Complete Issue
Mar 1980
MARCH 1980 Price 3.50
earo
meMarcfhi-April 1980 Vol. 2 No. 12
READERS’ FORUM
EVENTS AND PERSONALITIES
ZOROASTRIANS ABROAD
NEWS FROM THE MEDIA
THE YEAR OF THE MONKEY
SHERNAZ KERMANI: BOUND TO WIN
SMOULDERING EMBERS OF KADMI PRIESTHOOD
Gustasp Irani
DELHI SURVEY: PROFILE OF THE DELHI PARSIS
IMAGE OF ZARATHUSHTRA: DREAMS AND REALITY?
Z-QUIZ
THE KHSNOOM WAY
WORLD CONGRESS PAPERS: ADJUSTING TO CHANGE
AUTOBIOGRAPHY: DASTUR DHALLA IV
COMMENT: A WESTERN RESPONSE TO ZARATHUSHTRA
Dale Bishop
IN MEMORIAM
3
7
17
25
33
35
38
43
46
47
50
51
55
59
63
Cover: The Year of the Monkey: designed by Manjula Padmanabhan
Marg, Fort, Bombay 400 001 and print
ed by him at Kaiser-e-Hind Publishers
and Printers, 300, Perin Nariman Street,
Bombay 400 001. All rights reserved.
Address all editorial and ousiness cor-
EDITOR Jehangir R. Patel
MANAGING EDITOR Gustasp Irani
EXECUTIVE EDITOR R. P. Thanavala
ART ASSISTANT Najoo Amroliwalla, rcs^o^ence to^^
Ketayun Wankadia
iVDVERTISING Feroza Chavda, Vecra
Parbhu and Khushroo Amroliwalla
MANAGEMENT Dr. Rustem Colah »*«»? ^amail Rs. 36 one year, R^. oo
and Zarin Billimoria y^s; Airmail Rs. 80 one year,
CIRCULATION M. R. Ambujakshan por U.S. personal cheques add $ 1.50
to cover ba^ charges.
OFFICE Mathew M. George For Indian upcountry cheques add Rs. ?
. for bank charges. Cheques and drafts
Parsiana is published by Jehangir R. are to be drawn in favour of Parsiana.
Patel at Clo H. L. Rochat, Navsari Single copy price Rs. 3.50 and 50p. All
Chambers ground floor, 39 A. Nayak rates subject to change in postal rates.
892, Bombay 400 001. Phone: 268739.
Annual inland subscription: Rs. 20 for
one year, (12 issues); Rs. 3b for two
years, (24 issues). Foreign subscription
two years; Airmail
Rs. 150 two years.
Patel at Clo H. L. Roebat,READERS' FORUM
4
n .H'tMtldtiith'
a
(btitij)., ,
n.KiUc
¦•--•ton
t
B
M.
ft
it
Kvnc
nt***
a.
|b>»i**e»r***’
KK*’
To those who know Gujarati, I a “Gamadia ” family taken by a local
suggest that they go through the ori- photographer. The family seems to
HURMUZ KAUS
Hyderabad
gi^, which will make for enjoyable be a middle-class one.
»=»’ * 'j
¦I&
reading even for those who may not
agree with various views of the learn
ed Dasturji. He was quite prepared
to accept that all may not agree with ||
all his views and was ever ready to Refering to the picture of a family
discuss and explain to them his view- that a family member wishes to trace,
point. (September 1979) the gentleman a{>
pears to be a China trader from liis
‘Chinese Khokha ’.
RATAN R. MARSHALL
Surat
»»
JAMSHED PAYRl
Vancouver, Canada
4
“Where are They
I was interested to , , . «
photograph of a Parsi family of the Did A. Faizelipour feel better alter
see the group
‘ Pride and Prejudice”
his emotional and somewhat unba
lanced tirade against the Parsis (“Pride
c-nd Prejudice, Readers ’ Forum,
19th centuiy, (“Where Are They?
Parsiana, September 1979). ----------- ,
I have in my collection of old pho- t'nd Prejudice, Readers
tographs scores of photographs of Parsiana September 1979).
Parsis — single and group ¦— of 19th He accuses ‘ people of charging He
century, similar to the one mentioned (Muslim) Iranians exorbitant ren s,
above. Men with Jama/Da^a, loose never treating them_as huinan ^ipgs,
silken pyjamas, wearing fenta or pag- “arsing ” th^ Gw
ri or l±oku, and women with ornate
bordered saris, jackets and mathuba-
nu. The shoes of the m«i were . - •
mostly chadavi and women generally against the Parsis as a whole is no
wore velvet sapats. They appear only invidious but obviously untrue,
generation, and this K anything, the Parsis have had senti-
as mental and traditional ties with Iran
to the generation of mid its people spanning centuries.
The shoes of the m«i
and so on. Who are the “people, ” he
refers to? Parsis exclusively?
To make such sweeping statements
strange to this
generation ’s costume will appear
much strange 1 ' _
2079 A.D. The photograph in ques
tion appears to be of the third quar
ter of the 19th century.
I once picked up a photograph of would care to comment
my late father, ‘ ~
Nizam ’s Revenue Service, died 1918),
from a footpath kabadi and ask^ at this very moment,
him as to who the man was in the
photograph. He told me that he must
The Original ‘Atmakatha ’ be a Nawab “of the time of Mahboob II
It was interesting to learn about the Ali Pasha ” (i. e. Nawab Meer Mah • Having read the letter of A. Faizeli-
English version of Dastur EXr Ma- boob Ali Khan, Asaf Jah VI. 1869 pour in your issue of September 1979
neckji Dhalla ’s autobiography. It re- 1911). My father had “mutton-chop I ask if you are bound to publish
minded me of the times when the whiskers ” which was a fashion in the letters even if they are far froni the
Gujarati detailed second edition was “Days of the Beloved ” as the Belov- truth? Do you believe that Parsis are
out some time in 1946. ed himself had mutton-chop whiskers, so anti-muslim or anti-Iranian as des-
When the ‘atmakatha ’ was first and Jagirdars, Rajas and officers of cribed by Faizelipour? The fact that
published there were very few good the then Nizam ’s Government follow- you publish such a letter makes me
•autobiographies in Gujarati language, ed the fashion. Mutton-chop whiskers feel that you agree with its contents.
Dastur Dr Dhalla ’s autobiography was a common fashion of Parsi men ” ’ ' ’ “
was adjudged an important addition of the Victorian Era.
to the then limited list of outstanding "" __
autobiographies in Gujarati, though Parskma appears to be of an orthodox c>ur and he may have well deserved
Readers ’ views are welcome on
any subject of interest to the
community and should be sent
to The Editor, Readers ’ Forum,
Parsiana, G.P.O. Box 892, Bom
bay 400 001. Letters are subject
to editing for reasons of space
and clarity.
as
(Talukdar in The
And while one agrees entirely with
Faizelipour ’s sentiment that people of
all faiths should live in harmony, per-
¦ ¦ " t on
the “love and respect ” shown to the
followers of minority religions in Iran
GINA NAY AR
If the writer has experienced ill
___ treatment from anybody it may per-
To me, the group photograph in l^ups be due to his own nasty^behavi-
written in a style popular with Parsi Parsi _ family of Surat, Navsari or Ud- if- But he cannot generalise. The Pa-
writers. Besides the style the langu- vada, and not of Bombay. The studios ^re definitely not so rude or un
age was fascinating and drew the at- of Bombay photographers were equi- cultured as to abuse others as alleged,
tention of those literary people who ped and well decorated and the Th® advice of Faizelipour to “all
some sense in people of all faiths ” is uncalled for.
A. F. TARAPOREWALA
Madras
tention of those literary people who ped and well
came across it. I still remember how photographers had some sense in
happy I felt while going through the making the subject pose decently. The
chapters. Parsiana photograph seems to be of
3mainly because the Parsis themselves
have never encouraged them to initi
ate their children into the commu
nity. It is ridiculous to expect all the
r __ _ ______ y in the community
When they do marry outside, even if
___ - ' ‘ .... ............ ‘
Parsis, conservative relatives raise
III
The letter from A. Faizelipour was
uncalled for. Did he express fils exas
peration against Indians or simply Parsis to marry
against the Parsis. He should learn "
how to live in India by taking lessons they w^t to bring up their children
le Farsi refugees of 1,500 aS Parsis, conservative relatives raise
years ago. He talks of Indian Parsis objections. This is especially so, when
going to Iran for jobs. If the jobs are Parsi girls marry outside,
easuy available i
would not be here.
from
JEENA & COMPANY
ESTD, 1900
IATA AIR CARGO
Clearing. Forwarding
Warehousing and
Insurance Agents
10, Veer Nariman Road
Fort, Bombay-1.
Cable : ‘JUSTITIA’
Telex : 2313
Phone : 312032
Branches:
E. Merc House
19/B, Shakespeare Sarani
(Formerly Theatre Road)
CALGUTTA-16
Phone : 444711
*Jeena House*
50, Hanuman Road
Connaught Circus
NEW DELHI
PHONE : 310821
the Parsi refugees of 1,300 as
in Iran, Faiajelipour
That
Zoroastrians
Many girls on marrying outside,
would like their children to be ParsiS
F. F. MULLAA but feel that they would always b4
Udvada treated as outsiders. Should we not,
as a community, try to encourage the
growth and spread of our religion? 1
“Friends of tha Trees” am not suggesting that we take irt
I read with interest D. J. Cama s converts. But surely we could accept
views on why we should not keep a g child of one non-Parsi parent and
fire in agairies any more (“Friends of one Parsi parent as a Parsi. And su-
the Trees ”, Realers ’ Forum, Parsiana, rely we could encourage other Parsis
September 1979). who have married outside, to bring
At the cost of one ’s traditions one their children within the folds of our
might be able to argue that wood be community.
replaced by some other fuel. That should be proud to be Parsis.
might perhaps serve to conserve wood Unless we realize that we must learn
to a certain negligible extent. But to to accept children of non-Parsis mar
go so far as to suggest that the Fire ried to Parsis, as Parsis we will
itself is without utility and ought to eventually become extinct,
be put away with is, in my opinion,
most shortsighted.
Historically, Zoroastrians have
worshipped God throu^ His natural
elements of which Fire is one. Among
other things. Fire in agairies: symbo
lises the truth contained in the eternal
cycle of Creation and Destruction;
serves as a vibrant centre of focus, by
concentrating upon which, we are
helped in eliminating worldly distrac
tions for the given moment of prayer
— thereby liberating the Self from
the chains of the Ego; and reminds us
that our mission in life is to ^ow
from weak embers, to bum briglit,
giving warmth and light to people and
things around us, and to glow con
tentedly as the flame dies.
While socio-cultural reform goes
hand in hand with what we popularly
call progress, one must be ever more
cautious before seeking to break away
from one ’s traditions. After all, it is
our great traditions and the spirit they
symbolise that have kept us one of
the foremost communities in the
world even today.
KHURSHED PASIAKIA
AZMY BHARUCHA
Bihar
On Record
1 have been collecting old gramapnone
records on the Parsi community which
I believe reflect a heritage that is
worth preserving. In all I have 16
records which includes a number of
marriage and wedding songs, social
songs, comic songs, ashirwards, etc. I
would now like to transfer my collec
tion back to the community. Should
anyone be interested they may contact
me directly, at 138, Temkar^ Street,
P. O. Bombay Central, ~
400 008.
Bomb'iy
A. RASHID EBRAHIM
BOOKS WANTED
Encourage Them
Although I am only 14 years old, I
feel very strongly about my religion .
— Zoroastrianism. The Parsi commu
nity is getting smaller day by day.
many Parsi boys and girls marry out
side the coniniunity and bring up
(heir children as non-Parsis. This is
Wanted urgently : The Religious
Customs and Ceremonies of the
Parsees by Jivanji Jamshedji Modi.
Please write to C. Munshi, 7 Cuffe
Parade, Colaba, Bombay 400 005
or telephone 212301 at about
4.30 p.m. on any day.
5Events and
Personalities
At the Helm country today are the government ’s I
Jamshed Nusserwanji Guzder, a policy of industrial licensing, the I
prominent figure in the business and present monetary policy oi the gov- ¦
industrial life of the citv for the past ernment, the Monopolies and Restric- ¦
30 years and trustee of the Bombay tive Trade Practices Act (MRTP I
Parsi Panchayat, has been elected as Act) and deteriorating industrial- |
the president of the Indian Merchant labour relations, ” Guzdei is reported 1
Chambers (IMC) for the year 1980. to have said. , I
He had served as the vice-president Guzder is on the Board of Dir^tors ||
of the 73-year-old chamber, which of a number of comp^es cwering
individuals as members and more
than ------ -------- ------------J c
different trades and industries affiliat- ’v^^th the Wadi a group or companies,
cd to it, during the previous year. -
Jaiusucd Nusserwanji Guzder, a pohcy of industrial licensing, tne
prominent figure in the business and present monetary policy oi the gov-
industrial life of the citv for the past ernment, the Monopolies and Restric-
30 years and trustee of the Bombay tive Trade Practices Act (MRTP
the president of the Indian Merchant labour relations, ” Guzdei is reported
r • :—; " ' . — - ’--------
He had served as the vice-president
of the 73-year-old chamber, which of a number of companies covering a
has over 1,900 companies, firms and wide range of industrial and manu-
xxxxd ____s facturing activities, states a bio-4ata
170 associations representing by the EMC. He is closely associated
being the president of National Pero
xide Ltd. and a Director of Bombay
Eyeing and Manufacturing Company
Ltd. In addition, Guzder also serves
on the Board of several other Public
limited Companies, such as Calico
Mills, Herdillia Chemicals, Boots,
Bakelite Hylam, Citurgia Biochemicals,
and Vulcan Laval among others.
a
f
KT
Guzder: head of Indian Merchant
Chambers j
as Calico
Boots,
. 11
v
*¦
Contractor : almost there
instructor to teach
¦ ’ once a week
England, and then at the Thurrock Techmeal <^bege,
et really not there. ” Grays, Essex and al^ ^t
the many newspaper " • • - —
The Home Coming
“I am on the threshold of recoga'-
tion, ” says Dorab Contractor a Parsi appointed as an
sculptor who visited Bombay recently creative wood carving
after 18 years in p—Tec
adds modestly, “yet really not there.
.Tudging from C— -----— - * < u
clippings of leading British papers Centre, Homchurcb:
that focus on him, however, he ap- same vear he was
Centre, Upminister and Duty Falls
¦ 'in March the
elected as a full
mar locus on lum, iiuw^wx, x.v. -y acixnv xx-
pears to have already attained fame, member to the Committee of National
An Associated Press photo-caption Society of Painters, Sculptors
of his hands working on a piece of Printmakers. In addition, the mema
ordinary blackboard chalk writes that has praised his works m glowing
Contractor “is possibly the on.y terms. _ ,
sculptor in the world who works in '------- ----- .
chalk. ” Twenty five of these delicately cepts graciously. However, , it is when
rnizder Ciavs that durinp his oresi- carved pieces, presented to the Queen he is talking of his art itself that e ’s
deSy,^the Indian Mercham Chambers on the silver jubUee of her reign most animated and_ etnobon^.
vdll tackle the burning problems ( one for each year ) stand in dis- p----- -- „ x v * i,
f^ng the business commumty, and play at the Buckin^am Pala^, he projections of P^^^^T^P^the whole
endeavour to bring about an economic says. According to his bio-data, he should see the original. . . the whole
revival of the country, according to has held three one-man exhibitions in
a Business India magazine report. 1972, 1975 and 1977 and partici-
“The main problems which are
retarding industrial growth in the and 1972;
same year he was
society of Painters, Sculptors and
Printmakers. In addition, the me^a
possibly the on.y terms.
•’ ’ X - These recognitions Contractor ac-
_____2 :: ¦¦ ¦ ’--“I
&king of his art itself that he ’S
protests against the one-dimension
' ’ --------------- “You
structure. . . the curves. . . .the intri
cate work. ..” His hands caressingly
and an
imaginery scalpel works its intricate
7
pated in two group exhibitions in 1970 trace the forms in the air
« *___ _ HAaImaI 1^0
in early 1978 he waswas when he was nine
Since then he has been
Ranina, a tax consultant, author and
advocate.
he recalls,
years old. ------
tr ansf orming these brittle pieces inti
works of art.
And now? His face glows as he
speculates at the possibility of giving
up his present job and working full-
time at his art. “Well. . . maybe, ” he
says.
Zoroastrian Bank
“L________ . . . . ___
middle class families to maintain their those
M
Valued Contributions
A Bengali-Hindu by birth, Jatindra
Mohan Chatterjee has authored 10
books on the Zoroastrian religion in
addition to several others that he has
v/ritten on our religion in Bengali. In
early November 1979, at the age of
_ _________ _____ 91, Chatterjee suffered a heart attack
‘It has become impossible for the which caused great concern among
_______ _ __ ____ ¦ ¦________ ’ ' ’ ____; in the community that knew
mini mum standard of living, which fijm. Mahyar B. Patel, a c ---- ,
level, ” R. A. Gagrat, president of
________________ ___ _______ ____ close friend
as it is, is barely above the subsistence gud associate of Chatterjee, submits
level, ” R. A. Gagrat, president of g brief life-sketch of the “Zoroastrian-
the Zoroastrian Co-operative Credit by-choice. ”
Bank Ltd., in a hardhitting address patel writes that Chatterjee, who
at the Annual General Meeting of was bom in 1888 in Sungar village m
the Bank on 11, October 1979, traced
the dilemma of the middle class fa
milies to
on t
ment ” on the economic front.
in a harxfiiitting address
Chalk sculptures by Contractor
way around an imaginary piece
ihen almost apologetically he
at of
chalk.
re-
a district of Dacca, graduated from
Calcutta University in 1912 with a
the “utter mismanagement Masters degree in Sanskrit. In 1917,
the part of the (Indian) Govern- fig joined Government service and it
___ ___ 2__ \ was during the years between 1924
The sum total of the Five Year and 1929 when he was posted at
Plans has been nothing but a catalogue Behrampur in the district of Murshi-
_________________ , of increased poverty, food shortages, dabad that he was first drawn to the
netrThat he is unable to devote his utter lack of cheap housing accomo- message of Prophet Zarathushtra. At
said Gagrat. editor of Cherag Magazine, provided
.iiiivxiv _ _____*,_____ _ J “It is the duty of the Government to him with a number of books and in-
him he repairs damaged valuable manage the country ’s economy effec- formation on the religion. Meanwhile
’ ¦ .................... ’ ------- « our Chatterjee started to teach himself
! Avesta
luii-ume attention to his art but must dations, insanitary conditions of living fiis request
work as a professional musical m- and growth of slums, ” said Gagrat. editor of C
strument restorer, that is, according
to ixU-iAj - -------- ----- ~
instruments like the violin, cello ana lively but, to the misfortune of
the like; “My bread and butter job/ ’ c- ’y
He is not complaining. He likes his maintainance of living standards has language from primary books,
woik. He is thankful that it allows been completely subordinated to poll- satisfied with the existing
him enou gh time to pursue his art. tical expediency and self-interest. ” translations of the sacred book of the
lhen pin king up a photograph: “You Gagrat also frayed the Government Zoroastrian religion he sought to inter-
should see tne origi^. . his hands [or its inability to maintain proper pret the Gathas in light of a compara-
start to lovingly trace the structure law and order in the country and the five study with the Vedas. He saw
through the air. “woefully unimaginative ” budget of similarities between the Spenta and
Eighteen years ago. Contractor February 1979 which he felt was Angra Mainyu of the Gathas and die
country, orderly development and Gujarati, Persian and the
the like; “My bread and butter job. ’
tnankfui that it allows been completely subordinated to poli-
------- .. --I ----- J.------- self-4nterest. ”
was
says he set sad for Errand to pursue “positively detrimental to the eco- Satwa and Tamas Gunas of the Vedas,
his art and hopefully to be an assistant nomy ” and which led to all —around He believed that Zarathushtra was the
to the famous artist Henry More. He “inflationery pressure on almost all first Universal Prophet who enjoined
severe monotheism, anioonism, cast-
The results of the bank for the year equality, universal brotherhood
‘very satis- Sufi doctrine owes its, existence to the
_____ ____ > froni Gathas of Zarathushtra.
_ __ ____ In the last year ’s level of Rs 82,81, 471 to In his book The Hymns of Athar-
he got married to an Rs 89, 61, 552 while total loans and van Zarathushtra, Chatterjee writes:
Zarathushtra is mother to me,
He is father to me.
Zarathushtra is my friend,
He is my beloved.
Zarathushtra is my all-in-all.
None else I know
—None
Ji
844 to Rs 38, 37, 392. Net profits for
sculpture and modelling against last year ’s figure of Rs 3, 12,
]04. 64. Total reserves at the year
end were Rs 20, 88, 046, against Paid
up Share Capital of Rs 5, 91, 975.
