be bothered to make out a cheque and choose to laugh at ourselves and another dabad, Mehemavaz Parakh from Hydera-
mail it. This made Karanjawalla question thing to have others laugh at us. ” These bad, Sarosi} Palkhiwala from Poona and
whether an appeal had been received from ~ ~ - - - —
Parsiana and the reason for FOZYA fa-
“As a community we are becoming
were the opinions expressed during the Jehangir Bisney from Secunderabad. The
open forum. What many youths found Press was represented by Parsiana.
WITH
BEST COMPLIMENTS FROM
)
J
SOn-HEARTED
‘ WIBS'BREAD
)
WESTERN INDIA BAKERS' PRIVATE LIMITED
¦
KHODADAD BUILDING, 100 D'LIMA STREET
DOCKYARD ROAD, BOMBAY 400010
20 Parsiana April 1992AWARDS
A jewel in his crown
Arnavaz S. Mama
J
J.R.D. Tata, the first Zoroastrian awardee
obthe Bharat Ratna, was accorded a special reception
by the Bombay Parsi Punchayet
“You have endowed me with qualities,
expectations and desires which I do not
think I really deserve. If I did my job
fairly well and honestly and sincerely it
was to a large extent because I wanted to
be worthy of Jamsetji Tata and the tradi
tions he created for us. ”
Jehangir R. D. Tata gently disclaimed
the tributes paid by speaker after speaker
at the function organized by the Bombay
Parsi Punchayet (BPP) to felicitate the
conferment on him of the nation ’s high
est civilian award, the Bharat Ratna.
The community, whom JRD ad
dressed as “all my fnends and fellow
Parsis, ” crowded the central lawn of
Cusrow Baug and gave the punctiliously
correct octogenarian in dagli and pugri a
standing ovation. The few empty seats at
the punctual start of the function at 6.15
p.m. on April 7, 1992 had been occupied
as the evening progressed and latecomers
thronged the side aisles. Fortunate
Cusrow Baug denizens viewed the pro
ceedings from their ringside windows as
Tata wondered aloud why he deserved
“the esteem, affection, recognition of
these fine people for whom I’ve done so
little in any organized way. ”
Confessing that he “had not been a
concerned or active Parsi, ” JRD spelt out
for the assembly the development of his
ideas on the subject of communities and
religions: “Since I was much younger I
have felt that communities, organized re
ligions and activities, for too many cen
turies despite being well-intentioned,
have been res^nsible for quite a lot of
hatred, lack of friendship, violence even,
among billions of people who needed the
opposite. ” However, “if there is one
thing I’m proud of, it ’s of being bom a
A part of the audience on Cusrow Bang's
center lawn PMo. superstar video Labs
i
m
/ .A
}
‘46
aw*
gr“
I
r
23 Parsiana April 1992
»
L'9
situations; ” his physical and mental en
ergy generated by ‘ a cool head, an empty
questioning of his own worthiness for the stomach and a warm heart... You believe
award. At Cusrow Baug he reiterated that that man is made to live to 125. The
the Bharat Ratna should be reserved for dumbbell and weights are your compan-
tional press had been an unassuming
ions... You are young at heart... Your eyes
of Jamsetji Tqp,” JRD, bom 1904, the
J— -I— '----- ---------------- ¦ ¦ , . _
had been a student of his illustrious distress at the community ’s dwindling ing your 100th birthday. ”
grand-uncle since the earliest years of numbers and that “a time will come when *- - ------------------------
maturity. He quoted from a letter written
by Jamsetji, then in the US, to his sons on
hearing that they and their team had suc
ceeded in finding the ideal loca- i
tion for Tata Steel at what subse- ” **
quently became Jamshedpur. i
Jamsetji had exhorted them to > j
plan out the town for the optimum
benefit of all its inhabitants. |HH
JRD said he had been
“enormously impressed. Jamsetji
Tata not only created industry but '
was a great humanist who be
lieved in doing things right and
honestly. He was human at a time
when no one bothered about the
rights of labor, when there were
no unions. His whole life showed
the humanity of the man... I con
tinue to be a big admirer. I was
determined to be largely guided
by him. On a number of times, on
problems that were not directly connected gone down to this extent, ” im
with Jamsetji, I asked myself how Jam- the nonconformist did not
setji would respond to such a proposal... I elaborate. In a very rare ar- y
have tried to, want to and continue to do tide on the subject about 12 ? ’’
whatever is right and honest and simple years ago he had propagated [
and humane. ”
Another name JRD respects greatly is
that of Dadabhoy Naoroji. The compara
tively recent development came about the ire of the orthodox. The
three or four years ago when the Dada- lesson learnt, Tata now
bhoy Naoroji endowment wanted to give urged the Punchayet, the
its award to JRD who decided he must high priests and others to try
know more about Naoroji than that he had and arrest the decline, “find
been an MP and had propagated the case ways, new ideas, projects to
of India ’s freedom. Going through Sir serve the people of this
Rustom Masani ’s biography of Naoroji, community. ” Only half
JRD found that Naoroji “had done one jestingly did he promise, “(When) I do try in India and nurtured it for 46 years. It
pass on. I’m telling you I’m going to was, said Palkhivala, “also a recognition
come back to find out for myself what our of the business class — that good values
youngsters have done in the direction of in business have played a vital role and
will play an even more important role in
the context of liberalization. ” Recalling
a
the need for widening the |
community base through in- j
termarriage. It had attracted '
j
1
•!
thing that amazed me. As a young man
who had just finished college...he tried to
find who had paid for his education. More
than 100 years ago (he discovered that) it revitalizing this great community! ”
was being paid out of taxes on items of The evening had begun with an invo-
24 Parsiana April 1992
Tata, garlanded and
shawl-draped,
receiving salver and bowl from
Golwalla (left)
Photo: Superstar Video Labs
On the dais (L to R) Minoo Shroff,
Homi Ranina, Kanga, Wadia,
Tata, Golwalla, Palkhivala,
Desai, Bengalee, Guzder and
JamaSpAsa Photo; OoHyOvecha
1
ii
**
.j
sheed Kanga. Nor did he hesitate to loan
his top men to government, Kanga added.
Ardeshir Dalal, Nani Palkhivala were all
conscripted for national duties: “The gov
ernment never hesitated to entrust govern
mental affairs to a Tata man. ” In today ’s
to get a pilot ’s li
cence; the establish
ment of Tata Airlines Dr John Matthai, Sir Homi Modi, Sir
in the 1930s and Jeh ’s
“extraordinary dedica
tion to the new ven
ture, ” his profession
alism — stymied for a atmosphere of low ethics in business and
pilot to fly Wadia industry, “the country ’s best exponent of
from Jodhpur to Bom- the ethical way...owes it to the business
bay, Tata himself had community...to record his experiences, ”
taken over, exactly 55 urged Kanga.
years ago!
Wadia also remem
BPP trustee Jamshed Guzder referred
to JRD’s promptness in furnishing a 50
lakh rupee bank guarantee that enabled
I Guzder to set up a customs clearance of-
I Hee to clear air cargo in a day instead of
the two to three weeks that it originally
I took. Guzder also noted that Daimler
! Benz, makers of Mercedes cars, quickly
chose Tatas to collaborate with even
though there were many others vying for
the tie-up. The decision, according to
Guzder, was based on their finding in
JRD “a man who had a reputation that
A glimpse of the audience
Photo: Superstar Video Labs^
Isn't it time to start? (from
left) Desai, Guzder and
Tata before the function
began Photo: Rusi Davar
how Dadabhoy Naoroji
had teen elected to the
British Parliament in 1892,
Palkhivala underlined the
symbolism in a Parsi win
ning the highest national
award exactly 100 years
later.
