Complete Issue
Sep 1992
k
5 >5'^.
% ¦i-.
r.
k
k
k
L
‘i.
¦i;
/'
'•i’5
L
I
k
k
¦t
f
n
''?t'
Oe ’
IS
w
w
-vx-'-S
r
t
R
pSciV»na T^cz
8^'-i
September 1992
Volume 15 Numbers
EDITOR Jehangir R. Patel
MANAGING EDITOR Arnavaz S. Mama
EXECUTIVE EDITOR Parinaz M. Gandhi
ASSISTANT EDITOR Roxana A. Mirza
3 Readers' Forum
6 Events and Personalities
DESIGN Kranti Shilotri, Varghese Fernandez
MARKETING DIRECTOR Veera Patel
ADVERTISING MANAGER Zarin Mistry
ADVERTISING EXECUTIVE Cheryl Sequeira
CHIEF EXECUTIVE Rustom Thanavala
FINANCE B. L. Arora
EDP Rohinton E. Daroga
CIRCULATION Behram Umrigar
MANAGEMENT Jasmine Driver
10 Zoroastrians Abroad
13 The 1992 BPP Elections
15 Dr Syrus Irani: A matter of trust by Gustasp Irani
17 Rusi Sethna: Leading the court campaign
20 Jussawalia* s model commitment
OFFICE Khurshid Panthaki,
Patricia D'Silva, Bakhtavar Batliwalla,
Nowzer Batliwala, Bindu Pillai,
Sugatha S. Kurup, Asha Pillai
23 Keki PestonjI: Summoned by the sea
4
27 Kharas ’ burning (com)passion by Homi Rogers
OFFICE ASSISTANTS Umesh Poojary, Selvan
Mark, Sunil Sakhare, Pramod Patil
31 Wedlock ’s end: 6 by K. C. Vajifdar
33 Deen Rarest: A forum for the faithful by Noshir Dadrawala
36 Milestones
39 In iVtemoriam
Cover: Photographs by Gustasp Irani
Parsiana is published by Jehangir R.
Patel for Parsiana Publications Pvt Ltd, at
C/o H.L.Rochat, Navsari Chambers,
ground floor, 39 A.K.Nayak Marg, Fort, Bombay
400001 and printed by him at Kaiser-E-Hind
Pvt Ltd, 300 Perin Nariman Street,
Bombay 400001. Color processing. Comart
Lithographers; and black and white processing,
Samir Scantech Pvt Ltd. All rights reserved.
Phone; 2048730 Fax: 2042922
For editorial enquiries: 2048183 Telex 11-85710
RABO IN Annual inland subscription Rs 100 for
one year (12 issues); Rs 180 for two years
(24 issues). Foreign subscription rates:
Sea mail Rs 260/US $ 12/UK £ 7 for one
year, Rs 475/US $ 20/UK £ 12 for two
years (please allow six months or more
from the time of publication); Air mail
Rs 550/US $ 24/UK £ 14 (for Pakistan,
Indian Rs 290) for one year, Rs 1,050/US $ 45/
UK £ 26 (for Pakistan, Indian Rs 560) for two
years. For Indian upcountry cheques add Rs 5
for bank charges; for US cheques add $ 5; for
UK cheques add £ 3. Cheques and drafts are
to be drawn in favor of Parsiana and posted
to GPO Box 892, Bombay 400001t
READERS’ FORUM
I. I ¦l>lll)(»I(ll,l''
¦. ,«»> »»•»»,»»*>»»«•
illi»llH»H|i,V'
K .>»«I*»¦»><«{''
Al|< ?»»»»»»•(
. * > * » * » * * •*!
^^«««<) »»*»>
H
H
Hr, ’
fe'Kr
most democratic of all hobbies and one
can collect whatever one ’s heart desires;
you may do whatever you like in your
own house but when it comes to the pub-
»»»»»•.
»¦» I > I , I » O » ? II
• I H » I « »
Parsiana to merely reprint extracts from
old books is to do a disservice to the
cause of the multifold Zoroastrian inter
ests as well as to the extensive advances
in the knowledge of our long history and lie eye one has to observe some of the
ancient culture.
Mr Patel must be aware that there ex
ists a thriving London-based World
Zoroastrian Organisation (WZO), very lically reputable countries but from
active in the areas of amelioration of the
prevalent regulations and practices.
It is unfortunate that the stamps
shown in the article are not from philate-
t e 21»*
itiM*
|»H’ ’
active in the areas of amelioration of the countries which brought out a prolific
conditions of deprived Zoroastrian s here number of stamps with the idea of fleec-
and overseas. There do exist a South ing stamp collectors. Philatelic organi-
“ ------ zations have long been campaigning
against such stamps. The FIP has also
taken up the matter with (he UPU (Uni
versal Postal Union). Stamps on birds,
animals, butterflies, from philatelically
1
Readers' views are welcome on any subject
of interest to the community and should
be sent to the Editor, Readers' Forum,
Parsiana, G.P.O. Box 892, Bombay 400001.
Letters are subject to editing for reasons of
space and clarity. Unsigned letters or those
without an address will not be published.
and overseas. There do exist a South
Gujarat Fund and a Medical Benevolent
Fund. The point about “combined re
sources ” falls flat if he cares to recall the
clumsy attempts of our local association
here to discredit the WZO at every op
portunity: attempts that have dismally reputable countries like Great Britain,
misfired. Can these be connected with
Sasanian coins? farrokh vahfdar
London. U.K.
Australia, New Zealand, India, etc could
have been shown so that the collectors,
especially beginners, are not misguided.
The stamps displayed are not “rare ”
stamps. Some of the early issues like
Western Australia ’s “Black Swan ” or the
other early bird and animal stamps which
are not easily obtainable could have been
shown.
It is a misfortune that CTO (Cancelled
to Order) stamps which have not passed
J.
“The Stamp Safari ”
Let me congratulate you on the cover of
Parsiana, June 1992 and the article con
cerning me, “The Stamp Safari, ” by Ms
Meher Marfatia, which is very well
worded.
But I am very disappointed to see my
photo on page 20 which looks nothing through the postal mail and against
belter than wild life. d. r. mistry which there is much opposition from phi
latelists from all over the world, have
been shown. No commercially used cov
ers, cancellations, etc have been shown
D. R. MISTRY
The Editor replies
In deference to Mr Mistry we have repro
duced here the photograph he submitted which today are very essential,
(right) alongside the one earlier pub
lished so the readers may judge.
Sasanian coins
The letter (“Sasanian coins, ” Parsiana,
July 1992) from Mr Noshir Patel of Mid
dlesex is confused on several points.
While Prof A. H. Bivar has an interna
tionally renowned expertise in the nu
mismatic field, it is to limit him unduly
in implying that the Zoroastrian House
lectures were confined to coins and per
haps stamp-seals. Indeed the good pro-
fessor lectured amply on Ancient Iranian
inscriptions, complete with slides.
Similarly, Drs Kreyenbroek and Sims-
Williams just happen to be among the
very best scholars of Iranian languages;
their lectures too had little or nothing to article “The Stamp Safari ” (Parsiana,
do with numismatics. All three gentle- June 1992). However, I would be failing
men are no doubt Fellows of the Royal in my duty as a vice president of the
Numismatic Society here, but do their Philatelic Congress of India (The All In
Fellowships of the Royal Asiatic Society dia Federation) and as the Indian dele-
make them Asiatics?
Fardunji Paruck ’s large and excellent
book is dated, as are the sections on art
and history. Scholarship and specialized
researches have greatly progressed. For
One cannot also agree with the com
ment “Otherwise there is rarely any dif
ference between the value of used and
unused stamps. ” There is difference in
value in most cases.
The write-up and presentation is also
not up to current philatelic requirements.
The presentation and- write-up for the
Polish stamps done by numbers is not
proper. The making of black borders
around the stamp is long outdated. The
album page shown with a non-philatelic
photo/picture of a butterfly would imme-
As an enthusiastic philatelist I was happy diately disqualify the exhibit at even a
to see stamps on the front cover and the state level exhibition
items must be shown.
It is regrettable that the pioneering ef
forts of eminent Indian thematic collec
tors of the past like the late Mr Jal Coo
per, the late Ms Subhalaxmi, the late Mr
gate to two FIP (World Federation — the K. D. Dinsha and Mr M. P. Polson have
“United Nations of Philately ”) world not been mentioned.
congresses if I were not to draw the at
tention of your readers to certain impor
tant matters.
I
I
I
I
*
only philatelic
If Indian thematic collectors are to do
well at slate, national or international
Stamp collecting is the events they must properly study the sub-
3 Parsiana September 1992funds from all over the world.
A comment has been attributed to our
to sponsor a paramobed (“Federation
lends a sympathetic ear, ” Parsiana, June
1992).” This was only a suggestion given colleague Mr Dadi Mistry that he had
by one of the members and I disagreed as been wanting The WZO Trust to get an
we already have a panthaky looking after early tax exemption clearance,
the religious needs of the Jabalpur Parsis.
I may mention that Ervad Darabshaw E.
Karkaria is about 80 years old — and
stamps. Today, he has more than 20,000 may God bless him — and he attends to
wildlife stamps carefully pasted onto
1,200 ^bum pages. Some of the rare
ject and the present trends. This letter is
written purely from the interest of the fu
ture of Indian philately and with no other
moti ve . vispi s. dastur
Hon Editor, India's Stamp Journal
been wanting The WZO Trust to get an
It may be clarified that the application '
seeking tax exemptions for donors under
section 80G(5) was made to the tax au
thorities on September 20, 1991. The
every need here. He attends to the daily permission has been granted on April 6,
_ ___ r prayers of the members, and in addition 1992 and is retrospective from the date
stamps^ate baclTto 19th century. When performs the jashan ceremonies for the of application.
Mistry held an exhibition of his stamps Anjuman, which number about 10 every Donors to The WZO Trust are thus
in 1961, it was the first exhibition of year. He even attends to the muktad eligible for claiming exemption under
wildlife stamps in the world. ” table. In his work there is absolute sin- section 80G(5) of the Income Tax Act
Thus reads an entry on page 98 of the cerity and dedication, which the Parsis of 1961. dinshawk.tamboly
Limca Book of Records 1992 under the Jabalpur have been appreciating since Managing Trustee, The wzo Trust
section ‘Post and Telegraph. ’ It is indeed
a great honor for Parsis that in this five-
page section the names of only two phi
latelists appear
Darabshaw Rustomji Mistry.
His name was proposed by the Gov
erning Council of Baroda Philatelic Soci
ety for the award of Padma Shri. He was
cited as ‘Doyen of Philately ’ by the she is famous for. Many passengers
South India Philatelists ’ Association,
Madras at BIOPEX-89 Philatelic Exhibi
tion. He was a president of the Empire of mention that Banoobai ’s malida is some-
India Philatelic Society (EIPS).
Mr Mistry ’s labor of love has resulted
in a huge collection of zoos on stamps,
depicting birds, mammals, fish, butter
flies, insects, reptiles, amphibians and
pre-historic animals. A whole collection
is built on each topic, sometimes funning Some statements pertaining to the World
into hundreds of pages.
His collection on pre-historic animals
was displayed at the Eros Theatre during pathetic ear, ” (Parsiana, June 1992) re-
the show of the movie One Million Years
BC. In his one man show “Birds on
Stamps, ” at the silver jubilee celebration
of EIPS disclosed the fact, that India has poor Zoroastrian agrarians living below the Iranian Zoroastrians because the
not issued a single stamp on birds. This the poverty line, Mr Jamsheed Kanga is
news spread through the newspapers and reported to have commented that “There
made the government issue stamps on
birds.
The Times of India of December 25,
1966 notes: “To this modest, old man,
philately is hardly a hobby — it is a labor
of love, a way of life, chosen and culti
vated with tender care through the long
hard years of manhood and middle age. ”
CYRUS D. SIDHVA
“Largest collection of wildlife stamps —
D. R. Mistry of Bombay collects wildlife
Mistry held an exhibition of his stamps Anjuman, which number about 10 every
table. In his work there is absolute sin
cerity and dedication, which the Parsis of 1961.
one of them being Mr
1953.
Ervad Darabshaw is not only the pan- Psrsi Calendar reform
thaky but he is also the manager of The I was glad to know that the Federation of
Jabalpur Parsi Dharamshalla which he Parsi Zoroastrian Anjumans of India
has been managing very ably, assisted by (FPZAI) has taken up the matter of Parsi
his wife Banoobai, who, having suffered calendar reform and that the issue has at
a hip fracture, manages with a walker, least found favor with several persons in- '
and still turns out the tastiest food which eluding the chairman of the Bombay
Parsi Punchayet (“Federation lends a
sympathetic e^, ” Parsiana, June 1992).
It is well-known that all living organ
isms follow nature in the form of daily
thing out of this world. It is ordered by (diurnal), monthly (lunar) or yearly (an- ‘
the kilo and taken out of Jabalpur. The nual) regular variations. These are |
proof of the pudding (malida) is in the known as biological rhythms or circadian
eating! d.c.bajan clocks. Our Shenshahi and Kadmi calen- *
dars are all wrong because they have no
relevance to the seasonal variations in
nature.
Secondly, there is historical evidence
that a Zoroastrian from Persia named
Jamshid, who arrived in India in 1736 \
AD pointed out that the calendar fol- ‘
lowed by the Parsis in India was one j
month behind the calendar followed by |
come only because of the sumptuous
food that is served to them. 1 might also
D. C. BAJAN
President, Paisi Anjuman. Jabalpur
Zoroastrian Organisation (WZO) and the
WZO Trust in “Federation lends a sym-
quire to be clarified.
Regarding the work being done in the
villages of South Gujarat to rehabilitate
community in India had forgotten to add {
one Kabisa (or intercalation of one 1
is a wrong impression being created that month after 120 years) (Sanjana J. B., A ?
the work is done only by the WZO.” Comprehensive History of the Parsis, i
There is absolutely no doubt that were 1935, p. 608). It is well known that the
it not for the WZO the rehabilitation orbit of the earth around the sun takes
process would not have reached the stage
that it has.
The WZO, in keeping with its policies every four years as in the Gregorian cal-
of accountability towards its donors, re
leases regular reports on the project, ery 120 years as done earlier in the Ira- |
This has been appreciated very much by nian calendar. The late Mr K. R. Cama |
our donors who have been forwarding was the first to preach this reform in our |
Parsi calendar as early as 1882, but un
Regular reports on the status of the fortunately, to date we have not got our |
365.2422 days and the quarter of an addi- ?
tional day is corrected by adding one day |
i
endar or by intercalating one month ev
ery 120 years as done earlier in the Ira-
“Federation lends a... ”
While reporting on the proceedings of contributions from all parts of the globe,
the meeting of the Federation of Parsi
Zoroastrian Anjumans of India, which project not only keep the donors satis- calendar right because of the bigoted at-
was held in Bombay last March, you
have erroneously mentioned that “Agra, awareness of this massive problem/pro- trustees of the Bombay Parsi Punchayet.
Jhansi and Jabalpur have jointly agreed ject and results in a regular inflow of Our religion is the religion of right and
fied, but also help in creating greater titude of some high priests and some
awareness of this massive problem/pro-
4 Parsiana September 1992 s
5
Iwrong, and if a mistake has been com
mitted in the past, it must be rectified.
Even Pope Pius acknowledged about a
decade ago the mistake the ancient
Christians made of persecuting Galileo
for declaring that the sun was the center _______________ ___ _______
of the universe and not the earth. Today Parsi Punchayet were to set up a legal
we know that Galileo was right and Pope guidance cell, wherein Parsi lawyers/so- j wu. vununai *.-uiuiinia wu
Pius had the courage of exculpating the Heitors could give a helping hand to such indirectly favor conversion and mixed
great scientist after about 360 years, aged people. marriages. Is there any doubt that the
Such questions like vernal equinox on Such a cell could advise the aged on community will decrease because the
March 21 would correspond to spring how to regulate their papers (will, etc) so majority of those who go out are least in-
m the northern hemisphere but autumn that their assets pass on to their kith and terested in the Zoroastrian religion?
in the southern hemisphere are only kin with ease and a minimum of legal On New Year ’s eve, we had a small
foolish attempts at perpetuating a wrong formality and expense. get-together. As usual, in the party, con-
ca endar, for don t the Christians all There is also a crying need for more version and mixed marriage came up for
over the world celebrate their new social service organizations to arrange discussion. These topics were raised by
year on January 1, be it winter or sum- visits, assistance and companionship to those who had non-Zoroastrian spouses,
persons living alone. in explaining to their partners the rituals
About the question of doing baj jal m. korkhao of the great religion they were born into.