The 3,645 share holders of the Bank
I
adds, that circumstances forced him commodities of necessities of life. ”
to defer his dream as the right open - The results of the bank for the year equality, universal brotherhood and
• log just did not present itself, but that ending 30, June 1979 were, however, militancy . He also believes that the
did not deter him. He took up various according to Gagrat, ----- ----
other jobs and when time permitted factory ”. Total deposits rose
involv^ himself in his art. 1“ -----
meanwhile, o-’--------- - ¦ ¦ .
Enghsh girl and presently resides overdrafts were up from Rs 30, Id,
with her at Essex. 844 to Rs 38, 37, 392. Net profits for
Born in 1929 tn Bombay, Contrac- the year were Rs 3, 41, 263, 31 ^as
tor studied f
at the Sir J. J. School of Art in Bom
bay for five years to obtain a diploma
in modelling. After graduation,
cording to his bio-data, he was — j, t,
ployed by the Archaeological will receive dividends of 12% or Rs
Department of the Government of 3 per share which have a face value
India, to restore major sculptures of of Rs 25.
the rock-temples of EUora, Ajanta — ---------- -------- j t. i ? i. .i
and the Elephanta Caves. From a very joined the Managing Committee of tion of India and P^istan he left au
early age, he had been carving black- the Bank. They were T. R. Andhya- bis property back in Pakistan and
board chalk, his first chalk sculpture, rujina, a leading advocate and H. P. came to reside in India. At his new
ac-
em-
the
In 1947, Chatterjee resigned from
the government service when he was
During the year two new members the Deputy Collector. With the parti-
j
I
s
!!
9
1I
and games for children organized by
the Public Relations committee, now
in the second year of its existence.
Other activities of the PPP includtO
financial assistance to deserving ap
plicants of the weaker sections of the
\ the Education
residence at Barasat, 15 miles north
of Calcutta, the pictures of Zarathu-
shtra, Sri Ramachandra and Sri Krishna
are enshrined in what is known as the
‘Rudra Mandir ’ and therein Chatterjee
recites passages from the Gathas, the
Prisni and the Gita in his daily prayers.
Patel adds that Chatterjee was
felicitated twice by the community. ______
First in 1967 by the Parsis of Calcutta ed a socio-economic survey of the
who presented him with a shawl of community in Delhi (see ^ticle in this
honour and a silver salver inscribed issue); in Poona a committee to sup-
with a message of esteem and affec- ervise and attend the religious cere-
tion. Again in 1972 the community monies performed under ^the
reportedly on behalf of the entire has been established according to th?
c ommuni ty, with an address in which annual report of the PPP for the year
he was thanked for his contributions ending December 1978; and inJHy-
in the field of Gathic literature. - - - ¦—
The list of books authored by Chat
terjee are;
Ethical Conceptions of the Gathas- , „
1931 Gathas —1932, Prisni Gatha — that in addition to an upward revision
1934, Ramachandra and Zarathushtra of the salaries of the mobeds, agiary
—1935, The Hymns of Athravan and Anjuman “d
Zarathushtra —1967, Athravan Zara- the Anjuman has also insured the life
thushtra —The Foremost Prophet —
1971, Message of the Gatha as
Reflected in the Masnavi of Moulana
Jalal-ud-din Rumi —1971, The Gospel mobeds with
of Zarathushtra in the Words of deposit
Moulana Jalal-ud-din Rumi —1972, ----------------— „ . , , - ¦,
Visnu and Mazda —1975, The Origin Ughts two public lectures of Zora- view of the unproved econonuc con-
of Sufism —1978. ‘-------- ---------- -
Annual Reports
A number of anjumans and pancha-
yats in India are showing greater
social, religious and cultural aware
ness in extending their activities be- IlVOd 111 UlVll WN/VX T x: • xV 1%
yond managing and administering cornm^ity tmough
Ut properfe Reoenfly the DelU and Doles S^S-nu
Pa™ Anhiman initiated and snonsor- awards to seven outstanding studens
trust 1 .
Parsi Anjuman initiated and sponsor
and two sportsmen, and the securing
of wool from the Bombay P^i Pan-
chayat for the Zoroastnan ladies who
v/eave kustis for a living. The report
adds that 24 new members signed up
cEtta*^ honoured ^atterjee, of the Poona Parsi Panchayat (PPP) to Ae body S^^e U a ^al s^ength
.fAdiv hpbnif of the entire has been estabUshed according to th? of S
were held during the period.
Assets of the Panchayat recorded
in
ccwmmunity, with an address in which annual report of the PPP for the year
I of Trustees
held during the period.
derabad and Secunderabad, the Parsi -------- - -
Zoroastrian Anjuman of the Twin city in the audited^ statement of
reports in its tri-annual report for the are over 16.5 lac ru^es, up y
years ending December 1975 to 1977, 1.3 lac rupees over the previous yea s
^ound 1.65 lac rupees, only
figures; while the income for the year
was <------ - -”
staff and Nassasalais, marginally higher than 1977.
ux.v _ ______ ______________ The report from Secunderabad and
of one^mobed and one chasniwalla at Hyderabad, records that the Anjuman
an annual cost of a little over Rs. has been able to obtain exemption for
1,000 and further covered two other all the Anjuman ’s trust prr^erty from
a monthly cumulative the Andhra Pradesh Budding (Lease,
,1, ~Z,‘- Rent and Eviction) Control Act,
The PPP annual report also high- I960. The exemption was stl
Road, Secunderabad 500003. I
Merchants
under the auspices of the Bombay are
Parsi Panchayat (BPP), is in the
philanthropic market of the commu- i-------------- * . -
nity to raise funds for the construction in an appeal note that presently Were
of building on land owned by the is no movie film record of the suf-
BBP’ the Poona Parsi Panchayat has ficient part ” the Parsi commumty h^
submitted plans for the approval of played “in the development of poh-
the city municipality for the construe- tical, economic, cultural and sinted mobeds in addition to pro- is used to keep the fire of its agiary
Members to the advisory board of viding them with free boarding and aglow. An appeal note in Gujarati
the project are Piloo H. Mody, lodging, writes N. B. Captain honorary explains that the price of wood is
former M. P. and president of the treasurer of the D.P.A presently three times what it was a
Akhil Bhartiya Deenbandhu Congress Further, the Trustees are also con- year ago and that this has placed a
—Cultural Division, Dr. Peshotan B. sidering the construction of separate tremendous stress on the limited
Warden, founder of Akhand Parsa priests ’ quarters in the near future, funds of the Anjuman.
and ex-editor of Parsiana, Mahiyar an undertaking, they note, “which Donors may send cheques in favour
B. Patel, Secretary of the Iranian will involve heavy capital expend!- of the Agiary ’s President, Maneksha
Zoroastrian Anjuman and Noshir ture. ” In addition the Anjuman has N. Botawalla to the Igatpur Zarthosty
S. Pochkhanawala, an industrial also agreed to grant an ex-gratia pay- Anjuman, Igatpuri.
consultant. ment of Rs 15,000 over three years
Noted industrialist Naval Tata is to the widow of Head Priest Ervad SPOTLIGHT
reported to have already contributed Daraius Bagli who died early in 1979 Dilnawaz Variava was one of the
Rs 10,000 to the project from the after serving the capital city for more Indians among the 20 foremost
Navajbai Tata Trust. Donors are re- than 25 years. wild life conservationists who were
quested to send cross and order Names of all persons who donate awarded the Order of the Golden Ark
cheques in favour of “V. C. Enter- Rs 1,000 and above will be inscribed jpyg award which was creat-
rises ” or “Akhli Bhartiya Deen- on a marble tablet placed inside the founder president of the
bandhu Congress —Cultural Division ” agiary. Drafts, and cheques should be YVorld Life Fund Prince Bernhard of
to V. C. Enterprises, 7/1 J. K. Build- made in favour of “Delhi Parsi An- Netherlands, is in recognition *
ing, H. G. Road, Gamdevi, Bombay, juman ” and sent to the Honorary gpggial services to conservation.
Treasurer, Delhi Parsi Anjuman,_Ba-
Agiary Maintenance Fund 1 - - - - - _ - • ... __ _ __ —,
Appealing to the generosity of New Delhi 110002. Captain adds; Centr^^Bank of India, Hyderabad
“Parsis adl ovw India and the Chari- nuaUfy t-nx erm- . ----- ,—--------:
table Trusts of our community ” the cessions under section 806 of the In
rf
• A. • mWA tIVVi) VKZ T • •
Treasurer, Delhi Parsi Anjuman, Ba
hadur aah ZafM^aj^, Delhi Gate, Mehta chief manager,
“‘donations will qualify for tax con- j.eoio]i, won the best member recogni-
tion for 1979 awarded by the Indian
Society for Training and Development.
. The award is for his overall contribu
tion in furthering the Society ’s activi
ties in the area of human resource
development. ..
The Zoroastrian Co-operative
Credit Bank Limited
Earn interest upto 10|% on Fixed Deposit Account
and 5|% on Savings Bank Accounts
Mr Namdar Feredoon Kermmi
was recently appointed as the Assis
tant Police Commissioner for Bombay.
The former Police Inspector, who
started his career with the police
force as a sub-inspector in 1947, has
worked on many successful cases and
has been in charge of a number of
police stations all over the city. As
Assistant Police Commissioner he is
in charge of the Police Welfare
Division. ..
Feredoon
Loans and Overdrafts granted on moderate terms.
16, HORNIMAN CIRCLE BOMBAY 400 023.
Phone : 29 89 87
Mr Rusi K. Darawala has been ap
pointed as the new Chairman of the
General Insurance Corporation of
India. Daruwala, who started his
career as an assistant in the Actuarial
Department of the New India As
surance Company, was the General
Manager of the Corporation before
his recent appointment. ..
15ZOROASTRIANS ABROAD
“FIRE PEOPLE” OF PAKISTAN
Though the Pakistan Parsis
number around five to six thou
sand they have made a substantial
contribution to the country. In
an article in the May, 1977 issue
of the Karachi monthly, The
Herald, Khorshed Laskari wrote
about the Zoroastrian community
in Pakistan. We carry here ex
tracts from her article “ The
Fire People.”
Pakistan
the community. The Parsis, both men
and women are well-educated. They
show a preference for business and
industry' and professions such as law,
medicine, and teaching. Some h.ive
retired from the army as oflScers, and
a few young men are now serving as
officers, or studying as cadets in the
armed forces. Very few Parsis are
serving in high government posts
Mr S. Poonegar is a PCS officer at
Quetta. Two Parsis have been in the
diplomatic service for many years
with postings all over the world. They
are ambassadors Mr Jamshed Marker
and Mr J. G. Kharas. Mr Justice
Dorab F. Patel was appointed as a
judge of the Supreme Court of
Pakistan.
The Parsis of Karachi have taken School.
a keen interest in civic life. There The most notable group achieve-
have been several mayors, health ment of Parsi women in Karachi is
officers. Chief officers an^ engineers the systematic administration of the
] ’ ’• --___ - . -__ - "
The most outstanding was Mr Jamshed This organisation
Nusservanji Mehta, known as ............................
“Maker of Modern Karachi. ”
Several women are running their own
business, like hairdressing, confec
tionery, sari embroidery and interior
decoration with great success.
Rashna Homji, a Parsi girl from
Karachi gained plaudits as a solo
dancer with the Royal Ballet in
London.
Dr Ms Vera C. Cowasjee is a Ph.D
in Archaeology and holds the disctinc-
tion of being the first Asian lady to
get this degree from the Institute of
Archaeology, University of London.
Her subject is the art history of Iran,
with special reference to the Achae-
raenian Period.
Principals of both the Parsi schools
are women —Ms Dina Mis try at BVS
and Ms Mani Contractor at Mama
The Parsis first began trickling into
the Pakistan region in 1825—nearly
twenty years before the British annex
ed Sind. They made it in the fast
prospering Karachi. They went about
the task of ameliorating their own
commimity. For over fifty years the
Eduljee Dinshaw family have led in
building low cost houses for _Ae
poor and middle-class Parsis. ~
Lady Dufferin Hospital and innumer- . „
able public dispensaries as also the “Maker of Modern Karachi. He of social meetings and welfare work.
NED Engineering College were set up served as the head of the municipality in recent years its sphere of activities
by the Dinshaw family. Sir Kavasji lor thirteen years until 1934. He was has been greatly expanded with
Katrak was another prominent known all over the sub-continent as generous donations earmarked for
philanthropist of Karachi who gave " 4 _ x._
away large sums f ' -
other welfare projects. father of the Scouts Movement m
The Katrak Hall and the Katrak Karachi. He was also elected to the education^
in civic life. There
The
in the Karachi Municipal Corporation. Karachi Zarathosti Banu Mandal.
___ __1____ 1 for women was
the founded in 1912 with the joint aims
another prominent known all over the sub-continent as generous donations earmarked tor
xxxvx^lxl „ixw a dedicated social worker and philan- various welfare projects. Energetic
for housing and thropist. He was regarded as the sub-committees have been appointed
other weffare projects. father of the Scouts Movement in each department —Poor Welfare
The Katrak Hall and the Katrak Karachi. He was also elected to the education. Medical Relief Rehabili-
Building for the Sind Red Crescent Sind Assembly, though he refused to tation and Child Welfare. The best
Society are two of his munificences, join any party. physicians, surgeons and specialists
The Cowasjee family has also found- Parsis were pioneers of the modern willingly render free service for poor
ed various charitable institutions. The hotel business in Pakistan. The Beach patients. The Banu Mandal now has
century-old Bai Virbaijee Sopariwalla Luxury Hotel of Karachi, started by its own spacious premises known as
Boys School and the Mama Parsi Mr Dinshaw B. Avari, is thirty years the Manijah Mehta Hall donated by
Girls School, both now open to all old. Hotel Metropole was established the son of a devoted past President
communities, ’ were started by Parsi soon afterwards by the late Mr Cyrus jn her memory. Situated in the park
philanthropists. The BN Minocher- F. Minwalla, and is now run by his the Katrak Parsi Colony, it is a
homji Parsi General Hospital, started son Mr Darius Minwalla, who is convenient and pleasant place for
in 1935 moved into its own premises also connected with Hyatt ’s Regency y^ork and play. There is a monthly
later on with the help of donors who in Karachi. Mr D. B. Avari has now function for which members are
continue to aid it regularly. The established Avari Hotels Ltd., which charged a nominal fee.
beautiful Clifton Parade and Pier, includes the Karachi and Lahore p. uiay be a cooking session or a
opened in 1921, was a gift of Sir Hiltons. flower demonstration, a lecture or
Jehangir Kothari, a rich businessman Parsis have shown scant interest in seminar, a picnic, an educational ex-
¦' " ' ’• ”---------. cursion to factories or archaeology
public. * tan People Party issued a ticket to a sites as far afield as Mohenjodaro.
There are now a little over 5,000 Parsi, Mr Hoshang H. Broacha, to The Mandal is a registered social
jtiiaugu ivvvnuii, « __________ PaTsls ha VC shown scant interest in
and intrepid traveller, to the Karachi politics. However, in 1976 the Pakis-
public. I------- X - , .
There are now a little over 5,000 Parsi, Mr Hoshang H. Broacha, to — ---------
Parsis in Pakistan concentrated mainly represent all the minority communi- v/elfare body and its work was lauded
¦ in Karachi. Several new settlers came ties of Karachi, and was elected un- by the visiting government inspector,
with the opening of job opportunities opposed to the former Sind Assembly, as was reported at the annual general
after partition. Some migration to US Parsi women in Pakistan are march- meeting. The Managing Committee is
and Canada, especially among the ing with the times. Teaching, medicine composed of a dedicated band of
young, is taking place these days for and nursing had long been favoured ladies rendering selfless service. The
higher education and employment in professions. Now both married and un- Banu Mandal is often approached by
foreign countries. married women are employed in offices APWA, Red Crescent and other
Lahore and Quetta have small in large numbers as stenographers and organisations for help in collecting
Parsi colonies of about 150 Parsis secretaries to supplement the family funds for regular relief work or in
each. The Bhandaras in Lahore and income. Some Parsi girls are air- • * • ’ ’ —
the Markers in Quetta are leaders of hostesses with PIA and other airlines.
ties of Karachi, and was elected un- by the visiting government inspector,
as was 1.,—., 1
Parsi women in Pakistan are march- meeting. The Managing Committee is
times of national emergencies.
Other Parsi organisations of Karachi
17Zoroastrian Iranian languages and literature. Here
for a brilliant Parsi took his education
literary activities. It has a library. The and was installed as the High Priest
K JlTflCni Po-poi Mln,..__ 3 _ ______J. _P -rr . ]^^09 J J
was Shams-ul-Ulema Dastur Dr M.
J a
wise
and learned, who served the Parsis m
has a 67- all parts of the world through his
fetremely well-read, widely travel
led and broad minded, his well-
some balanced wews and authoritative
- of teachings were of immense value to
X . - com- those willing to learn. He died in
munity functions. Pages in English 1956 and even today his books on all
are also included occasionally. aspects of Iranian civilisation are
Parsi men and women have always frank as he himself was during his
taken a keen interest in eastern and ministership. Dastur Dr Dhalla not
western music. The pianist Mr. only studied the past, but was a keen
Ferose Buchonie took up the study observer of the way of life of the
of music seriously. He went to Parsis of his day whom he strove to
Europe on a scholarship and studied divert at the right path when neces-
music under the celebrated Alfred sary. “Righteousness rests on the in-
are 1 _____ ____
Association founded mainl y
Karachi Parsi Institute played a great of the'karachrParSs' in
part in fostenng sports in the city, Giiama-ui-Uivuia Dasiur lyr
holding cricket matches and tennis N. DhaUa, M.A., Ph.D., D.Litt.,
tournaments. It serves as a recreation - • - -
club for members and their families.
The Parsi commimity I__ _ _
year-old Gujarati bi-weekly paper, eloquence and writings.
Parsi Sansar edited originally by Mr " ' - -
Perzeshaw Dastur and now by his son,
Mr Meherji Dastur. Besides :
general news, there are articles
interest to Parsis and reports of ?
are also included occasionally.
T- •
taken a keen interest
most distinguished personality,
QUEBEC
Small is Beautiful
“Our strength is our smallness. ” says
Ms Dolly Dastoor, president of the
Zoroastrian Association of Quebec
who was on a recent visit to Bombay.
Dastoor estimates that there are about
150 Zoroastrian families, many of
whom have taken up citizenship,
living in the Canadian province
though not all are members of the
Association. Most of them Dastoor
adds, are highly qualified profession
als and a number of them have also
established their own business there.
The Association, one of the oldest
on the North American continent,
was established in 1967. Apart from
the regular meeting and functions
arranged to celebrate festive days, the
association has prepared cassette re
cordings of Zoroastrian prayers, the
Cortot On'his rrtum'’he wmtedT ‘'Righteousness rests on the in- ?o “uVSWcompilSon ‘’ind°^S-
Karachi. He has given many piano Again, Zoroastrian virtues have made visits bv Zoroastrian scholars to tail-
Fo^di o?thi^?t"hl
director. life of fjje teeming millions of India. ” ‘‘Beine out there we reallv want to
. In the early years of this century, Reprinted with permission from May nreserve the reUoion h
a chair existed at Columbia Univer- 1977 issue of The Herald: copyright The faced with Xfdc thTe'f?^
sity, New York, lor the study of A„ re.r,eA. Sen™?i^-Xlat “°To S
auspices^ of the^ Music munity has secured a pioneer place in
social, intellectual, and industrial
With Compliments of
ADI B. SACAR & CO
Electrical Engineers & Contractors
Bombay.
19sure up to the task she believes the
asswiation “will have to create the
environment, which is very diffi cult**
and will involve taking steps that may
appear unorthodoxy. In regard to
inter-communal marriages, the Asso
ciation accepts the non-Parsi spouses
and children of such unions into the
community regardless of whether the
husband or wife is Zoroastrian.
Though no request for a Navjote
ceremony of a person of non-Zoroas-
trian parentage has been received as
yet, such a request in the future will
in all probability be okayed by the
Association. “We are not trying to
become radical, ” Dastoor states. “We
are concerned about preserving the
religion...we have to look at the
future. ”
Presently the association is consi
dering the feasibility of having a
place, “a little centre, ” of its own, but
Dastoor adds “there are so many pro
blems... who will look after it? Who
will finance it?...we are so small. ”
Yet she is hopeful and confident in
the future of the community in
Canada. To illustrate the degree to
which the community has integrated
into the “multi-cultured ” Canadian
community she points out that greet-
ings are beamed over TV and radio
stations on 21 March each year to
mark the Zoroastrian New Year.
noted freedom fighter and theosoph-
ist. which we reproduce here:
AUSTRALIA
The-first-small-giant-step
With the establishment of the First
Building Fund Committee the Zoroas
trian Association of New South
Wales., Australia, has begun to realize
the creation of a Zoroastrian Founda
tion in Australia. Purviz Kolsawalla,
president of the Association, focuses
on the embryonic vision in the
March issue of the newsletter of the
Association: “I would like to em
phasise again the self reliance and
effort to be put in by our community
to get this project off the ground and
achieve our cherished dream. There
are no ‘soft ’ options in this issue and
constructive help and generous dona
tions from all of us, 5ong with the
blessings of Ahura Mazda, will get
the desired results. ”
Members of the Building Fund
Committee are; Farrokh Mistree,
Minoo Batliwalla, Purviz Kolsawalla
and Dr Peshotan Katrak.