As one who had known
and admired JRD for half a century,
Palkhivala spoke of the man ’s tendency to
live dangerously, of an instinct for court
ing danger in contrast to the general ten
dency to seek safety, wanting “to live on
the verge of disaster ” and enjoying it!
Added Palkhivala tongue in cheek, . .
“When the heart specialist told him he did mission to circle overhead so as to land the five Parsi recipients. The University
not need open heart surgery, he was dis- exactly on the dot! had declared him “prince of industrial-
appointed. He wanted to experience sur- Referring to the 88-year-old as the ists, master manager... patron saint of
geiy! ” “Grand Young Man of the community ” Indian aviation... an ornament of this
Tata ’s profound sense of humor pre
vents him from being pompous, attested Tata ’s “renaissance intellect, ” his “un-
Palkhivala. So “he walks up to your of
fice rather than call you to his ” and em-
_________
w
whatever he undertook should (net) the
best for the shareholders and the com
pany — nothing for himself. ”
In a ringing votb of thanks BPP trus
tee and vice chancellor of Bombay Uni-
versity Dr (Ms) Mehroo Bengalee de-
tered Air India ’s first flight to London on clared with “pride and confidence that
June 8, 1948 when it took off punctually this ‘Ratna ’ is ours; belongs to us... As a
at 0005 hours and after special receptions community, this achievement makes us
at Cairo and Geneva, all meticulously richer still. ” Bengalee read from the cita-
planned and executed, reached London 15 tion that had accompanied Bombay Uni-
versity ’s selective awards to 18 promi
nent citizens in 1981. Tata was one of
minutes ahead of time. Wadia says JRD
told the captain in the cockpit to seek per-
exactly on the dot!
Referring to the 88-year-old as the
“Grand Young Man of the community ”
BPP trustee Eruch Desai commented on city. ”
More importantly, Bengalee com
mented on Tata ’s “unparalleled humility
right" job, the leader who knows where that the community (witnessed) this eve
ning ” and brought to his notice the prob
lems of education and employment faced
nity has made is following Tata ’s advice by the community today: “Our children
¦ fall by the wayside. Can our youngsters
plan for the future? Even dream of a fu-
troF India ’s runaway population growth, ture? They ’re looking up to you to ex-
He was, perhaps, the first in the country to »
point to it as die most urgent national
canny ability to pick the right man for the
barrasses his juniors! Each speaker bore he ’s going and gets others to follow him. ”
__ UzxtvrAvrA** ffviiefoVA "PoFCi
witness to Tata ’s courtesy, respect and However, “one mistake the Parsi commu-
sensitivity to the suffering of others; to
the quest for perfection which drove
on family planning, ” noted Desai, refer-
lesser people to the wall; to his zest for ring to Tata ’s concern for the need to con-
life; to his reverence for human literal
ism; to his desire to “see as far as one may
into the great forces behind the detail; ” to
his ultimate Zoroastrianism.
Neville Wadia, who has known him avid in curtailing their progeny and the Punchayets of Bombay and Surat had
for more than 50 years, sees JRD’s ex- results are a dwindling community. also presented him with a shawl and sil-
ample of how he expanded the House of In an era when nepotism was fashion- ver salver. His low tones husky with emo-
tend a helping hand to them... ”
Tata had been showered with garlands
problem. The Parsis have teen the most by individuals and organizations. The
results are a dwindling community.
In an era when nepotism was fashion-
Tatas as his greatest gift to the younger able, Tata chose outstanding profession- tion, Tata responded from the depths of
A ««r «• 1 _ _ J _______ .^1_________...1_____ __________4.^ UAn«*«^ *kAnlr «r/>ii mA*
generation of entrepreneurs. Wadia re- als and gave them the freedom to grow,
called the years he flew at Juhu airport retaining their respect and affection,
with JRD and the latter ’s sister, the late noted BPP trustee and member of the In-
Sylla Petit who was the first lady in India dian Administrative Service (IAS) Jam-
my heart... thank you for honoring me;
thank you for liking me. I say goodbye
with a great feeling of thanks and grati
tude for tonight and for being a Parsi."
25 Parsiana April 1992r-
WELFARE
Emerging from the valley
of silent darkness
Gustasp Irani
The founder of The Helen Keller Institute for the Deaf and
Deaf Blind, Behroz Vacha believes
in the handicapped child's right to education
tience, caring and dedication. We see it
reflected in the smile of a mother who
sits observing her daughter interact with
it, for to her it is a recognition of the the teacher and learns how to reach out
needs of the deaf-blind and the people and touch the hidden crevasses of her
around her, volunteers and professionals daughter ’s life. At a neighboring table, a
Then, who work selflessly to meet these needs, little girl leans forward (she recognizes
people by their smell), her hands seek
ing out Vacha who is then drawn into a
great big affectionate hug.
There is a great deal of activity at the
table where two teenaged boys sit with
their teacher; hands darting around in fu
rious conversation. Nearby another teen
ager interacts with his counsellor, both
sporting wide grins. “They have a great
sense of humor. They joke about a lot, ”
says Vacha. Later she calls the boys over
to meet us and we realize that if there are
any inhibitions about their handicap, they
are within us. But soon they draw us
across the barrier and briefly we are com
municating, sharing each other ’s worlds.
One boy gently runs his hands over our
Recognition, it appears, came in a rush
to Vacha who started her pioneering work
Let ’s play pretend; pretend that you are
deaf, dumb and blind; pretend that the
dimensions of your world are defined by for the deaf-blind in 1977. She welcomes
touch alone. Into this world a lady in- "
trudes. Gently she takes your hand in
hers and caresses away any resistance
you might have to her touch. ' ,
slowly she starts to communicate with
signals. Repeatedly she sits and rises,
makes you sit and rise, and through her
touch and signalling alone reaches across
the void to you. Next, she signals she
cares, that she is there to guide and love
you. Welcome to the world of silent
darkness; Ms Behroz Vacha, founder, di
rector and motivating force behind The
Helen Keller Institute for the Deaf and
Deaf Blind, Bombay, the first and only
one of its kind in India, demonstrates that
it is not as despairing as it might seem at
first.
In recognition of her role as a beacon
of light in the bleak dark world of the
deaf-blind, Vacha was presented with the “I am just a part of the Helen Keller Insti- . _
Anne Sullivan Medal at an international tute. Any award I receive is on behalf of body, exploring its, physical form,
conference in Sweden on August 8, the institution, ” says Vacha, adding as she strangely the touch is not an intrusion on
1991. The award, instituted in 1966 to takes us around, “To know me is to know our physical form, no more than soineone
commemorate the birth centenary of Ms my children. ” looking at us is, for the hands are, in ef-
Anne Sullivan, the teacher of the world There is a little girl of six just learning feet, his eyes.
renowned deaf-blind Ms Helen Keller, how to walk; her parents had unwittingly “Anyone whose grey cells are ticking
comprises five medals presented every cocooned her, fearing she might get hurt can be treated as a nramal child no mat-
four years. Vacha is the first Indian and because of her multiple handicaps. Va- ter what his or her handicap. It is often
Asian to be so honored. cha aids the child ’s teacher with the ex- the way we, the society, think and feel
The same year (1991) she was pre- ercise; one hand firmly but gently across about them which is the real handicap, ”
sented with the Rotary Club of Bombay the small of the girl ’s back and the other says Vacha, adding that every child
Public Service Award and selected as the hand working the legs up and down. “It is should have a right to an education ac-
Woman of the Year by the Zonta Club painful for her, ” Vacha informs us. The cording to his or her ability.