(prayers for the dead) on the varsi (anni- _ . . . But none of the preachers are practising
versary) of a person who dies on Febru- Old ParSl Gujaratl SOngS Zoroastrian rituals or philosophy.
ary 29 of a leap year, I have already After scrounging in the Chor Bazar, sec- One of the gentlemen was patting his
stated that the heavens are not going to ondhand dealers and old record shops, I own back on his success in bribing a
fall if the varsi rituals in a few cases are have collected several records of old priest in Bombay to get his white Ameri-
done a day earlier or a day later (Par- Parsi Gujarati songs of which the new can wife ’s navjote done. Now two years
siana, November 1991). Trustee Jam- generation of Parsis has not heard. after the navjote, neither of them wear
sheed Kanga has supported me in my From the records I made several audio the sudreh and ku?ti. And his wife does
stance by stating that Whether you pray tapes and gave them to my friends at not even know the basic prayer Yatha Ahu
on one day or another is immaterial. All cost. According to their feedback three Vairyo and Ashem Vohu. Upon my re
days are equally holy (Parsiana, July very important songs are missing from questing him to subscribe to Parsiana, he
1992).” Dr P. D. SUNAVALA my tape. answered, “Who likes to read garbage! ”
The only support for you I got was
from the ones who were married to
Zoroastrians and their reason for sub-
•Goola mari gol gol, Bool ne maravi scribing to Parsiana was just to be in
touch with the community.
I suggest you take a survey of your
readers and ask them their opinion re
garding conversion and mixed marriage.
I am, confident the answer of the major
ity would be against it. -------
outsiders step into the vacuum, and much
money goes out of the community —
into the public exchequer or other private
hands.
It would be a good idea if the Bombay
we know that Galileo was right and Pope guidance cell, wherein Parsi lawyers/so-
unable to get the benefit. Sometimes Readership blues
I do not understand why you are crying
about our community getting smaller.
Rather you should be worried about your
job as an editor.
What you sow is what you reap. The
saying is old, but it holds value even to
day. Through your editorial columns you
great scientist after about 360 years, aged people.
Such a cell could advise the aged on
how to regulate their papers (will, etc) so
that their assets pass on to their kith and
kin with ease and a minimum of legal
There is also a crying need for more
social service organizations to arrange
visits, assistance and companionship to
aged persons living alone.
JAL M. KORKJIAO
After scrounging in the Chor Bazar, sec
ondhand dealers and old record shops, I
have collected several records of old
Parsi Gujarati songs of which the
generation of Parsis has not heard.
From the records I made several audio
tapes and gave them to my friends at
cost. According to their feedback three Vairyo and Ashem Vohu. Upon my
new
my tape.
„ . I shall be much obliged if some Parsi
Emerging from the... gentleman or lady can loan me the fol-
I refer to the article by Mr Gustasp Irani lowing records;
about Ms Behroz Vacha, the founder of • " „
the Helen Keller Institute for the Deaf sole, Dinshaw saihe thaigai pole...
and Deaf Blind (“Emerging from the val- •Kaka kalinger jeva, Su aven
ley of silent darkness, ” Parsiana, April
1992). He has very well displayed Ms
Vacha ’s international eminence in her
field of service.
In fairness to her husband Com
mander Nariman Vacha I would like to
add that it was only after he had com
pleted his term with the Indian Navy that
he had served as the secretary of the
Bombay Parsi Punchayet and the N. N.
and R. N. Wadia Trusts.
•Kaka kalinger jeva, Su
damam...
•O Morarji Bhai O, Dinkarrao Desai,
Mumbai ma rehva hamne bhari padi
gai...
Please contact me at Yazdani Bakery,
C. P. Street, Fort, Bombay.
no
T. M. ZEND Edited by Amavaz S. Mama
H. N. PATEI-L
5
NEVILLE SARKARI
Gaffney, SC. USA
!
i
&
I
R
I
J
I
I
Legal advice for the aged
With the dwindling numbers of our com
munity, it has become quite common to
day for aged Parsi men/women to live
alone in their homes, unable to move
about much.
Some of these aged people have res
pectable savings which they would like
to pass on to their kin. But for lack of le
gal guidance, their papers remain in dis
order at their death, and their kith and
kin (who are often themselves old) are
Aefl items
400 00^
PHONE
5 Parsiana September 1992
LI
o
I
Events and
Personalities
Gallantry rewarded
Of the 10,000 nominations from the
armed forces, paramilitary forces and ketball and squash player, the curriculum
civil services in India and from 30 coun
tries across the globe, 200 students were
selected for the Defence Services Staff and
College course —
1991-92. Among constituted Uttam Yudh Seva Medal, re-
them was Major ports the Fed Newsletter. This award is
Cyrus Addie Pith-
awalla,
the Fed Newslet
ter of May 1992.
Currently pos
ted in the Srinagar the Siachin sector in Ladakh. As in
valley organizing charge of Operation IBEX, Nanavatty re-
counter-in sur- ~
gency operations,
Pithawalla started
if
responsibilities; member of the Banking
Services Recruitment Board, Western
Region; member of the Board of Studies
vitae further mentions. in Management at the Banaras Hindu
For displaying exceptional gallantr"' University and at the Pondicherry Cen-
leadership Brigadier Rustom tral University; member of the academic
Kaikhushru Nanavatty won the newly councils of the
Rajasthan Univer
sity, of the Indian
School of Mines
and of Human Re
source Develop
ment. He continues
to be associated ,
with the Aligarh
Muslim University *
where he did his
graduate, postgra-
the university and the state in athletics.
He is also an enthusiastic volleyball, bas-
believed to rank the second highest in the
informs distinguished service category.
Nanavatty was rewarded for com
manding a brigade over a long period at
an inhospitable altitude of 21,000 feet in
J
(
Pithawalla: in hard
field, high altitude
operations
his military career in 1979 as an officer
with the 17th Battalion Jammu and
Kashmir Rifles. During his 13-year stint
in the army, the 35-year-old major has
been posted to most of the “hard field,
high altitude and active operation areas .
including Nagaland, Arunachal Pradesh, L&T ChaiT TOT PeStOHjee
Ladakh and Kashmir, ” mentions his cur
riculum vitae. He has also served the
Madras-based Officers Training Acad
emy as an instructor.
Pestonjee: stress
within control
duate and doctoral studies, his bio data
informs.
Formerly active with the Indian Coun-
portedly succeeded in throwing out Paki
stani intruders by his meticulous plan
ning of air and land resources in an area
where not even a blade of grass can grow
because of the year round frost. Earlier
he was the commander of the Junior cil of Social Science Research, he is now
Leaders School, according to the News
letter.
a representative of the International So
cial Science Council on the UNESCO
board of commission for conceptual and
terminological analysis. He had previ-
Job satisfaction, employee morale and ously served the International Sociology
stress management, the sphere in which ‘
Professor Dinyar M. Pestonjee has
undertaken considerable research and
The Ashok Chakra — the highest counselling, will be given further atten-
award for gallantry in peace time — was t , .
conferred on Pithawalla in 1982 when as L&T chair in organizational behavior at A regular participant at international
a second lieutenant he had successfully the Indian Institute of Management congresses on applied psychology,
headed a raid on a People ’s Liberation (IIM), Ahmedabad. This post he will ini- Pestonjee has presented more than 60 pa-
Army (PLA) hideout in Manipur. De- tially hold for a period of three years dur- pers in his field of specialization. His
spite a gunshot in the shoulder, ing which time “he plans to do more in- latest book is Stress Management — A
Pithawalla continued to lead the opera- tensive work on executive stress and Primer, due in ’92; prior to that he has
tion until the PLA chief was captured mental health, and the linkages between authored eight other books. He provides
alive and the recovery of arms, ammuni- organizational stress and work motiva- training and consultancy services to a
tion and equipment made possible. tion and satisfaction, ” as notes the IIM- number of national and international or-
Bangalore-born Pithawalla was at the
Air Force Central School in Delhi and May ’92.
later did his masters in commerce from
Association in different capacities and
was also the regional representative on
the division of organizational psychology
of the International Association of Ap-
tion following his appointment to the plied Psychology.
L&T chair in organizational behavior at A regular participant at international
(IIM), Ahinedabad. This post he will ini
tially hold for a period of three years dur
ing which time “he plans to do more in
tensive work on executive stress and
organizational stress and work motiva
tion and satisfaction, ” as notes the IIM-
Ahmedabad ’s publication Alumnus of ganizations like the World Health Organ
isation and has guided 16 PhD theses
with five more under way, the bio data
....... ....... 1- _________ " ' His present appointment at the IIM
the Delhi University having represented Pestonjee combines with several other further mentions.
6 Parsiana September 1992
I»
I
Excellence awards for two
For his rare contribution to equine breed
ing and for upgradation of the Indian
breeding industry Poona ’s Zavaray Soli
Poonawalla was conferred the
Rajiv Gandhi Excellence Award
’91 by the Shiromani Institute of
New Delhi. Outstanding accom
plishments in the field of finance
and management earned Adi
Bapuji Rabadi of Calcutta the same
award, informs a press release.
Thirty-six eminent personalities
chosen for this year ’s awards were
felicitated on August 20, 1992, the
birth anniversary of the late Prime
Minister Rajiv Gandhi. Union fi
nance minister Dr Manmohan
Singh recognized the efforts of
these dignitaries in promoting the
socio-economic advancement of
India and emphasized that human
resource development should be
given top priority to meet the chal
lenges of the next century.
Poonawalla, the managing di
rector of the Poonawalla Stud
Farms, is credited for his horses
winning 127 classics and five con
secutive Indian Derbies, a record
unsurpassed in India. He is also
the managing director of the Serum
Institute of India, the largest manu
facturer of quality biologicals in
the country, aiding the government
of India ’s immunization and family
health scheme, informs his curricu
lum vitae.
Rabadi, who is the vice chair
man and joint managing director of
M. N. Dastur and Company, spe
cializes in financial planning, man
agement and industrial cost ac
counting for which he has earned
distinctions like the Vijay Shree
Award and the Vijay Rattna, it is
reported.
rupees to promote advanced studies in Gulshan F. Sunavala (advanced study
universities overseas, according to the
press release.
Five-of the Zoroastrian girls opted for lege. New York) and Ms Zenobia F. Tar-
aporewala (PhD in cell and mo
lecular
Maryland, College
Among the the
choice was varied: Ms Dilshad Bil-
limoria (higher studies in flute,
B Royal College of Music, London),
Ms Dilshad J. Master (masters in
telecommunications/mass commu
nications management, Michigan
State University), Ms Firooza B.
Pavri (masters in geography. Uni
versity of Toledo, Ohio), Ms
Meher Dhondy Saran (masters in
business administration, American
Graduate School of International
Management) and Ms Dilnaz B.
Unwalla (masters in audiology and
speech therapy, Ohio State Univer
sity, Athens).
Of the four boys, three were go
ing to pursue a masters degree in
science and the fourth, a masters in
business*administration. Their cho-
sen fields of specialization are:
Hormuzd P. Commissariat (mas-
ters in electrical and electronic en-
gineering, Michigan State Univer-
sity), Mehemosh Engineer (mas- *
ters in metallurgy, Pennsylvania
State University), Adil F. Mistry
(masters in business administration ;
— finance and banking. University i
of Michigan, Ann Arbor) and <
Jamshid J. Tata (masters in com
puter science, Arizona State Uni
versity).
A brief on each of the students
was proferred by Malegamvala:
Billimoria ’s stay in London will
enable her to train as a professional
flautist. A self taught flautist, she
impressed a visiting British Coun
cil conductor who recommended
her to study at the Royal College of
Music. A gifted musician, she is ]
believed to have enormous poten
tial to enrich the quality of western
music in Bombay.
An engineering graduate in electron- !
ics from the Bombay University, Com- j
missariat is known for his creative and
_ „ innovative designs. When doing his
with serious, steady application and ton State University), Ms Kerman P. masters in electrical engineering he will
above all with a sense of responsibility, ” Dubash (masters in preventive veterinary specialize in communications, digital
he continued. In its centenary year, the medicine, Ohio State University), Ms signal processes and image processing.
J Endowment selected 120 Shireen C. Pavri (PhD in psychology. Plant physiology and plant molecular
1 Miami University, Ohio), Dr (Ms) biology are subjects which Deboo has
program in oral and maxillo facial sur
gery, New York University, Dental Col-
1
t*
14 select scholars
Of the 14 Parsis selected this year
as Tata scholars by the J. N. Tata
Endowment for the Higher Education of Poonawalla (top) and Rabadi (below)
Indians, 10 were women. “The future of receiving the Rajiv Gandhi Excellence
the community belongs to the girls, ” Awards from Dr Manmohan Singh
noted Dinshah Malegamvala, director of
the Endowment. “It is a joy to come
across such quality... intelligent, studious Deboo (PhD in biotechnology, Washing-
with serious, steady application and ton State University), Ms Kennan P.
science related subjects: Ms Gulshan B.
scholars and expended over 36.40 lakh
medicine, Ohio State University), Ms signal processes and image processing.
7 2 ’ 7 . • Plant physiology and plant molecular
8 Parsiana September 1992
I?
chosen for her doctoral studies. Her MSc
was in biotechnology with specialization
in plant tissue culture. She switched from
chemistry at the bachelors level (she had
stood first in the examination conducted
by the Pune University) to biotechnology
at the masters level. On completion of
her postgraduation she was training as a
junior research fellow at the National
Chemical Laboratory.
International management is what
Dhondy Saran plans to master in at the
American Graduate School of Interna
tional Management which is considered
the best' management school in the US
today. A Jamshedpur girl she had passed
the personnel management course at the
Xavier Labour Relations Institute with a
first class. She has subsequently gained
work experience at the Tata Engineering
and Locomotive Company Limited.
Assistant professor of veterinary sur
gery, Dubash chose to further qualify in
the USA. At the bachelors level she had
stood first in Maharashtra and subse
quently at the masters in veterinary sci
ence, she came first in surgery.
Engineer plans to do his masters and
doctoral studies in materials sciences
specializing in composite materials. Ear
lier he had completed his BTech from
the Indian Institute of Technology with
high grades in metallurgical engineering.
After her commerce graduation from
Bangalore University with a first rank in
taxation Master switched over to a post
graduation diploma specializing in video
and film production at the Sophia Poly
technic. She has worked as a production
crew member with a BBC (British
Broadcasting Corporation) team in Bom
bay and only recently completed a year
as assistant director with a television unit
making prime-time serials for the na
tional network.
Finance and banking is what Mistry
will specialize in while doing a masters
in business administration. A commerce
graduate from Sydenham College, Mis
try later did his masters in commerce and
completed the chartered accountants and
cost accountants examinations winning
innumerable prizes and scholarships.
While doing his articles with Price Wa
terhouse, he gained considerable experi
ence of banking in a multinational setup.
<¦
1992 Tata scholars (clockwise from top
left): Deboo, Dubash, Sunavala, Billi-
moria, F. Pavri, Unwalla, Engineer,
Tata, Mistry, Commissariat, Dhondy
Saran, Master, Taraporewala and S. Pavri
I
While pursuing a masters course in
geography, Firooza Pavri will specialize
in environmental analysis, planning and
computerized cartography. Even when
she had studied geography at the Bom
bay University and secured a first rank,
her specialization had been cartography.
Shireen Pavri has opted for a masters
in education and a certificate course in
school psychology. Earlier she had stood
first at the BA as also at the MA level in
special education.
Sunavala enjoys the distinction of be
ing a rank student in dental surgery at
both the bachelors and masters level
from the Bombay University. In addition
to her academic excellence which has
earned her several medals and scholar
ships, she is a keen athlete having parti
cipated in the javelin throw, shotTput,
heptathlon at the college, state and na
tional levels.
After completing her MSc from the
Bombay University, securing a first rank
in microbiology, Taraporewala has de
cided to do her doctorate in cell and mo
lecular biology. She was active in all
college extra-currieular activities, par
ticularly dramatics, and has also helped
in organizing seminars.
A masters in computer science with
specialization in software engineering,
artificial intelligence and computer
graphics is Tata ’s plan of study after
completing his bachelor of engineering
in computer science from the Bombay
University. Tata trained in software con
sultancy at the Tata Consultancy Ser
vices.
First Unwalla will do her masters de
gree in speech therapy. Thereafter she
will undertake her doctorate on hearing
disorders in children. Audiology and
speech therapy was also the subject in
which Unwalla completed her bachelors
from the Bombay University as a rank
student. Her work experience has been
at Jai Vakil ’s School where she served as
a speech therapist.
