Complete Issue
Dec 1982
r
I
December 1982 Price Rs. 5
Pdm
I
I
I
e
Mira INDIA J 325 Mira INDIA : 325
Mira INDIA ; 325 : 325
«
2
Mira INDIA : Kira INDIA J 325
• -flTn 50 «r^ i933>iH2
* SOYEAtSO^ClVIL AVIATION
X 4T7T7 ^60 0^ 1832 IM2
• dO YEANS O* CIVIL AVIATION
4 WT7T7 ftur.TW 80 1932-1993
* 50 YURS OP CIVIL AVIATION
* -TTJIV ^4r44^suae2
« 50 rCARS or CIVIL AVIATION
X HTIT-? SO 8^ I932-I982
* 90 YEARS OF Civil AVIATION
325 wn?l INDIA • 325
-rrnv f^uMH so aM >932 1982
50 vTAAS OF Civil Aviation
Mlla INDIA • 325
I
Mna INDIA i
• 41117 i^WI44 50 a4 (932'1997
* 50 YEARS OF CIVIL AVIATION
I
Mira INDIA • 325
i NT7T7 ih 50 rrf 1G3J1982
• SO YEARS OFCIVIL AVIATION
I
MIHINWA J 325 wna INDIA ; Mira INDIA
a 4IJT7 fil-lUH ^50 Id33 >9B2
* 50 YEAAS OT CIVIL AVIATION
* STJR.ftuTlTW 50 rt 1932-1982 ' « 41JT7 fiwi44 5U ai 19 i2-iVH?
• 50 YEARS OF Civil AVIATION * 80 YEARSOF CIVIL AVIATION
Hira iNDi^ J 325
Mira INDIA J 325 : 325 Mira INDIA « Mira INDIA •
-ifyr7 ftxir«4^S0®^ i932-i9e2
SO YEARS OF CIVIL AVIATION
« HTTTT 14144 50 1932 1982
* 90 YEARS OF CIVIL AVIATION
• lUlV fdHMH MJ IM^Z-HJh?
* 90 YEARS OF CIVIL AVIATION
X 41713 I^WI44^80a4 1932*1992
A 50 YEARS OF CIVIL AVIATION
325 )4r7M INDIA « 225
Mira INDIA J 325
1
-irJH f4Ml44 80 1932-1982 X '’T7T7 (^4144 >5 50 1932 1982
90 YEARSOF CIVIL AVIATION < 90 YEARS OF CIVIL AVIATION
325
Mira INDIA ' 325
t
Miia INDIA ;
A 9
• JTT7T7 f^inww 50 a4 193 2-1982
• so YEARS OF CIVIL AVIATION
Mira INDIA J 325 Mira INDIA • 325
I
h"
Mira INDIA •
X 4T7r? 50 1932-1982 X 4PT7 %WTXW ^90 0^ 1932-198.'
• 80 YEARS OF CIVIL AVIATION • 80 YEARS OF CIVIL AVIATION
X dfJN SO 1932*1982
• 80 YEARS OF CIVIL AVIATION
Mira INDIA J 325
Mira INDIA J 325
1
Mira INDIA *
I
^VK&Vll
smT7 ftwraa Sisoaif i»3J-'»8s J aivTi I^uivra i so s4 1935-1962 X anr? fKuTvra i 50 a* 1932-1982
Bo VEAASOr CIVIL AVIATION • BO YiAAS OF CIVIL AVIATION * SO VCAKB OF CIVIL AVIATION
X *Tin^ fdUT*r4 80 ai I9J2*I992
• so YEARS OF CIVIL AVIATION
« SlI <3*4 I9J?-39S.'
• 50’EARS OF Civil AVIHION
325 * 325 Mira INDIA • 325 Mira INDIA : 32s Mira INDIA
..^4
Mira INDIA •
HIJ12 5(J A« 1932-1962
80 YEARS OF CIVIL AVIATION
a mn? 11^414^ 9 80 aw I933 l9a3
• 80 YEARS OF CIVIL AVIATION
X 4IJT7 fijUIWW as 50 OW 1932 1982
• 80 YEARS OF CIVIL AVIATION
Mira INDIA ;
^50fl< 19d3>l9CI>’
50 YEARS OF CIVIL AVIATION
u
X -nTr^ f^wTww 50 74 1932-1992
• so YEARS OF CIVIL AVIATION
«r-cer'j
December 1982
Volume 5 Number 6
•ii
'•i
EDITOR Jehangir R. Patel
ASSOCIATE EDITOR Abraham Mathai
ASSISTANT EDITORS Hutokshi D. Doctor,
Gouri Wagadarikar
DESIGN CONSULTANT Mini Boatwala
DESIGN ASSISTANTS Kranti Shilotri,
Yasmin Irani
MARKETING DIRECTOR Veera Patel
ADVERTISING Zarin Billimoria,
Hanita Irani
CHIEF EXECUTIVE R.P Thanavala
CIRCULATION D;B. Chinoy,
Yezdi Gandevia
MANAGEMENT Cheryl D'Penha,
Minoo Patel and Jasmine Driver
3 Readers' Forum
1 Events and Personalities
f
J
16 The Fate of the Federation
19 Tata Flies Again
20 Wings for a Nation by Russi M. Lala
24 Arphi: the sound of success by Nirmala Ferrao
28 A matter of death...and life
32 The Creative Chef by Hutokshi D. Doctor
34 Clippings and Cuttings
36 Tete-a-tete with Dastur by Gurudev Sharan
38 The LWePPf Pastur Dhalla - XXX
Cover: J.R.D. Tata commemorative stamp to mark
50 years of Indian civiT aviation.
Parsiana is published by Jehangir R. Patel at c/o H.L. Rochat Navsari Chamlwrs,
ground floor, 39 A.K. Nayak Marg, Fort, Bombay 400 001, printed by him at Jyoti
InduWiesv 324 A to Z Industrial Estate, G. Kadafn Marg, Bombay ^^0^013 and
phototypeset at . .....—,----------- - ------------- - „ . Ann
editorial and business correspondence to Parsiana, G.P.O. Box.892, Bombay 400
001. Phone: 268730.
Anhddf inland subscription: Rs 30 for one year (1.2 issues); Rs 55 for two years (24
issues); Foreign subscription rates; Seamail Rs 60 for one year, Rs 110 for tvyo years,
ground floor, 39 A.K. Nayak Marg, Fort, Bombay 400 001, printed by him at Jyoti
” _____- . ... iz^-1____znn ni*4 and
Decora Printers, Bombay 400 009. All rights reserved Address all .
I
¦
AirmaiLJts 120 for one year, Rs 215 for two years.
For U.S. personal cheques add $2 to cover bank charges. For Indian upcountry cheques
add Rs 3 for bank charges. Cheques and drafts are tb be cfrawn in favour of Parsiana.
Single copy price Rs 5 and Re 1. All rates subject to change in postal rates.
add Rs 3 for bank charges. Cheques and drafts are tb be cfrawn in favour of Parsiana. ’1'
1T?
¦’*'
r
tREADERS’ FORUM
,1,
llUU'HM,, ,,
IIIHIiO.i, ¦¦ ¦ „ , .
I
I
I
f
IB
»»•ft•••
• » ! ' I »*»M,
itiliiiMm.
1 i » > J .
I'UJ
.1 hi
5
»**
iiiiji
1*1
I*
SB
k**»’>*
3
I
I
enjoying an Indian haven — the Parsis, kameez, pagri and d^patta look, almost
and a still smaller group living in Iran — exactly, like any Parthian, Saka,
the Iranis, we shall confine ourselves Kushan or Sassanian of the past. The
mostly to Iranian dresses.
Cap, turban, tunic, trousers, robe.
Gandhara and other akin sculptures and
coins are the best proofs. Moreover,
gown*, girdle, waistband and shoes have with the exception of the sari and chinoy
been and are still worn by Iranians, khokho, most of the Parsi dresses—the
They are the creation of hard-working, sudreh, kusti, jama, pichori, dagla,
fast-riding; people, living on the rough dagli, jabla, lenga and shawl — have to
terrain of the Iranian Plateau and this day their likes and prototypes in
J beyond, with four distinct seasons. The Iran, Afghanistan and the Central Asian
fact is attested by archaeological exca- republics,
vations. The change over the last three
: I may go further and state, on the
thousand years is, in general terms, neg- strength of my studies in ethnology, that
ligible.
The felt cap in various shapes — skull.
Asho Zarathushtra, an eastern Iranian,
wore clothes similar to those presently
oblong, pointed, folded, phenta-like worn by a man in eastern Iran and west-
with a shawl around it; the turban in
various colours — haphazardly tied or ,
artistically wound in Parsi, Khoja, turban, kameez, shalwar and shawl —
Bohra, Rajput and other styles; the all in snow white — and his flowing
tunic with its different names — kurta,
kamiz, jama, pairahan; the trousers,
most probably an Iranian invention for
easy riding, known as payjama, shalwar,
lenga, gharara, breeches
baggy; and shoes of leather and wool —
high, low, laced, strapped — are docu-
ern Afghanistan. A Muslim mulla, par
ticularly of the sunnite sect, with his
Readers' views are welcome on any
subject of interest to the community
and should be sent to the Editor,
Readers' Forum, Parsiana, G.P.O.
Box 892, Bombay 400 001. Letters are
subject to editing for reasons of space
and clarity.
beard, would look more like Asho
Zarathushtra in dress and feature than a
Parsi dastur with his ‘Indianized’ robes
of the Moghul-Rajput style. The reason
is simple. Early Islam did not have a
prescribed dress for its theologians
and mobeds, converted to Islam, kept
mented from the Achaemenian period their dress. And now, the changes
down to the present.
How much impact the early Vedic
dresses had on Iranian costumes, 1 am
not competent to assess. But the the Indian mobeds completely forget the
unstitched cloth
pagri — has quite evidently evolved consider their modern versions, mostly
throughoutthe ages into one of the most worn by Muslims, as of Muslim origin,
graceful dresses of our times. Moreover, Even the much-disputed figure of the
the Indians, with their vast and unlim- Taq-i-Bustan relief in Iran, from which
ited potential, have added great variety we have derived different versions of the
to the dresses brought by the incoming picture of Asho Zarathushtra, hasatyp-
Iranians. ical shalwar beneath a typical kameez.
The Parsi dress of just fifty years ago. The other two figures — Ardeshir Baba-
is not then of Muslim origin. In fact.
tight or
brought about by time and distance —
over a thousand years and more than
three thousand kilometres — have made
the sari, dhoti and dresses donned by their ancestors and to
Are These Parsis? , .. _
With reference to the interesting short is not then of Muslim origin. In fact, kan and a higher authority — wear the
article ‘Are These Parsis?’ by Shiraz history proves that some of the elite same. Modern painters have very clev-
Nanporia, (Parsiana, March 1982) may Arabs who brought Islam to Iran wore erly changed the shalwar into a flowing
I add a general note, rather long, which the Iranian turban, kameez and shal- Chinese robe ! But the turban still
could prove of some help to those scho- war. The reason was obvious. Sur- reveals the long tail. Take a closer look
lars who would shed light on the subject, rounded by the scantily dressed at the early drawings in the K.R. Cama
Dresses are created and evolved much Byzantine Romans, Greeks, Egyptians Oriental Institute’s Journal issues; you
more by socio-climatic environments and loin-clothed Africans, the neigh- will witness what 1 state.
than by cults or religions. In fact, it is bouring Persian dress was much more Here let me clarify a possible miscon-
social customs, including superstitions,
that take deep root and grow into reli- the Yemenite tribesmen. The dress of necessarily inventions of the Aryans,
gious tenets. ' the Muslims of the Iranian Plateau and What we see from Median and Achae-
But, since the Zoroastrian religion, the Indian sub-continent today, is that menian reliefs and carvings is that only
originally founded to become a univer- of the pre-lslamic eras. When Islam the Iranian nations, among all others of
sal order aimed at establishing a world
brotherhood with no bars of colour,
caste, race or land, has shrunk to other modes of living,
become the birth-right—rather the rite of
a s
bouring Persian dress was much more
modest and moderate. It is still worn by ception. Tunics and trousers are not
came, all that the people did was to the then civilized world, wore tunics and
change their religion, not their dress and trousers. Others are seen either in loin
cloths or long robes. The man in the
To-day the men and women of the European suit today looks much nearer
small community of Iranian origin sub-continent who put on the shalwar, to a Mede or Parthian than any of the
3
PARS I AN A: DECEMBER 19B2r
5 ’
L
ancient Indians, Mesopotamians, Egyp-
tians, Greeks, or Romans did. All one
has to do is to supply the Median, Par- |HbH
thian or any other Iranian with buttons,
a gift from Europe, and see him in mod-
ern dress ! The same is true of womens’
dress. One has only to shorten the
clothes to expose more of their body !
Nothing more. That again does not HH
mean that the modern suit is a direct HHH
descendent of the Iranian dress. It has
had its natural development through
the ages but does resemble its ancestor.
All the above-mentioned points need
scholastic elaboration. Fortunately, ,
both in Iran and India, as well ascertain
Western countries, scholars have done
extensive research on dress and food
through the ages. I have, in my humble
capacity, studied them both and have
tried to coordinate the two. The result is
r
‘rf’J
The Planners L to R:
J.N. Tata, the founder,
R.D. Tata (J.R.D. Tata’s
father). Sir Ratan Tata
(standing) and
Sir-Dorab Tata.
•i
-f
1
f *
Bi
“An Indian Nabob with his son.”
Turhaned Times However, now in my old age, after
From the photos of the late Jamsetjee reading the article I know that we had
Nusserwanji Tata (Parsiana August been so fortunate in being able to
1982), 1 U'as pleasantly surprised to see patronize a bakery of such historical
that even at home he wore the black origin. Thank you Mr. Dotiwala and
velvet cap and his sons and his cousin thanks to Parsiana for giving such an
followed this tradition. J.R.D. Tata’s interesting article.
father, R.D. Tata, is shown with a Parsi
cap on his head even though he had
married a French lady and was sup
posed to be modern.
The Parsi religion/custom ordains
that the head must be covered and who Culture of Physiques,” Parsiana, June
knows that such a method of covering 1982). In the year 1936 Tehmurasp and I
the head may be one of the causes of the published a monthly magazine named
Health and Physical Power. We started
the magazine, with the help of my friend,
the late R.P. Elavia, son of PestonjiEla-
via — proprietor of Appeal Printing
Press, Meadow Street, Fort. The illus
trated magazine was sold for “annas
FRENY DALAL
The Culture of Physiques ”
1 am a close associate of Tehmurasp H.
Sarkari (“Tehmurasp Sarkari and the
rise in prosperity of Parsees upto
approximately 1920. The rich Parsees
did not see anything wrong in going
about with a turban and a turban was
respected during those days.
The downfall of the Parsees came
after the turban and the cap gradually four.” The late Bernard Macfaddon of
the U.S.A., known as “the father of
physical culture,” gave us full right to
reprint from his magazine and also from
the Encyclopedia of Physical Culture.
1 used to excel in weight-lifting while
Sarkari used to perform extraordinary
feats of strength, breaking iron chains
around the biceps and chest and.also by
hand, tearing three packs of playing
During those far-off childhood days cards and the telephone directory and
u-j permitting a car to pass over his chest.
His display of muscle control was truly
yet to be studied further, revised and
edited before giving it final shape.
Meanwhile, let us conclude that the failed to appear on the heads of Parsees.
dresses we all wear have evolved out of khorshed m. shroff
the mingling and commingling of var- .
ious people, all along undergoing “History in the Baking ”
changes to suit the progressing age. It was so interesting to read the article
Clothes worn by a certain com'ihunity in “History in the Baking” by J.P. Doti-
a certain age have been abandoned in wala in Parsiana, May 1982. The names
another age, only to be adopted by ‘Dutch Garden’and‘Dutch Road’rang
, another group of people. The process of a bell in my memory.
take, give, abandon and adopt has been P
going on ill along. This is how the fast- when the evening shades were falling on
changing fashions have come into the river Tapi, our carriage wended its
vogue. I would, therefore; suggest that way past the Dutch Garden and on the, magnificent,
to know whether those pictures — or the Dutch Road till we stopped at a
others—are of the Parsis or not, one small low-roofed bakery. And what
should have a broader outlook in freshly baked toddy loaf and‘Farmasu’
his/her judgement. .biscuits we could buy there ! We knew it
B. B. RouDBARi ^as ‘Faramji’s’, the oldest bakery of
IxJs Angeles, U..S.A Surat.
U nfortunately within two years we
were compelled to discontinue the mag
azine as the Second World War was in
full swing and there was a shortage of
paper etc. and we had no assistance.
AsB. BHIWANDIWALA
¦^t^^PARSIANA: DECEMBER 1982
s
"1
¦J
¦I
¦ ‘..ii
I
Events and
Personalities
Justice Madon
Madon was part-time professor of law cern to the Trustees of the Navsari
at the Government Law College for Atashbehram and Vadi Dar-e-Meher,
three years, and is also the author of who have appealed to “Charitably dis-
Principles and Practice of the Sales- posed and Religious minded Zoroastri-
Tax. He was appointed as a judge in.the ans and Trustees of Parsi Religious
'— T.- . r-—* o——1— r-i—” jQ donate funds and
augment the resources of the Trust so as
Madon’s wife. Dr. Khorshed D.P. to enable them in turn, to help the Boy-
\
Noted jurist Dinshah Pirosha Madon,
who began his career as an advocate 38
years ago, took over as Chief Justice of Bombay High Court in September Charity Trusts,
the Bombay High Court from Sep- 1967. < „
tember 1 this year. He had been 1--------- ---- , — ------------
appointed the Acting Chief Justice from Madon, also an advocate of the wala mobeds.