........................... • • ’ .L - At the deaf-blind Institute the right to
education is offered at present to 23 deaf-
blind students. Because of the nature of
their handicap the teacher-student ratio is
Finger movements effectively used in
communication
takes us around, “To know me is to know
my children. ”
There is a little girl of six just learning feet, his eyes,
how to walk; her parents had unwittingly “«
four years. Vacha is the first Indian and because of her multiple handicaps. Va
cha aids the child ’s teacher with the ex
ercise; one hand firmly but gently across
Public Service Award and selected as the hand working the legs up and down. “It is
International (Bombay III Branch). A girl winces, but playing among the
year earlier she was conferred the Rus
tom 1
Award by the National Association for
the Blind, India.
' " - • " pinched features is a smile; she recog-
Merwanji Alpaiwala Memorial nizes the familiar loving touch.
The foundations of the deaf-blind In
stitute, Vacha explains, are rooted in pa- high — one to one for the young and one
27 Parsiana April 1992
4If
8
Mi
4
¦
git I
9,
T
¦¦li
^¦1
jifc
¦
¦
.............................
Vacha being presented the Woman
of the Year Zonta Club award by Mitha
Shroff (left). Looking on (from left) are
J ay as hree Masur and Freny Paghdiwala
¦
¦
Bulsar I had a deaf boy in my class and I
noticed that people and other students
picked on him only because he was so
timid and handicapped. ” Years later when
she revisited Bulsar she noticed a grave in
front of the school and was informed that
it was the last resting place of that same
deaf boy. To Vacha, the grave was sym
bolic of a muted spirit that was denied the
right to education for no fault of its own.
After qualifying in the education of the
deaf from Banbay and the UniversiQr of
b
a
to two for the more advanced students, dom in my work but
Qualified counsellors help the older chil- has actively supported
dren. “Many of them are reaching their
adolescence and must deal with the prob
lems that the age brings, ” Vacha explains, cha, there is a differ-
In addition the Institute has its own resi- ence between pity and
dence quarters in Borivli where 16 of the sympathy. With pity,
deaf-blind students reside.
It all began in 1977, with three stu
dents, a meager Rs 150 in the coffers and is the true foundation
a whole lot of courage, caring and deter- of philanthropy. “Phi-
mination that a handful of determined lanthropy is to give of
women started work from one residential yourself, not just your
abode. According to Vacha, the starting wealth. ” Vacha de-
was important for she believed that assis- rives part of her inspi-
tance from well-wishers would follow. “I ration from the lines
believe that people have a lot of goodness of an unknown author
in them and it is for me to reach out and who observed: “A >
tap it. Often what I get may not be what I hundred times I re
want, but I know that it will eventually mind myself that my
help the Institute and the children, ” says inner and outer life de
Vacha who does not hesitate to ask for a pends on those living
good cause. “I even fight with my God for and dead and that I
my children, ” she confesses.
And miracles, small and big, do hap
pen. Vacha shows us an unsolicited let
ter she received from the Gulf Refugee am receiving and pass
Relief Fund. In it they state that their it on to posterity. ”
primary objectives have been met and - -
from the surplus funds they are donating pass it on... ’ Vacha in-
a part to the deaf-blind Institute. There forms us, is her own
are companies which have donated furni
ture when refurbishing their offices.
Then there are people who have supplied doing. On the walls of
transport, the qualified and dedicated her office almost all inspirational lines The handicapped children at the Helen
teachers and staff, the volunteers who have handwritten tailpieces. Itisareflec- Keller Institute learn at the hands of
have donated their skills and time to the tion of her drive to give a little more and qualified instructors Photos: Gustasp Irani
Institute and of course there is Vacha ’s
husband Nariman (formerly a secretary of
the Bombay Parsi Punchayet and of the hood that were to influence her commit-
N. N. and R. N. Wadia Trusts): “He has
not only allowed me unhampered free-
me in my task. ”
According to Va-
one gives and forgets.
Sympathy, however.
must exert myself in
the same measure that
I have received and
The last part ‘and
addition. It is some
thing she is constantly
inspire those around her to do the same.
Vacha recalls instances from her child- Manchester, Vacha started her career as a
teacher to the deaf. In 1965 she met a 17-
ment to the deaf and deaf-blind in her year-old girl Shyama Mehta who was
adult years. “As a young schoolgirl in bom deaf and progressively lost her eye-I
j
s
i
OUR
SPORTS CUPS
ARE WINNERS
ALL THE WAY
Any sports event requires cups and
shields to honour the winner.
We have a very wide range of
sports cups,shields and medals that
can make any sports event
a memorable one. Oome to our
show-room and choose from our
exclusive range. We can engrave
names and messages on sports cups
and shields according to your
requirements.
‘Silver plat'pO •
and engr^'^Q
^undertaKeni
S JHAVERI BROS.
1914
• 5, Metro House,Dhobi Talao,
Bombay 400 020.
Tel.:29 14 23, 29 70 26.
• 345,Abdul Rehman St., =
Bombay 400 003. 5
Tel.:32 00 65. 32 61 96 / 97. ‘
1914
>
o
z
m
m
-I
co
I
sight till she was totally blind by the age
of 16. “Her courage, her sense of humor,
her sharp memory amazed me. She was
instrumental in showing me the true spirit
of courage. Indeed, she changed the en
tire pattern of my life, ” Vacha records.
From then on Vacha started to think in
creasingly about deaf-blind children.
In 1971 she took a seven-year-old
deaf-blind bc,y Persy, diagnosed as men
tally retarded too, under her wing. She
believed in him and his mental abilities.
This was certified by Dr Edward Water
house of the Perkins Institute of the
Blind and Deaf-Blind in the USA who,
on one of his annual visits to India, diag
nosed Persy as a deaf-blind boy with re
tarded milestones and not as a retarded
boy. In 1974 Dr Waterhouse invited Va
cha to participate in a program of the
deaf-blind at the Perkins Institute.
Vacha returned to India and, despite
the odds, ventured into the country ’s un
explored valley of silent darkness. And
in this valley there was self enlightenment
too. “I learned that ideas may come from
others sometimes, but I am responsible
for my own decisions, ” says Vacha. To
Vacha it was a rediscovery of the true
2k)roastrian teaching of choice based on
good thoughts, good words and good
deeds. Vacha sees a disturbing contradic
tion within the Parsi community. Parsis
are renowned for their charity and philan
thropy but when it comes to sharing their
best gift, their religion, they are selfish.