The newsletter also includes for the
interest of its readers a speech made
in 1906 by Ms Annie Beasant, the
AWAKE O ZOROASTRIAN
“O my Parsi brothers our Prophet
is not dead. He hag not perished. He
is watching over the religion that he
founded: ever seeking to raise it from
its present degradation, to give it back
its lost knowledge, its lost powers.
What nobler work for the Zoroastrian
of today than to permeate his brethren
with the ancient fire, to relight its
blaze on the spiritual altar of their
hearts: What nobler work than to
study his own Scriptures, and to go
forth and teach the ancient learning
with the authority and power that can
only be wielded, by men of the same
faith with those he addresses. The
fire is not dead; is only smouldering
on its ancient altars; white-hot are the
ashes, ready to reburst into flames.
And 1 dream of a day when the
breath of the great Prophet Zarathu-
shtra. shall sweep again through His
temples, fanning the ashes on the
altars of those ancient flames, and
evety altar shall flash into fire, and
again from heaven the answering
flames shall f^ll, making the Zoroas
trian religion once more what it ought
WITH BEST COMPLIMENTS
FROM
MAZDA MANUFACTURING
COMPANY
No. 6 Datta Mandir Road,
Bhandup,
Bombay-400 078.
Manufacturers of Hospital Equipment and Heavy Duty
Industrial Kitchen Equipment.
21to be, a beacon light for the souls of book Hi No Michi, which translates to
men, one of the greatest religions of Wnxr Pw” Kv
the world ”.
"The Way of Fire ”, by Seicho
Matsumoto suggests that the answer
is ‘yes ’. Pavri states that the book
presents enough evidence to lend
credibility to the theory that a section
of the Zoroastrian religion did reach
Japan via China. “The book of course
: North has many things which are not easy
the 16th to agree with, ”he adds “but related
the observations do indicate the presence
might of Zoroastrians in Japan. ”
“ Pavri also points out the popular
CANADA
Did you know
Did you know that a ‘Zarathushtra ’s
Temple ’ has existed in the
American continent since 1
Century? That one branch of
•great migration ’ from Iran
have reached Japan? That the Zoro- ____ ____ ,
estrian influence is apparent in the reception the Japanese market accord-
Dead Sea Scrolls? These enlightening ed to the issue of the book. Since its
it-might-interest-you articles are car- first publication by Bungei Shunju
ried by the newsletters of Quebec and Sha Publishers of Tokyo in November
Ontario. 1975 seven editions hit the market by
July 1976. Further N.K.H.—T.V.
‘Zarathnshtra ’s Temple’ started to broadcast programmes
The article, “Zarathushtra ’s Temple based upon the book in April 1976.
in the New World, ’’ by Phiroz
Dastoor of Brassard Quebec, appears Dead Sea Scrolls,
in the ZAQ publication Gavashni. The influence of Zoroastrianism on
Dastoor writes that ‘Zarathushtra ’s the Dead Sea Scrolls, believed to be
Temple, ’ which took millions of the earliest known record of the Bible
years to build, stands at a height and other Hebrew texts written bet-
of 7,136 feet and is said to guard the ween the 1st century BC and th©
Angel Creek of the Grand Canyon first half of the 1st century AD and
Valley in the U.S.A. The ‘I'emple ’, discovered in the caves near the Dead
• however, is not really a temple where Sea, is indicated in the book by J.
people go to pray, but is only a name Lewis, Religion oj the World Made
given to one of the many towering Simple. Pulti Byram] ee submits com-
mountainlike structures that the Colo- rnents from the book, Appendix B:
rado River and the forces of nature ‘The World ’s Great Sacred Books, ”
have carved into the Grand Canyon in a newsletter of the ZSO.
Valley over millions of years. When ____ __ ,
the first Spanish immigrants visited the to a small community which had
Grand Canyon around 1540 they withdrawn from the Hasmonean King-
“started naming some of these awe dom and established themselves in
inspiring structures rightly after the monasteries in isolated situations.
(American) Indian tribes, ” says Here they lived lives of renunciation
Dastoor. “Sometimes, the grand struc- and discipline while waiting for the
tures were called by mythological End of the Age. This would take the
names of Gods and prophets of the form of a War of the Children of
Old World. The size, shape and colour Light against the Children of Dark-
have no relationship with the names. ’ ness. In this struggle God would
The book. Grand Canyon, by B. H. intervene and destroy the wicked. ”
Granger which mentions the ‘temple ’ The Manual of Discipline tells ,is
comments on the prophet thus : that “the influence of Zoroastrianism
“Zarathushtra was the founder of is clearly seen here for there is a
what was for generations the national cosmic conflict between the Powers of
religion of the Perso-Iranian people. Darkness and Light. AU men must
He is believed to have lived around belong to one or other of these powers.
700 B.C. He was the founder of the The conflict goes on not only in the
wisdom of The Magi, rejecting the world but in the heart of man. 'ITius
myriad gods of his age in favour of the doctrine reflects a basic dualism,
' concentration on the spirit of good. ” closely connected with subsequent
“For location of the Zarathushtra ’s doctrine of Original Sin. Note also
Canyon, Zarathushtra ’s Temple in ‘The that every man is endowed at birth
Heart of the Grand Canyon ” Dastoor either with the Spirit of Light or the
writes “see a beautifully coloured map Spirit of Darkness... Zoroastrianism
of Grand Canyon in National Geo- is also reflected in the doctrine of a
graphics Vol. 154, No. l,p.32 (1978).” Day of Judgement and the punishment
of the wicked. It should not be sup-
Zoroastrians in Japan? posed that this is an essentially Hebrew
“Were There Zoroastrians in doctrine, nor is it purely Christain. It
Japan? ” Jamshed K. Pavri asks in the is an importation from Zpro-
title of his article in Gavashni. The astrianism. ”
“These important documents refer
a ! “ ¦ •” ’ "
There in
Handicrafts
and
Gifts for festive
occasions
Gifts&
the gift shop at
Bombay Swadeshi
Stores Ltd.,
Sir P. M. Road,
Bombay 400 001.
Tel : 253443
23NEWS FROM THE MEDIA
The Case of the Short-sighted supervision. In despair, the unhappy about to prove it to the world. He
lawyer wrote a letter to a man he dr;?'t?- -----
When the creator of fiction ’s most believed would save him —Sir Arthur case. His literary activities were shelv-
enduring sleuth, (Sherlock Holmes > Conan Doyle,
turned detective himself. Sir Arthur
Conan Doyle did more than save dam
sels from specked vipers or young
Lords from spectral hounds. In real
life. Sir Arthur rescued a coloured
man from criminal charges framed by
a biased police force. The persecuted
innocent was Geo^e Shapurji Edalji,
a solicitor living in Great Wyhrley
near Birmingham.
As the surname suggests, Edalji was
of Parsi descent. In spite of being born
in Britain, he was somehow regarded
by the local residents as an immigrant
with no moral and social sense. So
when certain bizarre crimes took place
in the neighbourhood, the police force
reasoned that the culprit could be
only the ‘sinister ’ Asian.
The crimes were out of the ordinary.
In Great Wyrley, a number of horses Sir Arthur Conan Doyle,
and ponies had been attacked at night
and slashed with a sharp instrument.
The mutilated animals were then left __ _____
to die. Coinciding with this savage out- stories had demonstrated a unique .
break of cattle-ripping was a stream method of scientific deduction. After we ask the public of Gr^t Bntain
of anonymous letters in which the all, it was Conan Doyle ’s own whether this is to go on. ^e nnpas-
gory deeds were praised. “There ’ll be experience of life which led him to sioned columns animated Sir Arthur s
merrier times in November, ” some of portray so vividly a character with compatnots to take up the persecut-
the unsigned letters exulted, “when whom he had much in common. But ed lawyer s case wholelwartedly. Street
we ’ll begin with little girls! ” more important than intellectual deiiionstrations and a flt^ of letters
Village gossip had already branded acumen were qualities of heart. He to the editors testified to their support,
the alien inhabitant as the offender. A had earned a reputation as a fighter Overm^t, George Edalji became hero
_ __ _ • 1 X-4-P nil +
wrote: “Many are the theories pro- prejudice as much as he detested
George Edalji goes out in the night
1 ¦ ¦ ¦___
idea is that he makes nocturnal sacri- Sir Arthur found Edalji reading a
fices to strange gods. ” newspaper ’------------------
On August 18, 1903, the police eyes and rather sideways. “Mr. Edalji, ’
arrested George Edalji on fabricated hie enquired, “Don ’t you suffer from crusading against the
charges of ripping a pony the previous astigmatic myopia? ” The swiftly drawn might of British bureaucracy,
night. He was later tried by a bigoted conclusion was as accurate as r"; r...
magistrate who accepted laughable Holmes ’ own. “Surely, this point was
testimonials as truth and finally sen- raised at your trial ”
tenced him to a staggering seven ye.ais" “Sir, ” replied Edalji, “I wanted to
• penal servitude. “Lord, have mercy on call an optician as witness but my legal . .. - . , -
us, ” cried EdaJji ’s mother as her son advisers said the evidence against me alleged he may have written the inde-
disappeared behind bars. was so palpably ridiculous that they cent letters. Result : a pardon but no
— wouldn ’t bother. ” compensation for the illegal
Conan Doyle reasoned that if Edalji imprisonment.
............................. If Sir Arthur was not pleased witii
the imperfect resolution of the Great
of fiction ’s most
J
The creator of Sherlock
was gifted for the occasion. His short
devoted around a year ’s work to the
case. His literary activities were shelv
ed, his political ambitions side-lined
and he generously met all the expenses
a fact-finding study entailed.
On January 11, 1907, the resolu
tion of the mystery unfolded. The
Daily Telegraph published an article
by Conan Doyle in which the lid over
the Edalji case was ripped off. The
author effortlessly demolished the
evidence against the young Parsi
gentleman, asserting that he had been
persecuted purely out of animosity
towards coloured people. He condemn
ed the strange manner in which the
prisoner had been set free without a
clearcut acquittal. The home office,
he declared, was aware that Edalji was
inoncent, but would not own up its
* mistake.
In powerfully-written prose, he
sought to rouse the Britishers ’ fabled
sense of fair play. “The door of of
ficialdom is shut in our faces, ” he
Holmes affirmed. “Now we turn to the last
tribunal of all, a tribunal which never
errs when facts are laid before it, and
important than
more
Village gossip had already branded acumen were qualities of heart. He
reporter from the Express and Star for the underdog, detesting colour^ of
pounded in the local ale-houses why racial or religious antipathy.
George Edalji goes out in the night They met by appointment in the
to slay cattle and a widely accepted foyer of Grand Hotel, Charing Cross.
The public outcry compelled the
home office to act. A committee of
three men was set up to examine the
question whether it was really Edalji
who ripped cattle or wrote anoymous
fices to strange gods. ” newspaper which he held close to his letters.
On August 18, 1903, the police eyes and rather sideways. “Mr. Edalji, ’ Sir Arthur did not realize he was
arrested George Edalji on fabricated he enquired, “Don ’t you suffer from crusading against the monolithic
« ..a. ... a X^aa FTM * 1 .1________ laiiM/vAimwn ZtT r ' J
any of three-man committee ignored his vital
findings and came up with a report
seeking of bias and diplomatic com
promise. While conceding that Edalji
was innocent of cattle-ripping, they
cried EdaJji ’s mother as her son
for
Then, in 1906, Edalji was inexpli
cably released. There was no word
of pardon. The home office did not was so short-sighted in daylight,^ he
say whether he was guilty or innocent. LL -----
For Edalji, living in this limbo of ‘free- at night. To expect such a man to Wyrley mystery, the chief protagonist,
but-guilty ’ was agonising. He had beer stalk ponies and maim them at n?d- George Edalji, was more than content
struck off the roll of solicitors and night was absurd. Convinced of the He had been welcomed back to the
could not practice while under police lawyer ’s innocence. Sir Arthur set roll of solicitors and The Daily Tele
25
would have to grope his way outdoorsn esiring to enshrine his memory in municipal corporation will repair the
¦ - ro mmi ttee fountain, as it has renovated another
For, it is not just a fountain and
, :;3?. :___ -j the of deigning it to the then municipal Persia lives on here,
celebrities like Jerome chief engineer, Remzi Walton.
Walton styled his work on Persian
__ __ _______ ____ architecture of 2,500 years ago. Then 25 Jan. 1980
ed'*GeOTge "shapurjfE^ji, the talent- on three sides of this square struemre,
selected fr rJanets Aseranan DOmts out
other animals have c —------ - ,
yearly stint through the planet. Though that the animals , -J
feese animals have been an endearing tjie Zodiac si^ r *
fratiire of Navroz the sigmficance and ----- , . „
origins of their dissociation with tlie or fish for Pisces, scales for Libra etc.
FaS calendar remain relatively were, however, abk to dajw^^^
obscure and in the sphere of specula
tion in the Bombay community. -
into txx*. . .— -— -
by the Fasli calendar. The year of the
goat ¦ ¦ ”
are
actually referring to the year of
Best Wishes
I vy uiivtx ***•»*' J——— £-------------- X 1 , • I
wifi return after a span of with. ” Patel suspeefe
completed their not the planets. Asganan pomts out
—¦ • - . —1, jjjg symbols of
more popular signs like a lion to Leo,
on the correspondence between the
animals and the Zodiac signs
or
____'Ll 111 VIKV -- --------------- ------------
Ervad Sorabji, the Irani boyewala pipets,
at t -- -------- ,
Fountain area speculates with reser
vations that the custom
been borrowed from Chinese astro
logy. “I don ’t know when the custom
suspect that it was existent even during of the m<^ey “But I, don ’t
the time of the Sasanians, ” he says. how grod all this is, he adds.
What might be expected from the
Year of the Monkey? “All this
,1« Dadiseth Agi^p; a Bomws the Monkey? “AU Ws is
must have really astrology and not religion. ”
Sorabji pleads. He points out that the
I uuii I xuww _ _____ _ ___ foitunes of the year depend on the
fii^Inkod^ced "into T^'^but l characteristics of fee pl^et ^d not
“Presently we are in the year of the
^(i goat which is supposed to be the best
“It must have come from China, ’’
says Mahyar Patel, secretary <— - -
trisuier of the Iranian Zoroastrian of *e ^twelve. But tos year wa^
/TUIXJ 1*11 -----------------------------—
astrians interviewed agree with this ,
view. G. R. Asgarian, the Iraman < ___
in Bombay, however, protests against on 16 February 1980 wnt^;
____<«Tx ____________ nr, ” Incrers sav the Year of the
treasurer of the Iranian zoroasirian uv»v±vv. -
Anjuman, and most of the Irani Zoro- really bad. See what has happened in
view. G. R. Asgarian, the Iranian A Tmes of Mia t^a on 4e
financial manager of the Iran Air ofBce Chin^ new year (46781 which feU
I-
the suggestion. “It is purely Iranian,' ’'
he states and then adds; “however,
(he custom is so old and at that time
there was a lot of cross-cultural influ- peaceJ
ence between
and the Chinese that it might be pos- • rr * • *
’ sible that it has a common cultural Centre and Iram Zoroastn^s wntact-
base. ” He believes the practice exist- ®d professed litfle knowledge beyond
ed even durmg the times of Danus
the Great.
The literature on Navroz provided
by the Iranian Consulate in Bombay
and available at the libraries of the
Iranian Cultural Centre, Bombay, and , ,
the Cama Oriental Institute makes no completely ignorant of the custom,
mention of associating animals with “I’m hearing of it for fee first time,
the new year. . said one. “Isn ’t it Chinese? ” said
All agree that fee custom is based another. “What ’s feis monkey busi
on astrology. Sorabji explains. “Just ness about? ” queued yet another.
: -'Asti-o-
logers say the Year of the Monkey
will be inauspicious, bringing floods
and disasters followed by a period of
the Iranians, Indians
Members of the Iranian Consulate
in Bombay, the Iranian Cultural
awareness of the custom. Are these
animals represented by any symbolism
on the Navroz table? “None, ” or “I
don ’t know, ” was the general consen
sus of the answers.
Most Parsis contacted were almost
“I’m hearing of it for the first time, ”
said one. “Isn ’t it Chinese? ” said
ness about? ” queried yet another.
m
BEHRAM WADIA
a ASSOCIATES
Consultants in Elearonics
Office :
n Koregaon Park,
Poona-4i I 001
India
Telephone ; (0212 J 23134
I Telegrams : Unitec
Tlx : Wadia care MCCI 145-333
Attention : Unitec
Laboratory ;
144/2 Sassoon Rd.,
I Poona 411 001.
IPhone : 26961
33Shernaz Kermani:
Bound to Win
Gustasp Irani
“It ail started when I was 16 and spend our own money or collect^ur
considering participating in the regu
lar swimming sports of out school, ”
paralysed below the waist and
own funds. . . there was no formal
organization to train or help us .. .
shot putt and the 100 metres wheel
chair sprint — and two bronze —
discus and precision javelin.
Keeping in shape is very strenuous,
especially before an international
competitic-n, says Kermani. In 1974,
the AU India Federation for Sports
and Rehabilitation for Paraple^cs
(persons parahsed below the waist)
was formed with the objective of pro
moting sports for the handicapped
lai swuiuiuug dpviiD ------- - . -___
says Shemaz Kermani, who has been the Government provided no tangible
paralysed below the waist and con-
fined to a wheelchair since the age
of two.
tor, however,
sports event
Fourteen years later, _ Kermani has
participate in -------- r ----- — - . - -
for die Handicapped, two intematio- Heidelberg m Germany and tne 1974
nal meets, won four gold, fcui silver
and three bronze medals in swimm
ing, track and field events in interna-
tioal competitions, and has been ho- — .
noured with the highest Indian sports Kermani and the entire contingent ol
awards: the Arjun Award 1979 tZ ’ ’ v_j
die Central Government and the Shiv
Chatrapati Award 1979 of the Maha
rashtra State Government,
misses these achievements
casual “I am one of the few lucky
ones, ” though upon being congratu
lated for her achievements, she is all
aglow as she reaches from her wheel
chair and offers a firm hand shake. 1
The eldest child of Gover and Din- |
yar Sharpoor Irani (Kermani), ths ¦
managing partners of Kermani Trans- i
port Company, Kermani losr the use |
of her legs after suffering severe I
meningitis fever and paralysis. When I
she started swimming at the age of I
11 as a form of theraj^, she says, |
“my parents, my mother in particular, I
had always hoped that I could walk I
again. But deep down in me I could |
feel nothing in my legs and I suspected
I would never walk again. ” After her Kermani: Award winner
.. .u tzA nrnrp? Kniith but uow they accept it quite natu-
lo boycott g P reallv she says. “Of course no amount
Afnea s participation, it was reauy , ¦ • . .u .
Ssappointing, ” says Kermani. “But of trammg can guaramce that you
sinc^was akeady in Toronto I thoa- wm an event nntd you have
might take ^vantage of it, ” she won it she ad*^.^ything
. .__ ___ _ —,1 can haooen. You micht eet the ner-
for a competitive examination
won a scholarship to study German
at the Foreign Languages Department
nf Philadelohia University. It was
“My hydro-therapy instruc-
•, introduced me U -
for the handicapped. ”
facilities. . . we were very much on
our own. ” Did she win any medals?