August 11, 1982. Supreme Court and the Bombay High Six months ago, both the Atashbeh-
Madon, who has practised in the var
ious courts in India and abroad, was „ _
appointed as a one-man commission of and the managing director of Progres- ago, were served by only two trained
enquiry to study the “communal distur- sive Corporation, publishers and book- Boywala mobeds. “This was mainly due
bances which took place in Bhiwandi sellers. With a Ph.D. in law from the to the fact that this old, holy and strenu-
and other places in the State of Maha
rashtra in May 1970 and the organisa
Supreme Court and the Bombay High
Court, is the principal of Davar’s Col- ram in Navsari, one of eight in India,
lege of Commerce and Management and the agiary, established 840 years
8
r
I
(
Bombay University, Khorshed Madpn ous profession of mobeds is unable to
has written and edited several books on ensure a reasonably good and steady
income,” note the Trustees in their
appeal. Traditionally, Boywala mobeds
were entitled only to the insufficient
‘Chamach’ offerings of devotees.
The Trustees have already employed
additional mobeds for the Atashbehram
and agiary and propose to pay them a
minimum monthly income of Rs 1,500,
approximately.
“Years back,” notes the appeal, “our
ancestors had created a small fund
solely for amelioration of Bhagarya
Mobeds. This Fund has now been incor
porated in our present Trust and the
Trustees have already started paying
subsidy to our Boywala Mobeds. How
ever, the corpus of this Fund is very
small and it has become absolutely
essential to augment it by inviting dona
tions.” The target for this scheme has
been fixed at Rs five lakhs, the money to
be utilised not only for the payment of
monthly subsidies, but also of retirement
benefits like gratuity, and provident
funds to deserving mobeds or their
widows.
“The survival of our Community
depends upon the preservation of our
Religious Institutions, and without
good and trained Mobeds those Institu
tions cannot be preserved,” notes the
appeal.
“It is the dpty of every Parsi to con
tribute whatever he or she can for the
7
J
r
a
K ’ ....
I
-i
I
Madon (right) being sworn in by Governer Latif.
tions and groups responsible for them.” law and management, and is profession-
His subsequent. report, notes the bio- ally affiliated to several institutions in
data,“including all the recommendations India and abroad,
made were accepted in toto by the
Government.”
A student of Elphinstone College,
Madon graduated in English Literature
from Bombay University and secured a
first class in the LL.B, examinations,
winning several prizes and scholarships Improvement of the low economic sta
in the course of his academic career, tus of Boywala Mobeds is of vital con-
Benefactors for
Boywalas
PARSIANA: DECEMBER 1982¦1
i
dwindling... the demand for housing is
increasing,” observes the report.
The idea that charities are not gov
erned by laws concerning construction report states are becoming increasingly hostages {Gujarat Samachar), in which
is erroneous. The report states'explicitly appreciative of the Parsi heritage and he claims “an accuracy of 80 per cent.”
“We Daruwallas have been textile
tical training in science and engineering
are also given.
For the younger generation, who the Weekly) and the release of the American
1
si.;
J*
.r
j
,1
IF''''
¦¦
P
j
I '•
i|
ji
eral important events including the
death of Sanjay Gandhi {Illustrated
the Zoroastrian religion, “Arrange
ments have been made (by the SPP) to giants (in Ahmedabad),” he writes,
teach Iranian history and the Zoroas
trian religion. Dr Eruch D. Dabu has
been managing this programme since
1975 with success.”
The trustees of the over 140-year-old
SPP are, Maneck J.R. Gheyara, presi- of English for 27 years, has also pub
dent, Dr Sam Bhacca, vice president.
only this Bejan dabbles in the occult.”
He has been authoring the Orient horo
scopes for the last seven years, selling
two lakh copies every year.
Daruwalla, who has been a professor
u
Patel, E.A. Pandol, Ms Dina R. Ghadi-
ali, the first lady trustee of the Pun-
Contractor.
Occult Dabbling
astrologer who contributes to several
national dailies and magazines, was
awarded a gold medal and thfe Jyotish
Martand degree by the Jyotirgnata
Mandal, Bombay, a registered institute
running classes in astrology.
“I worship Ganesa, am enough of a
Parsee to clown away to Kingdom
come, eat like a pig, sleep like a stone,
and am rich enough to buy the world!”
writes Daruwallh in what he describes as
“a Parsee banquet of a bio-data.” Yet he
finds the time to write “spoofs on presi
dents and catsi and actors for Indian
is erroneous. The report states explicitly , appreciative of the Parsi heritage and
that the Public Trusts Act and the ' “
Income Tax Act have to be considered
in the planning of housing schemes. In
case one floor is let out to shops, it is
considered a commercial activity and
liable to payment of income-tax, notes
the report.
The inability of the Pimchayet to
meet the high expectations of the people
has resulted in displeasure, even “bitter Burjorji N. Palia, B.S. Chacha, R.R.
criticism.” Most people are “unaware of
the legal intricacies involved in the man
agement of Punchayet funds,” and are chayet, Daver K.T. Modi and Dr M.K.
unable to understand why the lands
available with the Punchayet are not
used for housing purposes. Those
“seriously interested” are “satisfied with
the efforts made by trustees when the
matter is explained to them,” the report Bejan Daruwalla, the well-known
asserts. j ’ * ”
Regarding the help given to the i
impoverished farmers in the villages of j
south Gujarat, debts of Rs 7,500 were xtiuhuhu mv jj^uuigiiaia
paid in full. With the help of the BPP, Mandal, Bombay, a registered institute FUTldS
the SPP staff distributed grain, seeds running classes in astrology.
and fertilizers to the farmers. “Debts of “I worship Ganesa, am enough of a The need for self-reliance is being
Rs 1,68,754.90 involving 48 families Parsee to clown away to Kingdom stressed by the six-year old, 220 member
were settled and 587 persons (in 28 vil- come, eat like a pig, sleep like a stone, Borivli and Suburban Zoroastrian
lages) received grain worth Rs 80,885.39,” and am rich enough to buy the world! ” Association.
notes the report. writes Daruwalla in what he describes as “We are still in a very primitive stage,” i
The SPP runs two orphanages and “a Parsee banquet of a bio-data.” Yet he notes the editorial-cum-letter by the
three schools. Apart from providing free finds the time to write “spoofs on presi- association’s honorary secretary, P. R. |
lunches and bus facilities, the SPP also dents and catsi and actors for Indian Mulla in the August newsletter. “We do j
provides scholarships to outstanding Express and dPilmfare.”and to "predict not have any premises of our Own... for ]
students. Foreign scholarships for prac- correctly, in the name of Ganesa” sev- holding meetings... storing files” or for a '
library.
The February newsletter also noted
that though “the (Parsi) population in
the suburbs, particularly Borivli, has '
shown an upward trend... our funds are
showing a downward trend. The ratio .
and proportion between members and
jnds is not well-balanced.’^
The association planned to launch an
old newspaper collection drive. “One J
Sunday in a month... our committee
members have volunteered to go house- -
to-house collecting papers.”
In the annual report for 1981, Mulla '
notes, “The most outstanding feature
for the year 1981 was the benevolent
gesture shown towards us by The Jam-
setjee Nesserwanji Petit Reading Room
and Library, Dadar. Four hundred
books were given away gratis for our
Library by the chairman Mr. Firoze K.
Sholapurwala. We express our utmost
feelings of gratitude towards the chair
man, the honorary secretary and the
PARSIANA DECEMBER 1982
lished three collections of poetry. His
poems he writes, find him “very serious,
a poet of the graveyard, taut, polishing
every word to diamond brilliance.
Daruwalla, who believes that poetry is
“a cry; Torture unlimited; Torment of
birth,” has been to the Phillipines at the
invitation of the World Congress of ’
Poets.
“Ganesa is my ruling deity but I do
wear a sadra and kusti and pay my hom
age to Zoroaster,” he writes. “All reli
gions are respected.”
correctly, in the name of Ganesa” sev-
Bejan (left) receiving award
10
-i
Ju’
i
office bearers of the Petit Library.” The
association owes thanks “to Mrs.
Roshan A. Chhoi who has stored these
books in her flat, till the Association is
able to get premises of its own.”
The new governing body of the asso
ciation, elected on January 23 to serve
for three years, comprises: Ms D.H.
Minocher, president, Ms S.A. Cama,
vice-president, P.R. Mulla, honorary
secretary, D.F. Variava and Ms R.A.
Chhoi, joint honorary secretaries, N.G.
Paghdiwalla, treasurer, R.N. Sethna,
Ms D.D. Patel, Ms F.R. Siganporia,
M.S. Painter, B.R. Umrigar, Ms T.T.
Govadia, S.P^ Pavri, K.R. Amrolia and
M.E. Wadia.
Tower Model
Removed
The Prince of Wales Museum no longer I
exhibits the model displaying the lay- |
out of the Tower of Silence. “No reason I
has been given for this,” notes Bachi I
Bharucha, in a letter to the Bombay I
afternoon daily MID-DA Y on September |
28, although a tourist guide feels “the I
model was very helpful for tourists who I
were keen to know of the unusual mode I
of disposal of the Parsi dead. Could the |
authorities give reasons for the removal
of the model?” |
When asked about the mysterious dis- I
appearance of the model. Museum
authorities, while acknowledging its
removal, stated that the model was Are these Paisis ? Clothes and customs may change, lifestyles may differ but the
being held in reserve, along with several answer is stilh Yes. They are Astad Deboo, maestro of modern dance and Farida
other items, and that it would be rein- Pedder (inset) the well-known stage personality, performing at the Jazz-M’Tazz, a
stated as an exhibit at their discretion.
L
f
r
r *
new wave and modern jazz show held recently at Bombay’s exclusive discotheque,
Studio 29. The show was sponsored by Gentlemen magazine, the Gentlemen’s
Fashion Quarterly and the makers of Hamburg Pilsner beer. Photographs courtesy
Sohrab Daver and Gentlemen.
Blood Plea
An appeal to community members to
register themselves in the Zoroastrian group of donors will be arranged by the and Member of Parliament, at a public
meeting in New Delhi on September 8,
Zoroastrians willing to “light up a life his 22nd death anniversary.
_______ -_______ -• Gandhi would always raise the right
Venerable
Statesman
Blood Donors Directory has been Youth Wing.
issued by the Youth Wing of the Com- 7
mittee for Electoral Rights. The Direc- of (their) brethren” should send in their
tory is being compiled for emergency name, age, address, phone number and issues at the right time in Parliament,
use ijn Parsi hospitals. blood group, if possible, to Kersi P. and would not hesitate to expose his
“The compilation process is on and Gazdar, 7/2, Rustom Baug, Victoria closest friends should the need arise. He
even before its compilation we have Road, Byculla, Bombay 400 027. exposed the Mundra case knowing that
started receiving many requests from it would affect T.T. Krishnamachari, a
various quarters for blood require- close cabinet colleague 6f Nehru, said P.
ments... This calls for the immediate Shiv Shankar, union minister for petro
need to expand the list of donors... but leum, coal and energy, and the chief
so far the achievement has fallen short cnzi ziM occasion.
of the demand, notes the Youth Wing’s liiafl Gandhi would be remembered as a
honorary general secretary, K^rsi Gaz- personality in his own right, and not as
Glowing tributes were paid to the the son-in-law of Nehru or the husband
A simple test to determine the blood memory of Feroze Gandhi, statesman of Indira Gandhi, said Shanker.
PARSIANA: DECEMBER 1982
11f".
I
constant burning of the Holy Fires and 2,000 mobile cinemas,” notes a write-up,
for preserving the invaluable and effec
tive heritage of Yasna cerernonies. No
amount for this purpose will be consi
dered either too small or too large.”
Crossed and order cheques or
demand drafts drawn in favour of the
Navsari Atashbehram and Vadi Dar-e-
Meher Trust may be forwarded to either
Vada Dasturji Meherjirana K. Dastur
Meherjirana, Dastur Street, Mota
Falia, Navsari 396 445, or to Dasturji
Dr. Firoz M. Kotwal, 598-C A.H.
Wadia Building, Sir J. Shankerseth
Road, Bombay 40() 002.
The trustees of the Navsari Atashbeh
ram and Vadi Dar-e-Meher Trust are:
Meherjirana Dastur Kaikobad Meherji- student of the Central School of Arts
rana, Manekji Tehmurasp Desai, Firoz and Crafts, London, Wadia launched
Meherji Kotwal, Jamshedji Pestonji Interpub in 1964, notes her bio-data.
Desai, Dosabhai Hormusji Desai, Sheisaguestlectureratvariousinstitu- '
Noshir Dinshaji Kotwal, Kaikhushru tions including the Jamnalal Bajaj Insti-
Navroji Dastur Meherjirana. tute of Management Studies Bombay, i
has attended several national and inter- i
national conferences, and was the chair- f
person of the Delegate Promotion Doctor : Influence of Zoroastrianism
Committee of the 13th Asian Advertis
ing Congress. Ms Wadia has served on Vedic Astronomy.” In 1981, he passed
his M.A. in Ancient and Middle Iranian
ment Panel of the Printing Industry set languages (Avesta, Pahlavi dialects and
up by the Government of India, and has old Roman), after a six-year study,
won several awards for creativity.
B. S. Balsara and Ms Roda Mehta are _
among the other members of MEMOS,
besides Julian Almeida, S.K. Chawla
V. V. Menon, M. C. Nair and H. N. “Since the past few years we face great
Nagaraju. difficulties in the publication of trust
fund accounts,” observes the report
J. , , preceding the Surat Parsi Punchayet
Iranian Inesis trust fund accounts. “Printing presses
are prepared to accept straight printing
A doctoral thesis on Ancient and Middle jobs but are reluctant to accept large
Iranian languages is being undertaken jobs involving figures (tables etc.). A
. by Sam N. Doctor at the prestigious leading charitable trust in Bombay hav-
.! University of California in Berkeley. In
I addition he is researching ‘The influence
I of Zoroastrianism on Inter-Testamental printed in Surat.”
I Judaism and origins of Christianity in
? the light of the Dead Sea Scrolls.’
Over the past two decades. Doctor
while MEMOS have a checking service has, according to his bio-data, studied
at 800 cinema houses, “which however, various aspects of Comparative Reli-
account for 60 per cent of the expend!- gion, covering “diverse fields like
ture on screening ad films.” Mithraism, Hellenistic Gnosticism,
Ms Wadia “strongly feels that far Judaism, Christianity, archaeology and '
more positive steps are to be taken to
ensure an accurate and consistent check
on whether ad films are being screened
according to schedule.”
“There should be a control qh the
number of ad films per feature,” says Ms
Wadia, “so that a digestible number of
messages is served at a time to the
audience.”
A diploma holder from the Sir J. J.
School of Applied Art Bombay, and a
-s
Dosabhai Hormusji Desai,
F
I
Monitoring Head
I he new head of the Media Monitoring
Services, an organisation which several committees like the Develop-
attempts to exercise control over the
number of commercials screened per
Surat Report
1
1
1
•A.-
•^^4
J
r'B
ing their own press approached us to
enquire if their accounts could be
The cost of printing is also “prohibi
tive” notes the report; and as the old
Doctor, a teacher at the M.F. Cama letterpress technology becomes obso
lete, the costs will continue to rise when
the trusts have to switch over to the
more efficient but also the considerably
more expensive offset processes.
Thus it is that as the demand for
“My field has very few students, accountability increases, trusts are find-
_ , ing it difficult to always meet with the
Athornan Institute at Andheri, Bombay,
a Zoroastrian seminary-cum-schoot
which imparts religious and academic
instruction to aspiring Zoroastrian pri-
Wadia — Checking commercials ests, left for the-U.S.A, recently.
*’<7 aiMO VV/1 J AVW JlUUVlllJ,
r feature film, is the noted advertising per- though my professor, Martin Schwartz,
‘ sonality, Nargis V. Wadia. is a remarkable linguist, a pupil of the community’s requirements.
AT A J . . ..7 r, „ . Housing is as much a problem in
Surat as anywhere else. Even though
there are less than 3,250 Parsis in Surat,
there is an “acute housing problem.”
Paradoxically, “even though the
number of persons in the community is
I
•l«i
-3^
sonality, Nargis V. Wadia.
A former president of the Advertising famous Iranist, the late W.B. Henning,
Agencies Association of India, Ms and a former professor at Columbia,
Wadia is the managing director of Inter New York. The university (Berkeley) is
Publicity, one of the leading Bombay one of the biggest, and houses six mil
based advertising agencies. lion books, catering to 30,000 students,”
“India has 7,500 cinema houses and he writes.
PARSIANA: DECEMBER 1982
9
J*
dwindling .. the demand for housing is tical training in science and engineering eral important events including the
increasing,” observes the report. are also given. death of Sanjay Gandhi\ illustrated
The idea that charities are not gov- . For the younger generation, who the Weekly) and the release of the American
erned bv laws concerning construction report states are becoming increasingly hostages {Gujarat Samachar), in which
¦ • r., Vhe claims “an accuracy of 80 per cent.
the Zoroastrian religi&n, “Arrange- “We Daruwallas have been textile
ments have been made (by the SPP) to giants (iit^Ahmedabad), he writes,
teach Iranian history and the Zoroas
trian religion. Dr Eruch D. Dabu has
been managing this programme since
1975 with success.”
The trustees of the over 140-year-old
SPP are, Maneck J.R. Gheyara, presi-
tical training in science and engineering
are also given.
For the younger generation, who the
j^-'?
M’
“only this Bejan dabbles in the occult.”
He has been authoring the Orient horo
scopes for the last seven years, selling
two lakh copies every year.
Daruwalla, who has been a professor
of English for 27 years, has also pub-
Burjorji N. Palia, B.S. Chacha, R.R.