“Nowhere does Zarathushtra talk of non
conversion. He in fact asked his follow
ers to spread his message to all comers of
the world. ”
And spreading goodness, in her own
way, is Vacha as the story of Ashok illus
trates. When only one year old, Ashok, a
deaf-blind boy, was referred to Vacha by
an adoption agency as they did not know
how to handle a child with his kind of
handicap. The Vachas, who have no issue
of their own, took the little boy to their
home and cared for him for four months,
until such time as he was adopted by an
American couple. Vacha shows us a let
ter from Ashok ’s new parents. In it they
mention the medical treatment and opera
tions the child has undergone as doctors
try to retrieve his vision. They end by
thanking the Vachas for giving them
Ashok, stating: “He certainly has brought
a lot of joy, love and happiness into our
home. ”
!
j
!
i
<
I
r
i
30 Parsiana April 1992
With
best wishes
from
Farah
&
Tanya
1
i
¦i
t
i
11
i
aLAW
Wedlock’s end: 1
K. C. Vajifdar
With the last amendments the Parsi Marriage
and Divorce Act is once more in step with current thinking
I
I
the SMA. The only relevant sections of
the IPC are 494 and 495 which deal with
bigamy. It is important to note that
bigamy is not allowed either under the
PMDA or the SMA and both these laws
lay down that if any marriage is con
tracted in violation of these laws it would
not only be void but would attract a pen
alty of seven years ’ rigorous imprison
ment under Section 494 and 495 of the
IPC.
Under section 32(d) of the PMDA, a
Parsi can get a divorce if he/she is able to
prove that the defendant has committed
adultery, fornication, rape or an unnatural
act (defined as carnal intercourse against
the order of nature with man, woman or
animal and punishwle under section 377
of the IPC with imprisonment up'to 10
What are the responsibilities imposed by
marriage and what redress does one
spouse have when the other spouse
chooses to disregard them? Answers to
the question have been a part of the gen
eral social environment, changing with
time.
The Parsi Marriage and Divorce Act
(PMDA) was the first to codify such so
cial expectations in 1865, becoming the
most advanced concept of social justice
in India at that time. It was amended in
1936 but, 50 years later, contemporary
Parsis were chefing at the restrictions
and prejudices of a bygone social era.
What is more, in comparison to other,
later legislation in the arena of personal
law, like the Hindu Marriage and Di
vorce Act, the PMDA had lost its preem
inence as a legislation that was in keep
ing with the spirit of the times.
Legal personality K. C. Vajifdar to bring the PMDA in line with the pro- has been filed more than two years after
analyses the main clauses of the PMDA visions of several other marriage laws and the plaintiff learned of the fact.
since its last amendment in 1988. In a specifically the Special Marriage Act
series of six articles Vajifdar explains the (SMA), 1954 and the Hindu Marriage Parsi has no right to get a divorce by cus
tom. This sort of custom is, in effect, di
vorce by mutual consent. Particular
caste punchayets or tribunals have the
supported by the Bombay Parsi years). However, a divorce would not be
Punchayet (BPP). These amendments are granted on any of these grounds if the suit
Unlike some other communities, a
changes that have been incorporated as Act (HMA), 1955 whose provisions are
also the main heads under which either
party to a marriage may apply for di
vorce.
In this issue Vajifdar discusses the
similarities and common grounds be
tween the PMDA, the Special Marriage
Act of 1954 and the Indian Penal Code.
Forthcoming articles will discuss the le- present amendment includes this provi- hind closed doors), ” where no members
gal ramifications of impotency, bigamy, sion in the PMDA and henceforth a Parsi of the public were alloxVfcd, only if such a
adultery, desertion, cruelty and change will also be able to get a divorce on the wish was expressed by either party to a
of religion. Alimony, distribution of ground of cruelty. Cruelty can be either matrimonial suit. The law now states
property and custody of children, all of mental or physical and divorce can be that every suit filed under the PMDA
which follow when a marriage breaks up, granted on account of mental cruelty to shall be tried in camera and it shall not be
will be discussed in the concluding ar- either party. Mental cruelty is not de- lawful for any person to print or publish
tide. fined anywhere in both the Acts but it de- any matter in relation to any such case on
more in consonance with the times in
which we live.
The similarity between the PMDA and authority — recognized by the courts —
the SMA now is that it is possible to get a
divorce by mutual consent.
Under the SMA a person could always
get a divorce if cruelty is proved. The hearings were conducted “in camera (be-
to pronounce decrees of divorce. This
right, however, is not vested in the BPP.
Under section 43 of the original Act
either party. Mental cruelty is not de
fined anywhere in both the Acts but it de
pends on the circumstances of each case pain of a fine of up to Rs 1,000. Only the
The changes which have taken place in and the Court would decide the issue judgement of the Court may be published
the Parsi Marriage and Divorce Act bearing in mind the status of the couple, with the previous permission-of the Court.
(PMDA) of 1936 under the amendment their background, their financial level,
of 1988 were recommended by the Fed
eration of Parsi Zoroastrian Anjumans of can get alimony if the wife is rich and
India to the Government of India in the has her own income. No such amend-
form of proposals to amend the Act. The ment has been made uptil now in the
Minorities Commission then considered SMA.
these proposals and recommended the
proposed amendments which were also nothing to do with either the PMDA or tai problems.
Proceedings under the SMA, 1954 and
etc. Now, under the PMDA a husband the HMA have always been conducted in
camera.
The Indian Penal Code (IPC) has
Koover C. Vajifdar is an advocate of the
Bombay High Court. He is a frequent contribu
tor to rhe general Press on the implications of
rhe Rent Act and the legal ramifications of mari-
33 Parsiana April 1992BOOKS
JRD
An Endearing
Portrait
Burjor K. Karanjia
v.
Beyond The Last Blue Mountain — Life Of
J. R. D. Tata by R. M- Lala. Published in 1992
in VIKING by Penguin Books India (P) Ltd, B4/
246 Safdarjung Enclave, New Delhi 110029.
Pp: 398. Price: Rs 295.
>
i
j J. R. D. Tata is a biographer ’s dream sub
ject for many reasons: for his achieve- u
ments in spheres as diverse as aviation J
and family planning, hydroelectrics and ¦
women ’s uplift, soap and steel; for his I
unbending qualities of discipline and I
leadership that enabled him, bom to the I
top echelon, to stay there and at the same I
time to consolidate and expand Tata inter- I
ests, the exercise tempered always by the I
recognition of human relations as the first I
principle of management; and, above all, I
for the man that he is, cultured, refined, I
sophisticated and charmingly aloof, with I
an infinite capacity to see the funny side I
of things and the quite disarming ability I
to laugh at himself. I
There is another quality of JRD that is I
also a mark of his greatness, but in the I
instant case might have proved to be un- I
fortunate. That is his humility which led
him initially to object to his “life ” being JRD seated in the boardroom. Behind
published. His objections were over- " - -
ruled, fortunately for posterity and for
young men and women with stars in their
eyes who might otherwise have been de
prived of a glowing success story.
But a subject like JRD imposes upon
the biographer an additional burden. In a
world in which, normally, deeds find it
difficult to keep in step with words, he
has to find the words to match the deeds.