As a result of many students being of
fered financial assistance by the overseas
universities, “the award of Rs 36.40
lakhs of Tata scholarships has resulted in
the award of Rs 2.64 crores as financial
aid from American Universities to Tata
scholars, ” notes Malegamvala. “When
the US is in the grip of a recession and
university grants have been slashed, we
take this generous support to our students
to be a recognition of the quality of Tata
selections, ” he adds.
continued on page 25
*
9 Parsiana September 1992ZOROASTRIANS ABROAD
Zoroastrians prosper in Hongkong
Zoroastrian presence in the area predates
the establishment of Hongkong
Arnavaz S. Mama
“We may be among the richest anjumans 60-year-old structure in 1991 and its re- rest, the people are not out to change
in the world, ” says Jimmy Master of placement the association that began the system. No one would object to the j
Hongkong. Shoring up his statement The more than 147 years ago is gearing up for performance of rituals... The (r^ident)
Incorporated Trustees of the Zoroastrian a new life in the avant-garde British col- priest (Ervad Burjor Bhada, ex Deolali) |
Charity Funds of Hongkong, Canton and ony that is slated to return to China in
Macau (ITZCFHCM) will shortly be five years ’ time. And, in doing so, the
moving into their spanking new fully air- Zoroastrians are reverting to their older,
conditioned granite and glass building confident, venturesome ethos that pro
60-year-old structure in 1991 and its re-
more than 147 years ago is gearing up for performance of rituals... The (resident) j
J- - .
is under no pressures. The trustees never |
force him into doing anything not in ac- j
cord with his own beliefs. ’’ As an ex- ;
ample Master cites the mobed ’s refusal j
to set foot in a crematorium or aquiesce >
even to the ashes being buried in the 142- j
year-old cemetery. |
_______ Same day burial is the norm, notes |
The two schools of thought regarding Master. Holding the body for a second |
bers serve as pallbearers and the four-day
and subsequent prayers are said.
Three to four generations, of Parsi
families have made Hongkong their ,
home. Nonetheless ties with the host
a new life in the avant-garde British col
ony that is slated to return to China in
five years ’ time. And, in doing so, the
Zoroastrians are reverting to their older.
moving into their spanking new fully air-
whose total construction cost (exclusive pelled them into the region in the first
of interior decor) is currently estimated
at HK $ 32.43 million (approximately Rs
126.4 million).
The association will occupy four
floors of the 22-storeyed Zoroastrian
Building which has replaced the original Master; “The future may improve dra-
two-storeyed structure in a little more ’’
than a year, according to the memo cir
culated by association president Jal
Shroff to community members. This will
account for a social hall and kitchen, bar,
children ’s room, ladies ’ room, prayer
hall, library cum meeting room, priest
and staff quarters. There is no provision
for a guest house or dhararnshala.
The rest of the area, amounting to
over 33,000 square feet, will be leased
out on commercial terms with shops and
showrooms at street level. With the
occupation permit expected by end
November, the official opening of the
building will be on March 21, 1993 but kong, Taiwan, Canton and Macau (con-
Shroff hopes to move in earlier.
project has been financed by mort
gaging the association ’s land to the
Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Cor
poration (HSBC). The 12-year term loan
is expected to be repaid from the pro
ceeds of the rental income, according to
Master.
With a prominent corner position be
tween 1
Road, the Zoroastrian Building stands
cheek by jowl with a variety of high-
class commercial buildings, banks and
hotels in downtown Hongkong. It will be
professionally managed by Wayloong ing, ’’ he adds matter-of-factly. ,
Property Limited, a wholly owned sub- 3 *
sidiary of the HSBC, providing 24-hour Zoroastrians could be regarded as more
management service to the occupants. orthodox, more likely to wear the sudreh
With the demolition of the original kusti and pray daily, says Master. For the
place, even before Hongkong was estab
lished in the 1840s, as notes the histori
cal outline in the anjuman ’s directory.
The two schools of thought regarding Master. Holding the body for a second j
the future of Hongkong are delineated by day is exceptional. Community mem- i
. « , . 1 . 1- , z-1 f-V* £» ¦fzxi lt»_. 017 T
matically. If Hongkong flourishes, pro
perty prices will appreciate, resulting in a
healthy income for the trust funds. The
negative scenario is that the fall in the
asset value of land will continue until it
reaches zero by 1997 and the anjuman
must earn before that date. ” Master, who
does not subscribe cither to the dooms
day theory nor to its total-success
0 VZ V»* • W* — - — ---- Qy— - ~ 1
to lie somewhere in between. “It is likely secondary schooling in Hongkong before
that by the time China assumes sover
eignty it will have become so involved in
Hongkong that Hongkong ’s success will
depend on China ’s management... Hong-
}
family in India remain fairly strong, says f
Master and many have bought properties
Tn/Un rAfirpmpnf nlan nr r .
in India as part of their retirement plan or f
as a second home.
The general pattern in recent years |
counterpart, expects the emerging reality was for the children to complet^ their .
proceeding to the US, Canada or the UK I
for further education, with the majority I
opting for the UK and the cream of the
community migrating to North America.
With the establishment of several new
I
%
s
The stitute) a separate region in terms of institutions of higher learning in Hong
prosperity and a population bloc of 80 kong, that compulsion may now cease to
Hamilton and completed his masters
from London University. The older gen
erations by contrast had no such intellec-
million. These people have experienced apply, feels Master who graduated from
the most rapid development, success and " ’ ’ -
prosperity. They will not be agreeable to
giving it up, ” says Master, a businessman
whose export-import trade in textiles and tual exposure. They had hardly ever
garments, like that of other fellow even completed their schooling before
Zoroastrians, is said to be substantially being thrust into the family business^ In
Leighton Road and Hoi Ping based on sourcing in India for export to
¦ ¦¦ •• • other countries. But Hongkong Zoroastri
ans are too small a community “to make
any difference to anybody. We (have to) Parsi houses enjoyed years ago,
keen our heads down and get on with liv- admits.
Today there are 181 Parsis in Hong-
other cases their career was interrupted
by World War II. Conversely, “no Parsi
trading house today enjoys the status that
- • ¦------ ................. » he
keep our heads down and get on with liv-
The older generation of Hongkong kong as per the 1991-92 directory, with
50 families and 27 individuals. Accord
ing to Master many are on short or me
dium term postings and there may be
orthodox, more likely to wear the sudreh
10 Parsiana September 1992
Lrecognized by the the old guard of the 1950s to the late
1970s had aged and required to step
down. The social events include a
weekly dinner and cards on Friday in ad
dition to 14 specific events in 1992 listed
in the directory.
“Adventuresome Parsis... ‘went East ’
several more “who choose not to make updated and
their presence known. ”
An occasional navjote or wedding is
held in Hongkong, an additional priest ductible.
being flown in from Bombay. But the
general tendency is to hold the function pered, it rented its first property for com
in India. munity use in 1857 and went on to pur-
Describing his Hongkong brethren as chase its first house at Elgin Street four for fame and fortune between the two
“an insular community, ” Master explains years later. This property was later sold World Wars. Wherever P&O mail/pas-
that there is a great deal of intracommu- and a plot acquired on Leighton Road on
nity contact but little contact on the which the trust ’s first one-storeyed build
intercommunity level. “Our primary con
cern is with India — communities else- storey being added in 1970. During the Shanghai, Kobe, Yokohama... World
where have no locus standi. If an appeal
(for funds) comes from India, it is con
sidered. If it comes from other places,
Hongkong government as a charity orga
nization, donations to which are tax de
As the mercantile community pros-
senger ships stopped there were Parsi
families: Bombay, Colombo, Rangoon,
ing was constructed in 1931, a second Penang, Singapore, Hongkong, Canton,
it’s just not considered! (There is a
War II packed most of their return to In
dia. And from the 1950s the Parsi going
abroad was a different breed — well edu
cated and far better suited to life in the
West. Yet today the economic growth of
the world is in the Far East, ” is how Ma-
nek Daver of Japan sums up the Zoroas
trian presence in the area. The only flaw
in Daver ’s assessment of Zoroastrian set
tlements in the great cities washed by the
China Sea is the timing — they went
much before World War I to help in the
building of Hongkong. Names such as
Mody Street and Kotewall Street attest to
the contribution of ’the Parsi community
to the wealth of Hongkong, writes Jon
athan Braude in the South China Morn
ing Post of October 27, 1991. Jamsetji
Jejeebhoy “traded in Guangzhou before
the foundation of Hongkong. He became
a partner of Jardine Matheson and Com
pany (his portrait by Chinnery can still
be seen at the corporate headquarters on
the 48th floor of Jardine House) and a di
rector of the Hongkong and Shanghai
Bank, ” informs Kevin Sinclair in an ear
lier article in the same paper and repro
duced in Hamazor, the newsbulletin of
Only recently the trust fund appointed the World Zoroastrian Organisation. Re-
its first lady trustee — Ms Ruby Master, counting highlights of Parsi achieve-
The proposal had been stymied on three
strong belief that) Indian Zoroastrians
need preferential treatment and support...
Up to two or three years ago everything,
the minutes, proceedings o£ meetings, etc
of the association were written in
Gujarati and read out in Gujarati at the
annual general meeting, ” he adds, attest
ing to the conservatism of Hongkong
Parsis.
However, “religious issues have never
been of burning importance, ” says Mas
ter. “When Khojeste Mistree (founder of
Zoroastrian Studies) came a year or two
ago, he had a massive response. People
sat with him till midnight. When people
come, they are well received but there is
no active encouragement on a regular
basis. ”
The Hongkong directory traces the Master: “not out to change the system”
history of the anjuman to 1822 when a
piece of land was obtained in Macau for
the establishment of a Parsi cemetery.
Though records indicate that the China functioning from rented premises
Canton Anjuman was established in 1834 Causeway Hill.
it was only in 1845 that the Zoroastrians
of the region “met in Canton to create a
proper anjuman body for the mainte
nance of the burial grounds, a place of occasions before the change was incor-
association and for rendering assistance porated in the trust deed, says Jimmy
to the needy, ” informs the directory.
Cemeteries were also established in
Hongkong (1845), Whampoa (1847) and Shroff who is president, secretary Viraf scientious and outspoken Legco member
Shanghai (1854). Parekh who publishes the directory, Keki in the 1960s.
The trust deed of the anjuman dates to Jokhi, Homi Italia and Ms Master) may “The Ruttonjees, closely allied with
1874. Thereafter there were two major be elected to unlimited five year terms, the House of Jardine over the decades,
revisions. The first in 1920 was effected ...........
by Justice Dinshaw Daver of the Bombay I can ’t recall a single contested election. ”
High Court in response to certain dis
putes and differences, according to the
directory write-up. Then in 1989, to ac- which is proposed, seconded and carried “The first steam ferries that plodded
commodate the increasing size and com- in the belief that a contested election is over the harbor in 1888 were operated by
plexity of the trust funds as also the likely to lead to bad blood. In the upshot Dorabji Nowroji.
“Probably the most famous Parsi busi
nessman was Hormusji Mody, opium
auctioneer and land developer. He is re-
Photo: Varghese Fernandez
current rebuilding activity the anjuman is
on
Master.
The trust ’s five trustees (currently
ments in the colony Sinclair elaborates,
“Heerjibhoy Ruttonjee -was the first of
that noted clan who came to Hongkong
in 1843. One of his descendants was the
much respected Dhun Ruttonjee, a con-
Parekh who publishes the directory, Keki
Jokhi, Homi Italia and Ms Master) may
be elected to unlimited five year terms.
But Jimmy Master says, “In my lifetime built the sanatorium named after them
and funded a lot of medical care for tu
berculosis victims in the era when it was
In practice the procedure is one of inter
nal selection of the incumbent trustee still a major and dreaded killer,
which is proposed, seconded and carried
in the belief that a contested election is
planned redevelopment of its Zoroastrian the inflow of new individuals among
Building property, the trust was in- trustees is sa'id to be very rare. It was said
corporated and its rules and regulations -that the 1980s saw changes only because
11 Parsiana September 1992
¦0
membered by Mody Road in Tsim Sha
Tsui but he was also active with his Ar
menian partner Paul Chater in develop
ing the praya along the central water
front, the engineering work that gave
Hongkong at the turn of the century its
own character. Mody donated $ 300,000
to found the University of Hongkong, a
stupendous sum in those days and the gift
earned him a knighthood. His generosity
also helped him construct the Kowloon
Cricket Club on Cox ’s Road, an area
where many Parsis and wealthy Indians
then lived. ”
Naorojee Burjorjee Futakia seems to
be a typical example of the tum-of-the-
century Parsi, going to Hongkong in
1900 at the age of eight. “A tough-
minded optimist with implicit faith in
Ahura Mazda, ” he withstood the losses
of war, communist insurgence and
domestic tribulations with equal forti
tude, holding it as his philosophy that “a
man never fails until he gives up trying, ”
as notes an obituary of the one-time
trustee published in the anjuman ’s news
letter when he died in 1980.
As Shroff told Sinclair, “We ’ve been
in Hongkong a long time. We ’ll be
around for a lot longer yet. ”
VOUNG €NGIN€€RS
You are needed by an expanding
Company, presently a market
leader In Hydraulic and CMC Metal
Forming Machines (exporting also)
and diversifying Into two large
projects with a tenfold turnover In
4 years.
MATRIMONIAL
If you are a young, talented
engineer ready to work with top
management and want challenge
and growth for your dedication and
hard work, you are the right person.
Correspondence invited
from sophisticated,
well-groomed
and well-educated
Zoroastrian men up to
55 years for
a 49-year-old research
psychologist, temporarily
posted in Switzerland.
An attractive remuneration and
friendly atmosphere will be an
added benefits.
Please apply with details and
photograph (returnable) to:
Write to:
The Managing Director,
Himalaya
Machinery Pvt. Ltd.
HIMALAYA 608, G.I.D.C. Makarpura,
BARODA (GUJARAT) 390010.
The Advertiser
Parsiana
Matrimonial (Sept/35-92)
GPO Box 892
Bombay 400001
* !
J
For Pure Diamonds
JEWELLERS
324, Grant Road, Bombay 400007. Telephone 3073483 Fax 3099648
APPOINTED VALUERS BY THE GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
12 Parsiana September 1992POLITICS AND POLICY
The 1992 BPP Elections
Parties and Pacts
The lead that the ZCWA initially enjoyed is being
challenged by the other parties
Gustasp Irani
As the Bombay Parsi Punchayet Anju- formed an electoral alliance since the
man Committee elections eventually get
under way, a total of 1,632 candidates ___ ____
out of 4,812 registered voters have their Each party withdrew some of their nomi
nations to prevent a splitting of votes.
This compromise accounts for a large
share of the 122 nominations that were
withdrawn before the cutoff date, No
vember 15,1992.
In constituencies where the combined sounded out Patrawala ’s group on the
strength of the CER and JC is less than possibility of a^ mutual understanding,
the number of seats at stake, the CER but the offer was spumed. The Patrawala
will be supporting independents as well '
as select persons from the ZCWA slate.
“The CER is not a party in the strict
combined strength of the two groups ex
ceeded the number of seats at stake.
candidates. ”
And talking of trustees, will Marazban
Patrawala, member of the Maharashtra
Legislative Assembly be in the fray? Re
ports from a number of sources indicate
that a group owing allegiance to him will
be contesting the Anjuman Committee
elections from the Colaba constituency.
Initially, the CER is believed to have
1
hat in the ring. With 802 seats at stake,
about every other candidate will win.
Of the total, 684 are Zoroastrian Cul
tural Welfare Association (ZCWA) can
didates. According to Dr Syrus Irani,
president of ZCWA, 19 of his party can
didates over four constituencies with
drew their nominations after being, what
he describes as “unfairly ” influenced by
members of other parties. In particular,
it is the Committee for Economic Re
vival (CER-formerly Committee for sense of the word. We support all indi
viduals who we believe are independent-
minded and have the best interest of the
Parsi community at heart, ” Dinshaw
Mehta, a key member of the CER, ex
plains their strategy.
Commenting on the CER’s alliance
with the JC, Mehta observes: “Our December 5, r992. The schedule and the
_ _ „ venue of the different polling centers
group later reconsidered the offer, only
to find that the CER had already reached
an understanding with the JC. As a result
the Colaba constituency has the highest
proportion, 2.52 candidates for every
seat available. At the other end of the
scale, the Worli constituency has the
lowest proportion, 1.76 candidates per
seat.
The casting of votes will commence
Electoral Rights) that he holds respon
sible for a shift in loyalties among 18 of
his members in the Byculla constituency
who switched sides to join the CER-
endorsed Kersi Limathwalla group.
In the Dadar constituency, the Adi
Doctor orthodox slate of 81 candidates
has the endorsement of both the ZCWA understanding is for the Anjuman Com- venue of the different polling centers
mittee elections only. For the trusteeship have been announced; December 5 —
elections, each one will support its own
and the Jashan Committee (JC). The
other Dadar group of independent candi-
dates, put together by
Ms Pervina Doctor and
Ms Silla Motivala among
others, is being endorsed
by the CER. The CER
will also support the can
didates of the Petrasp
Patel group in the Khar-
eghat Colony constitu
ency.