Patel, E.A. Pandol, Ms Dina R. Ghadi-
ali, the first lady trustee of the Pun-
chayet, Daver K.T. Modi and Dr M.K.
Contractor.
is erroneous. The report states explicitly appreciative of the Parsi heritage and
that the Public Trusts Act and the the Zoroastrian religi&n, “Arrange-
Income Tax Act have to be considered
in the planning of housing schemes. In
case one floor is let out to shops, it is
considered a commercial activity and
liable to payment of income-tax, notes
the report.
The inability of the P'unchayet to -------- - ---- r - . .
meet the high expectations of the people dent. Dr Sam Bhacca, vice president, lished three collections of poetry. His
has resulted in displeasure, even “bitter Burjorji N. Palia, B.S. Chacha, R.R. poems he writes, find him very serious,
criticism.” Most people are “unaware of Patel, E.A. Pandol, Ms Dina R. Ghadi- a poet of the graveyard, taut, polishing
the legal intricacies involved in the man- ali, the first lady trustee of the Pun- every word to diamond brilliance,
agement of Punchayet funds,” and are chayet, Daver K.T. Modi and Dr M.K. Daruwalla, who believes that poetry is
unable to understand why the lands Contractor. “a cry; Torture unlimited; Torment of
available with the Punchayet are not - birth,” has been to the Philhpines at the
used for housing purposes. Those , I invitation of the World Congress of
“seriously interested” are “satisfied with (JCCUlt UdUUllHR , .. . ..
the efforts made by trustees when the is my ruling deity but I do
matter is explained to them,” the report Bejan Daruwalla, the well-known wearasadraandkustiandpay my hom-
• ’ ------------1 age to Zoroaster,” he writes. All reli
gions are respected.”
Occult Dabbling
Bejan Daruwalla, the well-known
asserts astrologer who contributes to several
Regarding the help given to the national dailies and magazines, was
impoverished farmers in the villages of awarded a gold medal and thb Jyotish
south Gujarat, debts of Rs 7,500 were '* ’
paid in full. With the help of the BPP,
the SPP staff distributed grain, seeds
and fertilizers to the farmers. “Debts of
Rs 1,68,754.90 involving 48 families
were settled and 587 persons (in 28 vil
lages) received grain worth Rs 80,885.39,”
notes the report.
The SPP runs two orphanages and
three schools. Apart from providing free finds the time to write “spoofs on presi-
lunches and bus facilities, the SPP also
provides scholarships to outstanding
students. Foreign scholarships for prac-
Bejan (left) receiving award
Regarding the help given to the
Martand degree by the Jyotirgnata
Mandal, Bombay, a registered institute
running classes in astrology.
“I worship Ganesa, am enough of a
Parsee to clown away to Kingdom
come, eat like a pig, sleep like a stone,
and am rich enough to buy the world !”
writes Daruwallti in what he describes as
“a Parsee banquet of a bio-data.” Yet he
Finding Funds
The need for self-reliance is being
stressed by the six-year old, 220 member
Borivli and Suburban Zoroastrian
Association.
“We are still in a very primitive stage,”
notes the editorial-cum-letter by the
association’s honorary secretary, P. R.
Mulla in the August newsletter. “We do
I
r
dents and cats^: and actors for Indian
Express and ^ilmfare,"and to “predict not have any premises of our own... for
correctly, in the name of Ganesa” sev- holding meetings... storing files” or for a
10
4
S?1
^;’
p
L
Ss£
>
holding meetings... storing files”orfor a
library.
The February newsletter also noted
that though “the (Parsi) population in
the suburbs, particularly Borivli, has
shown an upward trend... our funds are
showing a downward trend. The ratio
and proportion between members and
jnds is not well-balanced."
The association planned to launch an
old newspaper collection drive. “One
Sunday in a month... our committee
members have volunteered to go-house-
to-house collecting papers.”
In the annual report for 1981, Mulla
notes, “The most outstanding feature
for the year 1981 was the benevolent
gesture shown towards us by The Jam-
si setjee Nesserwanji Petit Reading Room
I and Library, Dadar. Four hundred
I books were given away gratis for out
I Library by the chairman Mr. Firoze K
I Sholapurwala. We express our utmost
I feelings of gratitude towards the chair
I man, the honorary secretary and the
PARSIANA DECEMBER 198:'5
I
Educational Meet
Limathwalla feels, is to conduct many
similar YEP’s. “By wondering whether
to allow inter-caste marriages or not
The five-week-long tour that commen- strongly prevailing are conversion and
ced on September 2 included visits to inter-caste marriages.” The answer,
Chicago, New York, Los Angeles,
Distinguished educationist and psychol- Washington and Toronto, in coopera-
ogist. Dr. Mehroo Bengalee, contrib- tion with the local Zoroastrian organi-
uted a paper on ‘The role of the sations. The 11 -member group was (the parents) are showing a passive
university in integrating international accommodated in Parsi households in acceptance of the problem. They should
students on the campus’at the interna- these cities. - provide enough opportunities to enable
tional conference of the World Educa- Zoroastrians in America are Parsis as
tional Fellowship at Seoul, S.Korea, in well as Iranis and call themselves ‘Amer-
August, according to press reports.
Bengalee’s recent trip abroad was one Youth Group met were Americans
of several such in the past, and besides who had “still not outgrown the influ
ence of Parsis,” said Limathwalla, in an Yearly Report
interview with Ms Merzin Mistry. He
expects the differences to be predomi
nant in future generations, mainly a dif
ficulty of teaching “a religion (to) a (Oct.’S 1-Sept.’82). Apart from the
generation which may not even have exchange programme, painting the
seen its place of worship.” The Zoroas
trians of Toronto and Chicago, among
others, “have in the past invited scholars
of the Zoroastrian religion to speak to
and educate their children about
Zoroastrianism,” he added.
Toronto has a “friendly, almost Bom-
bay-like Parsi atmosphere” and the
unity of the Toronto Youth Organisa- dead,”a trip to the historic Barot Moun
tion, which independently hosted their
stay in the city, is exemplary, remarked
Limathwalla.
Bombay’s youth wing is “willing (and) the J.J. Hospital in an attempt to
tentatively looking forward to hosting a improve the condition of the patients,
youth group from Toronto next year,” figured in the list. An important activity
the Toronto Youth Organisation having is the compilation of a Zoroastrian
offered to sponsor one student, he
the World Education Fellowship and added,
the International Council of Psycholo
gists, she is professionally affiliated to
several educational and psychological Statue of DadabhaiNaoroji at Bombay’s Flora Fountain garlanded on the occasion
organisations in India and abroad.
Currently Professor of Psychology at Dadahhai Naoroji Trust, who garlanded the statue, and to his right are Mr. B.K.
St. Xavier’s Institute of Education, Boman-Behram, former Mayor of Bombay and Dr. S.R. Wadia, prominent
Bombay, and a Professor for the Uni- homoeopath,
versity’s M.Ed. classes, Bengalee is the
author of 11 books on education, psy
chology and counselling.
Bengalee : Student integration
Youth Exchange
Programme
jr ’ “Their houses were situated largely in
the suburbs and we were very well
looked after. Most houses had a small
prayer corner, or a prayer room with
‘diwas’ and frames of Zoroaster,” so
stated Kersi Limathwalla,. Youth
Leader and chairman of the Committee
for Electoral Rights (G.E. R.) Youth
Wing, in his description of the recent
youth exchange tour to the U.S.A, and
Canada.
br
PARSIANA: DECEMBER 1982
these cities. '
Zoroastrians in America are Parsis as young people to choose their partners
within the community... They should
ican Zoroastrians.’ The Parsis that the provide us with direction as to how we
can maintain the sanctity of our reli
gion.”
In a ‘Yearly Progress Report’the C.E.R.
Youth Wing has listed the various activ
ities undertaken in the past year
Godavara agiary, providing medical
assistance to ailing members, presenting
a television set to the “lonely inmates” of
Parekh Dharamsalla, a visit to the
Tower of Silence to “apprise the young
members of the community of the signifi
cance of the various customs and cerem
onies performed in the disposal of the
tain near Gholvad (believed to be the
temporary sanctuary of the sacred Iran-
shah Fire) and visits to the Parsi ward of
Blood Donors Directory for which they
have requested assistance from the
As in India, the “two points of conflict members of the community.
of his 137th birthday. Seen in the picture are Mr M.R. Pai, a trustee of the•-^1
Farah’s Music
JEENA
&
COMPANY
ESTD. 1900
IATA AIR CARGO
Clearing, Forwarding
Warehousing and
Insurance Agents
J
A series of 20 lectures on western music
appreciation was due to be conducted
by the western music and film critic Ms
Farah Rustom in Bombay, in December
this year. A gold medalist Fellow of the
Trinity College of Music, London,
according to her bio-data, Ms Rustom is
the Western music and foreign film
*
BOYS’ TOWN
Public School
Nasik 2
Recognised as a Pnblic School
by the Department of Education
for Indian Merit Scholars. Excd:-
lent Climate — All-round
Education:
10, Veer Nariman Road
Fort, Bombay-1.
Cable : JUSTITIA'
Telex : 2313
Phone : 312032
1
BRANCHES:
E. Merc House
19/B, Shakespeare Sarani
(Formerly Theatre Road)
CALCUTTA-16.
Phone: 444711
'Jeena House'
50, Hanuman Road
Connaught Circus
NEW DELHI
Phone : 310821
r
t. C.14, Devtha Plaza, 1st floor
Residency Road
Bangalore-25
Phone : 564474
No. 26-26-24, 2nd floor
VIZAGAPATNAM-35
Phone : 62018
r’
.’sB*
Rustom: Music lectures
critic for Bombay’s MID-DA Yevening
newspaper.
A pioneer in the field of western music
appreciation, Rustom has delivered lec
tures on her subject all over the country,
through cultural organisations like Vai-
talik, who are sponsoring the current
lecture series.
Recently Rustom delivered several
lectures at the House of Soviet Culture;
in November she addressed the cadets at
the National Defence Academy in Pune;
she also addressed 500 young (and
“extremely handsome,” she says) semi
narians at the Divine World Seminary
in Pune. The fan mail from the cadets,
she says, is still coming in.
Rustom is a guest lecturer at the pres
tigious Film and Television Institute of
Pune. A student of Elphinstone College,
Bombay, she “qualified as an advocate
of the High Court (but) preferred to
devote her life to music,” her bio-data
notes.
Herself a concert pianist, Rustom’s
annual concerts, she notes “have
become a popular and much-looked-
forward-to event in Bombay, and an
integral part of the city’s cultural life.”
All Academic Subjects—Tech
nical Subjects: Workshop Tech
nology*, Mechanical & Electrical
Maintenance, Carpentry & Farm
ing. Training in Sdf-Govenunent
through Elected Boys’ Office
bearers. Gomes—^Physical Train
ing — Daily Assembly with
Congregational Prayen — Week
ly intensive Zoroastrian - Geeta-
Koran classes —. Excellent
Modem Kitten and Dfaib^
Room facilities — Airy Dormi
tories. Moderate Fees. Freeships
and Concessions to Deserving
Students.
Apply to —
THE MANAGING
TRUSTEE
P. N. MEHTA EDUCATION
TRUST
Cooks Building, 324 Dr. D. N. Road,
Bomtiay 400 001.
PARSIANA: DECEMBER 1982
15a
The Fate of the Federation
“The fear therefore that the Parsi
Amongst the other former anjumans
who withdrew from the Federation. Punchayet Bombay joining the Federa-
Surat, Ahmedabad and Hyderabad- tion would create a dent in our estab-
Secunderabad are in favour of rejoining lished practices, tenets and traditions is
as is Poona after some persuasion. Ban- indeed ill-founded.”
Bombay at the behest of the Bombay galore is said to have inquired aboui liie In reply to Desai’s article, Vimadalal
Parsi Punchayet and unofficial reports earlier BPP proposal to start a parallel stated in an article published in the
state that all the anjumans favoured rejo
ining the Federation subject to certain
conditions.
The Delhi Parsi Anjuman, whose
president Shiavax Nargolwala’s critical
remarks about the BPP election system
made at the Third World Zoroastrian
Congress in January 1978 sparked the
hasty withdrawal of the BPP from the
Federation, will in all probability be
represented by the Delhi Parsi Trust.
Among the other conditions for the
BPP to rejoin are reportedly, repealing able to
many of the amendments made by the i
Federation after the BPP and others right time,
left.
BPP Chairman Dr Aspi Golwalla at a
press conference held on 3 December
said the 27 November meeting was “suc-r
cessful” and there was “unanimity as far
as opinion went.” He however, refused
to elaborate as to what transpired at the
meeting until the minutes were pre
pared.
According to unofficial reports how
ever, the majority of the BPP trustees
appear in favour of rejoining the Feder
ation; these include Golwalla, Jamshed
N. Guzder, Erach Desai and Jamsheed oppose withdrawing from the Federa
tion in 1978, published articles in the
¦¦ conservative Gujarati daily The Jam-e-
Jamshed and the liberal Gujarati daily
The Bombay Samachar citing reasons
why the BPP should rejoin the Federa
tion.
“It is alleged that the Parsi Pun
chayet Bombay joining the Federation
will be the thin end of the wedge and
shall be a precursor for radical reforms
to follow...on the contrary, considering
the perponderant position which the
not'certain while Dr Nelie Noble has Parsi Punchayet Bombay has always
¦ /in
After being racked with dissent, the
beleaguered Federation of Parsi Zoroas
trian Anjumans of India appears set to
stage a comeback. A meeting of erst
while Federation members was held in
/Bombay
the behest of the Bombay galore is said to have inquired about the
body to the Federation. Nagpur has Jame, “there is no reason why the Bom-
already rejoined the Federation and has bay Parsi Punchayet should sacrifice.its
urged the BPP to do likewise. premier position and take a No.2 posi-
The first indication of a change in the tion after the Federation, if that will not
BPP’s attitude to the Federation was benefit the community any way. If the
noted shortly after Golwalla assumed Bombay Parsi Punchayet rcjoins^ the
the chairmanship when B.K. Boman-
Behram’s term expired in late 1981.
In an interview with Parsiana(March tant questions
1982) Golwalla stated, “If we can sit community are well-known...would
across the table, iron out our differences always be a thorn in the side of the
in a spirit of give-and-take, we might be Bombay Parsi Punchayet and of the
.J revive the Federation...! will community...it is a fallacy to think that,
make a move in this direction at the through the Federation, the Parsees of
India can speak with one voice.”
“During the time that the Bombay
Parsi Punchayet was a member of it, it
was found that the Federation created
more discord than accord...The Parsi
Puncha^et of Bombay can rejoin the
Federation, a man like Mr. S.D. Nar-
golwala whose views on several impor-
relating to the
revive the Federation...! will community...it is a fallacy to think that.
"The fear that the BPP
joining the Federation
would create a dent In our Federation only if the Delhi Parsi Anju-
established practices,
tenets and traditions is
indeed ill-founded."
ation; these include Golwalla, Jamshed
Erach Desai, the lone BPP trustee to
man resigns or is expelled or removed
from the Federation or decides to re
amend its Rules and Regulations so as
not to permit non-Zoroastrians to be its
members even with limitations on their
rights.”
Vimadalal’s stand was echoed in the
conservative Gujarati daily, the Jam-e~
"The Federation (must)
take stock of our assets
and funds scattered over
the distant corners of
this vast country."
"It is a fallacy to think
that, through the
Federation, the Parsees of
India can speak with
one voice."
Jamshed both editorially and in Edi
tor Adi Marzban’s ‘Personally
Speaking’ column. Marzban accused
the deliberations of the Federation, and BPP chairman Golwalla of performing
a “gigantic somersault” by agreeing to
withdraw from the Federation and sub
sequently “dancing with some of his col-
¦ _ ) a completely different
time even threatening the role of a guiding force-, the shining tune...of course^now h has beeji proved
light, the jockey in the saddle. 1
Kanga. Maneck Hodiwalla’s views are
not attended the BPP board of trus- enjoyed and would contmue to enjoy
tees meetings for several weeks; t---- ----------------------
she has also remained absent at most of its preponderant role, it is in a j^sition
the BPP public functions. Vimadalal, t--------------------
who verbally clashed with Nargolwala tion to the left or to the-right, or to
on the floor of the Congress, is the main ’ ’ ’ " «-* i._„
opponent, at one t—
to resign should the BPP rejoin.
to hold the reins, and sway the Federa
te
Adi
march ahead in a straight line, fulfilling leagues to
beyond the shadow of reasonable doubt
PARSIANA: DECEMBER 19824" f ' >¦ Jx
orthodox point of view.
While the decision to rejoin will earn
the BPP ill-will among the more
orthodox, there is littld doubt that
of the Delhi Parsi Anjuman’s liberal
outlook and the admission of non-Parsi
that with the going of (former BPP
Chairman) Mr.Boman-Behram and the
coming of Mr. Jamsheed Kanga (the spouses as members of the anjuman
¦ ¦ ¦ ¦¦¦ “ ¦ ¦ ¦ subject to certain limitations. At a meet
ing called.to galvanize support against reviving the Federation is a necessary.
‘Champion of accountability’) into the
Board and under the very pliable leader- „ _
ship of the present Chairman Dr Aspi the BPP rejoining the Federation on 30 though painful, step.- After the fiasco of
Golwalla, the Board of Trustees of the September at Sir Jivanji Mody Hall in attempting to make a united representa-
Parsi Punchayet of Bombay has Bombay, the leaders of the orthodox tion to the government on the adoption
become a fortress of “CNAC— movement including Kaikhushroo Das- bill, the need for an all-India body that
COUNTABILITY.” So many ques- can represent the community’s interest
became apparent. Coupled with it was
the realization that it is only through a
legitimate all-India organisation that
the interests of smaller pockets of
Zoroastrians throughout India can be
effectively safe-guarded. This was after
all, one of the primary reasons for first
forming a Federation.