“None, ” she says and then with a
to a shy sinile adds, “actually I came last
’ in all my events. ”
Since then, Kermani has partici-
two Olympic Games pated in the 1972 Olympic Games at
International Stoke Mendeville Games
in London where she won her first
international medal, a bronze in the
100 metres wheelchair sprint. Ln 1977,
of Indian athletes had gone to Toronto
to participate in the Toronto Olym-
___ _ pics when “on the advice of the In-
She dis- dian Ambassador to Canada, we had
with a _____________
¥
an
“ Of course no amount of
training can guarantee
that you will win an
event until you have act
ually won it.”
had always hoped that I could walk I
again. But deep down in me I could
feel nothing in my legs and I suspected
1 ....' ¦ " „............ ’
mother died when Kerman t was 16
she started to view her swimming as
sport and not hydro-therapy.
and preparing contestants for interna
tional events. Six months before any
such event athletes assemble in Poona,
where the main centre of the orgaiu-
zation is located, for rigorous train
ing, says Kermani. “Every morning
we go through one hour of weightli
fting, then three hours of swimming
practice and in the evening are taken
for a one-mUe hike around the army
camp where the centre is based. ”
Even if there is no competition
Kermani keeps fit with a daily one-
hour swim at the YMCA pool in
Bombay. Though the pool has a se
parate time for the handicapped,
Kermani prefers to swim during the
regular public hours.
others were concious of my presence
‘At first ±e
Africa ’s participation.
since I was already in Toronto I thoa-
a* MJ rh:ri.'e''appe3;id can happen. You nngh. ge, uerL
L a comnetitive examination and ves, or you nnght get cramp m your
arms dunng the race, or you can get
a flat tyre. ” Then suddenly remem-
5 ^PhiladelSlua University. ' It was strokes the wheels of her
while she w^ studying here that she dharr ftat adverti^ its joum^
availed of the oppirt^ty to parttd- ’d™-' <**« '"'•k«rs .1...
Kft rmani recalls the problems she pate in the Pan American Games of
faced when she had partiti]?ated in 1977. During this m€»t she won four
her first international event, the 1969 golds — three in swimmmg and one Sports aside, Kermam also talks
Tel Aviv Olympics for the Handi- in the 400 metres wheelchair race, — about the problems of being a para-
capped: “At that time we had 'o four silver — table tennis, javelin, plegic. “Social and psychological
There was no organiza
tion to help us ....
the Government provided
no facilities .... we were
very much on our own.”
it
across the globe with stickers that
cover its backrest, “This is my rac
ing chair, ” she says.
Sports aside,
35barriers aside, it is the archkecto^
blem for us crips (a tenn she uses to
refer to cripple and paraplegic like
herself). ” By architectural problems
she refers to climbing and descending
steps, getting in and out of public trans
port or 1 -u • ’
have to cover in their wheelchair.
.Accordingly, she derives a sense of
achievement in that she has toured a
barriers that are the greatest pro
blem for us crips (a term she uses to
refer to cripple and paraplegic hke
herself). ” By architectural problems
she refers to climbing and descending
steps, getting in and out of public trans
port or the kind of terrian that they
have to cover in their wheelchair.
.Accordingly, she derives a sense of
I me or do what he liked but I was not
I paying. ” She won her case.
I Now at the age of 30, Kermani
I envisages herself getting more involv-
I ed with the rehabilitation of less for-
« tunate paraplegics than herself and
less involved with sport though not
completely divorced from it. “At my
age I realise that there are only a few
years of competitive sport left. But
then, I achieved more than I ever
hoped for, ” she says.
Kermani is grateful for the en-
couragement her parents, brother,
I sister and friends have always given
* her. She sees her enrolment in Queen
I Mary ’s High School, from where sh<
I r-7'" ‘
I tant factor in enabling her overcome
® the social and psychological barriers.
Were these barriers formidable?
Kermani considers for a while. “When
«¦ I came to accept the blunt truth that
I would never walk again, my biggest
problem at the time was that I would
life. But gradually I came to
¦ ’ ’ '
only the degree varies, and
) terms with myself. ” But
vv _______________ _______ she observes; “we crips just
it but ’ because it was a matter of hate to be carried bodily, it reinforces
principle. I told him he could arrest our dependency too strongly.
s
greater part of Europe and USA on ',
her own.
“Abroad, ’ -— - .
so much more aware of our problems
than in India, and they have so many
more facihties. ” For instance, she
points out, that in Switzerland there
is a special booth for the handicapped
at all railway stations to help them
with their special needs. She notes
that after helping a handicapped person
onto a train they paste a sticker on
to the compartment so that the booth
at their destination knows tlat there
is a person who will need help to de
train. In contrast, she recalls, the first
time she travelled to Poona alone. The
ticket inspector
wheelchair as ba^age charges. “Why to pay, not because I could not afford
<
chair is my legs, ” an animated Kermani
she observes, “they are
pasesd her SSC in 1968, as an impor
tant factor in enabling her overcome
the social and psychological barriers.
Were these barriers formidable?
Kermani considers for a while. “When
I came to accept the blunt truth that
I would never walk again, my biggest
problem at the time was that I would
be dependant on others for the rest of
my 112-. ’
realize that everyone is dependant on
ticket inspector on that journey . someone, <
demanded that she pay exira for her protested. “I told him I was not going I came to
Whe?lch'" ‘r Hnaaaap. charges. “Why to pav, not because I could not afford even now j
should I have paid extra ?My wheel-
Kermani hurling the javelin
‘‘Why should I have paid
extra ? My wheelchair
is my legs”.
Match your AMBITION to a CAREER
To do so we offer you:
• Diploma Course in Business Management (Oral/Postal)
• Banking: C.A.I.I.B. Course (Postal & Oral)
e Commerce :G.C.D. Course • Executive Secretarial Course
• Private Secretarial Course • Telephone Operating
• Telephone Operating-cum Receptionist Techniques
• Shorthand & Typewriting • Punch Operating • Telex Operating
13^3
Enquire at :
Sir J. J. College of Commerce
14,Nanabhoy Lane, Hutatma Chowk,
BOMBAY 400 001.Tel:251185
37The Smouldering Embers
of the Kadmi Priesthood
Gustasp Irani
keeps declining the Kadmi
Navars or Maratabs anymore, ” says Iran
Sorabji.
Sorabji links the decline in
number of Irani mobeds to the eco
nomic prosperity of Iran. Previous!)^,
since Iran was *
a
In 1720, the Zoroastrian community
in Surat received the revered Dastur
Jamasp ‘Valayati ’ (of the motherland)
of the Kerman agiary in Iran, to
mediate the controversy over the
correct positioning c- t — -
.loori Rv time he had returned there was ---------
I?Us native land he had thrown the to ..perform Kadmi^
SS.W “^'Jtro^^y, » Ma. However, as the ec^
one over the two diilerent nomic conditions J™” f;;S-" Sani or Persi for not wanting
S'u^aifMa^- ”- ‘sXrrJ^t^ toYS-X kb?eom_e a priest.JheMd^Mi
then it has almost become a tradition country mainly yound the 1950s.
for the Kadmis, who <—..
Iranian calendar, which is a month Sorabji believes, left
ahead of the Shenshai calendar, 10
look towards Irani mobeds for reli
gious guidance and service.
“Previously it was believed that
only Irani mobeds were qualified to
of the feet of
section of the community has to
the increasingly turn to the Parsi priests
for service.
Ervad Dinshaw Ardeshir Iram, a
ras a Door country anu 50-year-old Irani mobed attached to
(Smand^r Irani mobeds the A. D. Dadiseth ap;:.ry was
to commit himself. “I do my duty
and don ’t get involved, ” he says. He
adds that the life of a priest is very
hard ” and he would not blame ^y
Ervad Dinshaw Ardeshir Irani,
poor country and
_ ___ ____ ¦ i in
India the Iranis found it beneficial to
inis uiic vvvx —
calendars foUowed by the Zoroastnans improve many of
“Previously it was
mobed, Ervad Rayomand Valayati
clarifies that he is not really Irani;
______ J a Parsi, only my mother
is Irani. ” Twenty-year-old Valayati,
who has been practicing as a priest
for the last five years, says he became
a preist because he was interested in
the religion. “But now I realise that
it is a very difficult life and more
difficult to make a living off. I am also
interested in electrical engineering
and if I should get a chance to study
more lucrative employment. Those further, I will definitely stop being a
adapted the Many of those who returned to Iran,
.......... ’ -t the priesthood “My father is
believed that
i and cere-
Ervad Sorabji, the 60-
If I should get a chance
to study further, I will
definitely stop being a
priest” perform Kadmi prayers
monies. ” says
year-(
-o____J _ _______________ - i ___
of Bombay. The tradition, however, yybo remained as priests have either priest, ” he adds.
. , . ivoc HAPn ... . ,----------- ij X4 . underscore this reluctancy
among the youth in the community to
• ¦*¦* _ 4t_
paying jobs in commercial activities Iranis, Sorabji points out that a
.uvu.. ----- --------- priesthood. Hence while the charity box was placed in the A. D.
After us I suspect there will be no number of priests both in India and Dadiseth agairy years ago with the
oj presenting the money
I collected to any Irani who should
B become a mobed. “It has been so
F many years that we don ’t even know
where the keys to the ix)x are. Now
b the box is filled over and there is no
i one qualified to present it to ’', says
B Sorabji.
I None of the three Irani priest know
I of any community o-ganisation or
I Anjuman which looks after their
I interest in particular. Dinshaw Irani
¦ says that he has received Rs 3(X) per
I year over the last two years from the
I Iranian Zoroastrian Aiquman but is
I otherwise unaware of any scheme that
I applies to the Irani me beds. Mahyar
I Patel, secretary and treasurer of the
I Iranian Zoroastrian Anjuman, points
out that over the last four years the
Anjuman has been distributing a
TACcics, ” says Ervad Sorabji, inc ou-
year-old Irani boyewala at the A. D.
Dadiseth agiary in the Fountain ^ea
over the last 25 to 30 years has been qj- have now become old. Mean
fading rapidly with the decline in^he younger generation of Irani
number of Irani mobeds and today Zoroastrians are opting for better become priests, especially among the
suspends over extinction on a slender paying jobs in commercial activities - ................ ’
thread of three Irani mobeds in India, over priesthood. Hence while the
u
more, ” says Sorabji.
The peak in number of Irani mobeds
in India, Sorabji estimates, was during
the early twentieth century when there
were about 75 practicing in Bombay.
“When I came to India in 1935, our
number was about 45 (in Bombay) ’,
says Sorabji. “Since then some have
died, others have stopped Practicing
as 1
Iran, and there are no ,
Zoroastrians to take their place
likely to do so, ” he adds.
While most of the Irani mobeds in
India had come from Iran —“Over
___-/I V) J , , J
The peak in number of Irani mobeds
the^eMly twentieth century when there
were about 75 practicing in Bombay.
“When I came to India in_l 935, our
___ ____ >
s^rSorabji. “Since then some have
priests and many have returned to
.. . « _ T**O*h5
young Irani
or
India had come from Iran — over
90% had become biavars and
Maratabs in Iran ”—today even in that
country there are not enough mobeds
to serve the community there. Irani
ans are now coming to India to look
for Parsi mobeds to come to Iran. 1
lui rmw iiiwu/vwo w - ----------- --
don ’t think they are able to produce Valayati .
38
‘a difficult life’
thisI
T'
“ Why should we mobeds
want our children
to become mobeds and
suffer as we did ?”
mobeds want our children to be-
mobeds and suffer as we did?
we
come
There are no regular working hours
for us, no paid leave, no day off in
the week. Above aU we earn so little
and there is no guarantee of out
earnings.
course, ” he adds, “we make them
Navars and Maratabs but..Sorabji
refers to the case of his own two sons;
“One is an engineer and the other a
MBA and both are earning well. I
can ’t except them to become mobeds. ’
“For years we have been trying to
draw the attention of the community
to this problem (of a decline in the
number of priests) but nothing seems
to be happening, ” says Dastur
Kaikhusroo JamaspAsa high priest
of the Anjuman Atash Behram
at Princess Street Bombay. It is
not that the community is
aware of problems. One session
the three papers was devoted to Zoro
astrian priesthood at the Third World
Zoroastrian Congress held at Bombay
. . _ — ------ . in 1978. Also, smaller Anjumans and
Six times he will ask the bride if she four Fasli full-time practicing mobeds, Panchayats in India like the Parsi Zoro-
wishes to marry the man chosen to according to one estimate. Including astrian Anjuman of Hyderabad and
be her future husband and six time, ---- - ---- ’— .................................. " ‘ ~ ’
she will find an excuse to differ an
answer. Only on the seventh occasion
does she consent and
i
4^ '
says Behramkamdin. “Of
he adds, “we
^.J -4.
Sorabji : ‘searching for the bride ’
total sum of Rs 3,000 every quarterly how to do them, ” says Ervard
equally between 10 deserving mobeds. Framroze Ardeshir Behramkamdin, a
“No distinction is made between Irani boyewala at the Banaji Atash Behram
or Parsi priests in this scheme, ” he at Chami Road in Bombay, but
says.
Though Parsi Kadmi mobeds have
been able to fill in the ,oid created by them. ”
the decline in the number of their
Irani counterparts, there still remain have to surrender a tradition for want
certain customs and ntuals chara- of any Irani mobeds to maintain it,
cteristic of the Irani commumty that the priestly class is apprehensive that
Irani mobeds are called upon U............................ ”
perform. For instance, at an
Irani wedding the mobed, with candle crisis in the not
in hand, goes ‘searching for the bride. ’ Presently there are
admits: “I suppose it won ’t be the
same as an Irani priest performing
If a section of the community will
>5
says
upon
at
to the Kadmi and Fasli sections of the
community will be faced with a similar
too distant future.
12 Kadmi and
un-
of
Six times the mobed
will ask the bride
if she wishes to marry
her future husband and
six times she will differ
an answer. Only on the
seventh occasion does
. she consent.
part-time priests Behramkamdin esti- Secunderabad and the Delhi Parsi
mates that there are around 30 to 40 Anjuman are taking positives steps to
Kadmi priests. Unlike the proverbial improve the lot of their priests (see
the marriage final burst the priestly class suspect ‘Events and Personalities ’). Further
inglorious extinction. “Soon there practicing priests have access to local
will only be Slienshai priests left. ” anjumans, panchayats and orginisations
says Behramkamdin. Estimates the in almost all the co mmuni ty centres,
number of Shenshai priest in India including Bombay which has the
today vary around 300 to 400. largest number of priests, for financial
“Why look at it as a problem only and monetary assistance. However the
from the Irani, Kadmi or Fasli angle,
it is a problem with the entire priestly
community as a whole, ” says Dastur __ ______ __ ______
Minochehr-Homji, high priest of the will cotinue to decline, ” says Mino
N. M. Petti p-’-= 1 , _1„1„ ~~__ ",
Bombay s New Marine Lines. “Young the sheer forces of market economics
Zoroastrians don ’t want to I
mobeds, because there is no status or
problem remains.
“Unless the community applies it
self seriously the number of priests
Falsi Atash Kadeh at chehr-Homji. Otherwise, he believes
become will correct the problem. “There will
----- - - come a time when there will be so
respect, and m the modern world status few priests and the deman d for their
f ' services so great that the community
problem will remain will have to start paying them better.
Sorabii concur S
form these ceremomes if we are taught with Minochehr-Homji. “Why should redemption.
ceremony proceeds. Presently only and respect are equated to economic
Sorabji performs th^e ceremonies in CL Lb.. ttL"
India. Dishaw Iram and Valayati sav until the community starts
that they do not know how these. - • •
¦ 'T: •
39The Trinity of Calanders
the separate places of worship. In 1783 a results. Almost aU Associations of
hilxxxxLlxxx. D™ 2-T- America celebrate Peteti,
Kadmf Atash Behram constructed Navroz functions stiff in August,
pnesi Krci,ciitiy m ^vixxuay, in that several of them have carted ^r-
r addition to the Dadiseth Atash Behram forming Ghambar Jashans as per the
“the which is located at Fanaswadi, the Mazdayasna (seasonal calendar) cal-
Banaji Atash Behram, opposite Charni Fasli. I believe it will change very
Road station, the Dadiseth Agiary at gradually? ’
of Fountain area, the Saher in Agiary at .
Warden Road and the Vachhagandhi calendars create from
^The Fasli movement, according to ^md mahs (months) fall at differ^t
Boyce took shape in early twentieth times. For instance, Ae days of the
wxxvxxx ..1_ 12___T. Ci?-'-", ~n ‘muktad ’ prayers for the dead accord-
the strength of his religious scholar- ing to ti„ —_
1____ - ___1- 1- results.
wealthy philanthropist, Dady Seth, had North
the calendi' SJe vatrfDashS'^^Mulir kIus Vs its high However, the most important thing is
vuw I___ •„ 4U<-t4- y-k-F thorn Koir/^ rori^H rw^r—
Though held together by
common bond of religion the World
Zoroastrian community is split into
three segments over Cv • t. u
Shenshais, who constitute the largest priest. ” Presently m BomMy,
m number, start then- year presently —------,
towards the end of Ausustt the which is located at rauaswaui, mv '
Kadmis who comprise oflarge 2^ .Kad ”? „ Ije 2™?!“
section of the Irani community and
also some Parsis, start their year a
month earlier; and the Faslis, cl
relatively recent origin, begin the year
on 21 March. Because of the un- at Hughes Road,
adjusted ‘leap day ’ in the calendar of
the Shenshais and Kadmis their new J , j
¦ ing to J,, -thr^ diflerem calendms
The difierences in the calendars, ship ^ popularity adyocaW that the “ ¥
flccordinp tn scholars traces to the most logical calendar for Zoroastnans question or a mooea penori^g
?^n rSjStoents ’ for the ‘leap was one which was to harmony with a'" “srlivrS
day ’, or, in the case of the pre-Islamic the seasons and started on the day of of the is
Zoroastrian calendar, the ‘leap month ’ the spring equmox, on 21 March In hiS nriest amiT^ol^
once in everv 120 vears Accor^ne to 1937 Nasserwanji Maneckji Petit wrong, says a hi^-pnest ana scnoiM
nV^t; buBt the onlv Fasli place of worship in Bombay, who does not wish^t^te
. ‘There cannot be
two rojes to one day .. .it is a matter
iiao ~1 r—_ c--' However, there are
1 the some mobeds who do indulge in this
die North practice.
crxJ The priestly community nevertheless
there emphasises that the difference between
The problem that the different
. 1 I ths religious
point of view is that their rojes (days)
Mary Boyce, in her bwk Zoroastrians: built the only Fasli place of worehip in °^of°Ae
Th^r Beliefs and Pnaaices, emstag eyeujoday,^ the N. Pebt ^denhM
published by Routledge and Kegan
Paul, London, the Z^oastrian com
munity that remained back in Iran ,
after the Arab invasion of the country found its greatest champions in
[ no longer made the ‘leap month' community se^ed^ m ti —
' mSr “S; C?nmii5;y “^''“set5;hi. re;,m “\™'*7commumty there FaXTs'
India made only one such intercalla- suggest that there is a concerted Je ShenshaisKadms^d Pasns is
-—-- effort within the community to adopt differemx of c^ndar, and not religion.
(Fasli) Atash Kedah at New Marine nature of the issue.
L-zincs.
Presently the Fasli calendar has of principle. ’
<• •. _____ J. -_i_______:____ 2___ rz^m/a mnl^AnQ
intercallation adjust- American continent. Newsletters and
!
tion adjustment in the year 1129-31
^^n^?J^eenVSvo°XS^ Xr ’ of Gavashru, the quarterly
In 1720, when Dastur Jamasp publication of the Zoroastrian Associa- E^ard
Valayati, of the Kerman agiary in tion of Quebec, Canada, who is Ardpchir
Iran,^visited India he pointed out this actively involved in promoting the j^amroz
difference. Sections the Indian Fasli calendar, v.“tec tc P—at the Bai
community felt that the local com- ‘"The response of those who make a
munity should adjust their calendar realistic effort to understand it ^e
to conform with the one followed in Fasli calendar,) is very g **
Iran and this led to bitter disputes, process (of change) has to be very
In 1746 a section of the priests and gradual, because matters such as these
lay community in Surat adopted the in today ’s age cannot be brou^t over
Irani calendar which was called Kadmi night. The shock of such a c ’nop
from the Persian work Qadim for old. can do more harm than good.
Boyce v/rites; “At its height the “Historicaffy it took 150 years
dispute between the Shenshais and before the Gregorian Calendar was
Kadmis pr^uced so deep a schism i>coepted by the Church of Engird,
that it necessitated the founding of I therefore, do not expect overnight
VrlUillll Liiv vuuuiiLun^j w - --------------------- , -
Fasli calendar. Dr. Jehan Bagli, There is no difference m the prayers
or ceremonies of the Shenshais and
differ in their prayers, but as prvard
¦ ¦ ¦ • Behramkamdin,
writes to Parsiana : boyewala at the Banaji Atash Behram
points out “this is only marginal. Our
ithomans teach their students both
good. The versions. ”
The question of which calendar is
he most authentic remains unresolv
ed. The Dastur-scholar observes that
ch ange ihe Fasli version is a new one,
superimposed on the commumty, and
the Shehshair and Kadnu versions
liave failed to make the intercallation
hdjustments. .“AU three are wrong, ”
le says.