Certain other constitu
encies have witnessed the
emergence of strange bed-
fellowji with the CER-and
the JC reaching an under
standing to support each
other ’s candidates. In the
Colaba and Fort constitu
encies, these two groups
13 Parsiana September 1992
*
Electoral distribution of constituencies
Constituency
Colaba
Fort
Kalbadevi
Malabar Hill
Worli
Parel
Dadar
Borivli, Goregaon
and Jogeshwari
Bandra and Mahim
Tardeo and Hughes Road J
Grant Road K
Denoted
by
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
Allocated
seats
74
90
79
71
84
49
81
72
I 69
79
54
Head Office Building, 209 Dr D. N.
Contesting
candidates
187
181
156
145
148
95
190
147
138
149
96
Road, Fort; December
6 —_Khareghat Memo
rial Hall, Khareghat
Colony; December 12
— Palamkote Hall,
Dadar Parsi Colony;
December 13 — Rec
reation Centre, Bharu-
cha Baug, Andheri
(W); December 19 —
Play Centre, Nowroz
Baug, Lalbaug; De
cember 20 — Head of
fice Building, Fort.
Voting can be done on
any of the six days at
any center irrespective
of the constituency one
is affiliated to.POLITICS AND POLICY
COVER STORY
A matter of trust
Gustasp Irani
Dr Syrus Irani believes he would be better able to
empathize with the community’s problems than any
of the affluent trustees of the Punchayet
BPP treated her. -What I saw at the face. Charity housing, he points out, is
Doongerwadi, and not just in my
To understand 43-year-old Dr Syrus D.
Irani, the eighth of 11 children, is to real
ize that he still lives under the shadow of mother ’s case, made me realize how
his father Darvish Irani, the poor migrant poor Parsis lived and how little the trus-
Irani Zoroastrian who served as the cus- tees (of the BPP) understood then prob-
todian of Bombay ’s Towers of Silence lems, ” says Irani. Little did they under-
for 45 years up to the time of his death in , ,4
1980. To Irani, the simple lifestyle of his ''
father is a touchstone, a constant point of J
reference that keeps creeping into the in- I
tCTview. It is almost as though Darvish |
Irani is still sitting in the pavilion outside |
the lower bunglis, a brightly colored |
Irani hanky tied around his head, worry- |
ing his string of beads and watching his |
son who aspires to be elected to the I
board of trustees of the Bombay Parsi |
Punchayet (BPP) — the same body he I
had served with unfailing dedication and I
devotion. I
Not surprisingly Irani informs us that I
the idea of becoming a BPP trustee first |
germinated in events that took place in
the household of Darvish at the Doonger
wadi in 1988. In April that year, Irani ’s
widowed mother, Goolbanu, who took
on her husband ’s job and responsibilities Irani: "I shall carry on my fight"
after his death, received a letter from the
BPP office that as she had reached the
age of superannuation she was being re
tired from her duties the following month community: for decent affordable hous-
and should surrender the accommodation i
which went with the job. Irani immedi- tional institutions, for proper religious For starters Irani obtained the mem-
ately moved the courts for a stay order guidance and even to have a good meal bership list of the new general register of
against her eviction and through the legal once in a while. “Why are they not using the BPP and started breaking down the
system worked out an understanding that all those ghambar funds they manage? I alphabetic listing of 19,000 plus names
his mother would stay on at the Doonger- know how I looked forward to eating at a according to localities. “I would work
late into the night writing down names
and addresses by hand, ” he recalls. The
job done, his band of volunteers started
fanning out in the city appealing to Parsis
to collect their registration certificates
under the new election scheme of the
BPP and even offering to do so on their
behalf. Often the reward for their efforts
was a front door slammed in their face.
¦f?
Photo: Gustasp Irani
stand the real needs of the poor of the
ing, for reservations in jobs and educa
tional institutions, for proper religious
for the poor but the rents the BPP is ask
ing excludes them: “How do they expect
poor Parsis to pay over Rs 1,000 per
month? ” On the issue of reservation
quotas he observes: “They can afford to
say that the community does not need
any special benefits because they have
comfortable jobs and do not have to
struggle for a living, like most others. ”
In religious matters, he believes that their
views, which milfy be commended by
their peers, are not necessarily shared by
the rest of the community. The time has
come, Irani feels, for a complete over
haul of the board of trustees. The new
trustees, he hopes, will reflect and under
stand the fears and aspirations of the
community.
The chance of effecting such a change
presented itself when the new scheme for
election of the Anjuman Committee
(AC) and trustees of the BPP filtered
through the legal system in December
1991 after a protracted period of wran
gling and delays. In February 1992 Irani
called a meeting of the Zoroastrian Cul
tural Welfare Association (ZCWA), a
cultural and charitable organization of
which he is the founder president, and
under its banner set out on the election
campaign trail.
I**'
his mother would stay on at the Doonger- 1 .......................
wadi till alternative accommodation was ghambar as a small boy. I can still recall
provided to her at Godrej Baug. She how much I loved the dal they served at
however died before she could move and a ghambar held at Alibag. ”
according to Irani she lived the last two ~
years of her life in constant dread, for her
son had dared to challenge the might of Irani, is that they have all come from the
the BPP.
“This lady had worked for 50 years in
a thankless job and this was the way the hardships their poorer brethren have to
The root of the problem with the cur
rent lot of BPP trustees, according to
affluent segment of the community and
are not in touch with the realities and
15 Parsiana September 1992»
)
“The BPP has done a lot for housing
in the past 10 years, ” Irani concedes, but
adds; “However, the system of allotment
is not just. It is not the poor and the real
needy Parsis who have benefitted. ” He
then the election of the AC from October points out that the merit rating system
“Parsis are fed up with the Punchayet CER and the BPP but according to Irani,
and its trustees. They just don ’t want to
get involved, ” says Irani pointing out
that only about 5,000 bothered to get
their new certificates by the middle of nations was shifted to September 17,
October.
To compound their problem they had to December and that of the two trustee has been manipulated. “For some there
to convince 802 Parsis, from 11 constitu- ’ “ '
encies spread across the city, to stand for
the AC elections on the ZCWA slate.
Since the Fort constituency was proving
to be a particularly difficult one, Irani
and three other volunteers sei
aside two Sundays in May to
comb the area for candidates.
From 9 in the morning to 8 in
the evening, they went from
house to house with their appeal
and persuaded 96 Parsis to fill in
nomination forms. “We were
able to do this because of my
father. When people heard I was
Darvish Irani ’s son they would
invite me into their house, ” Irani
recalls. As a result of systematic
campaigning, Irani claims that
the ZCWA was the only party or
group which had a slate of 802 'I'ndiilftLi' ¦ , ?
candidates ready by end May 1992 — The bereft family mourns the death of
the original cut-off point for filing of Darvish Irani Photo Rashid Bamanbehram
nominations (this included a group of
81 candidates from Dadar led by Adi
Doctor which the ZCWA proposed to
support).
Subsequently, the elections were post
poned and September 1, 1992 was set as
the last day for filing of nominations. In
the weeks that followed the BPP issued a
series of notices in the Press intimating
the latest development on the election
front. Irani monitored and responded to
each twist, and as the new deadline ap
proached, his ZCWA was the only group
once again that was fully prepared. Of
the 1,133 nominations filed, 802 be
longed to ZCWA, according to Irani.
The election campaign, however, had be
come an entirely new ball game.
The Committee for Economic Re
forms (CER — formerly Committee for all filed separate pleas for postponement.
Electoral Rights) which had swept the
earlier election, moved the courts in an
attempt to get an extension of the nomi-
it fell upon the ZCWA rather than the
BPP to counter every move.
Initially the last date for filing nomi-
I
posts from December 1992 to February are 10 rules why they cannot be given a
1993. The ZCWA challenged the post
ponements and got them rescheduled to
their original dates. Only now the elec
tion of the AC was slated for the last two point. He argues that under the current
H system, a person allotted a flat
¦ might be a deserving case but the
¦ moot point is that often a more
m deserving one has been denied
™ accommodation.
To remedy the situation he be-
lieves that the trustees them-
J selves should verify each case
, personally rather than send repre
sentatives of the BPP to do the
job. “But our present lot of trust-
(• ees are so busy with their own ca-
h- reers, where do they have the
time to do something like that?
Many of them do not even have
time to attend board meetings
regularly. ” Trustees elected on the
ZCWA platform will, according to Irani,
make a commitment to check out each
days of October instead of the beginning application personally and further should
of the month. The CER protested once they find that they do not have the tintg,
more. The scheme allowed nominations
to be filed up to 30 days before the date
of the election. They got the last date for personal capacity, he states that should
filing nominations fixed at September he become a trustee he will resign from
30. Since the BPP notice to this effect
was issued after this date the CER filed
for further postponement of the entire
election schedule. On Friday October 23,
the day before the courts went on a two-
week Diwali recess, they won their case.
Once more the AC elections were shifted
to December and the trusteeship elec
tions to February 1993. “The three CER
trustees,
Guzder and Minoo Shroff, and two CER around BPP,” a suggestion was made
members. Fall Poncha and Noshir Mehta
flat and for others there are no rules, ”
says Irani. He points out a number of
out-of-turn allotments to illustrate his
I
to attend board meetings, they will vol
untarily resign from their posts. In his
the Jain Mahila Samaj charitable trust
where he is the honorary medical practi
tioner and devote the two hours between
2 and 4 p.m. he sits at their clinic every
day to trust matters. And more, he will
sit in the BPP office on Saturdays and
Sundays, if the need arises.
Criticisms also came the way of the
BPP Skiff. In ‘-leaflets reportedly distri-
Jamshced Kanga, Jamshed buted by Irani ’s “well-wishers in and
that “All superannuated staff in BPP
must resign. These jobs must be given to
This alone shows that these three trustees our knowledgeable youths for the growth
had put their own personal interest above of our community. ”
the interest of the community and fair
nation deadline on technical grounds, play, ” says Irani. But he is not deterred.
Irani saw it as a blatant bid to gain lime
as the CER had managed to scrape to
gether only about 250 candidates at that
lime. “Instead of fighting the election
over issues that concern the community,
the CER was squabbling over dales in
the courts, ” says Irani who likened what
followed to a “legal tug-of-war. ” Tech
nically, the legal battle was between the and religious mailers.
“God is on the side of the just and I shall
carry on my fight for the poor of the
community, ” he declares.
Irani believes that there are three ar-
ca.s the trustees of the BPP should give
special attention and priority to — hous
ing of poor Parsis, reservation quotas for
Parsis in jobs and educational institutions
Irani ’s ‘glass house ’ which his critics
keep reminding him about is that mem
bers of his family, himself included, have
been allotted five BPP tenements over
the years. “But, of course, and I’m not
denying that. Punchayet housing is
meant for poor families like mine, ” he
retorts. He informs us that his father had
11 children and after 45 years of serving
the BPP he was earning a “handsome ”
continued on page 24
16 Parsiana September T992t
POLITICS AND POLICY
COVER STORY
Leading the court campaign
Gustasp Irani
CER’s repeated trips to the court seeking
extensions and clarifications has fortified its position
in the 1992 Anjuman Committee elections
The 1992 Anjuman Committee (AC) in 1981; but we were certainly not
elections of the Bombay Parsi Punchayet asleep. ”
(BPP) will probably be remembered as
the first one held under the new scheme.
It may also be an election more hotly as “a bit absurd ” that about 4,000 Parsis
contested in the courts of law than at the
hustings. The main legal contention ap
pears to have been a question of when
the elections should be held rather than
reference to the issues that concerned the
Parsis. In the ensuing legal tug-of-w'ar
the Committee for Economic Revival
(CER, formerly the Committee for Elec
toral Rights) which controlled the outgo
ing AC, emerged triumphant when the
courts allowed for a postponement of the
schedule.
This victory was crucial for, as one
active CER member observed: “We
would have lost the elections even before
the first vote was cast. ” The dilemma
the party faced was that as the original
September 1 deadline for filing nomina
tions approached, it found that it was
able to scrape up only around 250 candi
dates to contest the 802 seats at stake.
One of the main persons guiding the
fortunes of the CER through the legal
maze was reputed lawyer Rusi Sethna of
Manekshah and Sethna, a well-known
law firm in Bombay.
Sethna clarifies the position of the
party thus: “As I look at CER, its pri
mary objective was fulfilled when it
brought about an awareness in the com
munity as regards its electoral rights way
back in the 1981 elections. Apart from
that, its other aim was that the AC should
elect trustees (of the BPP) regardless of them again when the deed was done,
the party they belong to. We never
looked at ourselves as a party in a formal thing like that when you are dealing with
sense.' However, when it came to the
election of the present AC I am inclined
to agree that we were not as organized as
Looking at both sides of the coin of
the new election scheme, Sethna sees it
F'
17 Parsiand September 1992
Sethna: ensure effective representation
Photo: Gustasp Irani
the CER though it was undoubtedly a
product of its efforts. Personally, he
would have preferred a more compact
electoral college of an equal number of
members elected from the General Reg
ister and the Donor Register. Such a
scheme, he points out, was in the offing
till some of the donors objected.
Returning to the existing scheme,
Sethna points out that it has a number of
built-in flaws that needed to be, ironed
out and it was for this reason the CER
had to appeal to the courts of law. “The
system needed to be rationalized. First,
there was the issue of demarcation of
constituencies and second, the problem
of adhering to the scheme ’s timetable, ”
says Sethna.
Referring to the first problem of con
stituency demarcation, he observes: “The
idea of having constituencies is that a
voter knows the person he or she is vot
ing for. Its main purpose is to ensure ef
fective representation of the community.
But all that is lost under the present cir
cumstances. ” For one, he points out that
over the last decade there has been a ma
jor shift in the Parsi population from the
will be voting for 802 seats (he does not city center to the suburbs and even other
believe that all the 5,000 plus who have
collected their new General Register cer
tificates will vote). On the positive side,
the sheer size of the AC will make it al
most impossible to dictate to it. Sethna
refers to instances in the past when the
certificates of AC members were held by
certain individuals who issued them to
members who came to vote and collected
Ik
parts of the world. Furthermore, the de
marcation of the 11 constituencies has
been, at best, arbitrary. “You cannot do
that sitting in an office drawing lines on
the map of the city on the basis of rec
ords that arc over 10 years old. Even if it
means spending money, I believe you
have to go from door to door updating
your records, ” says Sethna. A fallout of
such an exercise would be a better under-
“It’s extremely difficult to pull some- standing of the real problems facing the
community, and also a knowledge of the
true strengths of the community.
That aside, such an effort would in
volve time, which leads invariably to the
802 people, ” Sethna observes.
He, however, clarifies that the new
election scheme was not the creation ofI
other problem Sethna identified in the
current election scheme — adherence to
schedules set by the courts which re
0
1
I
was born with a silver spoon in his her at the time, the flat should automai
mouth; they did not come from very rich cally revert to the BPP to be allotted j
" •--------- ------------ ------------------------- '•'2 “Of coursd
speak for myself and not on behalf of u
CER,” Sethna clarifies his position.
One area the trustees should stei
tions. “If we can get a minority status clear of is religion. “I am of the vie
with dignity I see no problem in accept-
- ¦ ¦ ¦ - families. They all have made the grade another deserving Parsi.
quired the process to be completed through their own efforts, ” he protests,
within a specified period. In effect, ac- ’
cording to Sethna, what the CER was
seeking through its legal action was a
guarantee that there would be fair and ef
fective representation of the community
on the AC (the prime objective of any
election process), thus defeating the de
signs of any single group taking undue
advantage of the flaws in the system.
Commenting on the office of trustee
ship of the BPP, Sethna believes that it
should be devalued. “Don ’t treat them as
gods; view them as servants, ” he advises
all concerned. According to him, to be a
good BPP trustee a person must possess
three qualities: “One, vision and by vi
sion I mean that he should be able to see
far ahead into the future. Two, the abil
ity to take a decision, right or wrong.
And three, boldness and persistence to
implement that decision. ”
Sethna refutes the allegation that the
present trustees of the BPP are insensi
tive to the needs of the average Parsi be
cause they hail from the more affluent
This leads to the question of reservations
for Parsis in jobs and educational institu-
“We were not as
organized as
in 1981: but
we were certainly
not asleep”
that they should not dabble in religio
These matters should be left to religio
scholars, ” says Sethna. And by religio
scholars he refers not only to the pries
but all recognized authorities on Zoros
trianism, Parsi and non-Parsi, from Inc
and all over the world.
Finally, Sethna addresses the specu
tion about his standing for election to I
board of trustees of the BPP. “I do i
believe in taking on something I knov
won ’t be able to do, ” he states, referri
to his flourishing law practice and otl
responsibilities like his position as mi
aging trustee of the R. D. Sethna Tr
ing it. But we should definitely refuse to
grovel for it,” says Sethna. _ _
Other concessions the BPP should which make it difficult for him to
seek, according to Sethna, are from the aside the time he believes such a co
Rent Act and those tax exemptions mitment would involve. “If and whe
which are not available to our commu
nity trusts on the grounds that Parsis are
a micro community. The specific Rent
Act exemption Sethna refers to is that
segment of the community. “Except for when a Parsi residing in a BPP flat dies
possibly one trustee none of the others L-1 ' J **’ '
and has no relatives living with him or
do ease off on my other activities I \
give it consideration, ” he adds. But,
course, he points out, there is one asp
that might prove to be a problem wl
and if such a time comes. “My pipe, ”
says from behind a cloiid of smoke.