He has to rise to the height of his subject,
catch the spark of inspiration off him, as
it were. R. M. Lala brings to his biogra-
It
IS
• i
s«s»««
- ¦ ¦ ( personal plane used to land to the excite-
him is a bust of Jamsetji Tala ment of the residents. Nob^y was more
excited than little Jehangir; From then on
One does not have to read this record I was hopelessly hooked on aeroplanes
of JRD’s achievements to realize how and made up my mind that, come what
richly deserving he is of the Bharat Ratna may, one day I^would be a pilot. ”^ _
award. But having read it, one gets the *' ’
rather uncomfortable feeling that the gov
ernment, having acted dishonorably and
dishonestly with JRD on more than one . .
occasion in the past, by conferring this aviation industry and its development, in
belated honor on him is seeking to redeem
itself.
Aviation was JRD’s first and remains
Sure enough, years later in 1930, he
undertook a solo flight in a Gypsy Moth
from Karachi to Paris. This was the his
toric precursor to the initiation of Indian
_¦ ; ¦ ¦ ’ ’ * '1
the course of four decades, into one of
India ’s success stories. Tata Air Lines,
founded in 1933, became Air India Inter-
pny, /jcyona ine his constant love. How this came about national m 1948 wjth the inaugurai mght
the requisite amount of hero-worship, but makes for interesting reading. The legen-
!• J__ T fk/i flwct t/A Tiv a nianp
35 Parsiana April 1992Then in 1953, like a bolt airline, the int^madonal airline
from the blue, came the nadon- and New India — were iiation-
alizadon of the aviadon Indus- alized within four years of each
try. JRD and Sir Homi Mody H other. Was the enterprise
expressed their indignation to worth it, asked JRD, whra the
the then union aviation minis- fruits of it were snatched away
ter, Jagjivan Ram, at the back- with confiscatory compensa-
door manner nadon- tion ?
alizadon had been brought in, But the worst was yet to
at the cost of heavy losses to come. When, later, the nadon-
the shareholders. In the course alizadon of Tata Steel was sug-
of discussion JRD asked gested, the then minister
Jagjivan Ram whether a bu- George Fernandes added insult
reaucradcally run airline sys- to injury once again by telling
tern was in the interest of the the magnate patronizingly that
country. The minister replied fe - the government would make
that it would nq| be run as a him “the czar of the steel in-
govemment department and dusiry, ” putdng him in charge
hoped that JRD would help them run it. At an Air India reception (from l^t): of all the steel plants of India, including
I told Mr Jagjivan Ram that I was so in- Bobby Kooka, Thelly Tata and JRD all the government steel plants that were
dignant at the manner in which the gov- making heavy losses!
emment had treated the air transport in- ponent of socialism, persuaded him to JRD was hurt and disillusitmed. All
dustry during the last three or four years accept — dll 25 years later in 1978, by the hopes he had cherished of budding an
and had deliberately brought it to its t' --------. ______________________ •. ....
knees, in order to acquire it for a song, removed by Morarji D^ai, the then Prime
that to ask me to be the head of the nadon-
alized company was to add insult to injury
and that I had no intention to preside at him. the much talked about concept of “con-
my own execudon, my duty being only to JRD’s protest at what was virtually a t ____ ____ ____
protect the interests of the shareholders dismissal was replied to by the Prime his own case, he said, “I doubt that th«e
ard the employees. ” -----...---------. . .___
Worse was the government ’s sheer hypocridcal praise the government is past any industrial execudve in charge of a
dishonesty in the matter of compensadon. master at laying on thick on such occa- major enterprise with less power than I
“First, they were going to take over — to ’ ....................
pay for what they took — and then did an
absolutely ^rty thing... The government country and the government itself which
banned their (the planes ’) export. We were the worst sufferers. The demorali-
said these planes have a value of Rs zadon of Air India, the decline in service.
ri
At an Air India reception (from left):
ponent of socialism, persuaded him to
the cruellest of ironies, he was summarily alliance for progress between industry
“7? " *' ‘ and government came to nothing. Afirm
Minister. Even the elementary courtesy believer in Andrew Carnegie ’s principle
of informing him directly was denied of the trusteeship of wealth, he debunked
him. the much talked about concept of “con-
JRD’s protest at what was virtually a centration of economic power. ” Taking
Minister with the sort of meaningless and is anywhere in the wwld outside India
master at laying on thick on such occa- i J
sions. But, as subsequent events proved, it have. ”
wasn ’t JRD but the aviation industry, the
He deplored the abolidon of the man
aging agency system in spite of its tre
mendous contribudon to the growth of
cAAA/vi- 1. ------------------------------ - Indian industry, recalling how years ago
500,000 in the world. They said exports popularity and profitability, began with Sir Dorabji Tata had pledged his per-
were banned and they banned them... just the dismissal of JRD. sonal fortune and his wife ’s jewellwy for
before (the) negodations. So what they But JRD had sdll to run an empire, a bank loan to pay the wagp-g nf .Steel
paid us was the original cost minus the —'— '• - • • •
depreciadon. ” JRD noted that the petrol
tax alone, paid by the airlines in seven
years, exceeded the total amount paid for when he took over as chairman, the endre I ’ ‘ ‘ _
- _ group consisted of 14 companies. When the one hand, and toTelease for nadon-
But JRD had still to run an empire, ____________
unique in India, of steel, electric power, employees. In vain he pleaded that the
insurance, cement, oil and soap, and tex- right policy for a socialist government,
tiles. A measure of his success is that armed with enormous powers, would be
, -----------^-3 to curb the use of illegitimate funds, on
the assets by the goveminent. group consisted of 14 companies. When the one hand, and to ’ielease for nation-
It was the same thing, complained he laid down office 52 years later, there building purposes all the resources of
JRD, when they nationalized the banks were 95 companies, their turnover having those in the private sector whose past rec-
and the insurance companies. “With iden- increased from 17 crore rupees to an esti- ord had shown them worthy of the
deal dishonesty, they said, ‘When we can mated Rs 10,000 crores. Perhaps the se- nation ’s trust, on the other. But his pleas
save money, why not?! So they didn t cret, as he confided to Lala, is : “If I have fell on deaf ears. The manaEinE aEenev
care a damn, including Jawaharlal! ” --------------------- ----------- . ..............................?
Of course JRD was offered the chair
manship of both the domestic and inter-
nadonal airlines. He was reluctant to ac
cept it, fearing that if he did, the govern
ment would be emboldened to grab an
other industry, pay minimum compensa- ______ ________ ___
don and then get the top industrialist to fecdon. pears to have been quite a charactn, he
preside as a government nominee. But JRD’s fears when offered the chair- would say: “She was a very formidable
his colleagues, the 18 heads of depart- manship of Air India and Indian Airlines lady. Her husband was a humorist and
merits at Bombay House, including, sur- proved to be true. Three companies after some dme with her ran away, as
prisingly, M. R. Masani, a vigorous op- ¦ ..... .. .
were 95 companies, their turnover having those in the private sector whose past rec-
increased from 17 crore rupees to an esti- - - - -
mated Rs 10,000 crores. Perhaps the se-
any merit it is getting on with individuals system was terminated in April 1970.
according to their ways and characteris- "
tics. In 50 years I have dealt with a 100
top directors and I got on with all of them.