41Delhi Survey:
Profile of the Delhi Parsis
The Parsi community in ra'e° Conuncnling on the proporto o£ de-
S*", ":Sono^ S?le; “"ta househo>ds,etc. penden^^ of the ^_^d m 4e P..
maintaining
living than the general populauon
----- chnw a definite trend towards lesser community, the interpretaUon notes
me city, is showmg a growing Parsis ” that this “also poses the problem of
sity to marry outside the wmmum.y birth P ’ intgj-.j^nununity mar- higher economic means for mainte-
and is faced with ^iages tL turvey notes that hl 1978 nance (and) more Jiving space for
dechne m its numbers. T^e S t’txvn thirds of all Parsi marria- young married couples. One may
tion is made by a recently pubhshed about two ttods of a^ Parsi expert the Delhi Parlis to show an
interpretation based tods in 1969 and only one sixth increasing percentage of old a^.de-
ing socio-economic survey of the Dto one^ intoretation points out pendents in the coming years. This is
Parsi commumty conducted m 1978 ^49^ J^e m^^em p^^^
^d sponsored by the Delhi Parsi ^at jhen^^a^^^^ educa- nutoy ’s future ” . .
Anjuman (DPA). husbands On the problem of housing the in-
liiis survey i-— —
three main social concerns
out of academic interest, ” note
authors of the inte^retaion,
Moddie, Ava ----- -
Jungalwalla. These social concerns
of ^cononuc modvation be the dominaa.
(^d) the extent and motivation here? If the community
impheations of mixed marriages, and needs to place greater emphasis on
a ^ssible loss to a number of Zoroa- pdnratinn. nrofessionahsation.
strians. ”
The survey shows i— —
while having a smaller number of of mter-marriage.'
youth, also have a larger proportion The reasons
of aged members in comparison to the hne is more difficult to -----------_
genrtal population of Delhi. Accord- “Without a base-hne study, trends ^nd NPRs live m rented houses,
ffig to the Delhi Census of 1971, over are not possible to assess ”, notes the and as paying guests. The
a third of the Delhi population com- interpretation. The figures, however, community needs to do more for
prise those under 14 years of age show that 63% have montffiy incomes jtseif jn this important, aspect in terms
versus one sixth for the Parsis, while of less than Rs. 1,(X)O. Yet if the earn- of social action; learning from the
Parsis over 60 are thrice in number ings are taken from the viewpoint of niore acute situation in Bombay
as compared to the general urban household earnings then about 64% which, it is reported, is a main cause
population __ 13.8% to 4.2%. of families earn over Rs. 2,C^ per of delayed marriages and population
Figures for the non-Parsis related to month. The explanation, the interpre- decline. ”
thrmioti -marriaffp,. classified as tation surmises, is because there are The interpretatior is based on a
____ ____ '• 131-page research study conducted
Delhi Parsi survey, corresponds more family. by the Centre for Study of Develop-
closely with that of the general popu- Other statistics indicate that the jng Societies, Delhi, and sponsored
lation __ 35.3% of their numbers Parsis and the non-Parsis related to hy the DPA at a cost of Rs. 3,000.
under 14 and 5.3% of those over 60. Parsis through marriage compare <‘To the extent that the Delhi com-
“In context to the concern over very favourably with the general po- munity could organize such a research
the decline in numbers, ” the interpre- pulation in their level of education, study undertaking, it may serve as an
tation notes, “the ^neral reader Parsis who have studied to the bache- example for other representative
wishes to kno w (if) there is a real lor degree level amount to 37.6% sections of the Parsi community to
threat of the kind of extinction pre>- while for the non-Parsis related group do the same, ” the interpretation
dieted? The data pertaining to the the figure is 34.2% as against only observes.
show a
outside^the coinmunity birth per ------
....... " As regards mter-commumty mar-
Ok a
has arisen
ween
out of tion and income
the levels of occupation, educa-
between husbands
out 01 uou cuiu p • terpretation observes, “what the sur-
and not and wives, Parsi wives ana non-rarbi r
the husbands show the closest similarities,
micrpictoxvtx, Aspi “The Parsi female ’s choice of non-Parsi
KhuUar and Piloo husbands is nearly always from a
similar high socio-economic group,
the interpreters comment. “Could the
1 are
, on
the education, professionalisation, and
economic growth of its young
that the Parsis if it wishes to turn the rising
The reasons "for the economic dec
ascertain.
to the line is more
males
tides
“ The Parsi female choice
of non-Parsi husbands
is nearly always from a
similar high socio
economic group. Could
the economics motivation
be the dominant
motivation here ?
¦B
vey does not highlight is that 50% of
lu uio _ ______ - ¦ are not possible to assess ”, notes the j^otels and :
tlffid'^^e Delhi population com- interpretation. The figures, however, community needs to do
pnse
versus one t —------
Parsis over 60 are
popffia^on — 13.8% to 4.2%. of families earn over Rs. 2,tW per of jefayi
Figures for the non-Parsis related to month. The explanation, the mterpre- decline. ”
Parsis through marriage, classified as tation surmises, is because there are The u
NPRs, who were also included in the two^or more earning members m a i-’-'
the
43The survey, according to the inter- encouragemen^
pretation, was a product of a sugges-
t'
study at the “North Zone meeting ;n
early 1977,” ’ „ *¦ ’'
the study was necessary because
discussing matters of concern,
community did not have
research based data; and this some
times led to speculation wihout facts. ”
The interpretation concludes by
Parsi Advisory Committee members posing questions that beg answers,
and other involved Parsis. In addition “Can the community think of some
to supplying data on the 557 Parsis practical social security for the old
¦ - ' also in the families with relatively low
non- incomes? Can the rich Parsis and
with
at
and efforts of the
tion calling for such a socio-economic
¦ xxxcctirg in -- xx - -
The meeting felt that of Delhi surveyed, the study
included information on 113
Parsis related to Parsis by marriage. NPRs help Parsis and NPRs
In all, the original study includes 36 family incomes below Rs 1,000;
tables of which 9 are reproduced by least to provide a health insurance
the interpretation paper. These tables scheme for the old, and an education
include information on the distrib.i- insurance scheme for the young be
tion of the community by age; educa- low 16? Where do we go next?
tion by sex; occupation; income (in- ‘ \
dividual and household) ; marital academic interest. It is meant to high-
status; migration by age, sex and light the community ’s social problems
marit^ status; dependency ratio and on a factual basis, eliminate unfac-
decade-wise Parsi marriages within tual speculation, and present specific
and outside the community. Also in- problems for solution through social
eluded in selected tables are statistics action. The days when ‘gambhars ’ and
__________________ of the Bombay Parsis obtained from ‘nataks ’ were considered social action
Response to the survey is reported the Bombay census of 1971 to esta- are over. There are harder problems
to have been 91%, not without the blish some basis of comparison. ahead. ”
“in
tire
sound
“ In discussing matters
of concern, the com
munity did not have
sound research based
data; and this some
times led to speculation
without facts
dividual and household) ;
“The study is not meant to be of
Taj-Intercontinental Hotel
— Bombay
< <
III
LH’S BUILD THEM TOGETHER!
Whether it's a five-star hotel,
a Sultan ’s Palace, a hospital,
a chemical factory, a fertiliser
plant or a housing project —
we have the expertise and
experience —to handle any
turn-key construction project
anywhere in the world.
Over the last 100 years we
have not only pioneered the
construction industry in
our country but spread our
wings to Muscat and the
I Middle East —where against
competition from the best
construction companies,
I
we won the contract
for putting up the imposing
Muscat Palace complex
of His Majesty the Sultan of
Oman—and completed
it in time.
The multiplicity of projects I
carried out by us over i
several decades has resulted j
in the building up of |
expertise in numerous ...
aspects of the construction
industry. We proudly offer
this expertise for any
construction project
and proposals for joint
ventures would be
welcome.
Otwrei-ShaMtan How
—Somboy
k
k
I
.S'
SssgS:’
I
??
,JS
I>J1
[Muscat Palace of His Majesty the Sultan of Oman;
MB
•J««
10
i
SHAPOORJI PALLONJI & CO. (PVT.) LTD.
International Operations Division,
Engineering & Construction Contractors
Nevy India Centre, 1 7 Cooperage Road,
Bombay 400 039 India
I
45?
'¦4^^ "I
“The image of Zarathushtra we know j..___ k_ :k_
presently is a dream image of a Parsi the Seventh (1933-34)1934-35 )
s
)»
P-*
pears in the Preliminary Report of
I painter, ” writes Feroze Cama, a long- Season Work' on the Excavation ""at
I time resident of New York who takes Dura-Europos, edited from lectures
I interest in Zoroastrian scholarship. A delivered by Rostovtzeff at Yale Uni-
I more likely and closer resemblance versity. The report was sent to Cama
I of what the holy prophet might have by the Washington D.C. Library of
I looked hke, Cama believes, is that of Congress in response to his request
I the person in the fresco reproduced for information on the portrait of
time resident of New York who takes Dura-Europos, edited
more likely and closer resemblance
1-
¦%<4;
9^
w
X
/
.w
^B-s
looked like, Cama believes, is that of Congress in
ri' _ ¦ " ¦ - ;
above, which some Western scholars Zarathushtra.
have identified as most probably a Cama ’s interest in the subject was
portrait of Zarathushtra. The fresco first aroused while reading Jim Hick ’s
was found during an early twentieth The Persians, published by the Time
century excavation of Dura Europos, ’’ ’
an ancient city located in present-day
Syria and believed to date back to
240 AD.
“The fresco was first identified
Zarathushtra by the late Professor check
Micheal I. Rostovtzeff, an internatio
nally respected scholar of Ir ani an,
r- ’ ...............
tory and one of the excavators of
Dura-Europos/
curator. Ancient Art and the Dura- aLtneuics lu
Europos coU^tion, Yale University, that. ” He, however, clarifies that “I
in a letter to Cama. Professor Rostovt-
zeff ’s own comment on the fresco and dress "of
a second one found at the s __
are: “the figures of the two prophets
of Mithraism - ’ ’ ’ “
tra and Os thanes — are of great in-
as most probably a
as
Life Books, wherein appears a port
rait claimed to be that of Zarathush
tra. Since the picture was printed
through the courtesy of Yale Univer
sity, Cama wrote to the University to
check its authenticity. He believes
that the image of Zarathushtra as we
presently portray him has evolved 1-^ -------------- —“ iiiin lido WOJ.VCU
(Greek) his- from the fact that “as the Zoroastri
ans who settled in India also adopted
—— ****•*! customs and dress, the
prophet ’s costume also attributes to
J3
writes the associate the Indian
do not imply that the present-day
-ZZ2Z ;,f our mobeds and dasturs
same^site should be changed to conform to that
photograph. I also do not im-
6f the person of Zarathus"htrc. be ”i"-
probably Zarathush- ply that the pictorial representation
terest for they may be regarded as tered to confrom to that depicted in
nrotntvnp*; rvf iHa •AmirAc fKz:* ^i
*¦*
U'
prototypes of the figures of the Magi the photograph
m Chnstain art (reference to the three “Mv intention
wise men ~ -
birth) .. .
4-' . 7 ’7------ “o lucit uiai me in
1 ™ their kind, in the and researches into the life.
in Christain art (reference to the three
Christ ’s and future
interesting
at the time of
These most
is that our present
generations should get
some idea that the investigations
div life, times and
teaching of Zarathushtra are far
from complete and we must continue
to dig up more information and also
analyse scientifically the diverse na-
Image of
Zarathushtra :
Dreams
and
Reality ?
XXX ixivxi xVXXx^A* 1x1 Ulw
usual Perso-Palmyrene (people of the
ancient city of Palymrea North East
of Damascus) dress, wear the Mith-
raic tiara (headgear worn by the fol-
'“" Of taformation'and opinio'n ’s pi;.
bearded and wear a drooping, short, sented by various scholars ” c£na
“Ae wf hand they hold a white ¦’"‘"T’'
roll and in the right a black cane
with a flat top. It is evident from the
rolls that they represent teachers
learned men, ;
canes that they are Magi or magici
ans. . . There is no doubt that the
persons represented in the paintings d^^i^MtaJJ' mvdations
must be regarded as Magi, or prophets, - -
those who were the authors or intrs-
preters of the several books of Mith
raism. Since Zoroaster was regarded
as the originator of the Mithraic my
steries and Osthanes was his most
famous pupil, we may speculate that
the two Magi of Dura are to be iden
tified with those two great Iranian
prophets, ” Rostovtzeff ’s
College, Philadelphia “It would be
the greatest achievement of my life
to initiate an expeditionary search for
Qnri k remains of Zarathushtra or at least
“If™”,*® the oldest evidence of.Hs lega-
cy. . . We have to penetrate into the
past and bring up the jewels. New
.» arp tippHpH ”
Cama feels that “the foUowers of
Zarathushtra may have hidden his re
mains to prevent desecration by con
quering nations and it may still be
lying hidden. . . just as the coffin of
John the Baptist was found in a cave
in Cairo. . . and what a glorious
achievement it will be if ths discove-
rers themselves are Zoroastrians. ” he
coment ap- writes.
and what
46
re-LEARN
and
EARN
I. Which are the twelve animals
associated with Navroz ?
2. What do the terms Fasli,
Kadmi and Shenshai stand for
or signify ?
3. Is a Zoroastrian
Parsi ?
Irani a
4. In what dialect do the Zoroa
strian Iranis speak ? Does it
have its own script ?
first 5. Who was the first man
according to Zoroastrian mytho
logy ?
which year
the
of
Z-QUIZ-7
6. In which year was
Zoroastrian Association
Europe (Incorporated) founded ?
7. Which two cities were the
abode of the Udvada fire before
it was moved to its present
location ?
8. Who was the first Indian
(Parsi) Chairman of the Munici
pal Corporation of Bombay,
equivalent to the present-day
position of Mayor, and when was
he elected to the post ?
9. In 1934, for the first time, 14
Indians were appointed as Justice
of Peace in Bombay. How many
of them were Parsis ?
10. When was the first agiary in
Delhi built and who was the first
high priest of the capital city?
How much do you know about
your social, cultural, religious
and economic heritage? Most
Parsis are brought up on myths
which they continue to believe
till the dokhma. To help readers
gauge the extent of their
knowledge and also to keep
them informed and enriched,
Parsi0n ct restarts the Z-Quiz on
behalf of the sponsor of The Lost
Generation Esay Competition.
The entry with the highest
number of correct answers will
receive Rs. 75, the next, Rs. 50
and the third, Rs. 25. In case
of a tie, the amount will be split
among the winners.
Send your replies to The
Editor, Z-Quiz, C/o Parsiana,
G.P.O. Box 892, Bombay —
400 001 by 15 May Answers
will be published in our next
issue.
There were two winners with all
10 correct answers for Z-Quiz No. 6
(Pa rsia na July 1978 supplement). The
winners are K. D. Chargeman and
B. S. Surti. Ms K. F. Seervai, with
71/2 correct answers, finished as the
runner-up.
Below is the solution to Quiz :
I. Can a Parsi couple adopt a
child under Parsi law ?
No. Parsi law does not recognize
adoption.
2. What is the Geh Sarna a
recital of ?
The Gathas.
ia ?
3. When is a Parsi male referred
to as a var-raja ?
At the time of marriage. The term
means husband-king.
4. What Is the name for the
central well in the towers of
silence ?
Bhandar.
5. Why is the kumkum red
pigment
pigment on the forehead long
and vertical for a man and round
for a woman ?
According to Sir J. J. Modi, the
long vertical mark of the male sym
bolises a ray ofthesun, as a handsome
man is compared by Oriental writers
with the sun, while the beauty of a
woman is always compared with
that of the moon.
6. In which town or cities in
India are non-Parsis permitted
to pay their last respects to the
dead after the Gen Sarn cere
mony ?
47!
LI;";
You neediYt look jar. Read all about it in Rarsiana.
a
tj' *
fc-
t.:
;; a
¦ 'ii
Hot and bothered about what's
going On in the community?
The magazine worth
waiting for.
Now on sale
The Parsiana
Book of Iranian
Names
The Iranian names of boys' and
girls along with their meanings
which originally appeared in Parsi
ana have now been reprinted
in an attractive 24 page booklet.
The book, which is priced at Rs. 9
is available on sale at:
Farcdoon and Burjor Sandalwood
Shop, Princes's Street.
*
* K. Bomanji and Sons Sandal
wood Shop, Next to Dadyseth
Agiary, Flora Fountain.
* Nalanda Book Shop, Taj Inter
Continental Hotel, Apollo Bunder
Colaba.
* Minoo Sukhadwala Sandalwood
Shop, Next to Aslaji ’s Fire Temple,
. Draupadi Bldg., 386 V. Patel Road,
Bombay-400 004.
* H. L. Rochat & Co. (Next to
Roneo Vickers) Navsari Chambers,
Ground Floor, 39 A. K. Nayak
Marg (Bastion Road), Bombay-
400 001.
* Or write to Parsiana G. P. O.
Box 892, Bombay-400 001. Phone;
268723.
48
Subscribe today
Subscription rates for India and abroad
For a one year subscription of six issues Rs 20
(save Rs 4 over single copy price)
For a two year subscription of twelve copies Rs 36
(save Rs 12 over single copy price)
Single copy rates Rs 3.50 and 50p
Foreign subscription rates inclusive of postage:
by seamail: Rs 36 or $4.50 or £2.25
by airmail: Rs 80 or $9.50 or £4.25
by seamail: Rs 66 or $8.05 or £4
by airmail: Rs 150 or $18 or £8
For U.S. personal cheques add $1.50 to cover bank
charges. For Indian upcountry cheques add Rs 3 for
bank charges. Cheques and drafts are to be drawn
in favour of Parsiana and posted to GPO Box 892,
Bombay 400 001.
Cash payment and money
orders are accepted care of the
Hopeful Playgroup Centre
40, A. K. Nayak Marg
(Bastion Road)
Fort, Bombay 400 001.
For further information
Phone: 262624.
If you are already a subscriber
please pass this form along to a
friend who ought to be one too.
NAME
ADDRESS
CITY
PIN CODE
STATE AND COUNTRYReportedly Delhi and Secunderabad
and Hyderabad.
(B. S. Surti writes : “In every town
and city in India, including Bombay,
there are some Parsi individuals who
permit non-Parsi to pay last respect
of their deceased relatives, against
the ruling of the local Anjumans.”
He rightly points out that the
question relates to Anjumans and
Panchayats that “do not object
to such practices. ”)
7. Aside from India, which
other countries have agiaries or
Atash Behrams ?
Pakistan and Iran.
India,
With Compliments
from
8. What is the difference bet
ween a Khandhia and a Nassa-
salar ?
The Nassasalars carry the body out
of the house and the Khandhias carry
it till the tower. The Nassasalars
then take charge and carry the body
into the tower.
EMPIRE
9 Which city of the world has
the second largest Zoroastrian
population ?
Teheran.
ESTATE
10. Which panchayat or anju
man has the second largest asset
in India ?
The Surat Panchayat.
Liberty Building
41/42 Marine Lines
Rashid D. Bamanbehram
Professional Photographer for Photos
of Weddings, Navjotes and Birthday
parties. Contact :
Flat No. 3, Thirst Root, No. 6 Wadi a
Block, Khareghat Colony, 30A Hughes
Road, Bombay 400007.
Bombay 400 020
PUBUSHER,
STATEMENT OF OWNERSHIP
& OTHER PARTICULARS ABOUT
PARSIANA
Form IV (See Rule 3)
PLACE OF PUBLICATION : Bombay
PERIODICITY OF PUBLICATION :
Bi-monthly
PRINTER, PUBUSHER, EDITOR
AND PROPRIETOR: Jehangir R,
Patel
NATIONALITY : Indian
ADDRESS :
285 J. Dadaji Marg, Bombay-400 007
I, Jehangir R, Patel, hereby declare that
the particulars given above are true to
the best of my knowledge and belief,
Sd (Jehangir R, Patel)
1 March 1980
49J?:
1
I
«
I
i
I
8
BOOK REVIEW
The Eshnuman Way
‘ The present kusti which we do is not
adequate, ” according to a 20 page
printed booklet Sarosh Khshnuman Sarosh.
Kusti; A Complete Prayer, by F. K.
Rustomfram of Hyderabad. “Hence, ”
the author writes “it is important that “
cur children are taught the correct
form of kusti with Sarosh Khshnu
man, ” which appears to be the mam
objective of the booklet.
The book is based on a lU-mc-
which may be broadly defined
the religion. An introduction on the
•• It Cl |.t«^ .. _ _
pollution. When this Naf-e-Bavra
blooms as 1
sincerely we are brought nearer
we recite the prayers
• to
With
Compliments
From
Kshnoom versipn of Zoroast rianis m
which may be broadly defined as
mystical, orthodoxical approach
“Khushnoomic interpretation ” of the Kusti
sudreh and kusti, “do ’s
instructions on the kusti __ _
notes on the Zoroastrain "^religion in L
light of Khshnoom form the body of /
the publication. In addition a '
I'age wallhanging chart giving the
specific actions to be performed while
saying the kusti prayers, the ‘Mathra ’
to be recited, in the devnagari script
and the thoughts, ‘Mithra ’, in English ’
t tcompames the booklet.