4
Vi
Best Wishes From
RUSY & PURVIZ SHROFF9
ART
JUSSAWALLA'S
model
commitment
¦
Gustasp Irani
r
. J
if
ri J’l
B
iiO
HilBL'
’jss^
By his painstaking
creations Burjor
Jussawalla
is rediscovering
the dignity of
labor of an older
generation of
Parsi craftsmen
20 Parsiana September 1992
On seeing splintered glass — the telltale sleep I am always thinking about my
sign of a road accident — most people work, ” he says. He seeks ideas for new
‘tut-tut ’ sympathetically and drive models or how to refine small details —
on. Not one Bombay Parsi a cross or maybe the afargan — in the
k though. He stops to examine the existing ones. “I don ’t stop. I continu-
I mess and without attracting too
B much attention to himself collects
’ fistfuls of the glass splinters in a
hanky before moving on.
Back home he sorts out his booty:
weeding out the slivers with sharp order,
edges, he matches the rest for a close
fit, piecing them together into a coni-
Not one Bombay Parsi
ously keep improving on.what I am do
ing. No two pieces are the same, espe
cially since everything is handmade. ”
He adds that he has very little ready
stock of the models and most are mad«^
According to Jussawalla, the afargans
with agiary clock towers are his bestsell-
cal dome which will house the flame of ers and can be found in Parsi households
his model afargan (holy fire container).
Around this afargan he constructs a
model of the sanctum of a fire-temple,
adding details like prayer books, bells
and a tray with a pair of tongs, sandal
wood sticks and a chumuch (long buy in bulk —10 pieces at a time — tc
handled, flat spoon). In the upper section
of this miniature agiary is embedded a
quartz clock. Meet Burjor Jussawalla,
in the US, UK, Canada, Australia, Hong
Kong, Germany and Sri Lanka. Nearei
home they are found in Goa, Mahablesh-
war, and of course Bombay and Pune
He has a list to prove his point. Many
distribute as presents. The Hindu temples
are particular, favorites as gift items, h<
adds. “The Parsi community may be verj
wood sculptor and model craftsman of small but their business acumen is good
remarkable ingenuity. If you do something good and different
But Jussawalla has more than afargans they are the first to encourage you, ” says
and clock tower agiaries to offer. He fab
ricates miniature temples and churches
with nightlamps and timepieces built into
the structures. '------ — * ---------------
items like model pendulum clocks and received though at one he had to b<
calendars with company logos. The content with comments like, “how
sweet, ” and “how charming, ” rather that
sales.
Of course, these “sweet ” and “charm
ing ” displays, Jussawalla explains, an
the end result of a lot of sweat and bone
If you do something good and different
Jussawalla whose work was on display
at stalls in five exhibitions in Bombaj
city and its suburbs. In most of thes<
There are conventional exhibitions his models were wel
The
unconventional pieces include
calendars with company logos.
more
handcarts and skulls fitted with clocks,
and owls with eyes that glow bright red
at night. “I can make almost anything. I
am always looking for new ideas of what
to make, ” says Jussawalia. The idea of aching toil. He works in his sudreh ani
the skull cloQk, for instance, sprang from
the pages of a magazine. “When going to
kusti at his Bharucha Baug flat will
simple and improvised tools. He showus his hammer which combines an ice
pick and bottle opener, and his set of
chisels made by filing down the ends of
broken saw pieces. Only the quartz clock
with dial and hands he buys from out
side, the rest he fabricates himself. He
uses only teak wood and though the work
he does may be delicate, he assures us
that it is physically taxing. The steeples,
the crosses, the pillars, the doors, all are
1.
.si
k
}•
¦T
I
Ingeniously designed clock tower agiary
finely carved and demanding. “Do you
know how many operations go into this
model? ” Jussawalla asks as he fondly
cradles the clock tower that houses an
afargan. No, he does not know himself,
but assures us that it is far more than one
would imagine.
“Carving is a gift God has given me, ’
says Jussawalla. Nevertheless it took
him over 50 years to tap the full potential
of this craft; and he was compelled to
¦
IL.
¦
¦
i
y /
'm
>9
o
Jussawalla: "I can make almost
anything”
(
pursue it because of the circumstances he
found himself in. “I was jobless. I might
I look young but once potential employers
learnt my age (I am 55 today), they
would say ‘sorry. ’” So in 1990 he took
courage in his hands — also hammer,
chisel and improvised tools — and con
verted what was an indulgence and a
hobby into a full-time commitment.
With every new piece he made he re
built his own self-esteem and redis
covered the dignity of labor his Parsi
forefathers had valued. Most of the Parsi
youths today, he laments, look down on
working with their hands in general, and its superstitious beliefs. As a result he no
on carpentry in particular. ‘“Who wants longer carves owl nightlamps as owls are
to hammer nails? ’that is their attitude, ”
says Jussawalla.
Looking back at his own youth, Jus
sawalla would have liked to have put his
talent to productive use earlier in his life.
“If I had started when I was 18...” No, he
has no regrets that he did not start young,
for he believes strongly in destiny. “Life best clients, advises him each time she
is like a film, it’s predetermined. We are
just experiencing it as it unfolds, ” he ob
serves.
And as the film on Jussawalla unfolds,
we find him working on wood carvings
in the carpentry shop of Boys Town
School in Nasik where he briefly studied.
Later he would carve logo calendars for a
comes to check out his work: “Tari
khopdi mane na batao (don ’t show me
your skull). ”
As we travel back after the meeting,
we come upon a patch of shattered glass
strewn on the road and think of Jussa
walla toiling in his sudreh and kusti in
- „-------------------- his small apartment in Andheri, wood
director of J. N. Marshall, a company he shavings scattered around him: appar-
was to join in 1963 as head of the carpen- ’ '' '
try department. From here he moved to
Nat Steel and was transferred to Poona.
After 15 years of service he resigned and
returned to Bombay in 1980 only to dis
cover that jobs in the city were not as
easy to come by as he had imagined. For
10 years he knocked about doing odd
jobs, including one in 1985 which in
volved the renovation of Late Night, a
restaurant in Andheri which belonged to
his neighbor Ms Mehroo Irani. When
Jussawalla took to full-time model carv
ing in 1990, Irani was one of the first to
encourage him in his efforts and even to
day gives quiet support. And, of course,
there is the backing of his wife of 17
years, Banoo.
Over the years Jussawalla has come to
accept struggles and battle as part of life,
yet he is greatly perturbed by the friction
that is part of the Parsi community. “Ev
erywhere you go, you will find two con
tentious groups of Parsis fighting over
everything, ” he observes. “We have to
learn unity if we are to survive today,
when everything is changing. ”
Though he laments over the plight of
the community he makes concessions to
With every new
piece he made, he
rebuilt his own
self-esteem
4
believed to be bad omens. Likewise a
steeple has replaced the afargan that ear
lier crowned his agiary.clock tower mod
els as a priest pointed out that the holy
fire should not be exposed, but protected.
And of course his skull clock is not one
of his popular designs. A lady, one of his
ently one of the last practitioners of
a once proud Parsi tradition of master
carpenters. Or does he herald a renais
sance?
Parsiana September 1992PROFESSIONS
Summoned by the sea
Seniormost Zoroastrian naval
officer Rear Admiral Keki Pestonji would
like to see more Parsi boys and
girls in the Indian Navy
Gustasp Irani
1971: Somewhere in the Arabian Sea.
Under cover of the night an Indian Navy
Ship with an ambitious young Parsi naval
officer on board, slips past enemy sur
veillance. Big guns boom as shells rain
down on the port city of Karachi. 1979;
Off the coast of Goa. A merchant ship,
M V Nandmayur, is in distress near the
Vengurla Rocks. The Parsi, now the
commanding officer of the naval vessel
INS Betwa, braves the turbulent sea and
rushes in to save and salvage the ship.
1980: Bonn, Germany. The same Parsi
officer is now posted here as the Indian
naval attache.
Rear Admiral Keki Peslonji, tall and
unmistakably brisk in his military bear
ing, has experienced all the romance the
sea and a naval career has to offer — and
more. He has been decorated with the
Ati Vishisht Seva Medal in 1989 for dis
tinguished service of an exceptional or
der; the Nausena Medal in 1979 for dis
tinguished service as commanding offi-
miral identified himself. The guard snap
ped to attention, flashed a crisp salute
and waved us on. At each checkpost the
exercise was repeated as Pestonji took us
on a brief tour of the naval base, a do
main he presided over with apparent af
fection and pride.
His bonds with the base, we were to
learn later, go back a long way. As a
young lieutenant he was selected, in
1968, to set up a naval academy at Co
chin, the first of its kind in India. Build
ing it up from scratch he worked out the
syllabus, the administrative structure and
organized the inputs required by the in
stitution.
When the Indian Navy launched INS
Godavri, the first ever frigate of its type
designed and constructed indigenously,
they entrusted it to the command of
Pestonji. As commanding officer of the
ship he successfully ‘interfaced ’ a mix of
weapons and sensor systems of Indian,
Russian, British and Italian origin. Later
inventory of the Navy, a task which
cer of the naval ship INS Betwa; and a he was to rationalize the entire
Mention in Despatches for action off inventory of the Naw aia.v,
Karachi in the 1971 war. Today, as the
Chief of Staff of the Southern Naval
Command Headquarters in Cochin, he is
the highest ranking Parsi officer in all the
three armed forces.
Yet when we first met him and his
charming wife Zarin in their sprawling
Willingdon Island bungalow overlooking
the Cochin harbor, we were embarrass
ingly unaware of his rank (this despite
his no-nonsense demeanor and clipped
speech). That was till we drove with him
to a naval checkpost. A military guard
marched up to scrutinize the occupants
of the car. “Chief of Staff, ” the Rear Ad
many years. “I am still very interested
and involved in the sport, ” Pestonji ob
serves.
He recalls that when he first joined
the Navy, there were many Parsis in the
services; most Rad joined during World
War II or just after it. A special bond of
comradeship existed between them no
matter where they were posted. Today,
he laments, the number of Parsis in the
Navy, or for that matter in any of the
three armed forces, has declined. “The
Navy offers an honorable profession with
bright career prospects. I would encour
age young Parsi boys and even girls —
the Navy is now open to women too —to
join. ” The total package of benefits of
fered by the armed forces matches what
the commercial sector has to offer, says
Pestonji. “I personally feel that young
Parsi boys in Bombay don ’t have what it
takes to join the armed forces. They
seem to be under the control of their
mothers and unable to venture out on
weapons open seas. ”
,. ____ re
sulted in large savings for the govern
ment and which won him the Ati Vish-
isht Seva Medal.
Pestonji ’s love affair with the high
seas began with his infatuation with l
lake. “Even as a young lad of nine, sail
ing fascinated me, ” he recalls. He first
took to the sport in Secunderabad, where
he grew up. Ever since he has been a
keen yachtsman, was the naval champion
Open seas aside, Pestonji urges the
Parsis to break free of the magnetic pull
that metropolitan Bombay seems to exer
cise on the community and venture out
into the heartland of the country if they
a hope to recapture some of their past
glory. He points out that it was their far
sightedness and vision that prompted
their forefathers to learn an alien lan
guage — English — which enabled them
in the sport twice and represented India Pestonji with daughter Anheeta wife
m two international regattas. ’ He has
been a member of the Yachting Associa
tion of India since its inception in 1960,
and has been on its board for the last
He has
Zarin and Ke fa Gandhi of Delhi (to his
right) at the function to commemorate
the memory of Param Vir Chakra Lt Col
Adi Tarapore in 1990 in Delhi
23 Parsiana September 1992
*the advice of all seven dasturs and abide
by them even if they go against their own
personal beliefs, states Irani.
What if they should be of the opinion
that the face of a dead Zoroastrian should
A MATTER OF TRUST
continued from page 16
salary of Rs 850 per month. “Just be
cause I stay in a Punchayet flat does not
mean that I must remain silent; it does
not mean that I cannot fight for the rights not be exposed? Irani pauses before he
of other poor Parsis, ” he adds.
And his fight against the alleged in
sis sitting in Bombay? The greatest thing justice is not confined to community
for them is to get a job in a bank and the
sad part is that it is not an easy thing to
come by any more. ”
Referring to his personal experience
he observes that in the 23 years he has
to become the brokers of the British, the
new rulers of the land. “Their ability to
talk to the English and the Indians made
them acceptable to both. Even today,
those Parsis who have adapted to the lo
cal Indian customs have succeeded, ”
says Pestonji. But for most, the equation
has changed. “Why are most of the Par-
answers — he had insisted that the face
of his dead father remain uncovered. “I
“Young Parsi boys in
Bombay don’t have
what it takes to join
the armed forces”
housing alone. He is of the opinion that
much greater efforts must be made to
seek reservation quotas. ZCWA trustees
will make a concerted push for special
concessions for the community. It is not
an empty promise, Irani assures us, as he
takes out a file of correspondence be
tween the ZCWA and State and Central
government departments on this matter,
“Reservations can be won but it would
become so much easier if the Punchayet,
which is the representative body of the
community, pushes for them rather than
the ZCWA,” says Irani.
While seeking special reservation
quotas for the community has been a low
profile activity of the ZCWA, its reli-
“Just because I stay
in a Punchayet flat
does not mean that
I must remain silent
))
been married he has accepted 10 major
postings. “It meant that the entire family gious postures are by contrast high pro-
had to move and relocate at an average
of once every two years. We accepted it
as an occupational hazard and both my
daughters (Anheeta and Taheera of controversies that followed the death of
whom he is obviously very proud) have Ms Roxan Shah and the decision of the
adapted very well, ” he adds.
Pestonji believes that while an indi
vidual Parsi is the master of his own des
tiny, the community as a whole is
doomed. “I don ’t think that our decline
in numbers has anything to do with Par
sis marrying out of the community. We
will die out as a matter of natural evolu
tion, ” he states. Clarifying the term
‘natural evolution ’ he observes: “No edu
cated and progressive community has
ever opted for a high birth rate. We Par-, religion and that they should not interfere
sis are an advanced, educated and pro
gressive community. Our women don ’t
want to be reduced to baby factories.
They would rather opt for a career and
have one or two children at the most. It’s
a thing you can ’t reverse. ”
The turning point in the community ’s
fortunes came when they started trading
in their farmlands for urban professions.
It opened the doors of progress which in
turn led to the crisis of numbers the com
munity faces today. “We came to India
as farmers and remained farmers for cen
turies. It was only in the last 200 years
or so we started selling our farms and
taking up other professions. ” And some
like Pestonji took to the sea, renewing
their subconscious bond with the natural
elements in true Zoroastrian tradition.
file, especially so when the Association
organized a morcha to the BPP and The
Bombay Samachar to protest against the
will accept it,” he says but adds: “In my
father ’s case I had acted impulsively but
later I discovered that what I had done
had not gone against the teachings of our
religion. Nowhere does it say that you
should cover the face of a dead person. ”
With the death of his father, Irani
found that the mantle of leadership in his
immediate family fell upon him even
though he was only the eighth of the
11 children. This Because he had quali
fied as a doctor against all odds. ‘‘Ever
since I was a kid my father wanted that
I among his children should become a
doctor. Maybe that was because I was the
most studious of the lot, ” says Irani.
BPP trustees to allow the bodies of Parsi
women married to non-Parsis into a ear
marked clokhma. “We were protesting With the aid, in the form of free text
against the way the trustees had handled
the matter and the bad publicity the com
munity .was receiving in the general tai.
Press because of it,” says Irani in defence
of the morcha. Did it not add to the
problem in the process? “No. It made the
other communities realize that it was a
matter that concerned the Parsis and their
books, from a number of charitable insti
tutions, Irani graduated from Nair Hospi-
At home, he learnt dedication and
selfless service from his “illiterate ” fa
ther. “People respected him because he
was always there to help them in a cri
sis,” says Irani. Often he would cut
through red-tape and retrieve bodies of
dead Parsi.s before they were mutilated
on postmortem tables. To illustrate the
point, Irani refers to the tragedy of 1960
in such matters, ” replied Irani.
Irani ’s critics charge that some of his
tactics such as the morcha are not in
keeping with the behavioral norms one when about eight boys and girls of
expects from a trustee. Allegations have
also been made in The Bombay Sama
char that Irani and his supporters tend to
browbeat those who oppose them.