September at Sir Jivanji Mody Hall in
Bombay, the leaders of the orthodox
movement including Kaikhushroo Das-
"As we opted for total
exemption from the
adoption bill so also we
want total exemption from
the Federation."
toor, Adi Doctor, Curset Patel and
Dastur Meherjirana, of Navsari
attacked the BPP and the ‘Nargowalian
tions asked by responsible Parsis have
remained unanswered. So many queries
have been and are being just ignored.”
The Bombay Samachar called on the
BPP to rejoin the Federation noting
“there are numerous tasks awaiting the
Federation. The first and foremost is to
take stock of our assets and funds scat
tered over the distant corners of this
vast country. There are some lands the
title deeds of which are not available.
We, Parsis, have large properties where
there are only a couple of Parsis living.
— It is essential that we should not only Federation’, as Dastur termed it.
gather this data but also try to get posses
sion of these assets. This work is beyond from the adoption bill so also we want
the competence of individual Anjumans total exemption from the Federation,”
¦ and Punchayets.lt has to be taken up by said Faribourz Nariman, an architect
the Federation.” and scholar. He was not in favour of the
The Zoroastrian. the journal pub- BPP joining even with veto powers or
lished by members of the Committee for any other safeguards.
Electoral Rights, editorially favoured
“As we opted for total exemption
Electoral Rights, editorially favoured “We used to bow our heads in respect
the BPP rejoining the Federation. “Ata to the Bombay Parsi’Punchayet trus-
time where strength is declining, both tees,” said B.K. Mistry, an advertising
numerical and economic, unity is the professional and one of the orthodox’s
dire need of the hour. Petty egos have to most prolific writers. “Now we bow our
be shelved and religious difference of heads in shame.” Mistry lamented that
opinion forgotten at thisjuncture. Maxi- he and other like-minded people were
mum co-operation leads to greater co- ...................................
ordination of socio-economic activities
and avoidance of the wastage of scarce the Punchayet (in the past) are being
communal resources — monetary and treated like royalty. We who are faithful
human.
“The entry of the BPP into the Federa
tion will strengthen the current socio
The Zoroastrian Link
being “kept in the dark” as to goings-on
in the Punchayet. “Those who ridiculed
are treated like dogs...Do we need a
Federation? The Bombay Parsi Pun
chayet can be a shepherd...there is one
strong body. Why do we need
another?
Mistry felt once the BPP joined the
Federation the next step would be to
affiliate with the World Zoroastrian
Organization. Many of the overseas
associations “have non-Parsi spouses as
members,” he warned. One reason why
some anjumans were keen to join the
W.Z.O. was so thdr representatives
could go on “jaunts to New York and
"Petty egos have to be
shelved and religious
difference of opinion
forgotten."
t
Communication is the vital link that
holds a community together. More and
more people are dependent on the
written word to keep themselves
informed of developments that
concern them.
That is why the need of journals like
Parsiana is being increasingly felt.
Parsiana narrows the communication
gap by keeping you abreast of the events
personalities and issues shaping
world Zoroastrian opinion. Parsiana is
also a catalyst for developing
contemporary literature on the
community. Whether writing on poets
or panchayats, anjumans or Agiaries,
Parsiana will keep you informed
every month of happenings in the
international Zoroastrian community.
Subscribe today and encourage others
... . . _ , . ... to do so too or gift a subscription to
economic revivaland poses nodanger to W.Z O. was so their representatives someone you feel should be in touch,
our religion. could go on jaunts to New York and
Russi D.R. Wadia who has been pub- London,” he alleged. Annual subscription Rs 30.
lishing ‘Cyclostyled Letter’ espousing “Golwalla said we should move with Parsiana, GPO Boat 892
the orthodox point of view, warned in the times,” said Mistry, referring to a Bombay 400 001.
his letter number 16 of 21 June that
rejoining the Federation was tanta
mount to committing “racial suicide.”
The orthodox view the Federation as
a threat to the religion, mainly because
PKRSlWHK QE.CE.MaER 1982
“Golwalla said we should move with
•i
meeting the orthodox group had with
the BPP on the Federation. Mistry
interpreted this advice to mean con
ducting “gheraos” and holding “mor-
chas”, should the BPP not heed the !
17.
I
Seda Slio^
“As we saw the plane circling the air
field. for a moment we li\ed up there
with him." was the remark of a young
aspiring pilot who wtitched the 7S-ye;ir-
old doyen of Indian industry. .1RI) I ;ita
land at the .Itihu airport on October LS.
The night brought to an eventful close
Tata’s re-enactment of the first Karachi-
Ahmedabad-Bombiiy flight, exactly .SO
years ago. which pioneered the ago.
I he Amul butter hoardings displayed
.IRD ;is 'Atipro Superman,’ hovering 1
like a guarditin aitgel over the city ol I
Bombay: newspapers tind maga/fnes I
ctirried bold hetidlines and photographs I
of the elderly man and his vintage air- I
craft; Mehei lleroyce Moos ol Air I
India, a well-know n globe-trotter, dedi- I
cated a poem to him. Lhe city rejoiced - I
It was almost as il a war had been won. I
Mchci llci'ovcc
i
«
N. k
Ji
1
5i
11
.'G'
*
JRD alighting from his de Havilland
Leopard Moth at Juhu airport on
p" October 15, 1982.
JRD (third from left)posing before the
Puss Moth after the inaugural flight
in 1932.
A large number of Parsis reportedly
saw l ata off at Karachi on the morning
of October 15. He vvtis accompanied
upto Ahmedabad by the chief flying
instrtictor of the Bombay Living Club.
Chauhan. and then flevv solo to .luhu, at
7X, probably the oldest Indian to pilot
an aircraft.
Several dignitaries, including the
(lovernor and Chief Minister ol M;iha-
rashtra waited to receive him, as he
touched down at .luhu airport at 4 p.m.
introduction of civil aviation in India. lata Hew from theStintti Cru/airport It was here that Air India lntern;itional
“I salute the spirit of adventure,” said to Ahmedabad and then to Karachi on first started operating Dakota.s and
Prime Minister Indira Gandhi in a mes- October 1.3 in his tiny, propeller-driven. Super Constellations in 1946, here on the
sage on the occasion, an occasion that single-engined de Havilland Leopard same mud Hats ol .luhu where lata lirst
was an exemplar of the pioneering and Moth, an aircraft similar to the wood
" '. and fabric Puss Moth he had llown as a
An editorial in The Economic Times young man of 2S. Carrying a packet ol
entitled ‘The Spirit of 78’ says, “At 78. mail in 19.32. Tata’s flight had heralded
an age at which the spirit of adventure
generally tends to recline in an arm
chair, JRD Tata decided to re-enact ried a green Tata Airlines mailbag and
what he did when he was 28.” a diplomatic bag which contained a let-
• Whether it was to illustrate “the fact ter from President Zail Singh to the
that from absurdly small beginnings Pakistani president,
worthwhile things can be achieved,”
that Tata flew again, as one press report refurbished at a cost of 16,()()() pounds in
had it, or simply that “I am old and 1 just the UK, had been used in 1962, when
want to re-enact what I did exactly 50 Tata had re-played his first Hight to
years ago,” as another claimed, there is mark the 3f)th anniversary of Indian
no doubt that the entire nation cheered civil aviation. On that trip Tata had car-
this spirited man on a flight that was ried a message of friendship from the
described as “JRD’s Air Odyssey”and a then President Radhakrishnan to the
“historic re-enactment.” Pakistani president.
enterprising spirit of the Parsis.
An editorial in The Feonomit
PARSIANA: DECEMBER 1982
j
Tata Hew from the Santa Cru/airport
the birth of an airline that now spans
five continents. 1 his time too. I ata ctir-
The same .Leopard Moth, recently
including
learnt to lly.
Tired but smiling, in a blue-grev safari
suit, and running a comb through his
silvery hair, Tata alighted froth the'air-
craft near a red carpet, and handed over
to the post-master general a mailbag.
He also brought a return message from
the Pakistani president. An Indian Oil
hoarding which stood close to the air
craft said; “Welcome ,IRD, the Mahar-
ajit of aviation."
Tata is reported to have said, on land
ing, that youth today were losing their
morale, tha-t “there is a lack of faith in
ourselves,” He hoped that his flight
would -“rekindle enthusiasm amongst
the younger generation to do something
for this country... When they are 7X, I
hope they will feel as 1 do now.”
19Wings for a Nation
An extract from
The Creation of Wealth
by R.M. Lala
It;
p,'
It was in the first decade of the century.
Two young boys spent their summer
holidays at Hardelot, a beach resort
near Boulogne in Northern France. One
was the son of the legendary Louis Ble
riot, the first man to fly across the Eng
lish Channel in 1909. The other was the
son of an Indian industrialist, R.D.
Tata. As they played, the boys would
occasionally see Bleriot’s Chief Pilot
Charles Pegoud land a plane on the
beach. Pegoud was the first man to
Loop-the-Loop in a plane. He was a
hero, especially for Tata’s young son
Jehangir.
In such small beginnings lie the seeds
of history. The exploits of the French
man stirred the heart of the young
Indian. At the age of 15 after taking a
joy ride in a plane. Jehangir decided to
become a pilot and if possible make a
career in aviation. Young Jehangir had
to wait nine years. He was 24 before a
Flying Club opened in his home town
Bombay, India—5,000 miles away from
that wind-swept beach in Northern
France. Though not the first to register,
he was the first Indian to pass out with
‘No. I’ endorsed on his flying licence.
And so it came to pass that India’s first
pilot, was to pour most of his creative
genius into building an airline for his
country, giving his nation wings.
Those were years of adventure. In
1930, the Aga Khan announced a prize
of £500 to the first Ipdian who would fly
solo between England and India, start
ing at either end. Among the competi
tors was a young man called Manmohan
Singh. His spirit was willing but his navi
gation was weak. Twice he left England
with a flourish to fly to India. Twice he
lost his way over Europe and had to fly
back to England to start all over again.
C. G. Grey, Editor of The Aeroplane
observed: ‘Mr Manmohan Singh has
called his plane “Miss India”. He is
likely to.’ Another hopeful from the
England end was 18-year old Aspy Engi-
Reprinted with permission from the Creation of wealth
by R.M. Lala, published by India Book House Publishing
Company, Bombay, pgs. 2I0; Price Rs. 45. Copyright
Jamsetji Tata Trust, I98I.
.-*
.1"
.j'll'.illlllf
(¦'
'/'I''
<1
PARSIANA: DECEMBER 1982
20r
I?
neer. Still another to enter for fun, tak
ing off from the Karachi end, was the during the monsoon the runway was
now 26-year old Jehangir R.D. Tata. At below the sea! So we had to pack up
Aboukir near Alexandria in Egypt, each year, lock, stock and barrel—two
below what we called our airfield, and ultimately to achieve growth and leader
ship in the field.’
The unfolding years were to justify
that faith. In 1936 the all-up Empire
Mail Service was launched by the Brit-
i
*
r
and transfer ourselves to Poona where ish Government, under which all first
we were allowed to use a maidan as an class mail travelled by air without sur-
' , appropriately under the charge, and Tata Airlines revenues
shadow of the Yeravada Jail! ’ soared. At the beginning the aeroplanes
The annual report of the Directorate used were so small that the service was
of Civil Aviation (DCA) of India for the restricted to mails, but a single pay
senger was occasionally allowed to sit
on top of the mail bags—usually with
his heels higher than his head!
In 1936 larger aircraft, though still
single-engined, were introduced. Tatas
felt the need to give more sophisticated
training to their pilots and hired an
instructor from England to start a train
ing centre for pilots. The Bombay-Delhi
service was inaugurated in 1938. Then
came the War and all services, including
Tatas’, were commandeered by the
Government of India.
With their airline operations severely
restricted and at times brought to a vir
tual standstill, Nevill Vintcent and
J.R.D. Tata looked for alternative
avenues for their brimming enthusiasm
nated there with the mails from England and their growing expertise. A specially
_______ ________ _ exciting opportunity, they felt, offered
itself in the field of aircraft manufacture.
Whereas the construction of metal air
craft would have involved an elabo
rately equipped factory, the De
Havilland Mosquito, an outstanding
twin-engined fighter-bomber made of
wood, could, they felt, be put quickly
into production in India. Tatas, there-
______________ ______ fore submitted in 1942 a project to the
chi-Bombay-Madras. Tatas requested British Government for the large-scale
_ _________ ... - manufacture of Mosquito aircraft inia
rying the mail as was the normal prac- factory they would build for the purpose
As an example how air mail service should
be run, we commend the efficiency of Tata
Services who on October 10, 1933, arriving
at Karachi as usual to time, completed a
... even during the most of the difficult mon
soon months when rainstorms increased the
perils of the Western Ghat portion of the
route no mail from Madras or Bombay
missed connection at Karachi nor was the
mail delivered late on a single occasion at
Madras ... our esteemed Trans-Continental
their staff on deputation to Tatas to see how
it is done.
Karachi was chosen as the starting
I
JRD ran into Aspy, who had left Eng- planes, three pilotsand three mechanics,
land a week earlier and who was
stranded for want of spark plugs. JRD
gave Aspy his spare spark plugs, and aerodrome,
they took off in opposite directions.
Aspy reached Karachi a few hours
before JRD reached England, winning
the prize. On the strength of his perfor- year 1933-34 stated;
mance, Aspy was admitted into the
Indian Air Force, which had just been
created, where he rose to be its first
Indian Air Chief of Staff. JRD, mean
while, had another ambition and he did ’ year’s working with 100 percent punctuality
not have long to wait, for this is what he
said of an event that happened two years
later:
On an exciting October dawn in 1932, a Puss
Moth and I soared joyfully from Karachi
with our first precious load of mail, on an
inaugural flight to Bombay. As we hummed Airways, alias Imperial Airways, might send
towards our destination at a ‘dazzling’ " • ’ ’
hundred miles an hour, 1 breathed a silent
prayer for the success of our venture and for
the safety of those who worked for it. We
were a small team in those days. We shared point because Imperial Airways termi-
successes and failures, the joys and heart- ,
aches, as together we built up the enterprise
which later was to blossom into Air-lndia
and Air-lndia International.
When JRD landed on the Juhu mud
flats that October day in 1932. India’s
first air service was inaugurated. He
does not take the credit for it. He gives it
instead to a farseeing Englishman—a
former officer of the R.A.F. called
Nevill Vintcent, who a year earlier had and the route chosen by Tatas was Kara-
come to India barnstorming the country (
giving joy rides. Nevill Vintcent offered Government for a small subsidy for car-
J. R. D. Tata a project to start an airline, ij-.-o ---------7“* .
The then Chairman of Tata Sons, Sir tice in other countries. The subsidy in Poona (Pune).^ The
and a new Company, Tata Aircraft
Limited, was formed to give it life. Land
was acquired and a large factory build-
would just give the service to the country ing constructed.
collecting the little stamp surcharge Unfortunately, the British Goyern-
........... - to connect it with the Imperial Airways instead that invasion gliders should be
radforno navigational or landing guides at Karachi. When asked why they did built under the project. This change was
faith in the future of aviation and work of building the factory, recruiting
believed that if we came in at the begin- staff and organising manufacture had
ning of an era we had a better chance already gone too far to be abandoned.
' 21
“We did not even have an
aerodrome in Bombay. We
used a mud flat at Juhu.”
J. R. D. Tata a project to start an airline.
Dorab Tata, was not a bit enthusiastic asked for was small but the Government approved byjhe British^Governrne^nt
about the proposition. But the initial declined. Tatas reduced the figure to a
investment was small—Rs.200,000— bare minimum. Government still
and he was persuaded by JRD’s mentor declined. So Tatas decided that they
and colleague John Peterson to give his '
approval. ----------c — — > *- - , , j
‘We had no aids whatsoever on the which the addressor put on the envelope ment had second thoug^jts and decided
ground or in the air,’ JRD recalls, ‘no
ofany kind. In fact we did noteven have so, JRD replied, ‘Vintcent and I had reluctanUy _accepted ^by Tatas as the
an aerodrome in Bombay. We used a
mud flat at Juhu (a fishing village-cum-
beach resort near the city). The sea was
PARSIANA DECEMBER 1982
Unfortunately, the British Govern-¦
i
r
,r
. between the public and private sectors
Nevilf Vintcent was a man of great in the country. The proposal was made
physical courage and resourcefulness, by J.R.D. Tata at a most inopportune
The project was revised accordingly.
He flew a number of times to England time, when communal strife raged in
for discussions with the British authori
ties. Usually flying by Imperial Airwa^
long-range aircraft, he was flown by a
tion was, and remains, his first love. He
did everything he could to make Air
India as good as the best among the
world’s airlines. Its planes were lavishly
Mi i
Delhi. To his astonishment, which still decorated. He 'insisted that even if a
lingers, JRD got acceptance to his joint
sector proposal from the Government
sufficiently circuitous route to keep out in only ten days. Many years later he
ter, Jagjivan Ram, why a decision could
be made so speedily in those days when
today it took the Government at least
two years ‘not to make a decision’. Mr
Ram replied, ‘We did not know any
better then !’
The proposal provided for a new
company to be called Air-India Interna
plane was used for 20 years, should
always look as if it had come out from its
factory—new, inside arid outside. He
insisted on it and he succeeded. With
Air-India, as efficiently run as it was,
JRD sees no reason why all public
undertakings could not also be run to
the world’s best standards.