“The audience intended is the child
who IS approaching the Navjote
writes Rustomfram “but tv caui
the kusti prayers to it (the child) is
the job of the parent. In order to do
so the parents themselves have
switch over to this
1'' ¦ __
ingly- the writer a^wI^ ’huSdf
a
to
and don ’t 3
prayers and
.... *he kusti absorbs
the blissful vibrationery
colours, spreads them
in the close environment of
the body and thence to
the Keherp and to the
soul.”
GLOBE
theatres
PVT.LTD.
“The kusti is a sacred thread girdle
made of lamb ’s wool. The term
derived from “Karsha ” meaning
(magnetic) circuit. Khshnoom teaches
us that lambs are under the joint
planetary influence of the sun and
Jupiter. Jupiter is. . .the ruling planet
of our faith. The lamb symbolizes lire
live-and-help-live principle of nature.
Also wool collects the vibrationary
colours (stoata) produced by the
prayer. In the case of the Avesta
Manthra (prayer formula) the kusti
3 the blissful vibrationarv
colours, spreads them in the close eu-
^itcrovT"to '» Seu“ kehX* aMurfsMe
Kh^^uS, S S? iSS .0 lhe
ingly, the writer addresses himself to
’“dience. The Zoroastrianism
piayers, it also offers the
insight into Khshnoom (see
Rustomfram writes, in a letter
15
a
a three
>5
age,
to explain absorbs
*•¦•1 is
'ironment (aipi)
82.“the kusii •¦Khshnoom teDs us that every
reaoer an major religion in the world is under
extracts), the^ii^uence of a planet. Zoroastria-
Parsuma, that the book is free of cost planet benefic. Also Jupiter^haj
Lane,"''Hy'^rabad,'
1 fl M !¦ 1 I M _ _
“Khshnoom tells
nism is under the influence of Jupiter
s a.. : J -------- vsw SZi wot z ------- -------------- *---- JU.p±LVl
and that readers may write to him at certain higher creations i -
201 Ai: ................................the animal, vegetable and
Kingdom. .. (which) are pre-eminent
in their own • .. .
groups. In the course
jirayers v/e come across references to
5(XX)01 for
the
la
mineral
way in their respective
of the kusii
a copy.
EXTRACTS
Sudreh - — -----------------tv
“I forefinger thrice. The forefinger k
(^iSrehl^a^l? Jupiter. Zoroastiam
closely. Cotten ssuls are referred to as Burjisi ihuum
gives out precedence
gives out waste matter mcescaniiv in comnansnn +r. .t,
and the sudreh helps
the friction between t
matter. Hence, our result of the never-endine OTocenr anrwnar.h to educational a name foi' themselves as master
For adjustment
political situations, we need to
the problems of educating our children, India,
^the °oSy ”teiitod Siis most educated conmnmity. Today the earn more titan a gradnate can
anaracTftat^ sitnation has changed com^^etely. further when there are fat more
J
Dr Homi N. Sethna
to
make
... .
"the^chang^ know any Indian language. In fact we ---------- v j.
c t^ ’id to look down on Indian languages college education is not for everyb^y.
for other with contempt. We should take urgent Hence, we should not waste time,
steps to avoid this gargantuan blunder, effort and money of charitable trust
already isolating us from the pushing a child through collie. Let
culture. Our approach to educational a name for themselves as master
____ J.__ l-I __ h as would craftsnien. But today it is next to
face keep us in the main stream of hfe in impossible to find a Parsi ca^nt^
-_____________________________ or an electrician or a machimst and
In the bygone days, we were the at a time when sucl^ craftsmen can
has changed^ completdy. further when there are far more
51
the changing problems, should be such‘We tend to look down cr.
Indian languages with
contempt. We should
take urgent steps to avoid
this gargantuan
blunder”.
on
prospering Parsi in the industrial sector —both large
t tn tu^ __ ____ j ___ i. _ ,
'"‘usi m me maustnai sector —^both large
Most los?nm"S" ”®^ \ andlere
ness. i believe h scope for new industries. I
traininc in necessary that the would urge those science and engineer-
the^SmmnntX^ ™^^ homes that ing graduates who have gone abrmd,
Gholvad Naviri seriously consider the very bright
biaS prospects in eonntn, and .,X
culture rather than towards
culture. We need fanners
--- * '1 . M --- VX VZUIL Vk/ULIUY* X I
toancfal benete Ind iSSS”
prospects in the country and to utilize
rural their expertise as well as managerial
an urbjo and entrepreneural skills for the
m the development of our country. I can
vacancies for such craftsmen than country. AU
^e are for graduates. lLx...iv.x«n urvucuis ana mcenuves have future
We have taken an aversion for been offered, but we have icnored
such vocations even though these them. We have generauJ not ceSed me to another
also provide opportunities for self- that rapport wUh the /amem of the I»t^y.&maU number of
employment. It is a sad commentary other communities. In short, we have enrineerin^^?? ’”® science and
on our very narrow outlook to failed to establish that rann^trt at 7i!^ engin^nng. We need a number of
education, because of which Parsi political and the social levS^ And I research laboratories
.^titufons giving such vocational Wame our eXaS Sci^ loj St
trainings had to close down I am that. Parsi boy or wilhng to make
referring to the Gamadia Polytechnic Added to that w,. i 1 P^® sciences. Similar is
m Bombay and the Parekh Pol^echnic a lure for^th^^itv and engineering. Today
in Surat. AU these institutions used to which is ereatlv damnmnrf . .more and newer
give exceUent tr ainin g in so manv socio-ecrmnmie' engineermg disciplines Uke nuclear,
trades, and had produced very gSd nSt^^ran^^Srh^^ t®l®®otnmunications, electronics, etc.,
people but later%n SSon^s Ed ='^“‘>le our boys and giils are
getting enough student. Th. glamour for eitv lite TOt tabng advantage. These require
^amo^ tor city hte. Putting it bnefly hard work but then our bovs must be
d simrt- adds ui«o this that “the ptepared for it 1 ETbuT hete
^ucated live in the cities and the mentioning that our girls as a rule
At this stage I should mention that .........
our country has grown tremendously medical^Md
uau lu Close oown. 1 am
retemng to the Garaadia Polytechnic
Added to that we have developed the
a career in pure sciences. Similar is
case with <
many more and newer
the engineering disciplines like nuclear,
• telecommunications, electronics.
getting enough students. The com
munity has to think —why and how
did it happen?
In the same vein, let me ask what
has happened to our agriculturalists.
We have in the past contributed
greatly to agriculture and horticulture.
------- ------- in scholastic
endeavour than the boys.
A similar situation prevails in
_.J life sciences. We have
52
Sorabji Nowroji & Co.
16 Horniman Circle, Bombay 400 023
Oldest & Largest Stockists
and Exporters of Sandal Wood
Sandal Wood Oil and
Palmarosa Oil
Manufacturers of
Grown’ Brand Sandal Wood Oil Agmarked
telephones
Office :
268911/2
268777
378316
331275
323262
351637
261573
Cable : WELFARE Bombay
Factory :
Wholesale Depots :
Retail Shops :TOWARDS SECULARISM
Dr (Ms) A. J. Dastur
The Constitution of India underlines
and emphasises the rights of minorities
as no other constitution in the world
does. The Constitution of India
recognises the right to freedom
religion and the cultural and edu
cational rights for the protection of
the interest of the minorities. The
of
do
several
of the Constitution were conducted by
groups and associations of minority
communities including the Parsis.
often been identifying medical and life
sciences as non —^mathematical, if not
anti —^mathematical. This is wrong.
Today we have active research work
going on in the various units of the
DAE and of other research institutions
in the country on bio-engineering,
molecular biology, bio-physics, etc.,
where physics, mathematics, engineer
ing and biology blend together.
I believe the Panchayats can
something more FKKitm Aan simp y
conductmg aptitude tests. They should schools and educational
organise and provide guidance bureau institutions even before the adoption
which could give up-to-date and detail- ...
ed information on the careers in the
various areas. It should also encourage
vocationalization of education in our
Parsi schools, at the same time
educating the parents also in the value
and usefulness of vocational training. ’
‘ Following modern
trends in education...
our schools, too bend
towards non-religious
education”.
no
talk of education for
¦
BH
I therefore
Dr (Ms) Aloo J. Dastur
Conclusion
In conclusion, therefore I will
stress that our educational programmes
and strategies should be such as to :
Bring us and keep us in the
mainstream of the soci^ and political
life in the country.
Enable us to utilize the wide rang-
. ing of talent that is bound to exist in
any community by channelising and
encouraging those gifted with manual
dexterity to become master craftsmen.
Selectively channelise the gifted
students to special institutions which
our Panchayats and educational trust
can establish. A good pattern could be
the Dnyan Prabodhinee in Poona,
which runs a special school for gifted
children of very high IQ.
Uptodate our charity schools so that
they can provide the best of modern
academic and especially vocational
education to children from the eco
nomically poorer sections. X . - ------ , „
Provide ample opportunities for admitted children without reference to duty falls
children from the S regions to ««
make proper adjustments and to 1------
acquire such skills in agriculture, gave its verdict m favour of ths
horticulture, etc., which would har- ’
old established Parsi schools are
exceptions.
When we
Zoroastrian children, do we imply, do
we mean to imply, that there is or
should be some new design or philo
sophy of education? Do we, again,
consider or intend to make them a
unique or distinctive band of pupils
and students to be given a different
type of education? A modem state
seeks to equalise the opportunity for
education to all its people irrespective
of status in life or wealth.
Formerly, education, certainly higher
education, was a preserve of those
who could afford it; here, an important
question is whether it is right that
good, sound, desirable education
should be available to those who can
afford it; and those who cannot may
be left out. Such an attitude in our
own days is just not possible. And
since the least common multiple of
education is training for life and living,
there must be a fair opportunity
provided to one and all to acquire this
training.
These schools used to receive Today, when substantial numbers
Government grants. In 1954, the gf Zbroastrians have settled in distant
Government of Bombay issued an lands, their children must and will
order that schools which were manag- accept the style of life and living of
ed exclusively for children of a special d^gi]- different environments with their
religious denomination would no different value systems. If Zoroastrian
more qualify for grants unless they ethics are to be cultivated then the
' " i on the parents and the
their religion. The matter went to the family. The study of religious tenets
Bombay High Court and a full bench and their significance is a domestic or
_ 1., ” ' " group obligation; modern education
Government, i'lic gravamen of their systems keep religion and religious
’ ” practices out of school curricula. In
hundred year old trusts, can and that sense, education has become
should be changed to move with secular and non-denominational.
While we emphatically plead
_____ ___ _____ _________________ 1 ______J education, at the
Parsi children threw open their doors higher secondary stage the aptitude of
lO all communities. This has benefitted the child has to be taken into accoimt.
larger number of His ability, his capability to work
.... rolls and Parsi with the head or hand or heart is or
children have to be more alert and should be of primary importance.
very lop-sided. A few decades
.« t _ ___ _
and a cultured citizen was one
acquire
even
and ihat
monize them for life in the agricultural
environments.
Provide guidance in respect of the
newer emerging areas of science and changing hmes. ,
technology, or medicine or agriculture schools which catered exclusively to universal primary
so that our children especially the
gifted ones, wherever they may be,
can be identified and guided to become ««
experts in these fields for which Pypjs are
r\ - \ C r»Kllrir/*Tl h
be identified and guided to become them as
Since then, these
tor
now a
on the
scholarly due to keen competition
from others.
Thus, following modem trends in the emphasis was
emerged from the portals of
competition “to; ii^iversily'system ‘can also be
’ FinaUy make them into toe human from others. loj^sided. A few
hpinps sensitive to the happenings in Thus, following modem trends m the emphasis was in the liberal arts
Sd^d SteTr^ST^ who education put in Eurtye and a cultured one who
would be ever willing to do their duty America, our schools too bend to emerged famflic : Tp^?? Hem-ee in
and fulfill their obligations to their wards non-rehgious education, with “diversity arm^ the
communitv as a true Parsi and to their emphasis on ethics and umversal arts. ..i™ in —ir- —- ' ,
country truths, rather than religious tenets. The was on science and all young men who
53
With independence, the focus!
Even now there
on
» - are prospering Parsi in the industrial sector —both large
what happened to the scale and small scale and there is
otners. Most lost out because of lari- fantastic scope for new industries. I
ness. I beheve it is necessary that the would urge those science and en ginp ar-
ainmg in several rural homes that ing graduates who have gone abroad,
tne comm^ty is conducting at to seriously consider the very bright
Jjrnolyad, Naysari, etc., shoifld be prospects in the country and to utilize
uawu as 09 lucuiagb-xial
If I towards an urb-m and entrepreneural s kills for the
vqeanr.:fxc f J. r. cultuTe. Wc need farmers in the developnnent of our country. I can
vacancies for such craftsmen than countiy. All sorts of protection and only forcast a very bright and lucrative
uier© are for graduates. pna-nmaj i___ j
have taken an aversion for t>een offered, but we have ignored
such vocations even though these them. We have generally not generated
also provide opportunities for self r?ppcrt "dth the farmers ef drv
employment. It is a sad commentary other communities. In short, we have
on our very narrow outlook to failed to establish that rapport at the
education, because of which Parsi political and the social level. And I
instimtions giving such vocational blame our educational policies for
trainings had to close down. I am that,
referring to the Gamadia Polytechnic /.dd™ .. .
m Bombay and the Parekh Polytechnic a lure for the city and the city life v/hen — „ „
Xa used to which is greatly damaging to the engineering disciplines lite nucl^ ‘
give excellent traming m so many socio-economic standards of the co* ” — -i--x—!._
trades, and had produced very good munity. Our approach and attitude
people but later on they .... -----
- -
thmk —why and how it simply adds upto this that “the prepared for it. I cannot but help
T « nappen/ educated live m the cities and the mentioning that our girls as a rule
hoc 1,?® Ignorant live in the villages ”. Nothing have done much better in scholastic
5SJSa
‘‘We tend to look down c;
Indian languages with
contempt. We should
take urgent steps to avoid
this gargan*uan
blunder”.
, . - ' -------yxvzapvvta ixx WiUiLXjr OilU LV UUIJIZ.V
oiasea towards agncultune and rural their expertise as well as managerial
nilflir/* rafbA«- fkr,., _______ « * ........................... .
culture. We need farmers
financia^ benefits and incentives have future.
t However, tWs brings me to another
for self- rapport wiA the farmers of the boys who are going in for science and
r.«nAr.tax,r Other enmmiiTiitiAc Tn cngui^ng. We need 3. number of
scientists in the research laboratories
I all over the country, but we hardly
.. ------ JT------- get a Parsi boy or ^rl willing to make
¦ J , career in pure sciences. Similar is
Added to that we have developed the case with engineering. Today
im Tcm- tkn ’¦'* I many more and newer
is greatly damaging to the engineering disciplines like nuclear,
many socK^conomic standards of the com- telecommunications, electronics, etc.. diiy sianaaros or tne com- telecommunications, electronics, etc.,
?od munity. Our approach and attitude to are available, our boys and girls are
, not education has caused this utterly false not taking advantage. These reouire
lite. Putting it briefly hard work but then^ur boys mSt be
v/ere
Sorabji Nowroji & Co.
16 Horniman Circle, Bombay 400 023
Oldest & Largest Stockists
and Exporters of Sandal Wood
Sandal Wood Oil and
Palniarosa Oil
TELEPHONES
Office :
52
Manufacturers of
Crown’ Brand Sandal Wood Oil Agmarked
268911/2
268777
378316
331275
323262
351637
261573
Cable : WELFARE Bombay
Factory :
Wholesale Depots :
Retail Shops ;“ Parsi children are some
how loath to use their
hands, they rather prefer
soft, white collar jobs
to more lucrative
manual labour”.
......... ’ J find his be* self. Routine and
iiS’p“™SV;e “l^ti.ti> ‘-tt^ ir “typed curricula do not, c^
P , i-urtrn A i-w-irt(T r»nf tHft best in the DVIDlls or
rneaning and purpose c. —-----
all, education is really a search by
the individual and society to under
stand what life is.
Taken a step further, education is
to make individuals more useful means may
time and necessity will modify it. In to
of life. After bring out the best m the pupils or
students. Mass education cannot in
reality cater to individual needs; but
experimentation with new methods of
teaching and adoption of a variety of
and do appeal to the
intelligent individuals.
members of society. One of the best better more intelligent inciiviciuais.
wavs is to get familiarised with the For all children, including Zor^
pn'dronment^ hence my plea that astrian, a sound system of educatton
Zoroastrian children ’cannot have a is one which appeals at every stage
believed they were intelhgent switched ^eT^^Vha^e^Tf^'^ln SeS^SdStSns of those taught
over to science and technology, ^roasman. iney ., , j^ave a moral content and
speciaUy engineering. More recently line with which^they enable the teachers to make
commerce has become popidar; next varied consider judgements. Secular education is nd
comes law. It is the general tendency reside. The child must nM ^ns g^,^ considerations,
to move ^vith the crowd that sways it muft Ivolve his Other concepts central to the spheK
even our young people. ® hk feelinss To this of education are knowledge, compre-
There is one aspect of our attitude interests ^d jeelw. ^o m s tendon and intelligence, where one
to education and ’work wUch “aSJ? a W?S^ds on o“X“f these fs lacking then t
obvious to go unnoticed. Parsi Ichildren take in fair substitute is education by the use
children are somehow loath to use the indmdual, , Idiw then a manne]
their hands, they rather prefer ^ft, ^^^Xig to their iribom replaces the mind or inteUect Tht
white coUar jobs to more lucrative Pf^^ions ia^rto^w continues to be on producing
S^Xy^-Sis aXdes- ’periiS:; «on “t^st en^'^t, in ’dividu. sociaUy useful individuals.
COB*
value
kmbbmmmi
With Best Compliments
From
Kermani Transport Company
54AEK ATMAKATHA
Both professionally and
personally Dastur Dr Maneckji
Husserwanji Dhalla lived the
religion of the good life. Born
and bred in poverty, he grew up
as, in his own words, a “ narrow
minded, orthodox to the core”.
Later his determined quest for
knowledge led him to the shores
of America where he obtained
his doctorate degree in Iranian
languages from Columbia
University in New York. An
outstanding scholar whose con
tributions to the religion rank
him among the top scholars
on the subject both in India and
abroad, he was the compassionate
and revered high priest of the
Karachi Parsis.
Aek Atmakatha is his auto
biography, published by the
Dastur Dr Dhalla Memorial
Institute, Karachi and translated
from Gujarati into English by
Gool and Behram Rustomji.
This is the fourth extract from
the book which is being serialized
by Parsiana.
Here Comes ihe Bride
The life of Dastur Dhalla-IV
THE STORY SO FAR
Born into a poor dastur family
in Surat on 27 August 1875,
Dhalla lost his mother at three.
In 1878 his family, which
included three elder sisters,
moved to Karachi when an uncle
arranged a job for his father.
At six Dhalla started his school
ing and by eight he was wedded
to five-year-old Cooverbai, the
daughter of a wealthy family
that traded with Bengal and
China.
His failure to pass his matri
culation proved to be a severe
disappointment to his family
and his refusual to answer an
invitation to come to China,
notwithstanding his failure, only
served to highten their
dejection.
The son of a relative was to be
initiated into Navarhood in Navsari.
I was invited
there. I was most eager to go to
Navsari because that would afford an
opportuntiy to see and meet my be
loved. That of course, in the presence
of elders-never alone!
Our meeting was always supervis
ed and chaperoned. The semor
members of the family would enquire
about the welfare of my folks
lengthen the conversation
meaningless gossip. Of
was that to me? My mind and heart
would cling only to the fascinating
form in front of me. In such a state
of absorption if a question was shot
at me unawares, I stuttered and
stammered.
Near the compound was a sweet
water well where our women-folk
went in the evenings to fiU their
pitchers. Before pipes carried water
into homes this was the only mode oi
conduction. Thus our women reaped
the benefit of an hour or two of fresh
air. Even the well-to-do availed
this opportunity. The village-well of
those days served the purpose of
modern ladies ’ gymkhanas or clubs.