According to him, the ZCWA protest days after the tragedy. “I still remember
was not against the decision of the trus
tees in the Roxan Shah case but against
the manner in which they reached their at Doongerwadi. Today Irani lives with
decision and the effect it had on the com
munity. “It split the community into two
camps. This could have been avoided if Baug in Mahim. But he believes his ori-
they had consulted all the seven dasturs gins gave him a true understanding of the
rather than just two (Dastur K. Jamasp hopes and aspirations of the poor of the
Asa and Dastur H. Mirza). ” ZCWA trus
tees will base all religious decisions on
Cusrow Baug drowned in the seas off
Bombay and his father recovered their
bodies from the morgue immediately af
ter they were found — some four to five
that incident because the smell was bad, ”
says Irani. It was all part of growing up
his wife Zarin and two children Farzan
(11) and Hushang (10) at N. Contractor
community whose interest the trustees of
the BPP are expected to protect.
24 Parsiana September 1992
1
«EVENTS AND PERSONALITIES
continued from page 9
A top LLB student
A remarkable performance at each of the
three-year LLB examinations, scoring on
an aggregate the highest marks, qualified
Ms Tenaaz P, Mama for the Vice Chan
cellor T. K. Tope Prize from the Bombay
University. This academic distinction
came to her shortly after she cleared the
final examination of the Institute of
Company Secretaries of India, informs a
press release from the family.
Presently undergoing management
training at Cadbury India Limited,
Mama’s past experience was at vacation
jobs as accounts assistant at Master Ma
rine Services and summer trainee at
Godrej and Boyce Manufacturing Com
pany Limited.
Her early education was at the Con
vent Girls High School, Worli and there
after at the Sydenham College from
where she graduated in commerce. Dur
ing her academic career. Mama has won
several scholarships and prizes including
the National Merit Scholarship in 1986
for performance at the Higher Secondary
Examination, the Glaxo Merit Scholarship
and the Zoroastrian Student Teachers
Association
Scholarship,
her bio data in
forms. General
knowledge,
general profi
ciency, speech
and essay writ
ing are die areas
in which she
has distinguish
ed herself.
Her other interests are French, having
completed the beginners and intermedi
ate courses at the Alliance Francaise,
Bombay and western music having
passed several Trinity College of Music
exams in piano. She has additionally
been an active fund raiser for the Na
tional Association for the Blind and
Helpage, India, mentions her bio data.
Brothers win Veedol rally
Every one of the 33 participants in the
Veedol Monsoon Scooter Rally had
fallen off their two-wheelers in the
course of the 250 km ride from Bombay
to Shahapur. However not all like Yezdi
Pali Patel would have said, “I was ready
to take any kind of injury if I could finish
the race.” Nineteen-year-old Patel’s de
termination won him the first place at the
Sportscraft organized Rally on Septem
ber 13, 1992, informs a press release.
The Veedol trophy and a cash prize of Rs
2,500 went to Yezdi while his elder
brother Kaizad had to settle for the
second place with a trophy and a gift of
Rs 2,000.
Consistency in control and high speed
on his LML Vespa were Yezdi’s chief
assets. In the 110 cc to 160 cc class it
was once again Yezdi and Kaizad who
secured the first two places respectively,
the release notes. For outstanding perfor
mance in the first part Yezdi was de
clared the winner of the Car and Bike In-
ternational Trophy while for the second
part the award was shared by Kaizad and
his cousin Zubin Kersi Patel. Last year’s
champion Zubin would have won the
race this time too, had he not been pena
lized for coming in 10 minutes early at
time control six, according to the press
release.
It was the prompt medical assistance
by the Highway Users Club and the Parsi
Ambulance Division that ensured the
smooth progress of the Rally, acknow
ledge the organizers.
Compiled by Roxina A. Miiza
*
MATRIMONIAL
MATRIMONIAL
Matrimonial correspondence
invited from suitable,
decent, educated and
well-settled
Parsi boys up to 27 years,
preferably from
AhmedabadZBombay
by parents of
a good-looking, educated
(BCom, also done computer
course) daughter, 5’5",
aged 22.
Please reply with full details
and preferably photograph
(returnable) to:
The Advertiser
Parsiana
Matrimonial (Sept/36-92)
GPO Box 892
Bombay 400001
Parents from an affluent
background seek matrimonial
alliance from well-placed
Parsi boys of respectable
families, for their two
daughters, aged 24 and 26
respectively. The girls are
currently residing and
working in UAE and are
due to come to Bombay
in December 1992,
Please forward
full details with contact
number and photograph
(returnable) to:
The Advertiser
Parsiana
Matrimonial (Sept/37-92)
GPO Box 892
Bombay 400001
MATRIMONIAL
Wanted an educated,
home-loving, good-natured
girl between 25 to 32 years
for a son aged 33, tall, 5’11",
handsome, having own
accommodation and business.
Girl should be willing to
settle outside Bombay.
Please apply with bio data,
photograph and horoscope
(essential) to:
The Advertiser
Parsiana
Matrimonial (Sept/39-92)
GPO Box 892
Bombay 400001
25 Parsiana September 1992WELFARE
Kharas’
burning
(com)passion
Homi Rogers >1
I
A magnanimous donation
of Rs 1.40 crores by Bhikhaiji
Kharas has helped create a
burns treatment center at the
Masina Hospital
f'l J
¦J-
¦¦iii
I •
ilBil
and two sisters,
grew up on much
love but with little
lucre to spare, in
the middle-class
of
t
<-<
Oi
3L0I-
I.
4*
*
Above: Kharas
(left) witnesses
Tata inaugu
rate the new
burns unit at
" Masina
Hospital on
May 3,1992
W Photo: Adi F. Suder
Jj The Kharas
I Memorial
I Centre (along-
I side)
" Photo: Jimmy Patel
The Parsis have never been known for she, along with
their parsimony. The sethias (gentry) her two brothers
have all along sustained the Parsi ethos
by doling out the occasional lakh for a
meritorious cause. Even the middle-class
Parsi, struggling to maintain a good stan
dard of living despite inflation, sub
scribes to the Gatha-ghambar or the kathi stronghold
fund in addition to feeding grass to the Bombay ’s Khet-
cow.
In a community celebrated for its
charity, Ms Bhikhaiji Sorabji Kharas, ployed as an engi-
fondly known as Bhikhoomai, is yet an- neer in
other member who will long be remem
bered for her magnanimity. The diminu
tive, frail-looking octogenarian appar
ently walked in from the blue and, ever the country to places which offered him
so quietly, put down a sum of Rs 1.40 job opportunities. Financial conditions
crores to raise the Kharas Memorial Cen
tre for burns victims.
Who is Ms Bhikhoomai Kharas? And elucidating the reasons in detail, “I had gold (or grime), that Kharas made her
from which wealthy, philanthropic fam- to take the family reins in my hands. ” killing. By 1938, she had become a sub-
ily does this new meteor of munificence
hail? Surprisingly, none. Kharas ’ story
is the archetypal rags-to-riches saga, or, yielded legitimate money.
in her case, an incredible poverty-to-phi- made and sold syrups and pickles and ex- tive, a claim Kharas laughs off dismis-
lanthropy story. And it is this fact that ported them abroad, ” says sister Dhun sively. But, despite her characteristic
makes her donation so astonishing, so
much more laudable. the construction scene. Among the build- for a good while she was the uncrowned
Bom in 1910, Kharas was brought up ings that bear her imprint are the twin queen of National Rayon. “Even today, ”
in Bombay by her maternal grandparents, skyscrapers Venus and Jupiter on Cuffe as Dr Jehanbux Chichgar, a consulting
“I have the fondest memories of them, ” Parade where she, as one of the builders, physician at the Centre says, “she could
beams Kharas, recalling the days when is said to have personally supervised the tip you with names of companies on
wadi area. “My
father was em-
neer in textile
mills ” and hence
was constantly on
the move all over
project as also the allotment and sale of
flats. •
But it was on Bombay ’s legendary were always strained. “At a very early
age, ” recounts Kharas, though without Dalal Street, where paths are paved with
to take the family reins in my hands. ”
So, enter a street-smart Bhikhoo, who broker, and traded in stocks and shares,
dabbled in anything and everything that “She could move the sensex up or down,
“She has by a twitch of her fingers, ” gushes a rela-
made and sold syrups and pickles and ex-
who resides with her. She even entered modesty, there remains little doubt that
the construction scene. Among the build
ings that bear her imprint are the twin
21 Parsiana September 1992I
Kharas ’ decision to help members of her
sex has resulted in eight of the 10 beds in I
serious condition. “And what about your the general ward being reserved for j
J women and children. “Men get burnt in j ‘
he replied, industrial accidents ” but, as a doctor on j
calls, informed her that he had come to
check on one of his patients who was in a
which you could make, your money,
without you ever having heard of them
before. ” It was with this assiduously ac
cumulated share portfolio that Kharas dinner, doctor? ” She inquired. “I carry
built the bums unit, on land made avail- •«” »«'-• ” »*¦“
able to her by the Masina (Hospital)
Trust. “I had no liquid money, ” con
fesses Kharas, a sheepish smile playing
on her fragile face. “My well-wishers
sold the shares I gave for this cause, and
raised the money needed. ”
But Kharas ’ story does not end here.
For it’s not the story of how Dick Whit
tington-like she amassed a fortune, gave
it all away and walked into the sunset.
No, it’s the tale of how compassion was
bom within her on the hospital floors of
Masina, how it grew and flowered, and
today continues to be nurtured by her Kharas was touched. “It was he who in-
ever-caring hands and benevolent mind.
It all began six years ago at the Mas
ina Hospital when her kind heart kept her
at the bedside of her ailing cook whom bom. Kharas, who had seen her sister
she regarded as a family member. It was
on one such night that, walking down the back in 1929, and had nursed her back to her again tomorrow. Kharas gently lakes
passage at around midnight, Kharas health “within a short span of three leave of her to attend to a pressing matter
bumped into the renowned plastic sur
geon Dr M. H. Keswani who now heads
her unit. Surprised, she asked him what bums victims are women and children;
he was doing in the Hospital at such a they get injured in household accidents,
late hour. The good doctor, Kharas re-
sandwiches in my box, ’
the panel informs us, they amount to
only 12 to 15 percent of the bums cases.
“And what about brides burned for
dowry? ” we probe Kharas. “Yes, that is
another matter, ” she states with equa
nimity, “though right now, ” she chuck
les, “we have an inverse case: a man with
two wives has been admitted in a charred
condition. ”
Kharas knows the names and case his
tories of all her patients. Even the inten
sity of their bums. But the knowledge is
not only academic. She tmly cares for
the victims, she makes their concerns,
hers, advises them, chides them and
counsels them. They return her love in
ample measure. Zaverben, who is recov
ering from bums caused when her stove
Dhun suffer from 50 percent bums way burst, beseechingly asks Kharas to visit
“She went round the
Hospital talking to
patients before she
came in to make a
donation to us”
spired me with his dedication, ” she as
serts simply.
The cook died. But a dream was
months ’,” was inspired by Keswani to do regarding the hospital ’s administration
something for burns victims. “Most awaiting her in .Jier spartan cabin. It was
a question Zaverben need not have
asked, for Kharas is there practically ev-
their saris catch and spread fire. ” ery day attending to the nitty-gritty of
Steamship agents — master stevedores
dubashes — lighterage contractors
Darabshaw B. Cursetjee’s
Sons (Bombay) Pvt Ltd
Oarabshaw House, Ballard Road, Bombay 400038
Grams: DEADWEIGHT Telex: 5824 DBCB IN
Phone: 2610021 (4 lines) (Dock Office: 2612230)
Also associates at
Calcutta, Vishakhapatnam, Kakinada, Mangalore,
Bhavnagar, Bedi-port, Navlakhi, Veraval, Porbunder & Kandla
Also sole Government Landing contractors at
Jamnagar, (Bed!) Bhavnagar
I
*
ft
28 Parsiana September 1992J
running the Centre she has built, and dis
pensing her salve of compassion. one lakh! ” right people are lending their ears (or
Even when the unit was being con- For Kharas that was no'rebuff. Be- reading this), Kharas ’ wand could give
structed, Kharas would be there daily, cause, her forte was never cash, but com- the housing problem a boost. “With her
“from nine to five, ” supervising every- passion. She had been through such dis- childlike enthusiasm, ” gushes a neigh
thing, according to her relative and ad- missals earlier, too. At the Bombay Parsi bor, “she can plunge herself into any new
ministrator Minoo Siodia. “She person- Punchayet office she was rebuked by activity and make a success of it.”
ally purchased the materials to be used. ” many a junior clerk when she asked to Enthusiasm, though, is not the only
Kharas also had her say in the appoint
ment of doctors, nurses, and ward
boys; she even sent a nurse to Eng
land for special training to head the
nursing unit on her return.
This minute attention to detail
has been a Kharas hallmark. For *
one who at 82 still scrutinizes the
fine print of the stocks page, it is not |
out of character. “I still recall the *
time, ” says a trustee of the Masina
Hospital who does not wish to be
named, “when she went round the
Hospital, as if she owned the place,
talking to patients, enquiring about
their condition, before she came in
to make a donation to us. ” It was
this meticulous approach that led ‘
to her decision to donate to the Mas
ina Hospital rather than another
Parsi hospital which she also studied for Otte of the operation theaters at the
the same purpose, and found disappoint- Kharas Memorial Centre Photo: Adi f. suder
ing.
The donation was not, as the trustees r
initially thought (judging by her simple some dole, not realizing that she was
sari and humble bearing), “in the region
of Rs 10,000.” The soft-spoken Kharas _____
offered Masina Hospital a donation of Rs problem plaguing the community, espe-
by the time her accountant and trustees i
finalized the legalities. “And we nearly Kharas Memorial Centre was built on
that we don ’t take donations less than afford to buy it and build on it.” If the
one lakh! ”
For Kharas that was no'rebuff. Be
cause, her forte was never cash, but com
passion. She had been through such dis
missals earlier, too. At the Bombay Parsi
many a junior clerk when she asked to
meet the chairman; they mistook her for thing Kharas shares with children. She
shares her love with them. “When
she goes to her bungalow in Thane,
. the street kids surround her and wel
come her. She has a treat in store
for all of them, ” says a friend. And,
like a child, Kharas has the rare
I qoality of innocence. “She is even
Iw kind to those who do not deserve her
kindness. ”
Like children, Kharas also has
her heroes. J.R.D. Tata is one of
SJ them. “I very much wanted him to
y inaugurate the Centre. It was a
dream-come-true for me when he
m agreed. ” JRD in turn sincerely ap-
¦ predated the honor and returned the
¦ compliment by valuing the welcome
B address as an award higher than the
Bharat Ratnp conferred on him. To
day one chair is missing from the
Centre ’s conference room. Kharas, we are
informed, has taken it home. It was the
chair JRD sat on after the inauguration.
We leave the Hospital, having wit-
there as a benefactress. nessed the largesse of this kindly old
Kharas is conscious of the housing lady. To us she reiterates : “Please don ’t
. „ ------------—x--- write much about me. Write about the
10 lakhs which increased to Rs 15 lakhs dally in Bombay. “Give me land, ” she Hospital. I’m not important; the Hospi-
I
L
Ul
S
9
B JHAVERI BROS.
1914
• 5,Metro House,Dhobitalao, Bombay 400 020.
Tel.:29 14 23,29 70 26.
• 345,Abdul Rehman St.,Bombay 400 003.
Tel.;32 00 65, 32 61 96/97.
32 Parsiana September 1992
ally borne by the party who makes an ap
plication. However costs can be awarded child ’s physical well-being and ties of af-
by the court covering minimal cost and fection.
not the amount actually incurred.
The divorced spouse has no right at all
in the intestate property of the deceased.
A divorced spouse is not considered a surroundings. The health of the child is
member of the family but is considered a ‘
stranger. However, that is not so in case
of the children. If there are children of telligent opinion about whom he or she
the divorced spouse and if the spouse wishes to live with, the decision of the
liefs must be considered as well as the
it is very important to bear in mind as
to whether the child would have good ac
commodation in happy and congenial
of the utmost importance. Whenever a
minor child is capable of forming an in-
intestate dies
then the chil
dren of the di
vorced spouse
would get an
equal amount as
the children of
the
spouse.
Under Section
49 of the Parsi
Marriage
Divorce
present
and
Act,
Visiting rights cannot
be denied to
either party, even
if he or she
is living in adultery
child would be
taken into con
sideration by
the court.
In a very in
teresting case,
an application
was made to the
court wherein it
was stated that
a child was very
ill and the visit
of the father,
the Matrimonial Court is authorized to
pass interim orders and make provisions
in the final decree in respect to the cus
tody, maintenance and education of chil
dren under the age of 18 years. But the
order is not final and the court can vary
the same from time to time. No order can
be passed regarding children who have she could still be regarded as a fit person
reached adulthood.