As Chairman, JRD believed in per
sonalised attention. He wa> dubbed a
perfectionist for he called upon his staff:
‘Always aim at perfection for only then
tional, to be managed and provided will you achieve excellence.’ On every
with crews, maintenance and all services
by Air-India Ltd. On June 8, 1948, Air-
India International with its famous
Maharaja, spread its wings to Europe.
The fledgling airline soon established
itself as one of the finest air carriers of career
the world.
Meanwhile India’s domestic airlines
were heading for a crisis. At the end of
the War, planes were disposed of by the
American Tenth Air Force in India at
throw-away prices. For political rea-
_ sons the Government sanctioned every
nally planned, would probably have airline applicant, and India soon found
resulted in an invaluable addition to
India’s aircraft industry.
In 1946, Tata Airlines, a Division of
Tata Sons, went public and became a
joint stock company. It was called Air-
India Ltd. The age of passenger travel
of range of German fighters. Tragically jokingly asked a senior Cabinet Minis-
however, on one occasion Vintcent, as
an ex-RAF officer, arranged to get a lift
on an RAF Hudson bomber on the first
leg of a flight from England to Gibral
tar. The plane never reached Gibraltar
and was reported to have been shot
down off the coast of France. The loss of
Vintcent was a grievous blow to Tatas
and to JRD personally, for apart from
being the able and moving spirit behind
Tata Airlines and Tata Aircraft that he
was, Vintcent and JRD were close
friends. This tragic blow was followed
by the cancellation of the project itself
by the British, who in response to Tatas’
own enquiries on the subject, discovered
that invasion gliders made by Tata in
Poona could not be used in the War
because there were no aircraft to tow
them! Thus came to a tragic end a pro
ject on which JRD had set his heart and
which, if it had gone through, as origi-
flight on which he travelled he kept
detailed notes of his observations and
would painstakingly take action on
them on return to base. He gave India
pride in its national airline. In a 46-year
that spanned an era from the
wood and fabric of the little two-seater
Puss Moth to the gleaming 400-seater
giant Boeing 747, he insisted that there
should be no compromise on operating
and maintenance standards or on ser
vice. One of the airline’s publicity chiefs
recalls how he once received a midnight
phone call at his home from the Chair
man suggesting how to improve word
ing on a publicity hoarding.'We had'to
they all ran into rough weather for there give so much of ourselves because he
were not enough traffic routes to allo
cate amongst them. Except Air-India all
________ the airlines lost heavily. In 1953 the
had arrived and there was to be plenty Government took a decision to nationa-
of competition. Even during wartime
Tatas were working on a scheme to
extend their services to London. In
October 1947, in the turmoil of the post
partition period, Tatas proposed to the
Indian Government a service to Europe.
They placed an order for three Lock-
• heed Constellations, on faith that this
venture would be approved. It was a
measure of their faith in the newly born
independent India, then in the convul
sions of the partition of the sub
continent.
Tatas proposed that the Indian
Government take 49 per cent of the cap
ital, Tatas 20 per cent and the rest be
publicly subscribed. This was the first
ever proposal of a joint enterprise
itself with eleven airlines while there was
room for only two or three. As a result
gave so much of himself,’ said this exe
cutive.
Air Marshal Nur Khan, former head
of the Pakistan Air Force, and later
Chairman of Pakistan International
lise the airlines proposing to merge
them into a single State Corporation Airlines, when asked by an Indian mag-
with JRD as Chairman. Mr Tata
advised that the domestic and the inter
national airlines of India should be kept replied: ‘A great airline and JRD is an
separate and two corporations should epic figure.’ In recognition of this epic
be formed. The suggestion was accepted figure’s services to air transport, JRD
and he was invited to head the interna- was made the recipient in 1979 of the
tional airline, a task he accepted. For Tony Jannus Award, named after the
the next 25 years he was to be the Chair
man of Air-India, and a Director on the
Board of Indian Airlines.
The international airline business is
ferociously competitive and JRD, engine Sir Frank Whittle; the develop-
Chairman of some of the largest com
panies in India, had to give more and
more time, to the running of Air-India.
He carried this burden happily, for avia-
azine what he thought of his neighbour
airline, Air-India, and of J.R.D. Tata,
founder pilot of the first scheduled air
line in the world, which began in
Tampa, Florida, in 1912. Amongst its
recipients are the inventor of the jet
ers of the Concorde SST, and the found
ers of the Douglas A’rcraft
Corporation, Pan-Am, Eastern, and
United Airlines.
A’rcraft
PARSIANA: DECEMBER 1982
23
¦¦ in
li
11
1
- 41
il!
’ 0
¦ if
Hf
¦'M
L»•
Phiroze Pestonjamas (right)
with Arphi General Manager S. Raina
testing professional headphone model.
A
I
I
I
s
Arphi:
the sound of success
A
By Nirmala Ferrao
Two decades ago anyone in India who
needed a hearing aid would have had to
get one from abroad^ Today he simply jamas initiative. And so, in collabora- In the early stages creating a market
s; indi,e„„„*,y'pr„dujd heari;j
model. As pioneers in ,he indigenous assembl/workers^anS an7nvestment7f »Bein.
g7rp‘Sa“:i“^ j-So •? m
audiometers (instruments for testing -------------- - ------- - --------------------------- ‘’^^’'ing aids to convince them through
actual demonstration that our product
was as good as any imported-product.”
Initially, the marketing effort consisted
largely of hearing aid specialists and
sales consultants touring the country
and arranging demonstrations at deaf
ness clinics and schools, research centres,
teaching colleges and government and
la
A New Venture r
Oticon responded positively to Peston- and volume controls are imported.”'”"
jamas initiative. And so, in collabora- I '
tion with Oticon of Denmark the Arphi for the indigenously produced hearing
storv hpQan With nn.. .1__ _ j___ .
the receiver, microphone, ear moulds
r audiometers (instruments for testing
hearing ability), the Arphi group has set
a pace that last year netted the company
two thirds of its total turnover for Rs.2
crores (the rest coming in from its
speaker systems and related products.)
It started with a parliamentary ques-
(then Congress secretary) to the then
Union health minister. Nigam wanted to
know whether there v . .
\ 4- manufacturers of hearing aids in
the country. Since the minister’s answer
was in the negative, Phiroze Pestonja
mas, managing director of Arphi Elec
tronics Pvt. Ltd., wrote to Nigam
expressing h^ willingness to embark on
St
tion in 1961 put by Savitri Devi Nigam
r
Arphi's first hearing aid
was assembled by
the entrepreneur at his
writing desk at home!
/¦
? .... vvii^^vo aiiu gvyciiiiiicni an
/ I civil hospitals. Uniquely, Arphi offered
mately 400 sq.ft, of space in Bombay. In three
1 was
assembled by the entrepreneur at his
writing desk at home! . .......................au ului sci u
At first merely assembly of hearing year after inception), Arphi extended ks
aids, based on the Oticon technology,
was carried out. Gradually as Pestonja
mas learnt the ropes he taught his engi
neers and workers every detail of the
manufacturing process. With the setting
up of its machine shop and tool room,
nents. As a result today, of .the 48 odd _____ _________ ut
parts that make up a hearing aid, only thd-ear” hearing aids that can'fit' dis-
PARSIANA DECEMBER
were at that time fact, Arphi’s first hearing aid
I
6
the enterprise, if the government sup-
ported him.
At the same time that Pestonjamas __ _ _____ luvm
wrote to Nigam, he contacted a Danish Arphi began?o manufect“ure the co7pol
hrm, Oticon, world pioneersand leaders * . . -
in the field of hearing aids.
< 24
year guarantee on its products,
right from the start.
Meanwhile, spurred on by the efforts
of its R&D unit (Which had been set up a
______ J
range of hearing aid systems to i
not only individual hearing aids, but
also group hearing aid systems, speech
trainers and audiometers.
In the field of individual hearing aids
besides the conventional accessories like
automatic volume controls, Arphi has
recently started manufacturing “behind-
¦' I
1
i I
I.I
k
i'
erectly out of sight behind even a loc k of headphones in India. The resulting peaker. And judging from the response
hair. Presently Arphi manufactures
1,500 (individual) hearing aids each
month in six different models, priced civil aviation special model). All India a commercial basis.”
between Rs.400 to Rs. 800. Radio (the A.I.R special monitoring Given full charge of the entertainment
superior quality meets even the exacting of friends to 4he Aquarius model, 1
standards of the Indian Air Force (the decided that it was worth promoting on
I
1:
Radio (the A.I.R special monitoring
version), Doordarshan, BARC, and the electronics range of products, Adi Pes-
Ministries of Home and External tonjamas first exparrded the range of
Affairs to name a few satisfied custo- speakers. Within 18 months, there were
mers. two more jnodels. Initially they con
centrated on established dealers in Bom
bay “where 60% of the market for hi-fi
With its priorities initially fixed on hear- equipment exists.” This marketing stra-
ing aid systems, Arphi’s entry into the tegy was supported by an aggressive
field of hi-fi production was relatively advertising campaign. Aimed at the
recent. Although engaged, in 1974-75, in upper middle claSs and utilising the
Principal Supplier
Since 1963, Arphi has also been the
principal supplier of group hearing aid
systems to almost all schools for the deaf
and speech clinics in India. Ranging in High Fidelity
cost (including installation) from
Rs. 3,000 to Rs. 15,000, they can cater to
classes of two to twelve students.
It is however, in the field of audiome
ters (instruments that test hearing abil- major English dailies, the campaign
ity) that Arphi has excelled. The . initially confined itself to the print
technology for the manufacture of audi- Arphi hSS fOCGntly Started medium. The combined marketing-
ometers according to international rnanufaCtUrinO ' behind- advertising strategy worked. “Within a
standards was developed by Arphi for ,, . . year, the word had gone around among
the first time in India in 1966. the-ear hearing aidS that the dealers; Arphi must be stocked.”
The electronic 900 mark IV model— Can fit discreetly OUt of Today out of 70 loudspeaker dealers all
the so-called digital audiometer — ¦ i_x l i_- j over the country, 45 are in Bombay,
incorporates features developed Sight Deninu even a Special emphasis is laid on Arphi’s
independently by Arphi and probably lock Of hair. relationship with its dealers. “We were
unique in the world. . the first in the field of speaker systems to
From the early years of production, ' list the names and addresses of all our
Arphi has also been manufacturing mic-
rophones in co-operation with the Aus- speakers for use in their audiometers,
trian firm, AKG; some of these are utilised
in the group hearing aid systems, but the
bulk of the microphone production is
sold to Philips India (Peico) who market
it under the AKG names.
The imported AKG capsules are also
used by Arphi in its headphones —
instead of the small loudspeakers
used in all indigenously manufactured
the-ear ” hearing aids that
can fit discreetly out of
sight behind even a
lock of hair.
the limited manufacture of free-field local dealers, no matter how many, in
our ads,” says Adi Pestonjamas, adding
these were not marketed individually, that, “having your product in as many
until Pestonjamas’ son, Adi Pestonja- shops as possible is the best form of
mas, joined the family business in 1977. advertising.”
“At that time,” says Adi Pestonjamas,
“entertainment electronics was still After Sales Service
regarded as a luxury. The foresight that The quality of the product itself has
its potential would grow was not pres- been bolstered by the peripheral client
ent. The first thing 1 realised was that we
had a very good product in our louds-
services offered by the firm. At the
Arphi Acoustic Centre at Hermes
The Arphi range: (from left) Loudspeaker, audiometer, briefcase model speech trainer, and individual hearing aids.
25 PARSIANA: DECEMBER 1982
I.
¦' A
.) ¦
I
• {
' j
I
¦ li
t
¦¦’ii
,'ti
hi
.4V
¦S
¦ i!-
¦'fl
i
5l
1 i
* 1
11
i
i
4
f
5'1
31
A '
Sh 1
KI
f
House in Bombay’s Opera House area, choice of words. “For instance,” says where engineers cheerfully doubled as
Arphi conducts acoustical demonstra- Phiroze Pestonjamas, “we would not salesmen, Arphi has moved gradually to
tions in a sound-treated room that simu- have an ad say, “Are you deaf?” Instead
lates an average sitting room. Here 12 we would say, “Are you hard of hear-
different brands of loudspeakers availa- ing?”
ble in India and 12 brands of amplifiers
can be compared, making a total of 144 Meeting Competition
possible tests in all.
Adi Pestonjamas also points to the systems have so far consisted mainly of
emphasis laid on after-sales service around 15 other indigenous manufac- primary one will be to acquire larger
“which is critical in the case of high turers, like Novax and Elkon but they premises. Although Arphi moved from
investment products like hi-fi. We offer are not considered a very serious threat, its original location atTardeo, Bombay,
a one-year guarantee on our amplifiers Recently, the corporate giant Philips has to larger premises (3,500 sq. ft.) at the
and loudspeakers and we respond to entered the field in India, but Adi Pes- Prabhadevi Industrial Estate, even this
calls for after-sales service at any work- tonjamas is confident that Arphi’s space has been overrun half by growing
ing hour.” market will not be affected. “The market needs, and plans for any production
In contrast to the aggressive market- for hearing aids is essentially a welfare expansion are at present frustrated by
ing-cum-advertising strategy for the market which Philips is not really the severe limitations of space.
Arphi hi-fi range, the approach in the geared to enter. It is a field in which
field of hearing aids is geared instead to all-lndia affordability is critical and discouraged the continuing process of
the promotion of what is considered “a where everything does boil down to the innovation and improvement. Spurred
welfare product.” One aspect of this price.” Therefore price is one area where by the promising response to its first
involves generating an awareness of Arphi hopes to score over the new Stereo Amplifier, Arphi is now working
deafness problems and their treatment entrant. on developing a full range of Stereo
in the rural areas : Arphi deputes three
touring hearing aid specialists to assist at tition from even the big names is aiso decks is also very much on the cards in
deafness camps organised by social wel- partly the by-product of the stringent the foreseeable future. Finally, Adi Pes-
fare departments of various state quality standards adhered to. With test
governments and groups like the Lions ing equipment from Bruel & Kjaer of
Copenhagen, world leaders in the
manufacture of quality control instru
ments in the field of electro-acoustics,
Arphi maintains standards that easily
conform to ISO and ISl requirements.
Over the last two years, the Arphi
group’s turnover doubled from Rs.l
crore to Rs.2 crores. Part of this spurt in
success may be attributed to basic
and Rotary clubs. They help the camp changes in the ownership pattern and
doctor in conducting the audiometric management structure effected during tonjamas has plans to expand his opera
tests and then, on the basis of his pres- this period. At the time of inception,
cription, Arphi hearing aids are supp- Arphi was a partnership firm with Phi-
lied at highly subsidised rates to those roze Pestonjamas and Armaity, his wife,
who may require them. In the urban as partners. In fact, the name “Arphi”
areas, Arphi sales personnel stay in was a fused derivation from the two the-ear” hearing aid, tentatively priced
direct contact with almost all the ENT names Armaity and Phiroze. On the at Rs. 1,150. Simultaneously, there are
specialists and audiologists, keeping death of his wife, Phiroze’s son Adi plans to expand the range of audiome-
them abreast of the latest technological became a partner. ters.
developments in the field. From 1 July 1982, however, Arphi
Under its own steam, Arphi has also was converted into a private limited Improving Expertise
set up a Deaf Aid Centre (the other com- company with shares held by the father Phiroze Pestonjamas however has no
pany in the Arphi group) where hearing and son in a 60:40 ratio. diversification plans. “We would prefer
tests are conducted free of charge and Much before this conversion there to continue in the electro-acoustic field
hearing aids provided, according to spe- was a switchover to a professionalised andimproveourexpertise,”hesaysdec-
cific needs. And Arphi claims today that cadre of management staff. (For this isively. As things stand, Arphi adds at
60-70% of its individual hearing aids are purpose Arphi inducted the services of least one new product or product-type
sold at subsidised rates. Santosh Raina, an ex-IBM and Tata
The advertising effort, in the case of executive who helped in completely
hearing aids, is similarly oriented reorganising and professionalising the Arphi exported a tenth of total produc-
towards an education/ welfare objec- company in his position as general man- tion to Denmark for around three years,
tive. Equally, there is the recognition ager.) From a set-up in which adminis- Bureaucratic impediments forced Arphi
that deafness is still a sensitive issue in tration of every section was to eventually give this up. Today,
the minds of most sufferers and the concentrated mainly in the hands of one although confident that his range can
advertiser must be careful in his very person, Phiroze Pestonjamas, and compete successfully with “the best in
26 ' PARSIANA; DECEMBER 1982
a more rationalised structure.
Marketing is a separate department
now, with professionally qualified staff.
And, overall, the Arphi staff has
increased to 100 persons today, of
Its competitors in the field of hearing aid whom 60 work in the factory.
As for future priorities, perhaps the
This, however, has not in any way
Such confidence in the face of compe- amplifiers. The production of cassette
"Having your product
in as many shops as
possible is the best
form of advertising."
Much before this conversion there
"It (hearing aid systems)
is a field In which
all-lndia affordability is
critical and where
everything does boil
down to the price."
tions into Calcutta “within the next six
months.”
In the field of audiology, Arphi’s new
offering is the minutely-crafted “behind-
to its range each year.
Around the late sixties-early seventies1
Europe and Japan,” Phiroze Pestonja-
mas would prefer to expand his home
base instead. .
The domestic market is not without
Its problems. “Bottlenecks at every step,
and obstructive processes of the various
government departments, exist.” In
addition to bureaucratic hurdles, are the
extremely steep rates of tax and duties.
Import duties on essential components
vary from (25 to 146 percent). Central
excise stands at 30 percent on louds
peakers and 8 percent on other items. In
Maharashtra even hearing aids, a wel
fare item, today carries a sales tax of 4
percent (even this being a reduction
from the 8 percent of a few years ago.)