Miserable daughters-in-law, tortured
by the tyranny of a harsh mother-in
law or troubled by tlie taunts and
tantrums of a sister-in-law, found
relief in pouring out their tale of woe
into the responsive ear of an equally
wretched friend. Both found solace in
each other ’s narratives. Others laughed
and joked and sang and were merry
as they filled their pots and went
their way. The stop press items of
newspapers carrying the latest news
reached but a few homes, hence the
main-spring of gossip and rumour
was that village-well. At least forty to
fifty companions gathered thus every
evening. I stood d^ly under the shade
of a tarmarind tree and watched the
cavalcade of companions pass by
with pots and pitchers balanced on
their heads or hung at their waists
One amongst the hundred was
distinctly outstanding. My gaze was
fixed upon this captivating beauty in
the full bloom of her youth, with
pitcher balanced on her head, gliding
to spend a fortnight
most eager
The
the
and
with
what value
unawares, I stuttered
of
gracefully along, her cheeks flushed
with a crimson glow of consciousness,
her features radiant with a sweet
smile, stealing sly glances at me. This
bewitching water-bearer was my
wedded wife.
The time for depature was drawing
near. There was still a little time for
the train to arrive so we settled on a
bench awaiting its arrival By chance-or
rather by contrivance we sat side by
side and that too at the furthest end
of the bench. Respecting the presence
of the elders, with whispers and
glances, through slight touches and
imperceptible flirtations, we, rapidly
exchanged sentiments of love and
affection. The beU tolled, the train
arrived. There was a hustle and bustle;
the guard blew his whistle and even
while I looked, my heart ’s delight,
wrapped in white Chinese satin,
receded from sight. To me she seemed
like an angle in the sky, this lovely
creature of unparalleled beauty of
form and features. But her image was
absorbed in my being. My heart held
its beloved within its deepest recesses.
Upon my mind was sculptured the
beauty of her form. Spiritually I was
a bom iconoclast, mentally I became
an idolater. With such beautiful and
unforgettable memories I left Navsari.
was
Self Confidence
Between December 1893 and
January 1894 Bombay was in a state
of agitation and excitement. The
great patriot, Dadabhoy Navroji, had
come to Bombay to preside over the
ninth session of the Lahore National
Congress. In the Bible it is stated :
‘Knock and it shall be opened to you ’
Lal Mohan Ghosh had Imocked twice
on the doors of the British Parliament
but they were not opened to him; so,
disheartened, he retreated. With the
persistence of a Navsari-ite, Dadabhoy
also knocked. He knocked again and
again, repeatedly and ever louder, and
only when they were opened, did this
‘black man ’ of Lord Salisbuiy rest. In
clubs and friendly circles this was the
main topic of conversation.
Bom and bred in poverty, Dada
bhoy Navroji by the strength of his
character and the wealth of his
December
55my detested subject —^maAematics. If
only I could find a school where I .......
could study the subjects of my choice! seU. ’ I,
of English, history, Persian, science
and oAer alhed subjects, but such a
school did not exist. So I resolved to
educate myself.
I surmised Aat if I continued my ... luc uwu yvi>; ai
v t. Knowleoge what was more important, within
Or fHnrtlich Ml o^z^«*TT 'D«^«kz>i« m ^2 ... r
. —J —Uiiv puuuvauvu UtL UId.1
_____... TT_ reading magazine. After aU Ae accounts of
succeeddi, then why shouldn ’t I? He centration. With utmost car^I cho&e
!? AU day long such thoughts filled books. No one ’s advice
j_.. _.-_j ,___, ..._________ . . ..
ni^t.
> -J -------------------—-------- --- jiitvicai Ui rvs /j yct Ul
1 returned a new man. An undreamed Eagerly did I devour history, bio ¦ borrowed remaineu intact
----- 1... , ------
a hundred rupees was due. Through
7 \ ------ J a Hindu
was sougi;t friend, I was loaned that amount a*
. an interest of an anna per rupee per
the preface month. Within a year I paid .an
interest of Rs 75, yet the amount
At last I decided to set aside m>
,----------- sense of shame and reveal the tale of
education philosophy. Though my troubles to my uncle. Everyone in
On retummg to Karachi I started the hbrary was replete with novels. I the famUy had been against this enter-
-eekrng some employment. A job was never read them. It was particularly prise from the start With er'^at
not easily available and when one did suprising as I had become the editor c ' ’ ' ’ - "
come my way, it was to be an and proprietor of a magazine that first issue to my father-in-law
honorary apprenticeship. I was a C’ contained mostly fiction. - . -
Class member of the Municipal C 1______ ________
Library at the Frere Hall. I realized of 1894 the Gulshcm-e-Danesh (the
that nothing could be achieved m Garden of Wisdom) ___ i
this world without higher education, under Parsi patronage and nty editor-
I had attained no such education nor ship. I was twenty then. My salary as
was I willing to do so because^ that ^ editor was Rs 5. As it faced a unde was" not mS?. With a .liKh'v
would entail the compulsory study of deficit m the very first year, the pro- reproath he immediately gave me ±e
.Cuatipued on page 51
graphy and stories of travel. Within a
span of five years I was attracted to
'¦eeking some employment. A job was never read them. It was particularly prise from the start '
, -J “ • ------- — -------' enthusiasm I had sent a copy of its
come my way, it was to be an and proprietor of a magazine that first issue to my father-in-law at
contained jnostly fiction. Bombay. I received strict instructions
from there never to send such trash
to him again. From China came tire
was published admonition that I should abandon
such vain endeavours a ndeven ae that
stage consider going to China. My
"¦“i a slight
On the Zoroastrian New Year ’s Day
Garden of Wisdom)
isBxasasuB
Invest in a gift from our incomparable series of religious medallions in 9990 fine silver.
Shiri Ganeshji*Shri Lakshmiji*Shri Saraswatiji*Guru Nanak Zarathushtra*Shri Tirupatiji*Shrinathji
zXvailable in 5, 10, 15, 25, 40, 50, and 100 gram Denominations
Manufactured by : NATIONAL REFINERY PRIVATE LIMITED
NATIONAL JEWELLERS
Manufacturers & Dealers in Ornaments & Jewellery 7/9, 3rd Agiary Lane, Dhanji Street, Bombay 400 003.
Phones : 329991 321078
56At that time the Lord of Justice would
surely hold me accountable for her
failings being her husband and the
custodian of her behaviour!
Religion teaches man lessons cf
truth and devotion. It holds before
mankind the ideal of universal
resurrection of the Day of Redemp
tion. Yet that same religion raises
lessons
of
With Best Compliments
From
F. B. Ilavia
Na.iaging Director
Messrs
Udaipur Distillery
Company Pvt. Ltd.
Udaisagar Road, Udaipur 313 001;
Post Box No. I
Rajasthan.
Phone No. 4521 & 4522
Grams ’ “DISTILLERY”
“ To ward off sin I used to
put on a deep, white
night-cap .... my (wife)
told me I look like a
corpse-bearer.”
With Compliments
of
jihads throughout the world, pitches
man against man, divides communities
into sects and castes and creates
bitterness
between loved
Religion alone was sowing the seeds
of separation in the soil of our love-
tilled lives. True, it was according !o
my concept of religion at that time.
Conventions and consecrations like
the utilization of taro were religion to
me. My co-mate was no worshipper
of conventions. I was in the ranks of
the faithful —my partner was an
infidel. Why were we so different?
Both of us had been born and bred
in conserorthodex. My father-in-law
was even more orthodox than my
uncle and my father. My life ’s com
panion had to live a dual existence in
her childhood. She had to wrap her
‘mathabanoo ’ (scarf) in two styles.
As long as father was home it had to
be tied just two fingers above the eye
brows. The moment father left for
the shop the mathabanoo travelled
upwards and loose, high-set, un-part-
ed hair adding beauty to the features,
came into view. Women wore long-
sleeved vests like men. These loose
vests were decorated with laces,
ribbons and frills. Should my lady dare
to follow such fashion and her father
chance to spy it, that apparel
immediately found a burial. Between
the ‘sapat ’ of olden days and the shoes
of modem times, the slipper had
established a place of prestige. Had
my lady to go out in the presence of
her father, she would leave the house
in ‘sapat ’ and then adorn her feet
later with slippers hidden in some
secret nook or corner. Such were the
strict and stern codes of behaviour in
and castes and
and misunderstanding
and loving ones.
Starlite
Electrical
Works
Electrical
Engineers &
Contractors
Fern House,
13, Or miston Road,
Bombay 400 039
spy it,
oiiivi. auu oLviii L/Vjuo ui uviiavluul ru
which she had been reared. On reach- I
ing adulthood, when her thoughts
and emotions functioned freely and
idependently, all obligatory rules and
restrictions of childhood were
immediately disregarded and discarded.
of
.57((
The village-well of those
days served the purpose
of modern ladies’
gymkhanas or clubs.”
money. However, the following day
I received a lengthy letter from him
on the malady of incurring debts and
the disgrace and dishonour that
accompany a debtor.
not
were wedded;
Here Comes the Bride
Child-marriage was not a Parsi
custom. In ancient Iran child-marriages
were unknown. After coming to this
country, among the many Hindu
practices adopted by the Parsis, tnis
custom of getting children married at
an early age was adopted. Thus veiy
young children were wedded; but,
until they reached puberty, the boy
and girl lived with their parents. Only
after the girl came of age did she
leave her parental home to go into
the home of her in-laws.
Forty-five years after my uncle had
settled in Karachi the auspicious
occasion had arrived to welcome
daughter-in-law into
a
daughter-in-law into our home. On
the dawn of my twentieth binhday.
* my bride stepped into our home.
“ counsels
deep and
Asho Zarathushtra counsels a
couple on the threshold of marriage
to let their love be pure and abiding
and vie with each other in devotion.
With my whole mind and heart and
soul, I loved my beloved. She return
ed my affection with a
sacred devotion. It seemed impossible
to find another couple in the whoie,
wide world so deeply devoted and so
passionately in love. But. . .
The more we lived together, the
more did we know each other, under
stand each other. It was not long
before we realized that our thinking
was not in harmony. Our principles
of life were completely different.
In order to vanquish the devil and
to crush his evil intentions I would
apply the ‘waters of the Golden
River ’—‘taro ’—three times religiously
to my face, hands and feet early in
the morning.
To derive the maximum benefit of
its miraculous effect, I would apply a
cupful of it three times over my whole
body from the scalp of my head to
the soles of my feet before bathing.
Not only did my good lady refuse to
use ‘taro ’ but she even dared to
dissuade me doing so, with entreaties,
that I was harming my skin unneces
sarily by the application of so unclean
a substance. One day while she was
running,
bathing. I stealthily and suddenly
poured a tumblerful of taro from
above all over her. She raised a
mighty hullabaloo and every one
came running, anticipating some
calamity. When I placed my case
before them, they declared my deea
as correct from the religious stand
point, yet my uncle did not ipprov;
of my behaviour.
According to the Vendidad shorn
hair is considered as desecrated as
pared nails. I also believed that it was
sinful to move about bare-headed or
to sleep with the head uncovered. In
order to ward off sin I used to put on
a deep, white night-cap like the one
mobeds wear. My good lady told me
I looked like a corpse-bearer in that
cap. To suppress the source of evil,
instead of the white cap I donned a
cap made of checked cloth. Not
pacified, my dear wife said I looked
like a cook in that headgear.
My wife persuaded me to go my
way and to let her lead her own life.
But how could that be? I was ner
rightful husband and as such was
responsible for her joys and sorrows.
If she did not use ‘taro ’, disregarded
the rules of piety and purity, flouted
customs and conventions, it would
result in heinous sin and after death
her soul would lose its way and be
unable to cross the Bridge of Doom.
OMtfnue.l on page ST
Dinshaw Shapoorji & Co.
Transport Contractors, Crane Owners
Luxury Coach Operators
414/3, Kasarwadi, Pimpri
Poona 411 018
Gram : TRUCK
Phone : 82658-83055-83056
Branch Office :
92/C, Mohammed Ali Road
Bombay 400 003
Gram : MOTORTRUCK
Phone : 323977-339718
58I
COMMENT AU
¦>»
A Western Response to Zarathushtra
Dr Dale Bishop
lence, Aesma which is akin to Persian
'^Kheshm'’ which means anger or
pu uappvxx .-------- fury. In the Avesta, Aesm is often
religion (Zoroastrianism), especially as charactensed by the epithet,
xv; Ju ouf 05^11 day,
in Zarathushtra ’s home-land we might
aptly substitute the epithet ‘Aesma of
One of the most frequently asked
questions of me has been, ‘how did
you happen to get interested in our
we^e such a small community ’? In of Ae bloody ejub ’.
fact, it might be asked, how is it tfcar
some of the finest scholars of the
stature of A. V. Williams Jackson,
Karl Geldner, W. B. Heiining, Mary
Boyce, to name only a few, how is it
that they have devoted lifetimes of
work to the study of a religion, which
today claims only a small number of
followers'. The answer, I think, lies
in a well-known aphorism, an apho
rism that certainly fits well also the
Parsi experience in Iiidia; It is not
the quantity but the quality that mat
ters and in encountering the thought
of Zarathushtra, western scholars have
agreed that they have encountered
the thought of a first rate mind, the
world ’s first great prophet and the
world ’s first great philosopher, to
borrow a description given by Jac
ques Duchesne-GleiUemin.
But what is it about Zarathushtra ’s
teachings that distinguish them as
uniquely profound? I will try to pin
point some of the aspects of Zoroas
trianism which have so inspired wes
tern admiration and which I believe
still speak in a meaningful way to the
human situation, East and West. The
first of these insights which springs to
mind is Zarathushtra ’s recognition of
the reality of evil in this world,
hate to start on such a negative note.
It is generally agreed that Zara
thushtra lived and taught his message
in the region of Eastern Iran at a date
for which, at least among
scholars, there ’s no agreement.
can tell from the Gathas, however,
that he lived in a settled pastoral
society, one which was prey to the
ruthless depredations of nomads. The
effects of the mindless and destructive
fury of these nomadic plunderers are
poignantly described in the Avesta,
where in the Meher Yasht, for exam
ple, we read of a man, his family,
and his cattle being led down the dry
and dusty path of captivity.
Evil presented itself to Zarathushtra
in the most stark and blatant form.
2Larathushtra called this wanton vio-
one
I
western
We
I’m touching the fringes of a contro
versy which was introduced by west
ern scholars. This is the problem of
dualism and monotheism. My own
feeling is that the term dualism is
capable of so many interpretations as
to be practically meanin^ess and Us
application to Zoroastrianism is mis-
I leading at best, and mischievous at
I worst. If Zoroastrianism is dualistic,
I then so must be Christianity, Judaism
I and Islam, for all three, to a greater
I or lesser extent regard evil as a reality
I of this world, propogated by an evil
I spirit.
I But as Zarathushtra recognised ths
I reality and nature of evil in this world,
I he also taught that evil is, by its very
I nature, finite and self-destructive. In
I the long run, it cannot triumph over
I Asa the good, the best Truth. Tliis
I world, at its worst, is a place where
I both good and evil exist and at its
I best, that is, when it reaches the state
I of renewal, called the ‘making won-
i derful ’, as ultimate potential, it will
I be a place where only good exists.
I Evil ’s victories are always short term
I ones. The good, because of its inhe-
" rent Truth and wisdom, will have the
ultimate victory. This victory, how
ever, cannot take place without the
. co-operation, the right choices of
This is not a gratuitous msertion, human beings.
’1 Thus, on the one hand, Zarathush-
t tra rejected the idea that evil is illu-
unique sory. On the other hand, Zarathush-
", tra rejected the idea that the world is
an essentially evil place, a place from
which one should seek escape, a re
lease. At various points in it ’s long
history, Zoroastrianism has been con
fronted with both extremes in belief,
and yet the central message, the mid
dle way as it were, remained essen
tially intact. It is this middle way
which William James, the great Ame
rican psychologist of religion, charac
terised as healthy-minded, as opposed
that is, its irrationality, that has dra^ to what he called the religion of the
the attention of western scholars.
Zarathushtra didn ’t try to explain
evil away. He didn ’t deny its reality. --------
He frankly admitted its existence and identify the good. I, along with mariy
activist as he was, he exhorted his earlier students of Zarathushtra ’s reli-
followers to get on with the business ^on, consider him to have been the
of eradicating it from this world. world ’s first philosopher, but if we
i
?
the summary trial and firing squad ’,
but is in fact very pertinent to the
topic of my talk, for it is in part at
least, that Zarathuehtra ’s ur.:-,:*
understanding of the nature of evil.
We miss an aspect of
Zarathustra’s greatness,
if, ... we overlook the
beauty of Zarathustra’s
poetry, a beauty, which
itself, conveys a message.
sick soul.
But the question may asked,
indeed has b^n asked, how is one to
earlier students of Zarathushtra ’s reli-
world ’s first philosopher, but if we
59BOYS’ TOWN
Public School
Nasik 2
look to the Gathas for an elaborate mind. Of the two spirits, the It
philosophical system explaining in follower chose to do the worst thing
deuil what exactly is good or giving the most holy spirit chose Truth. L
-i_, X clothed himself in the stoney vault <
the Heavens,
CHOICE SCHOOLING
FOR YOUR SON
Recognised as a Public School
by Department of Education —
for Indian Merit Scholars.
Excellent Climate — All-round
Education:
All Academic Subjects — Tech-
nical Subjects: Radio and Wood-
Work Technology, Farming —
Training in Self-Government
through Elected Boys ’ Office
bearers, Games — Physical
Training — Daily Assembly with
Congregational Prayers — Week
ly intensive Zoroastrian — Geeta
— Koran classes — Excellent
Modern Kitchen and Dining
Room facilities — Airy Dormi
tories.
philosophical system explaining in
r ’ ' ' ¦ ' ¦ _
a proof or elaborate exposition, such
as we might find, say, in Aquinas ’s the Heavens, so also do those wh
“Summa llieologica ”, we shall be choose to satisfy the Lord Wisdoi
disappointed. with true deeds. Of these two, th
The Gathas are hymns of devotion. False Gods did not choose correctlj
emotional outpourings of a man who tor while they were deliberating, con
had a vision, a vision of the cosmic fusion came upon them so that the
forces which govern the world, which chose the worst mind. They rushei
move history forward. They are also off into mindless fury with which the;
compositions of great poetic merit, ' '
which follow ancient standads of pro- ___ ___ ....................... ....... .......
sody, and yet are vivid, lucid and theme is choice, both the choice of thi
original in their imagery. We miss two spirits and the choice which eaci
an aspect of Zarathushtra ’s great- man must make for himself is cha
ness, if, in straining to get the mean- racterized by the use of interesting
ings of the Gathas, we overlook the parallels. Unfortunately it ’s very diffi-
beauty of Zarathushtra ’s poetry, a ’ -•
beauty, which itself, I believe, conveys
a message. To call Zarathushtra a
poet is in no way a derogation of the
<- . __________ _ ___________ _
vey levels of reality, can touch springs structure within each line of the
of human understanding, whivii dij
philosophical discourse cannot pene
trate.
in Aquinas ’s
we
We miss
of Zarathushtra ’s great-
now plague our mortal existence. ”
This passage in which the majo:
a cult to convey this in a translation,
In stanza two, the choice is laid out,
In stanza three, the antipathy of the
- , „ — two spirits is heightened or highlight
quality of his mind. Poetry can con- ed, I should say, by the use of paraileJ
vey levels of reality, can touch springs structure within each line of the verse,
of human understanding, which dry In stanza four, the additional contract
of beginning and end is added to that
of lie-follower and truth-holder. Five
is largely concerned with the correct
choice of the Holy Spirit. Six, with
the incorrect choice of the daevas.
Throughout, the sense of opposition
is emphasised by the use of these
poetic parallels. The poetic structure
strengthens the message by re-inforc
ing the stated theme of choice and the
two alternatives of that choice.
Neverheless, despite this wonderful
poetry, we have to face the fact that
the Gathas leave many questions un
answered. The composer of the
Denkar, the Pahlavi religious encyclo
pedia, recognised the problem and
The reason so many
disagree about the
teaching of Zarathushtra,
is that there is no con
sensus on an acceptable
translation of the
Gathas.
“Moderate Fees as per wish
of the Founder so that the
the children of non-affluent
parents are able to take
advantage of the school. Sub-
stanteal concessions and free-
ships offered to deserving
students. Zoroastrian social
workers welcomed r^arding
recomm'endation and admission
of boys at concessional fees. ”
to
Zoroastrian
welcomed
APPLY TO THE
MANAGING TRUSTEE
P. N. Mehta Education Trust
Cooks Building, 324 D. N. Road
Bombay 400 001 or to the Principal
Let me cite a brief example from
Yasna Hah 30 verses 2 to 6. I should
digress here briefly to say that one o. rtas“di^li;r;it7 “cor^l oV^rZstrZ
the reasons so many people disagree scriptures, which was much larver in
about the teachings of Zarathushtra,
is that there is no consensus on an
acceptable translation of the Gathas.
Each scholar has his favourite, usually
his own. -
is, appropriately, my own.