At times it involves suppressing yourself. _______________
It is painful but necessary... to be a leader Mountain is replete with examples of this
you have to lead human beings with af- quality. Of his Granny Briere who ap-
JRD’s fears when offered the chair-
If JRD wasn ’t embitter^, it was be
cause he could always fall back on his
inner resources, chief of which was his
sense of humor. Beyond The Last Blue
proved to be true.
which Tata had nurtured -- the domestic anyone would have done had he been
36 Parsiana April 1992
I
4
*1
t1
M
V,
1
Imamed to my grandmother. ” When the my name is spelt ‘Jeh, ’ in abbreviation of human aspect in all that he did: “All my
Germans took over Paris, Granny Briere, ‘Jehangir ’ and that any resemblance be- management contributions were on the
then 90, was one of the very few to be al- tween me and the bird is purely coinci- human aspect, through inducing, convinc-
lowed to leave the city. Comments JRD: dental. ” ing and encouraging the human being.... ”
“I always say they allowed her to get out More than his remarkable achieve- JRD had the example of his forbears to
of Paris in self-defence! ” ments, it is the little personal touches that live up to. Beyond... shows how it was the
No other chairman could possibly have make JRD come alive in these pages: The pioneer Jamsetji who dreamed a magnifi-
got away with what he told an earnest inferiority complex he suffer^ from for cent dream. Sir Dorab and Sir Rai an Tata
‘Jehangir ’ and that any resemblance be
tween me and the bird is purely coinci
dental. ”
More than his remarkable achieve
ments, it is the little personal touches that live up to. Beyond... shows how it was the
shareholder at an annual gen
eral meeting. This share
holder complained that his
wife, who had been using
Tata Hamam soap for years
now, found that its quality
had deteriorated. JRD told
him, “If your wife is so dis
contented, she must change
the soap. ” The shareholder
replied, “Sir, she won ’t do
that, she will never do that. ”
“Then, ” said JRD, “you must
change your wife. ”
When as president of the
International Air Transport
Association (IATA), JRD
was asked for a photograph to
hang on the walls of his
IATA office, he complied
with a covering letter: “As re
quested, I send herewith a
photograph of myself to join
the ‘Rogues Gallery ’ on the
walls of your room. ” But
JRD could be bitingly sarcas
tic too, as he was when
Romesh Thapar, a known
who gave it rich substance,
and JRD himself who con
solidated and expanded its
parameters. In this he was
helped by all the members of
his family, his dear wife
Thelly with whom he has had
a love affair spanning several
decades, his brothers and sis
ters, his co-directors, col
leagues and workers who
gave of their unstinted loyalty
and devotion, a truly dedi
cated team.
What might have struck a
jarring note in this story is
JRD’s initial support of the
Emergency. “I diink I was
wrong, ” he later admitted.
“But it was my feeling at the
time. You could put if that I
regret it today, but in those
days the apparent disintegra
tion that could have led to
anything, appalled me. ”
JRD feels that the presi
dential system of government
is more suited to Indian con-
1
I
s
supporter of the Communist Party, wrote Suzanne (Sooni) R. D. Tata with her five
to “My dear Jay, ” that he had given JRD’s children (from left): Rodabeh, JRD,
name as reference in his application for a Jimmy, Sy Ila and Darab
position in the Foreign Service. JRD
gave a scorching reply: “I have no objec
tion at all to your having given my name engineering degree at Cambridge. His appointed Municipal Commissioner of
as a reference, although I do think it is a debt of gratitude to John Peterson, ICS, the Bombay Municipal Corporation. It
sad commentary on the present condition then working for Tata Steel, for initiating
and frame of mind of the proletariat that him into the principles of management.
its leaders are reduced to seeking the sup
port of bloodsucking capitalists such as one occasion to berate no less a person
myself! However, I shall cooperate out of than His Excellency the Governor, Sir colleague of JRD’s is reported to have
enlightened self-interest, as I may one day Stanley Jackson, for keeping several said that in some ways the doyen of in-
have to come to you for similar support hundred persons including women and dustrialists had everything, but in other
under somewhat altered circumstances. I children waiting for an hour, so that His ways nothing. If a colleague seeing him
would be content with a minor post, say. Excellency ’s car could pass, on a bitter working late in the office pleaded with
as commissar for industries with a couple cold morning in Daijeeling. His meticu-
of dachas, three American cars and a few lous attention to detail, even to the lip-
servants (including a member of the se- stick worn by Air India hostesses: “White
cret police) thrown in... Yours, Jeh. ” APS lipstick from a distance makes you look able to loneliness, which tends to creep
to the letter is uproarious: “I have looked like a corpse and the passenger is not very in like a thief in the night But in the
up the dictionary and find that jay is ‘a interested in being served by one who light of day this is only a delusion of the
noisy, chattering, European bird of bril- looks like a corpse. ” His preference for mind, a strange revenge of the whirligig
liant plumage, ’ and, figuratively, an im
pertinent chatterer or simpleton. For fu- is a little on the edge, on the verge of dis- and reaped handsomely, there is now a
ture reference please note therefore that aster... ” The importance he gave to the whole rich harvest to be gathered.
not having been allowed to acquire an
ditions than the parliamentary one. One
wishes, though, that his case for the for
mer had been less sketchily presented.
And, to set the record straight. Sir Arde-
shir Dalal was not the first Indian to be
was Sir Rustom Masani.
It is said that lonelihess is the penalty
The flashes of temper that drove him on tagged on to greatness. The top is always
a lonely place to be. In the biography a
him to go home, he was wont to reply:
“What have I to go home to ?”
True, a life lived so glorious is vulner-
living dangerously: “I like everything that of time. For one who has sowed wisely,
is a little on the edge, on the verge of dis-
37 Parsiana April 1992BOOKS
Saklatvala
A Compassionate
Socialist
THE FIFTH C
Dina Mehta
The Fifth Commandment — biography of
Shapurji Saklatvala by his daughter Sehri
Published in 1991 by Miranda
Printed by Manchester Free Press.
Saklatvala.
Press.
Paragon Mill, Jersey Street, Manchester M4
6FP, UK. Pp: 487. Price: £ 4.95.
StUPi \PUHJI
\ATVALA
0
M
M
A
N
D
M
E
N
T
died in Vienna. Apart from his grief,
Shapurji felt personally vulnerable now
that the loving protection of his powerful
uncle was no longer there. His fears
were not unfounded, according to his
daughter, for after the crucial minerals
were located (thanks to his perseverance
against all odds) and the company was
being structured, Shapurji was eased out
of the business.
With his uncle dead, his health failing
and faced with antagonism from his cous
ins, Shapurji left for England in 1905,
where he met Sally Marsh, his future
wife, whose name he changed to Sehri.
He fathered a brood of five children, the
youngest of which was daughter Sehri
who was to publish his biography in
1991, when she was 72 years old.