Phiroze Pestonjamas is understan
dably bitter about the non-encouraging
attitude of the government to small scale
enterprise in India; but in spite of the
unhappy noises he sometimes makes,
there is no doubt that Arphi continues
to make good music.
J
b
'fl
• . I
With Compliments
From
?'
*
F
I
r
Reprinted with permission from Business India,
November 8 to 21 issue.
Warden is good
For sandalwood
Head Office
378 Grant Road
Bombay 400 007
and Branches
Tel. 371464
Quality sandalwood
Aggarbatties, gum benzoin
(Loban) and other
Perfumes
J?
/.
tl
I
PARSIANA: DECEMBER 1982
EMPIRE
ESTATE
Liberty Building
41/42 Marine Lines
Bombay 400020
21
•i
¦¦.;i
M
h
ir
I
I
A Matter of Death.. .and Life
By Bill Morris
Presswalla, a dapper 41-year-old native ‘There’sa poor widow with four kids and
------- -- ---------------; company.
phone calls, working weekends, vaca- What is $25,000 or $50,000 or $100,000
1 J , J , . *=---------- I---------------- • ¦»-i uiiv lias IV ivaiiiy lu iiiC
or burned beyond recognition, you’ll scrutiny. In 18 years in the field here, in truth.”
probably end up here. India, London and New York City, he
Ifyoujump offa tall building or swal- has performed more than 5,000 auto
low a bottle of sleeping pills or hang psies. It is an unsightly operation that
yourself, or if you ask to be cremated or requires opening the chest cavity, rem-
buried at sea, you II probably end up oving and dissecting organs; peeling
here, too. back the scalp, removing and dissecting
Here, in the “county” morgue, where the brain; photographing and documen
ting any wound.s and relevant evidence,
If you are shot in the head, stabbed in P , , ,,_____ _____ . ac v».umv » w„„n
the heart, electrocuted or strangled, of India who is no stranger to late-night there’s the rich insurance
you’ll probably end up here. i ’
It you re poisoned, crushed, drowned tionless years and the glare of public to them?’ Yet one has to testify to the
probably end up here. India, London and New York City, he
Ifyoujump offa tall building or swal- has performed more than 5,000 auto-
requires opening the chest cavity, rem-
Nothing is left to chance.
Even the most obvious
death could conceal a
darker truth.
death delights to help the living and a I' __ ___ _______ ,
tiny staff works long hours to make sure drawing blood and tissue.s for slides;
it does because that is the point of this
business. Not the blood or the bullets,
the headlines or the horror, not the beat
ings or the stabbings or the shootings.
The circumstances of every death tell about all this.
a story, frequently a helpful story. They ' " ’ ___ __ ___ v__ ,
are the driving force in the life of Dr. ally is not understood. Before the televi- society. If we were to sympathize with
Faruk Presswalla, deputy chief medical
examiner of the Tidewater District
Office of the Chief Medical Examiner,
and the six staff members and 44 physi
cians who work with him investigating,
analyzing, pondering, interpreting,
cataloguing and reporting the details of thinks we are the licensing agency.”
unusual deaths. It is sometimes gruel- A thin smile. “People think we are
ing, frequently grisly and almost always concerned mainly with crime and its
thankless work.
Under state law, roughly one-fourth
of the deaths occurring annually in the
-------------------- ~ Norfolk, Ports- government people, people in the medi-
It is a demanding master, the truth,
then reassembling the corpse so an There is no room for emotion in this
undertaker can embalm it.
Perhaps understandably, the public
doesn’t want to understand too much
arena of death,
“In the social or emotional sense one
may sympathize with the widow and her
four children,” Presswalla said. “But
Our role, Presswalla sighs, “gener- one must (see) the whole picture of
sion show ’Quincy’ became popular, the victims — as sometimes juries do —
even our name wasn’t understood. Very in medical malpractice suits where
often they thought medical examiners something went wrong but there was no
malpractice on the part of the physician,
that causes everybody to pay in the long
were involved in testing physicians.
Almost everyday, even now, we receive a
call from a doctor outside Virginia who run. What happens as a result? The
insurance company ups the doctor’s pre
mium and the doctor ups his fees and we
come to a ridiculous situation. So it’s
investigation. This is where there’s an shortsighted to look at the poor widow
improper understanding by everybody who may need the money more than the
— including the state bureaucracy, city rich insurance company.”
Tidewater district — Norfolk, Ports- government people, people in the medi- But this rigorous pursuit has not
Beach, cal and legal fields. They do not under- made Tidewater’s chief medical
miner numb to feelings. Outwardly soft-
investigating deaths beyond crime, that spoken, articulate, precise, it is apparent
our role is to answer questions that help that beneath the cool exterior there is a
the living.”.
The man who apparently died of a
heart attack, for example, while work
ing at home with a power drill. Did he he says, “and ultimately you-get worn
actually die of a heart attack ? Or was he out. Yes, 1 do feel worn out. There is no
A thin smile. “People think
Suffolk, the Eastern Shore, Hampton, stand that we are concerned a lot in
There is no room for
emotion in this
arena of death.
exa-
!
1
man who is alternately proud and tired,
outraged and driven and, finally,sad.
“This goes on day after day after day,”
Newport News, and York, Southamp- electrocuted? If he was electrocuted, happy solution — ever. You don’t lose
ton and Isle of Wight counties—i .................................
an investigation by a medical examiner,
a doctor appointed by the chief medical
examiner in Richmond. These are
deaths that stir public interest because
they happened in a “... suspicious, unus
ual or unnatural manner ...” migni ue someoody in or exclude some-
About one-fourth of the deaths inves- body. The person may be black, blond.
require had he wired the drill improperly? Was some patients and also deliver babies.”
So why did he go into “forensic
pathology,” the study of the medical and
the manufacturer at fault? The answers
could prove helpful.
“Our role,” Presswalla continues, “is legal aspects of death?
not to say who did it. Our role is to say
what was done — ; '
might tie somebody in or exclude
“At first it was the scientific challenge
and what evidence of being able to find things out. But
you’re constantly dealing with death
,- , under the most tragic circumstances—
tigated lead to an autopsy usually Caucasian, Oriental,male, female. We young people in the prime of life, for
. homicides, suicides, hit-and-run vic- have to remain totally impartial. When example. In the past three weeks I’ve
tims, abused children and drug over- the question comes up between the insu- had three deaths of people who had just
doses. Last year in Tidewater, .483 of rance company and the family, the deci- been married. I see babies, battered
1,569 were autopsied. sion may favor the insurance company. babies.Every timeyouseeawomanrap-
All but a few were performed by Dr. Very often the subtle pressure is: ed or murdered, it could be your sister.
28 ' PARSIANA: DECEMBER 1982
vic-
over-
-’’•JI“When 1 was younger, I dealt with it
much better — probably because I
viewed myself as a scientist. As I get
older I’m notable to handle it as well. So
you build a barrier. But by building a
barrier it tells in your personal life. You
get morgue humor because if you didn’t
do that you would start crying. Also,
people perceive you as cold and insensi
tive.
“It also tends to make you suspi
cious. Constant harping on these things
makes you suspicious of your fellow
human beings.’’
The morgue is a mirror of any com
munity. “You see the mores of the com
munity, and the worst of the community
goes through the morgue,’’ Presswalla
says.
It is the place where the victims end up
and so it tells stories about the people
who sent them there. The stories, as seen
through the eyes of Tidewater’s chief
medical examiner, have been getting
uglier.
s
««
<
-'1'
"You get morgue humor
because if you didn't
do that you would
start crying."
1
-X » 4
*
¦/ 'i-
tion like this from an article by Press-
“The number of deaths from criminal
violence is increasing,” he says, “and the
number of deaths from firearms is
increasing. In this area the number of
suicides for romantic reasons — or the
failure thereof — seems to be increasing
and the bulk of these suicides are taking
place with the use of a firearm. It’s males
as well as females. It used to be very rare
that a female shot herself. Now it is
becoming quite common.
“Maybe it is the new liberated female
who is familiar with firearms. Maybe it
is the society in general. It is my strong tion like this from an article by Press- It has only been since the second
belief that the easy availability of fire- walla in the Medical Science Law decade of this century that an organized
arms makes those little depressions magazine. system of investigating deaths has oper-
much more dangerous ... In spite of the “In falls from heights, aortic lacera- ated in the United States. Previously,
gun lobby and people who scream that tion results from vertical deceleration the states used coroners, elected officials
criminals kill people — all that may be forces, as the downward accelerating who, in some areas, did not have to be
true —there is no doubt in my mind that heart is abruptly restrained by its attach- doctors. The coroner system dates to
ment to the great vessels, the maximum feudal England when laws required a
stress here falls on the aortic origin and person to forfeit livestock and goods if
>
i
'I'
iibi
'^1!
“In falls from heights, aortic lacera- ated in the United States. Previously,
Si
J ’the easy availability of firearms plays a
very big role, not the only role, but a very
big role in explaining why the crime rate the tear usually occurs immediately he were found responsible for causing
I P n 1 /T n O O 1 xj zx I* « r zx liX zx zx z-x ¦ .x . .z, L .z* z.^ zj z, z^ ? 1_ zz. .£* zz ___ __ __ 1z ___ _1_
Of
J
above the aortic valve ring.” death of a Crown subject through
Which is a roundabout way of saying murder, negligence or accident. The
tall building is hazardous to your heart.
Such work is done in the interest of
I
is high,’’ he said.
A forensic pathologist sees elaborate
scenarios— both technical and human that jumping—or being thrown—off a spoils collected by the coroners were
in something as simple as a bruise, tall building is hazardous to your heart, used to finance the Crusades.
Nothing is left to chance. Even the most Such work is done in the interest of In 1915 New York City adopted a law
obvious death could conceal a darker scientific knowledge. It is part of his creating a Medical Examiner System,
truth. And so the forensic pathologist mission to know the truth and to tell it This established for the first time the
cuts no comers, and the result is erudi- without flinching. essentials of a competent medico-legal
PARSIANA: DECEMBER 1982
29
a'i
H
1
¦iLi
'¦;;Of
*r
With a $300,000 budget Presswalla autopsies; he believes 350 would be a
investigating system and a civil service
career in the speciality of forensic pathol
ogy. The system becaine a prototype for technicians,
other governments in the United States
and abroad.
In 1946 Virginia became the second
state to establish a statewide Medical Beneath the COOl GXterior
Examiner’s System, operating within
the Health Department. The Tidewater
District Office of the Chief Medical
Examiner opened in Portsmouth in
1956. One year later it moved to new
facilities in Norfolk, the staff was
expanded, and 35 medical examiners
served the area.
The present quarters, a squat brick
f. „ .BV, - —- -- J - - - J- - - V
Brambleton avenues near downtown his own $60,000 salary. The other labor- testimony.
Norfolk, opened in 1972. It is one of atory expenses are paid from a different ‘
must pay a staff of six — two autopsy more appropriate load. Also, he believes
a histology (study of all “unnatural” deaths, including 4II
¦ , an deaths in car crashes, for example,
administrative assistant, a full-time and should be autopsied. Such a move,
impractical under current money con
straints, would push the number of
autopsies up to 750 a year and would
require the hiring of a second forensic
pathologist.
So the staff makes do. Presswalla and
the 44 medical examiners don’t always
leave the job in the office. There are
classes to teach at Eastern Virginia
Medical School, instruction for doctors
and law enforcement people, seminars,
building at the corner of Colley and a part-time secretary — overhead, and speeches before civic groups, courtroom
Brambleton avenues near downtown his own $60,000 salary. The other labor- testimony.
Norfolk, opened in 1972. It is one of atory expenses are paid from a different “I don’t know if I’ll stick with it in the
four district offices in the state. Later state budget. He says he is stretched too future,” Presswalla says. “I do stick with
that year the General Assembly created thin. it because it is a job that has to be done
the Division of Consolidated Laborato- “A well-funded medical examiner’s ... and there are not many people who
ries. Ten lab technicians — in the fields office is cost-effective to the community could step in and take over.”
of toxicology (poisons), serology (hair, because it enables a more detailed inves- The work gets lonely, Presswalla
fibers, body fluids), firearms and drug tigation into deaths. Many potential admits, though you wouldn’t know it by
analysis — work adjacent to the chief questions that might lead to litigation watching an episode of ‘Quincy’ on TV.
medical examiner’s office, assisting him could be answered and the litigation But someone has to do it. Otherwise
and the police. Each of the 44 medical avoided. I’m mainly talking about civil death would only cause sorrow, and
walla is a doctor first, a public servant practice.”
and scientist second. Each is paid $50
for every case he investigates.
histology (study of all “unnatural” deaths, including 4II
microscopic tissues) -technician.
there is a man who is
alternately proud
and tired, outraged
and driven and,
finally; sad.
it because it is a job that has to be done
“A well-funded medical examiner’s ... and there are not many people who
of toxicology (poisons), serology (hair, because it enables a more detailed inves- The work gets lonely, Presswalla
fibers, body fluids), firearms and drug tigation into deaths. Many potential admits, though you wouldn’t know it by
analysis — work adjacent to the chief questions that might lead to litigation watching an episode of ‘Quincy’ on TV.
medical examiner’s office, assisting him could be answered and the litigation But someone has to do it. Otherwise
examiners now working under Press- litigation — insurance disputes, mal- would fail to delight the living.
Last year he worked an average of 60
hours a week and performed almost 500 counesy ne Virginian-PUot. July 15. 1982.
SERSON
E
t
[
r
r
r
PARSIANA: DECEMBER 1982
i
5
1
(J
-i!
¦
Electrolytic Capacitors
For
All Electronic Applications
From
12 VDC To 350 VDC
Manufacti^rK
Serson Industries Pvt. Ltd.
Pfaiipri P.F.P.O., Poon-lS.
Cable: Etchfoil Poona-lS. Phone: 82379
31
1 1J.
r.
Creative
duf
By Hutokshi D. Doctor
“Why should
we always have
'sail boti' or
'gos no palao' at
weddings
and navjotes ?“
/ ¦n
be taken into account. “The Parsi elite
will generally go in for ham platters and
lobster salads, but the simpler the meal
the better. If the cooking is not good, no
amount of lace napkins and tablecloths
will help,” he says. “Flavour, the fight
service, the fight timing, is as vital as eye
appeal.”
“Some chefs insist on specific culinary
efforts and procedures, and when you
are preparing an authentic dish you have
to follow a particular procedure, for
example, a bhuna ghosht must be given
a coal dum,” but Sarosh feels that
“young people today would like to
deviate. Cooking is both creative and
satisfying, involving experimentation
till you’ve captured a different taste.”
Creativity in cooking, he feels, is not
limited to garnishing a salad ordeciding
on accompaniments, though “accom
paniments are important, like an ice
cream without a cherry—you just can’t
send it out! If something looks good,
half the battle is won.” But “cutting a
chicken into six pieces instead of four is
creative, cutting down on expensive
ingredients, being economical without
affecting the taste is creativity; creativity
is using left-over raw ingredients in a
different way—never waste until you
really have to.”
“Our Parsi masalas are the simplest,
yet the product is most excellent. Our
dhansak and kababs are really way out.”
Sarosh’s favourite Parsi dishes arepatra
ni mac chi, sali boti and lagan nu custard
“but why should we always have sali
Embossed in gold on the deep red involve yourself.” Besides the actual
cover of Abanara’s menu, one of Bom- chopping, garnishing, and bestowing of
bay’s popular restaurants, is the outline finishing touches on his works of art,
of a chefs face, in the traditional tall Sarosh must also co-ordinate the opera
cap, with tufts of hair on either side of a tions of the kitchen with the bars, the manu email
plump face and a prominent moustache, food and beverages service, the sales and ' many Small
He is Sarosh Khariwala, at 25, already marketing people. “I’m very interested reStauraOtS have Opened,
the executive chef at Bombay’s ten- in feedback,” he says, “and the poolside . pp^vnlp will PAt
storied Fariyas Hotel. He creates, with parties and banquets have increased. pc up I c wii c
the help of his 60-strong staff, every culi- We all work in a team and market the almOSt anything On thO
nary masterpiece listed in the aestheti- hotel.” fOad-Sid© '
cally designed menu, right from the ¦
‘Shuruaaf with the inevitable jal jeera,
in the Muglai section, and the hors
d’oeuvres in the French section, to the
Mithai, Desserts and Boissons.
In the compact kitchen beyond, at
home amongst the enormous pots and
pans, the steam and smoke, the constant
hum of the exhaust and the clatter of the right. ”
dish-washers at work, Sarosh has never
been enamoured of the black coat and
tie, like many of his class-mates at the
Institute of Hotel Management,Cater
ing Technology and Applied Nutrition,
Bombay.
“I don’t like to sit around. I’m very
much a part of the kitchen; you must along with the preference of the guests.
Embossed in gold on the deep red
finishing touches on his works of art,
Sarosh must also co-ordinate the opera
tions of the kitchen with the bars, the
food and beverages service, the sales and
in feedback,” he says, “and the poolside
parties and banquets have increased.
hotel.”
And then there are the atypical guests
to deal with, those who demand ‘halal’
meat, that which is cut and slowly bled,
the chefs of different natures and
nationalities to be dealt with, the com
plaints of irate guests. But, Sarosh wedding or navjote here,” he says, “in a
explains, “In our industry all of them hotel owned by Parsis we’d look after
have to be satisfied asthe guest is always them better.” Fariyas is owned by
Fariyas Hotels Pvt. Ltd., a company set
Indian barbecue styles and French up by entrepreneur Hosi Mistry.
cooking are what Sarosh likes best, and
he has toned down Abanara’s earlier
menu to selected items in these two
styles. “An elaborate menu confuses,” school days, when he’d wander through
says Sarosh, who suggests that in plan
ning a menu, seasonal availability must.
bofi or gos no palao at weddings and
navjotes? But it will never change....