There is always a battle between hus
band and wife for the custody of their seriously affected by separation from her
children. It is believed that girls are child, the court would normally give the
handed over to their mothers and boys custody of the child to the mother,
are given in their father ’s custody. This
belief is entirely wrong. Usually the
court refuses to give the custody of the ther) is living in adultery and this fact is
child to the guilty party. However, under proved. The court ’s order would stipu-
normal circumstances, as children are
more attached to the mother, custody is
given to her with visiting rights to the fa
ther. If neither father nor mother are fit entitled to a maintenance allowance for
to have the custody of the minor child,
the court will be justified in giving the
custody of the child to a third party who Merely because the wife asks for more
the court feels is the right person to look
after the child.
There is also a misconception that
when there are four children, they are di
vided between the mother and feather at
the time of the divorce. In fact, it is not
so. It is not the right of the parents which
would tilt the scale in the opinion of the
court but the welfare of the child. It children,
seeks to ascertain where the best welfare
of the children would lie, whether they
be girls or boys.
What does the word welfare mean un
der the law? The moral and religious be-
who was a drunkard, would retard the re
covery of the child. The court ordered
that till the <^hild had completely
recoverd from the illness, visiting rights
would not be granted to the father.
It is worth noting that even if the hus
band were to accuse the wife of adultery,
to look after her children. If it is consid
ered that the mother ’s health would be
Visiting rights cannot be denied to ei
ther party, even if the mother (or the fa
late where and when the child may be
visited.
It is also to be noted that the mother is
the child, apart from the alimony which
she is entitled to get under the law.
money to look after the* child is no
ground to refuse custody.
In one case, the argument of the father
that he had to support his brother and
sister and therefore could not spare
resources for the child ’s maintenance
was disallowed. It was held that a fa
ther ’s primary duty is to support his own
Koover C. Vajifdar is an advocate of the Bom
bay High Court. He is a frequent contributor
to the general Press on the implications of the
Rent Act and the legal ramifications of marital
problems.
1
i
iCOMMENT
pnvaw
VO' 2 '
43®^,
A forum
for the
BP’’
lbehi O'*
.99' *
OH
?Wl'(
1
ten*
»’
«r
0. M.o-1
, loOP^^,
a
• •"* fl
I* ¦*
J co*.”*
..kOP* '®
I 9"'
'onT xe"
oaice
STSU" „
»<•'
r.-« ”> ;
• -'ll
P#‘4'
An editor of Deen Parast reviews the
orthodox organ’s mission after a year of
\ publication Noshir Dadrawaia
Q POP*
OA'O*'
.0
„,nTOt>*'
I**””'
-I «¦
P“''
kopp*"’
OPOP*'”
ohW-"”’
cS
,0 R-’
\\‘,X f”"
\\
V'*
Y O’*"'
«* is (boys) to Mahrukh and
A boy to Roshan and Neville
Avari-, August 25
A boy to Tanaz and Keki
A boy to Kashmira and Kaizad
Merchant-, August 25
A boy to Maya and Limi Banaji-,
A girl to Celin and Bomi Patel-,
A girl to Shehernaz and Kaiwan
A girl to Daizy and Zarir
Mistry-, August 31
Married
Yvonne Kampororo and Neveille
Homi Sagar, May 7
Meher Zarir Gagrat and Nozer
Barjorji Mehenty, May 11
Elizabeth Alexandra and Feroze
Rustom Variava-, May 11
Mahafrine Mehta and Rodney
Anthony Powell-, May 12
Kashmira Nariman Munshi and
Bahmanshaw Dhunjishaw
Baldawala-, May 14
Kunti Krishnaji Ranade and
Zarir M. Karanjia-, May 18
Rashmi Laxman Pai and Zubin
Marzban Nalladarw, May 28
Divya Karkhanis and Sam
Palia-, May 28
Kashmira Phiroze Banatwalla
and Dhependra Ramesh Bhatt;
June 2
Mayuri Vijay Kelkar and
Behram Jamshed Irani-, June 11
Bakhtawar B. Tantra and
KumarakrishnanP. K.-, June 12
Yogiru PravifKhandra Varma
and Sarosh Jamshedji Painter;
June 19
Pearl Ronald O’Cormor and
Hafeez Sorab Contractor;
June 22
Delna Dadyburjor and
Tarvinder Singh; June 26
Tina H. Saigal and Meherrutsh
R. Daroowalla-, June 27
Zahidabano Mohmadraza
Shaikh and Darayes Ardeshir
Appoo; July 9
Meher Dinshaw Patel and Ajith
V.; July 9
Meenakshi Maya Balachandran
and Percy Jamshed Irani-,
July 14
Roxana Shapur Irani and
Pradeep Mohanty-, July 27
Fari^ Parvez Saklatwalla and
Cyrus Marzban Gorimar,
August 3
Aditi Kantilal Manseta and
Faroukh Fall Mistry-, August 11
Kashmira Rustom Irani and
Rusi Sam Govekar; August 23
Zenabia Farrokh Dalal and
Firdosh Soharab Bulsara-,
August 29
Armaity Nariman Sahiar and
Kanwal Krishna Gopikrishna
Wattal; August 30
Shobhana Durgashankar Desai
and Adi Khodamurad Irani;
August 31
i
1
J
ft ;
Died
Jiji Jahangir Dastur (80),
residing at 1-A, Ashoka Apts,
Anandwadi, 3, Maylor Rd,
Pune, 411001; January 4
(cremated)
Rustom Framroze Jalanwala
(73), Firoz Ara, 160, M. Karve
Rd, 400021, January 9
(cremated)
Roshan Sharokh Sabavala (72),
Beau Rivage, 77, Worli Sea
Face, 400025; March 27
(cremated)
Farida Patel (43), 161-4,
Anthony Mans, 29th Rd, TPS
in, Bandra, 400050; April 8
(cremated)
Keikhushru Ardeshir Dondy
(84), 10, Sindhudurg Hse, 33,
Mereweather Rd, 400039;
June 17 (crematexl)
36 Parsiana September 1992Piloo D. Nariehvala (64), 29,
Suleman Chmbs, Colaba,
400039; June 28 (cremated)
Fakirji Hormusji Billimoria
(13), 13, N-2, New Khareghat
Clny, Hughes Rd, 400007;
August 1
Shavak Bomanji Choksey (83),
Divine Grace, 114, Turner Rd,
Bandra, 400050; August 1
Dorabji Maneckji Daruwala
(87), Fakhri Manzil,
Shankerseth Rd, Grant Rd,
400007; August 2
Minocher Rustomjee Jijina (80),
21, Police Court Lane, Behind
Handloom Hse, Fort, 400001;
August 2
Rati Fardoonji Billimoria (71),
Jehangir Mans, Next to Metro
Cinema, 400020; August 3
Sorabji Khurshedji Daruvala
(78), B, Yusuf Mans, Khetwadi
Back Rd, 400004; August 3
Soli Menvan Iraru (80), 204,
Shamaldas Gandhi Rd,
Dhobitalao, 400002; August 3
Homai Jal Pavri (75), 816,
Mistry Bldg (Widows ’ Chawl),
lame Jamshed Rd, Parsi Clny,
Dadar, 400014; August 3
Goses Sheriar Vakil (61),
Malegaon Bldg No 1, Station
Rd, Mahim, 4(X)016;
August 3
Khorshed Sorabji Mehta (80),
F-36, Cusrow Baug, S. B. Rd,
400039; August 4
Aranvaj Framroze Tobak (86),
2/A, Soonawalla Bldg, Tardeo,
400007; August 4
Kawasjee Framroz Vakeel (73),
Mayfair Gardens, Little Gibbs
Rd, Malabar Hill, 400006;
August 4
Jal Behramsha Anklesaria (66),
20, Rupa Lane, Chandanwadi,
Chirabazar, 400002; August 5
Noshirwan Dadabhai Dalal
(80), 2/C, United Chmbs,
Chami Rd Jn, 400007;
August 5
Morvarid (Motibai) Boman
Irani (74), 1, Harganga Mhl
Annexe, Khodadad Circle,
Dadar, 400014; August 5
Sohrab Dorabsha Korkhau (89),
Shroff Bldg, 259, Bazar Gate
St, Fort, 400001; August 5
Amy Rustomji Mobedji (60),
815, Engineer Bldg, Jame
Jamshed Rd, Parsi Clny,
Dadar, 400014; August 5
Piroja Jijibhoy Vatcha (88),
Lady N. Tata Bldg, Dhanbai-
wadi. Vile Parle (W), 4(X)056;
August 5
Nadirsha Fardoonji Wadia
(77), 5/3, Tata Clny, Tardeo,
400034; August 5
Sovak Rustomji Kanga (78),
l/B/3, Tata Mills Co-op Hsg
Soc, Parel, 400012; August 7
Telunurasp Edulji Mistry (90),
28/2, Malegamwalla Bldg,
Mahim, 400016; August 7
Nergish Hormusji Randelia
(58), Petit Sanatorium, Kemp ’s
Comer, 400036; August 7
Shirin Pherozesha Elavia (81),
515/B, Ratan Mans, R. P.
Masani Rd, Matunga, 400019;
August 8
Ardeshir Pestonji Chinwalla
(86), Burjor Bldg, Wadia St,
400034; August 9
Kersasp Nusserwan Dastur
(75), Katgara Hse, 15, Nepean
Sea Rd, 400006; August 9
Shavakshah Hormusji Wadia
(73), F. S. Parukh Dharam
shalla, 34, Hughes Rd, 400007;
August 9
Tester Minu Udwadia (70),
35/C, Muncher Manzil,
Jairajbhai St, 400008;
August 10
Allamai Behramji Umrigar
(91), 71, Ferena, Arthur Bunder
Cross Rd, 400005; August 10
Sheroo Noshir Aibara (75),
639, Rati Manzil, M. Joshi Rd,
Parsi Clny, Dadar, 400014;
August 11
Piloo Sorabji Gazder (82),
Kashinath Bldg, Cadel Rd,
Mahim, 400016; August 12
Farrokh Kekobad Mobedjina
(64), 794, Family Hse, Parsi
Clny, Dadar, 400014;
August 12
Khorshed Cawasji Bhandara
(62), Karanjia Bldg, Above
Nagina Restaurant, Grant Rd,
400007; August 13
Pheroz Dinshaw Khambatta
(64), 14/2, Rustom Baug,
Victoria Rd, Byculla, 400027;
August 13
Martekbai Faramroz Billimoria
(92), Rehana Manzil, L. J. Rd,
Mahim, 400016; August 14
Framroze Hormusji Dubash
(82), 36, Kama Hse,
A. Marzban Lane, S. B. Rd,
400039; August 14
Banoobai Jamshedji Sanjana
(80), 728, Sorab Mans, J.
Vimadalal Rd, Parsi Clny,
Dadar, 400014; August 14
Banoo Jal Bharucha (75),
802/B, Gool Villa, Khareghat
Rd, Parsi Clny, Dadar, 400014;
August 15
Minoo Rustomji Damania (79),
Master Chmbs, Metro Cinema
irmusji Talati (75),
Lane, Dhobitalao, 400020;
August 15
Goolbanu Hosheng Kased (77),
Sargent Hse, Allana Marg,
Colaba, 400039; August 15
Tehmina Jehangirji Bhagwagar
(72), 6/A, Cama Bldg,
Kashinath St, Tardeo, 400034;
August 16
Keki Nadirshaw Jalnawalla
(74), 203, Garden View, Off
Hill Rd, Bandra (W), 400050;
August 16
Amy Savaksha Kluunbatta (66),
Room no 9, Pandey Sanatorium,
Wodehouse Rd, Colaba,
400005; August 16
Rustomji Nusserwanji Marfatia
(75), 11, Andheri Kiran Hsg
Soc, Amboli, Andheri (W),
400058; August 16
Kety Dara Subedar (73), G/3,
S. B. Bharucha Baug, Andheri,
400058; August 16
Soli Maneckshaw Driver (58),
Old Chinoy Bldg, Chikalwadi,
Grant Rd, 4(X)007; August 17
Katie Rustom Ghadiali (60),
Victoria Bar and Stores Bldg,
Murbad Rd, Kalyan, Dist
Thane, 400601; August 17
Eruch Navroji Elavia (77), 16,
Tata Bldg, Parsee Clny,
Dadabhai Rd, Vile Parle (W),
400056; August 17
Gustad Behram Irani (80), Post
Bawda, Via Chinchan, Dist
Thane, Vangaon, 401103;
August 17
Putla Cavas Kerawalla (87),
13, Hampton Court, 125,
Wodehouse Rd, Colaba,
400005; August 17
Bapshi Naval Khandadiya (51),
At Acchad, Post Uplait, Dist
Thane, 401601; August 17
Mani Manecksha Deboo (61),
83/85, Mazda Mans, Dhobi
talao, 400002; August 18 .
Dinshaw Harmusji Talati (75),
Kerawalla Bldg, 307, Tardeo
Rd, Nanachowk, 400007;
August 18
Behram Nowroji Tavadia (72), (78), F/27, Cusrow Baug, S. B.
B/22, Jer Baug, Dr Ambedkar
Rd, Byculla, 400027;
August 18
Maneckji Nariman Amaria (87),
22, Aderbad, 34, Hughes Rd,
400007; August 19
Rusi Boman Irani (63), 17/4,
India Hse, Kemps Comer,
400036; August 19
Dina Burjor. Joshi (82), Burjor
Bldg, Wadia St, Tardeo,
400034; August 19
Mithamai Kaikashrii Singpor-
wala (68), A/12, Nowroz Baug,
Lalbaug, 400012; August 19
Roda Rustumji GaruBii (74),
Room no 16, Irani Dharam-
shala, Gamdevi, 400007;
August 20
Kersi Kaikasroo Mistry (59),
12/B, Cawasji Petit Bldg, Gilder
Lane, Tardeo, 400008;
August 20
Behriun Rustomji Pavri (J5),
204, Old Sitaram Bldg, Princess
St, 400002; August 20
Barjorji Sorabji Achhadwala
(96), F. S. Parukh Dharam
shalla, 34, Hughes Rd, 400007;
August 21
Naju DcuUba Banaji (78),
A/604, Minoo Minar, Veera
E)esai Rd, Andheri (W),
400058; August 21
Piroza Sariar Irani (80), Fakhri
Manzil, Shankerseth Rd,
Grant Rd, 400007; August 21
Jerestine Adil Sahukar (10
days) 14/A, Hammamabai Petit
Block, Gilder Lane, Maizban
Clny, 400008; August 22
Goola Phirozeshah Sodawater-
walla (77), 603, Goola Mans,
Jame Jamshed Rd, Matunga,
400019; August 22
Hoshang Cavasha Cavasji (43),
70/C, Phirojsha Bldg, August
Kranti Marg, 400036;
August 23
Bomanshaw Dorabji Mistry
(87), 2, Shanker Sagar, Sophia
College Rd, 400026; August 23
Nadar Dorabji Patel (68), F/17,
Cusrow Baug, S. B. Rd,
400039; August 23
Aspi Sorabji Contractor (68),
Room no 11, Petit Sanatorium,
Cumballa Hill, 400036;
August 24
Sheroo Dinshaw Kapadia (73),
648, Kaka Bldg, Firdausi Rd,
Parsi Clny, Dadar, 400014;
August 24
Tehmi Pesi U^adia (72), D,
Petit Block, Dinbai Petit Rd,
Grant Rd, 400007; August 24
Phiroze Rustomji Movdavala
?
s
¦
Rd, 400039; August 25
Mani Merwanji Batiwalla (90),
686, Vevai Villa, Khareghat Rd,
Parsi Clny, Dadar, 400014;
August 26
Nargis Naoroji Mistry (70),
(iQIN, Topiwalla Bldg, Supari
Baug Rd, Parel, 400012;
August 26
Najan Keki Havewalla (73),
G/3, Bhivandiwala Ter, 618,
J. Shankersheth Rd, 400002;
August 27
Burjor Shiavax Pavri (81), Villa
37 Parsiana September 1992Bem-Vindex, 4, St Alexius Rd,
Bandra, 400050; August 27
Minoo Nadirshah Shrojf (60),
Room no 10, Bhabha Sana
torium, Bandra Band Stand,
400050; August 27
Eruch Homi Bhesania (78),
70/D, Meher Villa, Hill Rd,
Bandra, 400050; August 28
Nergish Jehangir Elavia (68),
E/34, Cusrow Baug, S. B. Rd,
400039; August 28
Maru Dinshaw Kapadia (55),
Wake Mohalla, Chirabazar,
400002; August 28
Rusi Eruchshaw Bengali (68),
511, Kanak Vihar, Adenwalla
Rd, Matunga, 400019;
August 29
Jeroo Manecksha Bharucha
(72), C, Kanta Bldg, Grant Rd,
Near Super Cinema, 400007;
August 29
Sapal Cawasji Lovjee (73),
Malcolm Baug, Jogeshwari,
4(X)102; August 29
Baby of Kashmira Kaizad
Merchant (5 days), 12, Jer
Mans, Turner Rd, Bandra,
400050; August 29
Flicky Minoo Shroff (48), E/4,
Cusrow Baug, S. B. Rd,
400039; August 29
Framji Hormusji Commissariat
(84), Sylmoyne, 3, Carmichael
Rd, 400026; August 30
Jamshed Sorabjee Kalyanivala
(84), 658, Khorshed-Abad,
Firdausi Rd, Parsi Clny, Dadar,
400014; August 30
Ratanbai Jehangir Patel (88),
C/12, Shapur Baug, V. P. Rd,
400004; August 31
BORN
Boys
Girls
MARRIED
Parsi
Intercommunal
DIED
INTERRED
Male
Female
CREMATED
Male
Female
TOTALS FOR 1992
Bombay
A B
Other Indian cities Foreign cities
A B A
B
18
19
95
91
1 4
1 1
13
15
5
20
47
41
4
2
144
44
279
335
4
2
1
3
2
5
5
15
14
49
53
5
2
26
18
A: Total numbers in this issue
B: Running totals for 1992 (February-September issues)
These figures peruin to information provided to or collected by Parsiana.