Had Shapurji flourished in the family i
naa-t<-kr3, Vrundavan Soc,
Marjiwada, Thane (W), 400601;
March 21
Pestonji KuverjiAsli (86), 9/10,
Cool Mhl, Noshir Bharucha Rd,
400007; March 21
Dinshaw Rustomji Battliwala
(73), 764/F, Sarosh Court, Tilak
Rd, Dadar, 400014; March 21
Bomanshah Behramji Bhesania
(71), 688, Wadia Bldg, Dinshaw
Master Rd, Parsi Clny, Dadar,
400014; March 21
Gool Menekaji Dalal (J3),
Silla-Villa, 21, Megharaj Sethi
Marg, Bombay Central,
400008; March 21
Minocher Rustomji Keravala
(91), bll, Palia Mans, Parsi
Clny, Dadar, 400014; March 21
Banoobai Jehangirji Khot (79),
(,i9r22. Dr D. Master Rd, Parsi
Clny, Dadar, 400014; March 21
Tehmurasp Dadabhoy Patel
(90), Kuver Hse, Sassoon Dock,
400005; March 21
Jal Nawroji Elavia (Ji),
12, Bai Hirabai Petit Bldg,
Grant Rd Stn, 400007;
March 22
Bahadur Keki Gotla (27), 684,
Lalkaka Hse, Khareghat Rd,
Parsi Clny, Dadar, 400014;
March 22
Piroja Phiroze Panthaki (81),
Wadia Bldg, 604/E, S. Gandhi
Marg, 400002; March 22
Shireenbai Jalejer Mistry (88),
H/14, Nowroz Baug, Lalbaug,
400012; March 23
Perin Jehangir Virjee (73), 801,
Coover Villa, Khareghat Rd,
400014; March 23
Aloo ManekshaJt Billimoria (76),
266, Patel Bldg, Opp Central
Cinema, Girgaon, 400004;
March 24
Shainaz Mherwan Irani (35),
30, Jamaji Todiwalla Chawl,
Sun Mill Rd, Parel, 400013;
March 24
Banoo Cawasji Mody (78), 648,
Kaka Bldg, Firdoshi Rd, Parsi
Clny, Dadar, 400014; March 24
Khorshed Bejonji Talati (85),
52, Jupiter, 1, Anstey Rd,
Cumballa Hill, 400026;
March 24
Banoo Burjor Sinor (75), 1/11,
A. H. Wadia Baug, Parel Tank
Rd, 400033; March 25
Keki Furdooryi Zaveri (60),
5/1, Ratan Tata Clny, Sir Ratan
Tata Rd, Tardeo, 400034;
March 25
Rutton Dossabhoy Patel (83),
C/4, Sangam Bhavan, Opp
Strand Cinema, Colaba, 400005;
March 26
Homai Sorabji Aderianwalla
(90), C/o Ms Roshan Hoshang
Tata, Dara Mirza Bldg, Tata
Blocks, S. V. Rd, Bandra,
400050; March 27
Tehmina Cawasji Tatra (85), D,
Petit Chawl, Dinsha Petit St,
400004; March 27
Gool Ratansha Kearak (81), 5,
Jehangir Mans, 1st Marine St,
Dhobitalao, 400(X)2; March 28
Houshang Darabs^haw Elavia
(54), 5/12, Tau Clny, Sir Ratan
Tata Rd, Tardeo, 400034;
March 29
Nusserwanji Sorabji
Masalawala (80), 12/A,
Panthaki Baug, Andheri, 400069;
March 30
Dady Burjorji Mistry (81),
607^, Sohrab Hse, Dr Ambedkar
Rd, Parsi Clny, Dadar, 400014;
March 30
Ratanbai Rustomji Mody (92),
386-B, Sir Jagmohandas Bldg,
J.S.S. Rd, 400002; March 30
Homtu Rustom Andax (78),
Windsor Chmbs, Cawasjee
Patel St, Fort, 400001;
March 31
5
I
?
CALCUTTA
Died
Dinshaw Madan, husband of
Behroz a^d father of Armine
and Neville; March 13
I
I
i
*
M.PkLLOHJl & co
PRWKUMn®-
Industrial Pointing, Coating,Anti-corrosion
Water-proofing,Construction, Diving &
Offshore Contractors.
87, Abdul Rehman Street, Bombay 400003
Tel : 324150/336607
Tlx : 011 75871 MPEL IN, Fax : 022-2152998
(
I
k.
43 Parsiana April 1992Piroja Darab Driver, mother
of Shirin and Jimmy;
March 27
DARJEELING
Bora
A boy, Anaosfudt, to Dimple
and Marzban Mody;
February 11
KANPUR
Died
Dhunmai Bamanji Sukhia;
March 2
POONA
Died
Munchi Ardeshir Gohvala (91),
661, Taboot St, 411001;
March 20
SURAT
Died
Jalejar Faramroze Bhathena
(68), Ami Cottage, Vanki Bordi,
395003; March 1
Alamai Gustadji Kavina {93),
Elor Park, Gujarat Hsg Board,
Baroda, 390002; March 11
Pervez Sorabji Junwamvala (58),
Makipa Falyu, Vanki Bordi,
395003; March 21
Alabai Jehanbux Sena {96),
Adagca Mohalla, Nanpura,
395001; March 23
Khorshedbanu Jehangirji Munshi
(68), Gam Amamal, Post Karjan,
Taluka Kamrej, 394180;
March 28
ADELAIDE
Bora
A girl, Priya, to Taina and
Tinmy Pavri; February 21
Died
Ardeshir Maneckji Khory {69);
January 6
Cooverbai Darabsha Gohvalla
(90); January 10
Bachubai Gustad Framji (80);
January 15
Jamshed Peshotan Patel {Tl);
January VI
Kersi Nusserwaiyi Patel {12);
January 22
Sam Jamshedji Mulla (61);
February 2
Shirin Jeahangir Mody (82);
February 1
Noshirwan Rustam Asli {51);
February 11
Parinbanu Ratanshaiiv Kapadia
(91); February 25
Behram Rustanyi Kermani {12);
February 25
LONDON
Married
Vera D. Shroff and Farroakh
Homi Parekh-,
December 22,1991
Died
Vispi Mistri {A2), son of Hilla and
Keki; February 23,1992
Nancy Ardesher Cowasjee {66);
February 26
QUEBEC
Married
Dinaz Bhatena, daughter of
Sheroo and Minoo, and Khushroo
Kongo, son of Banoo and Adi;
September 28,1991
TOTALS FOR 1992
TORONTO
Married
Zarine Dover of New Delhi,
daughter of Freny and Rustom,
and Rajiv Silgardo',
January 18,1992
The telling figures
The annual figures for births,
marriages and deaths for 1990
were not published as Parsiana
had been awaiting the birth fig
ures 1
Corporation. After making sev-
augmenting the Parsiana figure
for total births in 1990 of 244 by
45 percent, the estimated total
births may be reckoned at 354.
from the Bombay Municipal Similarly, the Parsiana birth fig-
„ • ure of 319 for 1991 may be aug-
eral inquiries we were informed mented to an estimated 463.
that the Municipal birth certificate In 1990 there were approxi-
no longer states the religion of the mately 610 more deaths than
child. Thus there is no way of births - a rise over the 1989 fig
knowing the total number of ure of 571 (see 1989: The telling
In 1991 there were 100 fewer
deaths and 75 more births than in
1990. Hence, the difference be
tween deaths and births — which
depicts the numerical decline of
the community - is estimated
Petit Parsee General Hospital, the low^ at 407.
Breach Candy Hospital, the Parsi The marriage totals for 1991,
births to Zoroastrians in Bombay figures," Parsiana, May^ 1990).
unless one were to visit each and
every hospital and nursing home
in the city to gather the facts.
The birth figures cited are the
totals of births listed in Parsiana.
Their source is primarily the B. D.
_____ , . . ~ i marriage totals for 1991,
Lying-in Hospital wad the Masina 458, too showed an increase by .