“Listen with your ears to the best
things, see with a lucid mind, the two
choices, for the decision which each _ __ ____wa.
man must make for himself, aware whiclT explSd* to' the beUever how
beforehand of the great trial which is the lofty principles of the Gathas
to follow for us. P'— *----- ’ -¦ -
primeval spirits, who as twins declare what should
their nature as good or evil in thought,
word and deed. Of these the benefi
cial one, chose correctly; not so
evil one. / ' '
confronted each other in the b^iu- adherent of a reUgion neel ’ to h^e
nin^ they created life and non-hfe, principle translated into practice. And
existence thus over the yeare, the priests per-
would be for the foUowers of the he formed their yeomen ’s task
and for the truth-holder, the best This division of the scriptures no
scriptures, which was much larger in
ancient times than what has survived,
into three categories. Gasanig, Dodig
and Hadumanstig that is, Gathic, that
part which is derived from the Gathas
I sections
such as the vendidad and the Hadamn-
stig or the ritual sections of the Aves
ta. The latter two were considered to
be the supplementary texts, texts
- - . - 7-— ¦ pan wluul IS uciivcu irom tn
The translation I will use themselves; the DadiP legal
fhere were two could be applied to everyday life,
------- 1 be the laws governing
society, how should one punish sin
ners, what is the proper way to con-
. , , - duct worship of the deity. These are
And when these two spirits by no means trival questions, for the
60total
The late and lamented Prof. Zach- approach being Professor Mary Boyce
first orientalists were intent to getting encapsulated in the title of his famous Boyce has emphasized the continuity
attention to the rites and tht legal and triardsm. Professor 2Lachner it is clear,
scriptures. They discarded as late Professor Gershevitch ’s distinction bet- the Denkard passage. The Denkard
priestly acbretions those texts that ween Zoroastrianism and Catholic encompasses hll three aspects of the
didn ’t accord with their own vision of Zoroastrianism, we see a more subtle religion: The Dadi^ the Hadumans-
Tf we cut off the Gathas from the
rest of the Avesta,
the general spirit of the religion as it
is developed over the years. We also
risk falling prey to the fallacy of pro
jecting what we hope to find in the
Avesta from what actually is there.
This gap between expectation and rea
lity has influenced western views to
wards the prophet and his religion. To
________ _ _ some, he was the first protestant, the
¦ ¦ ¦____ ' ¦_________ ‘ • Although these scholars differ rebel against priestly authority, to
more typical approach was that of greatly from one another on many others, he was the first rationalist.
the on the scenario. After Zarathushtra, inspired shaman, another as a crafty
matter how well it served the need of theme in the western response to the total 2Loroastrian experience
the Zoroastrians through the years, Zoroastrianism. appears, the leading exponent of this
nevertheless bewildered and misled The late and lamented Prof. Zach- approach being Professor Mary Boyce
western scholars. Since most of the ner ’s views on this matter are perfectly of the University of London. Prof,
first orientalists were intent to getting encapsulated in the title of his famous Boyce has emphasized the continuity
to the heart of thin gs, they paid little book Dawn and Twilight of Tjoroas- of tradition as against ^continuity
attention to the rites and tht legal and trianism. Professor Zachner it is clear, and decline and in so doing, she ac-
ritual prescriptions of the Zoroastrian greatly preferred the ‘dawn ’. Again in cepts the evaluation of the writer of
scriptures. They discarded as late Professor Gershevitch ’s distinction bet- the Denkard passage. The Denkard
priestly accretions those texts that ween Zoroastrianism and Catholic encompasses hll three aspects of the
didn ’t accord with their own vision of Zoroastrianism, we see a more subtle religion: The Dodig, the Hadumans-
what the Prophet should have taught, perhaps, but nonetheless faithful ren- tig along with the Gasanig.
One scholar, James Daomesteter, dering of the same basic scheme cf If we cut off the Gathas from the
famous as a translator of the Avesta, Zoroastrian history. rest of the Avesta, we risk missing
laboured under the delusion for several
years that even the Gathas were not
genuine. At one point, he asserted
that the Gathas must have been a
forgery by a member of the school of
the Platonist Philo of Alexandria of
the 1st. century B. C. Fortunately,
this was a temporary and uncharacte
ristic aberration in an otherwise
ditsinguished academic career A far „ * . . - .
more typical approach was that of greatly from one another on many others, he was the first rationalist.
Martin Hang who counselled the points, they are in general agreement One scholar depicted him as a drug-
Parsis to pay attention only to the on the scenario. After Zarathushtra, inspired shaman, another as a crafty
Gathas, for these were after all in his it ’s all down-hill: accretion of foreign politician. In fact the history of wes-
view, the pristine and uncorrupted beliefs, priestly legalism, etc. tern scholarship of Zoroastrianism
form of real Zoroastrianism and to a It is only in recent years that among tells us as much, sometimes more,
certain extent this has been a general Western scholars, an appreciation for about western intellectual history than
If we cut off the Gathas
from the rest of the
Avesta, we risk missing
the general spirit of the
religion
Ruttonjee Jehangir
Established in I860
66, Bazargate, Fort, Bombay 400 001
Tel. 262679
Tel. Address : “QUICKWAY"
(Manufacturers of Tableware & Presentation Items)
The oldest manufacturers, exporters, wholesalers and retailers, of
Silver and Nickel-Silver items of Oriental and European design
61This affliction of
projecting ones own
expectations upon the
scriptures .... is the
well-known supermarket
approach to religion
what 18 right and just. He laid down conversion and inter-marriage, that is
the great moral imperatives and left a question the Parsis themselves must
it to those who followed him to apply decide. What I’m saying is simply
these principles to the living of our that since Zoroastrianism has pro-
everyday life. The process has con- foundly influenced the world ’s great
tinued through the ages and it goes reli^ons, including my own, Chris-
on today. It is what makes a religion tianity, the import and validity of
dynamic, not just a set of empty and Zarathushtra ’s message is a legacy
outdated legalisms, but a way of life, from which the whole world will con-
Sometimes the choices are easy but tinue to benefit. As a scholar of Zoro-
often they are complex and difficult, astriansm and an admirer of its tenets,
But it is perhaps consoling to remem- I proudly claim 'that legacy.
ber, I think, that the most significant
questions are those that defy pat and
easy answers .... ————
Finally, Zarathushtra has captivated Dr Dale Bishop
the attention of the West, because he ’
was perhaps the first universalist in New York, in 1979 Bishop
his, approach to religion. Zarathush- visited Bombay, to, in his words, ‘'study
tra s vision of history is a cosmic Zoroastrianism as it is practiced today
vision j his depiction of redemption, is among the Par sis”. During his stay he
a redemption for all mankind, his delivered two talks on the religion
God is not a national God or a tribal Western Response to Zarathushtra’’ at the
God, but a God of the Universe.
Thus his legacy is one to which the auspices of Zoroastrian Studies extracts
whole world can lay claim. By insist- which have been reproduced above,
mg upon the universal character of "Eloquence in the A vestas” at the
! teachings, I have no Cama institute of Oriental Studies on 31
it docs about Zoroastrianism itself.
This affliction of projecting one ’s
own expectations upon the scriptures
has not been restricted to western
scholarship. It is the well-known su
permarket approach to religion. Alas,
Zarathushtra does not fit neatly into
any of the categories, we so carefully
prepare for him. To the latter two
categories which I mentioned, he does
not fit at all. But it is perhaps a testi
mony to the stature of the man that
so many have tried to enlist his teach
ings in their own particular crusades.
Zarathushtra, it is clear regarded igno
rance as a manifestation of evil and
ffius impUed in his understanding of ^al&h^s uu ---
iruth, the uldmate good IS the use of intention of entering the continuing A/ay, 1979.
mans rational faculties in determining controversy among the Parsis over
is an Associate Professor
of Iranian studies at Columbia University,
------ > York. In 1979 Bishop had
_ visited Bombay, to,
vision of history is a cosmic Zoroastrianism as it
i among the Parsis". During
‘*A
Birla Auditorium on 8 May, 1979 under
342 Years
of combined
experience
have made the four units of
Tata Textiles
one of the largest leading groups
of cotton textile mills in the country
3,55,000 spindles and 7555 looms
spin and weave
over 1264 lakhs metres
a year of quality fabrics,
a part of which find their
way to distant overseas
markets
62
r/iTTi
f epro'.
The Central India Spinning. Weaving & Manufacturing Co. Ltd. Nagpur.
The Svadeshi Mills Co. Ltd. Bombay.
The Ahmedabad Advance Mills Ltd. Ahinedabad
The Tata Mills Ltd. BombayIN MEMORIAM
(^¦3
and was a strict vegetarian. ”
In 1919, Dabu was appointed the
principal of the Surat Parsi Orphanage
where he served for nearly 27 yeais
till 1946 when he took over as
principal of the M. F. Cama Athornan
Madressa at Andheri, Bombay. I wo
years later, in 1948, Dabu was instal
led as the high priest of the Wadiaji
Atash Betiram. Prior to his appoiiit-
__ _ moocus aa a mvut, the position was hereditary
¦_____________J. _____i (Dabu) who from father to son. Dabu retired as
dedicated his life to simple living and the high priest in 1977 due to his age.
service to tho community through Ervad Framroz M. the
simplified religious teachings. ” Among boyewala at the Wadiaji Atash Bemjm,
the many prominent personalities wuo spoke of the “simple life of Dabu.
....... -----“From eight to ten every mormng he
would sit here, ” says Antia, pointing
to the row of chairs in the foyer of
the Atash Behram. Here he would
meet those who came to visit him or
:1 ¦ ’ , he
were also held in community centers would retire to his room to his writ
Jam-e-Jatnshed, the Gujarati daily, would go to perform clerical c&p-
“great part in monies. “He never accepted a parse.
—J jjg always advised those whom he
_ 2 .......................... .IX J*--
The Kcdser-e-Hind charity, ” says Antia. Vakil estimates
that in this manner alone Dabu donat-
5 lacs to charity. He
the income-tax depart-
_ _____ _____________ J against Dabu for
prep^ed^by the BPP, Dabu was born non-payment of tax on earning he
on 20 April 1889 in a poor family had not accepted. However, with the
in Navsari and became a Navar and assistance of leading lawyers hke
of 12. He started Palkhiwalla and others, Dabu won his
I dastur almost case. Antia adds that Dabu h^ also
side-by-side he reduced his own salary which he
Zxiu-uiosuu uvu. _____ As an author, a religious author in
or passed his matric in 1906 with a first particular, Dabu contributed ai^cles
m class. After graduating with a Masters regularly to Chirag Mag^e, a /toro-
the degree in En^ish in 1912 from Wilson astrian Theosophist pubhcation, f^
a highly knowledgeable person, a
philanthropist. .. he left a great
treasure of religious literature. ” H. B.
Kapadia, joint secretary of BPP,
compared Dabu to a “king at the head
of the dastur clan. . .an intellectual
light for all. ”
Jal Heerjibehedin, editor of Kcuser-e-
Hind, appealed to the large gathering
at the C^a Hall to start a Provident
Fund for the dasturs and mobeds as a ment,
“fitting tribute to a man (
to thi community through
spoke at the meeting was Ercsch
Nadershah, president of the Rahana-
ma-Mazdayasni Sabha, a body crea!
ed for religious reform, and former
chairman of BPP. ------ - ¦ u u- t ?
A number of condolence meetings discuss matters with him. ^ter,
were dso held in community centers '—” ’ \ " •
outside Bombay. An editorial in the ing and study, and m the evemngs
Died: Dastur Khurshed S. Dabu, crests Dabu with u
91, high priest of the Seth Hormasji rekindUng the faith and sincerity /„i ‘..n
B. Wa^aji Ata^h Behram in Bombay Zoroastrians dunng the tune of reh^ served to give J*® ^g*)J
for almost 30 years, former princip.d gious dechne. ” The nhAntv. ” savs AnUa. Vakil estimates
of the M. F. Cama Athoman Madressa echtorial writes that H^bus prince
and the Surat Boy ’s Orphanage, ' ' „ ' " *
professor in English and noted author exists. ” __ _
and orator, on 30 October 1979 at
Ahmedabad after a proIongel illness.
¦ ¦ ' a very
brilliant man. .. there is no one to
;w-A<>A.J3
£
Dastur Khursfaed S. Dabu,
He never accepted a paise.
will be felt as long as the commumty ed about Rs. 5
recalls that th.
According to a life-sketch of Dabu ment filed a case
on 20 April 1889 in
________ ____ ______ __ i„ X?--- 1 —- --
replace him, ” says Dastur Kaikhusroo Maratab by the age ?
M. JamaspAsa, high priest of the to practice as a
Anjuman Atash Behram in Bombay, immediately and ---- , , > • «riPQt
“He dedicated his entire life to the studied at the Sir Cowasji Jehangir received as high pnest.
service of the community .. .He never
accepted any gift or present
ashodad, ” ... writes Shiavax Vakil m
the prestigious Gujarati daily,
Bombay Samachar. Vakil,
lawyer and director of the Tata group --------- - :¦ — t—write
of companies, was closely associated ed as an assist^t professor of En^ish ,on. In 1946, he ^e
with D&.U ever since his first job as at fergusson CoUege, Poona, where ® dS.un
a teacher under Dabu ’s principalship he worked for a year. Fhe Gujarati dady notes mai umi^
L 1936 He then worked for Dr Anine the 30 years of his asswiaUon^
Two condolence meetings were
ST ole'iomdv *67 theand was the head master of the published in poor lorm. inruugii i
I .It o ’of ciienS Studies and the Kanpur Theosophist High School writing on religious subjects, notw
Rahnuma-Mazdavasni Sabha at the run by the Annie Besant Educational Bombay SazMOc/wr eitonal m 19
the Trust'and later the Alighar Dhartn. when Dahn
other by the Bombay Parsi Panchayat samaj High School. ship, lungs of
(BPP) at the Framji Cawasji Institute “He was a theosophist from his Parsis the n-efd
Hall on 3 December At the second youngest days and he never made a our rehgion. Inevitably he h^ to tread
mStaB Ktan-Betanm of his views, ” says Vakil. ‘He upon the coms of ^udo schoats and
chairman referred to Dabu as “a great believed in reiiwamation as the only occidtists. . .Dabu fought e^ m
scholar of religirm, an educationalist, logical explanation to life after deash straight forward manner.
63
“The communtiy has lost
M. JamaspAsa, high priest of the to practice
He dedicated his entire life to the studied at — , _
Zarthoshti Madressa from where he
class. After graduating with a Masters re^arl^^to
iiwiiLuaj, viiC Sso studied early twentieth century upto 1945
Avesta and Pahlavi) he was appoint- when the magazine stopped publica-
________ t Ae Jam-e-Jamshed.
'Fhe Gujarati daily notes that during
- - ... ------i_x:— —
leader of the Theosophist the paper he wote 1,403 reli^ous
in moia anu uio wx/iid, articles of which 303 have been
the head master of the published in book form. Through his
. - ________ - 1 ^ ... .1*.!_____
a leading College, Bombay, (he
Beasant, a ------- .
of movement in India and the world,p^ed his punches. He not only call-
w a spade a spade but even went to
the extent of calling a hypocrite and
a charlatan without any trimmings of
language." ®
Dabu ’s son. Noshir, writes to
Parsiana that his father was in the
6^ '
demonstrator. He obtained his Docto
rate degree
m
Chemistry from
f state uSy. {JsA
1953, he returned m
^4 of die Physical
Cheimstry Section, Chemistry Diviskm
;^^^/^emical Laboratory
he was appointed
{5;® .Head of the Solid State S^cal
BARC. During his
‘ as uie
l*ad of the Chemistry Dhision and
® Committee on Steam
, and Water Chemistry.
A^rding to Dastur, Karkhana-
, {ehgious inclinations were
strongly influenced by Karkhanavala ’s '
famer whom Dastur described as “a
w^te bearded, staunch orthodox Zoro-
f • K"khanavala ’s father repor
tedly withdrew his son from sctool
for one year so that he could
. trainmg to become
bide influence. 'Hiough he
it'
1 i
w
w
A
car accident on
year so that he could
Minocher Dadabhoy Karkhanavala
mgs were held in memory of Karkha
navala. These ------ - -
under the ----- '
Parsi j
of Oriental Studies,
rnp rVorio*- _ •. . _ *
tho
son, N^lm, writes to
truest sense a friend, philosopher and
guide to all of us. ”
Dabu is survived by his son. Noshir.
Died. Minocher Dadabhoy Karkhan
avala, 53 director of the Chemical
Group of Bhabha Automic Research
Centre (BARC) and noted exponent
of Zoroastrian orthodoxy, of injuries
sustained in a car accident on 17
November 1979, at the Military
Hospital in Delhi.
Distinguishable by the priestly
pagri that had become a part of his
everyday attire, Karkhanavala held a
number of senior positions at BARC
was connected with a number of
scientific and educational associations
and organisations which included
president of the Indian Thermal
Analysis Society and Chancellor ’s
Nominee of the Senate of the Univer- Parsi PanchTyltTfiPPi personaUy perform all the ^digious
sity of Poona, At the time of his death the Cama InsfltiitA rJ; ceremonies of his famil y
he was also a director of Indian Rare SJ Sa^^ SmincapaS understand-
Earths and a Member of the Board of Trustees of the Rana»^Af^^^io®’u nature, religion goes bevond
Management of the Nuclear Fuel the Athoman ManH Behrani, science in explaining nature ” was in
Complex, both public sector under- the Rustom Baue Aq Bombay and often repeated observation of Kark-
takin^. According to the bio-data of additSr meetkt^wel^^'*° “- to Daftun
Pi^oyided by BARC ne ed in Udvada Buka^ Sa^- .Karkhanavala is survived by his
had done much pioneering work in Bangalore and Cumt ’ Poona, wife, Siloo, son, Khurshed and
introducing new scientific methods In ___ where two such daughter. Arnmitv
the country and developing new pro
cesses and materials. He is also re
ported to have published over 100
research articles in scientific journals
in India and abroad.
While on an official tour of Jodh
pur in North India, Karkhanavala
in 1958 he was appointed
tenure
as the
I and
Karkhana-
! were
as '‘a
go
a
Navar and Maratab without any out-
bide influence. Though he was not a
^actrang dastur, JamaspAsa notes
the auspi«s “Sru,rB h “
If????"!. joi^ar™
, —VXAWXALCU QU
the Dadar Jashan Committee,
meetings were held. daughter, Armaity.
“He was a very reUgiouis minded
man who had some very definite and
somewhat rigid views of the religion,"
says Dastur Kaikhusroo JamaspAsa,
hi^ priest of the Anjuman Atash
Behram in Bombay. “He was highly
—what is known as —orthodox. Even
meetings were held,
---- _ ___
man who had some vety definite and
somewhat rigid views of the religion,"
Kaikhusroo JamaspAsa,
hi^ priest of the Anjuman Atash
____ Behram in Bombay. “He was highly
sustained serious head injuries" when hk
the wheel of the jeep he was traveUing J’®, always
in came off and the vehical overturn- u S Ka.ikhushroo
, r' ‘*o*-j aft/o iSbcuKnusnroG
Dastur, head of the Legal Depart •
c^- who shared
was
niMy platforais with Karkhanavala
He was the greatest champion
•TfcHirMrtiovwk _ _________a.’ . _ « *
Even when addressing a gathering
of Zoroastrians in Los Angeles, USA,
Karkhanavala dwelled on the evils of
Parsis marrying outside the community
nroc though several community
was members had brought their non-Parsi
spouses along.
Bom on 29 Novembw 1926,
—- LI.. in
Chemistry m 1947 from Elphinstone
CoUege in Bombay and his M.Sc. in
1949 in the same subject from Wilson
College where he was working as a
ed. He was admitted to the Jodhpur
hospital and later shifted to Delhi
where he died without regaining
ciousness. Karkhanavala ’s body __
rushed down from Delhi to Bombay . u •
so that the last rites could be perform- greatest champion of
ed in strict adherence to Zoroasfrian Ji®
practice. The funeral was thronged rSir^ dokhma^ adds
with prominent personalities, notable
among them was Dr Homi Sethna,
•director of BARC, colleagues, and
associates who came to pay their last
respects.
News of Karkhanavala ’s death v. "
featured in the leading daily papers
in Bombay. “In Karkhanavala ’s death „„ punvpmhA,. i
the Parsis loose a religious scholar Karkhanavala c
and the country a brilliant scientist, ” his B.Sc.
noted a column in the orthodox Guja
rati daily, the Jam-e-Jamshed.
In Bombay, five condolence meet-
64
Warden is good
For sandalwood
Head Office
378 Grant Road
Bombay 400007
and Branches
Tel. 371464
ment of the Bank of Baroda, and well
wiin Jv-aTKnanavala on
regions discussions and lectures,
was the greatest champion of
Dokhmaism. . .sometimes he used to
Quality undalwood
Aggarbatibs, gum benzdn
(loban) and other
Perfumes
/
I
◆ ◆ ◆
From the archive