They do not represent the total number of births, marriages and deaths in
the Zoroastrian community in India and abroad.
CALCUTTA
Married
Roda Avari and Tarun Das\
August 5
Died
Burjor Dorab Mogrelia,
husband of Dorothy and brother
of Rusi and Phiroze; August 2
Saker Sovak Mehta, mother of
Katie Dalal and Kerbanoo
Bamji; August 3
Bejon Shapurji Tata, husband of
Perin and father of Roshan
Jeejeebhoy, Roda Bulsara and
Navaz Verma; August 13
Taboot St, 411001; August 5
Maneck Burjorji Gandevia (72),
7, Castelino Rd, 411001;
August 6
Khorshed Jamshed Nusser-
wanjee (83), 12, Parvati Villa,
411040; August 8
Shiavax Jamshed Bokdawalla
(67), 2414, East St, 411001;
August 10
Baby boy of Lily Ghadially
(5 days), 302/42, Peninshula
Bldg, Gidney Park, 411001;
August 12
Yasmin Chirag Anklesaria
(1 month), 425/A, Rasta Peth,
411002; August 20
Katty Jimmy Baria (61), St
Patrick ’s Town, Hadapsar,
411028; August 24
Dina Nariman Sethna (88), 7,
Tulsidas Apts, Dastur Meher
Rd, 411001; August 29
Najamai Khurshedji Marker
(92), 2, Immamvada, Syna
gogue St, 411001; August 31
Baby boy of Yezdi Aspi Shroff
(newborn), Bhimkacchi St,
Nanpura, 395001; August 8
Munchershaw Jamshedji
Bhagwagar (75), Palia Mohallo,
Nanpura, 395001; August 10
Burjorji Cooverji Bhathena
(75), Kumbhar Mohallo, Gam
Bhatha, 394501; August 15
Alamai D. Patel (78), Nariman
Home and Infirmary, Shahpore,
395003; August 15
Baby girl of Cyrus Noshir
Jabbar (3 days). Gam Bhatha,
Dist Surat, 394501; August 21
Shavaksha Rustomji Ichhaporia
(67), Gam Ichhapore, Dist
Surat, 395003; August 24
Nariman Cavasji Tamboli (72),
Agiary Mohallo, Rustompura,
DELHI
Born
A boy, Parvez, to Aban and
Aspi Dittia-, July 6
POONA
Died
Noshir Param Ogra (60), 761/6,
SURAT
Died
Ratanmai Nadershaw Dadre-
walla (78), Shanti Niketan,
Leprosy Hosp, Tarwadi, Variav;
August 1
Najamai Jamshedji Dastur (80),
Agiary St, Adajan; August 1
Dolly (Mani) Dinshawji
Dumasia (71), Parsi Wad,
Saiyedpura, 395003; August 7
Phiroze Dhunjishaw Kharadi
(71), Nariman Home and
Infirmary, Shahpore, 395003;
August 8
38 Parsiana September 1992
395002; August 24
Shavaksha Nowroji Baria (93),
Malesar Mohallo, Rustompura,
395002; August 25
Colamai Rustomji Mistry (80),
Palia St, Nanpura, 395001;
August 25
Mani Ratansha Patel (76),
Parsi Mohallo, Nanpura,
395001; August 28
VADODARA
Died
Darashaw Edulji Wadia (85),
Meher Villa, Alembic Rd,
390001; March 23
Pilloo Dady Muncherji (90),
Piroja Villa, B-3, Shakuntal
Park, Manjalpur, 390011;
May 16
CHICAGO
Born
A girl, Nadia Elisabeth, to
Karen and Daryoosh Tirandazi;
March 18
KARACHI
Died
Burjorji Hoshang Baria (92);
July 4
Ratanshaw Dorabji Kapadia
(80); July 8
Pilamai Faramroz Bhujwalla
(85); July 12
Aspi K. R. Cavina (78); July 13
Eruchshah Dinshah Sidhwa
(71); July 19
Piroja Nadirshaw Lawyer (87);
July 22
NEW YORK
Died
Hoshang Rustom Kakalia of
Karachi (58); July 15
Compiled by Roxana A. Miiza
Required
Editorial Assistant
For Parsiana magazine in Bombay.
Person must have
excellent command of the English
language and preferably two years'
work experience in a publication.
Job responsibilities include
proofing, editing, writing,
re-writing and production.
Write with full details to:
The Advertiser (Edit)
GPO Box 892, Bombay 400001
A
IIN MEMORIAM
The Open Heart
KERSI DASTUR
Arnavaz S. Mama
I
When celebrated sur
geon Dr Kersi Nusser-
wanji Dastur suc
cumbed on August 9,
1992 to the cerebral
stroke he had sustained
nine days earlier, the
medical fraternity in
general and the com
munity in particular
agreed they had lost
not a peer but a lode
star. By all accounts
surgery only became possible with the
advent of the heart-lung machine which,
attached to the patient, runs the pump
and oxygenates the blood which is fil
tered and returned to the body while the
lungs lie dormant during the operation,
explains Soonawalla. Everything must
be very precise as severe brain damage
can result from inadequate pumping, he
informs. Since the Indian government
would not permit the import of a heart
lunch machine which then costed about
seven lakh rupees, Dastur prevailed upon
the local technicians to make one. Now Farokh Udwadia in the
course of a speech everybody uses imported machines
punctuated with pauses which cost in the region of 30 to 40 lakh
as though to subdue rupees, he adds.
the high tide of senti
ment.
“I have learnt from
him all I know of sur
gery, the ethics and
morality of medical
practice, ” acknowled-
“I was his assistant during the first 20
cases done by us. Everybody came to
see how it was done. He did everything
here, never went to America... Senior
surgeons from all over India would come
to see his work. He was always a few
steps ahead of them, ” rejoices
ged Dastur ’s proteg6 Soonawalla, addisg, “Dr Lillihie, the
first man to do open-heart surgery in the
___ world, had been very impressed. lf(Das-
Soonawalla. “Although not a student of tur) had been in the US, he would have
¦ • *________ .__ . , • .i-T,....; been on par with (Lillihie). ”
Recalling those days of triumph and
deflation when a patient suddenly took a
downturn, Soonawalla reminisced how
~ ¦ . Commented radiologist there were no electronic monitors in the
Dr M. Tayabali of the Breach Candy hospitals in those days and resident doc-
Hospital, “Words are inadequate to ex-
and assistant of 15
years, well-known surgeon Dr Fardoon
his probity as an individual rivalled his
surgical skill which bordered on wiz-
ardry. his, I was an ardent admirer of Kersi as a
“A man of few words, gentle in his superlative surgeon with the most pol-
manners and possessing rare integrity, he ished technique and sound judgement, ”
made no distinction between the rich and wrote orthopedic surgeon Dr Jamshed
the poor... His degree of concern for the Taraporevala. < _ - .
patients was rare and he attended without P , . . . . ¦
looking to his own convenience, ” notes Hospital, “Words are inadequate to ex- tors were expected to watch the patients
the condolence resolution adopted by the press one ’s loss. ” closely. Investigations of such reversals
B D Petit Parsee General Hospital On his return to Bombay after a year ’s led to the realization that the resident
study in England for his FRCS (Fellow doctors were neglecting their job in the
of national of the Royal College of Surgeons) di- night and Dastur produced a characteris
tic solution to the problem: Thenceforth
__ _____ „ ,. the resident was required to phone Dastur
College (TNMC) and assistant honorary through the night with hourly reports on
surgeon, B. Y. L. Nair Charitable Hospi- the patient. The resident could not sleep
tai. In 1951 he began experimental work and neither could Dastur, but the patient
in heart surgery in the research laborato
ries of TNMC with a large team of work
ers to help him in the difficult task of tients are legion. Not only did he refuse
making a heart-lung machine, informs to charge professional fees to friends, re-
his bio data. In 1957 the first indigenous lations, students, teachers or mobeds, he
heart-lung machine was produced and
used for animal experiments. On Febru
ary 16, 1961 Dastur performed the first
using the machine on a 16-year-old girl cancellations of his own trips abroad in
with a hole in her heart, notes the Indian response to requests from the Bachchan
family, considering it his “contribution
to the happiness of Amitabh ’s fans, ” in
forms longtime family friend Arvind
On his return to Bombay after a year ’s
(PGH).
“Dr Dastur was a surgeon ---------
renown who was loved and respected by ploma, Dastur had been aj^inted^
tens of thousands of families... He was
felicitated on the 25th anniversary of his
first open heart operation at the Interna
tional Conference of Heart Surgeons in
Bombay in February 1985 and named as
the Father of Open Heart Surgery in the
Indian subcontinent, ” further attests the
resolution taken at the condolence meet
ing organized by the staff ol the Breach
Candy Hospital.
“People like Dr Kersi Dastur do not
die. They live on in their work, in memo
ries of people in various walks of life, in
their acts of kindness, of decency... I was
associated with him since 1959 when I
returned from studies abroad.
formed a team from the word ‘go ’... I
will miss him sorely, ” admitted eminent
physician and community doyen Dr
tant professor of surgery, T. N. Medical
got the requisite attention.
Stories of Dastur ’s concern for pa-
refused to take a single paise from film
star Amitabh Bachchan throughout the
latter ’s long hospitalization at the Breach
successful human open-heart operation Candy Hospital and made three to four
s
s
39 Parsiana September 1992-
We
with a hole in her heart, notes the Indian
Express of August 20, 1992.
Closed heart surgery, which had been
the rule until jhc 1960s had very limited
scope, informs Soonawalla. Open-heart Kaji.A model of self-discipline, Dastur
would be up at 5 a.m. — even if he had
Some of his unobtrusive generosity
came to light when the subsidized in
mates of the Breach Candy ’s Godrej slept just three hours earlier, says Nur-
Wing came after 10 years for replace
ment of the original pacemaker that had
been implanted for them by Dastur, nar
rates Soonawalla. They were aghast
when asked to pay for the new item — its
price ranging beyond Rs 25,000 — not
ing that on the first occasion the Hospital Nursing Home. His faith in God was im-
“enemy ” of the religion “out to play mis
chief with our unchangeable laws. ”
Dastur ’s own body was confined to
the tower of silence.
On other issues, especially on the
matter of intermarriage and conversion,
Dastur ’s viewpoint was that of the athor-
nan scion that he was. That one of his
had supplied it gratis. After much inves
tigation it was established that it was not
the Hospital but Dastur personally who
had paid (approximately Rs 10,000 each)
for the pacemakers installed in such
cases!
Indeed, money meant little to Dastur,
says Kaji. He remembers how on one oc
casion Dastur was summoned by an ur
gent call from the Nanavati Hospital in
Andheri when he was not even attached
to the Hospital, to attend on a Marwari ’s
son who had met with a road accident
that had virtually ripped the boy ’s en
trails out. Dastur drove there, completed training his students, giving them all the
the operation, then visited the patient 15
to 20 times. “At the end of it all, the
Marwari gave Dastur a packet of Rs 501
for saving his son! Dastur never saw (Kersi and Nurgish had first met as medi-
what came. He believed his rewards
were accumulating in the Upper Bank! ”
The man who went on to establish
fine departments of cardiovascular tho
racic surgery at the Nair, Nanavati, Jas-
lok and Breach Candy Hospitals was
equally indifferent to ego and prestige
and “always available — be it day or formity — one that had raised some hue
night, ” remembered PGH president and cry in the community — had been in
Homa Petit, recounting an instance when January 1974 when he had entered the
a female patient — a case of tubal deliv
ery — was in need of urgent aid. “The
gynac concerned could not be immedi
ately contacted. A frantic call was sent
out to Dr Dastur and within five minutes
he rushed the patient to the theater and
saved her life, ” narrated Petit. As vouch
ed Udwadia, “I haven ’t met a surgeon so
far with as ‘ (small) an ego as Kersi lay the mortal remains of my dear father
Dastur ’s — and that is saying a lot! ” to rest. I was horrified to see four dead
Dastur ’s wife Nurgish recalls an incident bodies consigned several months ago in-
when her husband was called upon to op- side the dokhma lying untouched in iden-
erate on the thyroid of a major millowner tifiable form,
at the Sir Harkisondas Hospital. Dastur
performed his usual artistry and left. The
accolades were collected by another.
An even more characteristic example
of Dastur ’s humane qualities was an inci
dent when a number of friends met at the
home of an ailing man in Tardeo. The
patient needed milk: though there were
several people present, it was Dastur who March 1974).
went to fetch some.
gish. He ’d be the first surgeon to report
at the PGH. After the day ’s operations,
Dastur would reach his consulting rooms
in the early afternoon and remained there
till 6 p.m. Thereafter, till 9.30 p.m. his
working day continued at the Northcote daughters chose to marry outside the
community was initially a matter of un
happiness for Dastur, acknowledges Nur
gish.
The community and its institutions
meant a lot to Dastur and, as Petit ac
knowledged, “He was deeply concerned
for and ever striving to enhance the im
age of the (Parsee General) Hospital. ”
Discussing the PGH in an interview with
Parsiana at the time of the Hospital ’s
“He was
uncomfortable
receiving praise
or awards ”
mense — there wasn ’t a day or night that
he didn ’t pray. Indeed, he was known to platinum jubilee Dastur had said, “I’m
pray before each operation and used to not in favor of cosmopolitanizing the
say, “The greatest surgeon is Dadar Hospital because we Parsis. are such a
Hormuzd. I am only an instrument, ” as
recalls Kaji. Nor did he hold back on
small community and once we start this,
it will bring in the money but it’s not going
to be beneficial to the community in the
chance to work under him. “He would long run... Let Parsis donate. They don ’t
wait patiently for them, ” adds Nurgish.
“A liberal, good, thoughtful husband
donate enough — they could do better! ”
His thinking* in matters other than
surgery, belonged to an earlier genera
tion, says Soonawalla of his late 74-year- cal undergraduates at the Grant Medical
College) and a kind father, ” Dastur old mentor. “His only concerns were his
wanted his daughters to be well-educated work and his family. He had no desire
and to pray regularly, says his wife. He for social life. He was very uncomfort-
had a collection of old religious books
and had learnt Persian in later life.
Dastur ’s one act of religious noncon-
able socializing and would avoid major
functions... He was uncomfortable sitting
on a stage, uncomfortable receiving
praise or awards. He was president of
the Cardiac Surgeons ’ Association be
cause he was nominated to it — he never
dokhma in Rajkot to retrieve the body of asked for it or tried for it.” Fond of lis-
his father which he had then buried in the
ground outside. In a letter to the Parsi
Press he had explained; “I had occasion the family.
to visit Rajkot to pay my last homage to
my father who died on January 18, 1974.
Along with the volunteers, my brother,
Dr Homi, and I entered the dokhma to
tening to classical music, he used to play
the violin in his younger days, informs
An earlier stroke, a year ago, had left
Dastur with one arm impaired, “but he
could do more with one hand than what
most surgeons could do with two, ” said
Udwadia, adding, “Long hours and stress
of work took a toll of his health. ” It was
at the end of his working day at the
Northcote that Dastur realized that a
second cerebral stroke was approaching
and called for help, says Nurgish. He
asked for a drink of Horlicks but before it
could reach him, he had slipped into
coma. He was shifted to the Breach
“In view of this state of affairs, after
24 hours I decided along with my brother
to remove the remains of my dead father
from the dokhma. When we went inside
the dokhma we found my father ’s body Candy where he passed away without
covering consciousness.
Dastur is survived by his wife Nur-
re-
was lying untouched by the vultures. We
therfore took him out again and buried
him just outside the dokhma (Parsiana, gish, daughters Sanober Ragina, Niloofer
1 aiA\ ” Balsara and Firuzan Patel, and five
Dastur ’s critics had labelled him an grandchildren.
J
A
40 Parsiana September 1992
I
◆ ◆ ◆
From the archive