Hospital. It should also be spcci- 108 over the 1990 total of 350.
fied that the births mentioned in While in 1991 the percentage of
Parsiana include offsprings of in
tercommunity marriages irrespec-
intercommunity marriages was
around 19 (if calculated as a ratio A ]
five of whether the father or the of intercommunity marriages to
mother is a Zoroastrian. the total number of marriages
We may assume from past 88:458), and 24 percent (if calcu-
percentages that the Parsiana fig- lated as a ratio of intercommunity ¦ ~ ~ . lated as a ratio of intercommunity
ures represent around 55 percent marriages to community mar-
of the Bombay births. Hence, riages — 88:370), in 1990 the
corresponding figures were 22
(80:350) and 30 (80:270).
We list below the actual Bom
bay numbers:
Hence,
VICTORIA, British Columbia
Died
Naoroji D. Kooka, husband of
Jini and father of Nergis, Rashna
Charania, Yezdee and Farrokh;
September 20
CHICAGO
Bom
A girl, Karishma, to Zenobia and
Khurshed Kasad, sister to
Cherag; February 7
BORN
Boys
Gills
Bombay Other Indian cities Foreign cities
A B A B A B
7
9
26
32
1
4
1
2
HOUSTON
Married
Niloofer Madon of Bombay,
daughter of Dinoo and Jamasp,
and Swapan Mondal;
February 20
MARRIED
Parsi
Intercommunal
27 57 1
1
2
2
1
1990
Born: Etoys 142, Girls 102
Married: Parsi 270
Intercommunal 80
Died: Interred 964
Cremated 12
Body donated 1
KARACHI
Bora
A girl, Veera, to Alla and Burjor
Rustomji; January 27
A girl, Tara, to Anaheet and
Eddie Shroff, Ptksnary 13
DIED
Male 46
Female 38
A: Total numbers in this issue
B: Running totals for 1992 (February and March issues)
These figures pertain to information provided to or collected by Parsiana.
They do not represent the total number 99
the condolence resolution. The AAA’s
chief purpose was to distribute text and
exercise books to school and college stu
dents at nominal cm * no cost, an activity he
had been undertaking in his individual
capacity since a young age from his mea
ger pocket money. Besides, several
Gujarati productions of this Association
did Godiwala participate in or script. He
also spared time and resources for the P.
D. Marker Physical Culture Institute
where he was trustee, states Dadrawala.
Godiwala ’s own health in the mean
time was deteriorating with mounting ten
sion, increasing diabetes and kidney com
plications that required regular dialysis.
Although there was a manifold in
crease in the work pressures, he never
regretted switching over to catering mid-
1
Godiwala’s
hearty
helpings
the taste of a dish before it was served. ”
Therefore, while his wife Freny would stream in 1964, believes Neville,
supervise the service tendered to the Godiwala ’s first job was with Indian
guests, Rohinton would position himself Oxygen and later as foreman at
near the kitchen. And since he had no Firestone. A graduate in arts from Bom-
qualms about dirtying his hands when a bay ’s Khalsa College, he additionally
cook or a rotliwala threatened to leave, he gave tuitions in mathematics. His love
had only to start doing the work himself for challenges then made him start a bak-
and the labor problem would be resolved, ery. Renowned, as a partnership venture,
observed his son. Later he went On to run the canteens for
Godiwala ’s magnanimity extended not the National and Grindlays Bank, the
only to his customers, but to his friends, Parsi Gymkhana and the Cusrow Baug •
neighbors, the poor and the destitute. Pavilion. The last served as a stepping
I
neignoors, me poor ana me uesuiuic. ravtiiun. luc uisi scivcu oa a stepping .
When catering for ghambars, he would stone from where he started accepting J
charge the lowest possible rates and even private orders. And as the husband and
include an extra course on the house, ac- wife team slogged away, the children ; Died: Rohinton Bejonji Godiwala, 57, include an extra course on the house, ac- wife team slogged away, the children
leading caterer of Bombay, on November knowledged Ms Homai Modi, one of the were left under the care of their grand-
12,1991 following renal complications. chief organizers of community functions, mothers, looking forward to the time
A simple, unassuming man who would The surplus from his catering assignments spent with their parents on long holidays
always be in the background, attired in a would often go to the widows ’ chawl at every two years.
cotton shirt and trousers, Godiwala was Mazagaon. Several individuals too bene- Of the three children, Tanaz, the
constantly sought by people of means for fitted from his largesse. Remembers his youngest is most interested in the cater-
. ¦ * ing line. In fact, after her was named their
allied business, Tanaz Dectxators, an off-
would often go to the widows ’ chawl at every two years.
Mazagaon. Several individuals too bene-
a meal catered by him carried with it the neighbor Noshir Dadrawala, now execu-
flavor of distinction. tive secretary of the Centre for Advance-
With their increasing popularity, often ment of Philanthropy, “Knowing that shoot of the catering business that sup-
the Godiwalas would be catering at more both my parents had died when I was 18 plies furniture, cutlery and linen to others
than one baug in Bombay on the same and still studying, he had extended an in the trade. Just before Godiwala ’s
evening. At massive community gather- open invitation that I cojuld always come death, the family had submitted a tender
ings like Jamshedi Navroze ghambars for a free meal at any of the baugs where for the running of the canteen at Elphin-
they would be entrusted with the catering, he was catering. ” Not only Dadrawala but stone Club, but subsequently withdrew it.
But the ultimate recognition came when several others too availed of such offers. according to a family source.
Several outlets in Bombay started sell
ing Godiwala eats off the counter. The
But the ultimate recognition came when several others too availed of such offers,
they had the dinner paats laid out with red ‘ "
cloth instead of the customary white in i , _
honor of Ms Indira Gandhi, the then children, donate vessels every year during caterers twice tried to establish a daily
prime minister, who was present at a cele- muktad to the Dalal Agiary, in Bombay ’s distribution network but could not suc-
bration function hosted by her husband ’s Mazagaon area, mentioned Ervad Nari- ceed, reports Neville. Godiwala ’s “mam
Parsi cousins. man Dalal at a condolence meeting con- dream, ” as was often conveyed to his
Only last year, at an exhibition, Para- vened by the Amateur Artistes Associa- family, was to set up Godiwala Enter-
sika, documenting the contribution of tion (AAA) on November 30. This Asso- prises, a setup akin to the Sir Ratan Tata
Parsis in India, Godiwala was approached ciation which he was instrumental in Institute, supplying quality f^ and of-
The caterer is survived by his wife
Besides, he was also known to finance
navjote ceremonies of poor Zoroastrian
muktad to the Dalal Agiary, in Bombay ’s
Mazagaon area, mention^ Ervad Nari
man Dalal at a condolence meeting con
vened by the Amateur Artistes Associa-
sika, documenting the contribution of tion (AAA) on November 30. This Asso-
for his ’recipes. He had a natural flair for founding in 1957, he further served as fering employment to the needy,
cooking though he had never studied at a president, custodian, honorary general
catering college, informs his son Neville, secretary and member of the managing Freny, son Neville and daughters Roxan
adding, “He was a better cook than my committee at different times, according to and Tanaz. Puinax Gandhi
48 Parsiana April 1992
j
I
5
I
.«
J
s
£
I
i
i
t
◆ ◆ ◆
From the archive