We’d be most happy to have a Parsi
“For me it was right from the start —
kitchen, kitchen, kitchen,”grins Sarosh,
and kitchens it’s been, right from his
the laden Sunday markets, fascinated,
and potter around happily in the kitchen
at home.
PARSIANA: DECEMBER 1982¦ 'f
f
"We'd be most happy
to have a Parsi wedding or
navjote here, in a hotel
owned by Parsis we'd look
after them better."
use
For potato straws:
Peel potatoes, slice thin, preferably
through a wafer cutter; cut very fine
straws from the slices of potatoes; soak
in salt water for at least 25 min. Drain ‘
off all water. Heat fat in kadai, and deep
fry the straws in batches till golden yel
low in colour; spread on paper, and let
all excess oil drain off. Sprinkle salt and
a little white pepper if required.
Dish out the kheema, in a flat dish
preferably, and sprinkle the potato
straws on the khecma. Serve hot.
Serves 6.
PATRANI MACHI
600 gm pomfret
2 banana leaves
50 ml oil
Chutney :
!/2 coconut grated
1 bunch coriander leaves
5 sprigs mint leaves
5 gm ginger
10 flakes garlic
10 green chillies
10 gm dhania seeds
15 gm grain sugar
1 lemort (juice)
Vi tsp salt
Not for him the confines of the cashi- SALI KHEEMA
er’s cage, though his father was the chief 150 gm onions finely chopped
cashier of Air India, and his grandfather 1 kg mutton mince
made history with 52 years in the Bank 2 carrots finely chopped
of India. Sarosh attended commerce 150 gm tomatoes finely chopped
college for just 10 days before news of 100 gm peas (shelled) boiled
admission to the catering institute 15 gm ginger finely chopped
caused him to leave, and gladly. “Youll 25 gm garlic finely chopped
just be a cook all your life,” said his 8 green chillies finely chopped
family, and that’s just what Sarosh coriander leaves
wants to be. salt to taste
Absorbed by the Welcomgroup She- 75 gm ghee
raton Hotel chain soon after gradual- 2 tsp malt vinegar
ing, Sarosh was posted first to Delhi, 1 tbsp grain sugar
then to Madras and Hyderabad, before red chilli powder to taste
spending two and a half years as execu- Garam Masala :
tive chef in Jaipur. 10 gm jeera
20 gm cinnamon
20 gm cardamom (small)
10 gm cloves
10 gm javetri
10 gm cardamom (big)
10 gm black peppercorn
Grind to a fine powder and
as required.
For Potato Straws:
1 kg potatoes
, “I’d like to go abroad, get trained ghee for tieep frying
abroad, maybe open a restaurant some- salt to taste
day, but not now. Too many small res
taurants have opened, and people will Wash the mince meat and let all the s'gnTtamarind
eat almost anything on the roadside, water drain off. Add red chilly powder;
rhAGrind all the ingredients to a fine paste;
Chowpatty than eat at a decent place, chopped green chillies, and garam note that the chutney paste should be
Epicurean, gourmet, what s that ? masala powder; mix well and keep aside moist in consistency. Cut the pomfret on
asks Syosh with a broad smile on his for at least half an hour. Heat fat in a the bone and make about five slices.
f that he loves kadai and fry the chopped onions till Apply salt and lemon juice on each slice
good food and is fastidious about it s brown; add jeera, chopped garlic,
> , preparation. “I like good food, wines chopped ginger and tomatoes. Fry well,
and liqueur that you can cherish and add i;/..„ ___J" „„
enjoy.” At home however, Sarosh is browned; add a little water and let it chutney
quite happy eating^pora and paun, a cook on high flame for about eight min; with chutney. Roll it in banana leaf
' 1^ h*"” food he then add chopped carrots, and let it taking care not to leave any open space
usu^ly has cook on a very slow fire till the mince is and tie it with a fine thread. Do the same
in^re hot-tempered chaps ’ almost done. Add boiled peas and mix for all slices. Apply oil on the outside of
and Sarosh flares up when faced with well; add malt vinegar and grain sugar the leaf also. Arrange the slices in a
poor service or needless delays. He to give it a sweet and sour taste. Simmer stvamvi and mcuih fur about
instinctively knows when something’s till the kheema is absolutely dry leaving Serve hot along with the bana
burning and he never lets a hair or fly very little gravy. Serves 4
escape his eye.
There’s an absolute boom in the hotel
industry now and Sarosh recommends
.this line to young people, but only hard
working youngsters, who prefer the
brightly lit steaming kitchen to the sub-
I tie shades and cool atmosphere of the
rest of the hotel. With “cooking up (his)
sleeve” and what he considers the chefs
' best friend, the knife, in his hand, the
j scars on every finger telling of fish
i • bones, chicken bones, unfortunate off-
j target hacks of the knife and angry lobs-
1; ters, Sarolh believes in his art, believes
that “each cook is a creator by himself.”
PARSIANA: DECEMBER 1982
eat almost anything on the roadside, water drain off. Add red chilly powder;
onions till Apply salt and lemon juice on each slice
and set aside. Cut the banana leaf into
squares and grease it with a little refined
m*nce ^rneat, and saute till well oil. Take each slice of fish and apply
1____ _ • J - - "ed; a l.ttlc .-.vctcz L; .v Cnumcy on all sides, thus enveloping
quite happy eating pora and paun, a cook on high flame for about eight min; ¦ • ¦ _ . .
¦s in a
steamer and steam for about 20 min.
ma leaf.
Gift shopping at its best at
Gifts&
If fUttgjSl Bombay
bHHSUi Sir PM Road.!
the friendly Gift Shop at
J Swadeshi Stores Ltd,
Road. Bombay 400001. Tel: 2S3443/2S2730
i
! J
it
- i «<
J ?
' i F
¦ I
; J
ij
. i
IM
PI
i :
ZOROASTglAN ARTEFACTS A SILVER
PENDANTS AVAILABLE
33
aOf Clippings and Cuttings
By Dr Kaikashru M. JamaspAsa
From childhood Parsi.s have been (If) one digs this pit bigger or smaller, i.s
it proper or not ?
In height, not (proper). In length and
breadth (one can dig) as much as one (If) one intentionally throw.s hair and
desires. In smallness it is not proper.
reared to believe that nail clippings and
cut hair are unclean. Many Parsis cut
their hair or clip their nails only on par
ticular days and at particular times.
In orthodox homes men would have
their hair cut seated on a balcony or
porch clad only in pyjamas and sudreh
with the kusti removed. Then avoiding
touching any object or person, they
would proceed immediately for a cleans
ing bath.
In an article published in the Georg ground. There is one who says: One
Morgenstierne, Memorial Volume, shall not place more than a fistful in the
1981, on “The Ritual of HairTrimming ground. From me: This shall be at that just
they smite, destroy ^nd dissipate
and the creatures of Ohrmazd.
men
naiLs (without the religious ritual), then
how shall one have committed demon
worship ?
How shad one dig a hollow and how
shall one fill it up and how much shall The man who does (this) even through
negligence, then he shall have commit
ted demon-worship as I shall say hereaf
ter. (Through) the very strong and very
one place inside ?
Height (shall be so taken) as the Avesta
quotes. Breadth shall be so made, (that)
when filling up (it is) level with the powerful (sin of intentionally throwing
hair and nails), men who (are) mortal
extol (the demons) by speech, (that is)
_ j t as one extols (the demons) by
and Nail Paring in Zoroastrianism,” the place where they dig a pit; if the ground speech, he shall have extolled (them) by
noted scholar and high priest of Bom- (is) dry, even more (than a fistful) is (this irreligious) action. From the
bay’s Anjuman Atash-Behram, Dastoor
Dr Kaikashru M. JamaspAsa examines
the ancient taboos and translates ques
tions and answers on the disposal of cut
hair and nails from a commentary on
the Pahlavi Videvdat text.
(is) dry, even more (than a fistful) is (this irreligious) action,
proper. Avesta (this is) revealed.
Is it necessary to take the grace (Vaz), or (If) one intentionally throws hair and
not ?
He who (is a ) friend of the soul, then he
shall take the grace (Vaz) of Sros.
nails, or throws with this intention that I
will pick up (later), or if through one's
negligence it falls hack, or one throws
not with this intention that I will not
pick it up, or innocently throws, then
what (is) the judgement ?
If one intentionally throws, then on
account of demon-worship Tanapuh!
milk of that sheep, health and healing (sin accrues) to the stock, and then sin
after sin. And if one unintentionally
throws, Tanapuh! (sin accrues) to the
stock therefrom. If one (throws) with
this intentionthat 1 will pick up (later), it
is not more than three Srbsocarandm.
But if it decomposes or reaches to the J
1
When they cut hair and nails, then how
shall they take care ?
If it is (a) ground, a short span if it (is)
hard ground, (normal) span if soft. Onesh- sheep eats (and) begets twins. From the
all dig a pit: 10 steps from the holy man, 20 i..................... .
steps from fire, 30 steps from water and 50 from many illnesses shall reach unto the
steps from Barsom, and one shall dis
pose of the hair from the physical pollu
tion. And with (the Avestan recital): whip, knife, bow and arrow of the
‘Thus for her(i.e. the Cow), Mazda shall
increase the trees through Right’, one
shall place them in the hollow. And one
shall fill it up with the driest of dry If they do not act thus, then what (is) the 'water and noxious
(things), and Bowing water shall be kept
away from it. And with (a) metallic
(instrument) one shall draw around (the
hollow) 3 or 6 or 9 furrows with (the ______ _________ _
recital of) Yatha-ahu-vairyo. When one they attract noxious creatures. Withpes-
tilence they dry up (things) from among
men, corn, and clothes of man. And if
they cause to conceal in the ground Through innocence, (then) what (is the
If one acts thus, then what (is) the merit ?
He who (ceremoniously places) hair (in
a pit) (makes) grass grow which every
creatures. And he who (ceremoniously
places) nails (in a pit, they) become (like)
feather of the eagle and sling-stone
which fall on the demons of Mazan.
sin and crime ?
If they refrain from placing hair in a
burrow or a hole then thereby they (i.e.,
the hair) become demons, and thereby
arise.
pares nails, then one shall dig the pit for
it as much as the smallest finger or the
joint (of the finger). And with (the Aves
tan recital): ‘Through Right, through without the religious ritual, they become judgement)?
Nothing at all.
creatures
(then) what (l.s the judgement) ?
Then Tanapuh! (sin accrues) to the
stock. Through negligence (it is) more
than 3 Srosocaranam. If through enmity
to the gods, one throws it in fire or
water, (one is) Margarzan.
J
Good Mind, so that I may be heard (like) scorpion, male serpent and lizard,
beyond the (circle of) faithful ones’ it If they (cause to) decompose in water,
shall be disposed of from the physical (the hair) become (like) swift serpent. If If one lets (hair fall) on the body (and)
pollution, then one shall put in semecar- t' -i
pus anacardium. And one shall recite 1
aloud: ‘Over to thee, O bird’ upto the heat and cold of the second and third
place, and one shall throw in it the driest (day) unto men and sheep. Likewise, if
. _ _ 1 one does not dispose of nails as revealed
they (cause to) burn (them) in fire, (the does not make (oneself) dean, then what
hair) will cause itch, and high fever of (is) the judgement for it?
1 Rosn said: If one has (hair) on the body
. .. .-------------- . ' an astak (in length, and) one so per-
of dry (things) and flowing water shall one does not dispose of nails as revealed forms the Yazisn, it will not be (proper),
be kept away from it. And one shall from the religion, they will become (like) Those of the professional guild say: If
draw around 3 or 6 or 9 furrows with the whip, bow and arrow, knife and one has (hair) on the body as much(as an
(the recital of) Yatha-ahu-vairyo.
the whip, bow and arrow, knife and
slirigstone of the demons, and thereby astak in length), even then one performs
34 PARSIANA: DECEMBER 1982the Yazisn, it will be proper. From me: if
it was (the hair) of moustache or if that
of nostril, anus and armpit, (an) astak
(in length, it is) just as Rosri said. (In)
another passage: Regarding hair, (it is)
not regular, (but) it is not grievous. For
men (of other categories the sin is) of
lesser degree, and for cavalry at the
front. It will be so much grievous (at)
that time when they will be camping.
For them application(of the rule) will be
thus: When their partaking of food,
drink (and going to) sleep (is carried
out) according to religion. And for them
(i.e. women, when) menstrual cycle has
passed; for themselves it, (i.e. the rule) is
so much applied as that for those who
(like) us is able to shave and collect
(hair, nail ceremoniously). And when
there is no such application, then (one
is) innocent therefor. And for this there
will be no application (of the rule) when
a non-lranian comes in, does harm, for
whatever harm they do, the warriors are
absolved. When one stood forth (disen
gaged from battle), he will be cleansed
by us. (If) the non-Iranians come, it is
not authorized except one pursues
, (them). (If one) keeps back fear (think
ing) that they will not do (harm and)
they do injury (and) harm, then (sin
accrues) for them to the stock. (For) the
priest it is not authorized except one
cleanses. And (for) the farmer when he
has brought water to agriculture, it will
be just as the warrior when the enemy
comes. When water has not reached
(hair or nails), it will bejust as the priest.
There was one who said: As to farmers,
also those (who are) harvesters (in)
autumn, it will be just as the warrior
when the enemy has come to him.
2,94,726
sodas
a day
and
more
going
down
Si
t
..>#9 -.W
.4
Reprinted with the permission of the author.
Old post cards etc./waiited
Advertiser wishes to buy OLD
picture postcards, photographs, cigarette
cards, playing cards, posters, iwlnts.
i
F ’
I
illustrated books, albums and
other related material
Willing to pay top i«ices fnr single
items or entire collections.
Plesse send, detailed list with
expected prices to The Advertiser,
(OLD) CZo. Parsiana, GT.O.
Box 802, Bombay 400001.
Since 1889, there
has been only one
soda for everyone.
Duke's. Today,
with so many other
sodas on the market,
there's still only one
soda for most people.
Duke's.
The best-selling
soda. Because
it's the best.
No wonder over
2,94,726 bottles
are drunk.
Every day.
Ttie one soda
for everyone
I
* y
¦>
*
PARSIANA; DECEMBER 1982
Market Movers/DS/155/Mag.
35
8
I
8
ii
ii
li
t
.{
I
¦r
r
t
¦'»-
'f
I
j
re’
1
)
ft’’
4
1
Firoz Dastur—my mind goes back in
time with the very mention of the name,
to the thirties, when I first saw him on
the silver screen. The film was “Vaman-
Avatar”, based on the famous Dash
avatar legend.
Firoz, then a teenager, had played the
title role in that film. 1 was also then in
my early teens. But I still remember
how, witnessing the movie, I stared at
the boy-actor in admiration, at times
tinged with envy, whenever he appeared
on the screen in the guise of a mendi
cant.
Thinly built but handsome, with a
sharp nose and expressive eyes, he lived
his role to perfection. He made a lasting
impact on my mind as much by his sing
ing as by his acting. His raga-based dit
ties, sung in a thin, silvery voice, were
musical to the core and easy on the ear,
and I used to keep humming them for
days on end.
Many years went by before I heard
Dastur’s voice again. But it was on the
radio, in the early forties. Firoz Dastur
had by then emerged as a classical sin
ger. He seemed well-groomed in the
Kirana gayaki made so popular by the
great Abdul Karim Khan. What is
more, Dastur’s frequent radio pro
grammes from Bombay I thought, were
a measure of his popularity with high
brow listeners.
As an ardent listener myself, and
more particularly, as a keen Kirana
enthusiast, I seldom missed Dastur’s Bombay in 1948 that 1 had the pleasure day and also ran a billiards c^ub, was a
broadcast. What struck me most was to hear him on the concert platform, great fan of Urdu drama and music, and
the way he had assimilated the gayaki of simply dressed in the conventional style he used to teach me his favourite songs
Abdul Karim Khan, as also his chief ¦ -
disciple, Sawai Gandharva—indeed,
almost to a degree where it had acquired
offered me an opportunity to interview
him at some length.
Q: Dasturji, not much is known
about the role of Parsis in patronising
and popularising North Indian music.
How many people, I wonder,know that
there was an institution, known as the
Gayan Uttejak Mandali, in the early
years of this century, which was started
and patronised by a group of wealthy
Parsi gentlemen of the time. It is
rewarding to know that the institution
used to feature leading lights in Hindus
tani music and even employ many of
them for teaching music to talented,
deserving students.
This shows that there is a section of
music-lovers in the Parsi community
which is involved in Indian music. But
on the performing side, there haven’t
been many exponents of our traditional
music coming from your community.
The only names that come to my mind
in this context are those of Firoz
Framji, the eminent instrumentalist
from Pune and Hirjibhai Doctor from
Baroda from the older generation and
that showed Dastur immaculately clad Jal Balaporia, Zarin Daruwala and
in western dress and donning a felt hat. yourself, from the present generation.
Somewhat intriguing and amusing, too, who have made a mark in the field,
was my reaction on such occasions. For,
the idea of an artiste, dressed in western
style and sitting cross-legged on the interested in Hindustani music. Is there
platform to perform, somehow, seemed music in your family?
rather ludicrous to my mind. A: Yes, in a way. My father, who was
It was only after I settled down in a well-known billiards champion in his
By Gurudev Sharan
>-'1
A: True.
Q: Tell me, Dasturji, how you got
r
broadcast. What struck me most was to hear him on the concert platform.
of a Hindustani musician. The number from the time I was seven. He also
of occasions I have heard him all these encouraged me to sing them for those
years are too many to permit a recount. I members of his club who had an ear for
a kind of personal colouring. Needless also got to know him personally in
to say he became one of my favourites.
To me’his radio concert was an event to
look forward to with anticipation; and I shy, retiring sort of disposition, always
used to browse through AlR’s fort- i
nightly journal to satisfy my curiosity. 1 typical modesty and candour,
remember, incidentally, that alongside
of the programme schedule in the jou
rnal, there often appeared a photograph brought me closer to Dastur, and Wadia Movietone who, in a manner of
36
music.
Q: But when and how did you get into recent years. But whenever I met him, I Q: But when and how did you get into
found him a man of few words with a the film world?
A: My interest in music came to be
more willing to listen than to speak with known to the small Parsi community
’ within a short time. Meanwhile it was
But it was the recent release of two J.B.H. Wadia, one of the doyens of
lovely cassettes of Dastur’s music that Indian cinema and the founder of
PARSIANA: DECEMBER 1982
I>
About the visit of
Maneckji Kursetji to Russia
in January 1865.
speaking, ‘discovered’ me for a role in
his production “Lal-e-Yaman” in
1932. It so happened that Wadia Saheb
was on the look-out for a boy actor AVho
could also sing. As you know, this was
long before the advent of playback sing
ing, when singing was a ‘must’ for a film
actor or actress.
The role 1 was assigned for the film
was a small one, in which 1 was to sing The visit to St. Petersburg of a Bombay
Parsee, Manekji Kursetji.
took up science, the study of Sanskrit
only one song. But after hearing me at Parsee, Manekji Kursetji. and the Zoroastrian religion. Inthethir-
my residence, Wadia Saheb was so ties he was in active correspondence
impressed that he introduced new situa- We had an occasion the other day to get with the famous Burnuf, one of the
tions to the original story so as to give acquainted with a rather remarkable prominent French Indologists of the
me scope to sing six more songs. Music personality — an Indian Parsee from
in films in those days was always based Bombay, an ardent traveller^ who came
on our age-old ragas. Despite their clas- ~ ..........................
sical colour, the film songs were simple
in tune, with a rhythmic lilt all their first woman of Parsee origin who has
own, and they had a tremendous appeal
for the cinegoers.
Q: I guess the film proved to be a hit. strangers. rare books and manuscripts in oriental
A: Indeed, it was a box-office success. Parsees follow the traditions and reli- languages. Atthe beginning of the forties.
Wadia J Saheb’who produced and gious rites of their ancestors, but he visited Europe for the first time. He
went to Italy to make the acquaintance
of Cardinal Maccofanti and was intro-
row certain customs from the life of duced to Pope George XVI, who gave
We had an occasion the other day to get
1^5 "V
-1
19th century.
Manekji showed to the author of this
to Russia with his daughter for the shor- article, with evident pleasure, letters
test period of time. His daughter is the which he had received from some fam
ous Orientalists and the diplomas of
come to Europe and contrary to the scientific societies to which he rendered
existing Parsee tradition does not avoid important services by giving them some
strangers.
Parsees follow the traditions and reli-
r
receive offers from many other produc- in this respect is the social position of the
ers even while 1 continued to work for women. Although Parsees do not have received the honourable post of a judge,
----------XL- .z:------ . - -
from 1932 to 1947, I think I must have kept in higher esteem than Hindus and
point to attend his protege’s concerts j,, not make appearances
even today. The meeting of the two on . . rr
such occasions is always heart-warming. IH SOCIGty, thcy dO nOt
I
directed “Lal-e-Yaman”, took paternal recently amongst them have appeared
iriterest in me and gave me the facilities reformists who admit it is time to bor-
toensuremy success as a singing actor in i ______ ;___ ¦ - ;
r this maiden attempt. Soon I began to Englishmen. One of the essential issues him a golden medal as a memento,
receive offers from many other produc- in this respect is the social position of the On coming back to India, Manekji
ers even while 1 continued to work for women. Although Parsees do not have received the honourable post of a judge,
the Wadia Movietone. In the 15 years polygamy and the women have been which he holds up till now. The main
from 1932 to 1947, I think I must have kept in higher esteem than Hindus and aim of his present visit is to see all the
played roles in 17 films. Muslims, the wives of Parsees do not Asian libraries in Europe and to find out
Firoz Dastur, who will be 63 next make appearances in society, they do what they lack regarding the Sanskrit
Thursday, turns emotional when he language and Zinda-Vesta literature. In
speaks with gratitude about Mr. Wadia. . our country he is very keenly inspecting
The octogenarian veteran makes it a I il© WIV6S OT HarS66S the oriental manuscripts which are kept
in the Asian Museums of the Academy
of Sciences and in the Imperial public
library and expressed his complete read
ddr© to sit ©t the iness to add new items to the collection,
same table with their general, he expressed the hope that
same laoi© Wltn xn©ir relationship between our scientific
husbands and g©t almost societies and the Asian societies in India
no ©ducation developed in the near future.
Manekji also took great interest in our
Geographic Society and promised to
send us the complete collections of the
publications of Bombay’s Geographic
Society of which he is also a member.
Manekji travels with his younger
¦•S'
Courtesy TTie Economic Times. September 26, 1982.
Rashid D. Bamanbehram
i
Professional Photographer
for Photos of
Weddings, Navjotes
and Birthday parties.
Contact:
Flat No. 3, First Floor,
No. 6, Wadia Block,
Khareghat Colony,
not dare to sit at the same table with
their husbands and get almost no educa
tion. Certain people of the new genera
tion started to oppose this strongly.
Our guest Manekji Kursetji is one of daughter, a girl of 16. While seeing the
them. He established a girls’ school in
Bombay and thus rendered an impor
tant Service to the local Parsee commun
ity. He educated his two daughters in a dress,
pure English way and as noted above,
did not lock them behind doors.
The father of Manekji had considera
ble property and was one of the most
respected personalities among Parsees Emperor and the Empress,
in Bombay. His son, since he was not
compelled to dedicate himself to the
usual occupation of Parsees, i.e. trade.
3
museums, libraries etc. she has attracted
general attention by her clever questions
and remarks and by her strange national
30A Hughes Road,
Bombay 400 007.
Phone: 8226074
Manekji Kursetji also visited Mos
cow. At Tsarskoye Silo he had the
honour to be presented, together with
his daughter, to their Majesties the
•4-
't
From the Bulletin of the Emperor's Russian Geographi
cal Society. Volume I. 1865, No. 8 Miscellaneous News,
pages 167-168. Submitted by Homi Parekh of Air India.
PARSIANA: DECEMBER 1982
37
'.'3:
> -.ir
>1
J Aek Atmakatha
The American
Mazdaznan Sect
i4
The Life of Dastur Dhalla XXX
Ul
this revered gentleman’s captivating
words was flowing in full force, through
the length and breadth of Uncle Sam’s
land, I happened to go to America for
my studies. A Christian by birth, he was
founding a new religion. Gleaning stray
concepts from the Zoroastrian, Chris
tian, Hindu and other religions com
mensurate with his own understanding,
he was offering a medley or hotchpotch
to everyone. Many a curious and well-
informed person Came to Jackson or
wrote to him seeking clarification on
various problems. Naturally some came
to us also. Some asked whether all the
strange things that Dr. Hannish wrote
and spoke about Zoroaster, the prophet
Aek Atmakatha is the autobiography of the late Dr. Maneck Nusser-
wanji Dhalla, high priest of the Pakistan Parsis and a scholar of world of'ancfem Tan, werTtrue or^ false^ I n
repute. This is the 30th edited and condensed extract from the book reply we referred them to Jackson s
‘*Dastur Dhalla - The Saga of a Soul” — an
Gool and Behram Rustomji of the original Gujarati, published by the
Dastur Dhalla Memorial Institute, Karachi.
a
•j
I
¦1
.4
¦a
*1
English translation by Zoroaster, the Prophet of Ancient
Iran, and other authentic books.
Although he was completely ignorant
of the rudiments of the Avestan lan-
• guage, yet to give a new form to Zoroas-
THE STORY SO FA R All major railway stations have an trianism and to drape it in new
Born to a poor Dastur family in Surat Inquiry Office. Details regarding travel garments, he began to give ungrammati
on 27 August 1875, Dhalla moved
with his family to Karachi three years
later. He was married to five-year-old
Cooverhai when he was eight years old.
After fading his matriculation,
Dhalla sought employment while
educating himself in religious matters.
With the assistance of the Karachi
Parsis, Dhalla studied Iranian
languages in Bombay and then
proceeded to Columbia University in
New York, where he was awarded a
Ph. D. in 1908. On his return to India he
was nominated head priest of Karachi
in which capacity he tried to critically
evaluate old religious beliefs and
customs in the light of his broadened
outlook.
This approach caused him to clash
with the more orthodox section of
the community and he became involved
in several religious and social
controversies. rival to Jackson. Verily he seemed to News of this novel movement reached
But despite the opposition, Dhalla have dropped from the sky, as he came our shores. On my return from New
proceeded with his efforts to educate the with a claim to prophethood. He was York after four years, I received anxious
community and resolve old conflicts. God’s messenger of this age — the Zara- letters from co-religionists in Surat,
In the last instalment, Dhalla wrote of thushtra of modern times. On the Bombay and other places, wanting to
the Joodin Navjotes that had been strength of his sanctity he even invested know what was going on in Zarathush-
performedat Vansda and Bharudi and himself with the title of Zardoost. He tra’s name on the other side of the Atlan-
his evidence in the High Court in had an intuition in ancient Babylonia, tic. Moreover, whenever news of our
Bombay regarding these navjotes. In the Desert of Gobi and in Tibet he having returned from America was pub-
had found Avestan manuscripts ! Many lished in the papers, such enquiries kept
such bombastic statements did he make pouring in. Later, many were impressed
to astonish the scholastic world. That by the information received here that
august person .was Dr. Ottoman Zar- those white Mazdaznans had sent for
Adoost Hannish. ‘sudras’and‘kustis’and were organizing
In the first decade of this century—i.e. ‘ghambhars’there.
While we were in New York in 1938
M
and other information can be had there, cal constructions and imaginary pro-
In the whole of the United States of nunciations; The word Mazdayasna—
America there was only one centre believers of Mazda—he turned to
where information regarding the Mazdaznan. Anaheet, the attribute of
Zoroastrian religion, its lapguage, its Ardvisur Yazad he dubbed Ainynahit.
history, the life-story of its founder- Spenta which means‘sacred’he changed
prophet, his birth place and many rele- to Speyent. The Chinvat bridge became
vant matters could be had,and that was Khinvat. Armaiti,'devotion’ through
Columbia University at New York. The him turned to Armaiy. The law of
person to give such information was Karma became ‘Kharma’. Avesta he
Professor A. V. Williams Jadkson. It chose to bifurcate into ‘ave’ meaning
was possible to study Sanskrit literature ‘living’and ‘sta’meaning‘word’and thus
at Harvard and other universities he measured and weighed many words
besides Columbia, through Lenman, according to his choice. A usurper must
Bloomfield, Hopkins and others, but manifest something different, hence he
the study of Iranian literature could be assigned to Zarathushtra ridiculous
Carrie^ on only at Columbia and under statements wound un in legend, such as
Jackson alone. Asho Zarathushtra had never meditated
At the end of the last century the stu- upon, believed in or expounded. ‘Maz-
dents of oriental religionsand languages daznan’ was an addition to the preten-
were taken aback. Suddenly, a religious sions that arise age after age of bringing
scholar came into the public eye as a a message from divine sources.
rival to Jackson. Verily he seemed to
God’s messenger of this age — the Zara- letters from co-religionists in Surat,
in 1905 — just when the sacred stream of
38
PARSIANA; DECEMBER 1982)
/
•rS
not serve any selfish ends. Such fakery,
they believe, is necessary and in the
interest of the people themselves so that
they may have faith in their message,
future Parsi historian writes the history ThoSO whltO MazdaznanS
had sent for 'sudras'
and 'kustis' and
were organizing
'ghambhars' there.
of this age — the
Zarathushtra of
modern times.
we knew through newspapers coming mother. Moreover, this supposedly selves that their deeds cannot draw
from Bombay that the lady disciples of Zoroastrian lady, passing through God’s wrath upon them since they do
Hannish had delivered a series of lec- India, had died in Surat and her body
tures there. They returned in due course had been placed in the local Dokhma !
and at the headquarters beautified by Not limited to columns of gossip in
the‘mighty American’dollar, a'Mazdaz- newspapers, this falsehood was pub-
nan Centre’had sprung up. After some lished in the Parsi Prakash which listen to their teachings and learn. When
time when 1 read in Karachi about the records noteworthy events that happen
in the life of the community. Hence, if a
He was God's messenger of the community, this event can pass as
an authenticated fact. This was most
distressing and disturbing for the com
munity. Here is a living example of the
type of charlatanry that goes on in the
name of religion.
Wherever faked pirs and prophets
discussions that were going on in Bom- come into the limelight, their movement
bay regarding this institution some very is always founded on falsehood. Some the original preachers are of such a cali-
queer things came to my notice for the receive inspiration from the angel
first time.
Dr. Hannish was born of Christian are informed by secret Mahatmas; while
parents. His family had come from Ger- others still go into seclusion and live
many and settled in the State of Illinois amongst an invisible tribe for a long
in U.S.A. Inspite of all this, leading co- time and attain some esoteric knowl-
religionists of Bombay who were over- edge that throws strange new light on
enthusiastic about the Mazdaznan ancient scriptures. The history of the the vacating of religious houses, the com-
Movement, created a myth by printing religions of the world reveals that such monplace‘Mazdaznan Centre’suddenly
in our papers that Hannish Saheb was things haye been taking place every- becamethe‘MazdaznanTemple’.Over-
the descendent of an ancient royal fam- where. So-called saints who give birth to night the centre of religious learning
ily of Iran and born of a Zoroastrian such mendacity seem to beguile them- turned into a temple of worship.
bre, what can be expected of those who
Gabriel or from Sarosh Yazad; others place their faith in them?
At this time the Bombay government
served a notice on the organisers of the
‘Mazdaznan Centre’, requisitioning the
premises for war work. As the govern
ment was not permitted to commandeer
r.
TiJ-lnwrcontlntnul HotH
— Bombay
£
lli
4^
0
JlflHHHHI
5F
i
I
s
&
LET’S BUILD THEM TOGETHER!
Whether it's a five-star hotel,
a Sultan's Palace, a hospital,
a chemical factory, a fertiliser
plant or a housing project —
we have the expertise and
for putting up the imposing
Muscat Palace complex
of His Majesty the Sultan of
Oman—and completed
it in time.
THsB
a
¥¦
f
S’*'?!?.
S:*i
w
SHAPOORJI PALLONJI & CO. (PVT.) LTD
int'nat»onaI Div.-iO
Engr'.ecTinq (?nf'sirnr * <, i
New !r’d'a '• n;
d I ' ¦' H J •1 — u ¦ •' i . • IJ. J
PARSIANA: DECEMBER 1982
39J
The hearing of the case was to com- sacred duty by sending a timely wire to
mence in the High Court within four the Panchayat. The case did not proceed
days. Hannish was not a Zoroastrian further and the matter ended there. An
but a Christian; to declare his teachings embarrassing situation was avoided,
and the tfcachings of his American disci-
tc
W-
It is true that these American Maz
daznans who believe in Mazda and love
Zarathushtra abide by a certain faith.
There- is a constant accusation levelled
against them by our scholars that since
sprinklings of Christianity can be seen
As the government was
not permitted to
commandeer the vacating in their teachings, they are contriving to
of religious houses,
the commonplace
'Mazdaznan Centre'
suddenly became the
'Mazdaznan Temple'.
Hannish’s Mazdaznan religion is
heterogeneous and eclectic.He believed
in it himself and made others believe it
was true. He died asa staunch Mazdaz
nan and not as a Christian. The follow
ers of his creed are honest. They believe
that the religion they have adopted is
true and excellent. They are true and
I
li.
¦
In the Desert of Gobi
and in Tibet he had found
Avestan manuscripts!
convert.us to Christianity. These gentle
men are mistaken in their surmise. In
America those who have btecome
Vedantists or Baha’is or Muslims or
Mazdaznans have completely aban
doned their Christian faith. Even today,
just as in Europe and America, we find
in our own country, white men and
women Vedantists of the Ramkrishna worshipping Zoroastrians. They have
themselves appropriated that role. If the
doors of the Zoroastrian faith were open
to Joodins today, they would enter and
add to the fame and lustre of the com
munity. The fold is made up of such
and I had chanced to see that this had woman in Virpur. Like them, others noble, qualified and learned people,
been published at the time in the Bom- have been dissatisfied with their Chris-
bay papers by the Secretary of the Pan- tian faith and have been converted to
chayat. In the interest of the their adopted religions and have adh-
community, and with the honest inten- ered to them faithfully. The condition
tion of removing this deceit, I fulfilled my of these white Mazdaznans is identical.
pies publicized since the start of the cen« Mission, who, like the well-known Sis-
tury as a genuine revival of the pure and ter Nivedita and others, were converted
pristine faith of Zarathustra was absurd to the Vedant faith as a result of Swami
and astonishing. I had commented upon Vivekanand’s religious expansion. We
this matter in my ‘Atma Kat ha’ in 1942 had met such a man in Bangalore and a
(tt
40
faithful devotees. They are certainly not
Christians in Mazdaznan disguise.
We have not made them Mazda-
This is the truth. This new facet of the
Mazdaznans of Chicago is posing a
fresh problem to the Joodin question.
With the Best Compliments of
7b be concluded.
1
j
1
J
INGERSOLL-RAND (INDIA] LIMITED
Manufacturers of
Air & Gas Compressors * Rock Drill Equipment
* Vaimtim Pumps
PARSIANA: DECEMBER 1982
1
-J
I
◆ ◆ ◆
From the archive
